Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1975
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

. ..

The Honorable Jack K. Williams Opinion No. H- 677,

President

Texas A & M University Re: Validity of proposed

College Station, Texas 77843 regulation of State Board

of Professional Engineers

limiting the use of the

word engineer in academic

Dear President Williams:’ titles.

You have requested our opinion regarding the validity of a proposed

regulation of the State Board of P:rofessional Engineers limiting the use

of the word “engineer” in academic titles. The proposed regulation,

Board Rule 23, would provide in pertinent part:

Engineering titles which are confusing to the Public

arid.which may be interpreted differently under varying

circumstances are prohibited. Included in this group

are Chief Engineer, Process Engineer, Project

Engineer, Plant Engineer, Highway Engineer, Traffic

Engineer, Sales Engineer, Utility Engineer, Water

Engineer, Design Engineer, City Engineer, Sanitary

Engineer, Professor of Engineering, Professor of

Chemical (or other) Engineering, Dean of Engineering,

Engineering Department Head or the Assistant or

Associate of any of these listed titles except that the

teaching title of Assistant Professor of Engineering

will be allowed until tenure is obtained. (This privi-

lege will not be granted for Engineering Titles above

the grade of Assistant Professor. This permissive use

of title does not allow the holder to practice Engineering

on the public. )

p. 2949

The Honorable Jack K. Williams, page 2 (H-677)

Special exemption is granted to the Educational

Community to allow Public identification of visiting

educators from out of state with their acquired

titles, provided they do not publicly practice en-

gineering in Texas other than speaking engagements,

lecture s~eries or research performed under the

sponsorship of a recognized college of university.

Non-engineer faculty teaching in Colleges or

Departments’ of Engineering should be designated

by academic rank and teaching field + or Ef the

College or Department of Engineering. An example

of this might be Professor of Applied Mathematics

in the College of Engineering.

You inquire whether the rule-making authority of the Board extends

to the regulation of academic titles, and our opinion is directed only

to the portion of the rule relating to academic titles such as professor or

dean of engineering. The Texas Engineering Practice Act, article 327la.

V.T.C.S., vests the Board with rule-making authority as follows:

. . . to make and enforce all rules and regulations

necessary for the performance of its duties, to

establish standards of conduct and ethics for

engineers in keeping with the purposes and intent

of this Act or to insure strict compliance with

and enforcement of this Act. Article 3271a.

section 8.

The Board contends that proposed Rule 23 is necessary “to insure

strict compliance” with section 1.2(2) of the Act, which provides that a

non-registered individual may not:

[dlirectly or indirectly, employ, use, cause to be

used or make use of any of the following terms or

any combinations, variations or abbreviations

thereof as a professional; business or commercial

identification, title, name, representation, claim,

asset or means of advantage or benefit: ‘engineer, ’

‘professional engineer, ’ ‘licensed engineer, ’

‘registered engineer, ’ ‘registered professional

engineer, ’ ‘licensed professional engineer, ’

‘engineered. ’

p. 2950

The Honorable Jack K. Williams, page 3 (B-677)

In Gerst V. Qak Cliff Sayings & ,Loan Ass’n., 432 S. W:2d 702. 706

(1968), the Supreme Court declared:

Thk determining factor, in. . . dealing,with the I.

question of whether or not a particular admini- .’

strativcagency has exceeded its rule-making,.

powers is ‘that the rule’s provisions must be in

harmony with the general objectives of the Act

involved.

The general objectives of the Act are indicate.d~in section l., 1:

. . . to pr.otect the public health, safety and

welfare . . i. and [to enable] the public . . .

to identify those duly authorized to practice

engineering in this state and fix ,responsibility 1’ ~’

for wo,rk done or services or acts performed

in the ,practice of engineering., _. . ,.,,’

.,

. /

It seems,.,clear that. the “general obje,ctives” of the ,Act contemplate the

protection of the public against persons who “practice” engineering without

fulfilling the requirements of registration and,licensing’. Since a “professor

of engineering ‘I does~,.not in such capacity “practice” engineering, we do not

believe the regulation ,of liie,employment g & professor’cah reasonably be

said to fall within the g.eneral objectives of the Act;

In light of the general objectives of the Act, we do not believe that the

exercise of the Board!8 rule-making authority extends to the prohibition

of names or terms, such as “professor of engineering, ” which are not

specifically listed in section 1.2(2), which cannot reasonably be deemed

to be “combinations , variations or abbreviations thereof’ and which do not

suggest that the person holding the title practices engineering;

As a result, it is our opinion that the State Board of Professional

Engineers ,may not restrict the use of the word “engineer” in academic

titles such as dean or professor of engineering.

p. 2951

The Honorable Jack K. Williams, page 4 (~-677)

SUMMARY

The State Board of Professional Engineers may not

restrict the use of the word “engineer” in academic titles

such as dean or professor of engineering.

Very truly yours,

APPROVED:

v Attorney General of Texas

L&

DAVID M. KENDALL, First Assistant

Opinion Committee

p. 2952

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.