Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1988
Status
Published
On the bench
Jim Mattox
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

OF TEXAS

Auqust 17, 1988

Honorable Andy J. McMullen Opinion Ro. Jr+940

District Attorney

Hamilton County Re: whether a contract for

P. 0. Box 706 services of a construction

Hamilton, Texas 76531 management consultant '

excepted from competiti.::

bidding requirements of

section 21.901 of the Texas

Education Code (RQ-1335)

Dear Mr. McMullen:

You inform us that a school district undergoing rapid

growth seeks to employ a construction management consultant

to advise the district on numerous construction projects.

You add that the consultant is also a general contractor

that has performed or is performing work for the district in

its capac~ity as general contractor. You ask whether a

contract for the services of a construction management

consultant is excepted from the competitive bidding require-

ments of section 21.901 of the Texas Education Code as a

contract for ggprofessional services." We conclude that it

is exempted from the competitive bidding requirement.

Section 21.901 of the Education Code provides the

following in pertinent part:

(b) Except as provided in Subsection (e)

of this section, all contracts proposed to be

made by any Texas public school board for the

construction, maintenance, repair or renova-

tion of any building or for materials used in

said construction, maintenance, repair or

renovation, shall be submitted to competitive

bidding when said contracts are valued at

$5,000 or more.

(c) Nothing in this section shall apply to

fees received for professional services

rendered, including but not limited to

p. 4725

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 2 (JM-940)

architect#s fees, attorney's fees, and fees

for fiscal agents.

. . . .

(e) If a school building or school equip-

ment is destroyed or severely damaged, and

the school board determines that the time

delay posed by the competitive bidding

process would prevent or substantially impair

the conduct of classes or other essential

school activities, then contracts for the

replacement or repair of such building or

equipment may be made without resort to

competitive bidding as otherwise required by

this section.

Subchapter B of chapter 271 of the Local Government Code

provides competitive bidding procedures for contracts

awarded by common or independent school districts for the

construction, repair, or renovation of structures requiring

an expenditure of more than $10,000 from the funds of the

district. Local Gov't Code § 271.024. Contracts that must

be awarded under the terms of the Professional Services

Procurement Act, V.T.C.S. art. 664-4, are exempted from

these procedures. ra. 5 271.022. Article 664-4 requires

contracts for the professional services of licensed physi-

cians, optometrists, surgeons, architects, certified public

acountants, or registered engineers to be awarded primarily

on the basis of demonstrated competence and qualifications.

You describe the duties of the construction management

consultant as follows:

The overall function of a construction

management consultant is to control time and

cost on behalf of the owner/school district

during the construction process. In this

regard his duties include without limitation:

(1) establishing a project budget; (2) pre-

qualifying and interviewing architectural and

engineering firms and advising the owner/

school district on the final architect/

engineer selection: (3) organizing the

design phase of the project: (4) establish-

ing a project schedule from design through to

completion of the construction: (5) advising

and consulting with the owner/school district

on materials, construction methods, and the

arrangement of the construction contract

p. 4726

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 3 (Jw940)

package; (6) managing the bidding and

negotiation process: (7) handling contract

awards: (8) providing coordination among the

various specialty contractors: (9) supervis-

ing the work; and (10) establishing the

project's accounting system. In essence the

construction management consultant accepts

managing responsibility of the entire con-

struction process from desi through to the

completion of construction. 9"

You do not indicate whether it is intended that the con-

struction management consultant will serve as the prime

contractor or subcontractor on any project covered by the

consulting contract.

Section 21.907 does not define the phrase *profes-

sional services." The courts have not adopted a universal

definition of the term: however, several cases suggest that

it comprehends labor and skill,that is "predominantly mental

or intellectual, rather than physical or manual." FI rvland

C ualtv Co. v. Crazv Water Co. I 160 S.W.Zd 102 (Tex? Civ.

A;;. - Eastland 1942, no writ). It no longer includes only

the services of lawyers, physicians, or theologians, but

also those members of disciplines requiring special

knowledge or attainment and a high order of learning, skill,

and intelligence. &S Attorney General Opinion MB-344

(1981); Black's Law Dictionary 1089-90 (5th ed. 1979) (defi-

nition of l'professionn).

