Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1972
Status
Published
On the bench
Crawford Martin
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

. . .

: I.

October20, 1972

Honorable Spencer Brown Opinion No. M- 1241

Kerr County Attorney

Schrelner Bank Bulldln Re: Whether exemption from

Kerrvllle, Texas 7802% ad valorem taxes may be

,accorded'property car-

ried on the tax rolls

aa owned by The Church

In the Hills, Inc., a

defun.c,t, non-profit

Dear Mr. .Brown: corporation.

You have requested an opinion of this Office,on the above

captioned question, and in so doing, have supplied us with the

following pertinent facts.

The Churc,hin the Hills, Inc. was ,chartered October 15,

1945. The purpose for which the corporation was organized was

the "support of any benevolent, charitable, educational or

religious undertaking as authorized by Subdivlslon 2 of,,Article

1302 of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas of 1925 ... , The

charter further stated that "no part of the earnings or assets

of this corporation shall ever be &se to carry on any ac-'

tlvitles other than those stated in Su%division 2 of Article

1302." On September 1, 1956, the chart,erof said corporation

was forfeited because It had failed to file the refiortrequired

by Article 9.01 of the Texas Non-Roflt Corporation Act.

The following excerpt Is from a letter by the,Honorable

John P. Hill submitted in support of the clalm‘for exemption.

"This tract containing approximately 82 acres

was given to the fkurch In The Hills by E. J. Nick7 es

about 1946 or 1948,. My father, Dr. P. B. Hill, who

was former Captaln & Chaplain of the Texas Rangers,

Missionary to Korea and Pastor of the First Presby-

terlan'church of San Antonio for 20 years. Durlng

that 20 years he broadcast his Sunday morning Service

-6076-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 2 (M-1241)

over W.0:A.I. in San Antonio. When he retired and

moved to Hunt,Texas, he continued his broadcasts

over W.O.A.I. under the nsme of The Church In The

Hills. At his death, the broadcasts continued from

his recordings for two more years.

"I was made Treasurer and later, President of

the organization and secured donations to It.

'"In some cases, where someone would make a

substantial donation, I would allow them to hunt

deer and turkey on the 82 acre tract.

"I leased the 16 ac. adjoining the 82 acres In

question from the Hill Country Cowboy Camp Meeting

Assoclatlon,~which my father also organized some 33

years ago and which 16 acres Dad helped pick out,

and purchas'ed. The Camp Meeting 1,sstill golng on

starting the first Sunday In August through the

second Sunday In August and during those eight days

the ranchmen's and visitors kids run all over the

82 acres having fun and recreation.

"There are no salaries or expenses of any kind

taken from the revenue or donations to the Church In

The Hills. The proceeds go to worthy students who are

unable to pay the high college tuition of first class

schools,,Missionaries in various countries, struggling

churches"and the like.

"InMarch or April, 1965, ... the charter was

allowed to lapse or expire and The Church In The

Hills continued to operate as an Association of the

surviving members of the P. B. Hill family and

several well qualified advisers (at no salary or

expenses to anyone). A11 proceeds going to the

Scholarships, Missionaries, Seminaries.

"It 1s my belief that the property In question

should come under Art. 7150, Section 1, Schools &

Churches as well as Section 2, Christian Associations,

and 2a, Religious, Educational and physical develop-

ment associations."

-607-t-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 3’ (M-1241)

We quote the following excerpt from a letter written to

you by the Tax Assessor-Collector of Kerr County, Texas:

“The pertinent facts that were presented to

this office concerning the ... &opertg.are as

follows :,

(1) Commisloners Court Order #11413 directed

that a request for tax exemption be filed

on each property requesting ad valorem

tax,exemptions.,

(2) Request filed on property in question by

John P. Hill, President of The Church of

The’Hills Inc.

(3) Exemption denied by Kerr County Tax Office.

Ex!n~~~;;t~n;ed .because:

apsed tid original not pre-

aented to substantiate ownership or

puFpo8a of creation.

b Land being ‘leased for deer hu.nting.

IC 1 Revenue received distributed to

church grbups according to owner*

but no evidence presented.

(d) Owner’s reply to Application Ques-

tion #12 was 81nvestmentt.

