Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1965
Status
Published
On the bench
Waggoner Carr
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

October 18; 1965..

Honorab~s:~~~.rWlnters,.

Commissioner-

Statet~p~ment:.of"Publlc Welfare

Austin; T&as2

Cplnlon No,.. C+2&

Re:.Is.theState.,Depart&entof

Public Welfare‘authorized.

,t0 se&up- a:Di%y.:Ckre

Advlsory;C?immlttee~.-conaltitlhg

of.r@presentative~~:of"'other~

State~.D&partiaents-~or:~Agerx9.es~

other”

and'.reprieaent&tiires'-ofl

profess~ona~'and'cl~lcgrm~~

fo~~.~the~putpose~:of'~comply~~.

tith.the?federdlzequ~rem6nt~

and.agreement:~wh%hI& tiii?

basfa-fdr~t~~.,~partment:'cr'

recelvine;lfederal.Ainds:for

th~~Ceire::Program'l~~t~e

.State;;o~~~~si.and~re2ated..

questMns?-.

Yi%w~-recent' 1ett~errequestBaanopMlon-.op%he;above~

captioned:matters 'and.-from':~icK

we-quote..:ln::part:'

~~~~Advls~~~Carmnittee~~consls-~ng- of:

re~esenti&lves.fi%m~~other+tate:~Agencl&3'-

and:'re@esentatlves,-of?other~.prof~sslonal

.- an&'-~f?lcgroups:-lntei?ested.'lnrDhe-

development

~~:~~~~~-Semrices-for~.Chlld~e~l~ the~state

*

!lii:pkepsrlng~.f6za-.meetlng

6f.~the:-Day.C&re

AdViaory-Committee;wer::dlscussed'wl;th

the

Comptrollerls:

Cfflce.th&method.of:payment

of~the-perdiem anal-the~travel-expenses'and

wec.were,<.advised~'that.payment.

coul&%ot'be

-de;. !l!lie:~Departme~t

ls:propos$ng:,to

spay:

the&@mt%ttee~members~-pezyd,lem

,..~ a@:ts&vel

expenses::.on

the~same.-basis..asl-per.!.diem

and

t?aveLexpenses are.~provided:for:.State-~-

.employees-,under-Part1V,'~Section

:13?.of:

H~use~~13ill.Noi.12....All

of.the:funds'tobe.

-2495:-

Hon. John Winters. Pa& 2 Cp$nion NO. C-!5~

used for this purpose are funds allocated

& the United States Oovernment for the.

puz$xes of carryingout the provisions of

Title V, Part 3, Section 523(a) (1) (B) of

the Federal:Social Security Act.

"The Comptroller'sDepartmentstated that

~paymentwould not be made on.+e basis that:

"1. The Department did &have any.

spealfgc.statutory authority to

appoint a Day Care Advisory

Committeeor to pay the expenses

of.memb&s of such Committee

whPle attendingofficial meetings;

Andy

: "2. "That employeesof other State

:-Agenciescould not serve on such

; Committeewithout possibly jeopard-

.:-,..

1,&zing their salaries with the

_,

ernploylngState Agency.

%he..hpartment takes the view that It does

.ha+e.the'statutory authority to appoint a

.Bsy Care~.Advlsory Commlttee,andto pw %he

pe=--dPem..and.travelexpenses of the members

of suchGmm&ttee while attendlng.o$Y&lal.

yeetlngs. .. .

:. .-:,.~- . .

II,

a . ..

II.

i .:. .Sin&e:theappolntment..of~fhe Advisory

Commlttee~:ls &'&ondltlon~:precedent %o the

-Departmen~*s'obf;ainine,.approvall~f~~b~eState

-P&ah fop ChI3d.Welfare.Services, -the Depart-

ment'feels:thiit:dt.%houldi.,andthat It.can,

legally.ljay these:Commttteemembers.-:per~dlem

.and travel expensesa&ally incurred in the

c&rse of the performanaeof their dutles~'as

'-C~ttee.,m&&er~'s; :.. ::;‘.::~'G_~

c+~.,~

.Ii

.-. ~.::.:I

1, '. "' >

"The .quesMon;has also,&~~~~Pa&& &&.the-

the authorlty.ofrepresen*atiives',of~ other

~State'Departments .tosex?veae..members .of this

Advisor-Gmanlttee. We.understsnd.:that.the

basis.:.~o~.~~e%tloning their..author$.ty

t6 serve

ls,~fhat.‘theg:-would

be h6ldinP;two~:pos~tlons of

..&96; ~.:.,:.

."~

<"Y,i:I '.

Hon. John Winters, Page 3, OQinion No.~C-528

honor and trust at the same time, and

therefore.,would be unable to receive'

their salary from the employing State

Agency .. ~. . .

I,. . -.,The Federal Laws providing for

the Advisory Committeesrequire that the

Advisory Committee include among Its

menibers‘representatlves~of other State

Agencies concerned with day care, or .

services reIat.ed.thereto, as well as

representativesof pfofessionalor civic

groups.~ !J!oellmlnatepeople from other

.agencleswould mean that we would be

deprived of the experienceand knowledge

of persons in close&y related fields

suoh'as Education,Health, and Extension

Service, which ls.badly needed in the

development of good Day Care Programs

In this State.

.-

%ly Qurpoae of~the Committee as S~ipiikted

I in the Law and the.agreement with the

United States Children% Bureau, ls.tto,

interest as many different segments.of the

pOQUtition as-QqSSihle with the view of

:extendlngand strengtheningthe services :

avall.able ln aommunltles. for the jpotectlon

and.care of ~chlldrenwho,ere cared for away

from their own homes. By working with

AdVlsory Connnittees~ the DeQartqe+.ls

better .ableto serve the needs of children

being cared .forIn day care centers.'

11.. . .

vWe 'shallappreciateyour opinion on the

following questions:

"1. Is the State &partment of Public

Welfare authorized to set up a Day Care

; Advisory Conimlttee consistingof repre-

sentatlves of other State Departments'or

Agencies and representativesof other -

~qrofessio@. and clvlc'grouljsfor the pur-;

pose of complying-withthe Federal re-

qulrement'and‘agreementwhichIs .the

basis for the~Department!sreceiving

Federal.funda for the Day Care Program

in the'State of Texas?

-2497-

lion,John'Wlnters,Page 4 Oplnlon‘No.~

C.328~

"2. If you answer Question No. one (1)

in the affirmative,then lz the State,

Departmentof public Welfare authordzed

""‘to pay for the per diem and:the.travel

expenses of those members of the ..~

Commfttee who are not employees of

other State Departmentsor Agencies

out of Federal funds made'avallableto

the Department fQr the extension of

the Day Care Program?

“3. If you answer QuestionNo. one (.l)'

in the affirmative,may employees c)S

other State Departmentsserve on this

Day Care Advisory Committee,without

Jeoparqiizln&o$ losing their salaries

from tiheother,State'Agency?~ ,:'.,

"4.. Is.the State Departmentof Public

Welfare empowered to.set up~other types

of'Advisor&~Boardsor.Commltteesof-

