Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1992
Status
Published
On the bench
Dan Morales
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

@We of tije Bttornep @eneral

55tate of ‘Qexag

DAN MORALES March 30,1992

.al-r‘,RSEY

CEXERAL

Ms. Georgia Flint Opiion No. DM-100

Acting Commissioner

Texas Department of Insurance Re: Whether an insurance company

P. 0. Box 149104 released from supervision or conserva-

Austin, Texas 78714-9104 torship may deduct from its premium

tax liability fees paid for cost of

rehabilitation (RQ-201)

Dear Commissioner Flint:

Your predecessor as CqnmLsl . ‘oner asked whether fees Texas collected under

se&on 17 of article X28-A of the Insurance Code from an insurer %ehabiIitated”

bytheS~Baoudof~~areallawableasacreditagaiastpremiumtaxes

payable by the insurer under article 4.10 of the Insurance Code.

Article 4.10 requires certain insm-ance axnpanies to pay to the eommisioner

af~fortransmittaltothestatetreasurer,anannualtaxongrosspremium

receipts. Section l3 of article 4.10 of the Insurance Code provides:

Theamountofallexmninationandevaluatkmfeespaidin

eachtaxableyeartoorfortheuse.oftheStateofTexasbyan

insurance carrier shall be allowed as a credit on the amount of

premium taxes due under this article except as provided by

Artide 13 of this code.1 Any credit allowed by the provisions

of this section is in addition to any other credits allowable by

statute. (Emphasis added.)

Artide 21.28-A provides for the mechanisms of “supervision” and “conserva-

tion” of an insurance company determined by the commissioner of insurance 1) to

,be insolvent, 2) in a condition hazardous to the public or its policy holders, 3) to

p. 505

Ms. Georgia Flint - Page 2 (DM-100)

have exceeded its powers or failed to comply with the law, or which has consented to

such supervision or conservation. The purpose of such supervision and conservation

is the preservation of the insurer’s assets and the “rehabilitation” of the insurer. Ins.

Code art. 21.28-A. $ 1. Section 17 of article 21.28-A provides in pertinent part:

The State Board of Insurance may collect fees from any

entity . . . that is successfully rehabilitated by the board. The fees

shall be in amounts sufficient to cover but not to exceed the

costs of rehabilitation of that entity. The board shall use the

fees for the sole purpose of the rehabilitation of the

entity.... Fees collected under this subsection shall be

deposited in and expended through the State Board of Insurance

Operating Fund.

We find nothing in artide 21.28-A or elsewhere in state law specifically

providing ,for the allowance of article 212&A rehabilitation fees as a premium tax

credit The.issue is whether the provision of section l3 of article 4.10 for allowing

*exarmnation

- and evaluation fees” as premium tax. .credits encompasses such

rehabilitation fees. In our opinion, it does not.

*Examinations” are regular inquiries into the “financial condition” of

inrmame companies generally, their “ability. to meet [their] liabilities, as well as

[their] compliance with the laws of Texas.” ins. Code art. l.lS, $1. As such,

examinations are clearly distinct from the article 2128-A procedures of

“supervision” or “conservation” of troubled insurers which give rise to the fees

assessed to cover the cost of rehabilitation which are at issue here. Article 1.04,

section (g). in providing that the state board of insurance may use its own examiners

or engage other persons or firms to perform examinations and that examination

expenses incurred are to be paid by the company, specifically refers to “examination

fees” as allowable credits against a company’s premium tax liability. See &o id art.

1.16 (providing for,the insurance commissioner’s assessment of companies for the

cost of examinations). We think it quite apparent that “examination fees” in article

4.10 refers to fees assessed in connection with “examinations,” not to those fees

arising from the distinct rehabilitative procedures .of supervision and conservation

under article 21.28-A.

The scope of the term “evaluation fees” as used in article 4.10, section 13, is

more problematic. Notably, when first adopted in 1951 as part of article 7064,

V.T.CS., the provision, otherwise virtually identical to the current one, read

P. 506

Ms. Georgia Flint - .Page 3 (DM-100)

“valuation” rather than “evaluation.” Acts 1951,52d Leg., ch. 402, 5 XV, at 711-12.

The bill transferring article 7064 to the Insurance Code in 1981 continued to use the

term %aluation.” Acts 1981,67th Leg., ch. 389, § 36, at 1782. However a separate

1981 bill amending article 7064 changed the word to “evaluation.” Acts 1981, 67th

Leg., ch. 844, at 3214 (the latter bill as introduced had used the word “valuation;”

but the committee substitute which was adopted used “evaluation”). We find

nothing in the legislative history indicating what, if any, substantive change was

intended by the 1981 change from “valuation” to “evaluation.” Conzpare Ins. Code

art. 4.11, § 8 (providing that “examination and v&arion fees paid” by life, health and

accident insurance companies are creditable against their premium taxes). See

gene&& Attorney General Opinions V-1003 (1950); V-967 (1949) (provisions for

“examination and valuation fee” credit against premium taxes for life, accident and

health insurance cornpan@ under former article 7064a, now in article 4.11 of the

Insm-auee Code).