Section 21.901(c) is a narrow exception to the strong

public policy favoring competitive bidding on contracts

involving the expenditure of public funds. Its purpose is

to permit a school district to obtain the professional

services of the most competent and experienced individuals

available. & Attorney General Opinion MB-342 (1981) and

cases cited therein. This purpose would be thwarted if the

district was required to award contracts for professional

services to the lowest, and possibly least qualified,

bidders. & Another reason for dispensing with competi-

tive bidding is that professional services, unlike con-

struction work and materials, can seldom be measured with

objective criteria. Since construction. work and materials

1. We assume that the school district does not intend

to delegate the power to make final decisions to a con-

sultant. $&g.9Attorney General Opinion JM-932 (1988).

p. 4727

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 4 (JM-940)

must conform to specifications of the school district's

choosing, it is reasonable to award contracts for such work

or materials on the basis of the lowest responsible bid.

However, with work involving specialized, technical, or

aesthetic judgment, considerations of cost yield to conside-

rations of quality and competence. The legislature has

determined that these concerns warrant a departure from the

strict rule of free competition for public contracts.

Attorney General Opinions JM-881 (1988); JM-712 (19%

(providing that the legislature may vary policy of strict

competition by providing exceptions to competitive bidding

statute).

We believe that the duties of a construction management

consultant as described in your letter qualify as "profes-

sional services" for the purposes of section 21.901(c).

These duties require a high level of knowledge, experience,

and skill consistent with the standards of professionalism

described above. &,q J. Canterbury, Texas Construction Law

Manual 5 6.10 (1981); MB

)'

v. Metrooolitan Councrl 2:9 N.W.2d 426 441-44: (Minn:

1979) (characterizing &nstruction manaqe;ent services as

professional services). && aeneru G. Hardie, Construc-

tion Contracts and Specifications 34-;5 (1981); R. Meyers,

The New Cont ctual Arranm in'construction Contracts

in the 80ts ::3-118 (1980). We klso note the trend in many

states to except contracts for the services of construction

managers from competitive bidding requirements as either

personal or professional services. Sns: State v. Brown 422

N.E.Zd 1254 (Ind. Ct. App. 1981); M naiovi v. Doerner: 546

P.2d 1110 (Or. Ct. App. 1976); Ohio iev. Code Ann. 0 307.86

(Baldwin 1985).

In Attorney General Opinion NW-530 (1982) this office

concluded that a contract for the services of a construction

manager were within the l'personal services" exception to the

competitive bidding requirement of article 2368a, V.T.C.S.

That statute, now chapter 252 of the Local Government Code,

excepted contracts for **personal or professional services"

from competitive bidding requirements imposed by the

statute. The duties of the construction manager were to

include representing, advising, and consulting with the

county procuring his services, ,coordinatinq and overseeing

the work of contractors, and making recommendations con-

cerning the payment of contractors. The attorney general

determined that because these services involved the

personal, intellectual or manual labor of an individual,

they constituted "personal services" within the meaning of

the statute. It was therefore unnecessary to consider

whether such services also constituted "professional

p, 4728

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 5 m-940)

h

servicesH for the purposes of the exception to competitive

bidding. However, the opinion quoted a passage from hunter

v Whiteaker & Wa hinat= 230 S.W. 1096 (Tex. Civ. App. -

San Antonio 1921.,swrit rek'd) stating reasons for exempting

certain contracts from the co;petitive bidding process. The

same passage was quoted in Attorney General Opinion MW-342

(1981) as the rationale behind the wprofessional services"

exception to section 21.901. Thus, it appears that through

identical reasoning construction man;r;;i:sservices may be

characterized either as "personal n under chapter

252 of the Local Government Code or "professional servicesnt

under section 21.901 of the Education Code. See a&g 64 Am.

Jur. 2d e f 43 (equating profes-

sional services with personal services).

Earlier in this opinion, we observed that your descrip-

tion of the duties of a construction management consultant

did not indicate whether the consultant would also serve as

the prime contractor or subcontractor on any construction

project covered by the consulting contract. We will now

discuss the significance of that issue.

Attorney General Opinion JM-282 (1984) concerned the

use of construction management contracts by state universi-

ties. The facts provided to us stipulated that general

contracting firms were invited to submit bids for the

construction of a project based on only a general descrip-

tion of the project and were asked to include hourly rates

for consulting services, in their bids. The consulting

services consisted of preliminary work with the designers of

the construction project, the preparation of cost estimates

for the project, the designation of work to be performed by

subcontractors, and the invitation and acceptance of sub-

contract bids. The construction manager/contractor was

allowed to designate the work it would perform, or the

university could require it to perform preliminary construc-

tion work. At the close of the design phase and preliminary

construction phase of the project, the contractor would

submit a guaranteed maximum price for the remainder of the

project. The university could reject the guaranteed maximum

price and pay the contractor only for the consulting

services, or it could accept the price and authorize the

contractor to proceed with construction.

