Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1976
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

The Honorable Joe Christie Opinion No. H-848

Chairman

State Board of Insurance Re: Whether persons who

1110 San Jacinto Blvd. were not subject to a

Austin, Texas 78786 disciplinary order of the

Commissioner of Insurance

may appeal that order to

the State Board of Insur-

ance.

Dear Chairman Christie:

You have requested our opinion regarding whether persons

not subject to a disciplinary order of the Commissioner of

Insurance may appeal from an order to the State Board of

Insurance.

On October 16, 1975, the Commissioner of Insurance

issued a consent order by which two business entities agreed

to

take such actions as may be necessary . . .

to make it clear that [corporation] is not

engaged as an agent in the insurance bus-

iness, that [companyj is an agent engaged

in the insurance business, and to delineate

the role or functions of each entity in any

integrated or joint program of insurance and

securities solicitations and sales! so as to

avoid the possibility of [corporation] doing

business as an insurance agent or the public

believing that [corporation], rather than

tcompanyl, is engaged in such insurance

business.

p. 3577

The Honorable Joe Christie - page 2 (H-848)

Apparently, the Commissioner's order grew out of charges of

"unfair methods of competition and unfair and deceptive acts

or practices in the business of insurance," as defined in

and prohibited by article 21.21 of the Texas Insurance Code.

Sections 3 & 4. Likewise, the Commissioner's consent order

was issued under the authority of section 22 of article

21.21, which permits the Board

[iln the administration of this Article

. . . [to] accept assurance of voluntary

compliance with respect to any act or prac-

tice which violates this Article . . . .

Article 1.04(d) of the Insurance Code provides, in

pertinent part:

Any person or organization, private or

public, which is affected by any ruling

or action of the Commissioner of Insur-

ance shall have the right to have such a

ruling or action reviewed by the State

Board of Insurance by making an application

to the Board.

Other portions of the Insurance Code provide for appeal in

specific instances, such as section 13 of article 21.07-1,

which authorizes an "applicant or accused" to appeal the

suspension, revocation, or denial of a license. Although

it is arguable that some of these special appeal provisions

were repealed by the enactment of article 1.04(d), the court

in State Board of Insurance v. Adams, 316 S.W.Zd 773 (Tex.

Civ. App. -- Houston 1958, nrwm held that they were

repealed only to the extent they are "repugnant to or incon-

sistent with the terms of the later statute." Id. at 776,

779. In any event, article 21.21 contains no special appeal

section except for the inclusion by reference in section 13

of article 21.44 with respect to cease and desist orders.

AS to orders acknowledging voluntary compliance under section

22 of article 21.21, we believe that the general appeal statute,

article 1.04(d), is clearly applicable.

p. 3578

The Honorable Joe Christie - page 3 (H-848)

Article 1.04(d) permits "any person or organization" to

appeal to the State Board of Insurance "any ruling or action

of the Commissioner," provided the appellant is "affected"

by such ruling or action. Whether an appellant is a person

"affected" requires a factual determination which is properly

within the discretionary authority of the Board. In Empire

Gas

mm- h Fuel Co. v. Railroad Commission of Texas, 94 S.W.Zd

1240 (Tex. G.?ipp. -- Austin 1936, wzt ref'd), the court

found it impracticable for the Legislature to define precisely

who were "interested parties affected" and held that whether a

party was "affected" was

generally a fact question dependent upon

the facts and circumstances of the partic-

ular case . . . . -Id, at 1244.

Thus, it is our opinion that any person "affected" by the

order of the Commissioner may appeal that decision to the

State Board of Insurance pursuant to article 1.04(d) of the

Insurance Code. It is for the Board reasonably to determine

whether an appellant is "affected" by the Commissioner's

order.

SUMMARY

Any person "affected" by an order of the

Commissioner of Insurance pursuant to

article 21.21, Texas Insurance Code, may

appeal that decision to the State Board

of Insurance under article 1.04(d).

Whether the appellant is a person "affected"

is a question of fact to be determined by

the Board.

p. 3579

The Honorable Joe Christie - page 4 (H-848)

APPROVED:

Opinion Committee

jwb

p. 3580

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.