Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1974
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

April 1, 1974

The Honorable J. W. Edgar Opinion No. H- 266

Commissioner of Education

Texas Education Agency Re: Whether ISD once having pro-

201 E.” Eleventh Street vided for a runoff election,

Austin, Texas 78701 must do so in each election

thereafter

Dear Dr. Edgar:

In 1955 the Texas Legislature adopted Article 2775s-1, Vernon’s

Texas Civil Statutea, authorizing the trustees of independent school

districts to order that all candidatea for school trurtee be voted on by

position and be designated on the ballot according to the number of the

position which they sought. It further provided:

“Once the Board of Truateen of an independent school

district shall have adopted the foregoing procedure

for electiopr, said Board of Trusteesbi their auccee-

#ors may not rescind the action which adopted the

foregoing procedure. ”

Pursuant to this legislation, the Board of Trustees of the Abilene

Independent School District resolved that its trustees would be 80 elected.

Election wao on the basis of the winning candidate having a plurality of

the votes. There were no runoff elections.

In 1969, with the adoption of the Education Code, V. T. C. S., Article

2775a-1 became $23. I1 of the Code. The language of Article 27758-l

which we have quoted became Subsection (0 of 5 23.11:

‘l(f) Once the board of trustees of an independent school

district has adopted the provisions of this section,

neither the board of truatees nor their Buccee#or# may

rescind the action. ”

p. 1248

The Honorable ‘i. W. Edgar, page 2 (H-266)

In 1971 by Acts 1971, 62nd Leg., ch. 760, p. 2410, effective

August 30, 1971, $23.11 ~8s amended by adding to it Subsection (h):

“(h) The board msy also provide by resolution,

at least 60 days prior to the election, th8t if no c8n-

did8te for 8 position receives 8 majority of the votes

cast for that position the bo8rd will order 8 runoff

election ,to be held not more th8n 30 d8ya 8fter the

date of the first election. At that runoff~election, the

n8mea of the two persons receiving the higheot num-

ber, of votes for that position in the first election~sh811

be pl8ced on the bbllot. ”

Pursubnt to this authority, the Borrd of Trustees of the Abilene

District, in 1972 sdopted the following resolution:

“BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that if in the election

herein cslled,for April. 1, 1972, no: cbndidate for :8

position on the. ballot ah811 receive 8 mrjor,ity of the

votes cart’for’.auch position, the Bosrd of Educ8tio,n

will order 8 runoff election to be held not more thrn

thirty days after the dste of the first election, and th8t

the names of the two perrons receiving the highest

number of votes for that position in the first election

shall be plrced on the brllot for the runoff election.”

There has been no rimilbr resolution adopted with reference to

the election to be held April 6, 1974. ,Youhsve asked:

“Under the submitted facts. leg8lly must 8 runoff

election be called in the April 1974 trustee election *

of the Abilene school district, should 8 candidrte not

receive 8 majority vote in 8 numbered position up

for election.

“St8ted 8nother way. where the district h8s once

provided for 8 runoff election - even though limited

p. 1249

The Honorbble J. W. Edgar, p8ge 3 (H-266)

by ite resolution to 8 p8rticul.r year - must it

there8fter hold runoff elections in plur8lity vote

oituationr. ”

Our function ib to attempt to determine the intent of the Legirlrture.

53 Tex. Jur. Zd, StatUtee, $125; p. 180 et seq.

Subsection (f) refere to “the provisions of thin section.” “This

aection” is § 23. Il. The 1971 Act rdopting Subsection (h) epecificrlly m8de

it 8 part of 3 23.11. Therefore,‘re of the 1972 adoption of the resolution

providing for 8 runoff by the Abilene Dietrict. Subsection (h) w8e one of

the “proviaione of this section” which, once bdopted, there8fter could not

be rescinded by action of the trueteer.

It is our opinion, therefore, thrt, once h8ving adopted the provirionr

of Subrection (h), even though itr reeolution referred epecificrlly to the

1972 election, the Borrd of Trurteee of the Abilene Independent School

District w8e withdut 8uthority to ch8ngc the rule 8nd that, in the 8brence

of 8 court decision or rhtutory chmge, the elections of trueteen for’th8t

dirtrict murt be determined in runoff eleciione if there is no m8jority on

the firae b8llot.

SUMWRY

Once 8 echool district,, rubjstt to the provisionr

of Article 27758-1, V. T. C.S., or 0 23.11, Educrtion

Code, V. T. C. S. , h8e 8dopted 8 runoff 8e 8 merne of

determining the election of itr trusteea. all ouch elec-

tions there8fter will be dttermined in that manner. ’

DAVID KENDALL, Ch8irm8n

Opinion Committee

p. 1250

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.