Opinion

Belden Inc. v. Berk-Tek LLC

  • 805 F.3d 1064
  • 116 U.S.P.Q. 2d (BNA) 1869
  • 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 19307
  • 2015 WL 6756451
Court
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Filed
Nov 5, 2015
Status
Published
Author
Taranto
On the bench
Newman, Dyk, Taranto
Cited by
138 cases
Authority
More cited than 96.9%

holding that a declaration appended to a reply brief “fairly respond[ed] only to arguments made in . . . [the patent owner]’s response,” as required by § 42.23(b), and that the patent owner had “a meaningful opportunity to respond,” as required by the APA

How later courts described this case

  • holding that a declaration appended to a reply brief “fairly respond[ed] only to arguments made in . . . [the patent owner]’s response,” as required by § 42.23(b), and that the patent owner had “a meaningful opportunity to respond,” as required by the APA
  • explaining that “the Board’s rules and practices establish standards bearing similarities to those often applied in district-court litigation” and that the Board “has broad discretion to regulate the presentation of evidence”
  • explaining that “obviousness concerns whether a skilled artisan not only could have made but would have been motivated to make the combinations or modifications of prior art to arrive at the claimed invention”
  • reasoning that re- buttal evidence should be responsive such that it is offered “to explain, repel, counteract, or disprove the evidence of the adverse party”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

United States Court of Appeals

for the Federal Circuit

______________________

BELDEN INC.,

Appellant

v.

BERK-TEK LLC,

Cross-Appellant

______________________

2014-1575, -1576

______________________

Appeals from the United States Patent and Trade-

mark Office, Patent Trial and Appeal Board in No.

IPR2013-00057.

______________________

Decided: November 5, 2015

______________________

MATTHEW B. LOWRIE, Foley & Lardner LLP, Boston,

MA, argued for appellant. Also represented by MATTHEW

AMBROS, AARON W. MOORE.

JAMES S. BLANK, Kaye Scholer LLP, New York, NY,

argued for cross-appellant. Also represented by BENJAMIN

C. HSING, DAVID SOOFIAN; GREGORY C. ANTRIM, JOSEPH

SOFER, Sofer & Haroun, LLP, New York, NY.

FRANCES LYNCH, Office of the Solicitor, United States

Patent and Trademark Office, Alexandria, VA, argued for

intervenor Michelle K. Lee. Also represented by NATHAN

2 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

K. KELLEY, THOMAS W. KRAUSE, ROBERT J. MCMANUS,

SCOTT WEIDENFELLER.

______________________

Before NEWMAN, DYK, and TARANTO, Circuit Judges.

TARANTO, Circuit Judge.

Belden Inc. owns U.S. Patent No. 6,074,503, which

discloses and claims a method for making a communica-

tions cable. On a petition for inter partes review under 35

U.S.C. § 311 et seq. filed by the predecessor of Berk-Tek

LLC, the Patent and Trademark Office’s Patent Trial and

Appeal Board instituted a review and later reached a

mixed decision: it rejected claims 1–4 of the ’503 patent

for obviousness, while confirming claims 5 and 6. We now

affirm the rejection of claims 1–4 and reverse the uphold-

ing of claims 5 and 6. We also reject Belden’s contention

that the Board denied it procedural rights in the review.

BACKGROUND

Belden and Berk-Tek compete in making and selling

telecommunications cable and cabling systems. The ’503

patent, issued on June 13, 2000, discloses a method of

making a cable by passing a core and conducting wires

through one or more dies, bunching the wires into grooves

on the core, twisting the bunch to close the cable, and

jacketing the entire assembly. These figures show an

assembly described as containing three dies (403, 411,

413) and a cross-section of a resulting cable (200):

4 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

’503 patent, col. 6, lines 4–17.

Belden groups claim 4 with claim 1 for analysis.

Claim 4, dependent on claim 1, adds an “extrusion” re-

quirement: during the passing step, “extruding the core so

that the surface features thereof align with the plurality

of transmission media.” Id., col. 6, lines 28–31.

Belden groups claims 2 and 3 for analysis. Claim 2

requires, “before passing the transmission media and the

core through the first die, passing the transmission media

and the core through a third die which generally centers

the core relative to the plurality of transmission media.”