Public Welfare (unrelated,toDay .Care

Advisory Committees)which are'essential

to,the accomplishmentof the other..

purposes.ofthe public Welfare Programs

1n.Texs.s

,. in accordanckwlth the Depart-

ment's.agreementswith the.Federa$:.

Government? ..

I'$* Zf khe'kpai-<meitd6es.'.h.&ve'th~ :

atithoi?ity

to'.setup'&3sentialAdvisoti$‘

Boa?@ qr:Cq~ltte&s~.f6raiiypurpose":

it deem appropriate:~d'essenqialto

litheaceoinpl$shuierit

of the'purpdses set.

out in the Public

._ Welfare Act, .z+d.o$her

relate&Stat& Stqtutps.suchas those:

ptividing:for.M~dical Asslst$nc&..un~er-

the'Feder&l.SoclalSectirltyAct,kloes

the Department have the authorlty:to

..paythe per diem and .travel.expelises

solely.out,ofl?~derz+l.Funds,.vhen:,the

State Departmetit.fin@$t.necessary tb..~

request such members Taoattetid'ineetings :

foti.the:purQo~se

of.c+rglng ,out..the~.

pro~lsi~n~of tJiese,IAct$?!'. : :I~._.

In answ&&g your first ~&&3tl&, 'it"& fi;ls.t necessiry

to examine-'and :lntex$l?et.bi$h,&be:

j?ert$$ent.

federal and state :

statutes, together wlth.their po1icy:basi.s..TheFederal SOCKS

Security Act prouidei,. i$,Tltle'V,Part 3.~(@ KS.C., SUbChaQt.

3)~ fcirChlld'Wqlf~k :S&vlces,@d: t$i6:~till,oc&t,ioti

and appropria

tlon of federal’guncjs~ to.the aii(rte,s

.$'!$ch.,aQpiid~+

StatesPlanEi

for,the.purppsq/ti,f ~rk+bllsh%tqj;extet+ng; and strengthening

i&98,- ", .'

..'.~I :

~on;'John Wlnteig, Page 5 y.CplnlonNo.c-528

such .servlceswlthln:the state,. In addition to various other

provlslonq therefor In the state, a.speclflcprovision Is made

in the~fedepalstatute for:th$ allocatlo? and appropriationto,

the states for the express.purposeof providing 'Day Care

ServIcesU. The law further makes It mandatory that the state,

through.lts department administeringthe program, appoint a

Day %are Advisory Ccmmlttee;'Title Vi Section 523 (a) (1) (B)

provides In part as followsi

"Sec. 523; (a) From .thesums apuroprlatedtherefor and

the allotment tivallable

under this part; the~S&cretaryshall

from time to time pay'to each State --

"(1) that has a plan for child-welfareservices which

: has been developed'asprovided In this part and .whlch--

"(Aj . .. .

"(B) provides, w'lthrespect to day care sirvlces

(ticludlngthe proiislon of such care) provided

under the plan --.'

"(I) for cooperativearr&ngementsmtij the.

St&te,healthauthority qnd the Stati agency

prlmar&ly responsiblefo5 State supervision i

of public sbhools to assure msxlmum utilization

.ofsuch agencies In the provision of necessary :

health tiervicesand education for children

receiving day care,

."(ll).

for an advisoryconrmittee,to advise the

State public-welfareagency.on the general

policy Involved In the provision of day care

services under the State plan, which ,shall

Include among Its members representativesof

other State agencies concerned.wlthday care

or services related thereto and persons

representativeof professional or civic or

other publlc.or nonproflE.prlvateagencies,

organizations,or groups concerned with the

provlsion'of day csre, (underscoringadded

for &nphasls)

"'(III). . .

"(iv) for giving priority, In determiningthe

existence.of need.for such day c&e, to

members of low-income or other groups ln the

populatlon.andto geographicalareas which

have the~greatestrelative need for extension

df such day care, and"

12499-

Hon. John Winters, Page 6 ~OplniohNO. .c+j@

Section 523 (a).(2)~also In part.provldes:

;,

. . i.Provided, that In developingsuch.services

~for chileen the facllltles~andexperienceof

voluntaryagencles.shallbe utilized In accord-

ance with child-careprograms and arrangements

In the.States and local communltlesas may be -.

authorizedby the State."

Rules and.regulationsfor the Implementationof this statute

'havebeen subsequentlypromulgatedby the Departmentof %Uth,

Education,and Welfare, Social Security Administration. In this

connectionand in order for the particular state to partlclp&e

In the federal allotment for Day Care Services, which Is but

another.facet.of Chlld'WelfareServlces,~.the. "HandbookFor Child'

Welfdre'Servlces"~ has been published, setting out the mandatory

provisions for the State Plan. See Chapter III; Subitem G.

The Tetis.Leglslature~.hix~madeprovlslon.forthe State

Departtientof Public Welfare's authority so -to,cooperate.x$th

the federal government and to accept -&nd.e.xpendsuch funds In

accordancewith approved State Plans, as shoti by Section 4,

subtiectlon(4) and (7) of Artlcle:695c,.V.C.S. of Texas, such

Act belng:tltlbd"pllibllcWelfare Act df 1941,"subsection (7)

having been *.-d&ted and.tiegded,byActs.1963, 58th Leg.? p.

70?, ch.-257, Sec,tl'.I,

~.eff&t$ve,Aprll12, 196Ti

~'~'P&tliie&

siibse&&ns,<lnps&'ar$:i&oted:

"Sec. 4.- The State D&a&ment &all be charged

wlth the administrationof-the .welfare.ac~lvltles

.dfthe State,as'h&el~fti?r pp'oqlded.

:.TheState

~psi$mentsball:

) '"Qjl. F,.... 1. : 'Y .: :

'. : .~

"(~2)..'i.'. ,.

,.;. 1 . . .-

-W.(3) ~.. :’ g. ::. .

“f(~)“:&&&& ‘&.th’%&~&&r& Sof$al Security

Board, cre$jed 'iuider'Tltle

7:of the Social

Security Act enacted by the Seventy-fourth

Congress and approved Aught 14, ,1935;and 8"s

amendmeniz.

thereto, and $&th any other agency

_ of .the,Fede&l.QovqMent ln.any reasonable.

manner which'ma+ +e...pecessary

-toqualify for

..F+dera?l..Ald::,

.:.l,:. .

Hon. John Winters, Page 7 'OpinionNo. c-.528

“(6) . ~. .

“(7) Establish and Qrcivldesuch method of

local admlnlstratlonas Is deemed advisable,

and provide such personnel as may be found

necessary for carrying out.ln an economical

way the administrationof this Act. To

serve ln an advisory capacity to such local

administrativeunits as may be established,

.forthe accellshment --

--. of theyGooses of

this

-~---Act not in conflict with or du licxlon

of.other --

laws on this subject;

----(we

added for emphaslr

