Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1967
Status
Published
On the bench
Crawford Martin
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE ATJXXZNEW GENERAL

OF TEXAS

CWAWPOLPD Ce MART=&-

AUSTIN,TEXAR 787ll

A1TDRNEY DICNSRAI.

November '21, 1967

Ron. Graves W. Landrum Opinion No. M-160

Vice Chancellor for Adminis-

tration Re: Interagency contracts

Office of the Chancellor between the University

The University of Texas of Texas and the Coordi-

System nating Board, Texas

Austin, Texas college and university

system for the utiliza-

tion of certain data

Dear Mr. Landrum: processing equipment.

Your request for an opinion reads, in part, as follows:

,I

. . .

"Chapter 325, page 685, 59th Legislature,

1965, R.S., provided for the development and

management of automatic data processing systems

in state agencies in an efficient and economical

manner. The Coordinating Board, Texas College

and University System, and The University of

Texas at Austin established a data communi-

cation system between the two agencies which

was evidenced by an Interagency Contract numbered

IAC (66-67) - 338 and approved by the State Board

of Control on February 15, 1967.

"Subsequently, Interagency Contracts num-

bered IAC (68-69) - 007 and IAC (68-69) - 008

were executed by the parties and duly approved by

the State Board of Control on July 24, 1967, in

furtherance of a more efficient data system and

in conformity with the expressed legislative

intent referred to above. Copies of the three

agreements are enclosed for your information.

Hon. Graves W. Landrum, page 2 (M-160)

"We understand that payment under the ap-

proved interagency contracts will be deferred

until the validity of such arrangement to fur-

nish data equipment is approved by you. As you

are aware, The University of Texas at Austin

changed from the IEM 1401 System to the IBM

360 Series System in the fall of 1966. The

University has cooperated with other state

agencies in the use of University data process-

ing equipment for official use on a time avail-

able basis. The Coordinating Board has been a

user of the data equipment under the above con-

ditions. After the transition period the

University continued to rent the IBM 1401 in

order to provide continued backup for the new

system and continued use by the Coordinating

Board. The Board was desirous of updating its

equipment for greater capabilities and more ef-

ficient data processing at a lesser cost. Where-

upon, to be compatible with the IBM 360 Series

equipment located at the University, it was

agreed that rental of IBM 360-20 Series equip-

ment to be located at the Coord'inating Board

would be the best ultimate arrangement. The

four months' rental on the IBM 1401 was continued

while awaiting the installation of the IBM 360-20.

In furtherance of this arrangement contracts were

executed, orders for the rental of said equip-

ment were issued, and the required approvals

obtained. Under the arrangement The University

of Texas at Austin submitted orders for the

rental of IBM 360-20 equipment, thereby pro-

viding compatibility with the new IBM 360 Series,

particularly the IBM 360-40. It was assumed

that the joint use of equipment, people, serv-

ices and programs to increase efficiency would

be in conformity with Article 4413(32), Vernon's

Civil Statutes, which provides that a state agency

may contract for the furnishing of necessary

technical services, services of employees, and

the services of materials and equipment.

-149-

Hon. Graves W. Landrum, page 3 (M-160)

"Based upon the above facts, we would ap-

preciate your advice as to the following ques-

tion:

"Are Board of Control approved Interagency

Contracts numbered IAC (66-67) - 338, IAC (68-69)

- 007 and IAC (68-69) - 008 by and between The

University of Texas at Austin and the Coordi-

nating Board, Texas College and University

System, which provide an arrangement for the

utilization of certain data processing equip-

ment for the benefit of the State of Texas,

valid obligations upon which the State Comp-

troller can issue warrants in payment of such

services?"

Under the contract, the University of Texas as the

performing agent has agreed to provide certain data process-

ing systems and the Coordinating Board, Texas College and

University System as the receiving agent has agreed to pay

to the University of Texas the cost of such services. The

interagency contracts referred to in your request have been

approved by the State Board of Control.

Section 3 of Article 4413(32), Vernon's Civil Stat-

utes, provides in part:

"Any State agency may enter into and

perform a written agreement or contract

with other agencies of the State for fur-

nishing necessary and.authorized special

or technical services, including the serv-

ices of employees, the services of materials,

or the services of equipment. The actual

cost of rendering the services, or the nearest

estimate of the cost that is practicable,

shall be reimbursed, except in the case of

service rendered in the fields of national

defense or disaster relief, or in coopera-

tive efforts, proposed by the Governor, to

-7.50.

Hon. Graves W. Landrum, page 4 (M-168)

promote the economic development of the

State. . . .II (Emphasis added.)

In construing the provisions of Article 4413(32),

it was stated in Attorney General's Opinion S-138 (1954):

"It should be noted that the three types

of authorized services - services of employees,

services of materials, and services of equip-

ment - are listed disjunctively. Thus, a con-

tract may be for each type separately or for

any combination of the three. Looking to the

complete language of the statute, we think the

term 'furnishing services' is used in the broad

sense of making the particular commodity (labor,

materials or equipment) available for the bene-

fit or use of the receiving agency instead of in

the narrow sense of performance of labor or

useful work. It is our opinion that either

materials or equipment may be furnished without

any further attendant 'services'."

In answer to a similar question, it was held in Attor-

ney General's Opinion C-78 (1963):

"Section 6 of Article 4413(32), Vernon's

Civil Statutes, reads as follows:

"'Payments for such services by a re-

ceiving agency shall be made from the appro-

priation items or accounts of the receiving

agency from which like expenditures would

normally be made, based upon vouchers drawn

for this purpose by the receiving agency pay-

able to the furnishing agency. . . .'

"It is the opinion of this office that

the State Building Commission has the power

and authority under Section 3 of Article 4413(32)

to enter into agreements or contracts with

other State agencies whereby the Commission

performs services for the other agency. The

services rendered by the State Building

-7Sl-

.

Hon. Graves W. Landrum, page 5 (M-160)

Commission would be 'special' or 'technical

services' within the meaning of Article 4413(32).

"In regard to the specific problem of the

installation of the IBM machine, the Building

Commission and the Department of Public Welfare

may enter into a contract whereby the Building

Commission will draw the plans and specifica-

tions for the installation and oversee the actual

installation. The Building Commission could sub-

contract the actual installation work since this

building is still under the control and manage-

ment of the Commission. The contract would be

subject to the limitations on interagency con-

tracts and agreements contained in Article 4413(32),

and payment would have to be made in accord with

Section 6 of Article 4413(32) as quoted above."

Applying the foregoing principles to the interagency

contracts in question, we note that the equipment in ques-

tion is for the joint use of data processing, services and

programs to increase efficiency, and thus is in conformity

with the provisions of Article 4413(32). You are, therefore,

advised that the interagency contracts referred to in your

request are valid and constitute valid obligations upon which

the Comptroller of Public Accounts may issue warrants in pay-

ment of the services rendered pursuant to the contract.

SUMMARY

Under Article 4413(32), Vernon's Civil

Statutes, the University of Texas may enter

into interagency contracts with the Coordi-

nating Board, College and University System

whereby it will furnish the Coordinating

Board at cost certain data processing equip-

ment and services.

C. MARTIN

rney General of Texas

Hon. Graves W. Landrum, page 6 (M-160)

Prepared by John Reeves

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION~CCMMITTEE

Hawthorne Phillips, Chairman

Kerns Taylor, Co-Chairman

W. V. Geppert

Charles E. Morris

Alan Minter

Larry Craddock

A. J. CARUBBI, JR.

Staff Legal Assistant

-753-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.