Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1978
Status
Published
On the bench
John Hill
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

The Attorney General of Texas

January 5, 1978

Ms. Betty J. Anderson, Executive Opinion No. B- 1110

Secretary

Texas State Board of Examiners in Re: Whether applicants

the Basic Sciences for licensing as.chiro-

319 Sam Houston Building practors must hold .basic

Austin, Texas sciences certificate.

Dear Ms. Anderson:

you inquire whether~the 1977 amendment to section 10

of article,4512b, V.T.C.S. (Acts 1977, 65th Deg., ch. 75 at

151), exempts certain chiropractors from the requirements

of article 459Oc, V.T.C.S., the Basic Sciences Law. Sec-

tion 1 of article 459Oc provides as follows:

No person shall be permitted to

take an examination for a license

to practice the healing art or any

branch thereof, or be granted any

such license, unless he has presented

to the Board or officer empowered

.to issue such a license as the appli-

cant seeks, a certificate of profi-

ciency in anatomy, physiology,

chemistry, bacteriology, pathology,

and hygiene and public health, here&

inafter referred to as the basic

sciences, issued by the State Board

of Examiners in the Basic Sciences.

It is-well established that chiropractors practice a healing

art within this provision. See V.T.C.S. art. 459Oc, § 16;

Attorney General Opinions V-1081, V-988 (1950). See generally

Attorney General Opinion Ii-913 (1976). The certificate of

proficiency can be earned by passing .an examination given by

the Basic Sciences Board or by completion of college courses

in the basic sciences. V.T.C.S. art. 459Oc, 9.9 6., 16-a.

Article 451213,V.T.C.S., governs the licensing of chiro-

practors by the Texas Board,of Chiropractic Examiners. Sec-

tion 10 of the statute requires applicants for a license to

P. 4546

MS. Betty J. Anderson - Page ' (H-1110)

pass a written examination given by the Board. Prior to the

recent amendment, this section permitted the Board to license

applicants on the basis of a standardized national exam:

The Board may grant a license without

a written examination to an applicant

that holds a National Board of Chiropractic

Examiners certificate who meets the re-

quirements of this chapter and who has

satisfactorily passed a personal inter-

view and a practical examination and

has paid an additional fee of Fifty

Dollars ($50).

Acts 1973, 63rd Leg., ch. 94, at 211. In granting licenses

under this provision, the Board required applicants to present

the certificate of proficiency in the basic sciences provided

for in article 459Oc, section 1.

The 1977 Act amends the quoted provision to read in part:

The Board shall grant a license without

a written emtion to an applicant that

holds a National Board of Chiropractic

Examiners certificate. . . .

Acts 1977, 65th Leg., ch. 75, at 152 (emphasis added). Other

amendments provide for Board review of the adequacy of the

national exam, and prohibit the Board from~requiring examina-

tions in addition to those set out in the statute. The Board

has construed the word "shall" in Senate Bill 446 to give it

a mandatory duty to grant licenses to applicants who hold the

National Board of Chiropractic Examiners certificate, even

though those persons have not demonstrated proficiency in the

basic sciences as required by article 459Oc, section 1.

Although the word "shall" generally connotes a mandatory

duty, Chisholm v. Bewley Mills, 287 S.W.Zd 943 (Tex. 19561, we

believe the duty imposed by the 1977 Act relates to the Board's

acceptance of the national exam results in lieu of its own exam.

Our careful examination of the legislative history reveals no

indication that the Legislature intended to exempt chiroprac-

tors from the requirements of the Basic Sciences Law. The

testimony in the House and Senate Committees did not refer to

the Basic Sciences Certificate at all. Instead, legislators

and witnesses emphasized that the Act was a house-keeping

measure and that it would facilitate the licensing of applicants

who attended chiropractic colleges outside of Texas. If such a

p. 4547

MS. Betty J. Anderson - Rage 3 (H-1110)

change as is now suggested were intended by the Legislature,

we believe a clear expression of such intention would have

and should have emerged from a review of the legislative

history.

Repeals by implication are not favored. Cordon v. Lake,

356 S.W.Zd 138 (Tex. 1962). A finding that the 1977 Act affects

only the Board's examination requirements harmonizes the bill

with the Basic Sciences Law and accords with the explanations

of the bill expressed while it was before the Legislature. The

Board itself interpreted prior law , which authorized it to grant

licenses on the basis of the national exam, to affect only its

own examination requirement. We feel, therefore, that absent

clear' legislative action to the contrary, we should conclude

that the recent amendment only removes the Board's discretion

to withhold a license from someone who has passed the national

exam and completed other requirements.

The provision for licensing by reciprocity also provides

that the Board

shall . . . grant license to practice

chiropractic to licentiates of other

states or territories having require-

ments and practices equal to those

established by the laws of this State.

V.T.C.S. art 4512b, 9 9. A prior opinion of this office.has

determined that applicants may not be licensed by reciprocity

unless they also satisfy the requirements of the Texas Basic

Sciences Law. Attorney General Opinion V-1081 (1950). Like

applicants for licensing under the reciprocity provision, appli-

cants who have passed the national exam must still present

certificates of proficiency in the Basic Sciences in order to

be licensed by the Board of Chiropractic Examiners.

SUMMARY

Absent a change by the Legislature to the

contrary, applicants for licensing by the

Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners

must earn a certificate of proficiency in

the basic sciences in accordance with

article 459Oc. V.T.C.S. A 1977 amendment

to article 4512b, V.T.C.S., affects only

the Board's own examination requirement,

not the basic sciences requirement.

p. 4548

Ms. Betty J. Anderson - Page 4 (H-1110)

Very .truly yours,

Attorney General of Texas

APPROVED:

DAVID M. KENDALL, First Assistant.

Opinion Committee

jst

p. 4549

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.