Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1975
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III Opinion No. H- 683

President, State Bar of Texas

P. 0. Box 12487, Capitol Station Re: Whether Department of

Austin, Texas 78711 Public Safety may provide

criminal history informa-

The Honorable Wilson Speir, Director tion to State Bar and

Texas Department of Public Safety Department of Public

P. 0. Box 4087 Welfare for licensing

Austin, Texas 78173 purposes.

Dear Mr. Lawrence and Colonel Speir:

Each of you has requested our opinion as to whether the Department of

Public Safety has authority to provide criminal history record information

to certain state agencies for licensing purposes. The State Bar of Texas

seeks criminal history record information concerning applicants for admis-

sion to the Bar; the Department of Public Welfare seeks only information

concerning felony and selected misdemeanor convictions of child care

administrator applicants and licensees.

The question here is not whether this information may be relied upon

as the basis for a licensing decision. Procedural due process requires

notice and hearing and confrontation of one’s accusers. See Willner v.

Committee on Character and Fitness of New York, 373 UT 96, LO5 (1963);

Greene v. McElroy, 360 U.S. 474 (1959). The only question is whether

the Department of Public Safety may provide such information to the State

Bar and the Department of Public Welfare to assist them in their investi?

gative responsibilities,

The Department of Public Welfare has a duty to license and regulate

administrators of child-caring institutions. Eligibility for a license requires

among other qualifications evidence of “good moral character, ethical commit-

ment, and sound physical and emotional health and maturity. II V. T. C. S.

art. 695a-1, $3. Section 7 of this licensing act provider:

p. 2971

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 2

The department may revoke a child care

administrator’s license if it finds that the licensee:

(1) has been convicted of a felony;

(2) has been convicted of a misdemeanor

involving fraud or deceit. , . .

Obviously, grounds for revocation of a license constitute grounds

for denial of an initial license. We believe that this express authority

to take action on the basis of certain convictions necessarily includes

authority to investigate and obtain information concerning such convic-

tions. It is a cardinal rule of statutory construction that the’statutory grant

of an express power carries with it by necessary implication every other

power necessary and proper to the execution of the power expressly

granted. Anderson v. Brandon. 47 S. W. 2d 261, 262 (Tex. Sup. 1932);

Imperial Irr. Co. v. Jayne, 138 S. W. 575 (Tex. Sup. 1911); Terre11 v.

Sparks, 135 S. W. 519 (Tex.Sup. 1911); Brown v. Clark, 116 S. W. 360

(Tea Sup. 1909).

Thus, it is our opinion that the Department of Public Welfare has

authority to obtain information as to whether applicants for a child care

administrator license, or license holders have been convicted of a

felony or certain misdemeanors.

The Supreme Court licenses persons to practice law in Texas. V. T. C. S.

art. 306. The Board of Law Examiners is responsible for determining the

eligibility of candidates for admission to the Bar and recommending qualified

persons to the Supreme Court. V. T. C. S. art. 305. The Supreme Court

has by rule imposed a duty on the Board, the State Bar and District Com-

mittees on Admissions to investigate the qualifications of applicants for

admission to the Bar. Rules Governing Admission to the Bar, Rules III

E. H. J, R, L, M; VIIr; IX; XI1 (c),(g) (1974).

Good moral character is an essential qualification for admission to the

Bar. V. T. C. S. arts. 305. 306. 307A. 307B. 308. Rules Governing

Admission to the Bar, Rules II, III, VIII, XII.

p. 2972,

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 3

Criminal conduct of an applicant for admission to the Bar is relevant

to an investigation of the person’s qualifications. Article 311, V. T. C. S.,

absolutely bars from admission any person who has been convicted of a

felony. Upon conviction for a “felony involving moral turpitude or of

any misdemeanor involving the theft, embezzlement, or fraudulent appro-

priation of money or other property,” an attorney shall be suspended during

pendency of any appeal, and shall be disbarred upon final conviction.

V. T. C. S. art. 320a-1, 5 6. Obviously, grounds for disbarment are

grounds for denial of initial admission. See Hallinan v. Committee of Bar

Examiners of the State Bar, 421 P. Zd 76, 81 (Cal. 1966).

The State Bar’s legitimate interest in criminal history information is

not limited to convictions. “Conduct not descending to the level of guilt

of the violation of a criminal statute may well present an insuperable

obstacle to admission to the Bar if such conduct evinces a lack of that

‘character and general fitness requisite for an attorney and counsellor-

at-law. “’ Application of Cassidy, 51 N. Y. S. td 202, 206 (N. Y. App. Div.

1944), aff’d, 73 N. E. 2d 41 (N. Y. 1947). See 7 C. J.S. Attorney & Client

97, p. 713.

