Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1976
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

OP'hCXAS

The Honorable Hugh C. Yantis, Jr. Opinion No. H-833

Executive Director

Texas Water Quality Board Re: Whether boat certi-

1700 North Congress Avenue fication fees erroneously

Austin, Texas 78701 collected by the Water

Quality Board can be

refunded.

Dear Mr. Yantie:

In Attorney General Opinion H-716 (1975) this office

advised you that a provision in the general appropriations

act specifies that any money deposited into the State Treasury

which is "subject to refund as provided by law" is appropriated

for that purpose. We said the provision would apply to boat

certification fee refunds "necessary to reimburse persons

entitled by general law to refunds of money placed in,the

special [boat certification feel fund." See Acts 1975, 64th

Lig., ch. 743 at 2417; Water Code 9 21.09m).

You have now asked if the money in the boat certifica-

tion fee fund is "subject to refund as provided by law" in

four specific situations:

1. In the instance in which a local govern-

mental entity is the designated certifying

authority, an applicant already certified

by that entity mistakenly applied for and

remitted fees for certification by this

office.

2. Persons have sent in applications for

certification when they operate boats in

salt water only. The law and this Board's

regulations apply only to boats operating on

inland freshwaters.

p. 3515

.

The Honorable Hugh C. Yantis, Jr. - page 2 (H-833)

3. Persons have applied for certification

when their boats have no permanent sleeping

facilities and no marine sanitation device,

in which case there is no need for certification.

4. Persons have submitted payment in excess of

the amount required for certification.

In the first three cases, certification may not be properly

given, and in all four cases, the fees were accepted and

deposited before the error was discovered.

Section 21.097(c) of the Water Code, which governs the

collection of boat certification fees and the establishment

of the fund into which they are paid, does not itself expressly

authorize refunds for any reason, but in our opinion, refunds

can be made if authorized by common law. Cf. Attorney General

Opinion H-716 (1975). We think the appropztion act proviso

p rmitting refunds as provided by law is meant to square

w f th article 3, section '44of the Texas Constitution, which

prohibits the Legislature from granting "by appropriation,

or otherwise, any amount of money out of the Treasury of the

State, to any individual; on a claim, real or pretended, when

the same shall not have been provided for by pre-existing law."

In explaining the constitutional restriction, it is said

with ample support in 52 Tex. Jur.2d, State of Texas 6 40

at 750:

[T]he legislature may not appropriate

state money to any individual unless,

at the time the appropriation is made,

there is already in force some valid

law constituting the claim that the

appropriation is made to pay a legal

obligation of the state. By that

legal obligation is meant an obligation

such as would form the basis of a judgment

against the state in a court of competent

jurisdiction in the event the state should

permit itself to be sued. The term 'pre-

existing law' does not necessarily mean

p. 3516

The Honorable Hugh C. Yantis, Jr. - page 3 W-833)

pre-existing statutory law. . . . Hut it is held

that a moral obligation will not authorize

an appropriation by the legislature, even

where the state has received the benefits

of the unauthorized contracts of its

officers or of unauthorized taxes voluntarily

paid into the treasury.

We discussed in Attorney General Opinion H-548 (1975)

the rules applicable to the refund of taxes where no statute

applies:

(1) a person who voluntarily pays an

illegal tax has no claim for repayment:

(2) a person paying an illegal tax under

duress has a valid claim for repayment;

(3) duress in the payment of an illegal

tax may be either express or implied, and,a

legal duty to refund exists in both cases:

(4) a taxpayer need not take the risk of

incurring the threatened penalties or

punishments while the invalidity of the

tax is being litigated in order to

claim duress: and

(5) in the absence of a statute to the

contrary, it is immaterial to the taxpayer's

right of repayment whether or not the tax

was paid under protest.

These rules, laid down by the Texas Supreme Court in National

Biscuit Co. v. State, 135 S.W.Zd 687 (Tex. Sup. 1940), have

been appmdTotherefund of fees, as well as of taxes.

Crow v. City of Corpus Christi, 209 S.W.Zd 922 (Tex. Sup.

m)TAttornz Generalans M-1048 (19721, WW-834 (19601,

ww-749 (19591, O-6974 (1945). Cf. Attorney General Opinions

M-576 (19701, WW-364 (19581, WWx8 (19571, O-7113 (19461,

O-6282 (1945).

p. 3517

I .

The Honorable Hugh C. Yantis, Jr. - page 4 (H-833)

In the above-described fact situations, the money received

has already been paid into the state treasury. Under the

ational Biscuit Co. rules, the payments must be considered

voluntary and no=efundable~unless they were made under

duress, express or implied. The most,recent Supreme Court

case on the duress necessary to entitle a payor to a refund

is State v. Connecticut General Life Insurance &, 382

S.W=4r(Tex. Suo~.1964l.Smnvolved occuuation tax

overpayments. The Court held that the taxes there were paid

under duress because an act of the Commissioner of Insurance

caused or resulted in an overpayment'of taxes by the'insur-

ante organization, the payment of which was necessary to

avoid loss of the right of the insurance company to do

business in this state. See

--p also Crow,.:y.

City of Corpus

Christi, supra.

In the examples you have given all the payments were

apparently made not,onlyytb'secure certification, but to

avoid the legal penalties attached to noncompliance with

the certification law. You'advise that,boat owners received

mass mailings from your office which included an official

letter explaining the certification program, an application

form for certification, a list of,Water Quality Board district

offices, a copy of House Bill 1422,,enacting the certification

law, and a copy of Board Order No. 74-0.521-4,implementing

the law.

Boat owners were advised by the letter sent them that

persons failing to comply with the regulations contained

in the Order might be found guilty of a misdemeanor and,

upon conviction, fined from $25 to $200. It has been sug-

gested that the letters sent were confusing and ambiguous as

to the boats for which certification was required, the

particular certifications necessary, the governmental units

which would perform necessary inspections and make certifi-

cations, and the fee payments necessary to avoid the penal

provisions of the law.

The definition of "duress" as a legal concept -- the

question of what is necessary to legally constitute "duress" --

is a question of law. State v. Connecticut General Life

Insurance Co., supra. But whether or not a particulat

person in a particular transaction actually acted under

legal duress, express or implied, is a question of fact.

p. 3518

The ~HonorableHugh C. Yantis, Jr. - page 5 (H-833)

This office does not decide

._ .disputed

_ questions of fact

in the opinion process , but if the facts are as stated abOW

and if the payments or overpayments described in the four

examples you give actually resulted from a misapprehension

of fact or law induced by the Water Quality Board or from a

threat of penal prosecution upon failure to pay, then the

cited authorities indicate there is pre-existing law to

support refunds of boat certification fees improperly

collected in the manner described.

S UM~MARY

Improperly collected boat certification

fees may be refunded if payment of the

fees resulted from a misapprehension

of fact or law induced by the Water

Quality Board or from a threat of penal

prosecution upon a failure to pay.

APPROVED:

v Attorney General of Texas

Opinion Committee

jwb

p. 3519

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.