Opinion

Brown v. . Rainor

  • 108 N.C. 204
  • 12 S.E. 1028
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Filed
Feb 5, 1891
Status
Published
Author
MereimoN
On the bench
MereimoN
Cited by
2 cases
Authority
More cited than 72.8%

The opinion

MereimoN, C. J.:

This is a summary proceeding, whereby the petitioner seeks, by writ of

habeas corpus,

to obtain possession of certain of his infant children in the possession of and detained by (as is alleged) the respondent, who was their grandfather. The Judge at chambers gave judgment in favor of the respondent, and thereupon the petitioner appealed to this Court, as he might do.

The Code,

§1662;

*205

Musgrove

v.

Kornegay,

7 Jones, 71 . Pending the appeal the respondent died, and this appears by suggestion and upon affidavits filed.

The petitioner asks that the administrator or executor of the respondent be made a party, and insists that, at all events, he is not chargeable with costs.

The proceeding is summary in its character, and in the nature of the matter has served its special purpose as far as practicable. The respondent having died is beyond the jurisdiction of the Court for any purpose. Nor can it be sustained against his executor or administrator. There is no statute that so provides. They, as such, are not chargeable in contemplation of law with the possession or detention of the children, the possession of which the petitioner seeks to obtain. Plis remedy is by another like proceeding directed against the person who may have possession of them now or hereafter. Ordinarily, the costs of a writ of

habeas corpus

proceeding may be awarded at the discretion of the-Court or Judge.

The Code,

§ 1860. But here the proceeding abates, and the Court gives no judgment for costs. Each party is liable for his own costs, according to law in such cases.

Officers

v.

Taylor,

1 Dev., 99 .

The proceeding abates.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.