It is within the discretion of the Supeme Court to deny admission

to the Bar on the grounds that an applicant made materially faalse statements

in his application for admission. See Rules Governing State Bar of Texas,

art. 12 5 5 DR l-101, DR l-102. Certainly the State Bar’s investigatory

authority includes obtaining information which will verify statements

made by an applicant concerning charges of criminal conduct made

against him and their disposition.

An administrative agency with investigative duties may take steps to

inform itself on matters within its jurisdiction, such as whether there is

probable violation of the law, or just to assure itself there is none. United

States v. Morton Salt Co., 338 U.S. 632, 642-643 (1950). We believe the

State Bar may obtain information such as that contained in crininal history

records held by another state agency in the course of its investigation. Such

information may suggest areas of further investigation. -See Application

of Levine, 397 P. 2d 205, 208 (Aria. 1964).

p. 2973

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 4

The Department of Public Safety has a duty to collect and file for

record information concerning convicted felons, well-known and habitual

criminals, the number and nature of offenses known to have been committed

in the State, of the legal steps taken in connection therewith, “and such

other information as may be useful in the study of crime and the administra-

tion of justice. ” V. T. C. S. art. 4413(14).

We believe that the general public policy of this State is that state

agencies should cooperate in the interest of efficiency and economy in the

administration of their statutory duties. See V. T. C. S. arts. 441?(23),

4413(32); 695c, $4(S).

We need not reach the question of whether some of the information

requested is excepted from general public disclosure under the Open Records

Act, article 6252-17a, V. T. C. S. In Attorney General Opinion H-242 (1974).

we said:

. . . Our office has previously recognized the need

to maintain an unrestricted flow of information

between state agencies. See Attorney General

Opinion M-713 (1970). The Open Records~ Act does

not undercut that policy. Information which is not

required to be disclosed to the public under the Act

can still be transferred between state agencies with-

out violating its confidentiality or destroying its

confidential character.

In addition we note that the Supreme Court Rules Governing Admission

to the bar expressly make information received in investigation of moral

character and fitness confidential. Rule II D.

p. 2974

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 5

We are aware of the growing concern about the misuse of incomplete,

inaccurate, or irrelevant criminal history record information. The

potential for harm to the individual concerned increases as modern tech-

nology makes such information more accessible through nationwide

criminal history record information systems. See generally, Tarlton

v. Saxbe, 507 F. 2d 1116(D. C. Cir. 1974); Menard v. Saxbe, 498 F. 2d

1017 (D. C. Cir. 1974); Menard v. Mitchell, 430 F. 2d 486 (D. C. Cir.

1970); Gregory v. Litton Systems, Inc., 316 F.Supp. 401 (C. D. Cal.

1970), modified, 472 F. 2d 631 (9th Cir. 1972); Davidson v. Dill, 503

P. 2d 157 (Colo. 1972); Henry v. Looney. 317 N. Y. S. 2d 848 (Sup. Ct. 1971);

Monroe v. Tielsch, 525 P. 2d 250 (Wash. 1974); Eddy v. Moore, 487 P. 2d

211 (Wash. App. 1971); Comment, Branded: Arrest Records of the Uncon-

victed, 44 Miss. L. J. 928 (1973); Comment, Retention and Dissemination

of Arrest Records: Judicial Response, 38 U. Chi. L. Rev. 850 (1971);

Hess & LePoole, Abuse of the Record of Arrest Not Leading to Convic-

tion, 13 Crime & Delinquency 494 (1967).

However, the Department of Public Welfare seeks only information

concerning convictions. At least as to convictions in Texas, this informa-

tion is public when held by the court clerk or other person responsible

for filing it. See Code Crim.Proc. arts. 1.24, 2.21, 42.01, 42.02, 45.13,

.45.49; V.T. Cx arts. 1200, 1899, 1945, 2383, 3930. It is not necessary

here to decide whether the public nature of this information is transformed

by virtue of the compilation of it in a centralized and vastly more accessible

form. The Department of Public Welfare is authorized to make decisions

on the basis of convictions, and we believe it is clear that it can obtain

information concerning convictions from another state agency which compiles

it.

The request of the State Bar is broader, arrl asks for all criminal

history record information which the Department of Public Safety holds

or to which it has access. This information may include notations of

convictions, indictments, informations, or other formal charges of

criminal conduct, dispositions arising from such charges such as acquittal

by reason of insanity, incompetency to stand trial, pardons, probation before

convictions, no bill, nolle prosequi, charge dismissed, and a Mriety of other

possible conclusions to criminal proceedings. It may also include information

as to arrest without any indication of further action or disposition.

p. 2975

. .

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 6

The United States Supreme Court, in Schware v. Board of Bar

Examiners, 353 U.S. 232, 241 (1957) has said:

The mere fact that a man has been arrested has

very little, if any, probative value in showing that

he has engaged in any misconduct. An arrest shows

nothing more than that someone probably suspected

the person apprehended of an offense. When formal

charges are not filed against the arrested person and

he is released without trial, whatever probative force

the arrest may have had is normally dissipated.