Section 8 of Article 695c, Vernon's Texas.ClvllStatutes

specificallydesignates the State Department of Public Welfare

a%the State Agency to cobperate with the United States

~lldren~s Bureau; and sets forth the m&ruierin which such -

eoaperatlonmay be accomplished:. t

i

"Sec. ,8. tie State Department.lshetiebydesignatedas

"the agency'to.cooperatewith the Chlldren'iBureau of

the United States Department of Labor In:

"(1) Est+bllshlng,extending,and strengthenlng-

especially In predominantlyruralareas, public

welfare services for the protectlon'tidcare of

~.hdoneless,

depende.nt,and neglected children In'

danger 6f becoming delcnquent;and

"(2) Developing State services for the encouragement

and assistance of adequate methods of ckmunlty

child welfare organizationand paying part of the

cost of district, county or ot,herlocal chlld.wel-,

fare services In areas predominantlyrural and In

other areas of special need; ahd as may be deter-

mined by the rules and regulations of sald'state

Department;and

“(3) DeveloQlna such plans as mav be.fotid'

necessary to effectuate the services.contemrJlated

in this SexIon, WC

-- and to com~lg with the rules and

reoulrements--

of the Children'sWlre'&.i.f

-- the Used

States DeQartmentof

- Labor Issued and Qrescrlbed

-2501-

Hon. John Winters, Page~8 opinion No- C-528

&I conformlt~with, and &virtue of the

Federal Social Securs Act as ameaec

l(corlng added for emphaslr

The State &+piWtmentof Pibllc Welfare IS ab30 designated

as the State LicensingAgency for children'sfacilities,

IncludingDay Care Centers,and Is authorizedto set up

standardsand promulgaterules and regulations for the admMs,

tration of the LicensingProgram. See'Sectlon8(a) of Article

695c for specificreference.

House Bill No. 12, Acts of the 59th Legislature,Regular

Sessioni 1965 (the General Appiqrlatlons Act for the blennlum

beginningSeptember1, 1965 and ending August 31, 19671,

appropriatesthe Federal funds and stipulatesthe conditions

under which suph funds may be expended. Reference Is made to

ArticleV, Sections27 and 28 of said General Appropriations

Act which provide as follows.

%ec. 27. FEDERAL FUNDS APPROPRIATEDFOR USE. & funds

received b the agencles:oftpc State named In this

from the.IF--

-- nlted States Governmentare hereby a rlated.~

to such agencps for the purooses s which te

grsnt. alloca Ion, aia, orp aymentwase, sub-~.

the provisionsof this Act. Wlthln%ilrty (3O)'d&k

i .’ ,afteEthe receipt of any such Federal &r&t& &.lo-&tlons,

aid or payments,.theamounts thereof and the purposes.for

'_ which they were made .shallbe epqrted to the Qovernor

and the LegislativeBudget Board. (Underscorlng'added

fop,emphasis)

!%ec; .28. #EDERAL &Pl!RAti 4ND AC+-. :None

-- .of

$&Federal aap~rop Mated for use by the terms of. /

this.Actx

-- & exoended pursuant.60 a contract or.

agreementwlth the Feder'alQovernmentunless.-=& until

.a appropriateState agency haS filed as.of -- such ;;

contractor BP:rea with thaew of

- State for

recordinj- Provlded~, however, that copies of research "'

contra&.classlflid In the.Interest of National SecurltY

shall not be flled,..butIn ,lleuthereof &..statx?iuent

that'

such &'c&tract has been made shall be filed.?... (Under-

~scohg 'addedfo+.empti&s) ,. ~'

From y&r letter, you advise that'kver since the enktG

ment of.Sen#e Blll~No: 118, Acts of the 52nd LeglSlatUre9

Regular Sessioq,~lg51,,yourDepartmenthas corii3lstentlycorn--

plied wlth'the.

provisions of,thqt law @s wellas~the pro-

vlslon;sas:&ontalned4.n..thetkneql, Appr6prlatldns.Act

pertainingto~$he '$llj$gof federal-cotitbacts;:

. It further

i.

$502; .:

Hon. John.Wlnteersi

Page.9 Opinion No. c-528

appears that The:.StatePlan for Child Welfare Services which

was developed by your~lkpartmentwas approved by the Depart-

ment-of Realth, Education,'andWelfare, United States Children's

Bureau, and all subsequentamendments.theretohave been filed

in accordance with the above cited provisions of,the law. The

curzent~officlalState Plan for Child Welfare Services,was

filed In the,Office of the Secretary of the State of Texas op

July13, 1965, which is, In essence, the contractualagreement

between the State Departmentof Public Welfare an'dthe Depart-

ment of Realth,.Educatlonand Welfare,' United States Children's'

Bureau Por.the operation of the Child Welfare Services Program

in this state; It contains provisions In relation to Day Care

Advisory Boards or Committees. The structure, need and

functionsof the Commltteeare evidenced in Item (bj of the

Annual.Budget.Narratlve,effective July 1, 1965, B. pg. 8,

"State Plan for Child Welfare Services," covering the federals

fist+ yea.z.endlngJune 30, 1966, from which we quote:

"(b) A Day:Care Advisory Committee t&~r;t;~eDe~etment

of Publlc.Welfarehas been formed.

used.for~consultationand advice In various ways during

the year. The members are considered. a representative

group from the point~.ofview of geography and individuals

concerned~.withday care. The State Departments of Realth

anffEducation are represented. These-is a high concerii;

tratlon of perions with background~trainlngIn presch,ool

educati,?n."

"The Day .&re Advlsky CommItteemeets on a,quarterly

basisin the offices of the.Departmentof Public

Welfare, Austin, Texas. The major focus of.the

commlttee-1s to evolve guides regardlng.w'aysIn which

the Department of Public Welfare~caribetter utilize

existing day cw services and encourage development

of other public and private day care services where

gaps exist. Some of the.lssues to be studied are:

“(1) Current observationsand .attitudesabout

day car&as seen by Commltkee members.

“(2) Present status of the Department's

role In the extension and strengthening

of day care services.

"(3) Relationshipand use of existing voluntary

non:proflt day care services and commercial

day care facilities.

,-2503-

