Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1974
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

, ~-a

3

TRE A’ITOIZNEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

AUSTIN. TIcsAs rsrll *

January 9, 1974

The Honorable Bevington Reed Opinion No: H-203

Commissioner

Coordinating Board Re: Wheth& church-related

Texas College 81 University System educational institutions

P. 0. Box 12788, Capitol Station participating in the Tuition

Austin, Texas 78711 Equalization Grrnt Program

are prohibited from limiting

employment to those of a

particular religion

Dear .br. Reed:

You have mquested our opinion on the question:

“[W]hether. . . church-related educational

inetititions participating in the Tuition Equali-

tation Grants Programs are prohibited from :

using employment practices which require

adherence to a particular religion. ”

It ir asked against a factual background identifying an institution of

higher education, whose bylaws state, in their preamble:

“[The College] shall stand as a witness for Jesus

Christ expressed directly through its administration,

faculty und students. To assure the perpetuation

of these basic concepts of its founders it is resolved

that all those who become associated with [the college]

as a trustee, officer, member of the faculty or of

the staff must believe in the divine inspiration of the

Bible, both the Old Testament and New Testament,

that man was directly created by God, the virgin

birth of Jesus Christ, our Lord and Saviour as the

p 955

.

. .

.

The Honorable Bevington Reed, page 2 (H-203)

Son of God, that He died for the sins of all men

and thereafter arose from the grave, that by repentance

and the acceptance of and belief in Him, by the grace

of God, the individual is saved from eternal damnation

lud receives eternal life in tbe presence of God; and it

is further resolved that the ultimate teachings in this

college ehall liwaya be consistent with the above prin-

ciples. ‘I

The College, has refused to hire a person of the Jewish faith for

a staff position solely because of the applicant’s religion. She ‘was inftirmed

this was its established policy.

Subchapter F of chapter 61, Texas Education Code (formerly Article

265411, V. T. C.S. ), authorizes the Coordinating Board, Texas College and

University System, to provide tuition equalization grants from appropriated

funds to Texas residents enrolled in approved Texas colleges or universities

under certain circumstances. (See Acts 1973. 63rd Leg., ‘p. 78, ch. ,51);. ’

Section 61.229 of me Code now provides in its subsection (b):

“The coordinating board shall mahe such

regulations as may be necessary to comply with

the provisions of Article I, Section 7 . . . and

other parts of the Texas Constitution.”

Article 1. g7, of ~theConstitution provides:

“No money &all be appropriated, or drawn

from the Treasury for the benefit of any sect, or

religious society, theological or religious seminary;

nor shall property belonging to the State be appropriated

for any such-purposes. ‘I

In Attorney General Letter Advisory No. 47 (1973). addressed to the

Chairman of the Senate Committee on Finance, we reviewed the constitutionality

ui kricie 265,4h as it related to separation of chiwch and state and of the

proposed Appropriatioar Act provision implementing it. We said:

Q. 956

The Honorable Bevlngton Reed, page 3 (H-203)

“We are of the opinion &at Article 265421.and the

appropriation of funds for that program, reflect a proper

secular legislrtive purpose and are constitutional, so

long as the Coordinating Board under its regulations,

ldmia isb r the

s program so as to avoid the advancement

or inhfbftion of religim and so as to avoid thejse of pub-

lic funds or property for the benefit of sects, religious

societies, or tfieological or religious seminaries, in turn

avoiding ‘excessive entanglements, ’ ”

In arriving at that conclusion we remarked:

“We have not been asked to pass upon, axI do not

pass upon, the constitutionality of any particular grants

to specific individuals attending particular schools. Indeed,

&at fact finding process ir beyond both the scope of your

request and the competence of thio office. The courts have

reviewed, in passing upon these questions, the precise

nature of the schools and programs involved, the precise

percentage of public funds going to denominational schools,

and a host of other factual matters which canonly properly

be determined by an administrative body or a court. ”

Your present request presents certain facts to be true, Fd our ansyer

here is so Iimited. This office cannot resolve factual disputes, and our

opinion regarding the law applicable to a given set of facts should not be

considered a finding that ouch facts exist

Subsequent to the issuance of Letter Advisory No. 47, pursuant to a

request by the Secretary of the Coordinating Board. we issued Attorney

Gensral Opinion H-66 (1973) which again reviewed the constitutionality of

Tuition Equaliution Grants in the light of recent opiniow by the Supreme

Court of the United States. We reaffirmed the conclusion reached by LA

No. 47 and said:

ffArtlcle 1, )7 of the Texas Conrtltutlon is more

restrictive than the federal charter . . . and will not

p. 957

The Honorable Bevlngton Reed, page 4 (H-203)

tolerate, in our opinion, any aid to sects or sectarian

schools. Denominational schools are not necessarily

sectarian in that sense, and some schools ‘with sectarian

progrems may be able to effectively separate their

secular programs from the sectarian remainder so that

the use of funds for the one does not have the effect of

subsidizing or furthering the other. The dividing lines

are delicate but must be sharply drawn so that public

funds are not put to sectarian uses. ”

