Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1971
Status
Published
On the bench
Crawford Martin
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

THE ATTOECNEY GENERAL

OF-XAS

AURTIN,TEXAR 78711

April 26, 1971

Hon. Bill Clayton Opinion No. M-044

Chairman, Committee on Counties

P. 0. Box 120, Capitol Station Re: The constitutionality

Austin, Texas 78711 of House Bill No. 501,

(62nd Leg., R.S., 1971)

amending the Code of

Criminal Procedure so

as to permit the trans-

fer of persons convicted

of felonies to the De-

partment of Corrections,

under certain circum-

stances, pending appeal

Dear Mr. Clayton: of the conviction.

In your recent letter you request our opinion as to the

constitutionalityof House Bill No. 501, introduced and now

pending In the House of Representatives,62nd Legislature,Regu-

lar Session, 1971.

This Bill provides in pertinent part as follows:

"Section 1. Article 44.04, Code of Criminal Proce-

dure, 1965 is amended by adding thereto a new Section,

Section (is, to read as follows:

'(i) If the defendant is convicted of a

felony, is assessed punishment which is not

probated, and gives notice of appeal, the

trial court may in its discretionorder the

defendantplaced in the custody of the Texas

Departmentof Corrections,where the defend-

and will be confined pending the appeal of

his convictionprovided that (1) the punish-

ment assessed exceeds fifteen years confine-

ment or (2) It appears to the satisfactionof

the txal court that the defendantwill not be

released on bond pending;such appeal, or (3) the

ae

f en an a itiT

~e~~lr~f"~~ed~~e~~~~f~~r~~ ~%%&%hto

exas Department of Correctionspending

appeal, he shall be entitled to all credits on

-409l-

Hon. Bill Clayton,page 2 (M-844)

his sentence the same as if his conviction

were final.'" (Emphasissupplied.)

It is evident that the Legislaturehas not limited bene-

ficial computationof time benefits to convicted felons with

more than fifteen years confinementbut has extended such

benefits to all felons who meet the prescribed conditions.

The Constitutionof the State of Texas authorizesthe

Legislatureto enact laws. Section 1, 42 and 43, Article III,

Texas Constitution. Specifically,by virtue of Section 58,

Article XVI, the Legislaturehas the authority to provide by

law for the management of the "Prison System of Texas'.

Moreover, the Legislaturehas the power to enact any law

not in conflict with the Texas Constitutionor the Constitu-

tion of the United States. De Shazo v. Webb, 113 S.W.2d 519

(sup.ct. 1938).

The first question arises as to whether this classifica-

tion, as set out in the Bill, violates the equal rights pro-

vision of Section 3, Article I of the Texas Constitution

and/or the equal protection provision of the FourteenthAmend-

ment to the Constitutionof the United States,

There must be a reasonablerelationshipbetween the

classificationmade and the objects to be accomplishedby the

statute. City of Houston v. Houston IndependentSchool District,

436 S.W.2a 5b?3 (Ci A difi d th d 443

s.w.2d 49 (sup.ct.Vig gj; lYbt))

%p Ru&rmz. St~te~3~2 ErW%y2; (Tex.

Crim. 1961); Carringtonv.Rosh,38C U.S. 89 (1965).

Here, the announcedpurpose of House Bill 501 is to per-

mit a convicted felony defendant to transfer to the Texas

Department of Correctionsduring the pendancy of his appeals

so as to become "entitledto all credits on his sentence the

same as if his convictionwere final". Some of such credits

are contained in Article 6184 1, V.A.C.S. which provides for

commutationof time for good conduct.

It seems clear that the Legislaturein imposing the condi-

tions precedent in the proposed Article 44.04 has done so with

an eye to the existing Subsection (a) of that Article. It pro-

vides as follows:

"Any defendant who is convicted of a misdemeanor,

or who is convicted of a felony and whose punishment

is assessed at a fine or confinementnot to exceed 15

-4092-

Hon. Bill Clayton, page 3 (M-844)

years or both, shall be entitled to bail under the

rules set forth in this Chapter pending disposition

of his motion for new trial, if any, and pending dls-

position of his appeal, if any, and until his convic-

tion becomes final."

It is equally clear that this provision is not violative

of the equal protection clause of the Federal Constitution.

In United States ex rel Stephen Fink v. Heyd, 287 F.Supp. 716

(196u1) tn u 1% a St t Ul t 1 t c t for the Eastern Dis-

trict if L&i~i~a, Nzwe&leki &vi:&, had before it the

Louisiana Statute which provides that those felons convicted

and sentencedto a term of more than five years may not post

bail pending appeal. In deciding that this statute was not

constitutionallydeficient the Court said:

"It is not irrational for the State's people

and its Legislatureto conclude that anyone already

convicted of a crime involving five years confine-

ment is so poor a bail risk that he should not be

set free pending appeal."

It would therefore appear to be equally certain that the

Texas Statute which draws the line at fifteen years would

similarlybe constitutional.

