Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1962
Status
Published
On the bench
Will Wilson
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

MEY GENE

OF EXAS

M r . Coke R. Stevenson, Jr. Opinion No. W- 1433

Administrator

Texas Liquor Control Board Re: Whether the Texas Liquor

Austin, Texas Control Board should can-

cel the permit granted

to Claude D. Neeley by

Dear Mr. Stevenson: virtue of the stated facts.

You asked this office an opinion on the following

questions:

"1 . Should the Texas Liquor Control Board

cancel the permit granted to Claude D. Neeley

for the 'FM Road 369' premises in view of the

adoption of Ordinance No. 1974 by the City of

Vichita Falls and the annexation thereafter of

the area in which permit is located?

"2 . ,Couldthe Texas Liquor Control Board

cancel the permit or license granted to Claude

D. Neeley for the 'FM Road 369%premises in view

of the adoption of Ordinance No. 1974 by the

City of Wichita Falls and the annexation there-

after of the area in which such permit is located?"

On October 25, 1961, Claude D. Neeley filed an ori-

ginal application for a retail dealer's off-premise license

with the County Judge of Wichita County for the premises at

"FM Road 369". On November 14, 1961, the County Judge of

Yichita County refused to approve the application. On the 28th

day of November, 1961, in Cause No. 69012-A, which was an appeal

from the County Judge's refusal to approve the application,

the 30th District Court of Wichita County, Texas, set aside the

ruling of the County Judge refusing to approve the application.

Thereafter, on December 7, 1961, in pursuance of the judgment

entered in Cause No. 69012-A in the 30th District Court of

Wichita County, Texas, the Texas Liquor Control Board issued

a retail dealer's off-premise license to Mr. Claude D. Neeley

for the "FM Road 369" premises. At the same time, the Texas

Liquor Control Board also issued a package store permit to Mr.

Claude D. Neeley for the "FM Road 369” premises.

The "FM Road 369" premises are within an arfflre-

cently annexed to the City of ;lichitaFalls, Texas. This

annexed area was adjacent to the City of lfichitaFalls before

the annexation. It had been under first reading for some time

Mr . Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 2 (W-1433 )

prior to the action of the County and District Judges of

County, Texas, set out above and on November 13,

'cfichita

1961, the area was actually annexed to the City of :;,JichLta

Falls, Texas.

The "FM Road 369" premises are in Precinct N:;.

1 of Wichita County, Texas, and the area was "wet" when

annexed by Wichita Falls.

On October 21, 1946, the City of Wichita Falls,

Texas, adopted Ordinance No. 1416 which provided that "no

spiritous, vinous or malt liquors" shall be sold within

the corporate limits of the City of Wichita Falls, Wichita

County, Texas, except within certain limits as set out in

that particular ordinance. Section 4 of this ordinance

further provided that the ordinance should not apply to

wholesale dealers, "who shall sell at wholesale to retail

dealers only and to no other person, firm or corporation."

On January 27, 1947, Ordinance 1425 was adopted

which amended Section 1 of Ordinance No. 1416 providing

that "no spiritous, vinous or malt liquors" should be

sold within the corporate limits of the City of l+Jichita

Falls, Texas, except within the described area. The

amendment of course changed the area.

On October 29, 1951, Section 1 of Ordinance No.

1416 was again amended by amending Section 4 by providing

that the ordinance should not apply to wholesale dealers,

"who shall sell at wholesale to retail dealers only and to

no other persons, firm or corporation; that this ordinance

shall not apply to retail dealers who are in business as a

package store at the same location on January 1, 1951, and

rwhoheld a legal package store permit or retail dealer's

off-premise license on January 1, 1951." This amendment

was to take care of an area recently annexed to the city.

On November 14, 1955, Ordinance 1740 was adopted

which prevented the delivery of "spiritous, vlnous or malt

liquors" except in the area set out therein.

On January 27, 1958, an ordinance was adopted

amending Ordinance No. 1416 as amended by Ordinance 1425

providing that "no spiritous, vinous or malt liquors"

could be sold within the corporate limits of the city of

?JichltaFalls except in the described areas. This amend-

ment allowed the sale of spiritous, vinous or malt liquors

within the site known as "Weeks Park Clubhouse".

. *

Mr. Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 3 (WW-1433 )

On April 13, 1959, Ordinance No. 1830 was adopted

amending Section 4 of Ordinance No. 1416 and Section 1 of

Ordinance 1579 providing that Ordinance No. 1416 and Or-

dinance No. 1579 "shall not apply to wholesale dealers,

who shall sell at wholesale to retail dealers only and to

no other person, firm or corporation; that Ordinance No.

1416 and Ordinance No. 1579 shall not apply to retail

dealers who are in business as a package store at the

same location at the time any area is annexed to and

included within the corporate limits of the City of Wichita

Falls, Texas, and who held a legal package store permit

and/or retail dealer's off-premise license, at the time

of such annexation."

