Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1969
Status
Published
On the bench
Crawford Martin
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Honorable C. W. Karisch Opinion No. M- 379

County Attorney

Wailer County Re: May Wailer County Hospital

Hempstead, Texas legally pay a charge for

an autopsy performed in

the hospital upon the body

of an expired patient?

Dear Mr. Karisch:

Ry recent letter you have requested an opinion concerning

the above stated matter. We quote, in part, from your letter

as follows:

"The Waller County Hospital was organized, and

operates, under Articles 4478-4494, R.C.S. A patient

of the Hospital who was being cared for by(a doctor)

who is a member of the staff of visiting physicians

of said Hospital, died. There was no question of

foul play and no occasion for an inquest. (The doctor)

determined that an autopsy was needed and one was per-

formed at the request of (the doctor)and the Superin-

tendent of the Hospital. The physician performing the

autopsy has billed the Hospital for his services and

such bill has been approved by the Superintendent of

the Hospital, and photocopies of such bill and approval

by the Superintendent are attached hereto. The

patient was in the Hospital under the Medicare Program,

and before authorizing or ordering an autopsy, officials

of the Hospital ascertained from some supposed official

with the Medicare Program that autopsies in cases such

as this was a proper Medicare expense. However, the

autopsy expense has not been charged to the patient's

account and has not been charged to any other account.

"I assume that the bill is reasonable, at least

no question in that regard has been raised. No reason

for the autopsy has been advanced other than to determine

-1873-

. .

Hon. C. W. Karisch, page 2 (M-379)

the cause of death. As I view the matter, it becomes a

question of whether or not the expense of this

autopsy was a reasonable and incidental expense to

operating the Hospital which the Hospital had the im-

plied authority to authorize, or whether the expense

should have been the expense of the patient's

estate." (Parenthesis ours.)

At the outset we are met with the consideration of the

effect of the hospital superintendent's request and obvious

approval for the autopsy in question upon the hospital's

responsibility to pay for the costs of the autopsy.

Article 4485, Vernon's Civil Statutes, details the authority

and duties of the hospital superintendent. We quote, in part,

from this Article.

"The Superintendent shall be the chief executive

officer of the hospital .. . subject to . .. the powers

of the board of managers.

"He shall ... equip the hospital with ... all ...

needed facilities for the care and treatment of

patients, ...

II. ..

"He shall cause a careful examination to be made

of the physical condition of all persons admitted to

the hospital and provide for the treatment of each

patient according to his need; ..." (Emphasis added.)

In addition to the above quoted language, Articles 4486

and 4487, Vernon's Civil Statutes, provide in detail the

authority of the superintendent on the procedure for admission,

and support of individuals admitted as patients. Both of

those Articles and the above quoted Article (4485) limit the

superintendent's authority to provide for "the care and

treatment" of the patients, subject to the rules and regulation

of the board of managers. None of the statutes involved

specifically authorize a superintendent to request or approve

an autopsy.

-1874-

. .

_ .

Hon. C. W. Karisch. page 3 (M-379)

So the question then is whether the "care and treatment"

of patients also encompasses autopsies of deceased patients.

In our opinion "care and treatment" does not include an

autopsy of a deceased patient. Great American Indemnity Co.

v. Dabnev, 128 S.W.Zd 496 (Tex. Civ. App. 1939, error dism.,

judgm. car.). Consequently, the superintendent has no

authority to request or approve an autopsy, and in the present

case, the request and approval would have no effect upon the

question of whether the hospital may legally pay the expense

in question.

In Attorney General's Opinion V-12Q'5 (1951). this office

ruled that charges against the county hospital are subject to

the aontrol of the Commissioners Court. We quote from that

opinion as follows:

"It will be noted from the foregoing stat-

utes that authority is vested in the board of man-

agers and the superintendent of a county hospital to

incur necessary expenditures for the operation and

maintenance of the hospital in a sum 'not exceeding

the amount provided for such purposes in the com-

missioners court'. By the express terms of Article

4484, the board of managers must transmit all bills

and accounts, including salaries and wages, to the

commissioners court for payment 'in the same manner

as other charges against the county are paid'. Arti-

cle 2351, V.C.S., provides that the commissioners

court shall 'audit and settle all accounts against

the county and direct their payment'. In view of

these provisions, the county treasurer may not issue

warrants in payment of bille and accounts of the

hospital until the commissioners court has approved

them for payment in the same manner as other charges

against the county are paid. Although the manage-

ment of the county hospital is vested in the board

of managers, the Commissioners court must approve

all accounts. See Att'y. Gen. Op. O-6433 (1945)."

- 1875 -

. -

Hon. C. W. Karisch, page 4 (M-379)

Your second question is whether the Commissioners Court

is authorized to pay this autopsy expense.

Article 4478a. Vernon's Civil Statutes, provides the

enabling legislation for the creation of a county hospital.

This Article is quoted, in part, as followsc

"The Commissioners Court of any county shall

have power to establish a county hospital . .. for the

care and treatment of persons suffering from any

illness, disease or injury . .." (Emphasis added.)

In the above quoted provision, we find the same limitation

of authority of the Commissioners Court, relative to patient

care and treatment, a6 is found relative to the authority of

the hospital superintendent, i.e., "care and treatment".

Therefore, it is our opinion that the county cannot pay for an

autopsy of a hospital patient dying of natural causes, under

the facts set out in your opinion request. Great American

Indemnity Co. v. Dabney, supra.

This opinion is limited to the facts submitted, and where

a person dies from uncertain causes, the Legislature has made

provision in Articles 49.01, et seq., Vernon's Code of Criminal

Procedure, for autopsies to be performed at county expense.

SUMMARY

.

A Commissioners Court operating a County

hospital, pursuant to the provisions of Articles

4478, et seq., V.C.S.. may not legally pay a

charge for an autopsy unless ordered by the proper

authorities pursuant to the provisions of Article

49.01, et seq., V.C.C.P.

C. MARTIN

ey General of Texas

Prepared by James C. McCoy

Assistant Attorney General of Texas

- 1876 -

Hon. c. W. Karisch, page 5 (M-379)

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Kerns Taylor, Chairman

George Kelton, Co-Chairman

Larry Craddock

Jerry Roberts

Bill Craig

Bob Crouch

W. V. GEPPERT

Staff Legal Assistant

HAWTHORNE PHILLIPS

Executive Assistant

- 1877 -

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.