Opinion

Betts v. Raleigh.

  • 142 N.C. 229
  • 55 S.E. 145
  • 1906 N.C. LEXIS 245
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Filed
Oct 9, 1906
Status
Published
Author
owN
On the bench
owN
Cited by
12 cases
Authority
More cited than 92.5%

The opinion

Be.owN, T.

It is contendéd by the defendant that the form of the petition presented to the Board of Aldermen is not in compliance with the act in that it fails to designate the questions which the petitioners desire to be voted upon at the election. In the view we take of the case it is unnecessary for us to pass on that contention. The writ of

mandamus

should have been denied for the reason that ■ it is never granted to compel an unlawful or prohibited act.

*230

Tbe statute is express in terms and unmistakable'in meaning. Tbe election petitioned for is required to be beld in tbe same year in wbicb tbe petition is filed. It cannot be beld during tbe subsequent year. Tbe statute also prohibits tbe bolding of tbe election witbin ninety days of any city, county, or general election. These provisions of tbe statute are as binding upon tbe courts as upon any other departments of tbe State Government, and effectually bar tbe bolding of tbe election petitioned for. Tbe fact that tbe petitioners aver they were compelled to resort to legal proceedings to compel tbe defendants to order tbe election is immaterial. Had tbe

mandamus

proceedings been commenced much earlier, and before their final determination tbe obligation of defendants to perform tbe alleged duty required of them, or tbe right of tbe relator to exact its performance, expired by lapse of time, tbe relief will be denied, since courts will not grant tbe writ when, if granted, it would be fruitless, or require tbe performance of an illegal or prohibited act. High on Extraordinary Remedies, p. 20;

Mauney v.

Commissioners, 71 N. C., 486 ; Topping on Mandamus, p. 67.

Proceeding Dismissed.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.