when the judgment is rendered void or retroactive relief after change in law
How later courts described this case
- when the judgment is rendered void or retroactive relief after change in law
- when the record is not sufficient
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
This document contains s
pages that are of poor quality
at the time of Imaging.
RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRiMINAL APPEALS
AUG 2 6 2015
A~Aoos\a, C'er~
.!\. \\ -tl\. "f'' CC{_t.\o(\ 4-\ \:t1'c~0
~~\eJ ~~
J ~0 'f IV\ 3S \ Y
6~"'\ ;-r.)(- t l{ 0 s-
~(f)~
C\') A\\ e.tl '' ~" C~l \u11 :#- \ \ ). 3 ~ 8D
& \·, \-e.s. ~:-\-
3 D(oo vM ~s l~
(1~\- ;\)(. 11{05
C:lJ *\)e. s~{\\eJ'
L<':t: 0 "6 CJ 0 j L0Do 6 ~ \•
A,t~-\-ur'\ 0x- -z0al~
· ke.ct \ 0 o.r-'t r t\ ..:rrtw e.~\-s
~o.r\e.s M. Wktl\f,n
~i e\ 0 \- ~. A~pell ~ Sec.-\1UJ
A (\~~\-GA.\ ~ir-Jna.( 0\~\nc\- AJ.A-or(\{
4.o\ <..AJ • B.e-\~~ ~\;.
\==a<'\-- w1> ~-YV\ ;Jx. . I i..p I<{~
('-/) j-\.vf"\ ~~\S E. ~-~vJI\S:
0 Gt ~ g..e_ ?.\3\h a i~\t\ c-\ GcvJ'..\
L{ 0 l g -e.-\~~
\_A) . s.-\--
~9-\- '-UDf~ ,1)(. I~ jq ~
i:t
\)e~~of'\ ~S' COC"'~\ B-t- r'vlO/l~i ~~ l
•
'I~~~/~ ~ \>OS'\\~~ 0 0
0 • ~-- \
\a-'o\~ -t>·f Co~\~ .. (\
~ I ~g\\
""·~~'/-.. b.\- A-c~<'\.\1 es '
0 0
~ ~ . ~- \v
.::C ~\-cA~ €!\\: 0-C. ·\hL L4£L
~ ~ ~,\
'>
0
0
\\ b.\-t:t~eA\ b.\- ~us\~ ~\c\;of\
0 . p.Y
.... 0' J ~. t{
0 • f' l-\
:3[ Ac SU/V'\-0\\ 0-/\~ ~r;~1 o d
0 < p.7
(A) ~e {(~a s~ C\>~ eC-\ ~ ~- n~ ~\ 0/\6 Otf'c\ o-\ Q-Mf ev0 o
cr ' p.7
\_g) ~\W"\dooJ'~ b{ Q~1 M fUr f"V\tY\~~ ~e.\)\ eW
t=Ds C{\' M-1 Act { L~ rvt etA- \.v' ..s "'
- f· ~
Cc) Qe;\c;,\-o_r \-\ct,'b A \L\sh-\- \ o A~u\G1u'el\*
P-e- u::>('6 ol\ Ae~.eq\ ~..cz)nj ri\~6 " a ., - P" ll
m An ~~\~V\~~ ~-\tA\-~H'( Q/l~ ILt.ih A~<\~:\- (e)(l~~-' .
6).. 1~ h\ \b .A c.:u~\.e\-e. ev-.6 .s~u eA\ ~~on Afp.ecc l ~~ weH e ~~c.6tt ~l~ecL f·l J..
~e.~-\-l~uf\ ~ ( CD··" t.t ({) ~ MU-1 c\CM-<-{.\ r·t~t "
,i
3J ~\- \L-~\t.z\vr~ ~ '--tS.~..\\a~\..Q_ £)(.'\)\CV14hbr\ \>rQ_~
A La.~~ w c;UU<..r 0v1 ,~lor ~ -e~l.Q__ o o o -- P· \~
q
0
Cu~-\
?c..KQ.s.
A~ cwr '-l ~ ~~ I,\')... 1-w J-~ I L'l C\e~ CSv"" ~ \ ~ t~ ) · ., o ... r·'q
At"'\~ 5on \J ('-~ ~~ ~ e-\Jet\ ~C)(·{\\s ~t:J..e S-wlb l ~~ t\ei-- \'111 ) 0 d \'.l\
If\. \ e,_ ~ a h (') ::Lo .s w ~d. ~(a-:;- C/\e ~. Af f ·' t=V.r+ wo!'--\1A)
Goci~ ~ fb(.Q.Q.~~ C> 'II ... t: '~·
~4A\~ \J g~~ !o'1~ J ~~ d-SS C\e~.~-(.~~
L J4~ 0> '~-\-l \7~s) Cor1j ~( oul~;~) ., r;- .,
~as(\-e.~ '\) s~ ~ 1d.. lwJ,~ 4~1.{ l:\ex A~Q.SCl/\AA~l\i() \9~) L - p .7
(S~V..QJ' \) L.Vt'nj b
~\'(' ~ 'V ~e. ~-o.\e_ <l' \ tt s v0:2.. 6 2v2.. CT e'i..~p. \).)G,UJ Vt11) ~ - \)· 7
~ovt\l.A'-() \J~q\4 to]lo )v0"),~5<t.o C.\-c'f.-.~p.~~~\-o i'l'bl)~. p.)O
{S <' \ \\- v N 1::10~ Lo-ro\A nQ 'i Oi..\ u.~. :1 )..~ (I~ l J) 'tl <7 .~ • ~· iS1 J(p .
~ VJ\\; ~ '\J \-\o.r ("''f\ ~:tI s w?..~ Li Y S" C\e}.. rs,~ ~~- \'1 <t J.. J ., . . p. <f
Go~ ~'6~ ·'-.J ~\\.e~ S~ J!oq US.L\J~ ( \1<p.l) " 0
S \~ \J ~\ ~'1 s- J w).d '{ 'i'l f:Ve'l- ~f~J.X;= \'ltJ
C-or-\~ ~ (()LQ.i ~~1) 0 q- u d
"p .10
(__ (0(\Q/\ \J s "'""' ~ ~ \").. ~ w J. ~ lo 9 ( \'e'j._ A(>p \-k~..t~~
L\~·\- \) \)-\--] \1tJJ) ( ur1'j e.o~\~~) Cl 0 G c. • f·~
'
~-e~·\;o(\ ~.r (.A)s-,-\-'bf M~ ~ ~j T ab\..L o{- A-t\'\....oN\-le-1 ~. \\J
f>Ci 3 eJ
S\Gl\-e. -e~ (~\ Cw-,~ "Jl!o -~-..v-~~ \').S: L"7\e)(Gv~,A(>~.\qf7J o ~\Cf
~e...le..o~-.~ \),~\-Me\ C..\V"'Y- lt.l, Sw3d Co/3 C\e~,CJ'-'""'-A..fp,JooW"' ,~J1
~t:.
0o'o'o~ vl..OJ.A~ \.\:1 S.G\: ~3 S Ll'1ttJJ c; t:-1 c , ~-_.l\
\)oVL~\cw ~ c_~'-'G-o((\\C!_ 11.2.._ u.~- lS.J (l9<olJ o e7 J • f-ltotl?
.r"'
D<'~ v Wet~~'0Jk ~\lu.S. L{.~( (\'1Co3J o e/ c. ~,IJ 1 !~1 lS
c "'\s ~n~v- \.J ::::Lov.ju.._ ~~ \.eu -~.I L{~ ( ltt(p/) ; P· IS,tlo
£ \J\~~ -J Lu~ vos- ~-L~ "'t ~o C\<1~ sj " . . P· IJ,I(p1(7
c c p- 1s1 14>
G-~Vt{( ~r& Cor-'\> '-' £v(ns ""63oJ-vv~ 6 3 s S"'
t. \-ci-- ..APP· C-or<> c..(~ UN-1~\-\. l q ~ J. )Cor[~ Q roLQ.Qdt_'~) ..
(:s..(, \0("\ v .::c-t\~ (\ ~\ s. 1> .$1 \...{. ~- i?._ ( l£t 5 CoJ 0 0
0
G-f'D~ \J G,..-ou\~ l o;).. .(IA.)-:z,~ 1}\Ll,tJllto CI~~-C\v.Afp.
'ffi.s' NOf'~ l 910 1 f\ v~ n't ) c <7 ,
- r. Jl)
~·ne_s v 'i-tJ.f'JVU' 4 QL( u.~ . . S" 1~ Ct <t 1 AJ c v
. f>·7
l-\a.0~~ 'J t.M\k ~ J~ 31~ uS. :1_ I I C\1~J,. . . p, J]
(o ~ ~ \) rt>t.r2L~~) o cY (, ..
\ a 'o\e 0\ ~~~\i-e ~
C q ~ .e...s pa g....e.l
\4-u-{)Q/)6-ez_ \J ~-\~ I ~~ S\.1))_ ~ "6).$"" (Te'f-_ Cs v~ J\-fp 19~0) or • (J· l 7
.s \-M Cf..... ~t 1-\-t \\ \J Q ~-f'\-\e ~I S"W~ 1.. '1-1. \ ("!C't.. es; 1"1.-Ai{J 197'~) • e~3
c. l~ o.f- r'"' ~I.e~ , \.e "-::s-b h n J V/1 S :r1 sw.;, ~ 11..1 &"' CTe i..A'(Jp (o.rp~J
~~\1 ~<i/0 God~ (?\6~~-"jJ o ,. _ a- c- ~ fA' tO
X"- ~- x" \:.\-,'niM'lo/1~ l-01 J·~J ~ <.o£1 (.·rei--.~(J. ~r{w<>.r-fC.r .2.oU:J
(_,0 n'~ ~ \0~ ~ 0,3 ) ., •· o ao .,_ ., -- e)~ 1 .).If?.]
L ~S ~ cd--e._ v IJ lllcwo\ ( "& \.5 s.v J, ~ \ "i 7 CT~ . f-W{J . 1-kl..{ ~.J.dl
L I !(~ () IJ\- J I t:t q I I {\A) p-et J 0
0
IV\ttr'i Of"\ v L.oc.\(.~~-\- 1\l{ S-v...J~cb. .J._Jtp C\~i-.1 <?J ~J
(0 - • p.t't
fV\ ~ fl/' v G ~-\ t) .c _Ap(U ·d.r L/ ~ ~ u J' . t-f;)., ( ( J9 g ~j a G ~- f· }{p
~Uvf") V Kri..{Ji/1 1?/~ J 1.0~6_ 1 ( ~ CTe~ )9) '{) ·rs ., ~ ~,I_S
0 ((~viD \) J.~ q I~ JwJ..~ S \ 9, S':.2.S 1'\·"6 CT~.Cr1'fV\~. 1q 7b)" P' ~
...::c 1'\ ('€_ ~~ \ ~ l '1 () J vJ J d, ~ ~3 (T~i-.. Arr. \for\- v.J)/'~ ~ j .. .P· ? 0
K'hQCMA r 'i- J j ~c.v-0 (', :J_ c S--0.ld- :171 (_ ~ ~ CJ ' \ 91> w~ -r' q
p (\' ~ ~ !-p~"\1 }Q ?)"' ___L <; ~w-]- Q, -1) -->0-"> J<>j. 1/l 'I~0 e >?
01 d Cso()c ·~
.J .; "v..\V) ·1- ;hl_) & s £ t \"CV' s \ ~ ' JO \)~ ,)_L ~ 0'0 a'1-;
L; d I' ,) (QcY>r' CD? M ~~ i-~l) 0 h 0 \ fe""'-f ~ r J 0 ] ~ j_~ v_::::r:::-
J I I d- ~ :? [.~L b\ "' __l_) );h ~
Ci). ~ 'f\"' s 0)~ > ~ \) b \A), (\ JQV~~
-\-~~ b~9 1_so,O) ~fC'0 S"O)L. \'f!-0 l\ 1~~-J
1
QJ & '"\h2.bJ ·1'1-N·f\.'?'i-a-_.4
_5 (' d - p .:? = 0 CL~b') ~ #2,' cs.) rr OJ~ <i: vc\ft\\:? ~ (\ -\;·YJ?d)
Q -e· ~ ,(LQ.()~ "~-.;~__L) CPh ~ l'C"" r 0) C!." o7· CJ \ _;;)_L) \~'8 1J f"O\"'~ Vv\~Q ) 0"' v~
bId Jl [lib I -(}J.:y W\J) '1-:;J._L:) h'i L \\~""'J ~ 'CL 1\ ')D\_i {\ '1f'-vv)
L_J ·~ · " <:> " pco-e) f>S'fJ · s·n ~--e 5 Yu~ ~~ f'. ~·~ S' /
r-c J , -=
o o ... ( OV~~Q b~J<Y) (Sbbl
~~~~ rno-}<?7 ·d<J-v·'f-'d_LJ [L\ ~t0r tJb ~ (\ -zrrvos
't-r'te'&t·d "'(.&.Q<;rr. ~JC(Y)\JO:;:!l 'od-v·"~-~_j_) ~O)L zrCY\5 &n-c a-'\Ms~o-o -(N v.::::c
[1 1Ct .J. ~ -:> r:oor rJJV· w.,ry"f.a_L) b L 't' ~f~f~" ~? f\ )\t7cno--d
-~ ,J · p C' ' \ J'lll~mQ.)~ F'.l...JO·J ( ~6bt ()_~~ Vo) · ~ov· r-?~)
fr,O) t''e ()-)fb")9:,. -\-:> -\:~(0 ) 0 '!'1·~~"'~ 1--rl ~~ f'\o ~7 )~1))70 d\'~~~
I'C' c) J " fJ-;;- 'i b I ~?.J.:.J d) L. 'f '{0'"\...f'l L. L -:) ~- 1 O""'S IJ 0 ~v3 ~ vrn~ () C\ ) J0.~~
b ·d ·" (U~ 1dJv v--lJ)J.;JbL.t'c ~ r~rh c_d"p1ZJoW f\ -z_(f(\d'~~ )'U) ~ ~\~
s-o~l?d
so-So-")
S'd ~~0~ J0 ?'\'\ 1?__L.
;
#
I
f>4f~
::r' A ~ Lt..\JU'-J i-y_s. £-ervl . .:.:Cf"\L .?-:H Sw3'd.- J 3 l (\~;.... \<J'9<(] o .,. • f· I"&
\J I W.ct 2> or.--.e 2- ~ve~~M ~1\:.J 1L LC. v V\11. 4 fe€ ;;. q L{ J w 1 ~ (, "b (
CT~i-. A~(>.;:,£+ ~•j+ ') '-k~...t~l"\ .?--00~) " t7 .., - ... - P· 1:2
..::::Ct~-· ~ \Jl~ MJ ~ .::Ii)c_ \<72_ JwJ ~ I s-1 CT--e-L .ld~~ .. p- ;z 0
..s \-Ct\..e ·-e. K r-e\ VJ er6R- \j MCV-(J (Q<( 7 \ -wl& ~c;J (Te'J.._ ~Af? I ~'tl).r9
~\L.\~. \.) ::)0(\.Qi 9 '2./ f J_~ 5 ~ .l_( y;- ~ Ct\r 197Jj "' 0 , • QJ-;.2 0
vJ\) otis ·v ~\-vON! L 9?.6 J w::2 -~.II 9 (Tee~. Cor ~j ~~-h 1 o.l't'_J
p c D(J2..Q ~""~ ) O\)Q/'\uJs b o/"\ ~ ~~~ \-r ~ c w-i ~ J ..... b (\-<)Y\. ·
(3 ('1·~ fC.~ ~- ) R~~)~ i +''1 L \J lh e..\~~ Co~- -o-C .A:--we-q(_r
CJ :L7 J ..J:2. ~ 4 L{ 0 ( T ~-(. I <j·~j c r , · ~ · 7 i '8
2 wvi j 'i 11 2 Ul\4, f c; I '!. JWJ l.. '1 1'1> CTej.._.Af~ So.-. ~ i\) 1 9'19_\ , . ~7
R~QJ'a{ Gn.!~~\1orv;A A~~
r r-- \7
I
l\
£e.lv--al ~~1 ;Gc\e.i &16 ~eJ
·;J_ ~ u .s.~c · <.:s .21 s ~
0
.- f· J b/ I{
c. f·l D
\ e'l--- \\-.A~-~·~. ~ 11. Lk' c
c
\e.'}... ~- ~q. ~, ~ Jt.\,l_o c
t.
•
(? ,e-\,~ol\ ~-- w ....:\- 0~ MGob<M<AJT«~ Of A..-\1...u-t~e..', f.\ '1\..
:L
~\o..\~er\\ O.C Th.e. ( ctSQ.
OA \h-e. C)\~'n\ o\- <..\ -:z...J- "!::):;,1.. ~e... ",-~-\-\<'<"\ £..,ere\ \.e Glno.r\.es. A." ~\e ~q ~
~~~ ~-\\e~Q ~ \ -\\ri\l~~ \~~('~()1 ~~~cd\ ~lf\Q~ -to~~ ~~h-\ lf-\-~\S
cv\J\e-~e~ s nt~i{ ~\'~ <'~'\' ..s'h-u-Q • -('-t·v:t.-\- ....J6\.i 'neue~ ct\- \tt\s. \eJ\cltll~
o...A· \ /~l( w \~~a/1 Av-IL, ~\'\w~r~ '7fassW\\ C.OWI.-\.r 1\Q ~s. ., ~Q/)
c. ct'\ ~n ~ u. \\ e ~ 1J'\) ~ ~ \J 1c~ IV\1 r-e .i \ ~.QI\~ ~- -\-v..Jo 411 eJt? ~ Iy M
e_" ~ q ~ Q ~ \ f'\ C\ 'o ~\ e-t G::>!\ -JQJ"__s q \i on .. ~ -J i ~"" ...Jai J h-u-\- OA.2. -\-{ f'l'-.('
\ (\ a\\ ~,1>\:,a\.~;\\\~ w ,¥v\_ -~ ~<.if\ ~ vH.k\IV\ '-0GtS. ~"'owf\ ~ '1-r&,p
l~ ~\':> Q~~).Q..S.S,IOJ \n Ct ~ ~\5.\.s<_r • C.~tA.\..on v-,}Ct_s, ..iu~.Q~u.0\~ oJ"--
C e.~\-e? CV)-~ ~jt d b'-1 in ~\c\""'~\ v.> '~ 4\~k J. MW'W ~'-1)
(A.us..e JJch C"'t'{] l(o~ ... ((("e~t 'N2_~nJ'S ~'n fu_ i.Vl ~~·t.llJ o\ ~1·Q be..8QI)
C>._f\.\-1-ol.{ CV\6. C-<bnc.J.M~6 Of\ 4-.17-o'-{ occW'NI~ aHe4\-\- cf)<..Qof"
-\-w\1..2-- Cc t\AP"'1'f.A CV\..6 &J.Q/\ -f'Ouf'.; \;~ ·, (') 0 OA.M.~ -o \- l.<::>Dq .~~s:e__
~~-\,\a.~ ~\n ~ s v..l-Qf'e e.o, ~eA.\\ OJl( t(\ 0ct\- use ., .:r"' \)DJ'-hu,j \ar -\iQ
\<).1-()4. 1 V19-o'-t 011·~ ..1 -\1-0~ Q\€-\r-~ct~ ~-ngs ~ 0'-tQ ~-\'i.e.. e.o1~te- uJ<tS
~t:-o\\% e ~ 'o'{ c. cc\ .\-en~\-\~ \ (\ ~\c ec.,\- .\v-(>~o!'-\-
'{)+-· ~ \S. ~-h·i)() ~ C)-~~
~~---s. ft~ \<-\4( U:>v-f'~._s <''-l\;'"lg A~iflg .JQ_l~ ~h~A on ~ujo
oc..L.£t~\ O'\S ~..Nas ~\s~:J ""'~t-\a.H z..e~ tA-1'NL- ~-\~~ \ecor~s a As
.J·-t"6ie.. G\\\s. _s\W'~cJ'6 \)\a_~~LQ_ ct\-~-\\~ '-'lG\S ks~.~ h\~ tuh(_\j'
o'"'~~LO'~ a.~~~'~ O/'\. )-\:l-t)lt 0/\~ctJG..In o-0 )-1f-6l{ u..hCV)
Cq,.t ~ ~v-r g fl.~ h\ ~ ~f\ \"'0 o~ ~ ~s " w \llL\ct \cr~ A(f,; do-.o~ ~
A'{'-(>.2_,{6) 1-. \ n -~ "f{Jt>r-\ 0 \- \\-u ~-R\.-\.;D() ~~ wrv\· 0-\- /V\(111 d.c-\MA.C ( ~ V'e_ -
Ct ~\if 0011-\ ~ "e-\.v-re J. -\-o CfJ Af{)QA ~ J-
Ej.l,,b,~ '' D'l -e '1-cJrr-\- '6-G-
c..ovf'\- ~oc:kr'~s (}QLDI"'~ ~r')~\ct\ 0-MUL J\) o ()/S""J/U \J'clv.-Q l{ p. . lo?
L..,~~ ~-~) CW' ct.-\- ~.(e. Of\ s-1 o- bl{ ~ \t-\Ql Of\~ tht/~\-:1
b~~ CV\~ ~-\-of"\ {)le ~ r.'\\Y\· ~~,.\~+u~~~tt. p__Q\Jt;IJ__p.J'()-G-
Q.e~~ifl ~~ \.0\'\-\ ~ ~ ev,~_s PCtJ~ I bt-cl ~
(
t·
COJ..lse ~~. o~L\ll!o~ .. Cct\Aon wct ~ Co<lvK~c\ by ct ~lAfi o.Q- ~ S~Gof)~
oe-~ce.J<... \~\\)"-Y o\~~-e o~ ~\~\ecl <Yl~·w on s-1<7- o4. s_!LQ_ -s'u~8-
M€1\\ ~~ A)o. l>~A3\ ~1. o~~~ -\ouJ\~ -~ ~b)~c;~ 'C)\~-~.
q.\te- ~ ~~Of'\S \-tv-Q__ GA ~ o. ~'-t ~sed F~IVI<!A\ 4\ Gof\.\\n~\ ~ r L,~
\(\ \ oc::O . LQ.Q_-:),_/~j M Q/\\ ~\N..- S~t..o()~ ~vJ"·\" -a-\ A.{>(X?o \.s A-\ t r ~~
CCtN\.uN c...o~rc\;o() .. u..e_ Cct\~ -..J ~\-~ .;).()os vv L .;l.!J'\ J..lo?.,;
.AJ·\). ~?-- oY- J-.1 't -(.\L \. \e-J... A~~· ~M--\.Oo\'~ AYO\J; ll 1 J-O\JS"J ~t- w~-
~ '~n.) CA:)o\- ~-Q~-~~na\-e c\ ~' (>v\o\L<-C('-' uf) }, Cct\M {1\,e~ ~\ S ,\n:1 \let(
~\~ \\a\oJL~ ~~\\(£{~\)(\ Df\ 3-ltc- o·~ 0/\6 So_;~ W<'\\-- •-No.S d01ied
~i.~-...t\ ~-\\Qn o~~!V' of) ..2-1.1-o? -SJl.JL-::r~~j~eA\ L0<'t-\- JJu, C.-
:2. \3 -c6i~\~ '""'t>~'41l(o~- A ~X~"~<.:..~~.e. ~ \r'\ C..ctt.\.-v~-~ 1"\~er\ S\-d..Q \-\ob&.S.
