Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1989
Status
Published
On the bench
Jim Mattox
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner Opinion No. JM-1051

Chairman

public Education Committee Re: A school district's

Texas House of Representatives use of local funds for

P. 0. Box 2910 career ladder payments

Capitol Building, Room 302D (RQ-1687)

Austin, Texas 78768-2910

Dear Ms. Glossbrenner:

You ask:

If the state allotment designated for

support of the career ladder (Section 16.158,

Education Code) will not fully fund the

career ladder supplements, can a school

district use monies generated locally to

allow the school district to meet the

payments for career ladder levels 2, 3~, and 4

of $2,000, ~$4,000, and ,$6,000 respectively

(Section 16.057, Education Code), without

implementing stricter local performance cri-

teria?

Chapter 13, subchapter E, of the Education Code pro-

vides for the assignment of each public school teacher to

one of four career ladder levels based on performance,

experience, job-related education, advanced academic

training and job assignments. Section 16.057 provides for

the supplementing of salaries of teachers at career ladder

levels two through four as follows:

(a) Except as provided by Subsection (c)

of this section, each teacher on level two,

three, or four of a career ladder is entitled

to the following annual supplement in

addition to the minimum salary set by this

subchapter:

Level 2 . . . . . . . . . . $2,000

Level 3 . . . . . . . . . . $4,000

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 2 (JM-1051)

Level 4 . . . . . . . . . . $6,000

(b) If the district pays more than the

state minimum salary prescribed by this

subchapter, the teacher is entitled to the

career ladder supplements in addition to the

amount otherwise paid by the district for the

teacher's step.

(cl If the allotment under Section 16.158

of this code that is designated for support

of the career ladder will not fully fund the

supplements under this section:

(1) the district may reduce the

supplements to not less than the

following:

Level 2 . . . . . . . . . . $1,500

Level 3 . . . . . . . . . . $3,000

Level 4 . . . . . . . . . . $4,500

or;

(2) provide for stricter performance

criteria than that provided under Section

13.302 of this code, subject to the

approval of,the State Board of Education:

or

(3) take action under both Subdivi-

sions (1) and (2) of this subsection.

Section 16.158 provides for q'allotments" to fund the

career ladder supplements as follows:

(a) Each district is entitled to an al-

lotment for education improvement and support

of the career ladder equal to its unadjusted

average daily attendance multiplied by the

following amount or a greater amount provided

by appropriation:

(1) $100 for the 1984-1985 school

year:

(2) $120 for the 1985-1986 school

year: and

P. 5464

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 3 (JM-1051)

(3) $140 for the 1986-1987 school

year and each school year thereafter.

(b) A district may expend 25 percent of

the allotment for any legal purpose, shall

expend 25 percent of the allotment for

payment of salaries for personnel other than

classroom teachers, and shall expend 50

percent of the allotment for career ladder

salary supplements.

(b-l) Expired.

(c) From the funds designated for that

purpose, the, ,district shall supplement the

salary of each teacher above level one on the

career ladder. The district shall decide the

amount of supplement to be provided at each

career ladder level.

(d) Money received under this section may

not be used to supplement the salary of an

employee for directing cocurricular or extra-

curricular activities.

The funding of the career ladder supplements is a part

of the Foundation School Program established under chapter

16 of the Education Code. The purpose of the Foundation

School Program is to "guarantee that each school district in

the state has 'adequate resources to provide each eligible

student a basic instructional program suitable to his

educational needs." Educ. Code 5 16.002. Section 16.051

provides that in order to receive financial support from the

Foundation School Fund, school districts must comply with

the standards set out in subchapter B of chapter 16

including the provisions of section 16.057, quoted above,

providing for career ladder supplements.

In your question; in which you ask about courses of

action available to a school district where the "state

allotment designated for support of the career ladder

(Section 16.158, Education Code) will not fully fund the

career ladder supplements," we presume that by "state

allotment" you mean the 50% of the "allotment for education

improvement and support of the career ladder," which

P. 5465

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 4 (JM-1051)

subsection (b) of section 16.158 provides shall be expended

for career ladder supplements.1

Section 16.057(a) sets out specific dollar amounts to

which teachers at career ladder levels two, three, and four

are entitled. We understand you to ask whether section

16.057(c), quoted above, provides the exclusive alternatives

available to a district when the section 16.158 allotment

is insufficient to pay the supplements or whether a district

may use other available funds to pay the salary supplements.

