Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1962
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE A~~o~~NEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

Aus- ~~.TEx.As

June 27, 1962

Honora.ble Joe D. Carter Opinion No. ~~-1367

Chairma.n, Texas Wa.ter

Commission Re: Whether the Texa.s Water

Austin, Texa.s Commission is required

to pay the costs of pub-

lication of notice of

Dear Mr. Carter: hearing.

We quote the following from your letter requesting

an opinion:

“On March 20, 1962, a. petition wa.s received

for the creation of a water control and improvement

district under Article 7880-3. The petition was

accompanied by a $25.00 filing fee a.s required by

Article 7532 and a $250.00 deposit as required by

Article 7880-21. The Commission entered an order

on April 10, 1962, setting the petition for hearing

on June 5, 1962 and in accordance with usual pro-

cedure, a copy of the notlce of hearing was for-

warded to the petitioners so that they could have

the notice published as required by State law.

Heretofore, the proposed district has borne the

expense of publication; however, the petitioners

in this instance have forwarded the notice of pub-

lication statement to the Commission for payment.

“It is the petitioners’ contention that the

Sta.te should pay the cost of publication of the

notice of hearing in the creation of the water con-

trol and improvement district out of the $250.00

deposit. Under the 1929 amendment of Article 7880-21

the State was ‘to pay all costs which may be incurred

in such proceedings’ out of the $250.00 deposit and

return the unused balance to the petitioners. Since

the 1929 amendment required the State to use this

deposit to pay the costs incurred in the crea.tion,

the petitioners contend that the phrase ‘for the

use of the State as provided for other fees collected

under this act’ In then 1961 amendment of Article

7880-21 actually did not change the meaning of the

1929 amendment. . . e”

Honorable Joe D. Carter, page 2 (WW-1367)

You propound the following questions:

“(1) Is the Texas Wa.ter Commission required

to pa.y costs of publication of notice of hearing or

is this an expense to be borne by the petitioners?

“(2) If the expense of publication is to be

oaid by the Texa.s Wa.ter Commission, should it be

paid out of the $250.00 deposit made under Article

7880-21?”

The cost of publication is not included in Article

7532, V.C.S., since it provides that the filing fee of $25.00

is “for the benefit of the State.”

Prior to the amendment of 1961, Article 7880-21,

V.C.S., required a deposit of $250.00 “to pay all costs which

may be incurred in such proceeding” and provided that a.fter

the payment of such costs any unexpended bala.nce should be

repaid to petitioners.

By the amendment of 1961 (Acts, 57th Leg., Chap. 460,

Sec. 1, P. 10&O), Article 7880-21 was amended and the pertinent

part reads as follows:

11. . . A petition to be filed with said Board

must be a.ccompanied by a. deposit of Two Hundred

and Fifty ($250.00) Dollars for the use of the

state, as provided for other fees collected under

this Act; no pa.rt of which shall be returned, ex-

cept as hereinafter provided. The deposit shall

be deposited in the hands of the State Treasurer

to be held in trust outside the State Treasury

until the Board does either grant or refuse such

petition, at which time the Board shall direct the

State Treasurer to transfer said deposit into the

General Revenue Fund; provided, if at any time

prior to the hearing, as hereinafter provided, the

petitioners desire to withdraw said petition, then

and only in that event, the Board &ail direct the

refund of said deposit to petitioners, or their

attorney of record, whose receipt therefor shall

be sufficient. . . .”

We see that under the 1961 amendment instead of

providing that the deposit of $250.00 is to be used to pay

all costs as previously provided, it is now to be used for

the use of the State and it is specifically provided that

no part of same shall be returned unless prior to the hear-

ing the petition is withdrawn. The amendment also provides

that the amount of said deposit shall be deposited in the

Honorable Joe D. Carter, pa.ge3 (~~-1367)

hands of the State Treasurer in trust until the Board either

grants or refuses the petition. This provision is for the

purpose of keeping the money out of the State Treasury until

it is seen whether the petition will be withdrawn in order

that it may be returned if the petition is withdrawn before

the hearing. If it should be placed in the Treasury it could

not be withdrawn except by an appropriation of the Legislature.

(Article 8, Sec. 6 of the Texas Constitution)

It is noticed that there is no provision made for

the use of the money except for two purposes: (1) return it

if the petition is withdrawn prior to the hearing or (2) de-

posit it in the State Treasury if the Board grants or refuses

the petition.

Since the Act makes no provision for the payment of

the costs of publication of the notice and makes only the two

provisions as set out above for disposition of the deposit, it

naturally follows that it cannot be used to pay the costs of

publication. Therefore, in answer to your first question you

are advised that the Texas Water Commission is not required to

pay the costs of publication of a notice of hearing and that

this is a cost to be borne by the petitioners. This ma.kes an

answer to your second question unnecessary.

SUMMARY

The Texas Water Commission is not required

to pay costs of publication of a notice of hear-

ing of a petition to create a water control and

improvement district created under Article 7880-3,

V.C.S.

Yours very truly,

WILL WILSON

HGC:dsd

Assistant

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

Frank Booth

Charles Lind

Woodrow Curtis

Robert Lewis

REVIEWEDFOR THE ATTORNEYGENERAL

BY: Leonard Passmore

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.