A~~\-I.<.A.\-:\0'1 ll\ Y\J(. -~~ ~uS'\- .. C...~\~n qlle~e.~ in G-c-.~)v-A6-41\ --M,q-\
"' ~ux-d..s 1-o~'*-r:::.' D~~()'t'~ ~ v.J~ J..Je~u~ ~' ~e~al.l/" I h w e\)-Qf
ci.v..Q.. ·\o £\e~ S<Jn)\\e.r ~ Cov.\'-\- ~or·+~/.s rvv\sc~re~~~\iur ~-v\ S
M(U''\-v~-t~u.s C..\cJ~ ('a.i\~ ~ o.s w~Q.\\ l<~ ~- \~~Q\ ..£-~ ha~as ~r6-
Cf2....-e~·'-n_g - .5...e..JL f:=)(~b ,-\-_s '' ~ '' 1 "f"' 011\ ~ \~G '' e'k~.i (Xt ~ 1\ I J.l{ <UJ d a--S'
t>-\--\c\l.l\ Cou.r+..s ~<!-af'Gl.A~V\1\1' I rc/1~\t'"\.Q.S '(){- ~4C-\ lG,n<:L.<.il~/1 ~ L~ C11 d.
0\'d.Qf' ..(i\eJ Of\ '\-q-t1( ~n \ -e~~reAc..t -\-v <...o--r,-\ ~. C<i'\1- 6tn\o\'~- 6 "l <(J-
\<e:>'Y;- ~ o{l-(1 ct_,\-. ~tff.Q.S {-C{ ., On £4 -15- (~ C q \k) ~--e cQ.-t\~ ~ e.'-' l ~--VI~-
~C\--\ U)f\~·r ~~ ~a.:\ ~- 5.~;11~ I\'\C\6Q q ~q..(.v; ol M,U(.'<2fre'J ~-h~l)
-+:> CA\.\-:-f'\ c..of\CVf\:\~ ~ ,~\.WMt.( D.\- \'he_ {f.C..Of~.S CCt\~ hq~ -\i-~~
OA ~ ~,\~s-('l'\"1 ~<2.'1 '-'l!lS\.t-~ - ~IlL, v.Jut! I(\ Me~ ll\ ..c a(~ \·n fe (cue..t <....e
~ ~ W\~~~V\~ o\~s_Q_., ~~ f'-0\ e.f~f).e.ous~ qJ(eJe~ o_~QF- ,,
'--'.l\~Q.. b'i S~u-e. Sc..,h,\\Qf o.\-~--\1~ \A ~u.Q-S\-\'tlf) ., SQ_Q_ Ex~1b\'\-- '' t4
s\ev-e Sd·h\\fli"',S An~v.H;r ~ lA U.-<:Ylrs ~\oirt\- \b \1-Q_ c.cLAI' t
~~r¥ ~~'-qholf .Board ( \~Q~~ c.Q..ctV Of~JJ~ a-\- ro.J!R-S
\:0 CV1 ~ ll .,- LC{.l -\-on ---\'h!V) ~ \~~ Ot ~.s-.~ sul viJl/\-\- s -\-~ App Ii cav~·b'l 6'1
to-~-lA v.)\t~JA <'"'---'~~~ Vv,e c.;\a.t·lY) ·~ Pr€.-\.r-\Ct( fle.,c..o(''~~ w~ on-,"+Le-~ -C'rc.'VJ
\
-~ :c..or~ @JI A(>p.QA\ ~ct\- w ue. f'\e...<..QSfor'( ~\' ~ ~\(.Q_c.,-\,·v--.e.., ~q,~(' GYI,!cl
~Jtt\ A~rea( (}..Qslll'-~-hDr~~ lh~s eo~~~\- wets no\- ceck~ cvt be~-1Z
o~ ~ A\o~e_ o-\- ~n\ 0\~ ~\-""-c.~~~ frQ.Ut~\.l.~l en\ve~ QJQ1~·~t
w~n o.n S-..2.1: -o~ .s~ 0'--{~J""€/\.t c-;_u.- Ci)'{(o-7<(- crPtJI lor JH. ~- t+-on
-h \~ ~ o~~v\\'·t><\~\ ,_s\-cd:.p Af~ kc.o---h i>l)_s --r-L> Nb Aual/ «t a\.st'n-s C IaJvts \·n ~<2.--
-\ueA~-\-c ~ Ol'h·,\{.e~ n.a.~0~5 on A.p&Je.al ~ lhw-~ 1t--Q__. ~v--f'lf b f
<:7 C<<~ncJ ~f-e-a-IJ <..O.()~(')\Ae~--\-o··rif\.A~~-.. ~(3 -\-o.'ie... ~ oc..-\-1\)nS Of)
~ e__ ....u (' \ ~ ,. Q> ~ -\-o ~Q --\- ~c..\- ~ cc\- c.~ d--u n "'- <..t ~ \> r ~ ~o s ~ '--l.
~c, ~ Q./\. A '-ov.tQ_ o-\- ~Q.. L.J:r)~ o\'~QS' en\-Q.red. a~oJn~\ ~~f'V) ~ S-€--e
e~~~\o\.\-.s \.\I 11 01\ ~ "'.I L, 0 r ~..s.. ~o'IV\ -~ Co\){'\-\- o\- Cr\ ('<\1\\nct\ Ar(X'ol~ d. a-\-~~
I() ·-Ji-JJ CVI~ s-.;..,L-1~ resQec.-\i\t-Q~ <\~· ~-\- (Xi~S 1). CV\d l3., Cctl-hr'\ ·-ti-1-VJ
,&o~'n-\ \e.o.\i-€. ._{:'\OVV1 fuQ_ \1\~ C \('c_u.A- U.~r Lovf'-\- ~ ~q..tai(s, \1:) fll-e_
A Su.c.<.t~J\~ f'e~QJet\ w(",\ f'W'H.tOJ\-\ ~ 1 )..l.S~ 1 \!..oSI o\' in OJ\. ..:t"n~e--
'
~-€/\~OJ\\- CtC.\io()c \kQ. ~~ ~~ C\C'(.U..t\- ~ e;,l ~ ~ \ ecw-e_ -\--c ~ S u of) I?~({- fJ
r_, U..SLI\. Nv. IJ -(/()'($ ~SzQ.. ~)( ~~b {~ II t" +o'
-r\.(L ~~~~ c ~~\-_s
OC{\"ion ~~~1~ o.\- ~4~-ts It{ Wl~ \~ • (_ctl~ ..}h,QA J~~ U/IW1f<;'i;_] .
-+-o \ \(\JLAAC..~ \1'-e \ <L \ ,-~!( ~~e Iir r\j ·~ -h\, r'l_~ o~ f\-e_ ~rete\ at rec..orJs ~ (q I-l-oll
_ ~u6JU \" ~ei r 0 ~-hu'al ~t.\~ evtd S\-e~ sc.J.,\ I( i f
f'\01/Y\ ed Se\Jtn:::t\
til h1~ os;{\da~ C..o-pQ~~ -\a o~in --\he_ 11\jU/\C..flo() .,~-..!\.t~+ wa.s .
din""'~seJ OJlttnSt -+fu2.. 0U~p vv-tLS di.s.()t15.~eci \ll ~~Q )J(), ftl~- J...7o r;,q.Q-
1L.f Df'\ 5,.:2_ \- 6t{ ~.rl.ae-K- D~ ~,_}oJ-ec.--\· r'\tt qtW 0urisdiC\-l<Y'l ,. ~ee. .Ex\.;, kif-.s
f • .
"j_t\ 0v1 ~\I M '1 ~o\ -(}vl-. -:::r'u~ gJLS n-o·hl:Yl I'D {)\_s,..,.·,ss CVld ~ Cov.rf-1 'Qr.i-'>J'
G-c<li\-\-1(\J*- S<YNL Off-t1dJ~ at- pajJlS /~-;)._0. ~.s\.U+ ctj<t/fl.S\- s\-ev--Q_
Sl-ttif(q.r '-AlQ{S ~-u""·,~s.eJ \n Vuis-L .No. )5J- ).,lOt.,'10-JY t~ll <o-{.-rS
bec..a..u. \ e ~.e Cov.0-\ ~W'"' A<' j \A/2 ~ CVl J ~- CoW"\ ~ ~1 ci ~eft .--\1\,.e_
C \~·MS G\ ~oJnS-\ ~e_ Co .if'\- Uslfof'-\<r v.J./U1?_ b~r~ ~ b'i ..yhe_ ckctr~tt-e_ -foW)d._
iA \-\e:c.~ v H-~l-r~ sL.2- lA-~- L/T7 Clt:t9Ajil~ ~,d,,bl~~ ''NL1,·'a" t Q/ld ~r''
••
~or \'he, ~W'\ ~o~.\ ~~ ~r, ·"Th \J1S nt(~~ ,14,·s {\~ kt 'ln
(0\-\~~_s 0-JLs~on\e. <Y\6 ~ CouJ'\'.s O('~ ~"M\-;rw ~ ~on
\ 0 \) u NV\ \S ~ ~ Q./)6}1.... a_\- ~ et ge~ .J. \ -::10 .
__ ]"[
S\a\-~e.A-\- 0 \; ~w'IS~\lhOfl
~- ~~"-0~ C..Ons-\,~hof\ ~('·ovl ~es ~q-\- ~ le }(aS. CovJ't
~ c_,~""''ncA Ap~a\~ 0/1~ ~~~~yes. ~ere-at ''.shalf hav--e pawij
~ \ ~.{v..e_ W<'t~.$ ~~ MW1~0N..LS ~d qj( uJ rrtr ~c.QUCV4f -\-a efl-
~rQ .)W'~J~·\c.A-1<n ~ r fU(__ Tc.-'1-.~ ~(\s-t-. Art- vj S.
T5.S.vJL.±i::. ~\-ev-e. S.~ 1\ \Q.J het s. ..yhQ_ (VV\~\~~~ q l c\ u.~ -~ -Qre_pw-er
~-~ o-·,c\ ~\e..~ C\~w~ cl\~oU:,'-.life~ ~rek1etl httwt\ttj -\-rcvtStrt ptS 1
~\ '(h('. ~~ \lQf' f\t>w ~a-~ 1\t"\ h-1<;. pc:>U-e.H ICY\ 0v1J ~ fltv\ . .Ccl,d-
\ Q..J ~~:>vJ 4\\ so Knt~vJS CN'e.. ~ e\wM\- ~ ~ LM·~li.Vtrll_j o~(.u ~..Q. ...
~\ ~ ~Ct\ ~ ~c...or~5. wQ.J'e. M!J.~ovy -+or ~- ~\fed-1~ ,.~aJ r
Cv\d '""Qcuv,(\g~( Of>-rctl \QS~L~.·\icYl o~ ~~a{ .No. o;?.-Ol/ -.l.-2'6 - ( (L
,\)-
'S\ot~~€1\\- ()~ Fd <:\.s
Q'<\ S--.)0- 0'-\ ~ Cct \\-vf\ ~VI-\-\~~~ S..·...t\o,...__,\\.e d, \,\ ~ AJ o\-i<..Q D~
.A\)~\ 0-1'1 S -d.~-o'-l CV\ ~ ot'\s. o .(.\ \ -e ~ ~ \ ~ f\'\..c\-1 on \=or- V ~ Q_e,__
{)c:('~ ~("~ ~ A\~~CV\l A 0\- ~a\o.,\,~ \"t) l(~ ~(' Cou/\i.e_{
0 r\ S--.2'0-0'-\ ~-"\h-e.. (..ui)J"\ ~WI ~e~ \\-~ or ~V' A~-()l:)'n\+0.j
Co wu~ ~ -Co ' A~ \)<Za \ OA ~ o r ~Q.J' ~J' S\ e.~ Sc..h' \'\V' -to 0 r ~ oJ"'(J_
~o0.~~/.s. ~u:>r-~ • ..u..e_ £Jl~,loi\s l'Qt' , ,,~u t l'sl' 0/\d n\1' con*tr .-
(vv1·n ~~ ~~ ~~<V\~l'f.. a--\ pU-ftS 31- J1 •
I
(dj Go-rri A\~r~ uJos A('~<>lnk~ A~ A~rQ_\\c:J::.Q CoU/\J-Q~ of\ Cct\~"s
b~~~\\- CV\~ ~svJoJ'~~~ Cal~ Ct t.o~ ~ ~-\or1et Y\Af'.A\f.or~ woS
~oin._s ~ -h\..e... (3¥1 CCiJfon S
1
~hoi~ A-\-~~~ -h·~ G:tt~ t'f')~~~d
c
~~ A\w~ b't ~ .Wov.~h ,., ~o~.s /e-tkrJ ~~+ Cqt-1-ttl wets
l'Vl
r e.1VJtS~n~ .&o"(Y"\~ -\-roJ\~cr( pt_s -.\i,a* he_ beh~ w~ ntrt c\nciLt-
~e~ ~n Y\--e._ ~ro0kr'r P--e,c.u('d ~,u, wa.l ~ ba.s1s. of rvv'"'. ·;~
A\\-o'~ 'bt\e..-f , UL.. £,c:~~b(~~ j'U''' Ba~ry A\hJ~s A(~c\cwA Dfp!VI-
J)~ ev\ pet~.Q.'S ]S a/\~3~ l
(__"'3) ...L\~ b.Q..{.'oj ~ u-\ ol"\ ~c..Q. obu-t ~ON11V\.e~ ~u,r6~ tvv-. A~~rJ.
Go(\\-uckd 'fV\S'~ ~~·,n~ c~c\)\-~ l'v\ce\-W 0*- ~ O<'l'71{kd. Cle.c..ords.
A\- ~I. UA ~~· on 0\ a be vt \ 4-{- 0 S"" /W'. S ~ il ( v fVlt .d-eJ 1/'N",
AU-o' ~ 'M \-o bd l -e-u l"·f\j ~c.t+ fu_ r e\ U)CM_t oMA f-k ~ 0r-£. ~ ia(
('" ec...or d..5 \N ~ (\ ~-\
e.\e.00vl\- ·-\o ~ '-V\~w-~ t'll_J '"Ct~\vts.e.., get-\-
c;
' {)~\..ead. ~- €J'\~ ~~~ a.HeJe~ 6'1 (\'\{'. JU..;I(RJ -\-o \oQ t'n
{' eWVIlt. ~ b\hef' tA~-e_s. C..cvl4-oJ Cih\:> "'-ad ~-et\c\.in_g a+~-
~rN._ • S-e.Q_ e )C...~;b~ t '' \-V 1 £~fa. cvr'd E")(\xi\,\. \ U'' , ~ Uf rq.
1 11
l ~) ~~1\\~ ~\~ ~~ ~~\)ecA\ ~\<--'""'~ ~~ ~ /"\~\\sif w+l\ t.:I-IJ-Ll~
(v\(\,
4.\- ~ 1c.h ~ rr--1L W~ <"' e<.M~~ :e-v' 4, a_ --H·v~A- u:t1*' r~ ~ %crt
1
~.e.. ('~ r~s c_"'- \.\-or'\ ~ ~ l -\1 I"Y'JL C¥1 ~ ~'\ \(J €n\~ Jcx.tJ ht W-1ife_ (n . . .
(...0
{> z \1hof"\ ~ r ~ r (\ a ~ M a.v~~J fa ?t So f)~
~···.
,(
(_sj Mf"'. c;~,\)Q.r ~('....Jcif'6-e~ Catk q ~!.-£ o.Q--\WL Pr-e.~Ql h~a.NA,,~
ce_c..o{' ~~ on 5-c?..-l.l..~JRJL £".J<-~ 1 {ott \{ Vtt ~r I"Y\r. Sc.!.tl.I(V's 1~-\-W
~ Gt l-\.-vn ~ ~ ~ s -.;l - r.J... 0\f pe-t~ 1 '1--.- a-\- ~ Ct fX- 17!
(_c.,) Of\ f :l-7-1).... ~\e_Q€_ S.clh\\'.Qf' wa~ \.oU/1 & -\-c ~. \()<..o"'i1~-\- G/1-~
LAJn.i \J.lf'batly \'~r lt'Y\<D-1~~~ b'-! ~ ~\.N'\ QofoPW~r ~catl~rt t?ooJ?d
-Cor h\~ ~\w-e ~ \>~w--e ·-\-f'c.v\.H..dp\-j ~ were pe-t>?~ \y f'e ~ ~J te J
t.etl~ CV\·~ -\?or -G~lJQJ ·+o MqJ0l. r eqJ()I)aloly i·n~U-f'ri e1 Cl'~t)Lt~
6"--l
~. e*.~-\ o~~ \eU) r~ ., ~~. Ex~~(,\ r vvr• -f!of' c. (t_C.t3, Hlno( 11
or~ tt"\ Uu..tr.e AJQ, 1.;1-tl '-P(O~ -dJ J.. q.pat ~ ~ qt- pqp-i 3~- ({()
(·7J C9n 't-..11.{,-1~.. L4l~ ~._u~e~ ~~Sc.Oul~ a D.4vltvl~ fe\kr ~'t Gli'-
-\t~-e~ Mcvt'l lalae( ~7()1~ <JtoLiO OCVJ (~~ \ '-llfo(o ....L:~Ad. le\-~ wa.S a(ru
.£[-e-~ <...v \~ ~ (Yi ~~---(c\ civ-1( <Y) ~ - s- -( ~ . ~~,fc0tt. d ~~ J_ #tct-\- (V\1\
J Uht\lw ~ tet>ore 1 CJu~ ~ r WiJ. ~(e ~ ~\J4JM~ p~q{ h.Q~V'/~ f'C:-
c..-oS'~_s \ 0 -\1-e. .Af~:e \l cJ::o Cou-.M As A. SVffl ~A- +o -\1--e.. record
o" Afreo \ ~" App~a( .AJ\1 , OJ..- o lf -:L.J_ z - c.(\_. f_.e.e__ ~h ,~l +'( X''
~r Cctl~'s 04vlcvtd f-e~.\{r--l-oJ~ev~ ~Jl-t~11.e/' crf07!1'( q4-pape_.s 41-<.tl
(_~ S\-ei.)..Q. s~H U' \'ec..el~ .rc::U~ 0~~ \et~ ~ /~.J{) ,..,~ ~ L{).fl-
~\f~~ b'-t 11'-e ~\IAfV\. ~~t CAr6 beo.rt~ f\N'~ ~cltdlV'~ StJf\ct{W'e
-\hQteDfl ~~ E~"', \, l \- \' Y'' -fos- -\1-...Q_ Pi . ~frV\. J ~I ( 0 c~h c
(I .
(leJWV\ 'O..e~t Cc4'~ ~~~'f-. ct+ pc:tre- Lf l{'
('1) \h~ ..\~ ..\c.J.t1lle.r re~ces -to C91ft D\..l1-- l;,J. I'W{tt{J~.q (
cl~ b'-( ~U"Jl --\'1--e- <'-t\-<.AJ M~ rre\<1 q \ ~ s t!--c.+ -~~ sdot~/ k_p
(/'('_(..i>'
A_() v-) /t:.rv.wS. QJ-e. \'e\-UJO'i:\- +o -1'4_ UA.w \..r 1/l.f 0 fC-vt t-e_ '
·g
~:S\.\M~ OA6 ~~"'\-y
~ ~\0 SQ.. <'.\ e_ct ~~() -~ S\0.1\~o..f'~ 0\- ~e..u( e.v0
~) ~ u.w\.e,~ S~ s. Sv-prQ;{\{L Cew"-\ ~ '\n~\rvt~ ~a\- ~ro-~-e_
p \ .(_C\~~() ~~ s h.o~\ b (\\)\- b.L h~ \ ~ 4-o ~ J~ ,{\-eM·~~~ As
~sQ. ~<:'a \;\e~ 'by {cv-vy-U'...S .. 1-u. x"' ~\~Lo_r ~~ .sw .sJ .Jt~Or
;2 <{ 5 ( T ( 1-. Mf CQr co ..2-ooo.J (c ~-\-;~ ~a,{'(\ {.S. \J v. Jlj Mi' Lttn-l u -~ .5 (l f s .,t 0
(_ \ q /)..j ·i A \s-o ~- 2_~ ~q ,J. 2~~Y. i r f-w] & 1 ct""'l 1 y;·~ C\e"-f.-. A(Jp .Sa/f
~~o 1'7'9q no ~e.-\-) · 7 gCV'0Q.-S \.J s.-~ .~.:?l_\-.oA~ ~1tt,~.:t~ CT-e"'-,
-A~q, ~ ' h ~·,o l q9 '1 , tl~ ~-\- ) •1 rs~<'d.o vI cue ~oSJL- ~\q .h.oJ.c\ d-1~ 1
J.tG CT~-t-- AtQ- ~co l1'71j. ~ -rhl\5 eo~!\- j 'lo~t~ ~.SOf\a~ ly
r ~ ~ ~ v\6\- 0\1\.\ Q.e\,\-;.;{') tt u., \~- \) ctAl-ert LQ. 0/'\6 I , 6V'a \~ ~ /~S-e_e
~ \€.. \ ~io\ .:t"t SwJ d Q/\-· J L{ s- ( u.\-ln_g goJI/\li ¥ 1J. f-w~ ~ q-\
Y..~l..Qp ', Ac..c...o r- ~ g \:r·~ ~ \9 s \. .'\.) ~ cl. q:-\ ~ 1'o "
A\~ gh (l.L\~r tf\ ~ ~cH~t CctU. "'-ct.s f\~ Go<vf1(e~ w\\t,
1~-t- .Q ..A~G- ~, ~ SJ..'l (~) Cu .CJVJL.\-o ~~ lA~IS0t\ CtA~ Ul\a~
-\-o QVS dAa <;.Q.. LV"'-h~ -e ~· o.r-- ·s-w-urf\ CDQ"l e.i ~· Q\ \ ~ t.o.NU\_s Mt;<Wt a(
CV\~ ~(l ~ vf~~'\ c\--h\~ wn\\ 0~ M~~ ~\aln.e~ ct\'\ -\1--e.. Ac...-
C.OrY'\f20N-(l(\~ Apq12A"6,,-'/-. ~n ~vf~ Qf'-\. ~iUe~oJ-~f ~~J -4ply
a ~ ·t~..Qf'at & \0/\~ OJ'<:\ ~<V\ r 120\ ~\'j> ~c-oLe..- ~I eq~"' ~ CPVa
ha~ c....o~\~QJ'ed ~ ~\_s co~. o<'\ ~ lnq\ u:>ICilQ.Il~f\g.i €.0~ tko~h
~ . ~ ro S.Sl.. ~\ ~ r~ ~ l.eQ ~;,r) gs ~atle~ -\-o -9u Ik, c.p "i' ly w l 4\c\ ~the_
· a.~\\ <Ab\.9... 0. ~ ~~ ~ oJQN\.~n~ · ~ v~ u;>leq~W\_\) f Q .Le..Q ..:r;, ('12__T CU.C l o.r'
.;<~ ~3~ Q.\- ')t.t[,.Cuh'QJ Wood.S ".f'\\..)~z_ 42S' S~.z.~ II '7;
I
tll L\e-i-- A~~ ~"~u& (k\~\\ t b~~ ~(O(QQ~~) 6UQ/'t;'~-~ Of\~
f'I"\Q.i\\~ \).5lJ' C w\CW"'' S u~. nor\-\· « c1d~~~~ / R-re~1~e... ~ -~-\\f'
~~ C.Ou0-\ tl\- A{>Qe-e~\s q,?-7 rwJ.·~ 4ll-O CT~ (99<p}J C..RI\~ v ~/\0-t~ ~ ll_
S vo'l.~ (p7; 7° LT"t'~.A(>p. \:\-.oy_~£1~·\- \)1~-\- '] \99( 1 or1_g ~ro<..QQ~fl2 4 (.eav-€
d~e-~J -, \Lc~_(L~ Q~£: ,L\--~ V {]j.i-\- W""u~'04\ D\~. C-\-. ~l.l(J~~·~
I
<P~1~ \.o4l(' C\e~. ~V· .S lV\ Ar\~\ o \99'{ 7 C><""'i3 \)f·oc.w~ttg) Co~1'~ i ~ro-
,
~~(\~ ~\- ~()w\ul·n_g ()(()i.e_ ~aJ"htJ ~s.e_ CouJ'-\-i ~ou~ klQ-
-\-u~~~ ~~ 1 bu:.GU,t~ fV'-0~-\- l(co<.QJ~~l ci~k~i i\., a ~~_g
~ l eq,M·n___~ Co/\ ~. ("e.~ ~\. \~ ~ rre~ e c\ 0/\ d- ~ pIe CA.~\t'l f (~e.-fl( ~ J.1
~ ~'"k-~~~ e>~ Ju~\4a.( et.-<J~ .s ~-\-1~-.e..c J'-Uh~·e..s. etd.dt'ellcn.__p
~ 1\1'\,ltJ'l~.\ o \- ~ \>.e\tha0 CtS 6q'.Jt'rRAfy -h\~d-.:r A a-\ ..ll{7~ (c.~'nf
l"')'\)a&~ q .15 .s ....:>J.J C{\- 1:t \ i Cn:l\M ~ \).. s \.0 ~ ~ q:\· 70 't ~.r-e~lte PaJ'~-
1\ u.s ~ \q 9 sv0 J d. Ct. t-- (Q~\Q, I
_x_, .{:4 c._.-\ CY'-0~\- \( (')\)-t- e<H '0\;-~ eke~~£ c..o~r.e:~ rn
~. Acc...o~cw1i". ~ ..i Vf\)<:>J'~n.g oq~~\ )( ~in ~ pL{b\ic re. '-'?.r J CVJd
~.s CV"e- A.-O\ ~ '--t .r ~.{-t lo\..p -h:> <l ~~ j ~ LGVlJ>d. ~ v ll II th ( ~I 3
.1 w:>-d.. ID1 1\<tCf-QO {T~. Af~ 1-kt<JkA[i~-,., ~~~-\-] 199/lllo(l'?f)~T«~~
0u ~,-uq{_ ~(Q. ~ .j'--fbjM.~ \ o\- ~~~b~fY\Vt\ b~~f Q ''~J4\r""0'\-\
t~ 4.. N'\4\-W @(:., QC-{\:olic r-e..c.oN. 0/\~ 11q_s ~~ct-t t \.\.-. \~ c.~b~ o-G- .
