Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1963
Status
Published
On the bench
Waggoner Carr
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

TEEATTORNEYGENERAL

OF TEXAS

November 21, 1963

Honorable R. L. Coffman Opinion No. C- 181

Administrator

Texas Employment Commission Re: An interpretation of the

Austin 1, Texas provisions authorizing

merit increases to em-

ployees of the Texas

Dear Mr. Coffman: Employment Commission.

You have requested our opinion as to whether the

provisions of House Bill 86, Acts of the 58th Legislature, Regular

Session, 1963, found in Article V, Section 1, B L, or provisions

found within the appropriation for the Texas Employment Commis-

sion in Article III are controlling with regard to the granting

of merit increases to employees of the Texas Employment Commission.

Section 1, S L, Article V, General Provisions, of

House Bill 86, sets forth specific provisions governing Merit

Salary Increases in recognition of oontinuing outstanding per;

formance of State employees "unless otherwise provlded. . .'

The specific provision within the Commission's

appropriation Is found,at page III-59 and provides as follows:

"Salary adjustments and Merit Increases

within designated salary ranges shall be

governed by agreements with the -Govern-

ment pursuant to Federal standards $or a Merit

System of Personnel Administration. (Rnphasls

added).

As a guide to a proper understanding of the question

presented, it is deemed helpful to first review the Texas m-

ployment Commission. It is a State agency and.lts employees are

State employees. It was oontemplated under this coordinated

Federal and State Unemployment Compensation System that the ad-

ministration thereof would be handled through designated State

agencies. The administration of the program is wholly financed

-8811

Hon. R. L. Ccffman, page 2 (c-181 )

by grants from the Federal Government and the Commission is

acting as the disbursing agency for the Federal Government.

The Commission was established In 1936 by Article 522lb-8,

Vernon'sCivil Statutes. Article 5221b-8 through Article

5221b-10 sets forth the responsibllitles and powers of the

Commission. Section (a) of Article 5221b-9, for example,

prescribes certain duties and powers of the Commission, and

in Section (5.)of Article 5221b-9, the Commission is directed

to cooperate to the fullest extent with the Social Security

Board,

Under this coordinated Federal and State system,

the Federal Government uses the taxes which it collects to

pay the cost of administration of both the Federal and State

plans. This money used to defray administrative costs is sent

to the states by the Secretary of the Treasury upon certlflca-

tion from the Social Security Board In compliance with 42 U.S.C.A.,

Section 502a upon proper compliance with Section 503 of Title

42, U.S.C.A. which provides as follows:

"(a) The Board shall make no certifica-

tion for payment to any state unless It finds

that the law of such State, approved by the

Board under Sections 1600-1611 of Title 26,

includes provision for--

"(1) Such methods of administration

(Including after January 1, 1940; methods

relating to the establishment and mainte-

nance of personnel'standards on a merit

basis, except that the Board shall exercise

no authority with respect to the.selection,

tenure of office, and compensation of any

individual employed in accordance with such

methods) as are found by the Board to be

reasonably calculated to insure full payment

of unemployment compensation when due; . . .'

(Emphasis added).

In Attorney General's Opinion v-427 (1947), this

Department held that with respect to Federal funds expended,

the Commission is primarily governed by the standards prescribed

by the Social Security Administrator and the U.S. Employment

Service of the Department of Labor and the rules and regulations

adopted by the Commission to meet such standards. In Attorney

General's Opinion WW-1242 (1962), the authority of the Commission

to administer the employment program in the most efficient manner

-882-

..

Hon. R. L. Coffman, page 3 (c-181 )

was held to be within the discretion of the Commission not-

withstanding special provisions within the General Appropriation

Act of the 57th Legislature to the contrary. Thus, we recognize

the ~somewhat different status with regard to the Commission in

comparison with other State agencies whose funds are not derived

from Federal grants. In fact, such methods were recognized In

House Bill 86 at page 111-56, which provides as follows:

"In order to comply and conform with the

terms of Federal laws and regulations and

standards under which such moneys are.:gl"anted

for administration shall be expended in accord-

ance with the terms of the Texas Unemployment

Compensation Act, the standards of the Bureau of

Employment Security and/or United States Etn-

ployment Service or successors, and the rules

or regulations adopted by the Texas Employment

In view of the fact that it has been long recognized

that agreements in compliance with applicable Federal social

security regulations are necessary to qualify for Federal grants,

it is concluded that the establishment of the recent Texas Em-

ployees Classification Act should be construed in harmony wlth

these recognized and prior conditions. Therefore, so long as

salary adjustments and increases do not increase the employee's

salary to an amount outside of the salary ranges designated by

House Bill 86, they are valid as a part of an agreement with the

Federal Government in the establishing and maintaining of a merit

system,

In reaching this result, we are particularly persuaded

by the mandatory language found in the provisions of Article III

of House Bill 86, as quoted above, by the historical recognition

of such agreements between the Commission and the Federal Govern-

ment and by the fact that the Legislature has limited such

-883-

Hon. R. L. Coffman, page 4 (C- 181 )

agreements only to the extent that the resulting employees'

salary not exceed the designated salary ranges of House Bill

86. It is further observed that the Legislature has recognized

the situation of a State-administered Federal grant program in

an area of such mutual importance, and it is concluded that If

the Legislature had intended to abolish such a system It could

have and would have done so In a clear-and convincing manner.

This it did not do, and therefore, It is concluded that the

granting of Merit Increases to employees of the Texas Eknploy-

ment Commission is governed by agreements with the Federal

Government pursuant to Federal standards for a Merit System

of Personnel Administration.

SUMMARY

Merit Increases within the designated salary

ranges for employees of the Texas EknploymentCom-

mission are governed by the provisions found at

page III-59 of House Bill 86, Acts of the 58th

Legislature, Regular Session, 1963, which provides

that Merit Increases within the designated salary

ranges are governed by agreements with the Federal

Government pursuant to Federal standards for a

Merit System of Personnel Administration.

Yours very truly,

WAGGONER CARR

Attorney General

By:

PP:mk2l

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

George Gray, Acting Chairman

Pat Bailey

Paul Robertson

Nicholas Irsfeld

W. V. Geppert

APPROVED FOR THE ATTORNHY GENERAL

BY: Stanton Stone

-884-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.