Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1974
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

TEBEA~TORNEYGENEICAL

OF TEXAS

AUSTIN. -rsxAa 78711

December 20. 1974

The Honorable Betty J. Anderson Opinion No. H- 484

Executive Secretary

Texas State Board of Examiners in Re: Applicability of Open

the, Basic Sciences Meetings Act to certain

1012 Sam Houston Bldg., 201 East meetings held by the Texas

14th St. Board of Examiners in the

Austin, Texas 78701 Basic Sciences.

Dear Mrs. Anderson:

Your opinion request requires us to consider the applicability

of the Open Meetings Act, article 6252-17, V. T. C. S., to certain

portions of the meetings held by the Texas State Board of Examiners

in the Basic Sciences. Your questions can be stated as follows:

(1) Must the Board hold open to the public

the portion of a meeting during which it considers

applications for certification and discusses the

academic records of individual applicants and

other pertinent information about them?

(2) Must the Board hold open to the public

the portion of a meeting during which examination

questions are proposed, examined, discussed, and

approved for usage by the Board in an examination

session?

(3) Must the Board hold open to the public

the portion of a meeting during which examinations

are graded and the results recorded?

p. 2196

The Honorable Betty J. Anderson page 2 (H-484)

(4) May the Board hold a closed meeting when

it believes the information to be discussed concerns

a situation which may result in litigation to which

the Board may be a party?

The Open Meetings Act was enacted in order to assure the public

an opportunity to be informed concerning the transaction of public business.

Its provisions are mandatory and are to be construed liberally in order

to effect its purposes. Toyah Ind. Sch. Dist. v. Pecos-Barstow Ind. Sch.

gi.&. , 466 S. W. 2d 377 (Tex. Civ. App. --San Antonio 1971, no writ).

By definition, it would embrace the Texas State Board of Examiners in

the Basic Sciences and would require its meetings to be open to the

public. “Meeting” is defined in section l(a) of the Act-as follows:

‘Meeting’ means any deliberation between

a quorum of members of a governmental body

at which any public business or public policy

over which the governmental body has super-

vision or control is discussed or considered,

or at which any formal action is taken. (Emphasis

added).

We do not think it was the intent of the Legislature to include

discussions of information deemed confidential by constitutional, or

other law, within the prohibition against privately discussing or

considering “public business or public policy. ” imputing the converse

as the legislative intent would bring the constitutionality of the statute

into question. In order to give effect to those consitutional and statutory

provisions making certain information confidential, we think the Open

Meetings Act must be construed in harmony with them.

We now turn to your first question in which you ask whether the

Board must hold open to the public the portion of its meetings during

which it considers applications for certification and discusses the

academic records of the individual applicants and other pertinent

information submitted in connection with their application. Section 2

p. 2197

The Honorable Betty .J. Anderson page 3 (H-484)

of the Open Meetings Act illustrates certain topics which governmental

bodies are permitted to discuss in closed session, but deliberations about an

applicant’s qtialifi~cations for certification or for a license ‘are not included in

the list. We are aware of no statute or other source of law that generally

makes confidential academic records or other information submitted to

the Board in connection with an application for certification. If the Board

determines, however, that, as a matter of fact, the information with

which it is dealing is such as to give rise to a protectable private interest,

the Open Meetings Act would not require the Board to hold open to the

public the portion of a meeting during which it considers the information.

In your second question you ask whether the Board must hold open

to the public the portion of a meeting during which examination questions

are prepared, discussed, and approved for usage by the Board in an

examination session. The Board is required to examine applicants in

order to determine their knowledge, ability, and skill in the basic sciences

and to conduct the examinations in an entirely fair and impartial manner.

V. T. C.S. art. 459Oc, sec. 6. Since an examination would be rendered

unfair and ineffective if the questions to be asked were made known in

advance, we determined in Attorney General Opinion H-483 (1974) that the

statutory directive to conduct examinations necessariIy carries with it the

authority to maintain the confidentiality of the questions to be asked. See

-

also

- Attorney General Opinion H-242 (1974).

Obviously, the Board’s authority to maintain such confidentiality

would be seriously undermined if the portion of its deliberations at which

future examination questions were discussed and approved were open to

the public. We cannot ascribe to the Legislature such an intent. It is our

opinion, therefore, that discussions by the Board of matters made con-

fidential by implication from the Board’s powers may be discussed at a

meeting not open to the public. But the fact that legally protected con-

fidential information need.mt be discussed in public does not mean that the

entire subject can be dealt with privately. Only the discussion of the con-

fidential information is outside the Open Meetings Act; the topic itself, and

the remainder of the Board’s discussion or consideration of it, are within

the Act and “public business. ”

p. 2198

The Honorable Betty J. Anderson, page 4 -(H-484)

In your third question you ask whether the Board must hold open to the

public the portion of a meeting during which examinations are graded and

the re.sults recorded. Unless some other law makes them confidential,

deliberations of this kind are not expressly excepted from the Act’s coverage

by any of the provisions of section 2. We are unaware of any statute or

other source of law that makes examination results confidential. It is our

opinion that, under the Open Meetings Act,. the Board is required to hold

open to the public that portion of a meeting during which it grades examina-

tions and records the results unlessthe process would compromise the

effectiveness .of future examinations by revealing examination questions, some

or all of which .will be used again. -See Attorney General Opinion H-483 (1974).

>

Finally, you~ask whether the Board may hold a closed meeting when it

believes the information to be discussed conce.rns a:.situation which may

result in litigation to which the Board.may be a.party. ..Section 2(e) of the

Open Meetings Act reads.:as follows: L.

ii, Private consultations between a,.gove,r,n- ‘.

mental body and its attorney are not permitted

except (in those instances in which the body seeks

the attorney’s advice with respect to:pending or

conternp$ated litigation,. settlement offers,, and

matters. where the duty of a public body’s counsel

to his client,: pursuant to the Code of Prof.kssional

a ,+esponsibility of the State Bar of Texas,iiclearly

conflicts with this Act.

Thus, by affirmative provision, the Act authorizes ,thaBoard to close to

the public any portion of its meetings during which.it consults with its

attorney about certain matters, including contemplated litigation. Butt

if its attorney is snot present, the Board is..not expressly permitted to

conduct a closed session even though~pending or prospective litigation

might be the subJect of discussion. Unless such a discussion additionally

involves matters made confidential by law, the Act permits the discussion

of litigation or its prospects at closed meetings only when the Board is

consulting its atto,rney,.

up. .2199

The Honorable Betty J. Anderson, page 5 (J-J-4&4)

SUMMARY

The Texas Open Meetings Law does not require

the revelation of information made confidential by

law. If the Board of Examiners in the Basic Sciences

determines, as a matter of fact, that information in

an applicant’s file is private and protected from dis-

closure by constitutional, statutory, or court made

law, the Board may close that portion of the meeting

during which it discussess and consjdere the inform-

ation. The Board of Examiners in the Basic Sciences

also may close portions of meetings at which it dis-

cusses examination questions if to reveal such ques-

‘.

tions would compromise future examinakons. However,

unless legally confidential material w,ould be thereby

revealed, discussions undertaken about prospective

litigation when its attorney is not present cannot be

closed to the public by the Board.

Very truly yours,

APPROVED:

DAVID M. KENDALL, ,First Assistant

C. ROBERT HEATH, Chairman

Opinion Committee

p. 2200

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.