The general rule can be stated, "the States are free to

provide such criminal procedures as they choose, including

rules of evidence, provided that none of them infringe a

arantee of the Federal Constitution." Knees v. Culbertson,

$"

06 F.2d 621 196 . To a similar effect is Martin v. Beto,

397 F.2d 741 t1968 .

Reading the quoted portion of the proposed statute on page

one of this opinion then, the classificationof persons eligible

to be transferredto the Texas Departmentof Correctionsand

therefore, entitled to receive all the benefits that accrue from

such a transfer Is drawn between those prisoners who are likely

to make bail and those prisoners who are not likely to make bail.

The object of the legislationis to enable the prisoner to begin

reaping the rewards of the beneficial computationof time in the

Texas Department of Correctionsat the earliest possible date.

Condition No. 3 in the proposed legislationeven permits the

prisoner himself to choose whether or not he will be transferred

to the Texas Departmentof Corrections. This is so irrespective

of the length of his sentence. It would appear therefore,that

there is a rational'relationship between the classificationof

prisoners eligible to be transferredand the object of the

-4093-

Hon. Bill Clayton, page 4 (M-844)

proposed legislation, Accordingly,In Its present form, House

Bill No. 501 is constitutional.

However, there is a constitutionaland administrativeprob-

lem presented by the Bill in its present form which should be

discussed and consideredby your commlttee. Those defendants

who are placed in the custody of the Texas Department of Correc-

tions pending their appeals would not be subject to compulsory

prisoner labor laws as are those who have been finally convicted,

that is, those referred to in the Constitutionand statutes as

"convict labor". For exsmple, Article XVI, Section 24, Consti-

tution of Texas, provides that "The Legislature shall make pro-

vision for laying out and working public roads, for the building

of bridges, and for utilizing f~n~a~~T~~~~~~,~~~u~i~t

labor to all these purposes. tt

thismandate, Articles 6736 and 67 4, Vernon's Civil Statutes,

were enacted providing for the utilizing of money end "convict

labor" and for the County Commissioners'Court to provide for

various services to and for the safe and humane keeping of

"Count convicts'I.See also related statutes,Articles 6739

and 673;6, Vernon's Civil Statutes. No provisions in this re-

spect have been made by those,constitutlonal provisions and

statutes enacted pursuant thereto for defendantswhose appeals

are pending. A ‘convict’ is one who has been finally convicted

by a court. Black's Law Dictionary 4th Edition, p. 403; Arcia

v. State, 26 Tex.App. 193, 95 S.W. 685 (1888);Brown v. State,.

b Tex.Crim. 8, 215 S.W. 323, 325 (1919).

Article 6166a, Vernon's Civil Statutes, declaring the

policy of this State, in the operation and management of the

Prisons System, provides, in part, as follows:

I,

. All prisoners shall be worked within the

. .

prison walls and upon farms owned or leased by the

State; . . .'

Article 6166x, Vernon's Civil Statutes, directs the Depart-

ment of Correctionsthat, "Prisonersshall be kept at work under

such rules and regulationsas may be adopted by the manager with

the Board's approval; . . .I'

In view of the above considerations,we believe it should

be observed that the ThirteenthAmendment of the Constitution

of the United States, which forbids involuntaryservitude ex-

cept as a punishment for crime upon final convictions,would

preclude enforcementof the above statutes by the state against

those defendantswhose appeals are pentiingand who are required

involuntarilyto labor. See Bailey v. Alabama, 219 U.S. 219

-4094-

Hon. Bill Clayton, page 5 (M-844)

U.S. 133 (1914);

Pollock v. Williams,

This opinion is not to be interpretedas Indicating either

approval or disapprovalof the merits of this legislation,nor

as indicatinghow the proposed constitutionalproblems might be

resolved. We have confined our comments to the constitutional

questions raised by 'theprovisions of the legislationand by the

Bill's necessary application,operation, and administration. We

only note in passing that with reference to constitutionaldue

process by law, the Director of Correctionspresently has only

power and authority over convicts and is not given any such

power and authority by the Bill incident to the transfer, care,

safekeeping,or other disciplinarypowers over those defendants

placed in his custody to await final dispositionof their appeals.

SUMMARY

House Bill No. 501, as written, is constitutional

insofar as it would permit the transfer of defendants

pending appeals to the custody of the Department of

Corrections, upon their request.

The classificationof prisoners eligible to be

transferredto the Texas Department of Corrections

bears a rational relationship to the object of the

proposed legislationand therefore is not violative

of the equal protection clause of Section 3, Article

I, Constitutionof Texas, and the FourteenthAmend-

ment of the Constitutionof the United States.

However, constitutionalproblems in the appli-

cation, operation, and administrationof the law

will arise if the prisoners were required to work

against their will or are otherwise subjected to

the disciplineof honvicts by the Director of

Corrections.

Yours very truly,

CHAwFOFuJC.NAHTIN

Attorney General

By

First Assistant

-4095-

Hon. Bill Clayton, page 6 (M-844)

Prepared by Max P. Flusche, Jr.

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Kerns Taylor, Chairman

W. E. Allen, Co-Chairman

Bob Lattimore

Sam Jones

Max Hamilton

Sally Phillips

MEADE F. GRIFl?CN

Staff Legal Assistant

ALFRED WALKER

Executive Assistant

-4096-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.