Opinion

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

Court
Texas Attorney General Reports
Filed
Jul 2, 2006
Status
Published
On the bench
Greg Abbott
Cited by
0 cases

The opinion

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

GREG ABBOTT

November 7,2006

The Honorable Eddie Lucia, Jr. Opinion No. GA-0482

Chair, Committee on International

Relations and Trade Re: Whether a water rights fee imposed by the

Texas State Senate Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsville

Post Office Box 12068 is an impermissible impact fee under chapter 395

Austin, Texas 7871 l-2068 of the Local Government Code (RQ-046%GA)

Dear Senator Lucia:

Chapter 395 of the Local Government Code limits the kinds of charges and assessments

known as “impact fees” that political subdivisions may exact on real estate development. See

generally TEx. LOC. GOV’T CODEANN. 5s 395.001-,082 (Vernon 2005). You ask whether a water

wrights fee imposed by the City of Brownsville is an impermissible impact fee prohibited by the

chapter.’

The City of Brownsville charter establishes the Public Utilities Board (the board) as a

“separate and distinct agency of the City” with authority to control, manage, and operate the city’s

water and sewage system.* We are informed that the board’s rules and regulations require a

developer to pay certain connection charges to receive city water service? These charges include

“water rights” fees and “impact” fees. City Brief, supra note 3, at 9; Association Brief, supra note

3, at 224. Concerning the water rights fee, the board’s rules and regulations require a developer

requesting water service for a development to either convey water rights measured in acre feet per

acre, pay a per-acre water rights charge in lieu of transferring water rights, or possibly perform a

prorated combination of the two. See City Brief, supra note 3, at 9-10; Association Brief, supra note

3, at 4. The purpose of the fee is to acquire water rights and otherwise provide for a water supply

‘See Letter from Honorable Eddie Lucia Jr., Chair, Committee on International Relations and Trade, Texas

State Senate, to Honorable Greg Abbott, Attorney General of Texas, at 1 (Mar. 17, 2006) (on file with the Opinion

Committee, also available at http:liwww.oag.state.tx.us) [here&&r Request Letter].

%e BROWNSVILLE, TEX., CITY CHARTER, art VI, $ 1(+(b), mailable af http://citysecretary.cob.us/

city_charter.asp (last visited Oct. 30, 2006).

“See Brief on behalf of the City of Brownsville, Texas and its Public Utility Board, from Richard D. O’Neil,

Davidson & Troilo, to Nancy S. Fuller, Chair, Opinion Committee, Office of the Attorney General ofTexas, at 9 (May

4,2006) (hereinafter City Brief); Briefon behalf ofthe Lower Valley Builders and Developers Association, from Arthur

Val Perkins, to Nancy S. Fuller, Chair, Opinion Canmittee, Office of the Attorney General of Texas, at 3-4 (May 4,

2006) (hereina& Association Brief) [briefs on file with the Opinion Committee].

The Honorable Eddie Lucia, Jr. - Page 2 (GA-0482)

to meet the board’s current and future obligations. See City Brief, supra note 3, at 11-12;

Association Brief, supra note 3, at 4. Nevertheless, the board requires payment of both the water

rights fee and the separate impact fee before it will provide water service and maintains both a water

rights fund and a separate impact fee fund. See City Brief, supra note 3, at 9-12, 15; Association

Brief, supra note 3, at 3-4.

Under chapter 395, “a governmental entity or political subdivision may not enact or impose

an impact fee” that is not specifically authorized by the chapter or other state law. TEX.LOC. GOV’T

CODE ANN. 5 395.01 l(a) (Vernon 2005). To impose an impact fee, a political subdivision must

comply with detailed procedures and other requirements. ‘See generally id. 5s 395.041-.058

(procedures for adoption of an impact fee). An impact fee may be used “only to pay the costs of

constructing capital improvements or facility expansions.” Id. § 395.012(a).

Your question is whether a “‘water rights fee’ imposed by [the board] amounts to an

impermissible ‘impact fee’ under Chapter 395 of the Local Government Code.” Request Letter,

supra note 1, at 1. An impact fee is a fee or exaction on real property development. See Salt Lake

County v. Bd. ofEduc., 808 P.2d 1056,1058 (Utah 1991); see generally Ronald H. Rosenberg, The

Changing Culture of American Land Use Regulation: Paying for Growth With Impact Fees, 59

SMU L. Rev. 177, 188-205 (2006). Chapter 395 does not broadly prohibit property development

exaction; rather, it prohibits apolitical subdivision from levying impact fees without complying with

chapter 395. See TEX. Lot. GOV’T CODEANN. § 395.01 l(a) (Vernon 2005). Because chapter 395

applies only to impact fees, whether the chapter prohibits a particular property development exaction

depends, as a threshold matter, on whether the exaction is an impact fee under the chapter.

