Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1962
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Aus- 11. TExAe

WILL WILSON

A-RNEY GENBXCAI.

January 5, 1962

Honorable William A. Harrison Opinion No. WW- 1234

Commissioner of Insurance

International Life Building Re: The correct method of valuing

Austin 14, Texas real estate in calculating the

tax rate under the provisions

Dear Mr. Harrison: of Article 7064, V. C. S.

You have asked for our opinion with regard to whether or not the

reasoning and conclusion of Attorney General’s Opinion S-200 is applica-

ble to real estate investments held by a foreign insurance corporation

taxable under Article 7064, V. C. S.

Article 7064, V. C. S., in general, taxes insurance companies other

than life, health, and accident companies on the basis of the amount of

gross premiums received upon property or risks located in Texas. The

amount of this tax, normally figured at a rate of 3. S5%, may be reduced

if the company had invested in “Texas securities” as defined therein from

75% to 100% of the amount that it had invested in “similar securities” in

the state in which it then had the highest percentage of its admitted assets

invested. (The actual rate being determined by the percentile relation

between the two amounts invested in accordance with the formula set out

in Article 7064. ) Under this statute, it obviously becomes necessary

for valuations to be made of the foreign company’s investments.

The inquiry answered by Opinion S-200 was directed at an invest-

ment in corporate stock and concerned whether or not market value or

actual cost of acquisition was to be used in determining the proper basis

of valuation. The opinion held that the plirdhase price wa’s the coirect

figure to be us&d Bs to carporate stock.

Your current request informs us that since the issuance of S-200

the State Board of Insurance has maintained that the “amount invested”

in foreign real estate is the amount actually expended by the company

for its original acquisition plus the amount expended for all subsequent

improvements. Your request is prompted by the fact that an insurer is

urging that the depreciated value of the realty should be used instead.

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 2 (WW-1234)

We have concluded that the correct basis for evaluation of a real

estate investment under Article 7064 is its market value. “Texas Securi-

ties” are specifically defined by Article 7064 to include real estate in this

State. Turning to the portions of the Insurance Code particularly applica-

ble to the type of companies covered by this article, we find, for example,

that Article 6. 08 authorizes fire and marine companies to hold and convey

real estate “for the erection and maintenance of buildings at least ample

and adequate for the transaction of its own business, ” with the further

qualification that: “Not more than 33-l/39/0 of its admitted assets shall be

invested by such insurance company in real estate. ” That the latter does

not refer simply to a “cost” figure is shown by the last paragraph of

Article 6. 08 which provides “The value of real estate mentioned . . .

shall be appraised by two or more competent and disinterested citizens

of Texas appointed by the Board of Insurance Commissioners of Texas. If

The amount invested in real property under Article 6.08 is thus deter-

mined by its market value. We can find no language in Article 7064 indi-

cating the Legislature there intended a different meaning. General casualty

companies are, by Article 8. 18 of the Insurance Code, made subject to

Article 6.08.

Life insurance companies offer an analogous situation. They also

are taxable on their gross premiums, by virtue of Article 4769, V. C. S. ,

the rate being reducible depending on the percentile relationship between

its investments in Texas securities and its similar securities in the state

in which it had its highest percentage of admitted assets invested. “Texas

Securities” for life insurance companies are defined by Article 3.34 of

the Insurance Code to include “the purchase of not more than one building

site, and in the erection thereon of not more than one office building, or

in the purchase, at its reasonable market value, of such office building.

already constructed and the ground upon which same is located. . . ” The

article proceeds by allowing all real estate owned by life companies in

this State prior to 1910 to be treated as a Texas security “to the extent

of its reasonable market value. I’ Appraisals are provided for, as in the

case of fire and casualty companies, by Article 3.40, V. C. S., which like-

wise contains a restriction regarding real estate investments of over

33-l/30/0 of the admitted assets of the company.

In addition, the Legislature, in 1955, amended Article 1. 15,

Sec. 2, to read as follows:

“The Board of Insurance Commissioners in ad-

ministering any provision of the Insurance Code, Acts

.

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 3 (WW-1234)

1951, Fifty-second Legislature, Chapter 491, shall

be authorized and empowered in determining ‘value’

or’ ‘market value’ of any investment in or upon real

estate or the improvements thereon by any carrier

authorized to do business in the State of Texas to con-

sider any and all matters and things relating thereto,

including but not restricted to, appraisals by real

estate boards or other qualified persons, affidavits

by other persons familiar with such values, tax valua-

tions, cost of acquisition, with proper deductions for

depreciation and obsolescense, cost of replacement,

sales of other comparable property, enhancement in

value from whatever cause, income received or to be

received, improvements inade or any other factor or

any other evidence which to said Board may be deemed

proper and material. ”

Thus, we see that the Legislature intended that the real estate

investments authorized by the Code were to be treated in the same manner

insofar as their evaluation is concerned regardless of the type of com-

pany involved; that the determinative figure is to be that commonly

referred to as “market value” and that such figure is to be arrived at

by the methods set out in Article 1. 15. This should obviously be the

figure utilized for tax purposes under Article 7064, as it has been under

Article 4769 for life companies. There is nothing in the Code to warrant

a different treatment for tax purpose as between life companies and those

affected by Article 7064.

We find that the Insurance Code contains no provisions comparable

to Article 1. 15 prescribing the method of evaluating securities other than

real estate. We, therefore, reaffirm Opinion S-200 insofar as it relates

to valuation of investments in corporate stocks.

SUMMARY

In calculating the tax rate under the provisions

Hon. William A. Harrison, page 4 (WW-1234)

of Article 7064, V. C. S. , real estate investments

should be valued at their market value.

Very truly yours,

WILL WILSON

Attorney General of Texas

BY

Bob E. Shannon

I

BES/pe Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

Martin DeStefano

Fred B. Werkenthin

Joe B. McMasters

William Allen

REVIEWED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

BY: Houghton Brownlee, Jr.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.