Qcc.w-£tt...e 0v1 d- ceo~'i d-~~(/. crho() b'i. \'-eJt>f'+ .-h::> \'-e-~~urJL
~ s.-e_. O...QLu..l'a ~ LCU\~ ~ ~ e.C<.S o~ly 'r ' l eJ.\; ilf\ ~ 4
(_~ · ~\- ~ ~o.r~ ot; o..~,~ ~' 1VI4/lc\.~ ~{ e\ ~r--Cn~I\Q \ Lo...JJ mC£::\-W.S
(_
-")o o\o\a1n M~~ relit{ rn ci~incA Ievv0 f'Vtct_.\ ~I
\" Cc, "".\ cv:~\
l ~ All4+\-tr..s J q ~l~ ~-\- -e_J\-aloh~ ~ ~:\..(_\j
~ ac.,\- h..rL J..R_Q_~ \-.co ~\ ·1 i ~ ~·ni .\Wjq ~ 1 rcr-rhV" ~Gil
I
Q-{,\,.\;. vf'\ ~=-a, <...01'1-\- 0~ ""':"' ,\.~ p Cc ~ \'D-\-J_ i
j
i
•
'· l
d\~cre.\\1:)"~ 1 ~ (J..j "~ c;:~tu~ \~~ aA \4vJ \,~ ct.ua.tla.~U...
S. -ee_ ~ ~ ~~\~ \ 9o Sw1d. ~~] t~S.S CTe~. Affr~i:lM U)aJ'~ .2.0-o~
A" Ac\- \s. ''~·"\~w\o\ //'~ ,\ ~ (\";;)\- \1'\\)o\v-e..-\-he. e~uj.e_-c{ ~ dH.-
Cn~.~"r"l ·: A ~n-\~~~ a\ a c..-\ \s. o rve. witt\~ 's ctc.c.t>~l\1heo '-'>t~u\ ~
e~ul-\\e o-G ~\~cre.~bn or ..)u~g""~\ .. :r\-~we. \~ ~ d\i<.r-e~cn or j\.(~\uq(
6e.'\v~Acr~o" et \-~~cvr\ ~ 0-vL ac\- 1 \~ \':.. f"'l;;)~ I'YlAni1W{ ol \n (\a-\.u.I'(L, A.Jor ·,_s
Q ~\~~W\a\ ctL\-- \ fV'\~) ·, ca.\..e~ \~· -\'\-...e -\<\a\ C..Ou.."' ~\t -~ ~h Got1-G\i c.\1 nJ
wa \
c....\~rvt~ b.f' c....o \\q rt1ct\\.tr...s ~ \Gv, \'e..<(LU.. f"e. l..ej ql ..)'-"~j>M€A\: ~ ~ eovJ{ 0~ Cd-
1
(\1\A·Aa( ho.s. ~~itr\'oed. ~ f'-.\\n\~\v'·ta\ Ct<:..\- t"e-'ll4\r'Ovt~~ ~S. ct. ~-e_~~..q\rev,(tA:-\t1ct~t
~ Q-.12.\c.A-ur~ ~\.!'-€. '\o ~"' r\·~~ ~ \ehe+ $otJu.j\.,·~o ~~\.dp -e)(.r-e\ (Lo-
~~~v..Q2.- v Mcv-1_\.Jl.e'L ~ S-wl& ;Ll.7,:l).'3 <.Ae'/....C(IIVl Apf·
19'71j', J~ e~~~
LA.:>ct~l '-.1 Mo.A{~ Ca'i'1 J w;,·~ ~'13 1 ~q9 (Te~. C..rt."'\ A{Jp. 19"3&-J .. ~c-e\lef -r~\tt
~ \- ~ 11 U~c.S' CV\ ~ 1 n ~\.s\i f\_g \.t.l~ \,a~t.Q ~ "6\~p~\-o·\alL // J4c..V1-\i-,~ ; :\-~
Meh\.-i ~ ' 1 ~~oflc\ d\~Q~ .:r~ aA:- '¥. (7 .·-o-~.u L.VJ~QJ'k (\fl1·vtti~q( Ac+/
0
c \-to.J" \esu\ t \~ 'n\ ,e. 1 v1\fe.wt~\ , ~ \~ ~-\-\ ,, c.lQa.f'~ -ire 11 o'-'<~ ~ ~uJ\y t-v~
~Q]'-Cu.rc--.Q_.~ L.Vt-\h ~OA(\~ ~ct\- ~1 Q.S> ts \ e\A ~~- -e#).I"G('~ o{ ~\~(JetlW)
Q(' 0\..A~j fV'\.QA\ ...-,...X d ot\- 'C,'1 "yvJ"-\1nQF --VN_ tiC~ ~\- b.JL ' ~v~1\;u--e..~ C..ONl-
1
MAA6~c\ ~6 ~-'V ~\CM\f\ ~ ~€~cri~~~ ~ W ~- \eu.J QS .\-u \o.e. ~~~ <ku\a\ ·
Se.e. Q,W\.~on v \\c.s~.n "'6:>..1 ~...0..1-b CJ4.S"" 1 CJ~9 er~.Cr,'IV\4-rf-19'1.:l,),t1'nQ11ra--roc.k
\ s ~~ "' ~ \-er' ~ \ \\
,\ ~-\t.~ i ~ c\ VI~ ~Lv .W-t e ~ lNl~ \ ev.t.-t\ce~ by . )
t ~ . .L.e..e j ~ e~ ~\ C..w'r'i. 1?-CQSw.l., ~ I.)$' 1 1·1_~ CTe-J...Cf\'"" Afp- 19"6 7.J
C 0<\~io~[ ~ r~@l\..' 1\.j) • v\N <U 1'1 ~ ":"'~""" "~ ~ J~ \,.(__ f>ul'lu.Q d. •'n -\U- )owe/'
C...OvJ'\-~. \-hwe.v-if ~v-.t.-~ UtA~~ (' ,~\rtt ~ 1()U~\dQ-\ ()/\~ s~~~
Af~a~ o.re a\- s\a¥-e. ~-~-eJ\\- Aec.eQ'~~ Ceill.s fur -\1-.e. e'j.SZJ'tt:-e- o~ 1'1n1~
c..-ovJ'\\ os\ ~{"'at _)W'\.\~~c.~dl o \. ~ U:>vJ't oC- \ct_s\- ('('.i()J'.\- ~.l~ ~ V
W\ \ ~ ;)..~ Jvv.;) 6 .5\.S (\e i-. \q 3 riJ/ p.._~Q.Urat'Y-. v &""cwJ (p).. "t .l;wJ.. 6 'J.77,.10 ~ CS"-#)
c.. \ r 1q ~t)J ( C) V-L ~ rult ~1 C.GA 'o~ 6!2At e d b·-1 ~ J '-t\oi\-cvr\1a ~ (4~CIJ1 ~\-;on '()G
~ A(>~\\~ {)\OLHi 1 flld.M~f)g 0/\ e~LH..I\\)'-Q. <\,.e\~ \1\-Cwll\iW"J o.Q. q-\('Oil-
S: C.<'\Q~:n oG :w~"IY'-0"\ ~le\.Jov-1 ~r ~- ~le\i~ o\~ ~\\~ K-
c.....oc~) .AA o\~ciQ\ ~""'~ ~ur\Rr \i ct ~wo<"'l) o\-~~ oG-~ l..ovJ'\- 01\·~
\.-vo\ ~ o~-C.\ 4> C\.~ M_ ~\ ~ cui.J..f'€ o.C ~ LovJ'·\<~ ~~-A \-fe .i o.r--e \J;\a.\ -\-o
~ ~~~~ u a:\ Q~<X.e. \.~ ' 1 ~ C..OvJ'\- ~ or-.\Rr f'v-..l\-i \- fV\4J}L.Q_ o. ~ e. eo~ 6
\)-e~~l>f"\ ~f" W<'~-\- C{- (VI CUt ~.i p ct fe_ Cf"6-r J. 4
·"
\ 'i
0\ ~ e_ CovV'\ ~ \ C)~~~n ~ S I rvtc.· \Le f'l\)~ 0~ v'o~e.c__.\·\ onS QA. ~ \"' u 1J 0 8-.\ l
MGV'\(_ 0/"\~·-h\e ~~~,\,,\.~ i'f~"~~ ~e.?u.QJ\-e~·kcvt~CJ\p\-__s QA~ ~+orfVl
1
o-\-hQ.~- Ot<:.. \s r~\~f)j ~ ~ \ ~orw~ e(~~ ct'\ d. 4\1 eJ u.s. -\1--e \t\Ql Co~-\-
~ tr ee;k~ o .S--e.e.. ~ ')(,.·\...;~ b'\\- s. "~t ,'1 tt' 0/)d "'C '' +a~ ~. _ , llf'\ac,+;f'Y'\ \ei...~-S
o-€ \e-... Cs-o\,) 1 -\ AC'\f\ ~ <; ~.()'-\\o 0v1~ l~'ll.Q...Aff.P. ~ IJ.(p
L-ou
OV\d ~~ .(o ~A f'\ o~.(:.)cict\ Co~\ ~orW hetS ·-\'h. Q. ~-lU\<ucd 6Y~ -\-a -*uv . -
1"'11\.~ ct \-('M\V'\\)t c~ ~r.~or\..ed, ~\~V\4' OVI~\)r<X...CU~n~J i\() QCUJ\'-
dlV'\<L vvl1'\r) .s~e~h<.. ~('0\J\)\uAS o{ ~ GoVV/\/1"\Cl-1.~ Co~~ s..QQ_ e~-
. htb\~··'A<c .S~rq ~~e-~... G-\)v'~ eo·u_ .k(\ t S .)..64\o (iJ.t)(Sj,.. An o{*'<)q·l
CouJ'-\- ~o~ekr \S ..s-.. lo~(.c_,\ ~ 1'\AMdrM-4~ ~\ \e-0.rcd -\--o ~-.sU'..f-ofM
d'-l-t\ei, S~ .S~ " 0-uf ~<] s-
h-\~ o~-C;ua.\ J'-0.l. ~ ~7~1 9oo (Te'f...
Aff· WQGO l i 1.S t cc,' s ·£? (~~03) ·1 c \ h.t -o~ ~~\eJ -,c;\e v -:rc'nA~on
s 1'1 s \."yJ.~ \4 ~ 11.ro C\e {.... Aff. Cor~L.ti c.tv-1~\--\ 1471Q 1 of~ Pf"(J}.R~ ins)
.:::L\- \..<; ~ 6-u~ o.\- ~ loiN'\ ~orW \o ~ r ¥ o..re
~S~\ <0~{4.(_\~ 4~-e..e. G-('~\J'-Q.i v ~\..1.\~ fOJ....SvvJ.cl. IJ1tl 1 J/Ilp
CT e 'f...· C..\\,) --Ai f l=Or \--..uot-\{A I q]lp 1 fH::; v...J {'1,-\- ) ,A C-(...0 r ~· n._f~ 1 b.e ,(:.ol'{. q
(A)r,\:· of Ml?A~J '-Vi/ I ~ H.i~~ -\-a ~'{ ~ r--e_ ..n..e_ ( '¥orlPJ -\-v
\)C~o..I'e.. Dl. J-\-~\ 0\- ..Cctc...\~ 1 -\-1-..Q_ c- e.,\~\-o \ f'Vvls:t- J h-ow -the.(+
a_ ~<MW\~ "'-c..ts. ~ Mu~ o.(- ~ (OforW W! 6 ~41{-. h.e
h tt.i (e.~ ~-e~ .. ~-t.Q_ s~ ¥- \) P\:ldd 11.o s '""-> ;_~ {,p(or i ~..peo 9 (T-£t.
c \\.l . A r f. g-eawvo ~- \- t'i J \.{ , /t.i:) v.:r 1\ ) . A l-\ivouf~ fW'. s&;,, f~ is (\ c w .
\ e.\-he J · A c....:...A{'-\- Ro.f or..\tr ~ ~ctS r~.1 if~'~~ 6 or \ ~ n-u Lon J..if" iUv"f loy.e ~
'\ " ~ ct\ ~Oft\ Gul'+y \.-, q ~ ~e.. c...on-\1 uJ l1j ~ ~ -\-o r ( ~aVe .s ~ \: ~ .Q. ,
(1 '-'t
-G4cl~ ('(\ ~~~ c...as-t.s ~("\~\eRA hQ wa.s ~ c~.C,ua\ Louf't P-Df~~
S-e.L ~<::~'1\~1\ ·-J ~ct\q \p~<o s-w.2-~ s-rD,S7f rr~.ArP,JCV!~~o /9"6:Y
·'"
I
~ ~~\ 0~ \\ a:t.Q -\-0 c...oi"V\. ~~ \ ~ ~ V' ~ ftvt 0/1 Lt 0 -t
"f\1\ a,t'\~Q./\NLS \
C{ d'-{~ \ ~~ UA\OJ' 1 ~ ~ .) 4 '6.\ U Ct l ~ '--( \_s. 'f"vv ·n,\ .l \.vi q l a 4
£.-e..t &-tl\vu\ ~\or~ Loc.'~. -~ t\,J\f\S ~ 30 J1...0 ..}~ ~S"S r)S7 C(e-J.-. .Aff·
Gv\~1..-\S ~\~\\ \ 99~ 0 \ 1_1 Q(O~~l()~ ). Ah 0 Jft -S~JU' \J f'V\~i.l2-Lf S'i'.l..o
J ...v.i..~ '1.'-\ ~ \~4\.o (-"\ei-.. ~q/1_) (~~ -e'i\\GtOt:>Jr\oJf VVf'l\ (V\Cv...( frD'{JV'ly
\~S.~ -..v"'-vt ~ e;..\~-\_s ct \Q.~Ci\ 'b"-f\r ·-\-o \>V"4..rl"\ er t"\..,'n\~\RJ.ic;(.
0t C \- , ~ Q._K {.~ b.e.. C\ ~ Q./V'k:Vl<l OV\c\ C{ ( €_~j C, r) . .5.\- e_,(/'-{_. ~ c...l-, ~~ l.erj
f\N ... \
~ u~-'\-o ~r~~ 1 u.r+.·~ 0/"\~ ~le ~ ~1\J..Q.s\-ed ~reA-f\a\ hg::v'lQf
\-rMscri~\~ I.A.)\~ ~ o..pre-\\~ eouJ""\- \S rn~'n~~iif1q( pvV's'-fwtt
~ 'Te-'l- &Dv'~ Co~-{ AN) ~ S) .{)Lj~ D/\~ \e~. {(,A~- ~J 13. lo
Cv'\b ~~~~ ;.s~r4 . . ~- e~h,lo,-~s 'Au,''(5i( ~"C'' ,sU-rr~ ~ e:sr~u·C<tkt
tA tt:~n-\ o-\. W\6 \e~~ ~jt\'hv' \.A)·\~ ~ hv-eA'()'~t.t~ r o..r-
(>U/V'\VV\- . 0V'I ~ evvt -0rvo~th e.s .. ~\-~ ~~~~ler ~reu Gh hii IV'-4h" \.vi ~r
~~~ --..J~Q./\ N.. \U~~e ~ -\-.o ~\<2f~- ; t.V'.\-,~ C\:/\d ~\e ~ \e-
~ v...e.)\.ed. (Jr~\1\cd "-ec:>.df\j -\-raA~c.r\p\-..s. C{\~·-\~~ \t\q\-qf' h4~ ~e-
1\1\~~e ~ '(V\J"' .. s~~~l u- \--o 6o .s--o.~ E-j_\·\\Li\- ~ \, ~~ Q/\c\ \' Y" J ~ f''1_ ....
·~v-e.\-ore. ~e. ~\~\ <4-t\M-\"~V~-\- ()\'. ~--~ \tct~ \o~ ~\\ ~\le_~. N\
A.Jow ~ ~ U.u..t~~\on o.f\ ~ S -(..C.O.n~ Q,o0j 011 -\1.---t ~\an
~ CAJ'6 I I.A.)\.-.e~if' \)....t\c:.tk- "Ci~ W\ ctl~f"lct~v-e_ O~Qf' ~lVI /VJM~
Ct \-a '~e. ~'1 {W'- S.~,\~v-'1 \ ~~":>q{ ·\o «r~o.,re 1 C%'h~
6Qti.AoU
0/\ ~ ~~.t. ~ ~re\.1\·, q\ ha..~()j \-rOI\su\~\:5 C\~ 'et~~\-e..~ 0/'1 ~ ~e;vw,~e 6
b'-{ c e..\J.or J-~~ \s f\~ ~\i)\.),~~\on -\or ~a\ c.-onc.et(\~'n_j
ht J <1{i} ·rf? d r~~ V>?w -J o -\' J(Y"\ _)0-:! u('tttt"J b
J.I) [I ' U l'! "t. f bL t: ff C0 S' c1) t1) ~) f\. \)q-0"~ craf s\'V , c~/) ::t=.
0
"oVt>J .tJ{Yl f\ h9 "r akl'\\Q-v Wd''1 ~I?"\ '\' ~ 0'""1 .d) ~ ~Vd- ~ \f?~
DLA.,v--vJ,l}UCY') t'~lj.} b 1/}? -\Vd) fl\JO~ \'t>VW bv'-\c V "\J'"'OJ J
(bQOr ~\"""at,\ [-t~'.G \fiJ JJv·"""~l."J \l.~' L~~ \' r~ s 'hb't t:ro X"2W
1\ "') I' 7 I ) \ V?i Vlll-'q-1' ~_r <. G--r-10 p \\ ~ (\. . 0: -~
b orr ' \.NO '\k 0-\ va ':\"" ""\-·
_ ).S'·~ v~l~-a ?VO ~\0 ~ \\~Ov ~- \.J~ )~.JCVJ ~~ o---v\ ~\~ "00
~hr \t?~~~uW\.1 ~~'i -tna hJ..ro"J .;;~ ~- 0-\- JCI\ ~vr>s '\.JW .)o_]- s--~ 5~Y¥V
U~-l )) ) -1- l? "'tn ~ JO j) ~\f)) "~ \..v.c JJ- ~"1'<7 \; S'> o\ f u ,wo~ 1o StJCV"' "'\A:J
U~\~) t:jo~ \<YV so<:>CJ ~ \~ \.,0~\J~ )~""\ -;JO JO{\':>~ ~v~
Ajf\, )t\f -tn'-11- :r~J<n o-~ ~ ~lJ r J-o J,-,o~ )l?llCfJO~ ·o uO-\YlOJ ov.~~0oJ c\
~oJaw ~-v;J ~r- ,/\,, \i~~~~~~ ao-s .. y.xncru ~~Jo~vu l~~wo\Jhr ·--o ~v
"...$00\ U\' )>\'J I? 9 pn>Jc}Q \..Jc \S<n? _) ~ \J~ ~~\f'f'()Vl ()--f\1?~ ~ \ V)~Y"C S'
l,tV?Jd:\tJ -yvv ~(!--.V.I.\ t.J<l-t\ l-J') '\"'"'¥\ S'~Jcn o) f u~-M""\ v))~N ~ 4'-AJO '5
00--fP:>J \'a,~CV'~ JO-jP_!.fJ~ 'J\N tb'tt o<'j\ )~ \\ '1~~V
r~"1! '1!?-t~51 11 ~ r-~ ) oiJJ\f uo ~J~ \\;(} n CjSh \' ~ vo ?-1-a-I():;;UCYJ v- o _L \''\ ~N
} olP~"'t'-\-~\JCJ -\lli7VJ~~ VJ-. h' ~ vu hJO-\ Y"f'~) r-1vo ~ \~~ vy
TIT
· "'D"I\1\\J ~ ~v~ jd\M 'i~lfr.:>vv J<>}- ~~vvo-.):r"'va ~
)IV .. td'\a--'> }nvlo~VIo\.A.-\ ...)or
~wo- ..:nnl~ ~uOJd-S ~ \(r-0J )l?~
J ~ b\ ~ -;}.JG.J ~ ""\),. ( O)C>OL. ·6~ · w 1-.Y) 'i--.,_L) }1 L h 1 [ L h ~ [' C"' S L ~ \
11 ,n,p \J'~\~~Q C'\ uo~'d~ tnr-) • ~\ -\;'17 ~ o-i..l'l"d..> ~Y\b~'? av
0}\-\ t'i l S"(rA!7o \ )o~~ :Jo h.tf\'~1ou~ a--u- ·-\V"YlOj ~ \\~oy
.J ~ b\ v
~ u.~ "'-\Ohr>WV)-\ d'v.\~ P'\l"\<NO d-"Y\: "0-\l.j- '\'V>o ~~VD 1 OJ'O~..)b
~ ~h~ o~~~v-~v..J ~~~ '-->).~-.£15~ ~
) \ l?'SY1().) ),J'~\\ ~V(IS '.J\]J
\
'
OJ\.'"\,\AA.,-..~
\ e_\ Q...VD/\ \ \ S 0 rvq \--\.e ~ ~ c-o""' ~ ~o("' ~-.S ~ <..o <:'~) Y\-e \r\ cA
c., W' ~ ' ~ AQ(>·{,\\ ~ LovS'\- or avu., reu'~ M ~ \o~ Ie~\.er ~i r ec\ -\hJL
~~u4 \ LovJ'\: ~o~\.er \o ~\~OS'€ ,0P-\r~ C<A~ ~\<.. \(\ ~ Apf-e \'I~
LoW"'~ A ~~~\~~Q;\ ~o('W~ (l~c.o('~ Cu(\\cl],~Mj ~of"V\-,\\-e~\\eNts.