Section 51.907 of the Education Code provides that

contracts for the construction or erection

improvements at institutions of higher educat% %manent

void

unless they are made pursuant to the competitive bidding

procedures authorized therein. After drawing a distinction

between contracts for construction and contracts for the

p. 4729

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 6 m-940)

planning or design of a construction project, we concluded

that work done prior to the time a decision is made about

who will perform actual construction consists of profes-

sional or consultant services not governed by section

51.907. Contracts for such pre-construction services are

governed by either article 664-4, V.T.C.S., or article

6252-llc, V.T.C.S., which concerns the employment of private

consultants by state agencies. Neither statute authorizes

competitive bidding; the latter, however, requires an agency

to publicly invite offers for consulting services if the

consulting contract may be valued in excess of $10,006.

The opinion went on to address the issue of authorizing

the construction manager to perform construction work on the

same project for which it provided pre-construction services

without resort to competitive bidding. We answered in the

negative, taking note that section 51.907 voids contracts

for construction work not let in response to sealed competi-

tive bids. We also sounded the following caution:

Beyond that, in our opinion, a contractor

who has acted as a consultant for a uni-

versity in the design of a facility, the

estimation of its costs, or the preparation

of the specifications therefor, is dis-

qualified from bidding on the resulting

construction contract. The Texas Supreme

Court, in Texas Hiahwav Commission v. Texas

Association of Steel INporters. Inc [372

S.W.Zd 525 (Tex. 1963)], adopted the &lana-

tion of Texas competitive bidding statutes

given in Sterrett v. Bell [240 S.W.2d 516

(Tex. Civ. App. - Dallas'1951, no writ)],

saying the purpose and intent of such

statutes were well stated there. In part,

the Sterrett court said competitive bidding

'requires that all bidders be placed upon the

same plane of equality.' 240 S.W.2d at 520.

It also said the purpose of such a statute,

among other things, was to 'prevent

favoritism,' and '[t]hat there can be no

competitive bidding in a legal sense where

the terms of the letting of the contract

prevent or restrict competition, [or] favor a

contractor or materialman . . . .' &

A potential bidder is undoubtedly put in a

favored position over other potential bidders

if he drafts the specifications of the job to

be let or participates in the design and

p. 4730

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 7 (JN-940)

cost-estimating decisions of the owner. All

bidders are not placed on the same plane of

equality. In our opinion, such dual activi-

ties create a conflict of intersts as well.

Attorney General Opinion JM-282 (1984) at 8. We closed the

opinion by observing that a construction management consul-

tant was at least within the spirit, if not the letter, of

article 6252-9b, V.T.C.S., which announces a policy forbid-

ding state officers or employees to hold any interest,

financial or otherwise, direct or indirect, that is in

substantial conflict with the proper discharge of their

duties.

Me believe similar words of caution are warranted here.

Because the construction management consultant will be

responsible for the preparation or coordination of informa-

tion necessary to formulate bid specifications, h, pro-

ject costs and design requirements, it will enjoy an over-

whelming advantage over all other potential bidders for the

general contract. Furthermore, since the consultant will

manage the bidding and negotiation process, it will know

what its competitors* bids are, thereby permitting it to

submit a lower bid. Me therefore conclude that the con-

struction management consultant described in your letter

would be disqualified from bidding on any contract for the

construction of a project for which it serves as consultant

to the school district.

SUMMARY

A contract for the services of a construc-

tion management consultant is excepted from

competitive bidding by section 21.907(c) of

the Texas Education Code as a contract for

llprofessional seNices." Contracts for the

construction of projects subject to the con-

sulting contract must be submitted to com-

petitive bidding in accordance with section

21.907. A contractor is disqualified from

bidding on a contract for the construction of

a project for which it serves as construction

management consultant to a school district.

p. 4731

Honorable Andy J. McMullen - Page 8 (JM-940)

JIM MATTOX

Attorney General of Texas

MARYXRUER

First Assistant Attorney General

Lou MCCREARY

Executive Assistant Attorney General

JUDGE ZOLLIE STEAXLEY

Special Assistant Attorney General

RICX GILPIN

Chairman, Opinion Committee

Prepared by Steve Araqon

Assistant Attorney General

p. 4732

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.