On January 11, 1960, Ordinance No. 1884 was

adopted amending Section 4 of Ordinance No. 1416 so as to

provide that Section 4 of 1416 would read as follows:

"In recognition of the principle of continu-

ance of nonconforming use, when an area is annexed

to the city limits of the City of Wichita Falls,

Texas, that contains businesses operating under

package store permit, a retail dealer's on-premise

license or retail dealer's off-premise license as

defined by the Texas Liquor Control Act, those

existing businesses shall be allowed to continue

in the same location with the right to transfer

said permit for license.

"That Ordinance No. 1416, as amended, shall

not apply to liquor wholesalers with the following

types of licenses:

"General Distributorls License, Local Dis-

tributor's License, Branch Distributor's License

or Wholesale Permits, as the same are defined by

the Texas Liquor Control Act."

On May 9, 1960, Ordinance No. 1425 and Ordinance

No . 1796 were amended by Ordinance No. 1907. Section 1 of

Ordinance No. 1425 was amended to Include an additional

area. To "establish a liquor zone in which liquor may be

legally sold within the City of Wichita Falls and adding

to that area a portion of land which is described in the

ordinance."

On December 18, 1961, Ordinance No. 1974 was

adopted amending Section 4 of Ordinance No. 1416 so as to

provide as follows:

Mr. Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 4 (Ww-1433 )

"In recognition of the principle of con-

tinuance of nonconforming use, when an area is

annexed to the city limits of the City of Wichita

Falls, Texas, that contains businesses which

have been operating in said area for a period

of no less than twelve months under a package

store permit, a retail dealer's on-premise li-

cense or a retail dealer's off-premise license

as defined by the Texas Liquor Control Act,

those businesses which have existed for such

period of time shall be allowed to continue in

the same location with the right to transfer

said permit or license.

"That Ordinance No. 1416, as amended, shall

not apply to the following types of licenses:

"General Distributor's License, Local Dis-

tributor's License, Branch Distributor's License

or Wholesaler's Permits, as the same are defined

by the Texas Liquor Control Act.

"Section 2, Ordinance No. 1884 and all other

ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby ex-

pressly repealed."

Nowhere in any of the ordinances set out above,

copies of which were supplied to this office by A. L. Fitts,

City Clerk, is any provision made restricting the sale of

beer. The ordinances all cover "spiritous, vinous or malt

liquors" with the exception of Ordinance No. 1907, which

speaks of "a liquor zone." Li uor is defined in the Texas

Liquor Control Act, Article 662 -3a(5), V. P. C., as follows:

"'Liquor' shall mean any alcoholic bever-

age containing alcohol in excess of four (4) per

centum by weight, unless otherwise indicated.

Proof that an alcoholic beverage is alcohol,

spirits of wine, whiskey, liquor, wine, brandy,

gin, rum, ale, malt liquor, tequila, mescal,

habanero, or barreteago, shall be prima facie

evidence that the same is liquor as herein de-

fined."

Beer is defined in Article 667-1(b) as follows:

"The term 'beer' means a malt beverage con-

taining one-half of one per cent (1%) or more of

alcohol by volume and not more than four (4) per

I$?

_’. Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 5 (W-1433 )

centum of alcohol by weight, and shall not be

inclusive of any beverage designated by label

or ctherwise by any other name than beer."

It is therefore the opinion of this office that

all ordinances set out above of the City of Wichita Falls,

Texas, apply only to liquor having 496or more by volume of

al:ohol, and does not include beer as defined in the Te::&s

Lic;uorControl Act. We therefore hold that the Texas Liquor

:ontrol Board, as you point out, was bound "to issue the

license . . ." as a result of the judgment of the District

Court and that there was no restriction on the issuance of

sue!?license because the city has placed no restriction

o-nthe sale of beer anywhere within its limits.

Under the facts stated, the "FM Road 369” location

is included within the area covered by Ordinance Nos. 197Lk

and 1884. The package store permit was issued by the Texas

Liquor Control Board on December 7, 1961; however, it is

noted in your letter that the area was annexed to the City

of Wichita Falls, Texas, on November 13, 1961. At the time

of this annexation, Ordinance No. 1884, approved on Janu-

ary 11, 1960, was in effect. Under this ordinance, a paclc-

age store permittee and a retail dealer off-premise licensee

could continue .tooperate if the business was in existence

at the time of the annexation. Under the facts outlined in

vour letter, Mr. Neeles was not in business at that time.

herefore, he could ha;e had no "vested right" to such busi-

ness. A city can by its zoning regulations restrict the

sale of alcoholic lio;uorto certain areas within the city.

Louder v. Texas Liquor Control Board, 214 S.V.2d 330 (Civ.

‘1pp.1 .

Inasmuch as the package store permit expired

August 31, 1962, and,under the cities' zoning ordinances,

cannot be renewed .thequestion concerning its cancellation

is moot.

SUMMARY

The Texas Liquor Control Board should not cancel

the Retail Dealer's Off-Premise License heretofore

issued to Claude D. Neeley by virtue of the circum-

;tan,zec

I and facts surrounding its issuance.

Mr . Coke R. Stevenson, Jr., Page 6 (W-1433 )

Norman V. Suarez

Assistant

NVS:nss

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

'd.V. Geppey'c,Chairman

RFXIE':!ED

FOR TKE ATTORNEY GENERAL

BY: Leonard Passmore

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.