A("\"-\ £~~\~.et\\q\ ~o<"'W~ Q-.Q,wr~ H ~~\ o~ ~ App..e\\a:k:.p RQ,U)<' t,"_d
~ -rew.i Cof\1\,~\1on ~~W\~d Ct dg\\\ -\o A~(>Qq\ -\-o
atl ~~~('\c.t\ \\\1~0/\~, J~ Jv ..o.\~of"\ v Kr4.SV\ <01"6 h..JJ-d ct1~ 1 411 CT0~ 19~L(j
~ .e..hrcd Dv-e.. QrvU ~ -Cor \o\~i ~ct-\- ~ ~ 4 o~ GV'b\'-\foJ';l[ € )( vLc..-t ci.~ '\s>
cv-\- ~-~ Qt>J' \\ e ~ 4o{V'\. f ~ -i'' n__g ~q \- \{·~ \-\.-\: .. ~. E u \ \i- ~ \} Lv. <- Ly
LOS s.c\ ~~o 1 ~Y.O (\q~c-...),_<0v-Q._~ro<..t~ \etu.{~e_s ~A4--C>r'lct.. ~
S \-u:k..Q ~c:U creG\\-€d ~. Q...U_£\r\\ oC A.qqea( 1 (t fV"M~'i o\W .e~c.V\ ~ eCv,-
1
~ Otl\\ CL ~ c.J{' n ~ ~ ~ t·1vr -\-o ~\::,\ ~ n CV\ &~ ~J'-'~ d.\ ctt-h o'l on 11--e. ""'Vl r\ ~
o (. 'nh A~Q.Qa~\ - ..:::r:. ~ et-\ "fl\.{ l ~ Onei 0/l ~e.ea( o~ d_gVIt h a.1 ~ j ra-tkd
-\"ncz... ~ r~<-e.~I..IV'e.S u~-e.-6 \(\ 6.e.u~(·nj Dfre-ah ~~~ c...o""Pt)-"t t-o 11\'(1\ ~
~~CV'\~S. o-C \Jv....R.. \>rcx.Q~~ CV'\-~ £1~'<,l Q(o\.ec!ion ()CM.{s-e.~ o{. Yh-e-
Cord-\,~:~01 a Le.e_._ E.u\\\-~ 1 S~f<:t _ ~. Lo(\J-\-zk hiYlq( ~~dA.~ .1-.S
~ct:\- ~ A·~~-Q\\~{K-Dl.Q.:~w-e ~s.\ ~n\~\, ~e GOM~un<?Ats 0~U
~.s~ ~\ ~MA\n...r~\ ( gv1.W .. .A .s'\-~ ~t>ut ~ 6.~ c,. ~~dQ/t-\
.s.~c..\1\. ct \l .(.aA\f' O(>-Qof'~\~ II \~ \\ ~ € ~Y <-e ~ ~ O(>~eu.A ~ q \·' ~'ng
t e ~~ (;' \\u.etl /r \J '"1 ~ .IC/\1.( t'r\jl h \!'I\ ~ ~~ ~ e_\~ec~ve~ (X'e S.S 'n\~
0-f~\\o.k.f a_r ~~\~
i.e.e. ~ ~~(\ \.} :r IIi(\·\>'~ 3.S \ \A.S, I~ ( \Gs-lcj (\~\6tQJ
Q
GA lA ~-j~\~ c-\~h.\ \-'0 ~e \rCV\.iCN~~~) '1 Co~~e ~_s.e '-l lM.tH J ~~J
·~~'t \...\,~ '--\1~ \ Y'-\\Q \.\~\.t>~ lQJ:8h\-\<> s~\~u-eA\ \c;-M!~p\) ·, \)r~ J
'-N et~\v:nj\-on ll1 u.~.'-\'1.( 1 L\ '7'-<- \ \Slo3) (s~j i \\6J"'~l-( "'~,\..e~S~s
~ ~~ u.s. ~ l l \.' ct'-t{} ( ·~~ n.\ \o Co~\~k -r:('o./Uc.r~e±)
..::r" \'G-(\\~1:\rrl ~ WCt~~\.Q~ o~J~~Co-~\rlN'\.sv-rp-\-deGt
.s \.WIJ ~e_. ~~{'~. (AUf\\-~\~ ~C{J\- \\ ~{~\-,~ ~-<.~.~--\~-\-.5. (Yv.A.~ \o.!2
oJ~)~oc-~.e~ o.S. ~~4.~cd:..e Of~~\\o.k.e re,),.ew ot" ~e~~Wl\~ ~~qu-e_
fV'A>f'\~ %-vvu.~\r\ --\o \ol \r~lf,\~\-i . 1S \ u.1 C0\ \~ ~ -\h\~ h....o 1 ~)"j
~ e.~\e~ Of'\ ~ '' C...OrUh~~Of\u( 0 U~a/\W S 0~ .~~. ft<>U~S OJ\~ €.t '--<etA
\> ~~c\\u" 'bo~ o \. ~ w··~ c...et.\ \ -\.o, ~( t>u.Jv,res ,-n c..d~ n4l -\ d ,A~
~\UA q\'!ow Au \ l\v-\~lb-..tS ~\~<s\~()q'-'(f) b.e~ {J..Q/'JunS ~~
~' \w ~\ ~ \Ov..-Q.s e-C ~.RP ~ tf'\s .v ::r ~ ~-\- \c ., ~ s~ r ~ c...o uJ\-\-
J CV..~ ~\~o\'i ~ a\;,\\:~ ~ ~~ t-o~\~ \n a~-.>W1<-t h-€Q{"..i l\1:> c;q'n!Xlc;{
c e..\"'\\ 0\\&~\ f ~ ~e ~ ~ ~\!_s 5 '--tl. \-\- or \n f\ ()(.2./l U.. -=t" d. C1.-\- \I &/) ~ \ ~ • A'"' ··6.
~ l\v\~e ~ ~e-tA "~ Q.J€ (..CV\ ~. (\/10 e '(_ '--fGI \ J Ul\\~ '-'\..) hQJ€ ~ \-Z~ () ~
b..C. -\-c\C\\ Ct "'"'W"\ 3 e\s ~~.JU~~s o" ~ ~ ~6 o .(;. ~"~ ~ ~ec.~-~ J
oA- \q_ ~\~ \~ ~o b~~ \\,\ \~ ~o tM6~l..¥h4-\-; onc.t..es\ab{ilNtdr
ct \J M v-e ~ cl A Q~ \\ d:_f \ VJ\ e.-vv rr-u..s.-\ \o..t? ~\- +r-ee o {:.. lA/\ rea s o11 e 6
~,~\n"v\\1.)(\s ~cA C...CV\ Qf\~ \~~~~Q. orvtan~ -e.1_•-u:u{ ac..uu~~
L...ou..A-..s /1' •. ~ <l_~ 1"\q \6\ v 1' .e c..t ~..if' 3 't '{ U.. L 3 OS
1
) J0 ( \9 (ptpj
~Q/'e~tt ~(\ ct\.-l c..01.~e~ ~ ~~.-~~ oC~.s~ 1-.\ .\--::, ~\ov\M
~ \1"\'0-~~~\ Ct~ ct~..e 1 -...t.~ Oc.A~ e\.\-e~v..e. CV\ C1p~\\ctk; '~\~ as
~&\\ ~ ~\) U\ ~-(> e, \\tV\~~ v,., \~ ~6-.s. ~- C:l(' ~ \1 )._ -~- 4-\ \{ '1 \o ~ .
l.\
(_ ~\~ (\ ~+vt \-o''-(
""- 4 ~ ~ J OV\ ~ c....om~ Of) cd g_.( ~VI-\ -\-o C., l.-Q"'f I~ \-e.
( ~ co~~ or\ ~~.ecd q\- S~ -e ~ i..e_ ct ~ W1 \1\ ~ j-0\.\ ~\\OJ\.-\- .. .u...t
A\orvo\ '-'~~ -ztl.h.....>·l.~ \3:1 1 1.1?-ILiO (~e-1-.. Cr\'CV\·Af~·l<r~~J- 1 G-rif-h'n
"3S\ v ..S.\l. 1 S\J-(>\Ct,~~ff\-e~q~ l~ QA i"'6\s~\ ~e~'~cvA \~~-h+l-e~~
-\--o ct {-\-e.€.. ~Q/\!>V"\Q\ \-c N.- ~ Y-e~ ot ~~,e~· ~\- w_. ex. QoJ'k
\ rcv\l\e.J' \ ~\ sw ~ 6 S$"£ 1 3.s-~ -S( (-:)e-'f..-Cr--\fV\-...A,-pf. .;>-o o.s") , A \.i o JJU.
c .\. \ -I \I {,-,.\.l "' (\ )\ ,, ( I\ '\. "' .....,...- 11
c jvh,\::7 \ 1"' .l \.X. I 'f- I ~ CV\ o \ I S ~ r"'. ·
~ J v-~ f ~ Co vJ'-\- h Cot~ l o "'.J k1~ · ~~-\- C4I.J...ul\ q .i
~ \1"\'~jVt-\ ~-\l W\t i....vt:U C...C().)\-r.kA-1 01 ~1~ ~-hPe ~ +o "*-t \aq.\ic
~\~ b ~ D/\ ct }...t1~~k cl.~ivlt..e. or Off~a\ 1 ~~ ~UL. ~a\.s ore_
IJ.::
:J·
Q·\J ~\a\:,\.e -C-oc- ~ ~ C \Ul \..o c~.S'r. S..a.z ~~\\-\- \J Ml ('~ C.o.ro\.ir'R YD4
u ·~ · ..1.1\..e, :>. 'l t ( V1lU (c....\-i()-1 ~\\in J.l V'f rq) . «o*" G<' \-\-\- ~(\ ~ ~t\~·n ~n
'-.1. o\\l'""t ~ .C,-fjL ~ CV\~I..i~ Q\1 .o-\- ~\ \ o.\ (\'<' (JI...U:~n 3 .s ., Dl..e... t?,C"\ \-\ 1-lo ~ v ..i. 9'\-
) ~~ \ G-C'"\ ~~~~ 1S \u.s..
o.\ \3 o
~s~~~ CovS'\-- eorS~~<~c\ ~o.r~ <e.o '-(ec..r..s et~o \' Q: ,-e,cur'd
o~ s~~~,u~\ ~\e~e~s./,.. C....Of'\~~~~ \oi ''~~-" ~r~~-~
(\1\ ~\- \,.u-.) 0 i j MWI e_ ~ ~ ~\"\ ~ <" cU~ll ~ ~I"\ ~ (>f2...Gt \ , .S_.e_Q_ M. ~ .er' "\J (_~~ \)~
C).-v\'A~ u L\,()q u.s. '~ 9. t \CZI\). ~ WM1 o-\--\-n ct.\ \e. <...o~ ~ -\'h \~ fV'-l_Q/l.} -\1--Q_
J ~_) 6"4U.A~~ Gt \ \-o' ~ \ ""' 6\ ') €1\.\ ~\\tvA~ .s ~ C1A a.~ Cct \.\-on . ct. "' f\e ~<?--~
o ~ s u.. i.. ~ U. -eA.\ Go 4 \(L\M e \..\ /" -\o QV' ("V\~ L..Q ns '6~-\-lutLS o-\ ~ \ s. uQA· f\1\S.S Ii1 LR..
\
et-\\ec-\) \ \O,(.p.J... .. s~ Co-Q~.e ~ s~ \J LM.,\..t~ _s\r&::::.Q.s ~tott us:. t4 ~a 1 44\p c \Cj(o J-f J
A\\o 5....e..e.. (:)('~V' 'J 1....0~~\J "-.S.\--o" \I). u.tWtl 1 L('}{t. (17(o~J ·i \~~\J~\..e~
~ \vJcR..S I S ~ { '\ . 1 £ "\i ~n ~ l f V . I c '-"-' ~ 1 '( \D V ..S • II.{ 1 1 I S 2.. (. \'1 (o{J j
~ (> e ch-\- '-..) Q ct \wsun '3. '6 ~ \...,( -S. ~A')$"" i (.,Ito c\<(.lp I) ·, lrfN"'6(\ V' \J c,s,.Go..-" lG
3~3 V. . .S. 1 '-PI 1 J '-f<t ( \ ~ ~ 1)
~ \~'-t\; ~ ~ct~\t::t~1\1~ D.\-~ ~r---e\n<.t\ 4--rM)(J'Ip-\-~ q,-\- h)~
~ \~ooJ ct \ f'A.r. A\k~ cu ~~\\cik..(1 c..oAA.I.e. \ \N ~N~otd-..t --\-'0 '<t.0\ ~
9 C\.)
~ )(?~~ ~c\q\_ ~~'".f~ eul~QJ\l.Q_ «">ro\we ~ b'-( (,c-tfl-ion <.\VJ1'()~ -Yh.t
.)~ee~ \(\4\ h.tOJ'\\-\~1 e:~~~h·,\-.s ~2. 11 01'"\~ e~c..D~~~~-'1
11
fhM.\hQ\.e _.tu_ At-\''
0/\~ \C) o~ \-s\ct\ CovJ'~S. (V"\~tV) ~WI\. 1 ~-"~n&.J 0~ ~etc.-\ 1 ~1<>11 \)-t ~
CV\~ o('~tJ h\.e.~ ~ \-c::r-t>7 ~n <:-e.~~UL \-a UJ'"''-\ .J..J\J, C-:l-1.)- 007tol~-
o~'-t1\""o ~- q_\ ~@I.~Q.l Lt s Q/\~ 4\.o . As. ~..s"i:'r~ Lou.J\-\ ~\~
-A
·\ " M '4 V' v C\.~ o ~ d,; f o C '<.\b c_""""'\ \:x ~ ""- i e ~ q c-e. LOr 6
=
6
~· ..)\.t\-~ t1 ~~ ~\~~.VH'~ I//~ ~Rf"'-~1 t ~\U('if C....yu i Wc.-\--1 arp 0 \-hiS.
t..,\£AA'w\.S. Lt~'-l ~ -~ Ct\- \lil • .:r..., -""-e. Lof\~~\ 0 ~ Cs~f\'"\~r1a\ ~fo5.eCJ.At-h0'1~; d~
Fot.o.'>'> N..tU.:.<el q c~t.oo·:- o.C W ~"'\ (i><o<..U_!J·n~S f(\ or1.V' +-:o
Ct\l o2.:> ~atJns~l ~b e.\-\..e~\}-Q_ 0-('~e-\\~ 'e-01~ ~-Q £t1\-scw:l\- 0
If_
f'l\,\ (\ ~ -V' J~ ~ U -~ • Cv\• -"1 S). . ~ .S "'"'f ( ~
\,q 5. ~\~4 ~ ~\ \\ .\S UvJ' \-
ct (..C'·\~ "y l de.~~ M \-.1 ct CU \~ ~ ·~. ~ t.o\ ~ ~-\0i-1 MG1 jle l ~ ¥ ._.
'~LH~k \ ~AJ·\e.vJ .~'vv1n.l~I.1'-.U._ ~~~NS >'13 u.S. ct.-\ 3<;,~. Ac(...Qr-~''(l~Lyf
\\
"""fU~ CQ/\ \oQ... ('\i\} ~ '""I.e-\- ~ "1-\- ~ ~ ~ tvv-..ti-\ ~ {' ou' 6-.e. 0/l ·,I) 11 ~ 0t t
~Q ~~01\\ ~...v '~ q \-rD.A~o-\~\ ""->~ .e-, \"i,Cft- A-rM~V'('p-\- -\.i NU. ~-e ~ -\or Q/1
e \~c.\1~ ~ e ~ \..Q.. 00 0-f\'.eo \ p U-.e... <1 <"' \-\- Y. o t.{ u .S . q ~ .J... l.7.
~'""" \AAu ~. .S~r -<W'Q.. ~vJ'\- 'n.c:t~ ~kt:As\ ~ ed ~<\A- ~.
\--v\)\~(~~~ \(\ ~- \\1\-e. o~ ~LeJ ~c-t-\- b.esCV\ \....V\~ \l~n\~f\..r tlin-
v b\ •.r~() 3. Ct c.r~~ n~ \ ~~~a/\\'~ ~; g 'n\- <>..f 4CU.L~ -\-o Gt -\(aAHr-~ et I
OU'-e .fi u""' \.1 (" o<JKc\ ~0 bo~ .{-he 6v-fL (j>C oUH G.-1 ~-e. 4. 4o { p ru~
~~c~-:>f\ c_\ou..ue~ b ~ ~ \l..iih A~-~QA\- .. ~ e:u,·\+J '1.1otU.5,
q\ \.{01- bl{. Ev·V\ t {t ~- o~ \>rocHS. Q.r\~ C<f\o!G1t 9, 0 -\-tc.h~
~Lt) -o{ ~ eo~\.,~-ho'l ·~ rvt~\- '-e.(u.,{\'e ~ ~o\Jer"""QI\\ ~
veG\.k Q ~-\4~.~c'i JiJ~ [ qJ 1\ h ti.S l'tt \e'f..q~ ] f"'.M.) .-\- q.f{ \:) 0
et\.t o.pf-t·l! tvt\.1 L.v\C@.\-\..v ~ ~ OA~ e'(\.tal c C<:.Q.~ s -\a ~ \- le.e_ E u 1\-~-.r &
S Vi>fct. 1 G-d~·"" 1 S~-l'ct (ho\'~\\r\~ ~c-r\· 3cvun~e.A L, ~~ o ~l.U. ~ {'0,....
Ce.S.S ~(...{*l n~-\- ~ \\M~~ --\-h~ o~~~w~ b~ s\er~~f'~ ('_('e_q\-edclkee_.\-
G.f~-tal \ n ct. <:J't~oo\ casl(. J_A~~ ~'-i>re.-e.. ~'-\- -S\\e~e~ ~\,
\1\vvt c.. Lu1 \J c.ovJ'\ 'C> + Aef€ols ~ Y\tv'.Atforc\ J ~t.t 1J ~qii'Q_ Cte{ ~the
t>~~-o<"'\Wt~kt -tv ~C{~ ~ ~le.\.e \eCO<"\~ q\-kl~ ~-i~pc.)£?1_.. ~-S
wo 4 1 ~ ~au-e ct\~r~~ ~.Al~r6 ~ ('~q.r'()()ablQ.. tJ\{'p~rk(~
-\-<> Nl~~ ~- ~\ q \ r--e (...Q (' ~ I -tiun--cuJ!t, r e.s.eo..rdA f1..e. (Q.v.) I ~ ~lr
e~sfL. J 4dj' ~~ t ~€/\\-t~.~~ CVJWVIVt.\-.s 1'4.Cf-\- fVtcM.f 6-€. C(J \.)all<.i ~
0.(\ A.Q(Yl-Gl~ .. '-\.~4\J.S. LtJ.<f I L(J~ (l<f~~
A~~,\;()(\C{\~ os. -\-1-e_ ~~r ~ L.o ~ \; 1' Oo\.AJ\c.U \) C~\~tov-~~
e.....of\.~-r~ ~ LGt \4-vl"\ ~ o~\~ hGtv<.. be.r,e.bA-kJ ~ro""' (\1\r'r A.l~r~s e.'ko-
~ i n~-\-1 01\ tJ \-. ~ 0 M\ \\e ~ ~·~' ett heo.r ~ \-\'a;U V'~p-\-..s M.lvo<''\ a\ I z..c\flJ
pr J-e_LJ o·J? d P'YvOfva:::>W -)-0 t) -.)01 .fo3' v(l"t·~r~ d)
U() .' -~ V"vQ ·0"1k ·t Q ~' h~ d_j
~v \G6 9 # .s' J ~- ·w\..J
7 ·'f.~_, ) ~ \~,.' _s t~ f"G<Y1 S'
_s !L ctrt r~ -z Ofi11?V~ ·h) • T~ )a-d Jo 1-vo- d' :~ v' vv ~o o-·-~ VQ{j---j-. ~ ~s
to StJD) -Jo ~)
~~\0-..crJ o \q~~C'I'>->J oq -\'·n'-'v '--''\\1-:7")
}b lJj_ "'Jaj+hW ~JhcG)O f;-.ro~ 1/P/1 CQJ !l?~ )OoOcJy )l?V ~..VV~V) -)"Q
}-lfY'OJ ~ hjlbl\~ • of- ~I -\-0 · Yn ')l_~{\\.r (\ V~j \..:>~ Oo-y ~1Yd- G
-. lJ>v '· ·()J'O ~ ~'~0-.\: )-\d\~J)nMJ.-t ~~ -1n~ 1 ~f\ \~~] ~ VV') ~
lrft1lfl- o.r tdJJ)fVOJ-t \'?~~-~ ""lt)~O~ !lJ<'b d~)J\AJ ¥NUl:i) -1-JY>CJ v """)(__ 'C -)"l?
. f.L // )P11Jtb \l::>VyrtCP 1~JO'vV ~ <1..\ ~~"\7\o_) 'S\ lb~ ~~ 17 \)'-~ ~q-c'\\c)dJ
·ff9)1!<Y"l \"l?~ s1va b'~-rln VO · ~'tr '";(}.._N)\\fO. J.,cyouaso·~ l" \ .Po ~\ib l a :o, <:""? \ f'.