Section 395.001 defines what constitutes an impact fee for chapter 395 purposes:

“Impact fee” means a charge or assessment imposed by a political

subdivision against new development in order to generate revenue for

funding or recouping the costs of capital improvements or facility

expansions necessitated by and attributable to the new development.

The term includes amortized charges, lump-sum charges, capital

recovery fees, contributions in aid of construction, and any other fee

that functions as described by this definition.

Id. 5 395.001(4) (further listing exclusions from the term’s meaning, none of which are pertinent

here). The section also defines “capital improvements” and “facility expansions”:

(1) “Capital improvement” means any ofthe following facilities that

have a life expectancy of three or more years and are owned and

operated by or on behalf of a political subdivision:

(A) water supply, treatment, and distribution facilities;

‘wastewater collection and treatment facilities; and storm

water, drainage, and flood control facilities; whether or not

they are located within the service area; and

The Honorable Eddie Lucia, Jr. - Page 3 (GA-0482)

(B) roadway facilities.

(3) “Facility expansion” means the expansion of the capacity of an

existing facility that serves the same function as an otherwise

necessary new capital improvement, in order that the existing facility

may serve new development. The term does not include the repair,

maintenance, modernization, or expansion of an existing facility to

better serve existing development.

Id. § 395.001 (l), (3). From these definitions, an exaction is an impact fee under chapter 395 if it is

a charge or assessment to fund or recoup the costs of capital improvements or facility expansions,

or if it is a fee that functions as such a charge or assessment. See id. 5 395.001(4). A capital

improvement is one of the facilities listed in the statute-roadway facilities and “water supply,

treatment, and distribution facilities; wastewater collection and treatment facilities; and storm water,

drainage, andfloodcontrolfacilities.” Id. § 395,001(1)(A). And a facility expansionis anexpansion

of an existing facility’s capacity that serves the same function as new capital improvement. Id.

5 395.001(3). While the statute does not define the word “facility,” the exclusive list of facilities that

constitute a capital improvement in section 395.001(l) includes only physical infrastructure. See

id. 5 395.001(l). A “water rights” fee that is not used for the costs of physical infrastructure is

accordingly not a fee for the costs of capital improvement or facility expansion as those terms are

defined. See id. 5 395.001(l), (3).

In addition to fees for capital improvement and facility expansion, the definition of an impact

fee expressly includes certain charges, fees, and contributions, and “any other fee that functions as

described by this definition.” See id. 5 395.001(4). To function “as described by this definition,”

a fee must be imposed to fund or recoup “the costs of capital’improvements or facility expansions

necessitated by and attributable to the new development.” Id. The phrase “any other fee” cannot be

construed to include fees other than those for physical infrastructure costs because chapter 395 also

provides that “[a]n impact fee may be imposed only to pay the costs of constructing capital

improvements or facility expansions.” See id. 5 395.012(a). A fee to construct a water supply

facility is an impact fee under chapter 395, but a fee imposed solely for acquiring an adequate water

supply is not. See id. 5 395.001(l), (3)-(4); id. 5 395.012(a). Because a “water rights fee” to

procure a water supply is not an impact fee, it does not constitute an impermissible impact fee

prohibited by chapter 395.

That is not to say, however, that the assessment and collection of the water rights fee is

permissible. Questions have been raised, and the facts are disputed, whether the fee is actually used

to acquire water rights or merely accumulates in a water rights fund. Moreover, the propriety of the

fee on a basis other than chapter 395 is not entirely clear from the limited information provided us.

But because that question has not been presented to us, and because the answer to that ~question

appears to call for factual determinations, it, is inappropriate for us to opine on it. See Tex. Att’y

Gen. Op. No. GA-01 86 (2004) at 6 (stating that this office does not resolve questions of fact),

The Honorable Eddie Lucia, Jr. - Page 4

SUMMARY

A water rights fee imposed solely for the costs of procuring a

water supply and not for facility construction costs is not an

impermissible impact fee prohibited by chapter 395 of the Local

Government Code.

Very truly yours,

Attorney General of Texas

KENT C. SULLIVAN

First Assistant Attorney General

ELLEN L. WITT

Deputy Attorney General for Legal Counsel

NANCY S. FULLER

Chair; Opinion Committee

William A. Hill

Assistant Attorney General, Opinion Committee

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.