Hon. John Winters, Page 10 Opinion NO. C-528

“(4) What are the gaps In day care services.

If any, and if there are.gaps, what are

the solutions?

“(5) zkg;sof,khe non-profitday care

.

:

"(6) Extension of~trainingresources on a

.State-widebasis for day care personne!.."

Provision is made in the State Plan for meetings of the Day

Care Advisory CommItteeon a quarterly basis In the office

of the Departmentof Public Welfare In Austin, and for

participationof representativesof the AdvlsOry Committee

In other meetings, some of which could be held in Washington,

D.C. upon call by the United States Children'sBureau. It

would seem that as a practicalmatter, meetings at.least on

a quarterly basis are'essentialIf the Committee Is to function

on an effective basis, and members must also be permitted to

participateIn meetings on a national level lf~Indicated.

Item 7, Subitem (7) appearing on Bi ,Psge 11 &f+& State'Plan

definitelycommits the.Departmentto pay such expenses and

'providesas follows:

"(?) Advisory CommIttees 2 Fe’deral '&da till be used

to pay the expenses of the Day Care Advisory CommIttee'

.to.theState Departmentof Public Welfare to attend _

quarterlymeetings .forthe p oses of carryinglout

the functionsw.stated'ln.5(b"p above. Delegates

from the~Day Care Advisory Committeemay also be sent

to state-and/ornational day care meetings to gain

l&wledge in behalf-..ofthe Department of Public

Welfee~for the extension-andstrengkhenlngof day

care services.;,Xt~e~expensesmay Include travel, per

diem and/or registration.fees."

We observe that this statute was enacted for the pro-

tection of chlldren:andfor the public welfare and as such

should be given a liberal construction,since in rts observances

the public 1s held,to.have.snInterest.'. Small v. State, 360

1962,

S.W.2d ~443...(Tex.Civ.App., error .ref.)..Such general

statutes must be accorded a liberal constructionand given the

most comprehensiveapplicationof which It Is susceptibleto

'effectuate-the-legislative object or public purpose and to

promote t@publl$ interest andywelfare, 53 Tex.Jur.2d298,

Sec. 194; Sec. 203, p. 309, Statutes; .Friedmanv. American

..:T2504-

Hon. John Winters.,Rage 11 Opinion.No.C-528

Suret?iCo. of New York,.137 Tex. 138, 151 S.W.2d 570 (1941),

holding that unemnlosment and nublic welfare laws are legltl-

mate p&+oses within-thepowers of the administrationof-

government. Under this construction,not only all powers and

authorityexpressly granted will be upheld, but allythose

which may bereasonably inferred or implied are to be read

into such a statute.

We are unable to find any law which prohibits the state

Departmentof public Welfare from appointingan Advlsorylloard

or Committee of Public Welfare, such as a Day Care Advisory

CommIttee,nor'any law which Is in conflict with Section 4 of,

Article 695c, which expressly authorizesthe establishmentof

Advisory Boards of Public Welfare. Construingthe statute so . .

asto give it the broadest or most comprehensiveapplication

'ofwhich it is susceptible,as we must, we hold that it was

unnecessaryfor the statute to enumerate specificallythe

various types of committeeswhich are authorized to be

appointed..The statute Is sufficientlycomprehensive,and

the legislativeintent therein sufficientlyclear, to imply

the power and authority for the appointmentof the required

AdvisoryCommIttees or Boards for any phase of such public

welfare,the responsibilityof which is placed In the Depart-

ment of PublSc Welfare, as covered and set out in the statutes.

The.generalwording in the statute, construed ae a whole,

empowersthe Commlsslonerto aPpolnt such advisory boards or

committeesfor such purposes as are reasonably appropriateand

essentialfor the accomplishmentof,the purposes of the Welfare

Act In the absence of any other conflictinglaws on the.subject.

For ln broad general terms The Public Welfare Act authorlies

the Department to performany and al1 acts not Inconsistent

rriththe law for the'purpose of carrying out the provisions.

.ofthe state and federal laws authorizingthe Public Welfare.

*wpama in Texas.

We are unable'to find anything In the Texas Constitution

; which would prohibit such a constructionof the Act aswemake

herein; Section 51, Article III of the Texas Constitution,

..Prohlbltlngthe Legislature from making any grant, or author-

ising the same,.of,public moneys to any Individual,aseocla-

tion of ~lndlvlduals, .munlcipal.

or other corporations,Is not'

given a strict application but Is held to be Inapplicable

where a public purpose for the expendltures.lspresent. State

x.

m Cl 160 vex. 348~331 S.W.2d (1960); Brown

y* Calveston,97,Tex. 1,'.75S.W.2d 488 (i903 Blal;asvWF

%a 37.s.W.2d 291, afflrmed~,123 Tex. 39, 6

lo33 (1931); Allydon Realty Corp. v. Holyoke HouslnR Authorits

23 N.R.2d 665 (x&ss.SuP.Ct.1939); Attorney General Opinions

C-342 (1964) and c-464, and authoritiestherein cited.

-2505-

Hon. John Winters, Page 12 Opinion NO. C-528 .'

Your first and ,fourthquestionsare therefore answered

"Yes".

Your second Inquiry Is also answered in the affirmative.

Your Department is authorizedto pay per diem and travel

expenses of the Committeemembers out of federal funds made

az;vaAle to the Departmentfor the extension of the Day Car,

As previously obsemred,the appointmentof the

Advisor; CommitteeIs mandatory under the statute, and under

Sect. V, Section 27 of the General !Ipproprlations Act (House

Bill No. 12, Acts, 59th'Leglslature,Reg. Session.1965).the

funds received from the federal government were expressly

appropriatedto the various Departmentsfor their use and for.

the purposes for which the,federal grant was made to the

state. It is well-settledthat the statute must be COnStrued

as a whole and with reference to the other statutes both state

and federal, and general system of legislationof which It

forms a part, giving full recognitionto the legislative

