Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1963
Status
Published
On the bench
Waggoner Carr
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

THEA ORNEP ENE

OF TEXAS

February 28, 1963

Hon. Menton J. Murray, Chairman Opinion No. C- 23

Sub-Committee, Public Health

House of Representatives Re: Whether House Bill

Austin, Texas 167 is constitutional.

Dear Mr. Murray:

You have requested an opinion from this office as to

whether House Bill 167, presently pending in the House of Rep-

resentatives, is constitutional. You have advised us that the

Committee as a whole instructed you to request same.

You have stated in your letter that:

"The bill seeks to permit, through an elec-

ti.on,the establishment of a school for retarded

children. Some members of the committee are of

the opinion that in order to establish such a

retarded school district, we would have to amend

the Constitution similar to amendments required

when an area seeks to set up a hospital district."

House Bill 1.67authorizes the establishment of Rehabi-

li.tatTonDistrrcts, composed of a county or a combination of

counties, to provide education, training and special services

and guidance for mentally retarded and physically handicapped

persons over six (6) years cf age. House Bill 167 further pro-

vides that:

"AL1 powers relating to the acquisition of

land, the construction or acquisition of facilitieS

except the Issuance of bonds, and to taxation,

vested by law an Independent school districts, shall

be applicable ,toany Rehabilitation district, sub-

ject to a tax limitation of five cents (5#) on each

One Hundred Dollars ($100.00) valuation."

Hon. Menton J. Murray, page 2 (C- 23 )

Also, in Section 7(i) of House Bill 167, which deals with the

powers of a Rehabilitation District, there is granted to the

Board of Directors of the District the authority to:

"(3) Levy taxes and make such distribution

of such taxes as it may deem necessary for pro-

viding needed housing and facilities, and for the

support of the Rehabilitation program, except that

the total annual tax for all District purposes

shall not exceed the rate of five cents (59!) on

each One Hundred Dollars ($100.00) of assessed

valuation of taxable property located In such dis-

trict;"

The procedure set forth in House Bill 167 for the

formation of a Rehabilitation District requires that a petition

requesting an election upon the Issue of creating a Rehabilita-

tion District be filed with the Commissioners Court, and after

the filing of such petition the Commissioners Court is required

to order an election for the purpose of determining whether a

Rehabilitation District will be established.

It Is apparent from a reading of House Bill 167 that

the Rehabilitation Districts provided for therein are a form of

specialsschool districts with the purpose of providing educa-

tion, training and guidance for mentally retarded and physically

handicapped children of school age who could not safely or ade-

quately be educated in the existing public schools.

Section 1 of Article VII of the Constitution of Texas

provides that:

"A general diffusion of knowledge being essen-

tial to the preservation of the liberties and rights

of the people, it shall be the duty of the Legisla-

ture of the State to establish and make suitable

provision for the support and maintenance of an ef-

ficient system of public free schools."

Section 3 of Article VII of the Constitution of Texas

provides in part that:

11

.provided, however, that should the limit

of taxition herein named be insufficient the deficit

may be met by appropriation from the general funds of

the State and the Legislature may also provide for

the formation of school district by general laws; and

-92-

I .

Hon. Menton J. Murray, Page 3(C- 23 )

all such school districts may embrace warts of two

or more counties, and the Legislature shall be au-

thorized to pass laws for the assessment and collec-

tion of taxes in all said districts and for the manag-

ement and control of the public school or schools of

such districts, whether such districts are composed

of territory wholly within a county or in warts of

two or more-counties, and the Legislature may authorize

an additional ad valorem tax to be levied and collected

within all school districts heretofore formed or here-

after formed, for the further maintenance of public

free schools, and for the erection and equipment of

school buildings therein;. . .' (Emphasis added)

Section 48 of Article III of the Constitution of Texas

provides in part that:

"The Legislature shall not have the right

to levy taxes or impose burdens upon people, ex-

cept to raise revenue sufficient for the economical

administration of the Government in which may be

included the following purposes:

tt

. . .

"The support of public schools, in which shall

be included colleges and universities established

by the State; and the maintenance and support of

the Agricultural and Mechanical College of Texas."