Id., col. 6, lines 18–22 (emphases added). That is, claim 2

calls for the large die (“third”) that is upstream of the

small die (“first”) shown in the left figure above—the

“second” being the tube-shaped structure shown there.

Claim 3, dependent on claim 2, claims for the third die

what claim 4 claims for the first: it requires “extruding

the core at a center position relative to the plurality of

transmission media” when the core and media pass

through the third die. Id., col. 6, lines 23–27.

Belden groups claims 5 and 6 for analysis. Claim 5,

dependent on claim 1, requires that the transmission

media be “twisted pairs of insulated conductors.” ’503

patent reexamination certificate, col. 2, lines 7–9 (empha-

sis added). Claim 6, dependent on claim 5, requires four

such pairs. Id., col. 2, lines 10–12.

On November 19, 2012, Berk-Tek’s predecessor,

Nexans, Inc., petitioned for inter partes review of all

claims of the ’503 patent under 35 U.S.C. § 311. The

petition—actually, the corrected petition filed nine days

later, making changes not material here—asserts antici-

pation and obviousness based on seven prior-art refer-

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 5

ences. 1 On April 16, 2013, the Board, as delegee of the

PTO Director, instituted a review of all claims under

§ 314(a), finding a “reasonable likelihood” that the meth-

ods of all six claims were unpatentable. Nexans, Inc. v.

Belden Technologies Inc., IPR2013-57, 2013 WL 8595538

(PTAB Apr. 16, 2013).

The Board found likely obviousness of the methods of

claims 1 and 4 based on Japanese Patent No. 19910 (JP

’910). It found likely obviousness of the methods of claims

2 and 3 based on JP ’910 together with either U.S. Patent

No. 4,393,582 (US ’582) or Japanese Patent No. 76694 (JP

’694). And it found likely obviousness of the methods of

claims 5 and 6 based on JP ’910 together with Canadian

Patent No. 2,058,046 (CA ’046). 2

The central reference, JP ’910, describes a method of

making a communication cable, illustrated below. The

method entails extruding a core (thread-like object 1)

through heated rollers (2a–2c) to form four grooves in the

core, located at corners of a square when viewed in cross-

section. The core and four conducting wires (4a–4d) are

fed through a die (wire-splitting board 5), the wires placed

1 The versions of 35 U.S.C. §§ 102 (anticipation)

and 103 (obviousness) that apply here are those preceding

the changes made by the America Invents Act, given the

effective filing dates of the claims of the ’503 patent. See

Leahy-Smith America Invents Act, Pub. L. No. 112–29,

125 Stat. 284, 293 (2011).

2 The Board also found likely anticipation of claims

1 and 2 by US ’582, but in its final written decision, it

rejected anticipation, so we do not elaborate on the initial

likely-anticipation finding.

6 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

into the grooves on the core, and the assembly bunched,

stranded, and jacketed to form a cable. 3

FIG. 1 (JP ’910)

FIG. 4 (JP ’910)

JP ’694 and US ’582 also describe methods of making

a cable or cable core, illustrated below. JP ’694 teaches

passing a group of wires and shielding tape through a

first die (plate 31), then a second die (plate 32), and

finally a set of shaping tubes that wrap the shielding tape

around the wires. JP ’694, col. 4, lines 7–28. US ’582

similarly teaches making a cable core, in which a metallic

tape and two groups of wires are fed through a first die

(plate 67) and a second die (plate 71). ’582 patent, col. 5,

lines 1–33.

3 JP ’910 describes “S-Z” stranding, which involves

alternately twisting in one direction, then the other. The

name reflects the difference in the resulting helices

viewed from outside: “S” has a diagonal from northwest to

southeast, “Z” from southwest to northeast.

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 7

FIG. 1 (JP ’694)

FIG. 1 (US ’582)

CA ’046 describes a telecommunications cable contain-

ing twisted pairs of conducting wires, separated by a

spacer to minimize cross talk. The patent illustrates

different spacers separating four twisted pairs of wires.

CA ’046, col. 3, line 36 to col. 4, line 37.

