Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1975
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

OF ‘TEXAS

AUSITIN, TKKAs 78711

!

May 20, 1975

The Honorable Chet Brooks Opinion No. H-611

chairman

Joint Committee on Prison Reform Re: Use of certain line item

Senate Chamber appropriations by the Texas

Aurtin. Texas 78711 Department of Corrections.

Dear Senator Brooks:

You have requested our opinion regarding the use of certain line

item appropriations by the Texas Department of Corrections.

Your firat question aeks what constraints a specific line item

appropriation for a specific construction project plsces on the Department

of Corrections, and whether expenditures on other construction projects

are permissible. A line item appropriation must be expended only for

the purpose designated therein, subject to any riders applicable to the

appropriationfor the particular agency and subject further to any relevant

general provisions in the Appropriations Act. Attorney General Letter

Advisory No. 2 (1973); Attorney General Opinions H-444(1974); M-999

(1971); O-4769 (1942). As to appropriations for specific construction

projects of the Department, the Act contains the following provisions

in Article III;Acts 1973, 63rd Leg., ch. 659, p. 1948.

The amounts indicated as ‘Building Appropriations’

hereinabove areappropriated subject to construction

and completion of said projects by the use of prison

labor insofar as possible.

. . * .

Any unexpended balances remaining in projects under

the respective items for Building Appropriations may,

p. 2705

The Honorable’ Chet Brooks page 2 (H-611)

with the approval of the Board of Corrections,

be transferred and used for the purposes of

completing construction of other projects enumerated

in the same item; provided, however, that copies of

such approvals and copies of requests for Comptroller’s

action on such transfers shall be filed with the Governor

and the Legislative Budget Board.

Thus, the unexpended balances remaining from appropriations,

authorized for specific construction projects may be used for completing

construction of other projects, provided that such projects are enumerated

in the same item: provided that the approval of the Board of Corrections

is obtained; and provided that copies of such approvals and copies of

requests for Comptroller’s action on the transfer of such funds are filed

with the Governor and with the Legislative Budget Board. Unless it has

complied with these requirements, the Department may not use the

unexpended balances appropriated for building construction for comple-

tion of any other project.

Your second question asks about the procedure for authorizing

construction of “other” projects as contemplated by the rider, and

whether a “report” approved by the Board of Corrections after a

construction project is substantially complete can adequately serve as

evidence of the “approval” the rider requires.

The rider does not require that the approval of the Board of

Corrections be evidenced by a particular writing, but that “copies of

such approvals ” be filed with the Governor and the Legislative Budget

Board. As couched in general appropriation acts prior to 1973, the

rider required that expenditures on “other” projects be approved by

the Governor rather than the Board of Corrections and that copies of

the Governor’s approval were to be filed with the Legislative Budget

Board; but in Attorney General Opinion M-1199 (1972), with reference

to that rider, it was said on page 5:

That portion of the rider requiring the Governor’s

approval is invalid: such approval cannot be required,

but that portion requiring filing of information with

Budget Board is valid. M-1141 and V-1254. The agency

Board must vote the transfer of funds. (Emphasis added).

p. 2706

The Honorable Chet Brooks page 3 (H-611)

The purpose of the ;‘filing” provision is to acquaint the Governor

and the Budget Board with the use to which the funds will be put. However,

we cannot say that a project was not properly authorized merely because

the evidence of “approval” filed was in some form other than a resolution

of the Board of Corrections to transfer the funds. Whether or not a

project was actually approved is a question of fact.

Your third question asks if an appropriation for “capital outlay”

can be expended on building construction. Section 10 of Article V of the

current general appropriation act specifies; Acts 1973, supra at p. 2202.

Funds appropriated . . . in items designated

for . . . capital outlay . . . shall be expended

only for items set out in the Comptroller’s

Manual of Accounts, Expenditure Classification,

effective November 1, 1965, as amended, and

numbered . . . 60 to 69 for ‘capital outlay. ’

Expenditure classification no. 68 from the Manual of Accounts

is “Building Purchased, Constructed or Remodeled” the purpose of

which is described by the manual:

. . . to record payment for materials and/or

contract labor for construction or remodeling

of state owned buildings. Does not include pay-

ments for repair or maintenance jobs.

We answer your third question in the affirmative.

Your last question inquires as to whether the funds appropriated

for “classified salaries” may be expended in any other manner. A rider

to the Department of Corrections appropriation in Article III provides:

From the line appropriation for Salaries of

Classified Positions the Department of Correc-

tions is authorized to purchase electronic security

devices for installations on compoind fences to

minimize security risks while reducing the number

of officers required to man outside pickets, pro-

vided that the purchase of those devices will not

necessitate any supplemental or additional appropria-

tion out of any funds of this State. Acts 1973, ~upra at 1950.

p. 2707

--.

*

The Honorable Chet Brooks page 4 (H-611)

Furthermore, a general rider in Article V of the Appropriations Act

states that; Acts 1973, supraat p. 2195:

Appropriations for ‘Salaries of Classified Positions’

may also be used to pay the salaries of positions

exempted from the Classification Plan by the Governor

under authority granted in Section 2 of the Position

Classification Act of 1961. Sec. l(t)

Thus, the General Appropriations Act provides that the funds appropriated

to the Department of Corrections for classified salaries may be expended

to pay the salaries of positions exempted from the Classification Plan

by the Governor, and, subject to the stated proviso, may be expended for

the purchase of electronic security devices for installation on compound

fences.

SUMMARY

A line item appi-opriation may be expended only

for the purpose designated therein, subject to any

riders applicable to the appropriation for the particular

agency and subject further to any relevant general

provisions in the Appropriations Act. Whether or not

an agency action complies with the requirements of an

Appropriations Act rider is sometimes a question of

fact. Whether an expenditure is proper as a “capital

outlay” is determined by the Comptroller’s Manual of

Accounts, and Appropriation Act riders authorize the

use4Dr certain other purposes of monies appropriated

to the Department of Corrections for “classified salaries. ”

Very truly yours,

/ /JOHN L. HILL

I/ Attorney General of Texas

p. 2708

The Honorahle Chet Brooks page 5 (H-611)

DAVID &f. KENDALL, First Assistant

C. ROBERT HEATH, Chairman

Opinion Committee

lg

p. 2709

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.