We do not think that subsection (c) was intended to prohibit

a district from paying the supplements out of other

available funds.

Subsection (a) states that teachers are entitled to

specific supplement amounts except in the instance of an

insufficient allotment. Subsection (c) provides for

reduced supplement amounts and for stricter performance

criteria for supplement eligibility. We read the reference

to the insufficiency of the allotment as a prerequisite to

the availability of the alternatives set out in subsection

Cc)- In other words, we think that the express meaning of

subsections (a) and (c) is that a district is without

authority, other than as provided in subsection (c), to

lower the amount of the supplements or to raise the criteria

for receiving the supplements. We do not find any language

in these provisions that prohibits the use of other

available funds to pay the supplement.

'Several factors support our reading of section

16.057(c). First, nothing else in the controlling statutes

suggests that a district may not use available money other

than allotment money to pay the supplements. Substantially

all of the controlling provisions were enacted as part of

House Bill 72. Acts 1984, 67th Leg., 2d C.S., ch. 28, at

117. The provisions of subsection (c) of section 16.057,

which are in question here, were added to the language of

that bill only after it already contained substantially all

of the other provisions discussed. See Bill file, House

1. See Educ. Code 55 16.251, 16.252, 16.254; see also

Acts 1987, 70th Leg., 2d C.S., ch. 78, art. III, 5 1, at

632.

P. 5466

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 5 (JM-10513

Bill 72, 67th Leg., 2d C.S. (1984).2 If the addition of

subsection (c) were intended to limit the use of other

funds, we think the legislature would have expressed that

intent.

Moreover, we think that construing subsection (c) to

reouire districts, whose allotments are insufficient to meet

the subsection (a) supplements, to either lower the supple-

ment, raise performance criteria, or both, without leaving

them the option of making up the subsection (a) supplement

amounts with non-allotment monies, would be contrary both to

the purpose of the career ladder program, which is~ to

improve teaching quality by providing monetary incentives to

more qualified and better performing teachers, and to the

overall spirit of House Bill 72.

You do not ask and we do not address in detail what

kinds of "monies generated locally" might be lawfully used

to help fund the district's career ladder supplements. We

do note that section 16.253, for example, provides in part

that "local maintenance funds in excess of the amount

assigned to a district may be expended for any lawful school

purpose.1' See also Educ. Code 5 20.48.

A brief 'submitted by the Texas Education Agency3 in

response to your request notes that an administrative rule

adopted~ by the agency, 19 T.A.C. 5 149.71(l)(4), would limit

the use of other available funds for the section 16.057

supplements.

In the event that funds designated as the

allotment for career ladder salary supple-

ments are deemed insufficient for placement

2. Hence, the language in section 16.158(c) providing

in part that "the district shall decide the amount of

supplement to be provided at each career ladder level,"

which language was in both the'original bill as introduced

and in the enacted version, must be read in light of the

later added supplement provisions of section 16.057.

3. The Texas Education Agency is generally referred to

by statute as the Central Education Agency. It includes,

inter alia, the State Board of Education and the State

Commissioner of Education. See, e.a., Educ. Code 5 11.01 &

u.

P. 5467

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 6 (JM-1051)

and/or maintenance of all teachers meeting

the state-mandated minimum criteria for

selection and/or maintenance on the teacher

career ladder, the local district may fund

additional career ladder salary supplements

from local or other funds permitted by law

and State Board of Education rules effective

with the 1985-1986 school year, provided that

the following requirements have been met:

(A) that funds available for any legal

purpose in accordance with the Texas

Education Code, 516.158, have been fully

exhausted in the payment of teacher career

ladder salary supplements; and

(B) that the local school district

demonstrates its intent to utilize career

ladder supplements as a means of identi-

fying and rewarding excellence in teacher

performance as opposed to a salary

supplement for all teachers meeting the

minimum requirements by establishing in

written policy one or more requirements

for stricter performance as specified in

subsection (e) of this section.