FIG. 2 (CA ’046) FIG 3. (CA ’046)

Among the Board’s preliminary determinations in its

Institution Decision are the following. (We discuss only

8 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

claims 1, 2, and 5, there being no separate arguments for

claims 4, 3, and 6.) As to claim 1, the Board determined

that “JP ’910 articulates a special need to have the wires

aligned at precise locations on the core during stranding

after passing through wire-splitting board 5” and, based

on that need, “one with ordinary skill in the art would

have known that the passage of core 1 through wire-

splitting board 5 preferably should be made such that

twisting of the core causing misalignment of the wires

would be prevented.” Nexans, 2013 WL 8595538 at *14.

As to claim 2, the Board found that “each of [US] ’582 and

JP ’694 discloses the concept of an additional die which

centers, in a general manner, the core relative to the

plurality of transmission media,” id., and that “[i]nserting

an additional die upstream of wire-splitting board 5 of the

assembly of JP ’910 involves merely a predictable use of a

prior art element disclosed in each of [US] ’582 and JP

’694, to achieve the same advantage[ou]s result.” Id. at

*15. As to claim 5, the Board determined that CA ’046

discloses that “a telecommunication cable is constructed

normally with one or more core units each of which is

conventionally a twisted pair of conductors,” id. at *17,

and that, because “JP ’910 is directed to a method of

manufacturing insulated communication cables,” a skilled

artisan “would have understood that the method of JP

’910 is applicable for use in manufacturing a telecommu-

nications cable” and “would have known to apply the

teaching in CA ’046, about a conductor unit’s being made

conventionally of a twisted pair of conductors, to each

conductor unit 4a, 4b, 4c, and 4d, in JP ’910.” Id. at *18.

The review having been instituted, Belden submitted

its Patent Owner Response on June 24, 2013, attaching a

declaration from its expert, William T. Clark, who is a

named inventor on the ’503 patent and many other ca-

bling patents. Berk-Tek submitted its Reply on August

26, 2013, attaching a declaration from its expert, Les

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 9

Baxter. Berk-Tek had attached no declaration to its

Petition.

Belden orally opposed receipt of Mr. Baxter’s declara-

tion with the Reply, arguing that it had no opportunity to

respond. On September 10, 2013, the Board noted that its

regulations permitted Belden to cross-examine Mr. Bax-

ter, see 37 C.F.R. § 42.51(b)(1)(ii), and that Belden could

move to file non-argumentative observations (up to five

pages) calling the Board’s attention to relevant aspects of

the cross-examination. The Board also “cautioned” Berk-

Tek that, if its Reply “includes material it should have

submitted together with its Petition, the Board may

decline the entirety of the Reply,” and the Board gave

Belden “two days to consider whether to file a Revised

Reply”—only to remove material, not add any. J.A. 876;

see Office Patent Trial Practice Guide, 77 Fed. Reg.

48,756, 48,767 (Aug. 14, 2012) (Reply material is limited

to responsive matter; whole Reply may be rejected if any

part is improper).

On September 12, 2013, Berk-Tek submitted a revised

Reply. On October 17, 2013, after taking Mr. Baxter’s

deposition, Belden filed a motion for observations on what

Mr. Baxter had said. The same day, Belden moved to

exclude Mr. Baxter’s declaration and accompanying

exhibits, arguing that portions of Mr. Baxter’s declaration

were not responsive to Mr. Clark’s declaration and that

Mr. Baxter’s declaration contained arguments and evi-

dence necessary for the prima facie case of obviousness.

Berk-Tek opposed the motion, and Belden replied.

On the merits, Belden focused its argument as to

claim 1 on the prevention-of-twisting element. It argued

that JP ’910 does not suggest configuring board 5 to

prevent twisting, that board 5 would not have been able

to grip the core in JP ’910, at least not without producing

friction that would have deformed the core, and that any

tension placed on the core during the cable-making pro-

10 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

cess would already have been relieved in JP ’910 by its

(alternating-direction) stranding step. As to claim 2,

Belden argued that JP ’910 did not suggest adding a third

die to its method, Berk-Tek had submitted no evidence

showing a reason to combine the third die of US ’582 or

JP ’694 with the JP ’910 method, and that a skilled arti-

san would have viewed adding a third die to JP ’910 as

only increasing stress without any apparent benefit. As

to claim 5, Belden argued that JP ’910 teaches away from

making a cable with individually insulated twisted pairs,

particularly because using insulated conductors would

render JP ’910’s jacketing step redundant and “would

destroy the circular shape of JP ’910’s ‘quad’ wire.” J.A.

