Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1965
Status
Published
On the bench
Waggoner Carr
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Mr. E/P. Slater OQlnlo~ No. c-519

County Attorney

Caldwell Countv RI?: ProDrlets of lncltiion of %eserve

Luling, Texas- for-Bad i)ebts"and deserve for

Bond Depletion" In determlning

the value of shares of bank stock

Dear Mr. Slater: for ad valorem tax purpoees.

You have requested that we advise you as to how the shares

of stock in the First Iockhart National Bank of.Lockhart, Texas-

should be valued for ad valorem tax purposes. The Bank has sub-

mitted to the Tax Assessor-Collector of Caldwell County a state-

ment of the condition of thenBank. !l!he’copyof thlsfstatement

which you have furnished us shows as liablllt~es a Reserve for

Bad Debts" In the amount of 3:z.s and a Reserve for Bond

Depletion" in the amount of t% . .

As stated in your letter, Attorney General Opinion No.

O-4675 (1942).held that a "Reserve for Contingencies" must be

taken into consideration by the board of equalization In fixing

the value of the stock for tax purposes. We quote the following

excerpt from page 4 of this opinion:

"The phrase' reserve for contlngencies~

Indicated that the bank hea set apart and

segregated a part of its earned surplus for

the purpose of meeting whatever contingency

that may arise. That fund, by whatever name

It may be called, Is a part of the bank's

personal property. As such It is neither

assessable nor taxable to the bank. Article

7166, supra; City of Marshall vs. State Bank

of Marshall, 60 C. A. 508, 127 S.W. 1083. On

the other hand, as personal property, it Is a

part of the assets of the bank and Is one of

the factors to be taken into consideration by

the board of equalization in ffixlngthe Value

of the stoak for tax purposes.

You then make the following statement:

-2439-

.:

.

Mr. E. P. Slate* - Page .2 (C-519) '~

“Following ‘your opinion No. O-~&O, MS,

are unable~to determine If these reserves

represent definite accrued llabllltles rather ,.

than capital furids,surplus or undivided

Q??ofitS.':.~ .

..:

:. We quote 'the following eX&e&ts f m pigee' 2 and 3,of ..'

Attorney Oenersl Opinion No. 0-686~ (1943: .. . ‘~,

"We therefore advise you ttit &.?ognlsed

acqounting practice d~stlngulshes sur~lus.re-

serves such a8 for.addltions, anticipated

losses,~ bond sinking funds, end the like from

so-called treservesR set 'up for contra asset

..,

acoo'unts,such as accrued llabilit%es. While

accrued llablllty 'tieeerveti' represent funds .

;.

held by the bank not imsnedlatelypayable, by

their vely'nature as accrued liabilities or'

debts,~little, If any, .conslderation could

be accorded such funds as elements tdnding :,

to compose or~augment the ,valUe of the stook :

‘.., In ,the hands'of the stoakholder. Therefore,

if 'the facts ,arefound to,be as'titated.by

.’ ‘,

the bank, the assessor and counjiyaommis810nersr

court should give a Qroprlate conslderatlon to ‘. .

the facts that the 8 265,376.23 Qortlon.of the

so-called ~'reserve'fund represents definite.

accrued~llabllltles rattierthan capital'funds,;

surplus or undivided profits. The assessor

or ,the~board of equalization may, of~course,

In exercising their expert 'adminlstratfve

Judgment, conclude that an amount In excess~

of' that necessary to meet these liabllltles

has b&en set eside. Any such excess should,

of course, be treated as surplus or undivided ,~

QlVfltS.

"It Is believed that the ratlonallsatlon -

suggested in this opinion will serve to dlstin-

gulsh It from Opinion No. O-4675 to which you

Invited the attent.ionof this department. That

opinion involved a fund set up for contingen-

cies rather than accrued 1iabllSties and ~the

holding was that such fund was 'one of the

factors to be taken into, consideration by the

board of equalization in fixing the value of

the stock for tax purposes. I”

-2440~,

Mr. E. P. Slater, Page 3 (C-&9)

We .think the "Reserve for Bond Depletion" constitutes a~"Reserve

for Contingencies" within the scope of the holding of Attorney

General Opinion No. O-4675. 4

Attorney General Opinion No. Ww-935 (1960) speclflcally'

held that the “Reserve for & Id Debts" set up 'by a National

Bank pursuant to Federal rulings may not be deducted In arrlv-

ing at the value of the shareh61deris shares for State and

County ad valorem tax purposes. A copy of Opinion No. WW-935

Is attached hereto.

You are, therefore, advised that these two Reserves are

neither assessable nor taxable to the Bank, but that as personal

property they constitute a part of the assets of the Bsnk and

would be one of the factors to be taken Into consideration by

the assessor or the board of equallsatlon in fixing the value

of the shares o? bank stock for ad valorem tsx purposes.

SUMMARY

The "Reserve for Bad Debts" and the "Reserve

for Bond Depletion" are neither assessable nbr

taxable to the First Lockhart National Bank of -

‘Lockhart,Texas. As personal property they COQ-

stltute part of the assets of the bank and should

be taken into consideration by the Tax.Assessor-

Colleotor In determining the value of the shsres~

o? bank stock for ad valorem tax purposes.

Your0 .very truly,

WAOOONER CARR

Attorney General of Texas

MMP/fb

AP&NED:

OPINION COMMITTEg

W. V. Oeppert, Chairman

$;sp$ Taylor ;

l

Brandon Bickett

John Pettlt .

APPROVED FOR TRE ATIy)RNRYQERERAL

BY: T. B. Wright

-2441-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.