This language is pertinent to the Bar’s evaluation of information, but

we do not believe it can be read so as to preclude inquiry and investigation

into potentially relevant areas, reflected in official records of alleged or

proven misconduct.

While the State Bar and Department of Public Welfare have authority

to obtain this information they seek and no state law restricts the Depart-

ment of Public Safety from providing it, applicable federal statutes and

regulations do limit dissemination of criminal history information in some

instances.

As a participant in the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s National Crime

Information Center and as a recipient of Law Enforcement Assistance

Administration funds, the Department of Public Safety has certain contrac-

tual obligations and is subject to recent regulations issued by the Attorney

General of the United States pursuant to various federal statutes concerning

the dissemination of criminal history record information. 28 C. F. R. § 20.1

et seq., 40 Fed. Reg. 22114 (1975) (effective June 19, 1975).

Under these regulations, the Department of Public Safety is under a

duty to limit dissemination of criminal history record information to:

(1) Criminal justice agencies, for purposes of

the administration of criminal justice and criminal

justice agency employment:

p. 2976

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 7

(2) Such other individuals and agencies which

require criminal history record information to

implement a statute or executive order that

expressly refers to criminal conduct and contains

requirements and/or exclusions expressly based

upon such conduct;

. . . .

(6) Individuals and agencies where authorized by

court order or court rule.

28 C. F. R. 5 20.21(b).

The regulations also provide in section 20. 33 as follows:

(a) Criminal history record information contained

in any Department of Justice criminal history

record information system will be made available:

. . . .

(3) Pursuant to Public Law 92-544 (86 Stat. 115)

for use in connection with licensing or local/state

employment or for other uses only if such dis-

semination is authorized by Federal or state statutes

and approved by the Attorney General of the United

States. . . .

The Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been given

authority to approve exchanges of identification records with State and local

governments for purposes of empl.oyment and licensing. 28 C. F. R. 5 0.85(j)

(1974).

It is our view that the Department of Public Welfare’s child care

administrator licensing statute brings it precisely within the terms of

28 C. F. R. $2-.21(b)(Z), in that the statute “expressly refers to criminal

conduct and contains express requirements and/or exclusions expressly

based upon such conduct. ‘I V. T. C.S. art. 695a-1, § 7.

It is apparent that the State Bar of Texas is within several categories of

those agencies to whom criminal history record information may be dis-

seminated.

p. 2977

. . .

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 8

In our opinion, the Department of Public Safety has authority to

cooperate with the Department of Public Welfare and the State Bar of

Texas by providing those agencies with the information they have

requested and which the Department of Public Safety holds.

To the extent that the federal regulations discussed are applicable to

all or part of the information you hold or to which you have access through

contractual arrangements, it is our view that the Department of Public

Welfare and the State Bar are within the categories of agencies described

in the federal regulations as those to whom dissemination is permissible.

In order to avoid questions as to applicability or possible breach of con-

tractual provisions, the Department of Public Safety should request the

Attorney General of the United States, through the Director of the Federal

Bureau of Investigation, to approve the dissemination of that criminal

history record information to which the regulations are applicable to

these agencies pursuant to 28 C. F. R. $20. 33; E 28 C. F. R. 5 0.85(j).

Upon receipt of this approval, which we believe should be forthcoming,

the Department of Public Safety may provide the requested information

to the State Bar and thenDepartment of Public Welfare under such terms

and conditions as are reasonable and necessary to accomplish such inter-

agency cooperation. See

- V. T.C.S. art. 4413(32).

Colonel Speir also asks in reference to the Department of Public

Welfare’s request, what misdemeanors involve fraud and deceit within

the meaning of section 7 of article 695a-1, V. T. C. S. In our opinion,

this refers to offenses which include fraud or deceit as an element of the

offense.

Without attempting to be exhaustive, and by way of example only,

depending upon the circumstances of the particular offense, misdemeanor

offenses such as those defined in Penal Code chapters 31 (theft), 32 (fraud),

37 (perjury and other falsification) may involve fraud and deceit.

p. 2978

-. . .

. . ’

..

The Honorable John M. Lawrence, III (H-683)

The Honorable Wilson Speir

Page 9

SUMMARY

The Department of Public Safety may provide

criminal history information to the State Bar of Texas

and the Department of Public Welfare to assist them

in their licensing responsibilities. The approval of

the Attorney General of the United States should be

sought to disseminate criminal history record

information from the National Crime Information

Center System to these agencies.

Very truly yours,

/\

// JOHN L. HILL

u Attorney General of Texas

APPROVED:

DAVID M. KENDALL, First Assistant

C. ROBERT HEATH, Chairman

Opinion Committee

p. 2979

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.