Opinion

Seaboard Air Line Railway Co. v. Brunswick County

  • 198 N.C. 549
  • 152 S.E. 627
  • 1930 N.C. LEXIS 407
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Filed
Apr 2, 1930
Status
Published
Author
CoNNOR
On the bench
CoNNOR
Cited by
7 cases
Authority
More cited than 86.7%

The opinion

CoNNOR, J.

It does not appear on the record filed in this Court by the defendant that defendant excepted to the judgment or appealed therefrom to this Court. The judgment is set out in the case on appeal which was served on counsel for plaintiff. There are no entries, however, showing any exception by defendant, or any notice of appeal to the plaintiff, either in open court or within the time prescribed by statute. C. S., 641; C. S., 642. The appeal docketed in this Court by the defendant must therefore be dismissed.

Corp. Com. v. R. R.,

185 N. C., 435 , 117 S. E., 563 ;

Howell v. Jones,

109 N. C., 102 , 13 S. E., 889 . The record filed in this Court must show at least that an appeal was taken from the judgment. Otherwise this Court acquires no jurisdiction of the action. Const. of N. C., Art. IY, sec. 8.

The assignments of error shown in the transcript filed in this Court are not based upon exceptions appearing in the case on appeal. They

*551

will therefore not be considered. They do not supply the want of exceptions.

Boyer v. Jarrell,

180 N. C., 479 , 105 S. E., 9 .

The question discussed on the hearing in this Court, to wit: Whether in the absence of a demand on the treasurer of the county, within thirty days after the payment to the sheriff, under protest in writing, for the refund of money paid to him for a tax illegally levied by the county, the taxpayer is entitled to recover in an action instituted under C. S., 7979, is not decided for the reason that this Court is without jurisdiction of the action. In this ease, the demand for refund was made, within the required time, of the sheriff, to whom the money was paid, under protest, in writing, and also of the board of county commissioners; no demand, however, was made of the treasurer of the county, as required by the statute. Ordinarily, where an action is authorized by statute, and can be maintained only because of statutory authority, the provisions of the statute must be strictly complied with. A substantial compliance is not sufficient. The appeal is

Dismissed.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.