Opinion

Untitled California Attorney General Opinion

Court
California Attorney General Reports
Filed
Nov 12, 1997
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 3.5%

The opinion

TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

State of California

DANIEL E. LUNGREN

Attorney General

______________________________________

OPINION :

: No. 97-502

of :

: November 12, 1997

DANIEL E. LUNGREN :

Attorney General :

:

CLAYTON P. ROCHE :

Deputy Attorney General :

:

______________________________________________________________________

THE HONORABLE JAMES B. LINDHOLM, COUNTY COUNSEL, SAN LUIS OBISPO

COUNTY, has requested an opinion on the following question:

May the electorate of a general law county enact through the initiative process an ordinance

that would require a vote of the people for (1) any closure, sale, or lease of a county hospital, (2) any action

transferring the management of a county hospital from the board of supervisors to another entity, or (3) any

reduction or elimination of medical services at a county hospital?

CONCLUSION

The electorate of a general law county may not through the initiative process enact an

ordinance that would require a vote of the people for (1) any closure, sale, or lease of a county hospital, (2)

any action transferring the management of a county hospital from the board of supervisors to another entity,

or (3) any reduction or elimination of medical services at a county hospital.

ANALYSIS

In this request for our opinion we are asked if the electorate of a general law county may,

through the initiative process, enact an ordinance that would require prior voter approval with respect to

changes in the management or control of a county hospital by the board of supervisors. We conclude that the

electorate may not enact such an ordinance through the initiative process.

In article II, sections 8 and 9 of the Constitution, the people have reserved to themselves the

powers of initiative and referendum with respect to state laws, that is, the power to propose (initiative) or

reject (referendum) such laws. In section 11 of the same article, the people have similarly reserved to

themselves initiative and referendum powers in "each city and county under procedures that the Legislature

shall provide." We are here concerned with the county initiative process, for which the Legislature has

provided facilitating procedures. (Elec. Code, §§ 9100-9126). Pursuant to the governing statutory scheme, the

1 of 4

provided facilitating procedures. (Elec. Code, §§ 9100 9126). Pursuant to the governing statutory scheme, the

electorate of a county may propose an ordinance through a petition signed by the requisite number of voters,

requiring the board of supervisors to either adopt the ordinance or submit the matter of its adoption to the

electorate.

The right of the local electorate to initiate ordinances is generally coextensive with the

power of the local governing body to enact legislation. (De Vita v. County of Napa (1995) 9 Cal.4th 763,

775; Voters for Responsible Retirement v. Board of Supervisors (1994) 8 Cal.4th 765, 777; Simpson v. Hite

(1950) 36 Cal.2d 125, 129.) "`Only ordinances which involve an exercise of legislative power may be

enacted by initiative.' [Citations.]" (Arnel Development Co. v. City of Costa Mesa (1980) 28 Cal.3d 511, 516,

fn. 6.) "[T]he purpose of an initiative is to enact laws the local governing body could enact." (Memorial

Hospitals Assn. v. Randol (1995) 38 Cal.App.4th 1300, 1310.) In this respect, we note that the Constitution

prohibits boards of supervisors of general law counties from adopting ordinances that conflict with state law.

Section 7 of article XI of the Constitution provides:

"A county or city may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary,

and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws." Footnote No. 1

Thus, neither a board of supervisors of a general law county nor the electorate through the initiative process

may adopt ordinances that conflict with state law.

It is also now well settled that the initiative power may not be exercised by the local

electorate where the Legislature has designated the local governing body as its agent to administer policies of

statewide concern. (Committee of Seven Thousand v. Superior Court (1988) 45 Cal.3d 491, 500-507; Yost v.

Thomas (1984) 36 Cal.3d 561, 570; Associated Home Builders etc., Inc. v. City of Livermore (1976) 18

Cal.3d 582, 596, fn. 14; Simpson v. Hite, supra, 36 Cal.2d at 129-135; Da Vita v. County of Napa, supra, 9

Cal.4th at 780-781; W.W. Dean & Associates v. City of South San Francisco (1987) 190 Cal.App.3d 1368,

1374-1379; Ferrini v. City of San Luis Obispo (1983) 150 Cal.App.3d 239, 248-249; Merriman v. Board of

Supervisors (1983) 138 Cal.App.3d 889, 891-892; Redevelopment Agency v. City of Berkeley (1978) 80

Cal.App.3d 158, 167-171; Friends of Mount Diablo v. County of Contra Costa (1977) 72 Cal.App.3d 1006,

1010-1012; Walker v. City of Salinas (1976) 56 Cal.App.3d 711, 715-717; Fletcher v. Porter (1962) 203

Cal.App.2d 313, 318-321; 66 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 258, 259-261 (1983).) As recently explained by the

Supreme Court, the Legislature may "delegate the exercise of [legislative] authority exclusively to the

governing body, thereby precluding initiative and referendum." (Da Vita v. County of Napa, supra, 9 Cal.4th

at 776.)

Here, we are concerned with a county hospital. As to the property of a county, the court in

County of Marin v. Superior Court (1960) 53 Cal.2d 633, 638-639, stated:

". . .[A]ll property under the care and control of a county is merely held in trust by the

county for the people of the entire state. The county is merely a political subdivision of state

government, exercising only the powers of the state, granted by the state, created for the purpose

of advancing `the policy of the state at large, for purposes of political organization and civil

administration, in matters of finance, of education, of travel and transport, and expressly for the

general administration of justice.' [Citations.] The county holds all its property, therefore, . . as

agent of the state. [Citations.]"

