Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1971
Status
Published
On the bench
Crawford Martin
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

E ATI-QIKNEY GENERAL

UDFTEXAS

Hon. Harry B. Keltbn, Director Opinion No. M-890

Texas National Guard Armory Board

West Austin Station Ret Questions Concerning an

Austin, Texas~ 78703 award for the construc-

tion of an armory.

Dear Mr. Kelton:

Your request for an opinion reads as follows:

"Bids for the construction of a National

Guard armory in El Paso were opened on 14 June

1971. Contractors were required to include in

their bids an alternate to build at a location

other than or in addition to the present site.

"As a consequence of this procedure, the

results of the two low bids are as follows:

"Ponsford Construction Company

Base bid and all alternates,

except the new site $299,810

Alternate to construct at

the new site 1,700

$301,510

"Croom Construction Company

Base bid and all alternates,

except the new site $298,780

Alternate to construct at the

new site 4,750

$303,530

-4338-

Hon. Harry B. Kelton, page 2 (M-890)

"Since armories are constructed under the pro-

visions of PL 783 on a'75% Federal, 25% State fund-

ing basis, invitations to bids were advertised at

this time to preclude the loss of Federal partici-

pating funds for this project or other possible

disadvantages if the Federal money is not obligated

by the end of the Federal FY 1971, or on 30 June 1971.

"The matter of a base and an alternate site

as a part of the bidding consideration has been

occasioned by a possible exchange of properties

between the State of Texas and the Federal Govern-

ment, the authority for which is now pending in

the U. S. Congress. In the event the legislation

is effected, the new or alternate site, which is

much more suitable, would be the one designated

for construction of the armory. Should the legis-

lation fail to pass, construction on the present

site would result.

"Your opinion is requested as follows:

"Under the competitive bid law, does the

Armory Board have authority to award the contract

to the Croom Construction Company, which is lowest

with regard to the present site and to issue a

change order when and if Congress enacts legis-

lation to effect an exchange of sites?

"In the event your opinion pertaining to the

above question is negative, can the Armory Board

contract with the Ponsford Construction Company

for construction of the armory at the alternate

location when that site is not owned by the State,

for the reason stated above, and delay issuance

of a work order pending favorable Congressional

action with regard to the exchange of properties?

-4339-

Hon. Harry B. Kelton, page 3 (M-890)

"Since the above two questions and the bidding

involve the unknown factors of the element of time,

as related to a fixed bid, price, and Congressional

action, can a valid contract be entered into with

either of the above construction companies?

t,....13

In Texas Highway Commission v. Texas Association of Steel

Importers, 372 S.W.Zd 525 (Tex.Sup. 1963), the Supreme Court of

Texas cited with approval a statement in Sterrett v. Bell, 240

S.W.Zd 516, 520 (Tex.Civ.App. 19511, setting forth the require-

ments and,purposes of competitive bidding as follows:

"'Competitive bidding' requires due advertise-

merit, giving opportunity to bid, and contemplates

a bidding . . . upon the same thing. It requires

that all bidders be placed upon the same plane

of equality and that they each bid upon the same

terms and conditions involved in all the items

and parts of the contract, and that the proposal

specify as to all bids the same, or substantially

similar specifications. Its purpose is to stimu-

late competition, prevent favoritism and secure

the best work and materials at the lowest practicable

price, for the best interests and benefit of the

taxpayers and the property owners. There can be

no competitive bidding in a legal sense where the

terms of the letting of the contract prevent or

restrict competition, favor a contractor or

material man, or increase the cost of the work

or of the materials or other items going into

the project."

In the instant case all bidders were placed upon the

same plane of equality and each bid upon the same terms and con-

ditions involved in all items and p,arts of the construction pro-

ject. In the invitation for bids Alternate No. 5 stated:

-4340-

Hon. Harry B. Kelton, page 4 (M-890)

"Bidder must show the amount to be added to

his total bid price for construction of the armory

and all facilities on the alternate site as shown

on sheets No. 2-A, 3-A and 4-A of the plans. Site

work, utility lines extension, access roads and

curbs only are affected. All other work remains

unchanged."

In determining the lowest responsible bidder the award-

ing agency is not performing a mere ministerial duty but is exer-

cising a duty which is deliberative and discretionary. Attorney

General's Opinion V-1536 (1952). The awarding agency may take

into consideration among other things the ability, capacity,

experience, efficiency and integrity of the bidders as well as

their financial responsibility. Attorney General's Opinion V-1565

(1952). In exercising honest judgment the awarding agency's

determination of the lowest and best bid will not be interfered

with in the absence of fraud or an abuse of discretion. Attorney

General's Opinion V-1565, supra.

In view of the foregoing, your questions are answered as

follows:

If, in the opinion of the Armory Board, it is for the best

interest and benefit of the State under the facts submitted, it

may award the contract to the Croom Construction Company, which is

lowest with regard to the present site and issue a change order

when and if Congress enacts legislation to effect an exchange of

sites.

If. in the opinion of the Armory Board, it is for the best

interest and benefit of the State under the facts submitted, it

may award the contract to Ponsford Construction Company for

construction of the armory at the alternate location when that

site is not owned by the State and delay issuance of a work order

pending favorable Congressional action with regard to the

exchange of properties.

-4341-

. .

Hon. Harry B. Kelton, page 5 (M-890)

In other words, it is our opinion that either contract may

be awarded by the Armory Board in the exercise of its sound

judgment and neither award would in our opinion constitute an

abuse of discretion under the facts submitted.

SUMMARY

Where the cost of construction of an

armory varies as to alternate sites to be

named by the Armory Board, which involve

unknown factors of the element of time as

related to fixed bid, price and Congressional

action, it is within the sound discretion of the

Armory Board to determine the lowest and best

bid as will be for ,the best interest and

benefit of the State.

Ve truly yours,

#

General of Texas

Prepared by John Reeves

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Kerns Taylor, Chairman

W. E. Allen, Co-Chairman

Pat Bailey

Mike Stork

R. D. Green

Roger Tyler

MEADE F. GRIFFIN

Staff Legal Assistant

ALFRED WALKER

Executive Assistant

NOLA WHITE'

First Assistant

-4342-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.