The above quoted provisions of the Constitution of

Texas clearly establish that it is the duty of the Legislature

to provide for an efficient system of public schools in this

State. The same provisions of the Constitution also clearly

show that the Legislature is authorized to create school dis-

tricts as well 83 to provide for the assessment and collection

of taxes in such school districts. While the type of special

school districts proposed in House Bill 167 tends to fall out-

side of the generally recognized types of school districts, it

is also well recogn,izedby the courts of this State that the

Legislature has broad discretion in enacting laws which it deems

necessarv and exwedient in organizing, operating, and maintain-

ing the public school system of this-State. Mumke v. Marrs,

120 %e.x.383, 40 S.W.2d 31 (1931); El Dorauo Independent School

Distrfct 3 S.W.2d 420 (Comm.App. 1928); and Wilson

v. Abflene Independent School District, 190 S.W.2d 406 (Tex.

Civ.App. 1945, error ref. w.o.m.). In addition, it is stated

in 37 Tex.Jur. 847, Schools, Sec. 5, that:

.

Hon. Menton J. Murray, page 4 (C- 23 )

"Under the Constitution public education is

a division or department of the government the

affairs of which are administered by public of-

ficers, and in the conduct of which the Legislature

has all legislative power not denied it by the

fundamental law. In ascertaining the power which

the Legislature may constitutionally exercise with

reference to the school system, the courts will

not limit or restrict that power unless they find

in the Constitution itself a specific limitation

or one which arises by necessary implication from

the language used. Consequently the Legislature

may pass such laws as in its discretion appear

necessary and expedient for effectuating the

declared policy, subject only to the general

limitations imposed in the organic law. It is

the judge of what means are necessary and appro-

priate for the purpose, and its determination will

not be reviewed by the courts if the act has a

real relation to the subject and the object of the

Constitution."

The courts in this State have held that liberal rules

for construction of the Constitution of Texas should apply in

determining the power of the Legislature in organizing the pub-

lic school programs of this State. Mumme V. Marrs, supra. In

the case of c cCraw 132 Tex.

613, 126 S.W.2d b27 (1939), the Court said that:

"This Court has repeatedly held that no

act of the Legislature will be declared uncons-

titutional unless some provision of the Constitu-

tion can be cited which clearly shows the invalidity

of such act. Brown v. City of Galveston, 97 Tex.

1, 75 s.w. 488; g Tex.Jur., sec. 59, pp. 477, 478,

and cases cited in footnotes. The burden is on him

who attacks a law for unconstitutionality and courts

need not exert their ingenuity to find reasons for

holding the law invalid. As was said by the Supreme

Court of the United States in the case of Middleton

V. Texas Power & Light Co., 249 U.S. 152, at page

157: 39 S.Ct. 227, at page 229, 63 L.Ed. 527:

'There is a strong presumption that a Legislature

understands and correctly appreciates the needs

of its own people, that its laws are directed to

problems made manifest by experience, and that

its discriminations are based upon adequate

grounds.!

-94-

Hon. Menton J. Murray, page 5 (C- 23 )

"If doubt should be raised as to the validity

of a statute, such statute should be held valid un-

less it clearly violates some provision of the Con-

stitution."

In view of the foregoing authorities we are of

the opinion that the creation of Rehabilitation Districts

as proposed by House Bill 167 would be a valid enactment of

the Legislature pursuant to Section 1 and Section 3 of Article

VII of the Constitution of Texas, and would not require the

submission of a constitutional amendment authorizing the creation

of this type cf district.

SUMMARY

The creation of Rehabilitation Districts as

proposed by House Bill 167 would be a valid enactment

of the Legislature pursuant to Section 1 and Section

3 of Article VII of the Constitution of Texas, and

would no,trequire the submission of a constitutional

amendment authorizing the creation of this type of

district.

Yours very truly,

WAGGONER CARR

Attornev General of Texas

PB:mkh: wb Assistant

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

W, V. Geppert, Chairman

J. C. Davis

W. 0. Shultz

Ernest Fortenberry

Grady Chandler

APPROVED F3R T'HEATTORNEY GENERAL

BY: Stanton Stone

-95-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.