-o-.J "Vpn> fe1\\.o<>Jd ().J'f'!"<DoJ& ~1 \:1 h "")L..'t .:yo y::r:· · ~ '_C'71:J q:vl'"M-o
d-J)~")")""J.ro f'V'Q ~n&~fJo )lvo~VCIJ~~ \vo-c;:~.v\ ~..><1-J)o' ~Oj(;}J?>""'" 1 -ysnvv
)~)~(o<"OC) LL-~l..."C 1 bsc 'S""h 2:.~ '5' y-u~~~~o---u "· '1\~......,·~ -ooy ~/,.. q-."~:·p~Ja
~vo ~h 6&)~~ 11 ) .o~J.<}\o ~ 2>7!1?\N CL..\..,·...1 ),J'O r~~nav· !""l.ft7nd~J::J S' \/Y\'vV
- ~V;n-u 11 .0'1} }1/l)JI~ jlJ~.~J? {) clU~j C'Q)& h.9 ~Vj15"jJOJ )oV(l~~l-tS"V c>-::>
· -;r-r cY"l1+ J"\f? s ssnojd ~ ji'~Jo v v r b r -1 o ·sn b OJ tr r-1-\ 1<:2 ~S'
f'C) ~
0
,_,··(.;~~lfrti(Y) «rU-JO n1fY>1?)0 \._/(ILfJ~J~ )t7nbo ~ j){PO..Jd ern,:;- -~ J Q
~fVVWO~ d"iJ- ~ICY\ ;-vQ.3'-"0J tf}'yv.,) 5'\l?d""aJo dV\YjY->"0~ V't \']"~y) S"qJ"Y"l~~J
-QJd Jo~ ot tiiJf~~ ."'0 'Slvo~ ~"Z>f \W~!.J-::> S'~\,t.ooJ~ r-'01
0"-i)- 'J I
~rjX."(Q"Cto·r0/5t '1fV)~ J'u~o<nOJ 'f&r -\!?'S"D bO)l? f11'.<'.3 G)o-y
~, 0"-I'~'JrJj'J fVV ~nbe7fl0 )'.?~ 1v'V)f a-"j )7\.V 0\- ~.N~O)N ~sohc;'
-dj~.> )t>"l-1.yvrw~~tu'OJ O"'f\~~ rVI
b' {'-' ~<6 !O ) baJJ..a -\~ J ~ }Q 0\JYn ~
- J'Y)C 1-vc~ "1o f )r.:xJ{~.VJs:> o S'ao-)1/0J\on~ 1vow ~~ '1.J..n\ ~
(l:O)J;:, 1) ~->' f 1 rs r. ')' n 'rL ~ .. -\V1 ~ :v Jo ..!0)\ ovv v ro y~~ -\;\'S~
~V0-tP:::>u dVf-FO V )w\h?~ VO\~'v..>.'f )"0\J().~~ll-rucYJ u~o-~ 'J'O ~~ VO
j-)o~~ '~ 1 ~~1'='") vo \~JD v-o }Jl?'-'\l'~W \'VD \""?) o--yv. vpJ<:>a<;'"d-J \ w~
Uc>to}Ql(') "trvJ~ ~ ~vo ""~\'J V<l~"V,~l(\ yo~»-L. ~o1t~"S 0-T \"'\~~ ~-
-~·
-~
' '
O\ !,(r.fL ~ r-€-\C'\a ~ l,..e<>N1n_J . ~"" <..o s-~s .-\ .n:,""' ~ ~€ co • ~ 0 ,.... Ap('JLa{ • .
S \...\-\\-cu'v\5. Y4: -\Ctct ~q-\-~ A-~-(\D~~ Co~ 0--e.i\)\IA-\it>n Df C4-fk!l~
o ,~c.\ A-~-{1«2~ \ '-NuS. cw\: ~~~l'f {q;\r' C\/l~ ~- reJL«l ~lt)J a{!-
~~ o ~ Cc...ti\-on .S e-<>"'~'G\-\l>f"\ b'-t ~ A{'(Lellakp G~-\-·<-0ctj UJ\I-€a-
1
SCV\-o.~l(_ ~~ ~ A~~rfV\0../\U... o\- CctH-or{~ C..VI\v-,ck\o() t.Na,s f\.{)t reJ~Q<olQ.
\/l[
{l~\~r-~ 0w"~c.b~ E~(>'a/\q\)u~ Pc-ec..kM>.s A Lu~.5. ~-i'J-tU'OAdfor 0-e(iALR.
~~h r'V1W1~~ r\Jn-ut e~4~-\-o.~\..Q_ ('~~t-tl! i-.~UO/lQ {_s.
Cv\
~ar~Q\"( L.&A\olle-d- \., ~ e"tu...i\ot.~ 6>r1nwol~i ..SJte. ::r" r-e '-'~ifj ~~J . .i -u0.1. f
It~'-· .l.l\ ~v..:>3.} 51 I, !J ( t:\e 'J.. \1V Co~_g q>~-~~) j 0 . \\J<!.J'~kr A~s oc5 ·
\.) ~'\\.JV'Ct. 'bs'G fw.;Jd J(olo I ~(o/ C.Te--L. 111:J) o\'\.,g r(OCQ.Qck~·,..:r.., re.. ~rtWI.i!-.J
t 01 i\A).1~ lo\l 1to.)..O (Te'f..._A.~~· \:-o.r\-UJ1)J'~ 1 ;..oo] 1 onJ l(lro<.J..t~ 11 ,p).. 0(\e o G-~.s..e
e<t~\""~l!L \'rlouQie1 .i.i -\'hcc\ e. <t\.M·~ ~-~ ~- ~1\\J Mt Q/\~ rv~-\- -nvo~_Q_. ~
6\'-\J'/"\'bJU""" Df\ ~\\ ~\~ h-\-~ r ~ R\\)~\.lf .Auoc...\ ~~'? ..\ i...,_)';)_~ a-+ Jlo 7 rT/1
c;'L t-\t(\w\o!'\~ \t)'1 J-wJ ~ c.-\: ~~0 ~-n-v. xs.. CV\.GV)~OVVlv..-S. ~e\\e\ fV\~ b~ ~e_
1
~.e-~ w'h.JV\ a ~o.r~ \(\e'1-.~\"lc4\o~ cl~ \~J t:<H ~'n_f \\-s; c-i'j~\-s '"'J.J._.L
e..._J, \t\V~UA~ AU vU. ~-s-1;· &~~ ~<o [ ·1 :r-" r-e.. ~n\.v'lor\f l 0'1 J w3 d s:+
(o.')..()... XA ~ e-4rrv'-\~~n__J \-t (.q.l \..o"s .1 Q \~ t' n .f-t2.Q._ 't(01 {Y\ev,~(AM..4~ ( elt ·e.f
'o ~1 I.Uu_M<..Q. oC. ~ \..o ~\\ 1 q c..ovJ'--t m ~ Q/\4 \o_p \ 2<2. -\--o k Lo d-tc- n.e
'0\ law_i ~LV~\~ ~_1 £.-'(4\\-ab\J! ('<c\\e~ o ~ :::t="n ~e. ~~01\~ 1-~ q
~w1~ 'tto'-t 11/l CTe~·~f· \=or\-w11r~ .Loo~j(~ln\f\.j> ..::!:A~ ~nW~nj
l o't ~wJ~ Ct \ \o.)..()J .
_x ~ ~ ', f\i \-~-\- t:..CA.U2
C. Gt\ +vZs ~ e,\~ \\11 b n'n .g -~ "'-"\evtd CM«J
\ el\ e~ c....v as. ~v-.Q.. ~ L't.\M.s J, t ~ ~ ct/~ h cb\-c:u\n \7 ~\,-e:{ Q 11
·\n)\) llw.\v\i Cv\~ ~~ \-\-~\ot_tq~ Lur~~--<S ~urJ\.(GVt\- -h T.c.cf .As-~ \\.07
·:l.,
\-<.
' ,_
I
OJ\~ VA~<t.r ~-e~Qf'Ql ~~kCt.i ~ .l'8'u.S.c.\:u.st{ ,J-\~w ~~l lOIN\~&
e>G: a.c:A ~ \-o (\-c) ~I c~t,~ *h<2A. ~ r <X.,Q.i~ e j_ --\o 6~ < e..\( e~ ~n ~ (1
t.t ~ '-' s .c \ \4 't1 ~'n 'o ~ ~ . n-~:k.e 0/\ ~ r e.~~\ ~W'-\-., A prQ. re~u. rs d-e --\-u
o\*a1~n~ """cvt~ V-Lu e--t \.s. ~ ~~w ~~ Q\00€.. ~Ct+ ~~ h rw-t OM)-
-\'hu- p\cJ() 1 e~d;;~ 1 ~ ~ q~ e<t l.{~ ('~Q ~l -~ ~~\-a.t'n f e.\i e{ -h -,
W~\ ~ h e.. rv\ cu..r_ be.. ..I2I\ \1, He~ . A t..0 lt o \: fVlCV>6~.s ti' evt -e)C'-{I:::t ~
I'
0 <'~~0J\-( ("'-€Jn-e_~ ~ C-o~i\_s q f'e.S(>v()'6eAt ~ 'QJU'~-f'r"'' ~ Ol'-£ ~tnt
SW1et\ cc..-\- " 6 ~~ \ (\\)\)\~~ o.r-e.. .SW\.fl.tlv-e <1uejhorl.f Co()CVfl}~ 0/l elet-
-\.-e~ t:l~ua\~ c::tM~~~~.,-~ \)-~\-o-r'""' Q.(>CV'\iu.t\Cc/' ~u~.\o a~.)ure ~ct\-a r-e-
~\a\-or ~\\\ 1\-o\- ~re.rN~.\-wQ~ ~~'t ~r e t--\-fctD("'~,~ar<-f re.\\e{ 'Vier 1"\'lMJ~..i 0
-\N2.. Cov.f'\ ot C('\~na I A.fpt'ei! \ s 1 c..onsHteA~ I-V t~ ~ j V1l r~ ~uf\-t-
0~\'e~~~ I \etul-re ~V\.-\- Ct (2_~J't-lu\ n"UA_if -s~~ hJL Ctc:tj f\v o*'Qf'
r-eMe.:~i a.\- \cvvv b.t-k~ ~a.,o~J Ul\11 l~v--Q. ., .u..e_ J""''~ v (/aC/::
I'A ~ s"" ;.,~ :>."Z Y 1 l <1-l. CTe'f.... c.n''""' ~f Jtt1LJ _ J~ J+c..~Q..rt o~ ih,e_ cc::u..e
Ct\o~ u A\~o s..u --\'1...e.._ A'-~O'Vflll_f ~l~.J-or_j A f.C, dcx..Ort -e ~p/o./rtc:fl__g
~w-h-~a\:.\.L o~\"1 1n J:tt ~~ IV\OV1~0vv.A.C (lQ_ lie.t- aA- pa(UJ ~- 7
p CV' a~ r 0() "'J Y. - ).._7 o '\ ~I.e_ h.Qr-o'\n .,
IV\tvl~~ onrt.~.t lte5 or~lnav1~ ....vhWI 1.\-\.s u41t'Led Cf.S -rN!_
\ a_~\- ~..sof't- ~ 1\10/'t,lYl v£-ud~-h.:v"'+ fPLUw...lJ 2..'1 (£) c-re'i. (CfJ¥ J"'
--f}..Q_~ \S. f'Vo ofher w~ fo S4J-\-o.tn ~~c.:-\ ~-\-.;--here ·~ () o-\'
~~er ~\M\n 1 -eJkv\1~ Q/\~ a~.etu~ r~,e~ -for (C\J!b ~
o\o\OJ.'n ~~ ,e\\ e\- r-ecc_u.Q.J~~ h~n .- ()~W'~V\ .h e~LJ·'()'·M~~ ea.~
UA~ ~er'( ~ o\- ~R \ ~~\es C£t\~ hCiS exhCU-<Jkd --\-o f'\..10 ,
~cJl ,-ri -o\:A-<4~,~11J Ovv--( t'e\\ e~ s~u~ ~ ~v--e\n .. ""lhu~ ~~~nj\.(.ultllll_j
~- \ (\s\-o.A.\ C.cu.ll -G(\)-rt"\ ,, \L\\)<U'c.'U'..W A~ ocs // wh~ (\'\0/I~GV\.(..( ~ r-e-ti e.f
v-> cri ~.eA\ec;\ -f-oe *ol\v.J'e. +-o 5~ .)~.\\--t~<Ahon -for -VI--e ~~\~ ~S~
jv..1)..~ ak-JltJ? .,A\soJ-t..e <?.o.1l~ v ~u1L-Qr "Cf(p Jw~'c.\, :l5b"r:J.S(o
C\~'f.. . A () P· \~ ~~ L' ~ )1r) 0 u+J \q ~s <'~ (?rD(..QJ c\A -..f ) ( \-ect v--t ·-\-o-f:'I.e
I 0 (l
d -eA\ t. ~ I..A..)~v-e.. 'e. to ("d. r- eN Q..~t\e~ f'\Al ~1-fltVt~t-hon -+or ~...e~ tn
~ fL e_ V-'\~ ~ IV\ 011'\ 1~ cvv..M..i (' JL\ \ e\- I\
. ·, \:"\G~to\ (_ Ctl-YDn
j , .
- I
\f"\\~4\"'1
.. ·· · \ ;
..
\. • . ·
,i·()u,g'-"\ MGII~QIM)..S
c:>1l~\\. \\i~ N_ wou\~ ""4~ ~ ~~ted rQ.\ie.-\:- ~~ -\-c \~ -\'t.AG:t:\
1-\olo~\. l-VI'~QJ'
A<'\ .1\.{;7 war ~ pro~lf r~e ~ h
Lot Qu.<;
<'e.. \\.e~ - ~ e. ;g, b\l\JI o v ..l ~ q l'6 ~v0~~ cSl (1-t s J.S (l, ~ c_Te(
C<t"" /'..~ Q• \ 'l1.1o) I .:M Ire. \~.nc i '"" 1-.1 J ...:> J ~ 1~ '] 1 UJD ( \e-J.. . App .-re-t.-
c.r~c. .1..~) Co<'lj ~.-o<Qt~.f) . "(NL "b~ s WlY""<A o~ ~ c<l;~
a/\~ ~- Acc....o4~1f\g -~~~~rktQ_f 1\{t.;~\~ e'f-.~\aA.nt'r'-3, Cc.tt+or.~.
~u.s~.\, (A\; Of"\ ~\'"'e._ a~\o.y \n ~'t-.Cn._!i r¥\01~~ {U.A'(e..{- . . .s u-S~o..t'n.s
~Q.. \c.c\ ~" \c Lul.\.o1 ~ ,g "<>\ &\Of!,- Cf'\ lr. Is r i ~ t..·b· • 8 u\- Cll!t {;> n
\t u..s. ~~~ Ct ~\ \'\Q <j:.CV\ ~ ui ~uA c\'-- Ct.i ~e._ <:..OJ\ ~ \\ V/\~
t,,~ e.-t).w\ ~ \) J -tdt~\.l.-t>'{>\c CJV'l·~ \~c;t~-\t\ C<JJ"t~'-\-1 oru 0/16 c.At tv' Q/A-s
Me.~\<.~-\;on ,e~\'M~ .-.:::t:J\ ~\S. ~1\i,3e.A\ o~-\-. \-o o\:A-dt\n reti'eC
Ct~ Ct tv\ ~C( llr .I\\ ~ \ClQ_ \' :\13 01\\ . . \ ~
1
A(-f,ckwi\- t X'-'"" ·· (4;\q, \_-t> rs
io
~\aM~ 0 '-"\\~ab\L e\"'1 ~ ._._.__'1'-vv,_g MwJ0.<M-<-{.S @.<>lie(:. IYl -hit- here1\n
Ct.\- qa.~ 11..' J-
ro '\> """r
"11"'-s ,;;_ 'i-Jl. !\Is o ~ ~~~.., \) \D>f\Q.S 9:n F:~ l
. 3 '!. ~ 1 3 '(,&""-~(? (Y-11-, C ~ I'i"1_0 (. e<i}o,if" (?ru~ cl~ 1h,;J /"'"'fol-re 6 1"1 e.-tk(
h<!"- [1(\r, a.-~ ~
1.1 "'l L 'i'J; (i>J~ ~
r n:. t>e c.orJ-,-1-uf..t R·o ex\ ~w\,,m ~ c.au.J
A\~.""'j' (,., ( Q. \"' X-o \ \-,. ,., \(twu> n s '• oct. '-\- 11 · \) ~\ .\ ~ -\--<:> ~ku-Q.
.S"'-'VW\ \"- '-"""1::~-\: :c..ov.r\ ~rli\"g ,f<o.c.ln <-e.S • ~\e.>M\ . j>r€.-kt«(
(l_Q_ c...-vr- ~ ~- C!;V\tfu ~ {-_ro~ Q- ~\c..~ f S \)I. rec-\: Aq~.e..a \ CVt ~ ~JQ.
o ""'-lr\-e <> ~ c...::.Je.
.--e "-"" t<>" e 1;\e<.J<:u-e 1 .C c.l·.r ~ ""-""'n P (
""<JHJ ""[
~ieal «ru-o\ ..A-\ot') . ~v.>ev-lf' d Q\"-y alo~ &>e.s ""* '3<!/\0V'C< ~~ e~-\-c..
b\\~""' c.. ""-""' ~S W!q i ~ • i.u .:::t:A ~ J o~ ~ wN"vA ll.e.l\ 1-el •(.u •
L.f. ")-.2..\_e.SwJ'd '-l..oo, 4oJ CTei-.d-oD-zJ (C\\=\n~ \.)\s\-~ ~...r
..:tA ('-€. o
~ ::::r~"- \qJ.. J'-"'3~ ~s-'1 ,t<a:l (Te<\. .)...()cl.<> ):il--Qr€kre -11Ml c.,.uA- <.cu'liW-\:
c ew~"i ~ctd-()OM. er.-Cv~ct. .J'\.--e. de~ --\-<>low Gl~ ~-
I
L.t;Wl
\, e~ ~ """""~s. .jlh ~ ¥ '"k«l .\ <'<' ct~ 01\oiolr I< \--\'1-.t>_ (lsz_~ Q"" ~e-._-\-
"-"
1
~r ~r '0 ~ fVI""' ~~s ;}. Dnf .l. ~
I
'-'.:> ""\- fk< J.e..
f
,i
,....
~ \ ec.t~ CA!'c <( c-ov-€.- ·-\'NL \ ~ d. rA . , • ·
. - s. c £·'\-'Ut~ .. Es~C{qllt \'1 \ cgh\ oG ~e~
~Gt~ t\ wQi ·~ lle..s~of'l~~\ v.>hoiQ. (V)q~in\ ~\.f{7-fJ'€~Q./\~-h~0 +o-\tt.e
~e~\.e , W'nV1 ~- S.t1-J(I{e_r oUe<:&-t ~ --\-o A(>q.o-1\~ ~J-e_( -+hcJ. -\102.--
'i ec..c0·~ ~ ~~~ ~4~ ~()<t~\red. ofoo.-t-\ WV'e--.~ '~e-tce_ -\-o ~
CctLe..s A'hcA Cctl-\.vn Cf\so hu~ p~~·t'ru> a~~fi~.~-~-rf'\e~e~ 4-e
re.et~o~\alr CCUL~Ud as~. -\-('VI~ o{-~ IV1c.r+i-V' .~r'rvl\n.g -G.t-u./\1"\
a... S'-'..)D\f\ e~~ Uif' o\- ~~ Co\AJ\~ ., ..l.Q..e_ Exktlo, (- \' \-\ l'
fV\.J'. , 1 ..t vp rc.. 1
.S<J,...,'\\~s \J.Ja~ ~.Q ~ ~(ec.t CJ:wi.Q. +or CV\..0~-\- o_f~-~ ~Q\~ ,~ C.ctA4-on0.
~l\(s-eA\ o~-\- -\-o ~~oc.lJ\J'e_ ~ <'e\.wtvt-\- ~<'t_~c.l "'eOM\n._g \'ec.af'~ ..
.Se..e... e.,~. Dc'-o~~ 'V ""2W'l-\: \\1 s,~ ~~~~~J~ (\<t'1Jj C\he ~-\:·i\<e ~.IV\~{
s'r-.o~ \~ ~v-e.. '»~ N'\.4·~ ~tCi~ ~.r ~\o~ j 0 ~c-e~ A.er.e.ct\ a,.~~-
&\:~~: (-_~~r.<t;.H?I\\,e~. ~ ~.J~\Co~-"'~ ~4-\- ~ S ~c.in__r r"'C<J.e.. ((ell~
os·~~Q.I\\--i ~-.t\ ~ rv~\: 'oe...-\<'o-;ucrda.oJ a~lo\:,.s poHho.n -Hrtq~ k-t. te,pi·H-
(\AC\.\.e~ reh e~, ~··~. &WJ r~r-es~-\-et\1'¥1 tJ~H {q((Q/\j ~ 11v<._
\) o\o\ol 0:>~-\- W ~-\ Of\ ~ ~\a*-e Oft-~ \C1G+.S 'D ~~\i (..Q{f,_IL.j
e K<:J...u..i\()1') o~ ~ \-!'MHI"0p\- CCU"M:>\- b-e 0 '-tJh~·e6· b'1 c\-e(l ~f"\·L~l dt~
(.o\ltf""(_ ;. ~ e ~ Q. \ l ~J Y. \ ~J .J \.\ W-\-~-\\ ~d kc _..(:c <Yv\ ~. ~__s' Q J -
S./l/'.:\\Ufl ~C\\ C\os\(\j CV'JLlM%ts hq~ <\N\: b-~-\-rcvtJcrtbel.
·~ \·n ~ ~\-tM-\- C. Ct ~JL ~ ~vJ' ~V\ { ~ Of\ \4l()i:l/\~QA\: +u ·
e 1~-:{~h~~ bo\"h -e\QMe..t\.s o\- ~ \.'1~.S De.~tQ <~ A ~o.J'-ht auet~np
-\1---e. ~.e~(..L e~ ~{;i~~ ~\- s~w b o~ 0/\. L.vv~·c~.:>" ~lolL J e {~by
~D~ \)W~ l!l ctSJ~~ ~-~1 ~3h-\- ~~ ~""- ~J~t-h~} ~ ~{
b e.LA.u. ~ 'C>~· ~. ~.e...\l o S-e....e_ ~ j !U" .i \J QA.(.OI\.(C E "\v-~r~~..e ~ c_r/l c.
·t,l/1.. h.D.l~ (~(~() C..\-e-1-.. \'1~0 i ~ ~ ::r'"'~lortg toq sw3~ q-\- Co:).O/
.I"' r-e. '(3,q_\,.\l, )-oJw~JA ~\as- 1'\il . C.Tei-..-~. ~~~~~~ ::t.d)a)UNJ rro-
CJ...Q.-~'n~). ~ ~~"Jw.i~olo\Q_ ..Ccu(V"\ 1'\-.e.. ~\~ {lV'f,'C:l~ -H--e_ ~\q-\-<>r t'n
"'o-o )( \ CY\€ // .s Uuj' ~\ IV\ tv! ~0\f\US ~ \( ef . A f('r -o 't-(\111. tiXQ ~ ~ 2 1/ ~ yeoJ'
-W~ '{'ll.N{)6 .i \nee.. Lt- t J- U .. u.l.\L.lt\ \ i ~ 6.~ Cal~ f"'to1~6 a WfY
~ &\e.~ S.<...h\\1\.u~ -~ (_ct.t~-.) C<:>~\ct.t'n.t ""~M ~\~~
01\h.o,}Qf'.
c_~.c..G. a ~cJns\ '<'N"'. &0,:\Vtu- ~'n 'n \ S.. C<>-(>Cia\.y Q.S Ct 1 h'O!'\hCV\. ~ ~1'\.QrvA-I'l~
~~ fY\~ ~ ~Q ~QI'j\)~ ~~ ~Q.\CAA.(*\0/V\ uW't -~ Coull{ .
oC<:C-{_(ro'\q\
0/\~ ~ -({\A Qj ~ ~ \ e G4'~\0J -\..o \>I e q 6A'(')_g • '\.hw e.uQf' I o\JQ('q/11 ~ re c.IDrd
ti\ -\he_ \n.i~~ C.qifL -s~ Cl ~\\vn ~ CA 14-o"' ~}.n_j -\o J~\<- re--
\.\ e.C -C~o(V"\ e~dA oG-- ~ Cou!'~.i ~ ~\)~ -i\-a::t..p 0,16. V e~QJ'a('T~~W\cA-i •
As. ~-\ \ a. £ ~\ ~~ ~ ·, \ ( Jl ~\ a-\-\~\-- ~ (·n~r M~t ~ r€J-c\ v--e- ~ 0'\4'\kr o_n
0/\ o.~ ""-~·"\~~a.\1~ \ev-e\ in <»'1. '"'~-~'C\.\CiA (i"~_ro\4\-\0r'l \~ ~ c.(LCi3, v.J
OA~ (Vv-_ {~1'tw. ~ ~ ~ (Lo~~OA£_ 1.41 J-w1~ Q-\-cl( ( L...ovJ'I\-~\-cd1~
CLA~v~_Sh ~ ('eeorc;\ J~ ()Qf'I~~J o\-- 6Q\( by P-o'I-S~ r\t LJlQ-
~m~ 'e,\ \ e,{ ru -\-o XWL.. ~\non l'0 ~~\erJ ~~(:)~) 1 a.JV"C~/{ ,~ f'e c..o I' d.
o\<>o s ~~ ~- ()Ct\:\v." 6'-i. ~l-.SC\1\(2_ o\-- -\--n.<c~ ~ r~K re\~e.~
...C('UfV"\ e..4ck. o~ ~~ct \ L.ouS'-\-.r \J\ui:)tue ~
~-\ ~ ~trt\.ore. COV'\ \'eGUonu~~ c...onc.1..J..A.k -\'hq\- Ccd hn
Couf'.\:
~ \~ M~ Vvt\.re.ct~on c.\o~ ~ -t~ ~r\ r~·~\n_f a.__ c-o~( eA-t. 0/1~ .r '-&Gl·u; e1:t t'e c.or-d
D 1'\ ~(lQCI\ Ce/\ ~ ~ W'io..ty o-~ \- -o \ -h rNL ~- \ ~ u \, l12.-e S Ct-i, J \e.-
f\..e
c....o.r~ ~ l)~.u ct r Q...y\·e......) _ C/'1~ c.....onJ \ Wct~ ~ or\~ l"r-QQ"'l~s {}f._ c.~(-Lcn's
re\ihvn Cf w~fM-\-eJ .. J..u.- ~ r-e_ ~~~aAfL .2\{ C} Jw 1 ~ cv\- [l J..