586.

Berk-Tek, in its Reply, countered Belden’s arguments.

As to claim 1, Berk-Tek argued that JP ’910’s requirement

that each conducting wire fall into its corresponding

groove on the core made it imperative to prevent twisting

of the core, that there was no reason to doubt board 5’s

ability to grip the core, and that a skilled artisan would

choose an appropriate polymer, and use cooling after

extrusion, to avoid friction-caused deformation of the core.

As to claim 2, Berk-Tek reiterated the need to prevent

twisting and argued that using extra dies to align and

alleviate stress in cable manufacturing is routine. As to

claim 5, Berk-Tek argued that a skilled artisan, making

any cable by joining transmission media with a separator

and stranding the group, as in CA ’046, would have been

motivated to use a die to align the separator and media

and prevent back twisting, as taught by JP ’910.

The Board agreed with Berk-Tek as to claims 1–4 and

with Belden as to claims 5–6. Berk-Tek, LLC v. Belden

Inc., IPR2013-57, 2014 WL 1253012 (PTAB Mar. 18,

2014) (Final Written Decision). As to claim 1: The Board

concluded that, “by teaching alignment of the grooves and

the conductors at board 5, JP ’910 suggests using board 5

to prevent twisting motion of core 1. That is, a person of

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 11

ordinary skill in the art would have recognized that

preventing twisting motion of core 1 in relation to board 5

would maintain alignment between” the grooves and

conductors “in accordance with the teaching of JP ’910.”

Id. at *13. As to claim 2: The Board concluded that US

’582 and JP ’694 each teach “the benefit of a third die,”

stating that adding a third die to JP ’910 would have

“involve[d] merely a predictable use of a prior art element

. . . to perform the same function it was known to perform

and to yield no more than one of ordinary skill would

expect from such use.” Id. at *19–20. As to claim 5: The

Board determined that “JP ’910 cannot be understood

reasonably as teaching or suggesting a method of manu-

facturing all types of twisted cables having a separator,”

in particular “conventional twisted cable . . . that includes

twisted pairs of individually-insulated conductors.” Id. at

*23 (emphasis added). The Board faulted Berk-Tek for

giving no “apparent reason to combine the known ele-

ments of JP ’910 and CA ’046.” Id.

The Board also denied Belden’s motion to exclude. It

concluded that Mr. Baxter’s declaration “fairly re-

spond[ed] to Mr. Clark’s declaration” and was unneces-

sary for Berk-Tek to establish a prima facie case of

obviousness. Id. at *26.

Belden appeals the cancellation of claims 1–4 and the

denial of its motion to exclude. Berk-Tek appeals the

upholding of claims 5 and 6. Both appeals are authorized

by 35 U.S.C. § 319. We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.

§ 1295(a)(4)(A).

DISCUSSION

We begin with a review of the substantive challenges

to the Board’s determinations on the evidence and argu-

ments presented to and considered by it. We then review

Belden’s procedural challenge to the Board’s decision to

allow Berk-Tek’s Reply evidence.

12 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

A

Whether a claimed invention would have been obvious

is a question of law, based on factual determinations

regarding the scope and content of the prior art, differ-

ences between the prior art and the claims at issue, the

level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art, the motivations

to modify or combine prior art, and any objective indicia of

non-obviousness. Randall Mfg. v. Rea, 733 F.3d 1355,

1362 (Fed. Cir. 2013). We review the Board’s compliance

with the governing legal standards de novo and its under-

lying factual determinations for substantial evidence. Id.

1

In challenging the cancellation of claim 1 for obvious-

ness, Belden argues that JP ’910 does not teach making

cables, but only transmission lines (a component of a

cable), and it disputes the Board’s finding of a motivation

to use board 5 in JP ’910 to prevent the twisting of core 1.

See ’503 patent, col. 1, lines 4–8. Neither argument has

merit.

