Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1988
Status
Published
On the bench
Jim Mattox
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Honorable Tom O'Connell Opinion Wo. JR-861

Criminal District Attorney

Collin County Courthouse Re: Whether employment as a

McKinney, Texas 75069 substitute teacher consti-

tutes continuous employment

under the nepotism statute,

article 5996a, V.T.C.S.

(RQ-1261).

Dear Hr. O'Connell:

you ask about the application of the nepotism law to

a specific situation. You explain that a teacher was

employed full-time for the school years 1978-1979,

1979-1980 and 1981-1982. The teacher resigned in the

spring of 1982 and her name was placed on the substitute

list. She served intermittently as a substitute teacher

until January of 1987 and then worked as a part-time

teacher for the remainder of the school year. In

September, 1987, she began work as a full-time teacher and

continues in that capacity. The teacher's spouse was

elected to the school board of trustees in April, 1904,

and continues to serve on that board.

The question is whether the teachergs service as a

substitute satisfies the continuous employment exception

to the general prohibition of nepotism found in article

5996a, V.T.C.S.

At the time that the spouse was elected to the school

board, article 5996a read as follows:1

No officer of . . . any . . . school dis-

trict . . . shall appoint, or vote for, or

Under a 1987 amendment, the requisite length of

prior iiployment is only six months if the officer is

elected at an election other than the general election for

state and county offices.' m Acts 1987, 70th Leg., ch.

427, 51, at 3958-59. That change, however, does not affect

the result in this opinion.

p. 4176

Honorable Tom O'Connell - Page 2 (JM-861)

1

confirm the appointment to any office, posi-

tion, clerkship, employment or duty, of any

person related within the second degree by

affinity. . [Plrovided, that nothing

herein con;ain;d . . . shall prevent the

appointment, voting for, or confirmation of

any person who shall have been continuously

employed in any such office, position,

clerkship, employment or duty for a period

of two (2) years prior to . . . the election

or appointment of the officer or member

related to such employee in the prohibited

degree.

Acts 1951, 52d Leg., ch. 97, 51, at 159.

This article applies to school board trustees and to

the employment of teachers. Attorney General Opinion Nos.

JM-636 (1987); 374-371 (1985); O-6259 (1945).

The spouse of an officer to whom the nepotism statute

applies is related within the first degree of affinity.

.- Attorney General Opinion V-785 (1949); see also Attorney I

General Opinion Nos. JW-371 (1985); H-993 (1971).

The information provided to us indicates that the

teacher resigned her employment as a full-time teacher and

her name was added to a list of persons available to serve

as substitute teachers. As we understand it, having one's

name put on this "substitute list" creates neither a

guarantee of being contacted by the school district to

serve as a substitute teacher, nor an obligation to accept

a teaching assignment if offered one. The teacher about

whom you inquire was not a party to any continuing

contract.

We distinguish the current situation from that of a

school district auditor. In Attorney. General Opinion

JW-45 (1983) this office found that if a school district

auditor was continuously under contract for two consecu-

tive years prior to the election of his first cousin to

the school board, the auditor could continue his employ-

ment for the school board after his cousin took office.

/- The auditor, like the substitute teacher, was performing

services on a periodic basis, but, unlike the substitute

teacher, the auditor was employed by the school district

by virtue of his contract.

h

The substitute teacher's status is more analogous to

that of a court-appointed attorney. In &an v. State, 691

S.W.Zd 773 (Tex. APP. - El Paso 1985, pet. ref'd), the

p. 4177

Honorable Tom O'Connell - Page 3 (JM-861)

court found that repeated appointments to represent

indigent clients did not constitute continuous employment:

but rather that "[e]ach appointment represents a marate

employment." & at 775 (emphasis added). The same is

true in this instance. The employment relationship does

not exist until the school district offers temporary work

to someone on the list of available substitutes, and the

person accepts the assignment.2

Therefore, based on the fact that the teacher was not

continuously employed for two years before her spouse was

elected to the board but served periodically ona sub-

stitute basis, the two year continuous prior employment

provision was not triggered. In our opinion, her employ-

ment as either a full-time, a part-time, or a substitute

teacher by the school district during her spouse88 tenure

on the school board violates the nepotism statute.

SUMMARY

Service as a substitute teacher does

not constitute continuous employment under

the provision of the nepotism statute which

Ip

allows continued employment of a person

related within the prohibited degree to a

school board member.

J )h

Very truly y0 ,

4

JIM MATTOX -~

Attorney General of Texas

MARYKRLLER

First Assistant Attorney General

mu nCcREARY

Executive Assistant Attorney General

2. Hence, when the teacher changed from substitute

teaching to part-time teaching in January 1987, she did

not terminate her employment in order to come within the

- exception to the nepotism statute found in section 2 of

article 5996g, V.T.C.S.

p. 4178

Honorable Tom O'Connell - Page 4 (34-861)

JUDGE ZOLLIE STEAKLJZY

Special Assistant Attorney General

RICK GILPIN

Chairman, Opinion Committee

Prepared by Karen C. Gladney

Assistant Attorney General

p. 4179

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.