Subpart (B) of the provision appears to require that

before local funding may be used to make up a deficiency in

the section 16.158 allotment for the career ladder supple-

ments, a district must establish one 'or more requirements

for stricter performance criteria. See also 19 T.A.C.

5 149.71(e). We think that to the extent that the Texas

Education Agency's'rule makes mandatory the establishment of

stricter performance criteria before local funds can be used

to make up a shortfall in the section 16.158 allotment for

the section 16.057, subsection (a), career ladder supple-

ments, the rule exceeds the agency's rule-making authority.

Agency rules must be within the clear intent of the

statute and not in excess of the powers delegated. See.

e.s., Kellv v. Industrial Accident Bd., 358 S.W:2d 874 (Tex.

Civ. App. - Austin 1962, writ ref'd). We find nothing in

the Education Code or elsewhere in state law which empowers

the Texas Education Agency, or its component body, the State

Board of Education, to require stricter performance criteria

in particular districts or particular local situations. See

Educ. Code ch. 13, subch. D (providing for the establishment

of career ladder appraisal procedures and performance

p. 5468

.

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 7 (JM-1051)

criteria by the State Board of Education), 55 13.302(a)

(providing that the board shall adopt an appraisal process

and criteria, and the criteria must be based on "observable,

job-related behavior, including teachers' implementation of

discipline management procedures"), 13.302(c) (providing

that the board shall provide for *Iauniform training program

and uniform certification standards for appraisers to be

used throughout the state"), 13.302(d)(l) (providing that

"the assessment process may be administered by or under the

supervision of the Central Education Agency on a statewide

basis"), 13.304-13.312 (providing for uniform performance

categories, classes of teaching certificates, criteria for

entrance into and maintenance of career ladder levels,

without making any distinctions in such classifications or

criteria based on particular local situations). See also

id. 55 11.24 (board's rule-making authority generally),

16.005 (commissioner of education to administer Foundation

School Program in accordance with board rules). Again,

although section 16.057 provides that local districts may

with state board approval implement stricter performance

criteria under the circumstances set out there, we find

nothing in the agency's statutory rule-making authority

empowering the agency to require particular districts to

implement stricter performance criteria before it uses funds

other than the section 16.058 allotment for salary supple-

ments.

Finally, we note that the Texas Administrative Code, 19

T.A.C. 5 149.71(1)(4)(A), requires that local districts

wishing to use local funds to make up the cost of section

16.057(a) career ladder supplements where the section 16.158

allotment for such is insufficient must first exhaust the

portion of the section 16.158 allotment funds available for

"any legal purpose.'* We find nothing in the statutory

scheme governing the career ladder program which authorizes

the Texas Education Agency to thus restrict the use of local

funds and accordingly conclude that the provisions of

subpart (A) also exceed that agency's statutory rule-making

authority.

SUMMARY

In order to meet the cost of career ladder

supplements in the amounts specified in

Education Code section 16.057, subsection

(a), a school district may, without imple-

menting stricter performance criteria under

chapter 13 of the code, use available local

funds where the allotment for the career

p. 5469

.

Honorable Ernestine V. Glossbrenner - Page 8 (JM-1051)

ladder under section 16.158 is insufficient.

Rules adopted by the Texas Education Agency,

19 T.A.C. 5 149.71(&)(4)(A)-(B), purporting

to require a school district whose section

16.158 allotment is insufficient to first

exhaust section 16.158 funds available for

"any legal purposetl and to establish stricter

performance criteria before using other local

funds to cover the supplement amounts, exceed

that agency's statutory rule-making author-

ity.

JIM MATTOX

Attorney General of Texas

MARY KELLER

First Assistant Attorney General

LCU MCCREARY

Executive Assistant Attorney General

JUDGE ZOLLIE STEAKLEY

Special Assistant Attorney General

RICK GILPIN

Chairman, Opinion Committee

Prepared by William Walker

Assistant Attorney General

p. 5470

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.