Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 1993
Status
Published
On the bench
Dan Morales
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

QBfficeof tiy !Zlttornep Qkneral

6btate of aexas

DAN MORALES March 17,1993

ATTORNEY

GmErw.

Honorable John W. Segrest OpinionNo. DM-208

CriminalDistrict Attorney

McLulMncounty Re: Whether a person related to a district

219 North Sii Street, Suite 200 judge within the degree prohibited by the

Waco, Texas 76701 nepotism statute, V.T.C.S. article 5996a, can

take employment with a community super-

vision and corrections department without

causing a violation of the nepotism statute in

light of the provisions of article 42.131 of

the Code of CriminalProcedure (RQ-473)

Dear Mr. segrest:

You have asked us to determine whether, in light of the provisions of the Code of

Crimind FVocedure article 42.131, the director of a community supervision and

cmrections department may hire, without causing a violation of the state nepotism statute,

V.T.C.S. article 5996a, a person related to a district judge who sits in the same county as

the community supervision and corrections department. Your question is based on the

following facts:

1. McLawncountyhasfwrdisbictcourts,...eachofwhich

can be considered as “trying uiminal cases” in th[e] judicial

diStZiCt;

2. On January 1, 1987, one district judge took office after his

election the previous November, and continues to serve to this

date;

3 On SeptemLxr 12. 1988, all of the judges appointed

[a] . . Director [of the community supervision and correction

department in McLennsn County], a position [the same person]

holds to this date;

. . . .

5. OnMayl. l99o,theDirectorhiredthermployeeinquestion;

6. The Employee is a nephew of the Judge, being the son of the

Judge’s natural brother, and is thus related within the third

degree of consanguinity.

p. 1092

Honorable John W. Segrest - Page 2 (~~-208)

We undemtand that you have rewived wntlicting opinio* one from the general counsel

oftheTexa,DepartmentofCriminalJusticeandonefrom~attonyrwtrOhs

representedMcLuman County in civil matters,on whether the directo~‘shiring of the

judge’s nephew constitutes a nepotistic hiring. We wnchxle that the hiring is not

llt@StiC.

Section l(a) of the nepotism statute, V.T.C.S. article %%a, states in pert&m

palt as fbllowa:

[n]o officer. . . of any. . . rmuricipal subdivision of this State, nor

anyofficerormemberofanyStatedistrict,wunty,city,...orother

~~~board,orjudgeofanycourt,cnatedbyorundaauthority

of any General or Special Law of this Stat% . . . shall appoint. or vote

for, or confirm the appointment to any office, positioq clerkship,

employment or duty, of any person reJated...within the third

degreebywnsqhity, asdetermined under Article 5996h, Revised

Statutes, to the person so appointing or so voting. or to any other

manbaoflllly~~board,...ofwtrichsuchpasonsoappointing

or voting may be a memk, when the salary, fees, or compensation

of such appointee is to be paid for, directly or indktiy, out of or

fkompublicfimds.. . ofany kind or charactexwhatsoeva.

By its terms, section l(a) applies only to officers or judges who have actual, statutory

authority to hire PCfSOMCt. Attomey General Opiion DIM-163(1992) at 1. A person

with such authority does not, even if the person attempts to delegate the authority to

another, “abdicate [its] statutory authority or control.” .%e Pena v. Rio Cm& C@Y

f3ansd. In&p. Sch. Disl., 616 S.W.Zd 658.660 (Tar Cii. App.-EasUand 1981, no writ);

Babcock & Collins, Local Government Luw, 36 SW. L.J. 471, 509 (1982) @mmakiq

Penal. Thus, to determinewhethera wmmunity supavision and tions departmmt

(the departmeat) lavAidlymay employ the nephew’of a district judge who tries crimbml

casesintheMmecountyasthedepamnent,wcmustda~hasMuaZ~~~

authority to appoint persod fbr the deparhnmt.

Article 42.131 of the Code of Crimi~I Prowdmx perknstotheestabliAmentof

wmmunity supervision and corrections departments. The article reads in pertinent part as

follows:

Establishmentof Departments

Sec. 2. (a) The...districtjudgestqingcrimimdcasesineach

judicial district in the state shall establish a community supervision

and wrrections department and empky disbicf personnel as mcrybe

necesxq to conduct presentence investigations and risk

p. 1093

Honorable John W. Segrest - Page 3 (Dt+208)

rssessmanq supervise and reh8biuit8teprobatioller& enforce the

terms and wnditions of probatior&and ata wmmunity wrrections

facilities. Both the district judges trying uiminal cases and the

judgesofstaMoryw~wurtstryingcriminalcesesthatare~

by a wmnnurity supewision and wrre-ctions department are entitled

to participate in the mansganent of the department.

. . . .

DepuWent Diir

Sec. 4. The. . . judges shag appoint a department director. i’k

akZ3artmenldirector shall emplv a suficient number of ofjkers and

other employeesIOpe@m the professional and clerical work of the

kprtment. [Emphasisadded.]

Obviously, the emphasizedportions of sections 2 and 4 are inwnsistent: section 2 rewires

the district judges to employ the personnel newssary to perform all of the tasks a

department is to petikm, while section 4 rewires the judges only to appoint a department

director, who, in Turk is rewired to employ all other newssary personnel.

We exam&J a similar statute in Attorney General Opiion DM-79 (1992). Jn that

opinion, we were asked to determine whether the Brazes County Juvenile Board has the

authody to hire employees of the Braws County JuvenileProbation Departmaa at& the

juvenile board has employed a chiefjuvenile probation officer. Attorney General Opinion

DM-79 at 1. Section 152.0007(l) of the Human Resources Code, which de&es the.

duties of the juvenile board, rewires a juvenile board to “employ personnel to wnduct

probation services, including a chief probation 05cer Md, if more than one officer is

neceswy, as&ant officers.” On the other hand, section 152.0008(a) of the. Humsn

Itemmes Code.provides that the chiefjuvenile probation officer “mq appoint wwssaty

personnel with ihe qpraval of he hard’ (Emphasis added.) AdditionaUy, section

152.0271(e) of the Human Resources Code provides that “[t]he chiefjuvenile probation

officer may set the salaries 8nd aUowanccs of juvenile probation persowel with the

qnprcnwIof Ihe &I&..” (Emphasis added.) Given the applicableprovisions of the Human

Resources Code, the requestor was uncertain as to whether the board or the chief

probation officer is rewired to employ other members of the d-t, or if that duty

may vary at the juvenile board’sdiscretion. Id. at 2.

We determined that section lS2.0008(a) delegates to the chiefjuvenile probation

officer the authority to hire assistant juvenile probation officers and other employees

subject to the juvenile board’s approval. Id. Thus, while the juvenile board’s authority

with respect to hiring personnel is limited to approving or rejecting the chief juvenile

probation officefs hiring decisions, it retains the actual authority for hiring personnel. Id.

at 2-3. Section 152.0007(1), which rewires a juvenile board to “employ” personnel,

rewires a juvenile board only to compensate, not to hire, personnel. Id. at 3. These

p. 1094

Honorable John W. Segrest - Page 4 (DM-208)

detenniwtions, together with the juvenile board’8 role under a predecessor at8tute,ledus

to wnchde that the juvenile board, not the chief juvenile prob8tion offices, was the

appointing authody for purpnses of section 152.0008(b) of the Human Rewurws Code,

which empowers the “appointingauthotity’to tamiaatejuvenile probation officers. Id. at

4.

Article 42.131 of tha Code of Ctiminal Pro&me difFhilltWOSiglli6C8Ilt

~~mthe~o~oftheHumanResourcesCodethatwew~daedinAttorney

&nerd Opinion DM-79. Fhst, article 42.13 1, section 4 requires a department director to

employ 05cers and amployws as newssary to perform the de’s profbssional and

clerical work, whereas section,152.0008(a) merely authorizea the chief juvenile probation

officer to hire asktant juvenile probation officers and other employees. Second, article

42.13 1. section 4 does not explicitly reserve to the district judges the pownr to approve