( LPuA--~\~ ~ -V\-e ~Cur~ 5 ~wi -\'h.~\ (to~{O./\J_ ~ \~
0-U-\
\JJ\\e-et\of"\C«\:,'-{ ~eA( \n ~tt~~j ~e.l(e.~ cti ~ ~ rrt>~te\r ~-G- .
~ re·h\,'o() 7::k- VIW'Je-,hc.)/\ ...~~ I UJ.e.. wll( r e.v('e....:J CV\~ (....01\J\W -\i.e
/h..9/'f\i G-t kv..s~~ ~10vl"'-\ ~n ~\~ tv\Cvl'~~~ fr()(.Q]~Vlj' LC4l~
h 4~ ~~..on CY' ~ e'L{->\~""t ~ ~e. reQ~oJI {o, ~ ~~s lvl {~\it1 1l-Jl t~lvr
G/\ ~ ~ 6~ Ll ). t { ].._ yeo.r ~ -e \~ . ~ f..e.Q ~V\2 Mev, ~OV\A.{ ~. (1\ ~· tVt-
.S\CI\ \-- (...0)~. ~\JA \)f'€J«:\-~ a.. c..N'<..lM'\J~LL~ct-\ tv\W"l~~_\ N'J(:>OilleJ
~d -\'\L {'eq·\ \)oJ'~eS \h ,_'"~-£\- +os~ bX~~. o..-, U/\':4lul)alc,{~ ~e \{
·\o'i ~\ -ht1 h at u e!'.\1 nJ h \J " j hts 0'"\~ \rwM r-e.N(-\, llJ +-a \~ 6<. VCtM t.--e.
,.
a~ ~e_. ~eACAA-( ~ ~- ~ ~ ~~~ n h~36 q~ Yl\ C0.~~ 1~cle"l..
'0 \-\e.s~ ~\\ ~· v-J 1_6 \l3 ill~ (TeA..... ~~, Cu- p4~ dnrt~\-\ t '"i7.r 6\lf pr·o-
C-e.st~~). A-~~~~~ Oti ~r'V\..ct\'~ o~ \ev-J CA\kn's .e~\GVtot'ho~l) q!'
Gof\!\-c.{,(\e~ \" ~\S. Ac~~G-u.(·c~ A~(,~·i\ .f\\e_ h0'et\n QAd --\-1~
Of""\
~ \-~ o~X\\e.. <:.4(.Q. c..\oo~ o.re....J 4-\~ u. ~\ ~ e_s-\-al.~:k~~ as ct "c::c\-kr
b~ \Cvv0 .\AAt\~ c~ \+of) hcu 1\..o\ .s\~ 0("' .i \lAM.bQre ~ Qfl ~\'!!. nj~h ~.!JLe.
~.\ \Jf/J'c.MwA ~J o(..i .' ~ s- ~ s w l. ~ ~-:\: "'f:'eI i sl\. re.. vh AW bf\.f t 0 '1 h . iJ-1 d
4\- ~.l-0 Cc...o~\- "~\\-n~ c.o~H-e( ~s- \-h0\u'~ ~ le 6 Q/\ 1-\\~ ~~t\
QrDu)~\·~g C\. ('e_Qjorv~'d..Q_ e~\~"~hD!l -Rr ~ ~ ~l~J.. .
er~~~
~Q.r€~rt: ~ ~~-e.s C....OOJ) ~JU'e d. 1 (Lt \~-tor ~J(>-e~~\ L.r ~~J 0/\8
(V'-O~J ~ \. ~ LoVJ""'-\- ~ f\t\ CA/l~bV\A-(J. O...~.lie{ ..\"'h\~ ~t S k-1 ~ Gvll~ t -
~~c.v\~ ~<-OA.\ 'e\etwr~ ~e~\-1on ~6 ~~c-e-0\ 0-eiron~:\- ~\-~ ~J-u'll.er
~ {'\efo.re_ 1 ~~ ~-c\ ~\e evv.;_ Q/\1~ ct.'{( o{ ~ t>re~a( h eon~
c .<t_ co\~ ~- ~ ~i CU' rvov:.::> KI\-\J '-"" .S. o.r-e.. ~\1 \ e.W e/1 cQ -\-u Vu..« LQ A.J-u '
'\ \
o"'b'-t1l\o% . . S ~~ ~c.oJ"~-S. 5 h..o\..(\d be-h\ed o.s. ct S'->{)~l~k( re<..of'~
~ ~- \'€_ L0f~ O.f"\. ~re.a \ -Go_(' ~e£1 \ AJ'o, D.1- () ~ - .)..:J.. Cj - ( ~ ~..:::C/'1
~ C\.,\wrv:-~.~o-Q ctJ ~~ cu~~ o\-~ CoW'-\-- of &-,(""\JJ\fl4( Are~(s 1
~1~ LouJ'\: 1 {V\( lN\~ k\~ 'isJu.CY1~ <()\--~ ~~ CV'\ <.\ 1-\~k>r~ W,
.S ~·,.1(.u ~ or~v<4-lM~t, -\-o corf<ifV\. ht~ 4C+iortS ~ -rhi~ Co~
o"'w . . .Du.. .s~ -e--t-r-e-\ ~-n \l ~w--t\~ ~"'6{ 1wld- q.2! 1 <)JJ_ (Te~c.r'""'
-A~~ lCfCJt,{J _f~:Oo~ \\ ~\..ld.A ac~ifl l~ ~\- ~\tw\ v-Jtil ~- wrl~~
€) ~ MUll~ ~).S :::I: Si ~ 1/ X ~ C\-\ Cf 3.l C Ct.\ -hn ~w f1w' f'-.-Vv-t'.S ~
t
~ tv\_-·~ cdL C)\10' ve__.\,\e-\- k IV\_dy \oLJ4jir~ -U\-\,-\--le,J~ by
\ o.w uv~ ~ <t <-u ~ ' {Le_JptcACu I~ j ....J.""'~ f4 dj
~ lt:" I{ CcJ:byL
h-nhcf\ Wr I...Qr-\\- ~ fV\ 01 ~ f «p1-..U o{:J.t.f
h f &Q·J,c o-JQ.J !YvY'O~'VV\\) :t a -+~ J(Y) JOj \f)tt.to d
~/l.::J\.~ 51~~\-..<:& vo ~~?1'3
, 5J- ~\- ~ VQ
")bl UJ L -J<_j__!~J<tM tJ '~} ~"7\v~-u - C") '\ 011 ~\ ~ M ~nw~
7lv1'J) -:p ~J'lG f vo J 0) b \I] L. ·)<-'-1 \.vJOcY" 1:J 1 -\: )'~\>'A\o ~ : M
)Q]) "'?Jl?"V fd}JO"r) 1 ~ ~ 1O)L ·~_J_) \/tks('("'YJ' -yj I -tY ~V)Y\ (}tJ '(_VI l~'h
1 rtAJY)tr r~ ~ d F~ ~ s::. .t. 't, o0) L ')<_£ vo-rr~~->'\1 ·..)G f<t Qrn ~o ~ ~ob 1
JO )1' '1'J ~ ~ ~ ~ o \~'-'..1 n ~ \J'J 'j- rl? (YI ~yw-c~ vrJ\.v --j" G> \-'~· o-")
JCl:3 Vtt.~tt<rJ r-'-'\~&?J~ -~--JQ, ~oC'J l? -\~,"V\- ~r~~ -yo, htYJ-?V"l>-~
?J'i-t ~ \rf) ~~ ~~~ CN\"
yr;r, -d~ ~ """"~ vcr-ICJ-J(} _s:. v_,
I¥~ f~ \.Lf) ~ --Y~ r·d-\~ v 1' (2!2.. fC\ \ --=tF Uot\ ~ »~'' VO\ \'d < :::r:.--
75! ~ ()~) jO J-00 Jc}
~ 11 _:1"~ RS'I-~\----l. Vo ~o:vn'dt-3
r/ f;2JVO.t..t ~~~lJ~ rl?~ -~ -\~VVb-:;) h);;>,J'<'l")')l') o-_f~ 'QJJYl 0 ) Q
tq--...., •b
Of t-.\o ~~_) A'l v('qoo.r'~<r~ ~o'd..:> -yvo ~J"l:>'Jl? -)0 <1\"\'!?&:,'J '5"}
t.1 h,'()hf' )\ -yvo //~sen~ ..., 'Y~Y"lb -Jg ~1~'\A.J >:7 n \Yt5'-Vo~nv -~\'
01~ 1-vovvM~~\ y to tvowcf~n\'b -jo 01~<:YV )bP~ n<; ou\~~.-L")
Oo - b 'h \ -YO "' 'C(Y'I r 1\ k ~ Jl,Ao7 OOj .. ~~ cna-J 'J_, \~""~ Cf'\,X -v \
(7-J'o \A,~ '-vt fo~\ro~-Vc-) ftV?Jvvn")~ n!? 7 0 OJ '-fCVV )b 0 ~ h \ 0";;\ ~
1/PJ 1-v"OJ 'i~o')l_~voJao dll!'4o~'Jo "'!A- v,\ "~v-rpv, o---~\0-o
-T~~{'I-) t,9 ~d-\J<'dthrdJO LIQ~l.\-ttad ~-lAt. r-1~Y \.,h1'JoJ A-.ro"o
+~} r~LI(Y) ~· \./D l;O~I.y:a-~ d\.J~ 0 ~ ~~ ~ \ <7-~ ~(Y?> _) o-" b '1 -Tl? 't\-- +=
~ l
~rJ?}d -J'l ~Yl?vod~~.vn ~r J.,~OJ?>'-1 7JY1() ·)<:_1_/~""'<0 vor~_c.
"'
--~ 1~ tJ1t r <Ti}ib r ~ u~ I 0~-& fCI L:tr Ut.t\ lo') } J \\ VO\ \v
1 IX
U0~>:0~-
/\'
CSINIB02/CINIB02 TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUBTICE 08/18/15
ST55/LS00069 IN-FORMA-PAUPERIS DATA 09 ~ rZtG : ~:ii
TDCJ#: 01123880 SID#: 03437930 LOCATION: STILES INDIGENT DTE: 03/26/15
NAME: CALTON,ALLEN FITZGERALD BEGINNING PERIOD: 02/01/15
PREVIOUS TDCJ NUMBERS: 00484586
CURRENT BAL.: 0.00 TOT HOLD AMT: 0.00 3MTH TOT DEP: 0.00
6MTH DEP: 153.57 6MTH AUG BAL.: 28.84 GMTH AUG DEP: 25.60
MONTH HIGHEST BALANCE TOTAL DEPOSITS MONTH HIGHEBT BALANCE TOTAL DEPOSITB
07/15 0.03 0.00 04/15 ill. 2-3 0.00
06/15 0.03 0.00 03/15 137.36
05/15 0. 13 0.00 02/15 142.71 153.57
PROCESS DATE HOLD AMOUNT HOLD DESCRIPTION
STATE OF TEX MOUI\ITY):{F _j_e.J~_G_y~()Y)
9
ON THIS THE ..!Jl DAY OF\::f¥§TIS.-t:=~;·r~ I CERTIFY THAT THIS DOCUMENT IS A TRUE,
COMPLETE,AND UNALTERED COPV MADE BY ME OF INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THE
COMPUTER DAT~IBASE REGARDING THE OFFENDER' S ACCOI,J!iT. NP S I G:
PF1-HEL.P PF3-END ENTER NEXT TDCJ NUIYIBER: U~~Q_(JOR SID NUIYIBER: -------·---------·
STEPHANIE LUTE
Notary Public, State of Texas
My Commission Expires
03/03/2018
Notary without Bond
RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
AUG 2 6 2015
Abel Acosta! Clerk
r-
/
l
C\Qr 'i}
()_Q : =c: "' ('(2_ A'\ <Ul " f l' Cq 1+on
(\ ) (? 12 \I ~of) t=V_r v.::> (" \ \- Q{ ~ 6-o..u.t_j
C:}.) \4\0-M'~ A.\-.(:,~\~ .Ap(l01'~··~ Xf"'\.J~f'OM 0{:---·~ l.I,Jrtt ~f ~ ~
._,:- ·, \JJ Q..Q_\ct~<::j .A.\:~6CUJ "~
E-x.(>\cJrJn_J 'T4~~~ c.(.,'--l_D-€\~4/\ r..ul4~ ~~ (lo,U ef
CP/) t""VJ.\vv/) 'for u "!~ \ U \-1 LL ~ Acc..u~~ ( (\ r Met-. }. ~j Pe -\,\, J"
(gt) ~~.\.o('J ~q-h~A ~(\~(~~ ~revt.oy.J ~lt\~JS
C<:P) ~ .\.W/') ~ r Le.~ \'\) r: \.('
~ ~ d.~J , t:tt ~VI"\ \'\,.>\~t-o( ~ ·~ pl( l.o rri e,j \ \:{
Ql\~ f\ en ~ 1 ~~ Uf'.\. h--e J. evv6 ~~ ,_ eA ,o ~- ~ ~ ~o::;tp
\c~-\- ~~ Ac..L.i:>W\-\ J~~ ~ ft"k~ Orlj-1\t<dJ () {. ---Yf.-e.. j ~
~ ev+ CA> 1 \ \ ~ ~f\ \€. weJt if!_ -h XLe__ J ~ ( -e 6 Ceut ~ c:t6~\..K? ,
AtJ o f,\Q_ M.cJ' 'l -~ 4-Lt. fJ 4~J § {' -e.crci-1 CV7,ci C{J r~.- ..ft..(_
~ JZ. (\ ~ b.U'· J-o -€_4~ ~ ~- PQ ~ ~~~ ~-\w- (\ ik_ I
--fct~ (jJ tt.~ Qs- b et vk_ ~ ~ ~ 11-P . J . A .-J, t ~ C\' lJ 0
--€/\ clo J <V d ,
-(hcv'\ \::.... 't·o~ f
~\IF-U~
AU~u~"tCc..t~4- \\~.S !~-() RECEIVED IN
j.\,\-eJ ~1 COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
'bd-DD fM 1SIY AUG 2 6 2015
e~+-r-rx../7 -pos- Abel Acosta, Clerk
c QuAj_Q_ AJ 0 ' -----------
3 / \ ~- A\\V\ '' f,., Cct\~11
C(\·~nG{ \ Are.Q.a;\ c~ \e'LQ-S
~\4-\-v,'~ ~ 0 '\ ~r Lee{v-e.__ TO ~1L-e
~ A. cc.~CV\ Q0:-:Vj t\~ ~ e.A1 \-1 on ~_r L.O C'-\ \- o .f. MCVJ -~~
---'(""c ~ \~orvor a \ole ·-:r 1..-1 hj .e_s 0 .( S cJ d
AJ<hv0 (.()~s fU.. \ tt\-or ..A\:\ ~ '' f Cc:d ~-" ( \te\ ctkr) 0/1 c\ ~v--e ~
1
'
--th \ ~ CovJ'"\ Q W' .l\A. wr\ ~ \. \\-.A f>. ~ '"T2. \ -Por I~ C1 v-e -to -hIe
~..e Acvoi"V"\~~l· "j {)-€\1~d) hr Lu<"'l \; o+ M.&l (\OWA,~ I
~.C-v~. ~f-0Vl\~.t~ ~J,~<lfe~ P-Ju\<t~r '(leJ[Je~~/1 M..Ov'-eJ
-fhl~ CovJ'\- +or l-e4~ ~ ~t~ ~ Ac~o..u,rrtJ ~.e-h-ho11 ~.r'
(Le_Jpetk !A lyJvb~fk J)
~''f''~
£CDO t ~ -S er-v·l c..JL..
~ ~ ve.\o'( ~~ ~ ~ LA)f>i 'D-\-~.t +orej4 \f1j 1
1..>-)QJ -hr-.'A ~C!.SJ
rvtav\e ~ ~ ~~ Jvt,dtif l90~ OojvJ\)nd Dr. Ar\i'llsh:Yt;Tx../"6'~
--c) lA ~ ~JL Lovt\ ~ .J ~uJf\S L{ ol e0 - Ke ~'?tl\~ J \. ; F+ C!Jif.~ ;T~-~~ 19\...
~ ~cJ' \-e ~ M q,l t t\n
Q/'\- Li o L LV. ~~ ~\tvtuQ ~ ~, F~ \.A.)ur~ 0-x. '~''c,
0./\ ~ - \ ' - { ~ ' ,.. (\ (\
~\
\f r (I+-:~ •
L( lA.)I..A.JIJJ'-.
oC
c_ ('I "M) fla'l Af p-eed <tt \e'lq_.s
Re\ct\-or~ ~ Lea~\~ ~1\-e. ~~ Au-A0~~rVIJ ~~\.-hoi)
f\t\_..o\-\o!l
tor °"' \
\..0 0 ~ N\ CU\ ~CV"\~Vt ~ ~ '~v~ t ~ <4. yV'\\r P ~ f\'\.vtl \,' 9\ ..e. Co9 t' .e ~
\ b -(\'"\__Q.. \~(\~f o.lo\..Q_ -::)~ ~ Ji ..s 0{ ~ ~; ~ ~uf\ \ .
AJwvCcxv-Jl\ ()._Q_\~~~ CVI~-Bie1
fh..o-hun ~f'
A\,\Q/\ ''f''Cc.Jt-o/1 -rhil hi~
L e. 4vi \o ~'\~e ~. A<t..-o~OvVt~"j ~e"-\10f\ ~--~' wr,~ Of- tv/0--1~-S.
w\~'-i\- ~ (Leq\...Vt'<:'l ~ A--cUI\·-\- o+ ~\-\i pl-e Copi ei A-i (l..e-
q ~ r:e ~ b--t Vtt. i 1 Co\JJI\ .. ~\a. \-or IV--:0~~ -\1Jl.. Cov-.n;~ (? lAI'Ju M{- h
\ . Q... A . \\ We. .2.. +:,r _, c,c.V\ 1.eq~ . w • ~ 1 1.. J l-vow ,·n .S<>(Ieol'\
A'::::. f.=oil ovJ.S :
_:r:._
u) ~\Jro\ IJ (?{1)~~'".1 ~ (l)J..Q. I i' )I) 61 j Q..,~ I jV\ wrt« !i't 1/( a. d ~J
('/Q Ct ·cu ~_) +-a Q Lo Qcc. r'\1\et ~ ; ~ N_ M_ Ct.. ~ a d ~' .\-1 Jr\ 4 ( u pi'e J'
\)vvt~ ~ \4 \-v r c...v-o u \. 6.-- have_ .+-o M·t u J ~c, I ~4'~ a ·f.
h.i\ .} ~ ~ L- C1 \, ul\ .-f-o ( M. 4~ 0 r ~:-ef re ~~ I u n 4o w rd-~- J. o (""\ ()/\ l(
Go'{) I eJ.
l2) ~\c,<h,r m1>.;;nJ _s-o ...,~ .kte-> pl.).)e~ c,JuW~.k.,( r/.1)(
-\-0 ~ .1 M~ 1~ cv, 6 s "'~ , Dv..e +v s v c)-1 « d0'fl re Jlf d. ..! ~
~M ~oir1..J '-"'~uJ hI 1 rr-R~~\ <<c.A,ul\. ~r Lonj f'U''"'d.r
0 { . -\,'·rl_ , ...f..Y._.L- (l.e\4-~ rs A\{, c\~t \ 6 ,(_? \~vt t'ng ·-s- h -f1 c; b\.t
1
\A_)
,,.A_.
I .
'
\)~\~ \"" 5~Y--.\(\J MM~~~ 0-Q;~\e~. ()f\ -h\~ h-ere)'('\ a.·t
f Gt_ }Q. ~ { - l 0 p WGt j ( ~\u J_ q - 3t ~
~ ~- \-vee.1 ~rQ..vv\\s.e.s Wll..S"'·b-QJ'-€ ~; (t...~.A~\-or f'V'-O!N?..~ -Vltv\.i CoW'-\:
-+a<' \ -e_qv-e -\-a .h~-e_ -\'N. Ao.~~Glvtt'll_f ~~ct\-or eu1 ~Y\ ~- C'€?l411:'-e- ~
Q..r-o UA. \-· o -\ ~ \\-{ Qlre La\)\ eJ C\' ~ Q._Q. tu..il'-f ~ bY -Y\...e_ T e 'f-. q -l ~
()~ ~'QQ~-,,~ ~ (\) (.,{ ~ uf'e_ .
Gl-e_.if t- \.\~I\~ ~.A\of"\,+,i.e ~
~-''f''~
..X Gr~l.4 ~Ct\- Ci LU'(J'-( 0~--~
'-"v-e\o-r +o.rejOl'0J LAJQj
~ r.) \-- c.Act ~s AI\ c0 \ e ~ -\-o _) ~ .s ~dAe.r 19-0 "i' (j-0 J vJ{)od Or' Art( ns hY?(
~~- llRorl 0u ~JL 1-oJ..\\ ~\-wllJ ~(.)1 w, G-e\~qp--n-.1 F-1-
J
~cv_r ~ 1}-·;o(- 1 ~ I cr (o cvv~ ~ciflle j IV\ a.A l< !1 4 o 1 w . (!::. e\ k-
!\~ ~\Jf\-vU>f'~ ;-1"'--!lol9(p 0/\ ~-1~-1~.
