Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1981
Status
Published
On the bench
Mark White
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

The Attorney General of Texas

November 5, 1981

MARK WHITE

Attorney General

Supreme Court Building

Honorable Robert E. Davis opinion No. Mw-384

P. 0. Box 12548 Chairman

Auslin, TX. 78711 Texas House of Representatives Re: Interpretation of Texas

5121475-2501 Committee on Ways & Means Engineering Practice Act

Telex 9101874.1367

P.O. Box 2910

Telecopier 5121475+3266

Austin, Texas 78769

1607 Main St.. Suite 1400 Dear Mr. Davis:

Dallas. TX. 75201

2141742-8944

You have addressed questions tp us concerning the construction of

the Texas Engineering Practice Act, article 3271a. V.T.C.S.

4624 Alberta Ave.. Suite 160

El Paso, TX. 79905 The Texas Engineering Practice Act is quite comprehensive. The

9151533-3484 act appropriates the terms "engineer," "engineering" and various

derivatives thereof to persons who are duly registered with the Board

1220 Dallas Ave.. Suite 202

of Registration for Professional Engineers. Generally speaking, the

Houston. TX. 77002 act forbids the use of the term "engineer" or any of its derivatives

71316500666 to all except those who are duly registered. Tackett v. State Board

of Registration for Professional Engineers, 466 S.W~.2d332 (Tex. Civ.

806 Broadway. Suite 312

APP. - Corpus Christi 1971. no writ).

Lubbock, TX. 79401

EOWi’47-5238 The act itself contains exemptions, one of which is articulated

in sqction 20(g), which reads as follows:

4309 N. Tenth. Suite B

sec. 20. The following persons shall be

McAllen. TX. 76501

5121682-4547

exempt from the provisions of this Act, provided

that such persons are not represented or held out

to the public as duly licensed and registered by

200 Main Plaza. Suite 400 the Board to engage in the practice of

San Antonio, TX. 78205

engineering.

5121225-4191

. . . .

An Equal Opportunity/

Affiranative Action Employer

CR) Any regular full time employee of a

private corporation or other private business

entity who is engaged solely and exclusively in

performing services for such corporation and/or

its affiliates; provided, such employee's services

are on, or in connection with, property owned or

leased by such private corporation and/or its

affiliates or other private business entity, or in

Elr.Robert E. Davis - Page 2 (Mw384)

which such private corporation and/or its

affiliates or other business entity has an

interest, estate or possessory right, or whose

services affect exclusively the property,

products, or interests of such private corporation

and/or its affiliates or other private business

entity; and, provided further, that such employee

does not have the final authority for the approval

of. and the ultimate responsibility for,

engineering designs, plans or specifications

pertaining to such property or products which are

to be incorporated into fixed works, systems, or

facilities on the property of others or which are

to be made available to the general public. This

exemption includes the use of job titles and

personnel classifications by such persons not in

connection with any offer of engineering services

to the public, providing that no name, title, or

words are used which tend to convey the impression

that an unlicensed person is offering engineering

services to the public.

V.T.C.S. art. 3271a, 920.

Your first question is: "Does the exemption stated in article

3271a, section 20 remove engineers in industry from the scope of the

act?" We conclude that engineers in industry are not subject to

licensing requirements if they meet the requirements of section 20(g),

but they are not exempt from the scope of the act.

Section 1.1 of article 3271a, V.T.C.S., sets forth the

legislative purpose of the act, as follows:

In recognition of the vital impact which the

rapid advance of knowledge of the mathematical,

physical and engineering sciences as applied in

the practice of engineering is having upon the

lives, prw=rty. economy and security of our

people and the national defense, it is the intent

of the Legislature, in order to protect the public

health, safety and welfare, that the privilege of

practicing engineering be entrusted only to those

persons duly licensed, registered and practicing

under the provisions of this Act and that there be

strict compliance with an enforcement of all the

provisions of this Act, and, in order that the

state and members of the public may be able to

identify those duly authorized to practice

engineering in this state and fix responsibility

for work done or services or acts performed in the

practice of engineering, only licensed and

registered persons shall practice, offer or

. -.-

Mr. Robert E. Davis - Page 3 057-384)

attempt to practice engineering or call themselves

or be otherwise designated as any kind of an

'engineer' or in any manner make use of the term

'engineer' as a professional, business or

commercial identification, title, name,

representation, claim or asset, and all the

provisions of this Act shall be liberally

construed and applied to carry out such

legislative intent. In furtherance of such intent

and purpose of the Legislature, the practice of

engineering is hereby declared a learned

profession to be practiced and regulated as such,

and its practitioners in this state shall be held

accountable to the state and members of the public

by high professional standards in keeping with the

ethics and practices of the other learned

professions in this state. There is specifically

reserved to graduates of all public universities

recognized by the American Association of Colleges

and Universities the right to disclose any college

degrees received by such individual and use the

word Graduate Engineer on his stationery, business

cards, and personal communications of any

character.

