Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1961
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

OF =XAS

WTIA. WILSON

A=O’RNIFy OBSNERAI.

May 29, 1961

Hon. William A. Harrison Opinion No. WW- 1071

Commi~ssioner of Insurance

International Life Building Re: Whether County Mutual Insur-

Austin, Texas ance Companies which are

authorized to issue automobile

liability insurance policies in

the State of Texas are subject

to the mandatory provisions of

Section 35 of the Texas Motor

Vehicle Safety-Responsibility

Act, Acts 1951, 52nd Legisla-

ture (Article 6701h, Civil Statutes

of Texas).

Dear Commissioner Harrison:

You have asked our opinion on the following questions:

“1. Are County Mutual Insurance Companies which

are authorized to issue automobile liability insurance

policies in the State of Texas subject to the mandatory

provisions of Section 35 of the Texas Motor Vehicle Safety-

Responsibility Act, Acts 1951, 52nd Legislature?

“2. If your answer to the above question is in the af-

firmative, would a County Mutual which subscribed to the

Assigned Risk Plan be required to charge the rate of pre-

mium prescribed by the State Boa,rd of Insurance for poli-

cies issued in accordance with the Texas Motor Vehicle

Assigned Risk Plan? I’

Section 35 of Article 6701h, V. C. S. , the Motor Vehicle Safety-

Responsibility Act, after making provisions for the formation of “a plan

and procedure to provide a means by which insurance may be assigned

to an authorized insurance company for a person required by this Act to

show proof of financial responsibility, ” commonly known as the assigned

risk plan, continues by providing: “When any such plan has been approved

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 2 (WW-1071)

by the Board of Insurance Commissioners, all insurance companies auth-

orized to issue motor vehicle liability policies in the State of Texas shall

subscribe thereto and participate therein. I’ In addition, the Board is given

the authority to set premium rates commensurate with the risks. (In the

field of automobile insurance generally, the Board, by Subchapter A of

Chapter 5 of the Insurance Code has been given the responsibility of pro-

mulgating policy forms and regulating premium rates. )

County Mutual6 have a somewhat unique history. Chapter 17 of the

Insurance Code (Art. 17.22, Vol. 14, Vernon’s Civil Statutes) has consis-

tently provided that such companies shall be “exempt from the operation

of all insurance laws of this state” unless otherwise specifically provided

in said Chapter. Formerly, no such company could write automobile

liability insurance. In 1955, however, certain changes were made in

Chapter 17. Article 17. 02 was amended to prohibit the formation of such

companies; Article 17.25 was amended to authorize the writing of auto-

mobile liability insurance by certain classes of County Mutuals; and Article

17.22 was amended to provide that such companies are subject to certain

specified statutes outside of Chapter 17.

Shortly after the passage of the above-mentioned amendments, this

office was called upon to answer somewhat the same ques:tion in regard to

automobile liability insurance generally that we are now called upon to an-

swer in regard to the assigned risk plan. In Opinion No. WW-401, we

held: 1) that County Mutuals were specifically made subject to the policy

provisions of Article 5.06, but 2) were not subject to the rating provisions

of Article 5.01, et seq, because of the exemption provisions.

The reasoning of Opinion No. WW-401 applies equally to the ques-

tion before us. Although obviously the purpose of Art. 6701h in its entirety

is “to encourage safer use of motor vehicles, ” in our opinion Sec. 35 of

that Article is an “insurance law” within the purview of Art. 17.22 since

the regulations which it imposes upon the insurance industry after approval

of the plan by the Board are of the most fundamental type, i. e. the com-

pulsory insuring of a risk at a prescribed rate. Nowhere in the 1955

amendments to Chapter 17, neither in those giving County Mutual6 the

authority to write automobile liability insurance, nor in those specifying

other portions of the laws of this State to which such companies should

thenceforth be subject, are there any references to Article 6701h. although

it had been in existence since 1951.

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 3 (WW-1071)

Accordingly, we are compelled to hold that County Mutual6 are

not subject to the provisions of the Texas Motor Vehicle Assigned Risk

Plan, and both questions are answered in the negative.

SUMMARY

County Mutual Insurance Companies

which are authorized to issue automobile liabil-

ity insurance policies in the State of Texas are

not subject to the mandatory provisions of Sec-

tion 35 of the Texas Motor Vehicle Safety-Res-

ponsibility Act, Acts 1951, 52nd Legislature

(Article 6701h, V. C. S. )~

Very truly yours,

WILL W.ILSON

Attorney General of Texas

Assistant A

RVL:lmc

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE:

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

Virgil Pulliam

William R. Hemphill

Ben Harrison

Tom I. McFarling

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

BY: Morgan Nesbitt

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.