In County of Los Angeles v. Graves (1930) 210 Cal. 21, 25, the court observed:

". . . If there be legal title in the county, it is held in trust for the whole public. In the

absence of constitutional restrictions, the Legislature has full control of the property so held by

the counties as agencies of the state. [Citation.] . . . ."

Th L i l t h t d h i t t t h i th i iti

2 of 4

The Legislature has enacted a comprehensive statutory scheme governing the acquisition,

sale, lease, or other disposition of county real property. (Gov. Code, §§ 25520-25588.) Government Code

section 25521 provides:

"The board of supervisors of any county may sell or lease for a term not exceeding 99

years, without a vote of the electors of the county first being taken, any real property belonging

to the county."

Not only has the Legislature vested the authority to dispose of or manage county property specifically in the

"board of supervisors," the establishment and administration of county medical facilities (Health & Saf.

Code, §§ 1440-1475) rests solely in the board of supervisors (Health & Saf. Code, § 1441). Health and Safety

Code section 1442.5 expressly provides in part:

"Prior to closing a county facility, eliminating or reducing the level of medical

services provided, or prior to the leasing, selling, or transfer of management, the board shall

provide public notice, including notice posted at the entrance to all county health care facilities,

of public hearings to be held by the board prior to their decision to proceed. The notice shall be

posted not less than 14 days prior to the public hearings. The notice shall contain a list of the

proposed reductions or changes, by facility and service. The notice shall include the amount and

type of each proposed change, the expected savings, and the number of persons affected.

"Notwithstanding the board's closing of a county facility, the limitation of or

reduction in the level of services provided, or the leasing, selling, or transfer of management of a

county facility subsequent to January 1, 1975, the county shall provide for the fulfillment of its

duty to provide care to all indigent people, either directly through county facilities or indirectly

through alternative recipients."

Accordingly, the Legislature has designated the board of supervisors as its agent to

administer public hospital services in each county. (See Health & Saf. Code, §§ 1442.5, 1445; Welf. & Inst.

Code, § 14000.2; City and County of San Francisco v. Superior Court (1976) 57 Cal.App.3d 44, 46-47; 38

Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 176 (1961).) It has expressly authorized boards of supervisors to sell or lease county

property without voter approval. (Gov. Code, § 25521.) However, before selling, leasing, transferring the

management of, or reducing the level of medical services in a county hospital, the public must be notified and

public hearings held. (Health & Saf. Code, § 1442.5.) Footnote No. 2

Since a local initiative measure may not conflict with state law, a vote of the people may not

be required for the sale or lease of a county hospital. (Gov. Code, § 25521.) Because the Legislature has

designated the board of supervisors as its agent to manage county hospital medical services, a local initiative

may not grant voters "approval authority" over management decisions. (See De Vita v. County of Napa,

supra, 9 Cal.4th at 775-777; Committee of Seven Thousand v. Superior Court, supra, 45 Cal.3d at 500-507;

Board of Education v. Superior Court, supra, 93 Cal.App.3d at 584-585.) As recently affirmed by the Court

of Appeal in Memorial Hospitals Assn. v. Randol, supra, 38 Cal.App.4th at 1313:

". . . Where the Legislature has enacted a statewide policy and has assigned to a

particular local body the duty to implement that policy, the Legislature thereby places

implementation of the statewide policy beyond the reach of initiative and referendum.

[Citations.]"

In 7 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 85 (1946), we concluded that a local initiative may not require a

board of supervisors to contract with a hospital district to provide medical care for indigent persons, stating:

"In the present situation the care of the indigent sick is a matter which requires the

constant administrative attention of the board of supervisors and their use of discretionary power

3 of 4

p yp

to decide the mode and manner of care. A contract with a public agency such as the proposed

hospital district would be the proper subject of a resolution by the board after consideration of

the details of the service to be rendered and the funds available. This would be an administrative

function of the board and a decision to contract after an offer to perform by the hospital district

....

"It is our opinion that . . . an ordinance which would itself effectuate or require the

supervisors to effectuate a contract with a hospital district constitutes an interference with the

executive and administrative powers of the board of supervisors and is not within the initiative

power." (Id., at p. 87.)

We reaffirm our 1946 opinion, which we find to be fully supported by case law developed over the past 50

years.

In answer to the question presented, therefore, we conclude that the electorate of a general

law county may not enact through the initiative process an ordinance that would require a vote of the people

for (1) any closure, sale, or lease of a county hospital, (2) and action transferring the management of a county

hospital from the board of supervisors to another entity, or (3) any reduction or elimination of medical

services at a county hospital.

*****

Footnote No. 1

The promotion of the public health and welfare of the citizens of a county falls within the powers conferred by section 7 of

article XI of the Constitution. (Goodall v. Brite (1936) 11 Cal.App.2d 540.) Return to text

Footnote No. 2

As one court has observed, if voters are dissatisfied with decisions made by their elective officers, "they are not without a

remedy; the recall procedure is expressly made applicable. [Citations.]" (Board of Education v. Superior Court (1979) 93

Cal.App.3d 578, 585.)

4 of 4

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.