~~~-F''~-
~ (\ J9 1, a&'"'~ --~..~ "+ "~-- ~ lrJ> Ocly "1' ""'~i'"J~ v >;-s~""\Ulll
)oo"l/(} -1-o "~-,~~0~ aJ 110 ·c: -s \ \)\Jv ·-~~
t, (\o ~ -'1-~j_-j-g. 1-s-~.L--w.~""Jc> f\ .0'\k ~I ,N I' 1'~'.,'1~3 'o ~r'r>~\V (8
·~ J~~'OD o-s QJ o o )t>
l.J~~'JD ~~llqJbjo-' cr"c~o o~ u~ j\~fhvJ ou~vord-J~.J \..V'O :r: (t)
4 ~+);>w 0'-tK J Q \l}\-n4 -~ fu,~cr P~ )to ~o)~ hm\~~
j-Q htlb~d ~ ~:vn J'o~r ~vo ~S ·0'\K 0-...\ "':Y~~d} -vv"J
-:r:: tJVU rl )?~ o~- q ~ ··-J o )a \oQ'-') -fJ <N.) o-:> ~ \rlQ ~~-\- ·<J--.1'0
tt~~ fl~6JQdJOJ~ -yvo \~~-\b fJ\.Y\ \-1?'-tt \'Jl:J-j- 0\-\t\" 0 o
Qd~,O"''\""'~ lbUO_fJ?;()\ ?J-"1?'-') ~\/?:)) \-'~\ljjb ~\"'\)\ 0U,(1111?VJ -J"Q
0)0., o(J'ro ./ ~~VVJ ~ \rA a()~ 'J -to f .J"'o }-.. O'JC> ~'-''0-C'll \ ....r0 t"' v.P()
) -J q. I
-L \-b'1t: r~r· V-;)\.J~P'~\rf} ~ 1 Q1~l'e,\\~ l.fo.t\\:J),,~,, VO\\v· \f)
'~~vovv 7 0 -t'~ ..>~ uo~'\'7J& ,~ 'JG \'J·o~~r V::t: ~~b~~1•o ~
? ~VAn ry -\Vo\NYY)<:'-Q ~-'0\J~UOJ "J\o) v 30 "'~~vvod\{ \~~~)V
)\~ ~\'-1\- fd)'J" yVO \J~\'0"'0) ~\9-:) ~~" VO)\V '.~O"J ~acy-
:-tvnOJ ~~) J-G -oS~n_L. O)~l?Jau~\ -~o_J_
r~~:ii?:J\.v tQ \-\.sC'C') )~ ·lO \J 0 0c)-ns- v.::::r:- 1!t~ddV \'C'O::>~;"JJV )~~l?\~"t\
rvroJ 0-y )bV\jhN \ - . ) J
._j~b\0\l
-J-0
~VV'~ -~ u-r-
Vcrt)b'J VI~\\ Vo nv ~ vx
~ Q (Y '()S'Y'I"O J
·'~
_,
I rH-o I J --atD ~ --)..." ""=- --~. ,~ vW c> v r, """~ "flv ':><>-'?'\a-U
.'
01tk <>t -\"'\""\ ~ \l.C1 \ >:. J "'1" Vl>\\''1' s--•uv 1\~\.' vf' s <rM> \ l 'J ~
~
<U.._
.(<}if) ~d-J-.1<>-:l ~VV (}-M~ b SX 1
,\l " t;i''"'\"-3 >o \'~"''1\'V' (C11)
b -oS -o~ -\-~
I
) t \1""d.f"' ~"""' C-\ Ol ~Jb j
\;1- '!."> I £ Jo'l.."' - 9,.\ <l'l L <lQ -£ rc -J . OlY \'
--0~ \J\~ LO--b-1 VQ ~d-\"J- Jb~Q ~.\ro ~l JQ LI?Jc~UC) ! YJ'-1::1,
} Q r.f' Vl'I'U lj I VW<~ "'-'>-1l\N f ~if) \'I' ';>-\ -) 0. S-t: 1)!:m d -0 .m1 1-? ~ <'b
. )-Jt:::r; -fJ~-\J~ fl..-0 ~ "b ) :C. )I-C),'-· t '9'~t<_3 po ~ <f"Pl?l'\V (~
~ () ~ 11 & --\"""'?
1-. L'1. voJ:Jo 'tJ - 1_ 0) 1f h~ ()-- ~ J 0) L Q Q-~ [ \\ • 7 '~(Y -\ ".>01 ~ Q!Vd RJ,)
- o-J u~ (_Q·b-\ {A ~d-\~ ~JO ~vo ~ -10 ~o' \Y'C"y) uo; I ~-J11_j.
JQ fd V )'~ U 10 I V\A")r frOJQ...v.iuJ }~OJ \}? \ J_}_ ·-J- 0 fl -c 0 ! l7 0 -\-~JO) '1.? ~ ()
"hO.cn ::poJJOJ ~~vo <f0.}-\? r:r:: '"J "1·"~'~1<3 )"O "~~~1\7' (~
·-z_ ·-o f-v a ·--\ --a
"X .I;~ 10ddv 't)- ~ "l 1 [ "h ~ Q - ~' OJL QQ -- r n:- ; ' t\CY 1~ -.)en 0-\ 01 \JQJ?J J
-"dJ \J,t L._Q-6-\ L4 ~q~l_:! ~JQ ~-VO ~J -}a lJQ_I\¥T'pU~ I ~1.?::::1
j-Q. sf~·-~~)).:) lVW)ri/Oj ~'\..\) '\'~O"J \'0 ~,)~ -J Q )~ o' r-o d -\0 J()~ ?- -T \)
;..,de>-) fl~.JO'":) ~-~ --r<'->\ Q 5':r }1 ~\~C\~"~3 ~-Y.? ~1f'P~V (L,.)
~oJl?c) 'tl? i.vvl0~ (t-£ )CYV~! LO)'& p~,Q..\'\ f~Lt'SLCJ
\ O(Y ~ \ 0 \~_L.J'O:::j ~J<n~ ~~-:;-a~ -\JY'O') 10 -1-0--m}.d-
tG ].,c}<r) _'f)()JJ(Y) ~\ft.:] lf'C'.>\ t) s-.::r: Jj I\ t'C)')")(~ ~r;? ~l"'frJ~V (OJ)
s-[ ra31?o -\1? j~c>v- f1l. ~-a ·~~~,.~
''h.;J...L }0 \~.d-__L w'~~...ro-~ 4'\-\ s::r: uJ~\ -\''·"~~~3 "lv.:> ~<5'fJ~\V CS')
y y&oo -y:o "'i 1~ verd av 1'\ ~ , o ·0: ~ · '1)
'"i..a_L~Q \'~--a-l.. w(\-\-~JOC\ o'\\'SX ~~ V' 1i~~~~~3 ~'0 ~'6'\J~~V \\7)
~
(
Co v-.0\- ~ Dr\..v\s G..A\-vC\c..CA ~-on ~ oCAJ'I6 ~61 "'- t?afx~ 1 0 ~ V{
(_\ \) t;\:Sc._ke ~ Q<;.E'f.-"'1~~± '\ -=c" 0-S'~./' ~ro~ 11--e__ '-R'f-.CtS. ~u/1{- c-{
~,(VV\(J a{ A\' p-eal~ d ~- ~ 'A--.~ 3 .,.., 15 D-NtJ.u" _:-~ ._ )_
vu v - u.,. -()\ " p a fe-- c
U ~) -A\-\-aili-~ o.s. £x.\..~\o1\- "\l '' \.~ a__\-<'~ ev, ~ C-()fr~e~ ~\Py-c{:~
11 1
GoCYQ..s ~on~<..Q Froi"Yt ~-\-e~Q.S ~W'--\-.o-G- c_~'<vt{na~ Ap p-ect\s ~q:\-e d
s; - ).:1. -{ { Ae ~-~ "'- cu\- ~o gJL \3
\_JJ) _A\.\u~~ 0.~ E)(.~b;\- ''\(t( \~ Ct \-c-~ CV) 6 ce>\r-e~ Co\f)y o~e_
o0 ~u ~-"'\ -\1-e_ u. ~.Go vf'T I)C A~p.e.cds fl' (~ c 1 ~<-u.tl-\-- 0-€1\4-l'·n_g Cc;:( \.d)
L~c-t-v-e.. ""T'D \=--1\ ~ et 't v--e- ~ :J-.;;1.. .s c...t 'P ~-\,-\,-on ~S'
-S '--lc<.Q.sJ vOrt -\- '6 -\ l~ 6-eq s
C-D S' ~ L-{__S. A-p ~ ~'\ y.._ a..+- f C{ ~! { Lf 0-1 6 \~ '
(\~ ;A\--\-~~~ o.s &l-ti~1\- \lLu \-~ 4 4-tv-.e. (1/\d ~rc,-ect ~f'Lt t>Q~O~
~i~ ~:-t- 0" vt b f-Q.( .A<Uv.>QJ' d ~\--lo/1 -ro o,·.srnt'sr f=or Lo.U..L of
Gvt
~ '--v\oj~~ 1V\ ou\ W ~v'J'-\~ ~-\c\;tn A-t~~' i--. cu\- Pu:S'.e___s 16-19,
Q~J ,A\-\u.chQ ~ OS E><~' \,.1 \= "M_t~ t-~ o__ ~ 0v1 ~ c..vrre~ ~Pt "{){'- -\1--e_
~ vt.-"~~ fV\{?A;\ Gs- t' cvt,-\+nj 0 -e_ ~-b-OA\ --s-\A~\ ~~-\Yl \\) 0 ~~ rwt S..S ~S' Lu c.(<._
of- .S. u.\o J ~ ~ -M~\-w T ~ t ~ l c\1 of\ A p(l'Z1<\·1 "'- ~-\-- t> u ~ ~
'
CtCeJ ,_A \-·\c.. W.-~ ~s E ><- l-td2 J- ''.AJ 1' is Ct. ~('vLQ__ OV!~ C-oJ1re ~ C-<J~y c\.-e~~\
s- -\-~ .s LL 1\ l,v- 5 ~\- A~~~ A C")J..N--0' ~ ~ ~-\-i ~J\ 'TO o ~-J.flvi sJ PW'J ~mrt
~ ~oQk.r \l{ 0 ~ ~ lei.ctS C.\uil -Q~e;\.'c..Q._ CV'l-~ ~~e~ ~ck Ap---
(> .2/\ ~· '~--- AA-· 6' o.f~s :2. t c.t 0 ,
(j j) A-\-.\-et ckt ~ Ol..J &k, 6 t 1\ 0 1r 1 ~ o.. --\-('J-Q 0/v ~ (\red- ~1 Dt:-
t CQ)
~ ~ ai\A &\- ~- .s~,~,lv-l1 ~~ -ro ~ lo)M1\-~ 0-.tJ~a-)J_Q_ 'l<:> o~~ott\ _
yv-.o-h v-1 10 Oti ~"vii~ ~wJi..tV"\ -\-o cJ-t~ \q o~- 11-e. Tc-i--L;'vi\ p{tlc_ ~~ ~~l e_r
•
jLdqJ-or_J A~-(. ~Q..<.II-\- A,~}, )'J- .::r:f'1~~ ()c.t~ -lCt cr{ \) [
(_\ ~ A \-\6..- t \ ~ K ~,, ., \\tf'll(
V\1\e-c CA ·~ I'Ol\ Y ls Ot \r\J...Q o.Ad. (..o-rrec\ -\'le Of'~
G-~ (M\i A~ ~ e ~ ~ <:M\ &\ev-e ~ ~ dlt.r:S '%>tl611 To iJ\& 0t-l ~ ~ ur .s \.w..-t{-·+n
~~w 1'-\ t.t. ~~ \~os C\'JH OrCic-hlQ. CZA~ Q.QMe~'t e.s L.oJ~ Pyyl?A~j''i...
Cv\- pC\~fL 3D
- .,, l(
llq) A\-\ovhe-~ &'-Jo'\ \ 0 \5> a. \-r~ 0/\~ G-Dfr-e.-ct C-0{><-f o? the
C<s
\('\et\ Li>W'V.s. GA\~C£.t.\1bn 6~ ~~ ~0/l~ ~jh\- TV App.ea( Af(J.QAdj X
~-\- Qu._S~ 3(
(~oj A~a~~ ~i E-t-\..\ 'b \\: ~ ~~ \~ a.. \-,lM? CVld Go rreG\ (_;v~'f
b~ A\\€.1\ H ~·' Ccd·\-vrl A> D\;(R. ~pea\ A('~e.., t1 ~ 01+- ~Qje J 2
(_~\j A~\-~~~ QS Ex~;~l~ ,.,Stt \s o._·\-n}.~- Q/vct c..oriecl-lPf'(
o ~ /V-Dt, .,,.., He> r T ~ \Up o r4-u'~ fLe-c..o; 6 &1 ~ At'~ }.CUJ; t a€
~c.~lt ~ 10 \'"[ ~ LotM.u>l a. 6 tupoi'\V>J ilQ.wn~ Ap(lll1/i, 1 '~- a\- f·:JJ
( ~ :1-J A ~CtcN l ~~ £J-.~(~\~ \~:1" "t~ ct:\-r:u..e CV\~ (...().rf(.c.Jc Gb~l( (r\- or~
A-(>Qo~'.(\~~ Goi.V\~··\ t=Os ~ ...AcfpQa( 0/\d D"~ ~r LoW\-'\- (le_poJWr
s.\- ~· ~~{ \\ QJ -w ~t e.p~ ~'Or\.v~ 6l.cuv<-~ .A(Jf0tr~) ~ a+f>u ~ 3~
(:lJ) A\\c.~~ ~ e~ ~~ lo~ \: \lu_: t-& o. ·\r lA.Q Cv\6 co rreG\ ~PY 0-\--
A~~\\a:k.f LoLV\J-eJ . ga.rr1 A\-tvri'~ ,_;.J{..;~~v.)r) O{Jf1~~ cA~are-f 35 Cl//d3h
(2l\) A-\-~ c~e ~ Ct ~ E)(\,\, 1;-r\- '.., Vu \ s. q_ \-,lJ\.Q 0/\ d co r r-c c\ ~'f(y o-C
'·
Lt-tW\1> A~\-€.1\''ftt (evli-tYl ~ -S\-~ S ~~1\V' do.::bc\ s- 2-IJ
AfpLq~))( Ot\- @ag~ 3 7 ·
~\ql,.u \"'-_~ A\.(., ~C<.A.> ,-t Afpe-1 f1 x.. .::r,..,d ~ 'I( fJ a.~ \ \) t:>{' \} j
'
I
c~s) A\\c. c.M.e~ C-tS £'k ""'\~\\ ~w \( .\ ~ q \- ('~ Cv\~ (.;o t f'e-Gt ~~ 't 6~ ~
"'f\(\et\ o <'W +{orv--- ~ (bv.f'\; ~ 0 ~ ~\lcaA1of'\ (Yo~ c\ct\-e~ I J.-1- ().
tn ~e-. ,v,~-\-\er n{ .&\e~ S~t\\Qf' ~ JJo, 1.2.. -LJtDCoS-11, A~p-Mcll '(
a.,-\- v 4 8t s 3 ~ - 4 ()
~~_) ,A\\uc..h.e.~ Ot~ ~)(~;~~\- ''x'' \ & 4 \-,v--e_ Cvlck c..orrec~ o-\' G:vl~~
'(J~Q/)~ Le\-~ ~ s.\-e~ S.~\\W u..pp€11~11--. a\- petfi-5 41-'-13
()__ l) -A-\-\-ac.he,6 Cd
11 · t S. ~. \-cu._e CV\~ c....-o r~ct CA(>V[ D.f
E ~\"'.\,,-L'\ ~
{)S ~!'I"\ ~~ \ ~~rN2.~\\c Gt.Q\wn \)..e\.ti\)t ~~ A~~'~i¥.. aA-- fa.~ 4~
0- ~) A-\-\-~~~ 4~ E,J,\ b\t \\ 2'' :Ls 4 ·tcv--Q.. Cvld c...o rrec.k Go~'-( -o-f
'""-Ho..r~ p4 S~ q 0 ~ ~\a\ G:,W'\~ rn """'"""!""""' 1=1~6, In ~J
1 oC tc.c\1
C...Onc\u.!JQf"') 0·\:-·· L~ Q/\J 0\'~ ·1="JI.e~ 0/l 1-1-67 tn <:'e.W-€1\~
-\-o <...V('i\ .AJ1>. C-1.\1- 6a7CQl~ -D'8\.f1i ~"6 ._A O-(Jp1V1hi-.. ec/-\- ~fe.. l!JS
~ L1) -~\-9 vhe.~. ~ E: Y-k~\o~l ~\'AI\ 2L.& ct \-rv-JL Q/\d e-c\{'{'cl U:>f('t ~
(4
e V...<w-f>~ ~a~ e.- ~0 o\-. \r' l!t \ C..O\JJ't' s ~~.fW'l &VV'-, ~(l)d.'""' ~ -l -t> \. ~c~ I
1
G-onc.h.(~l dl o~ ~ Cv1c\ oc-W. ~de~ o.n 1-9-'6 7 in c-e~er~c.e..
-\-o c.o<""\-\- .A.Jo, C, l.\ J-OOl(ol "6 -C5'B'-(11(p"b- A ~a-,~1·'( Q::\- P(tft t.j ~
0-.Q.sQ·e~~\l.~ ~vi/·~~\~~}
~v\fl(~.
~ ) ~L\ "Vl''t I{ Lct t+v(\ ~ \\)3'8"<60 ,~,'()~ ~C'-1·~~~ t'nC.OJ"'(Jt!'C{-Wd cA ~ ~~les
lM.t.\ 1 \(\ 0e~\-v-J~fl GLV\~ 1 1-e-'1-..c·c~ 1 ci~c.\o-re \_.VI~~ ~q~l~ l{- QW'Jury
~ct-\-~ ~ r-e3ol() ~
~<:.<MI\Sl-rtJ q·\-\c.tc),,.~-t~ ~ere+o ar-e. \-r~. 0/\~
L-a f('ev\ <--o()1 e~ -c.\. ~- o,,'_g ~~Ql ~ <M~ .r ~y~ {)-W'J~no( \<n.()w\-e~JQ_
o\ ~ J orr--R.-.- CAd~&~ ~c;. ~CtJ..ed o.f\ ~£onq( ~ 0 '-'.)1-eJ.~"
l=;<.e~~o/\ ~-l<&-(~ ~ ~~\< ~ ~
f\-.t_ ~~ r' s ~ ~~.-~..n \- A f p~ ~ 1 y._ .=c..-, ~.(. ~ f ct J.e V'6 f: V(
r\,
'
'•
:c: { A \\-eA \,\ ~ L~vto/1 :#: \ \13''6'60 l 1\n CAF' CQ/"'C{k~ a~ ~ J\Jl(~ l.k~t)
H
\ (\~e\-~~on Co V-/t~ 0~~u~ ~~ ~-Q/'e\,~ ..s:~ ~-~ \1-e. ~€/\~( ~
o C- Qst5'.)""'1 ~e--tA-- ~-co~~ o\- ~ kv<e.<j<>1~_f ~-e-\J\un . ~~"" C..O\':-t
() ..(.. M~~o-v...u. GVCd -h ~~\ U Ct \J fY\~~) ti~ \-o -1~ ev--e k~~ (( U' I Cf 0 '6
o o .3 w!n>~ Cc · J ~c:'4~~" j1x_.l ep o l.:l · J ~u~ g..e__ Lot..t.l ~ ~-\- UJILS
Y o I w . $-e--\ Krqp &~ 1 ~ t v<Jbr.fl.\ ,-:rx..' Cu f<H~ / ~CV'[e ~ mq__/{(\r,
·Lto 1 w - C?. t, "(\
~ s\ 1 t" +. U-x> Jf1/\ 1-r>Z ~~ 19c., 1 CVi ~ o'~-t~:J c.*
C\QJ' \L- ~mcd WI)~ i f t-l() 1 w- G-tl\ ~C\P ..)-\- · 1 +i:. ~~ -;T'>~..7{of9~
Dr'\ ~-\<i-\~'
~-''fl1 ~
§ 52.046~ General Powers and Duties I
'I
(a) On request, an official court reporter shall: I
(1) attend all sessions of the court; \
(2) take full shorthand notes of oral testimony offered before the court,
incll1~ingo-bjec!{oil;s made t-o- the adinissibili ty qfevidence, coutCrulirigs al.ld
remarks-em the objections:· a~d ·exceptions to the rulings; · ·
(3) take full shorthand notes of closing arguments if requested to do so by
the attorney of a party to the case, including objections to the arguments,
court rulings and remarks on the objections, and exceptions to the rulings;
(!J) preserve the notes for future reference for three yP-ars from the date on
which they were taken; and --·- ------·-
(5) fu~nish a transcript of the reported evidence or other proceedings, in
whole or in part, as provided by this chapter.
(b) An official court reporter of a district court may conduct the deposition of
·witnesses, receive, execute, and return commissions, and make a certificate of
:the proceedings in any county that is included in the judicial district of that
:court.
(c) The supreme court may adopt rules consistent with the relevant statutes
r to provide for the duties and fees of official court reporters in all civil judicial
proceedings. ·
(d) A judge of a county court or county court at law shall appoint a certified
sl:to:rthand reporter to report the oral testimony given in any contested probate
matter in that judge's court.
Rule 13....C.oud~Jie~mters
proceedings before the .. court take. preference
~nd Collrt '~e~orders -· other work.
13.1. Duties
.. ·.
of.····:··
Court '
Reporters. and Record-
. ' ; .
: '
Eff. Sept. ~. 1997.
· ers 13.4. E,epQrt of R~p~rt~rs_i
The official court repo);ter or court recorder must: To aid the trial court in setting priorities under
(a) unless excuseq by a~eeme~t of · the parties, each court reporter must giy~.the trial court a .
atten_d court sessions. and make_ a full record of the ly written report showing·tqe aiJ!ount and nature.
proceedi~gs; , · the b~si:qess peU:ding in the r~porter's office. A
of thA:;;' rep_o!;i must, .!Je' fil¢d ~~h _the appellate clerk
(b) take all' exhibits offered in evidence during a each district in which the court sits. . .
proceeding and ensure that they are marked; Eff. Sept. 1, 1997.
(c) file all exhibits with the trial court clerk after a 1:t5:: · Appointing D~puty Reporter
proceeding ends; . Wh~~- th~ 'offid1a( '6~kt ~-~~cn~t~r is u~able to '
(d) .perf()rm the_ duties prescribed by Rules 34.6 _and form the' duties i~ '13.1 0~'13.2 because of . . _·
35; and of offi~i~J ~otk, or'
~h~10'iddble ab~~nce . . . '
(e) perlorm other acts reiatjng,to the .reporter's or the trial court' rriay ·designate ;~ dei)uty reportei~~
r~cord~r's offici~, du,ties_, as, .t~e, trial court •dir~cts.
the court appoints a deputy reporter, that person
Eff. Sept. 1, 1\)97. Amended by Sup~eme Court Dec. 23, 2002, eff. must file With tne triai cbtirt clerk a. docU:merit statingr
Jan. i,'2003. · " · · · · · ·· · · :(a) the 'date th~' d~puty ~orkkd; · _ · ·
. Not~s ~~d Continent~/ . (b) the coJ.ITi; in which.t)le d!i!puty.~orked; and
. ,,1•' ' ,· . ' •' ' ' '
Comment to 2002 change: Subdivision 13.1(a) is (c) the number and style of the ,case on which the
amended merely for clarification. · deputy worked. . . · . ·.
Addit]~ll~l D~ties of CourtRecorder
1
l3.2. Eff. Sept. i,1997.
The officia,l court recorder 1p.ust also: 13.6. 'Filing of Notes in a Criminal Case
(a) ensure 'that the recording system functions When a defendant is convicted and sentenced, or is
properly throughout the. proceeding and that a com- gi~nted,defe~kd 'adjud_icat1bn 'rJr felony other than :a
plete, clear;-and transcribable recording is made; a;state 'jail felppy, and· do'es :'not appeal, the court
''(b) ·make a detailed; legible 'log of all proce'~ding;; rep.orter inus~WitP,in ·20 clay(> after the time to per-
being recorded; showing: · · · fect the appeal has 'expti-~d~fil~! the uih.ranscribec1
notes or the original recording of the proceeding with
(1) the numbdr and style oflhe case before the the trial court clerk. The tr!al court 'Clerk need not
court;'· · •·· retain the' notes beyohd 15'years' of their filing date.