The Board found that “[t]he purpose of the invention

of JP ’910 ‘is to provide a method of manufacturing plastic

insulated communication cable.’ ” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL

1253012, at *11 (quoting JP ’910 at ¶ 3); see Nexans, 2013

WL 8595538, at *12 (“JP ’910 discloses an assembly for

manufacturing insulated communication cables.”). That

finding is supported by substantial evidence. The title of

JP ’910 is: “A method of manufacturing plastic insulated

communication cables.” JP ’910 at ¶ 1. JP ’910 claims

“[a] method of manufacturing plastic insulated cables.”

Id. at ¶ 2. The patent further explains: “The present

invention relates to a method of manufacturing plastic

insulated communication cables.” Id. at ¶ 3. Belden

argues that, despite those descriptions, JP ’910 teaches

only the making of quads, which themselves are not

cables but mere components of cables. But the claims of

the ’503 patent do not so limit the meaning of “cable” to a

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 13

category that excludes quads, and Belden does not dispute

that it never argued for a construction of “cable” before

the Board. Thus, Belden’s argument that JP ’910 does not

describe a method of making communication cables fails.

The Board also found that, by teaching the need for

alignment of the conductors and core at board 5, JP ’910

suggested using board 5 to prevent the twisting of core 1.

Although the Board twice stated that “board 5 could have

been used to prevent twisting of core 1 by one with ordi-

nary skill in the art exercising ordinary creativity,” Berk-

Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *13, *17 (emphasis added), it

did not stop there—and properly so, because obviousness

concerns whether a skilled artisan not only could have

made but would have been motivated to make the combi-

nations or modifications of prior art to arrive at the

claimed invention. See InTouch Technologies, Inc. v. VGO

Communications, Inc., 751 F.3d 1327, 1352 (Fed. Cir.

2014). The Board found that “[v]iewed as a whole, JP ’910

does teach the importance of avoiding any misplacement

of the conductors in relation to the core,” Berk-Tek, 2014

WL 1253012, at *14; “[a] person with ordinary skill in the

art would have recognized that such alignment of the

grooves on core 1 with the fixed positions of the conduc-

tors on board 5 cannot be maintained if core 1 twists in

relation to board 5,” id. at *13; and “[t]herefore, by teach-

ing alignment of the grooves and the conductors at board

5, JP ’910 suggests using board 5 to prevent twisting

motion of core 1,” id. And the Board reiterated its earlier

finding in its Institution Decision: “ ‘Given that JP ’910

articulates a special need to have the wires aligned at

precise locations on the core during stranding after pass-

ing through wire-splitting board 5, one with ordinary skill

in the art would have known that the passage of core 1

through wire-splitting board 5 preferably should be made

such that twisting of the core causing misalignment of the

wires would be prevented.’ ” Id. at *14 (emphasis added).

In support of those affirmative findings, the Board re-

14 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

peatedly cited the Petition. Id. at *13, *14, *15 (relying

on J.A. 146–47).

Those findings suffice to show that claim 1 (and claim

4) must fall, because the findings are supported by sub-

stantial evidence. In the circumstances here, involving a

simple point in a mechanical field and one very close piece

of prior art, the Board was entitled to rely on its own

reading of JP ’910—supported by the Petition’s observa-

tions about it—to find that a skilled artisan would have

understood the importance of aligning the core and con-

ductors and the connection between achieving such

alignment and preventing the core from twisting at the

aligning die. And the Board also had substantial evidence

on which to reject Belden’s contrary arguments.

Mr. Baxter responded to Belden’s suggestion that a

skilled artisan would have had no reason to modify board

5 of JP ’910 to prevent twisting, as required by claim 1 of

Belden’s patent. He stated that JP ’910 and Belden’s

patent address the same problem of aligning conductors

with grooves in a cable’s core; that JP ’910’s touted elimi-

nation of “back-stranding” of wires—imparting a prepara-

tory twist to the wires before cable manufacturing to

compensate for twisting during cabling, JP ’910 at ¶ 3—

made it evident that twisting should be prevented by

another means; and that a skilled artisan would have

seen that the die (board 5 in JP ’910) should be used to

control twisting. Mr. Baxter also plausibly explained why

the S-Z stranding in JP ’910 might increase the need to

prevent twisting at the die, contrary to Belden’s sugges-

tions that the alternating-direction stranding would by

itself so clearly prevent misalignment of the core with the

conducting wires that there was no reason to contemplate

using board 5 to prevent twisting. And in answer to

Belden’s argument about friction-caused deformation of

the core if the die hugged the core to prevent its twisting,

Mr. Baxter stated that a skilled artisan would have

chosen a polymer with the right resistance to heat and a

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 15

cooling process after extrusion. The Board thus had an

ample basis for its obviousness determination as to claims

1 and 4.