.intent.-53 Tex.Jur.2d180, Statutes,~ Sec. 125. Construing

the statute In such light and-giving it the required liberal

Interpretation,we conclude.thatthe'authority to pay

reasonable and necessaryper diem and travel expenses of the

cattee members must be held to have been conferred as a

reasoriable and necessary incident to',committeeservice. It

would bi an unreasonableand unduly technical and harsh.,

i constructionto expect cltlcens~fromvarious parts of the

- : state to expend their own monies for such out of pocket

expenses. Being wlthln the-general-authorized purposes, the

-statutewas not required to-specifically&nunerate these

'particularpurposes In order to authorize the same. .lhe.~

general purposes are broad and comprehensiveenough-to

atithorlzethesesnecessarilylmplled:andIncidentalexpenses,

which are dlstlngulshablein law from salary or compensation,

as Is herelnafternoted.

Your third question asking whether employees of other

state departmentsmay serve on'the Day Care Advisory CommIttee

without jeopardlzlng.orloslng.thelrsalaries 'fromthe .other

state agency la llkewlse answered ttyescr.: It Is:importantto

observe first that the membership on-the Advisory Committeeis,

'not made an offfce or position of proflt~or~en!olument,under

the state or federal government..It.provldesfor.no salarJror

compensatlonjwhich ls:.tobe.dlstlngulshedfrom out-of-pocket

;travel;:

sixbsistence,.and other such per diem expenses/the

'payment.ofwhlch:may be properly authorlzed,bylaw to state

.&nploye& without violatingany constitutionalprovisions;

In&m&h as ;compensatlon is heid to.mean ~sal,ary.Terrell'v.

52371’ 241; i4 s.W.2d .F; 791 .(192g);State v. :

-~."Kingt::118.Teirci~

-2iO6-

Ron. John Winters, Page 13 c-528

Opinion NoJo.

Aronson 314 P.2d 849,

85 (Sup. Ct. Mont. 19%); Kirkwood v.

Soto, Cal. 394, 25

P. 288 (1891); McCoy v. Randlln. 35 S.D.

ml53 N.W. $1 (1915); Milwaukee Co. v. Halsey,g14~l~l~~a~,

1% N.W. 139 (1912); Treu v. Klrkwood,255 P.2d 40

sup.ct. 1953). It would not be an "office of profli or trust;'

under

-_--- the Constitution.as in Sect. 12 of Art. 16, or "civil

office of emolument" under Sect. 40,,ofArt. 16, or "office or

~~ltlon of honor, trust, or profit under Section 33 of Art.

.

We also hold that the place of membership on the Advisory

Board or Committee would not rise to the dignity of "any other

office or position of honor, trust . . . under this S~tateor

the United States. ; ." within the constitutionalmeaning of

such terms In Section 33 of Article 16, Texas Constitution,

which states In part:

"The Accounting Officers of this'state

shall neither draw nor pay a warrsnt

upon the Treasury in favor of any

person, for salary ~or~compensatlonas

agent, officer, or appointee,who i

holds a?t.the,sametlmeany other office

or position of honor, trust or profit,

under this State or the United States,

extG@t as prescribed in this

Constitution. . . ." (emphasisadded)

This Se&ion was notincluded 5.nthe Constitutionof 1876

as a safeguard against a recurrence of the evils and abuses of

the 'carpetbag"era, since It made Its first appearance In the

Constitutionof 1869, a constitutiondrafted by Reconstruction'

Republicans,and its policy reasons are at best conjectural.

See Vol. 43, Tex.Law.Revlew,p. 951; Tex.Const. Art. XII, Sec.

42 (1869).

The only policy basis for the section has been stated to

::.~.

be that of lnaurlng full value for state services rendered In

the payment of'salary or compensationout of state monies.

Thus the safeguard was aimed at preventing a person from hold-

.lng at the same time two state offices or positions; or a

state and federal office 'orposition, the effect of which

Would cause that person to divide his time and fidelity,'to

the detriment of his state service. See Attorney General

@Inion No. 0-2607 (1940);,Vol.43, Texas Law Review, p. 952.

In construing the'meanlngof the Constltutiohand statutes,'

a court will never adopt a constructionthat will make them

absurd or ridlculous.orone that will lead to absurd conclu-

sions or consequencesif the language of the,enactmentIS

-2507-

Hon. John Winters, Page 14 "opinion NO. C-528

susceptibleof any other meaning. 53 Tex.Jur.2d241, 243,

Statutes; Sec. 165.

Furthermore,wherever.posslble,that construction shall

be adopted which shall promote the public.Interest In accord

with sound economic or governmentalpolicy. State v. DeCress

72 Tex. 242, .ll S.W. 1029 (1888).

Generally; In arriving at the meaning of the Constltutlon;

we find It should not be given a "narrow or technical con&-u+

tion" but It Is to be given a "liberalmeaning In order to

effectuate the purpose of the provision of which It IS a part"

and 'words will be consideredto have been use.dIn their

natural-senseand ordinary signification,unless the context

:lndlcatesthe contrary." 12 Tex.Jur.2d 362-363, Constitutional

Law, Sec. 14; Sec. 16, p. 364, and cases therecited.

The words in the phrase "Office or position of honor,

trust,nor profit" are each words.havlnga meaning ascertainable‘

by reference to the other words with which they.are associated

under the maxim, noscitur a soclls. 53 Tex.Jur.26221, Statuted

Sec. 154.

Thus, unless it is an office or posltlon'of honor or trust

within ttiesense intended or meant,by the Constitution,a 'Stats

i employee may serve in such a capacity and still draw his salary

from the Comptroller.

The words ?offlce or position of.honor or trust" as used

in Section 33 of the Constitutionshould be held to have been

used analogously;.sndas'havlng the sqne chsracterlstlcsand

general though not i'dentitiaj. meanlng;,whengiven a.practiCal,

natural, -ordinary,and reasonable construction. Webster's

Third New InternationalDictionary 'p. 1769; Black's Law

Dictionary,.&thRd., p. 1234, 33 Words & Phrases, p. 5%.

nPosltlon;"and cases there annotated. The authoritieshold