Section 1.2 specifically reserves to registrants of the board the

practice of engineering. Subsections (2). (3), and (4) of section 1.2

preclude non- registrants from using the term "engineer" or

derivatives thereof, from using any symbol or abbreviation which

would, in any manner, tend to create a public impression that the

person so using was a registrant of the board, or from receiving any

fee or compensation for "engineering" services. The concluding

paragraph of section 1.2 of the act provides that any entity utilizing

the term "engineer" or otherwise holding itself out to the public as

an engineer "shall be conclusively presumed and regarded as engaged in

the practice of engineering." It is our opinion that the essence of

section 20(g) is to exempt the average engineer in industry from the

requirement of state registration; however, we do not believe that

section 20(g) of the act can be construed in such a way as to thwart

the express purpose of the act by permitting any non-registrant to

hold himself out as a'engineer.

The preamble to section 20 of the act reads as follows:

Sec. 20. The following persons shall be

exempt from the provisions of this Act, eded

that such persons are not represented or held out

to the public as duly licensed and registered by

the Board to engage in the practice of

engineering. (Emphasis added).

p. 1307

c

..

Elr.Rohcrt E. Davis - Page 4 (Mw-384)

You next ask, in the event of a negative answer to question

number one, to what extent the engineer in industry is covered by the

act.

It is our opinion that all persons. not specifically exempted by

the act, are covered by the act. Although a person employed in the

engineering department of a" industry may carry the "in-house"

designation of "engineer" without being registered, such designation

may not be used in such a way that misleads the public into believing

the user is a registrant. It is worthy of note that section 20(g)

specifically provides that "such employee does not have the final

authority for the approval of, and the ultimate responsibility for,

engineering designs, plans or' specifications...." In other words, he

is not authorized to practice engineering.

You next ask the following question: "Does the certification of

engineers in industry as a specialist with respect to specific skills

in a recognized discipline of engineering pursuant to standardized,

nondiscriminatory guidelines fall within the scope of the act?

(a) If the answer to Question 2 is 'yes,'

would such a" undertaking fall within the

definition of the 'practice of engineering' as set

out in the act?

(b) If the answer to Question 2(a) is 'yes,'

would the board be authorized to require

registration of such activity?..

(c) If the answer to Question 2(b) is 'yes,'

under what circumstancei would the board be

authorized to withhold registration of such

activity?

(d) If the answer to Question 2 is 'no.'

would a private nonprofit corporation composed

solely of engineers in industry be authorized to

certify an engineer as possessing the requisite

degree of education, skill, expertise, and

knowledge so as to indicate a specialization in a

particular discipline of engineering if such

certification is pursuant to standardized,

nondiscriminatory guidelines?

(e) If the answer to Question 2(d) is 'yes,'

may the corporation formulate its own procedures

and rules for recognition of a" engineer as a

specialist in a particular discipline of

engineering and, on this basis, issue him a

certificate of specialty?

. 12na

.-:

Mr. Robert E. Davis - Page 5 (MW-384)

In answer to your question concerning certification. if the

result of a certificatio" is to represent the holder as duly licensed

by the board, he is in violation of the licensing provisions of the

act.

The board registers only individuals; a business entity,

incorporated or otherwise, acquires its engineering legitimacy only

through the registration of an individual, who is held responsible for

the engineering work done on behalf of the entity. We therefore

answer your question 2(b) in the affirmative.

We answer your question 2(c) simply by stating that the act

confers broad powers on the board. The principal duty of the board is

to protect the public; if, in the opinion of the board, such a

certification could tend to mislead the public, the registration could

be withheld.

SUMMARY

The Texas Engineering Practice Act, article

3271a. V.T.C.S.. does not exempt persons employed

in industry as 'engineersfrom the operation of the

act; industry certification of an employee as an

engineering specialist falls within the scope of

the act.

MARK WHITE

Attorney General of Texas

JOHN W. FAINTER, JR.

First Assistant Attorney General

RICHARD E. GRAY III

Executive Assistant Attorney General

Prepared by Robert W. Gauss

Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE

Susan L. Garrison, Chairman

Jon Bible

Robert W. Gauss

Rick~Gilpin

Jim Moellinger

p. 1309

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.