In considering the meaning to be given the term “sectarian scho01s~’

in the constitutional sense, we quoted from language in Church v. Bullock,

100 S. W. 1025 (Tex. Civ. App., 1907, lff’d 109 S. W. ll5):

“‘Inviewofthe.. . constitutional provisions,

we conclude that the words used. . . must have been

intended by the people who ratified them to provide

against the promulgation or teaching of the distinctive

doctrines. creeds or tenets of any particular Christian

or Mher religious sect in schools or institutions where

such instruction was to be paid for out of the public fund,

or aided by such fuuds or by public grants. , . . I I’

Speaking of the responsibility of the Coordinating Board to promulgate

rules and regulations for the implementation of the Tuition Equalization “’

Grant program, we said in H-66:

“Rules should be so framed that institutions

’ having the characteristics attributed to [schools with

which recent U. S. Supreme Court decisions were

concerned) will not be the beneficiary of Tuition

Equaliaation Grants. Individual recipients should

not include those, for instance, attending seminaries

or divinity schools, nor shouldtuition paid from pub-

lic funds for a student be in anywise comingled with

funds used to defray the cost, expense or bpkeep of

sectarian programs or facilities. Mere church

sponsorship of an institution would not seem by itself

Q. 958

The Honorable Bevington Reed, page 5 (H-203)

to be ground for disqualification, but every possi-

bility of a grant having more than an indirect or

incidentof effect upon the advancement of religion

mad be eliminated. ”

In Committee for Public Education and Religious Liberty v. Nvquist,

U.S. (1973). and in Levitt v. Committee for Public Education and

Gigiouaiberty, -Il. S. -(1973), ~&heSupreme Court of the United States

struck down a program of aid to private schools described in H-66 as one

where:

“[G]ualifying institutions . . . ‘could be’ ones which

[I] imposed religious restrictions on admission, [2]

5required attendance at religious services, [3] required

obedience to the doctrinem and dogmas of a particular

faith. [4] required students to attend instruction in the

theology or doctrine of a particular faith, [5] were an

integral part of the religious mission of the church

sponsoring it, [6] had as a purpose the inculcation of

religiour ,wlues, [7] imposed religious restrictions ‘, ]

of fkculhr apDoihtments. and [8] imposed restrictions

on what or how the faculty may teach. ” (emphasis added)

‘V

It is not neceeeary, in our opinion, ,,that & these elements be present

in order to render an institution “sectarian” under either the federal or the

state Constitution. It is enough under the Texas constitutional prohibition

against use of public funds that an institution requires obedience to the dogmas

of a particular faith on the part of its staff nysmbers and refuses to have a

pamon as a staff member became of that pason’s religiour belief.

In our opinion, discrimination among staff members on the basis of

religious affiliation or religious views, in policy or in practice. is very

strong evidence that the institution is sectarian and that funds channeled

through it would be used to promote or inhibit religion.

In answer to your inquiry therefore; it ii our opinion that the Coordi-

nating Board would abuse the discretion vested in it by $61.229(b), Texas

Education Code, if it approved participation in the Tuition Equalization Grant

Q. 959

-. .

.

The Honorable Bevington Reed, page 6 (H-203)

program by an institution which, in the factual context presented to us,

follows a policy or practice of refusing to hire non-Christians for staff

positions solely because of their religion. See Attorney General Letter

Advisory No. 47 (1973), ~Attomey General opinion H-66 (1973).

/

SUMMARY

Where an institution of higher education requires

as an establirhed fixed policy that all of its trustees,

officers, faculty and staff members acknowledge belief

in and adhere to particular and detailed rd,ligious doc-

trines and refuses to hire a person as a staff member

because of the person’s religious beliefs, it would be

an abuse of discretion for the Coordinating Board, Texas

College and University System, to find the institution

qualified to participate in the Tuition Equalization Grant

program a8, a non-sectarian institution.

Very truly yours,

v Attorney General of Texas

DAVID M. KENDALL. Chairman

Opinion Committee

p. 960

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.