(4) Applicant ap$ealed to Ctiissionera Court

under authority granted by Attorney General’s

Oljln+on&6g M-328.

Exemption denied by Commissioners Court .~

‘,11

56 Owner claims that Buthority to grant tax

exemption lies in the power granted in

the Texas Constitution, Article VIII,

Section 2, Article 7150 (1, 2, & 2A VACS).”

The Tax Assessor-Collector has also advised us that the

tax records show’The’Church In The Hlllsl Inc. as owner of the

property in question. The reference to ‘owner” in the above

quoted excerpt therefore refers to “John P. Hill, president of

The Church In The Hills, Znc.“, a position which he obviously

cannot hold In what is now a defunct corporation.

We agree with the concluaion’of the Tax Assessor-Collector

and the Commissioners’ Court that exemption should be denied

In this case,

-6078-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 4 (M-1241)

Article VIII, Section 2 of the Texas Constitution1 provides

the’constitutional authorlzatlon for legislative exemption from

taxation. The pertinent portion of that Article reads as follows:

“Sec. 2. ...the legislature may, by general

laws, exempt from taxation .,. actual places or fifJ

religious worship ... .’

Pursua t to the above Constitutional authorization, the 60th

Legislature!I amended Section 1 of Article 7150 by adding the fol-

lowing thereto:

t * l + l * l *

“l(a) .The term ‘actual places of religious

worship’, shall include property owned by a church

or by a strictly religious Institution or organ-

ization; Including the personal property therein

and the grounds attached to such buildings neces-

sary for the proper use and enjoyment of same,

used exclusively to support and serve the spread

1 Other Gonstltutional authorizations contained In this

Article, such as that provided for the exemption of “property

used exclusively and reasonably necessary In conducting any

association engaged In promoting the religious, educational and

physical development of boys, girls, young men or younn;women

operating under a State or National organization of like charac-

ter; also the endowment funds of such Institutions of learning

and religion not used with a vlew,to profit; and when the asme

are Invested In bonds or mortgages, or in land or other property

which has been,and shall hereafter be bought In by such lnstitu-

tlons under forecloeure sales made to satisfy or protect such

bonds or mortgages, that such exemption of such land and property

shall continue only for two years after the purchase of the same

at such sale by such institutions and no longer, ...' are clearly

Inapplicable to the facts of the case under consideration, as are

Sections 2 and 2a of Article 7150; enacted in pursuance thereto

and equally relied upon by the taxpayer In the lnatant case.

2 Acts .Lg67, ch. 336, p. 802, 81.

-6079-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 5 (M-1241)

of a religious faith, and to effect accompanying

filq religious, charitable, benevolent and edu-

cat onal purposes by the dissemination of lnfor-

matlon on,a religious faith through radio, tele-

vision and similar media of communication. Such

church,~rellglous'lnstltutlon,or organization

shall be, or shall be sponsored by, a faith group,

denotilnationor association of churches, which

ordains ministers or.ele.ctsChristian Science

Readers and establl,sheshouses of worship com-

pletely dedicated to the propagation of the reli-

glous faith of such faith groups, denominations

or association of-churches."

This seotlon~la valid Insofar as It Is within the Constltu lonal

authorizations and llmltatlons of Article VIII, Sectdon 2.3

It ia evident that the property described In your request

la not within the plain terms of the statute In that the prop-

erty Is not owned by a church or a strictly rellglous lnstltutlon

or organization. Furthermore, the exemption Eccorded real prop-

e.rty belonging to such Institutions Includes ... personal prop-

erty therein and the grounds attached to such buildlnR8 necessary

for t-proper use and enjoyment of same ...". (hphasls ours.)

Stated differently, the authorized exemption for I'actualplaces'

of religious worship" extends only to the real property owned by

a zhurch or reli+ous institution, and, further, requires that

a building" or house of worship' of some kind be erected there-

on.

