Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 2000
Status
Published
On the bench
John Cornyn
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

March 9,200O

Mr. Charles E. McMahen Opinion No. JC-0194

Chair, University of Houston System

Board of Regents Re: Whether the governing board of an

3 100 Cullen Boulevard, Suite 205 institution of higher education may conduct a

Houston, Texas 772046732 meeting by telephone or videoconference call:

Reconsideration of Attorney General Opinion

DM-478 (1998) (RQ-0129-JC)

Dear Mr. McMahen:

You ask whether the governing board of an institution ofhigher education may hold a regular

meeting of the board where a quorum of board members is present at the meeting location, and other

members attend via a telephone or videoconferencing connection. In connection with this question,

you ask us to reconsider Texas Attorney General Opinion DM-478 (1998). We conclude that the

governing board of an institution of higher education may not hold a regular meeting with board

members participating from remote locations except as expressly authorized by the Open Meetings

Act. A governmental body may hold a regular meeting where a quorum is present at one location

and other board members participate by videoconference call if it complies with section 55 1.127 of

the Government Code. The Open Meetings Act does not authorize the board to conduct its regular

meetings by telephone nor does it allow a board member to participate in a regular meeting by

telephone. Attorney General Opinion DM-478 correctly stated the law when issued and has not been

superceded by statute or court decision. Accordingly, we find no basis for altering its conclusions.

You state that the Board of Regents of the University of Houston System would like to hold

regular meetings at which a quorum is present but some members are unable to attend in person.

Letter from Mr. Charles E. McMahen, Chair, University of Houston System Board of Regents, to

Honorable John Comyn, Texas Attorney General (Oct. 8,1999). The absent members would be able

to participate via telephone from a remote location. Id. You ask whether a goveming board may

hold regular meetings with a quorum physically present, and have board members participate in the

meeting by means oftelephonic connections which are audible to the public. In connection with this

question, you ask us to reconsider Attorney General Opinion DM-478, which concluded that the

governing body of an institution ofhigher education was not authorized to conduct a regular meeting

by telephone conference call. Tex. Att’y Gen. Op. No. DM-478 (1998) at 4.

The Open Meetings Act (the “Act”), TEX. GOV’T CODE ANN. ch. 55 1 (Vernon 1994 & Supp.

2000), includes several provisions that authorize members of a governmental body to participate

in meetings using telephone or videoconference connections. See TEX. GOV’T CODE ANN.

Mr. Charles E. McMahen - Page 2 (X-0194)

$8 551.121-551.127 (Vernon 1994 & Supp. 2000). Before these provisions were adopted, the Act

did not permit governmental bodies to meet by telephone or videoconference call, nor did it

authorize any board member to participate from a remote location using telephonic or

videoconference connections. Tex. Att’y Gen. Op. No. JM-584 (1986); see also Tex. Att’y Gen. Op.

No. DM-207 (1993) (in absence of specific legislative authorization, a governmental body may not

permit a member to participate in a meeting via live video transmission). A member of a

governmental body subject to the Act may participate in a meeting from a remote location only as

expressly authorized by the Act.

You cite two provisions of the Open Meetings Act as relevant to your question. Section

55 1.121 of the Government Code allows the governing board of an institution of higher education

to hold a meeting by telephone conference call if

(1) the meeting is a special called meeting and immediate action

is required, and

(2) the convening at one location of a quorum of the governing

board is difficult or impossible.

TEX. GOV’T CODE ANN. 3 551.121 (Vernon 1994); see also id. 5 551.125 (Vernon Supp. 2000)

(similar authorization for all governmental bodies). This provision applies only when immediate

action is required and it is difficult or impossible to convene a quorum at one location. It does not

authorize the board to conduct a regular meeting by telephone, or allow a board member to

participate in a regular meeting by telephone.