the departmmt directofs employment decisions, whereas section 152.0008(a) requires the

juveade board to approve (or, implicitly, to reject) the chief juvenile probation officer’s

rppo-.

The legislature added article 42.131 to the Code of Ctiminal Pwwdure in 1989.

See Acts 1989, 71st Leg., ch. 785, 8 3.02, at 3483-86. House Bii 2335, the bii that

proposed adding article 42.13 1, made many changes in the structure of the crimiwl justice

systematthe~~locallmlsinane$orttolllleviateprisonudjailovacrowding.

See Sen8te Comm. on Criminal Justice, Bii Analysis, C.S.HB. 2335. 71st Leg. (1989);

Attorney General Opiion JM-1185 (1990) at 1-3. Notably, while Housa Bii 2335 added

article 42.131 to providn for the nstablishment of departmeDts itrcp&dsection100f

&sting article 42.12 of the Code of Criminal Pm&urn, which had ptwided for the

establkhment oflocal probation departments. See Acts 1989,716 Leg., ch. 785,5§ 3.02.

4.17, at 3483, 3519-21; Attorney Gcncral Opinion JM-1131 (1989) at 2. Both the

predecessor local probation departments and the current wnununi@ supnrkion and

wrrections departments were or are designed generally to wtrespond gengraphicagy to

judicial districts. See Code Ctim. Proc. art. 42.12, 5 lo(a) (repealed by Acts 1989, 71st

Log., ch. 785. 54.17, at 3519-21); id. art. 42.131, 52(a); Attorney General Opinion

JM-1131 at 2.

Prior to its rapcal in 1989, section 10 of article 42.12 of the Code of Criminal

Procedure provided in pertinent part as follows:

(a) For the purpose of providing adequate probation satvices,

the...districtjudgestryingcriminalcasesineachjudicialdistria~

this state shall establish a probation office and employ. in accordance

with standads set by the wmmissio~ dislrictpersannel a7 nrqy be

?n?cew to wnduct preswtence inyastigations, supwdsa and

rehdditate probation- and enforce the tetms and wnditions of

misdemeanor and felony probation. . . .

p. 1095

Honombk John W. Segrest - Page 5 (Dn-208)

(b) Where more than one probation officer is required,

the. . . judges shall appoiat a chief adult probation officer or

dimctor,who,tid~2heir~shallappointasu5cientmrmba

ofasshntsandotheremp~oyeestocmTyotttbeprofe.ssion4

Cklical.MdOthWWO&OfthCCOlUt.

Acts 1989,71st Leg., ch. 785.5 4.17, at 3519 (emphasisadded). Under the uow-repeakd

article 42.12. K&M 10 of the Code of CriminalPro&me, the district judges chiy had

authority to appoint a chief adult probation officer or dire&q fiuthermom the district

judges clearly had authority to approve ail of the chief adult probation officeh relections

fixemployment. Whilemuchofthehguageofarticle42.131,aections2aad4ofthe

Code of Criminal ProcAre parallels the. language of the nov+repealed article 42.12,

section lo(a), (II), article 42.13 1, section 4 does not reserve forthdistrictjudgesany

power of approval over the depamneat directoh employmentsehtions.

We musf the&m, ckrify the use of the.word “empl~ in sections 2(a) and 4 of

article42.131 oftbeCodeofCriminalPro&ure. Eachaectionrequiresapatticulara&y

to “employ”personnelto staEthe local dw however,section2(a) obligates the

districtjudgestryingcrimiaal~ineachjudicialdishict,while~w4obligrtesthe

department director, whom the judges have appointed. We no& that SC&M 6(b) of

article42.131 OftheCodeofCrkninalProcedunrequiresthejudi~districts~ncein

services fkom a department to pay the salaries of department petxonnel. In our opinion,

therefore, article 42.131 uses the term “employ”inwnsktently. We believe that “employ”

in the context of section 2(a) refers to the responsibility of the judicial district to

wmpensate departmental personnel.~ See Attorney General Opinion DM-79 at 3

(concluding that “employ”in section 152.0007(1) of the Human Rewurws coderefe!rs

only to providing wmpematioq not to hiring). on the other hand. “employ” in the

context of section 4 refers to the department directoh obligation to hire necesq

pasonnel.

As article 42.13 1 provides the department director, not the district judges, with

actual authority to hire 05cers and other employees newssary to petform the professional

and clerical work of the department, no violation of the nepotism statute occurs if the

department director hires a person related within the third degree of wnsa@nity to one

of the district judges.

p. 1096

Honorable John W. Segrest - Page 6 @M-208)

SUMMARY

Article 42.131 bf the Code of Criminal Frodurerequiresthe

director of a community supervision 6nd wzrections depattment to

hire the officers and other employees wcusary to perfoml the

professional and clerical work of the department. The judges in the

judicial district that the commudy supervision and wrrections

dep&mentservesappointthedirectorbuthavenohrtherauthority

to hire or to approve the directofs hiring of additional department

persod. The word %mpioy,” as used in sections 2(a) and 4 of

article 42.131 of the Code of Criminal procedure. has two dZfemnt

meanings. In the context of section 2(a), “employ” refers to the

responsiiity of the judicial district to wmpensate department

perso~d. However, in the context of section 4. “etnp~oy”refers to

the department director’sobligation to hire necessary personnel.

Because the judges have no authority to hire or approve the

hiring of department persormel other than the director, no vioiation

of the nepotism statute, V.T.C.S. article %%a, section I(a), occurs

ifthedepartmmtdirectorhimsapersonmlatedwithinthethird

degree of wnsanguinity to one of the judges in that judicial district.

DAN MORALES

Attorney General of Texas

WlL.LPRYOR

Fi hsktant Attorney General

MARYKELLER

Deputy Attomey General for Litigation

RBNBA HICKS

State Solicitor

MADELEINE B. JOHNSON

Chair, Opiion Committee

Prepad by Kymberly K. Oltrogge

Assistant Attorney General

p. 1097

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.