that a vposition'! is analogous.to an "office" In that the

duties that pertaln.to it are permanent and certain. The same

essentials,attributes,and characteristicsarepresent lnsof~

asthe duties aresgovernmental: Frajler v. Rlmore, 180 (petit-

232;'173 Siw:2d 563, 565;. Fredericks v. Doard of'Health of

Town of West Hoboken, 82 A.528, 529, '82 N.J.L. 200; Rlsle v.

Board of.Clvj.1Servlce~Cori@'s.of Cl htyvof~~dAr$e~+

2d 167, 16% 60 Cal.App.2d32;.Elurr, P

Freeholder8of Bergen County;Sup.,'163-A. 555, 556, 110 N.J.L*i

9.

An'"bfflce~'~means"place" or "position" and they have

.beenheld',tobe~substsnt%.ally

_~. ., analogous and Interchangeable

-2508-

Hon. John Winters, Page 15 opinion No.~C-528

as understood in law. 29 Words'& Phrases, p. 270, under

"Office -- Place or position";and 1965 Pocket Part pp. 97-

98 and cases there annotated.

As stated in 22 R.C.L. 383. Sec. 1.6, Public Officers,

"Constitutionsand laws sometimes

contain provisionsapplying to offices of

trust or honor and offices or places of

trust or profit. The line between 'offices'

and 'placesof trust or profit' within the

meaning of such provisionshas not been

clearly marked, and they may be considered

as approach@g each other so closely that

they are In all essential featqres identical.

A place of trust or profit is not, however,

Identical.wlthan office, yet it occupies

the same general level in dignity and

importance. . . .'

We have, therefore,~heretofore correctly held on this

subject in Opinion No. O-5341, dated July 19, 1943, that there

- fs no mz$terial;

legal dl~t~nctlonIn meaning between the term

offic0 and po$ltion, and that,as used.in our Constitution,

,zsuch-"posltion'or "office"means that the holder thereof must

exerclse~some governmentalfunction, or be the de@osltory of

some sove~lgnty of the sta$e.'or t:e United States before It

l%%esto .thedignity of an office under the state.,orUnited

Ther& must be delegated to the person holding Such

"OffI&" some of the sovereign functlotis of the state -orthe

Utited States Government.

We held'ln the Opinion as follows:

"There are several persuasive, though not

conclusive,characteristics, oft~&hat

constitutesa public office; or to express

It In another way, what constituteshold-

lng an 'officeunder the U&ted States.'

Weemention B few: Tenti and duration,

oath of office, official bond, etc. But

one indispensablecharacterlstlc,as the

cases hereafternoted affirm, is that the

duties performed shall Involve the

exercise of sovereign power, whether

great or small. Our ownsupreme Court, in

a comparativelyearly case,-Kimbrmh v.

Brnett, ,93Texas 301, 55 S.W. 120, quoted

wi~vio~pi?oval Mechem on Public Officers as

:

-2509-

Ron. John Winters, Page 16 Cplnlon No. C-528

"'A public offlce Is the right, authority,

and.duty created and conferredby law, by

which, for a.given period, either fixed

by law or enduring,atthe pleasure of the

creatingpower, an Individual1s Invested

with some portion of the sovereign

functions of the government,to be

exercisedby him for the benefit of the

public."'

In the above Cplnlon.No.O-5341, and from the authorities

we found that "office"had a definlte,legalmeaning In the

sense employed In the Constitution:

"'The term "office" implies a delegation of

a portion of the soverelgnpower to, and

possession of, It by the person filling the

office; a public office being an agency for

the state, and the person whose .dutyit la

.to perform the agency being a public officer.

The term embraces the.ldea of tenure,

durzitlon,emolument and duties, and .has

.respectto a permanentpubllc,trus$to be

exercised ln'behalf of government,and not

., 'toa rqerelytransient,occaslonalgr.

incidentalemploylnent.A person --'the ',

~ervl~ of the governmentwho -deriveshls~

posljzlonfroma du&y and legally authorized

election or appointment,whose duties '&re ..

continuousIn their-natureand.defined by .~

rules prescribed by government,and not by :

contract, consistingof the exercise of I

importantpublic powers, trusts, or duties,

-asa part of the regular admi,nls~tratlonof

government, she place and the duties:

remalnlng, though the Incumbent dles.or

1s.changed, every office In the c~nstltutlonal

ieanlng of.the tern!implying an author19

to exercise some portion of the sovereign

power,.eltherln~.maklngi exeautlng Or

administeringthe laws. M&hem on.Publlc

Officers,:0.179."

The recerit~caseof Wlllls,v.~~otts,37f~sYW.2d 622 (19641,

by the Supreme C&t.of ~Texas~.construing Art.:3, Sect. 19, ad

Art. 11. Sect: 5 Of the Constitution,held that a City Council-

man'of ihe C&y-of .fi.z,-Wo&h,heldan~'Iofflce~underth& State.'

Utlliz,ingthe reasoning of the earlier de~isl&is, the Court's

declslon.is~ln~harmony~wi~th~'our~~lnlonand .notIn conflict

with it or the distinctionsought to be made. ..~

72510-

Hon..John Winters, Psge 17 Opinion No. C-528

Those authoritiesso coiistrulng the meat&g of."offlce"

or "position"as comprehendingcontlriuous performance oftdefined

permsnent public duties, compensation,tenure,.exercise of

SOverelgnty,and other essentialrequisitesare In accord snd

are thoroughly discussed and briefed In our Opinion O-5341.

See Witkowskl v. Burke; 65 A.2d 781 1949); Sowersv. Wells,

150 Ksn. 630, 95 P.2d 281, 284 (1939f; .Abbottv. McNutt, 218

cdl. 225, 22 P.2d 510 (Zg33),89 A.L.R. 1109; Howard v..Saylor,

305 Ky. 504, 204 S.W;2d 815 (1947);United States v. David

Mouat, 124~U.S. 303, 307, 31 L.E& 4b3 1888 ; People ex rel

Attorn_er 14 P. 853 1887 ; rr.n

me ~oe's

In Re. Wheeler.Mallory, as Public Adm'r. v. Wheeler,

< 130 N-i. 97 (1912); Patten 8 S.E.2d 757 (1940);

wherein the Supreme Court of Georgia approved of a,state

employee (member of the Highway Board) holding at the same tlme-

B position as a niemberof the Advisory Committee of the Atlanta

'Agency of the ReConstructlop-Finance Corporation,the Court