Section 55 1.127 of the Government Code’ allows a governmental body to hold a meeting by

videoconference call “only if a quorum of the governmental body is physically present at one

location of the meeting.” Id. § 55 1.127(b) (V emon Supp. 2000). In addition to the usual notice

requirements set out in subchapter C of the Act, meetings held by videoconference call are subject

to the following notice requirements:

The notice of a meeting to be held by videoconference call

must specify as a location ofthe meeting the location where a quorum

of the governmental body will be physically present and specify the

intent to have a quorum present at that location. In addition, the

notice of the meeting must specify as a location of the meeting each

other location where a member of the governmental body who will

‘This provision was enacted in 1997 as section 55 1.126 of the Government Code and renumbered as section

551.127 of the Government Code in 1999. See Act ofMay 30, 1997,75tb Leg., RX, ch. 1038, 5 2,1999 Tex. Gem

Laws 3896-97, renumbered by Act of Apr. 23, 1999,76th Leg. R.S., ch. 62,s 19.01(50), 1999 Tex. Gen. Laws 127,

414. Thus, the Government Code section 551.126 addressed in Attorney General opinion DM-478 (1998) is now

section551.127.

Mr. Charles E. McMahen - Page 3 (X-0194)

participate in the meeting will be physically present during the

meeting. Each of the locations shall be open to the public during the

open portions of the meeting.

Id. 5 551.127(d).

Additional detailed requirements in section 551.127 are designed to ensure that board

members are audible and visible to one another and to members ofthe audience. Each open portion

of a meeting held by videoconference call must be visible and audible to the public at each location

specified in the notice, id. 9 55 1.127(e), and each location must have two-way communication with

each other location during the entire meeting. Id. 5 551.127(g). Each participant in the

videoconference call, while speaking, must be clearly visible and audible to each other participant,

and, during the open portion of the meeting, to the members of the public in attendance at the

location of the meeting. The Department of Information Resources is required to adopt rules

specifying minimum standards for audio and video signals at the meeting, id. 9 55 1.127(h), and if

technical difficulties cause the quality ofthe audio or video signal to fall below those standards, the

governmental body must recess or adjourn the meeting. See Tex. Att’y Gen. Op. No. DM-480

(1998) at 2-3.

Section 551.127 of the Government Code clearly requires that all participants in a

videoconference under its provisions be able to see as well as hear one another throughout the

meeting and, during open portions of the meeting, to be seen and heard by members of the public.

The Open Meetings Act does not authorize the board of an institution ofhigher education to conduct

its regular meetings by telephone nor does it allow a board member to participate in a regular

meeting by telephone. Accordingly, the governing board of an institution of higher education may

not hold a regular meetings where a quorum is physically present and board members participate in

the meeting from remote locations by means of telephonic connections which are audible to the

public. We decline to overrule or modify Attorney General Opinion DM-478.

Mr. Charles E. McMahen - Page 4 (X-0194)

SUMMARY

No governmental body subject to the Open Meetings Act may

hold a meeting by telephone or videoconference except as expressly

authorized by the Act. The governing board of an institution of

higher education may hold a regular meeting where a quorum is

present at one location and other members participate by

videoconference call if the board complies with the provision of

Government Code section 551.127. The governing board of an

institution of higher education may hold a meeting by telephone

conference call pursuant to section 55 1.12 1 of the Government Code

only when immediate action is required and it is difficult or

impossible to convene a quorum at one location. The Open Meetings

Act does not authorize the board of an institution of higher education

to conduct its regular meetings by telephone, nor does it allow a

board member to participate in a regular meeting by telephone.

Attorney General Opinion DM-478 (1998) is affirmed.

Yorsve trul,

4JYv

JOHN CORNYN

Attorney General of Texas

ANDY TAYLOR

First Assistant Attorney General

CLARK RENT ERVIN

Deputy Attorney General - General Counsel

ELIZABETH ROBINSON

Chair, Opinion Committee

Susan L. Garrison

Assistant Attorney General - Opinion Committee

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.