We thln~kthat this conclusion is'necessitated by a long line

of decisions either approved or written by our Supreme Court. It

was held in Trinity Methodist Episcopal Church v. City of San

Antonio, 201 S W b6 (T C A 1916 f ) t

~parsonad;e'was9note$e~~; %er ei;h:~~~~~fo~s~~~~~lo~a~

authorlzatlon or the then statutory exemption . . . houses

3 City of Wichita Falls v. Cooper, 170 S.W.2d 777 (Tex.Clv.

App. 1943 error ref )* Dlcklaon v. Woodmen of the World Life

Insurance'Soc., 280 i.i.sd 315 (Tex.Clv.App. 1955, error ref.);

4 Tex.Jur.2d 200, 201, ~64, and authorltlea cited therein.

Article 7507, 4 Vernon's Saylea' Texas Civil Statutes

(1914;.

-6080-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 6 (M-1241)

used exclusively for public worship, the books and furniture

therein and the grounds attached to such buildings necessary

for the proper occupancy, use and enjoyment of the same, and

not leased or otherwise used with a view to profit.” We quote

the following excerpt from pages 669, 670:

“The Constitution provides that all ‘t.axatlon

shall be equal and uniform,’ and that ‘all property

In this states,whether owned by natural persons or

corporations, other than municipal, shall be taxed

In proportion to its value, which shall be ascer-

tained as may be provided by law. I Const . art. 8,

Bl. To this provision general exceptions are made,

under which the Legislature may exempt certain prop-

erty specifically described. Section 2. In consld-

erlng eXemptlone It is the rule that the law must be

strictly construed and not enlarged, but confined to

the very terms of the provision as to the exemption.

Cooley, Taxation, p, 357. Following this rule the

burden devolves upon any one seeking an exemption

to bring himself clearly within the terms of the

statute ‘or constitutional provision, and further,

should any reasonable doubt as to the property being

exempt arise, the doubt must be resolved In favor

of the government levying the tax. Morris v. Masons,

68 Tex. 698, 5 S.W. 519.

* + l + +

II

... The Constitution undoubtedly Intended in

granting permission to the Legislature to exempt

houses used exclusively for rellglous worship from

taxation to grant permission to exempt the land on

which the house Is built and other ground on which

to enter and leave the church and ground Immediately

surrounding the house which would be ‘grounds attached

to such buildings necessary for the proper occupancy,

use and,enjoyment of the same.” What would be nec-

essary grounds would be a question of fact, but this

would not render the statute unconstitutional. The

Constitution will not be so construed as to defeat

its own purposes, which would be the case If only

the ground actually covered by the house used for

-6081-

Honorable Spencer,Brown, page 7’ (M-1241)

religious worship was exempt. The construction

must be reasonable and not such as to defeat the

very end deslred."5

Although Section 2 of Article VIII was subsequently amended

in 1928 so ai to authorize legislative exemption of "any property

owned by a church or by a strictly religious society for,the ex-

clusive use as a dwelling place for the ministry of such church

or religious society, and which yields no revenue whatever to

such church or religious society ...",6 the above quoted lnter-

pretatlon of the authorization for exemption of "actual places

of rellglous~worship" remains unchanged.7

SUMMARY

Property carried on the ad valorem tax rolls as

owned by The Church In the Hills, Inc., a defunct,

non-profit corporation, and having no actual place

of religious worship thereon, Is not exempt from

taxa~tiohunder Article 7150(l)(a), V.A.T.S.

5 Later cases enunciating the general principles stated In

the first quoted paragraph may be found In 54 Tex.Jur.2d 200-206,

Tsxatlon, 8864-65.

6 Implemented by the enactment of Article 7150b, V.A.T.S.

The 1928 amendment has been construed ;y the Supreme Court as em-

powering the Legislature to determine ... who, and what activities

shall constitute the ministry of a church", rather than limiting

the exemntlon to a dwelling olace for Its mlnlstrv owned and used

by an lnblvldual church. McCreless v. City of Sak'Antonio, 454

S.W.2d 393 (Tex.Sup. 1970).

7 54 Tex.Jur.2d 214-216, Taxation, 869.

-6082-

Honorable Spencer Brown, page 8 (M-1241)

Prepared by Marietta McGregor Payne

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COmMITTEE

Kerns Taylor, .Chalrman

W. E. Allen, Co-Chairman

James H. Broadhurst

Bill Campbell

Gerald Ivey

Bob Davis

SAMTJEL D. MCDANIEL

Staff Legal Assistant

ALFRED WALKER

Executive Assistant

NOLA WHITE

First Assistant

-6083-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.