holding that his-office (llsnot an office of profit or trust

under the Government of the United States"; HartIRan v. Board

of Renents of West Virginia University, 38 S.E. 698 ('1901);

Hirschfeld.Commonwealth ex rel Attorney General, 76 S.W.2d

.%7 (w:1934);- State ex rel v. Hawkins, 257 P. 411.(1927), 53

A.L.R. 583' and Ki~ston.Assoclatea~v.La Guardia, 281 N.P.

Supp. 390 2X935), wherein It was held that members of the

A~QE% Committee on Allotments,tcreated:bythe President of

., were not holding an office of honor, trust, or

emolumentunder the-governmentof.the United States."' The

.$urt said:

"'C'learl?;the members of.the Advisory

Committee on Allotmentspossess none of

the powers of the sovereign; They per-

form no independentgovernmentalfunction.

Such functlon.3.ngeneral is either

legislative,judlcla& or executive. It

Is too plain to require discussionthat'

the Advisory Committeeexercises no

legislative or judicialprerog&lves. It

appears to be fairly evident that It IS&e-

wise possesses.nopowers of the executive.

The CommItteethus lacks the most.

&o&&t cha@acteris$icor attribute

associated w%th the Idea of publlc~office,

namely, the right to exercistiSOme part

of the power of the sovereign.'"

Opinion O-5341, of July 19, 1943, that 8~Mstrlct Attorney

could receive his salary and also serve as Chairman of the

Local.Chapter of The American National Red Cross, a Corporation

-251!-

Hon. John Winters, Page 18 Opinion No. c-528. i

charteredby Congress,because the latter was not an officeor

position under,the United States, Is consistentwith our

earlier Cplnlon No. O-5314, of July 2, 1943, holding that a

state or county official could not be excluded from drawing

his salary while serving as a member of an advisory bosrd for

registrants,the latter not being a position of honor, trust

or profit under this State or the United States ,wlthinthe

contemplationof our Texas Constitution. i'

Our still earlier Opinion No. O-4458, of April 8, 1942,

holding that a state employee could serve without loss of

salsry as a member of a~County Tire Rationing Board for'the

same legalreasons Is llkewlse consistentwith the above

Opinions.

Our earlier and thoroughly consideredOpinion No. O-4313,

of Jan. 24, 1942, written by gollie C. Steakley, now a member

of the Texas Supreme Court, Is likewise consistentwith the

above opinions ln.holdl that a.8tat.eemployee.(memberof

State Board of Education"B could still draw his salary .aud

serve on an Allen Enemy Hearing Board, created by the federal

government through the U. S. Attorney-General,paying only.

nominal compensationbut requiring the member to take an.oath;

The Bomd appointmentwas temporary,'forsn lndeflnlteterm,

with only occaslonalmeetings and sporadic activities. It

was merely a fact finding and advisory admlniatrative

Instrumentality,which could neither make norenforce deciel&&

.We expresslyheld that membershipupon such a Doard, which _

would be presumably identical to an Advisory Doard or Caamrittee;

did.not constitutethe holding or exercising of.an offlae of

trust, honor, or pro~fltunder'the'unltedStates. Wethere held

that~"it does not constitutea 'posltlon',as'that term was

Intended by the Frsmers of the Constitution."

The precise question has still never been determinedby

a Texas court but other'jurledlctionsare In general accord

with our clted.hol.dings.

In McIntosh v:Ifutchlnson,59 P.2d 1117.(1936),the

Supreme Court of Washingtonheld thata State Senator.could

still draw his salary and serve as a~"Dlstrlct Supervisor"

of the Federal Works Progress Administration,which was not

deemed to be the acceptance of a "civil office," cltlng

.Bexneyv. Hawkins, 79 Wont. 506, 251 P. 411 (lg27), 53 A.L.R,

583, as to the meaning of the term 'office,"to;wlit:

"After.an exhaustive examinationof the

authorlties,..we

hold that five elements

are~lndispensable.ln.anyposition of

public employment,In order to make it

-i512-~

lion;John Winters;'.Page

19 .. C-528

..,OpinionWo.

a publYC office of a'clvil nature: '(1)

It'must'be created by the Constltutlon

or~by the Legislature or created by a '.

municipality or other body through

authority conferred by the Legislature;

(2) it must possess a delegationof a.

portion of the kovereign power of

goverrqent,to be exercised for the

benefit of'the public; (3) thepowers

conferre'd,snd the duties to'be discharged,

must be defined, directly or lmplledly,

by the legislatureor through leg&slative

authority; (4) the duties must be per-

formed Independentlyandwithout control

of a'superlor power, other than the law,

unle&,they be those of an Inferior or

.subordlnateoffice, created or authorized

by the Leglsiature,.andby It placed

under the general control of a superior

officer 'or'body;(5,) hitnqxsthave'some

permanency and continuity,and not'be

only temporary or,occasional. In addition,

:

in this state an 'officermust take and

. . ' ,file'an offtclal oath; hold a commls~slon

or other wrktten authority,'andgive'an? ..

official bond, if.the latter be required -

-by proper authority." -

The Court concluded that the Senator was not appointed

.toan office since "the-g$eatweight of authority well supports

the.necesslty of meetingall of the .cqndltionslaid .downby the

Montana Courtand. . . it $8 not made to appear that these

conditions;'orany of them;have been here met . . .".

'In accord and Involving similar questions and constltutlon-

al prohibitionssre State v. Corley,.172 Ai 415, (Dsl. 1934);

'Curtinv. State, 214 P. 1030 (Cal. 1923); Mulnlx v. Elliott,

156 P.,216 (Colo..x916); State v. Jo- 78 So. 663 (~a. 1918);

McCoy v. Roard of Suoervisors, 114 P.2d 569 (1941),.cit

Carpenter 135 Tex.'413, 145 S.W.2d 562 (1940 ,

for the.necessityof taking a liberal vlew.~toward the'.encourage-

m&t of such ena&ments t&t.their protectivepurposes~"may be

fulfilledwithout undue.lmposltionof'constltutlonal1Smitations

