Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1965
Status
Published
On the bench
Waggoner Carr
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Mr. Joe G. Moore, Jr.

Executive Director

Texas Water Development Board

Sam Houston State Office Building

Austin, Texas

OPINION NO. c-571

Re: Tuition expense of

employees of the Texas

Water Development Board

to attend an eight day course

in earth control and inves-

tigation held by the Bureau

of Reclamation, Denver Labo-

Dear Mr. Moore; ratories.

You request our opinion as to whether the Texas Water

Development Board may pay the tuition of two employees to

attend an eight day course in Earth Control and Investigation

conducted at the Bureau of Reclamation, Denver Laboratories;

said course includes training in soil classification, logging,

and soils engineering investigations. You further advised

that each of said employees has a degree in Geology and each,

in his present employment with the Texas Water Development

Board, is charged with the responsibility of investigating

foundation geology of dams and reservo,irsand you state that

even though they are trained and experienced in the field, the

relative uniqueness of this occupation requires continuous

education in new processes, conditions, and operations.

You propose to make the $300.00 tuition expenditure

($150.00 per man) from your appropriation for "Water Studies

and Investigations" which are designated in the appropriations

bill to be used for "ground water, surface water, and chemical

quality investigations; ... and shall include statistical

compilations in cooperation with other government agencies ...'I

However, you are informed that the Comptroller of Public

Accounts will not approve the tuition expense without an Attor-

ney General's Opinion aut.hori.zing

payment.

The appropriation to your department, contained in Article

III, House Bill 12, Acts of the 59th Legislature, authorizes

-2760-

Mr. Joe G. Moore, Jr., Page 2 (C-571)

such expenditure unless it violates Section 51 of Article

III, of the Constitution of Texas, which reads as follows:

"The Legislature shall have no power to make

any grant of public moneys to any individual,

association of individuals, municipal or other

corporations whatsoever; ... .'

The most recent expression of this office on this matter

was contained in Attorney General's Opinion WW-505 (1958),

approving a request of the General Land Office to pay the

registration fees for the Chief Appraiser to attend the South-

west Appraisal Conference. Through the years many other opin-

ions of this office authorizing expenditures for travel expense,

registration and tuition fees have been issued, including, but

by no means limited to ww-83 (1957) and WW-433 (1958).

In all such expressions the opinion was that Section 51

of Article III, of the Texas Constitution, prohibits the Legis-

lature from granting or appropriating public money to an indi-

vidual, but it does not prevent the Legislature from making

available such funds to an individual if the use and purposes

of such expenditure is for the furtherance of the governmental

duties of the State, and that the expenditure of such funds for

personnel to attend schools, clinics and conferences for train-

ing purposes is directly and substantially related to the

performance of the State's governmental functions.

As stated in Attorney General's Opinion WW-433 (1958):

"In reviewing past Attorney General's Opinions

on the same question of training of governmental

personnel, it is noted that the following rules

have been consistently applied to determine whether

the training was such that the State could pay for

it. The question asked is whether the training des-

cribed will be directly and substantially used to

facilitate the governmental duties and functions of

the State agency requesting such training. Also, do

the facts establish that there is a reasonable, sub-

stantial and direct relationship between the purpose

of the training and the accomplishment of the govern-

mental functions entrusted to the employee? (Attorney

General's Opinion No. ww-83, April 1, 1957, Insurance

Commission employee training at I.B.M. school, 2-week

course; Attorney General's Opinion No. WW-223, September

12, 1957, Department of Public Safety employee pilot

training in flight proficiency training program;

-2761-

Mr. Joe G. Moore, Jr., Page 8, (C-571)

Attorney General's Opinion No. S-209, July 20,

1956, Secretary of State employee training at

I.B.M. school, b-day course; A~ttorneyGeneral's

Opinion No. ~-2128, Department of Public Safety

employee training in Police Administration at

Northwestern University, 4 l/2 month course)."

In applying the above rules to the fact situation that

you have presented, it is the opinion of this office that the

training to be provided such employees will be directly and

substantially used to facilitate the administration of the

governmental duties of the Texas Water Development Board and

the expenditure of such funds is not prohibited under Section

51 of Article III of the Texas Constitution.

The remaining question is whether the appropriation is

restricted by Section 18, Article V, House Bill 12, Acts of

the 59th Legislature (Appropriations Bill); which provides:

"Restriction on Registration Fees. None of the

monies appropriated in this Act may be expended for

dues, registration fees or any'kina of similar ex-

pense incurred in joining or attending any type of

organization unless the membership is in the name

offthe,State~of Texas."

The above quoted provision of the Appropriations Bill

would prohibit expenditure of such funds for such purposes

only if the provision, in this situation, did in fact require

registration in the name of the State of Texas and this were

not complied with. It could be argued that the course of

instruction conducted by the Bureau of Reclamation was a "type

of organization" and the registrations must be in the name of

the State of Texas if the tuition is to be paid from such

appropriated funds. However, in this particular instance,

inasmuch as the Bureau of Reclamation is an agency of the

United States the term "organization" would not be applicable.

In holding that the word "organization" did not apply to the

United States, the New Hampshire Supreme Court in the case of

Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. v. Manson, 54 A.2d 5c30,583; 94 N.H.

39; stated: "Certainly ~organization' is not commonly employed

in speaking of the United States."

Therefore, it is the opinion of this office that such

Section 18, of Article V, of House Bill 12, Acts of the 59th

Legislature, does not require, as a prerequisite to expenditure

of appropriated funds, that registration at courses conducted

-2?62-

- -

Mr. Joe G. Moore, Jr., page 4 (C-571)

by the Bureau of Reclamation be made in the name of the State

of Texas. However, there is no reason why 'the registrations

could not be made in the name of the State of Texas.

SUMMARY

The Texas Water Development Board may pay

from appropriated funds the tuition fees

of two employees to attend an eight day

course in Earth Control and Investigation

conducted by the Bureau of Reclamation,

Denver Laboratories and the registration

need not be made in the name of~the State

of Texas, although it may be so made.

Very truly yours,

WAGGONER CARR

Attorney General of Texas

HGK:ab

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

W. V. Geppert, Chairman

John Reeves

Pat Bailey

Robert Flowers

Linward Shivers

APPROVED FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By: T. B. Wright

-2763-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.