(2) llie name cif each person speaking; . Eff. Sept. l~ 1997.: ·i ; · · ·~, .
(3)0the event be1rig recorded such as the voir
Rule 14; ' Recording arid
dire, the opening ·statement, direct and cross-exami-
nations, and ~b.ench c.onferencei:J; B~~·adc'kstip.g. ·court
(4) each exhibjt offered, admitted, or excluded; Proceedings
· (5) tl:le time ()fday of each event; and Notes and Comments :
(6)'' the .ina'ex riumbe~ on the recording device ,Comment to ;1997 .change: lfhis is former: Rule
showing whereieach event is recorded; 2~.· The ru~~ ~re~tten _;mcj now; allows recor~
iiig arid broadcasting' 6f court proceedfugs at the
(c) iiftet: ~ proce~ding ends, file\vith the elerk the discretion· of the court and subject tO the stated
origin_all?gi / ,, . . .: . : ·_ . . guidelines; ; ,,
(d) have the original recording stored to' ensure 14.1. Recordipg and Broadcasting Permitted
that itis; presery~d
.·
~nd is accessible; arid ' . '·
- ··:. · ' " ' . . \•·.
.An .appellate ·court rriay •permit. courtroom proce'ed-
(e) enstir~ that r:o one gains access to the original ings to be broadc,ast, televised, recorded, or.· photo-
recording witlioutthe court's Written order. . graphed in accordance with this rule.
Eff. Sept. b,199f" ' .,; . . , .. . ' . : Ef(,
.... ,.
_Sept.l,l997,
. . ..
13.3._ :.Pr.iorities'of Reporters.· _ 14.2. Procedure
Th!( ,@kl. ~burt. n\ust help ensu,re that the. <;ourt (a) Request to Cover Co'/krt Proceeding. ·
reporter~.s \V'ork ~s. timely accompli~}leJ Ly :s8LLing (1) A. person ·>vishing to .. broudcact, televise, rec-
work priorities. The reporter's duties ;elating to ord, or photograph a court proceeding must file
... -- -------·------- ------------·-- -·-----------------
~ui~'-'34. A,:}:ipeli~te. :Re~ord . (10) any request. f9r preparation of the
reoo~; ' ··
34.1. Contents (11) in civil cases, a certified bill of costs ·
The appellate record consists of the clerk~s recqrd ing the cost of preparing the clerk~s record,
and, if necessary to the appeal, the reporter's record. ·credits for payments made; ,
Even if more than one notice of appeal is filed, there · (12) in criminal cases-tl;le trial court's ce.J;tltJca·tioi-
should be only one appellate record in a case. of the defendant's right of appeal under l~ul.e
Eff. Sept. 1, i997. . .
and · .··· ..
34.2. Agreed Record (13) subject to (b), any filing that a party
By written stipulation filed with the trial court nates to have included in the fecorcf ·
clerk, the .parties may. agree on .the contents of the (b) Request for Additi~nal Items.
appellate record. An agreed record will be presumed , (1) Ti~e for Request. · At any time before
to contain all evidence and filings relevant to the clerk's' record. is prepared,. any party may. file.
appeal. To request m~tter to be included in the ..·the trial court clerk a written designation ·_snE~ci1Fvit1<i'
agreed record; tpe parties must comply with the pro- items to be included in the record. ·
cedures in Rules 34.5 and 34.6. · · (2) Request Must Be Specific. · A party request-
Eff. Sept. 1, 1997.
ing that an item be included in the .clerk's record
34.3. Agreed Statement of the Case must specifically describe the item so that the clerk
In lieu ofa reporter's J.;ecord, the parties m~y agree ca:n readily identify it. The clerk will disregard a
on a brief statement of the case. The statement must general designation; such as one for "all papers filed
be· filed with the trial court clerk and included in the in the case." · ·
appellate record. (3) Requesting Unnecessary ·Items. Irt a civil
Eff. Sept. 1, 1997. case, if a party requests that more 'items than
34.4. Form necessary be included in 'the clerk's record or any
supplement, the appellate court may_:_regardless of
The Supreme Cour~ and Court of Criminal Appe<'lh;
the appeal'~ uutcome_:_require that party to pay the
will prescribe the form of the appellate record.
Eff. Sept. 1; 1997.
costs for the preparation of the umiecessary por-
tion:
34.5; Clerk's Record (4) Failure to Timely Request. 'An appellate
(a) Contents. Unless the parties designate the fil- court must not refuse to file the clerk's record or a
ings in the appel~ate record by agreement under Rule supplemental clerk's record because of a failure to
34.2, the record must include copies of the following: timely request items to be included in the clerk's
(1) in civil cases, all pleadings on which the trial ·record.
was held; · (c) Supplementation.
(2) incnmirial~ases, the indictment or informa- (1) If a relevant item has been omitted from the
tion, any spe(!ial pl~a or defense motion that was clerk's record, the trial court, the appellate dourt, or
presented: to the court ._and overruled, any written '·any party may by letter direct the trial court Cl.erk
waiver, any written stipulation, and, in cases in to prep a~, certify, and file in the appellat~ corirt a
which a plea of guilty or nolo contendere has been supplement containing the omitted item.
entered, any documents executedfor the plea; (2) If the appell~te co1.1rt in a criminal case orders
(3) the court's docket ~heet; . . the trial. court'to p~~par~ and file findings offact
(4) the court's charge and the jury's verdict, or and conclusions of law as required by_law, or ceitifi-
the court's findings of fact and conclusions of law; ' cation of the. defendarit;s right of appeal as required
(5) the court's judgment or other order ,that is by these 'rules, the ..trial court cierk rriust prepare,
being appealed;. ., a
cer~ify, and fi!ldn the appellate court supplemen-
(6) any request for findings of fact and conclu- tal clerk's record containing those findings and con-
sions cif law, · ~ny post-juqg!nent motion, and the clusions. · ·
court's order on the motion;···. · (3) ·Any supplemental· clerk's record will' be 'part
(7) the notice of appeal; of the ~ppellate record: ·
(8) any formal bili of exception; (d) Defects or Inaccuracies. If the clerk's record is
(9;) any request for a reporter's record, including defective or maccurate, the apvellaLe de!'!" mu[:;t in
any statement of points .or issues under Rule form the trial court clerk of the defect or inaccuracy
34.6(c); and instruct the clerk to make the correction.
.. ---- -- ------------------ - - ---- ---------- ~ ~- ---~-~---- -·-------~-----------· ---------
(e) Clerk's Record Lost or Destroyed. If a filing to the appeal designate, and certified copies of the
designated for inclusion in the clerk's record has been •logs .prepared by the court recorder under Rule
lost or destroyed, the parties may, by,written stipula- 13.2.
tion, deliver a copy of that item to the trial court clerk (b) Requestfor Prepa1·ai{o?t.
for inclusion in· the clerk's record 'or a supplement. • If
(1) R~quest to 'C~urt Reporter. At or J;>efore the
the· parties cannot'agree, the trial 'court must~n any
time for perfecting the appeal, the appelia~t mu~t
party's motion or at the appellate court's request-
determine what constitutes an accurate cop;y of· the request in writing that the official reporter prepare
missing citefu and order it tci be included' in the clerk's the reporter's' 'record. The request must designate
the exhibits to be included. A request to the- court
record or a supplement.
reporter-but not,_ the court recorder~must ·also
·'(f) Original Documents. If the trial court deter- designate the portions of the proceedings to be
iliiries that original docum:~rits fii~d with the t;ial included.
cbrti~t cl¢'rk should be inspected by the _appellatec'ohrt (2) Filing. The appellant must file a copy of the
or sent't_q that CO\lrt in lieu of COpies, the trla] court . request\vitn the trial court clerk. ; .. ·.
' mu~t. make. a!l order for the safekeeping, tl~ansporta
.:(3) Failure '£6 )illieiy Request.. .An app~ilate
tion, and return of those original documents .. -The
court must not refuse to file a reporter's record or a
order . must list the original document;:; and ,briefly
supplemental r~porter's record because of a failure
descl:ibe thepl. Ail. the documentS must be. arra~ged to tim~ly reques(if . . '
i'n their listed sequence and bouild fiTrr!ly tog~ther.
On any_ party's motion or
its own initiative, the, appel- ,,(c);fa:;;tial Reporter's Record.
late court rnay direct the trial court cJerk to ~elld it - - (1)' Effect on· Appellate Points or Issues~ · If the
any original document. . . . . ' appellant requests a partial'reporter's record, the
(g) Additional Copies of Clerk:s Record in Crimi- appellant must include in the request a statement of
nal. C:ases. In a criminal case, the Clerk's record must ; the points ·or issues ·to be presented on appeal and
be .made in duplicate, and in a case in which the death Win then be limiU:!d to those points or issues.
penalty was assessed, in trip!i6ate. The· trial court .- · ·' (2) Other PaAies May Designate Additions. Any
clerk must retain the copy or copies for. the parties to othe~ party may'. designate . additional exhibits .and
use. with the court's permission. ._, portions of the testiino_ny to be included in the
reporter's record. _ ··
(h) Clerk May Consult With Parties. The clerk
may consult with the parties concerning· the contents · (3) Costs; Requesting Unnecessary Matter~ Adc
. ditions requested by another party must be included
6f the clerk's record.
Eff. Sept. 1,.1997. Amended by Supreme Court Dec. 23, 2002,. eff.
in the reporter's record at the appellant's cost But
J a?: 1, 209~· if-, the trial court finds that all or part of the ·
Notes and Comments -·· designated additions are unnecessary to the appeal,
th~;trial court may order the other party to pay the
· Comment to 2002 change: Rule 34.5(a). is costs for the preparation of the· unnecessary add,i-
amended to require that the record in a criminal
case include the certification of defendant's right of tions~ ··· This paragraph- does not affect the appellate
appeal; see Rule 25.2(d). Rule 34.5(c) is amended court's power to tax costs differently.
to .make clear that an appellate court may order · '·• (4) Presumptions. _The appellate court must pre-
- the;. trial court to make._ such , a certification for
inclusion in a supplemental _clerk's record.
sume that the partiaJ reporter's record· designated
34.6.... lteporter's Record
the
bY parties constitutes ·the entire record for
· pdrposes \:if revieWing the stated points or issues.
(a) • Contents. This presumption applies even if the statement· in-
(1)_ ·Stenographic Recording. ·u the proceedings cludes· a point• or' issue complaining of the legal or
were. stenographically recorded, the reporter's rec- factual ·insufficiency of the evidence to ·support a
ord consists of the court reporter's transcription of · specifi~ factual finding identified in that point';or
so much of the proceedings, ~nd any of the exhibits, 'issue.
that the parties to the appeal designate. (5) Criminal Cases. In a: criminal case,' if the
(2) Electronic Recording. · If the ··proceedings · '~tateriient contains a point complaining that the
were- electronically recorded;- the reporter's record evidence is insufficient to support a finding of guilt,
consists of certitied copies of all ·tapes or other the reeunlmut;L iHdude all the evidence admitted at
audio-stor~ge devices on which the proceedings the trial on the issue of guilt or innocence and
were recorded, any of the exhibit,s that the parties punishment.
. --- ------·· ---
'~
RuJ~ 34.6 . ;} ..
: .- :~
(d) Supplementation. - If anything r~levant is bruit- court clerk must ·give all original exhibits to the
ted from the. reporter's record, the trial court, the reporter fm· use in• preparing the reporter's record;
appellate court, or any party may by letter direct the Unless ordered to;,include original exhibits in the
official court reporter to prepare, certify, :and file in reporter's record, the court repprter must return
the appellate court a supplemental repo:tter's record the original exhibits to the clerk after copying them
, containin~ the omitted iterns. Any supplemental re- for inclusion in. the Teporter's record, If someone
porter's recoFd is part ofthe appellate, record. other than the tryalcourt clerk possesses an original
(e) Inaccuracies in the Repmter:s Record. exhibit, either the trial court or the appellate court
may order that person to deliver the _exhibit to the
(1) Correction of Inaccuracies , by Agree~ent.
trial court clerk.
The .partiep may agree .to .correct a!!, ipaccuracy in '
the reporter's record, including an. exhibit, without (2) Use of Original Exhibits by Appell~te, Court.
the court reporter's recertification. . . If the trial court' det~rmines that original exhibits
. (2), yorrection of Inaccllracies by 'rpal Court. If
or
sh,oulq be inspeet~<i by the appella);e court sent 'to
that court in liel1· or' copies, the ·trial coUiit iriu~t
the parties cannot agree on whether or lJ.ow to
ina,ke ~n order fot the safekeeping·, transjlOrtatiori
correct the reporter's record so that the text accu-
. rately discloses what occu~ed in the u~al; court and
and return of'those exhibits. The order mustlist
the exhibits and briefly describe them. To the
the exhibits· are accurate,' the trial court must_:_
after notice and hearing.:_settle the dis:tn:lfe; 'tf'the
extent_pi•acticable,, all the exhibits mi.is_t be
aminged
in. their l}sted order· and hound firmly togethe~
court finds any inaccuracy, it must. order the·'court
before being sent to the appellate·· clerk. ' ()r( any
reporter to conform the reporter{s record (inCluding
party's · moti_on or its own initiative, _the appell~te
. text and-any. exhibits) to what occurred in-the-trial
court may direct the trial court clerk to seiid, it arty
court, and to_ file •certified co~ections, ~~ tlJ.e appel- original exhibit. . · · ' ·•
late court. . · . . . _
(h) Additional Copies of Reporter's Record. in
(3) Correction After Filing in Appellate -Court.
If the dispute arises after the reporter~s record has Criminal Cases. In a criminal case in which a party
been _file~ i~ t~e. appellate cou_rt, that court, may requests a reporter's record, the court reporter. must
submit the dispute to the trial_ court for resolution. prepare a: duplicate oflthe reporter's record' arid 'file it
The trial court must then proceed ~s under ~ubpar- with the trial court clerk. In. a case where the death
agraph (e)(2). · · ' penalty was assessed, the· court reporter must prepare
two duplicates of the reporter's record.
(f) Reporter's Record.Lost or Destroyed. An appel-
lant is entitled to a new trial under the following · (i) Supreme Court and Court qf Criminal Appeals
circumstances: - · · ·· ··· May Set Fee. From time to time,.the,Supreme_Court
(1) if the appellant ,has timelyrequ~~ted a .report~
and the Court of ·criminal Appeals may set the fee
· er's record; that the court reporters may charge for preparili.g the
reporter's record. .
(2) if, without the appellant's fault, a significant Eff. Sept. 1, 1997. .Amended by Supreme Court De~. 23, 2002, eff.
exhibit or a· signifj.cant portion of the ·court report- Jan. 1, 2003. ·
er's notes and records.has been lost .or destroyed Note~.and C_ornrnents ., .,.
or-if the proceedings. were electronically vecord- Comment to 2002 charige: · Subparagraphs .
. ed-a. significant,portion of the recording.has been 34.6(e) and (f) are amended to clarify the applica- ·
lost or destroyed or is inaudibie; . . : ·' ' . tion to exhibits, ·''The language is subparagraphs -
(3) if the_ lost, destroyed, or inaudil:>le pqrtion of (e)(2) referring to the text of the record ·is simpli~
fied without substantive. chaj1ge., · Sp.bp:J.ragraph
the reporter's record, or. the lost or ·destroy'ild _ex- (e)(3) incorporates· the procedu1'es 'speCifi(td in
hibit, is nec~ssary .to the< appeal's,.resolution; and (e)(2). The language in subparagraph (f)• is 'dari-1 •
. (4) if the lost, destroyed or. inaudible port;ion of fied to, require agre~ment only as to the P\lrtiqn• of
the reporter~s rec()rd c11nnot be repla<;ed. by;;agr:ee- the te).iat issue, and to provide that the tnal court.
may determine that'a copy of an exhibit should!:\~ .
ment of. the parties,:ov tl;le-lost or destroye<f-e:J4llbit used' even if the'parties cannot agree. ";'
cannot be replaced eithe1; by agreement of;the
parties o~ with a copy qetermined by the trial court ·
to accurately duplicflte with reasonable certainty the
original exhibit. ' . .· - . ·,·
(g) Original Exhibits . .
(1) H.eporter May Use in Preparing Reporter's
Record. At the court reporter's request, the trial
STATE VS. ALLEN CALTON
.~·
64 66
15:J1:49 1 Fort \~orth School District. 11:11:01 1 MR. CALTON: Okay. Well, how about the
l5:l7:5l 2 THE COURT: Okay. You can stay. 15:15:03 2 motion for pro se defendant motion to be tried without
15:11:54
1
J UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Thank you. 15:15:09 1
J leg restraints, July 16th, for the record to be clear
'·54 4 (E:: parte hearing held.) 15:15:11 4 e::actly how you are going to rule on that.
.)9 5 MR. CALTON: Motion for deposition of !5:15:14 5 THE COURT: The way I am going to rule
15:2!:40 6 alibi witness. l.5:15:tl 6 on it is that you will have leg restraints on, but the
l5:11:4l 7 THE COURT: Somebody have the 15:15:51 7 jury won't be able to see your leg restraints. Both
15:21:13 8 prosecutors step back in. 1.5:15:51 8 tables, both of them are going to have a curtain
15:11:51 9 \</hen did you file that? 15:21:54 9 around. And then any time either side, either the
[5:21:55 10 ~ffi. CALTON: July 14th. 15:15:58 10 State or the Defendant, needs to bring an item of
15:11:55 ll (State returns to courtroom.) 15:16:01 ll evidence or document or something to the witness
[5:11:13 12 THE COURT: Motion for deposition of 11:1~:0) 12 stand, they are going to hand it to a clerk or bailiff
15:11:14 13 alibi witness, July 14th. Do y'all have that one? 15:16:0613 and it's going to be transported up. So the jury will
!5:21:30 14 MR. HAGERMAN: I might have that one, 11:16:09 14 never have any idea that you have leg restraints on
15:11:)0 15 Judge. Let ·me look. 11:16:1l 15 and that will protect your due process rights.
11:21:33 16 MR. HAGERMAN: May we know if the 15:16:14 16 MR. CALTON: In other words the State
15:21:34 17 previous motion to appoint an e::pert Barry Norman was 15:16:1G 17 won't come around the table?
15:11:31 13 granted or not? 15:16:19 13 THE COURT: They are going to be at
15:1"1:3ij 19 THE COURT: Denied. 15:16:19 19 their table and you are going to be at your table.
l5:1J:OO 20 MR. HAGERMAN: Judge, I apologize to the [5:16:11 20 HR. CALTON: Thank you.
15:13:01 21 Court. We thought we had that motion handy and we do 15:16:11 21 THE COURT: Both sides will be treated
!5:13:06 22 not. May I see the Court's copy of it? L\:16:11 22 equally.
15:13:51 23 Judge, the State, we object to 15:16:11 23 MR. CALTON: Thank you.
15:1J:Sb 24 Defendant's motion for deposition of alibi Hitness. 15:16:3) 24 You want the ne:ct motion, sir?
J5:1J:5~ 25 The motion fails to state an essential need as to why !1:16:34 25 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
Connie Gilfeather, CSR Connie Gilfeather, CSR
~~==================~~~======================~
65 67
15:14:00 1 he has to depose this witness. 11:16:35 1 MR. CALTON: July 17 motion for findings
15:14:01 2 Additionally, I believe there has 15:2&:36 2 of fact and conclusions of law.
L\:14:0) 1
J already been testimony in this trial or somebody has 1.5:11:10 1J THE COURT: When I make rulings, I will
!5:14:06 4 mentioned that Dan Raven is out of town. The motion 15:17:1! 4 state my ruling on the record. And if there is any
15:14:09 5 for deposition of this witness is an inappropriate 15:11:1.1 5 additional matters that need to be stated for the
15:14:10 6 remedy to solve that problem. 1.1:17:11 6 record I will do so. And if the law requires the
!5:14:16 7 THE COURT: Do you want to be heard on 15:11:)0 7 findings of fact and conclusions of law to be in
15:14:1N 8 the motion? 15:11:)] 8 writing I will do so.
15:14:1j ~ I think Mr. Raven is going to be back in 15:11:34 9 MR. CALTON: Thank you.
15:14:)1 10 to>m by the time we go to trial in the case. 15:1i:ll 10 THE COURT: Most of these motions the
!5:14:34 11 MR. CALTON: Do you have an indication 15:11:31 11 law does not require written findings of facts and
15:11:15 12 of when that is going to be, Your Honor? J5:11:J9 12 conclusions of law. So I will mot be doing such.
ll:H:40 13 THE COURT: He is going to be back in 11:11:0 13 MR. CALTON: Thank you.
15:14:H 14 town about the first of August. 15:11:ll 14 But the ones that the law requires you
1l:1l:H 15 MR. CALTON: So you're indicating that 15:11:48 15 will --
!5:14:41 16 we are not probably going to go to trial by the first 15:11:49 16 THE COURT: I will.
11:14:48 17 of A.ugust? 11:11:11 17 MR. CALTON: -- address them that way?
15:21:!8 18 THE COURT: Probably not. 11:11:53 18 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
15:11:19 19 MR. CALTON: We are not going to trial 15:1l:5l 19 MR. CALTON: And, Your Honor, on the
tl:1~:sr 20 ne::t week? 11:11:16 20 motion for evidentiary hearing, in Frank's motion.
Ll:24:lt 21 THE COURT: I doubt it. We are still in 1.5:21:59 21 THE COURT: Uh-huh.
11:14:1! 22 pretrials. Unless you \vant to go to trial rlithout 15:17:5'1 22 11R. CA.LTON: That motion is going along
23 hearing the pretrials. ll:1a:o1 23 ~lith the suppression motion, and obviously the speedy
ll:1us 24 l1R. CP..LTON: No, sir. n:1s:o1 24 trial motion Hi th the testimony that 1ve' re hearing in
15:25:oo 25 THE COURT: Okay. '\ \\ 1( l.l:ls:o7 25 court, correct?
Connie Gilfeather, CSR e:~""' 'tn\ D Off· q\ ~.(p Connie Gilfeather, CSR
Ground Eleven: Records lost or destroyed that were necessary for appeal.
#.
97. Applicant presents no credible evidence that a court reporter w,as present and
recorded proceedings on January 8, 2004, January 16, 2004, February 12, 2004,
Col--~,..,~"
~ \..IUJ. UUJ.. J 'Jh
."-\..J'
")(\(\If
.L..tVV~,
.,,,-1
U.J.J.IIo..&. ~
r>,.;l 'Jh
A.L.t-'..I...J..l ~\J\J
4-1\.J,
'J(\(\1.'1 ; , th;c;,
1
.1...1.1 ._ ..... ..._._.
r~<OP
....,.L-4.._,_.,
98. Applicant presents no credible evidence that records for this case were lost or
destroyed.
99. Applicant presents no credible evidence that the records he alleges were lost or
destroyed were ever recorded by a court reporter in this case.
100. Hon. Alford contacted the court reporter, Mr. Steve Schiller, regarding the alleged
missing records. See Alford Affidavit, p. 1.
101. Mr. Steve Schiller advised Hon. Alford that the hearings Applicant was concerned
about were on different cases and not this one. See Alford Affidavit, p. 1.
102. Applicant had four other cases pending in this c
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.