or hlnderance through narrow judicial construction."

In Parker v. Riley, 113 P.2d 873, 875-876; 18 Cal.26 83

(1941), 134 A.L.R.'1405,the California Supreme Courtupheld a

statuteproviding for ,thecreation of the California Comm$ssion

on Interstate Cooperationand providing for members of the

legislatureto serve thereon. Although the Constitution'

-25X3-

Hon. John Winters, Page x) Cpinl&No. C-528 :.

expresslyprohibitedthe '&embersfrom accepting "any Office,

trust, otiemploymentunder this state," the Court held that

the constltutlonal,mesnlngof-“office” or.“trust” ‘wawnot

applicablethereto as follows:

'*It may be noted, however, that the

pds~flons created by the +tute here

attacked lack certalrielements usually

associatedwith an "office or "trust .

Thus, It Is generally said that an office

or trnat requires the vestlng.ln-an'

individualof a,portlon of the sovereign

powers of the state. (Citationof

authorities) The positions here created

do.not measure up td so high a standard.

They involvemerely the interchangeof.

infopnatlon, the assemblingof data, and

the formulatlon.ofproposals to be placed

before the Legislature. Such tasks,do

not require the exercise of a tart of the

.'

. sovereignpower of the stat&.'

The Riley case doctrine was recently recognizedand re-

aff&ued by the Supreme Court of Califormia~ ln State v. Aron-

son 314 P.2d.849,856-857 (1957)..li.aCcord, see also

'&es le v. Barrett 15 N.E.2d 513 (Ill. 1938); Johnson v.

T)(Ga. 1919); and-ReadlnR hll, .52

P.2d 155 Adz. 1935 , for the.proposition-t& certain

:eesentialelements are required to constitute sn Icofflce"

oi?"'posltlon"as used in such constitutionalsense and:the

~ineaning,ofthese terms as so used do not precltie the 'accept-

ance of such duties and serVlce involving honor &nd%rus$ and

fran which sny citizen could n&escap& without evad$ng bl8

civic or patriotic duty to aid his government or coun!rY in’

.tlmes of ten@orsry emergencies.

The terms "office"or '$osltlon"the&fore' neces&irllY

implies, smongother eiements, compensation,' stability,

dui-ation, permanency, continuity, taking oath and giving bo&t

and the~msklngand administeringof governmental decls-ions‘

independentlyand wlthout Control of a super&or powertietc..--

..

., The &@&M-Sal absence.ofthese essentiali appertainingto

membership on a Day Cai-e AdvlsorJr.Ccmmitte&frees a state

emplcrgee .fiomany constitutionalinhibition to.such service'

while continuingto draw his &ate ssla??yi

In a&wer to goW fifth questlon,'thatis; 'dossiout?

Departmenthave the authorlty.topay the per diem and $r&vell

expense8 solely out of federal funds Upon a finding of-.

.necessltythat such camnltteemembers attend the meetings ~.

-25 14-

for the nwtxe of .csrrjklng of the Acts,

out the pr&r,iri~lons

_ ws hiiyeconc$ded fm*‘l$ m&y be answered in'the afflrma- '

t1v.e. Under the gerieralst+$ut~ry.scheme,and plan of

operation, ws holdsthat under the'federal and~ktate laws he‘&-

inabt&e disouased, the power Is Inherent ln‘the'Dspartme@t,of

F?ibllcWelfare to t@ce the.twxessary steps to comply wltih.+lts

authokrl d contract+ilagreementrequired to be filed tith

the Se0".

x%fary of State'before. the fed&raLm&a can bs

expen,&%qd thereafter'to use and expend such.funds for the'

pUrp1"

Q% 8.,fixtit& they were @lotted to the state without

the ni3~sslty ef a'speclflc enumeratfon In tik statutes. Ln

this connectl~, we.heretof&e held In Attorner%eneral's

Cplnl~ C4K) .(Msy12,.1965) that~'travel'expeksek of unpaid

persm1, such as committeememb&ti.tihlle.&sged in the

perfoMauce of the .offlc.lal business of‘the comm%ttee, can

Abe pald'out of.fe.deya& fur@ received by the State of Texas

by vlrtue of the contractualagreement between the state and

the federal government,,The factual situation presented i"

that:'QjlnlonIs an+ogous to:the one here presented and Is

subijt8iit&ally

the &me. The state and federal government

'we* authprlzed to enter into the contractual arrangement.

We we -ware of any law of this state which .worild prealude .'

~.the pay&at ~~'$iioh.per-diem or travel expelisesout of the

federal mds tib'a~zkprlatedIn such general.terms compre-

hetis&Pe~ei%@ghto.ln&lude such purpose tid under'the s,tat&d

clrcumsttiees.

SUMMARY~

------- _i',

The State.Dspartmentof Public Welfare.

Is authorized to set up a Day Care Advisory

Committee consisting of representativesof,

other State Departments or Agenclea.and,.

representativesof other profess$onal and

civic groups for the purpose of complying

with the federal requlrementxnadethe basii3

for the Department'sreceiving‘federal @nds

far the lky Care Prog&m .ln the State of ,,

Texas.

It is empowered to set up other types~of

Advisory Boards or Commlttees.ofPublic'

Welfare (unrelatedto,Day Care Advisory ,~

Committees)which are essential to the

~aacomplls~entof the other purposes of the.

PuJ~licWelfare Programs In Teias in accordance

with the Department*8agreement with the

federa& government.

-2515- :

Hon. John Winters. PsSe 22 opihio" No...!528

It Is authorizedto pag per diem and

travel expenses to the committee members out

of federal funds made avazlable tQ the.Depar‘t-

ment for the extension of the Day Cat%

Program.

Employeesof the State Departmentsmay

serve on the Day Care Advisory Ccmmlttee.

without loss of salary from the other state

agency, such membershipnot constituting

'an office or position of iionor,trustYor

profit, under this State or the United St.ates"

within the constitutionalmean1 of those

terms In Section 33 of Article T

1 of the

Texas Constitution.

Yours very truly,

WAGGONRR

CARR .

Attorney General :

-APPROVED:

'OPINION CCHMITTEZ

W. V. Ceppert, ChaIrman

Bob qowers

Arthur.Ssndlin

H. Grady Chandler

Roger TJrler

Marietta Payne

APPROVEDF'ORTREATTORNEYGENEEiAL

.BY: T. B. might.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.