It appears that the process of examining an insurance company% %nancial

condition and its ability to meet its liabilities,!! Ins.Code art. 1.15.8 1; see supm p. 2,

itself entails “valuation” or “evaluation” of their assets. Sections 1 and 2 of artide

LlS, spedfically refer to the board’s determining the “value. Or “market value” of

certain company assets as pait of a examination. It may be that the “valuation” or

“evaluation” fees referred to in the provisions of section 13 of artide 4.10 as

aIIowable premium tax credits are simply those portions of “examination fees”

attriitable to the valuation component of examinations.2

We do not think it necessary however, to determine here exactly what the

reference in section l3 of a+cle 4.10 to ?aluation”- or “evaluation” fees encom-

passes, sii~ce it does not appear to relate to rehabilitation fees assessed under article

2128-J& section 17.

Websiers defines “evaluate” as “to determine or fix the value of,” and

“vah~tion,” similarly as “the estimated or determined market valud of a thing?

WJBSTER’S NINTH NEW COL.LE@TE DICTIONARY 429,1303 (1987). The rehabil-

itative procedures of supervision and conservation imposed on troubled insurance

%e note that seaion A(28) of article4.07 authcirizcsthe State Board of Insurance to charge a

510 fee ‘for vaIuingpolicies of lie insurance, and for each one million of insurance or fradion thereof..

It would “f appear hov+ver that kvaluation feb” in article 4.10, se&on l3, refers to this article 4.07

fee, since article4.10 does not apply to life itiuranee companies. See Ins. Code art. 4.10,§ 2; see ~zlso

id. M. 3.28 (annual valuation of life insurancecompany resewes).

P. 507

Ms. Georgia Phnt - Page 4 (DK-100)

companies by the commissioner of insurance under article 21.28-A involve

substantiahy more than “valuation” or “evaluation.” When a company is placed

under supervision, the commissioner may appoint a “supervisor” and may require

that various actions of the company - for example, conveyances, investments,

lending, borrowing, mergers, cancellation of policies - be taken only with the

approval of the commissioner or the supervisor. The commissioner may require the

company to comply with “lawful orders” of the commissioner within a specified time.

Ins. Code art. 21.28-A, $5 3, 4. If the commissioner determines that supervision is

inadequate to accomplish the company’s rehabilitation, he may appoint a

conservator, through whom to “operate” the company. The conservator may “take

all necessary measures to preserve, protect, and recover any assets” of the company

and may, with the approval of the commissioner reinsure the company’s policies,

transfer company reserves to the reinsuring company. Id 8 5. If rehabilitated “the

company may be returned to management or new management” under appropriate

COllditiOItS.Id $9. Section 5, similarly to section 17. provides for the

commissioner’s assessing against the assets of the rehabiitated confpany “[t]he cost

incident to the snpetvisor’s and conservator’s service: Id 0 5.

The legislature could not have had artide 212&A rehabilitation costs in

mind when it fhst adopted in 1951 the provisions now in artide 4.10 for the tax

credit for “examination and vahtation fees” since the provisions of artide 2128-A

induding that in section 5 for asses@ companies’ the “cost incident to the

supervisor’s and conservator’s set~Ice,~ were first enacted only in 1967. Acts 1967,

60th Leg., ch. 281. The specific provisions of section 17 of that article for the

connnissioners assessing rehabiitated companies’ “fees.. . to cover. _ _the costs of

rehabilitation” were not adopted until 1989. Acts 1989,71st Leg., ch. 1082, at 4387.

Nor do we think that in adopting the provisions of article 21.28-A, the legislature

would have considered the rehabilitative procedures there provided for to be within

the scope of the word “valuation” or “evaluation.” If the legislature had intended

that artide 21.2&A rehabilitation fees be creditable against premium taxes, we

thii it likely that it would have specifically soindicated. Compare Acts 1957,55th

Le& ch. 499, at 1457 (section (g) of article 1.04 of the Insurance Code specifically

providing that examination costs paid by a. company directly to private persons or

firms are allowable as tax credits “just as examination fees are credited when the

Board uses its own salaried examiners”).

In support of our conclusion that article 21.2&A rehabilitation fees are not

allowable as premium tax credits under section ~13of artide 4.10. we note that you

say that it has been the administrative practice of the .board, since the adoption in

P- 508

Ms. Georgia Flint - Page 5 (DM-100)

1967 of the article 21.28-A provisions for the commissioner’s assessing rehabilitation

costs, to disallow them as premium tax credits. Courts ordinarily give considerable

deference to the construction placed on laws by the agency charged with their

administration, particularly where the construction has been a long standing one.

See 67 TEX. JUR. 3d Srorutes g 155 (1989).

SUMMARY

Rehabilitation fees assessed insurance companies rehabili-

tated by the State Board of Insurance under article 21.28-A of

the Insurance Code are not within the premium tax credit

allowed by Insurance Code article 4.10, section 13 for

“examination and evaluation fees.”

DAN MORALES

Attorney General of Texas

WILLPRYOR

First Assistant Attorney General

MARYKELLER

Deputy As&ant Attorney General

JUDGEZOLLIE STEAKLEY (Ret.)

Special Assistant Attorney General

RENEAHIcKs

Special Assistant Attorney General

MADELEINE B. JOHNSON

Chair, Opinion Committee

Prepared by William Walker

Assistant Attorney General

p. 509

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.