2

As to claims 2 and 3, Belden does not dispute that

both US ’582 and JP ’694 disclose a third die. See US ’582

Fig. 1; id. Fig. 3; id., col. 5, lines 20–33; JP ’694 Fig. 2; id.,

col. 4, lines 7–12. Belden disputes only the Board’s find-

ing of a reason to combine a third die with the method of

JP ’910.

The Board found that “die 71 in [US ’582] and die 31

in JP ’694 each suggests passing the transmission media

and the core through a third die that generally centers the

core relative to the plurality of transmission media,” Berk-

Tek, 2014 WL 1253012 at *18, and that each patent

“teaches the benefit of a third die,” id. at *19. It also

found that “a person of ordinary skill in the art would

have added a third die, as recited in claim 2, in order to

align further the cable components.” Id. The Board cited

the Petition’s argument to that effect. Id. at *18, *19

(citing J.A. 154).

Significantly, it was only in the context of those find-

ings about why a skilled artisan would have had reason to

add a third die that the Board quoted the Supreme

Court’s reference to a “ predictable variation” in KSR Int’l

Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398, 417 (2007). Berk-Tek,

2014 WL 1253012 at *19. The Supreme Court’s passage

does not establish that it suffices for obviousness that a

variation of the prior art would predictably work, but

requires consideration of whether, in light of factors such

as “design incentives and other market forces,” the hypo-

thetical skilled artisan would recognize the potential

benefits and pursue the variation. KSR, 550 U.S. at 417.

In the present case, the Board, in its overall analysis,

made the required full inquiry.

16 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

The Board’s findings suffice to show that claim 2 (and

claim 3) must fall, because the findings are supported by

substantial evidence. Here, as with claim 1, the prior art

is close enough and plain enough that, with even an

abbreviated argument in the Petition, the Board could

determine that a skilled artisan would see the benefit of

adding a third die to enhance alignment. And here, as

with claim 1, the Board had sufficient evidence to reject

Belden’s arguments to the contrary.

In response to Belden’s argument that a skilled arti-

san would have no reason to add a third die to JP ’910,

though one is undisputedly shown in US ’582 and JP ’694,

Mr. Baxter explained that a third die upstream from the

first die would have a “benefit” of “ ‘more accurately

aligning the input wires with the rest of the machine with

less or lessened tensions and with better angles, allowing

the supply reels to be located farther from the wire-

splitting board.’ ” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *19

(quoting J.A. 706). Mr. Baxter also responded to Belden’s

argument that a third die would increase friction and

drag, harming a fragile core. He stated that fragility was

speculative and that an upstream die would be “ ‘looser

fitting.’ ” Id. (quoting J.A. 706). Berk-Tek, citing the

Baxter declaration, argued in its Reply that a third die

was a “ ‘routine’ ” way of improving alignments and less-

ening tensions. Id. (quoting J.A. 897). The Board thus

had an ample basis for its obviousness determination as

to claims 2 and 3.

3

As to claims 5 and 6, Berk-Tek argues that a person of

ordinary skill in the art seeking to manufacture cables

disclosed in CA ’046—with four insulated twisted pairs

and a separator—would have been motivated to use the

method of JP ’910 to solve the alignment issues common

to manufacturing the cables in both prior-art sources.

Even giving the Board the deference it is due under the

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 17

substantial-evidence standard of review of factual find-

ings, we agree that the record requires the finding Berk-

Tek urges. The Board’s contrary finding rests on legal

errors.

There is no meaningful dispute here, and the Board

did not deny, that the two pieces of prior art in combina-

tion teach or suggest the methods of claims 5 and 6. The

dispute concerns motivation to combine. The Petition and

the Institution Decision reveal the two related ways in

which that issue was presented and considered: whether a

skilled artisan would substitute the twisted pairs of CA

’046 into the method of JP ’910; alternatively, whether a

skilled artisan making the cable of CA ’046 would look to

the JP ’910 method to make it. The brief discussion in the

Petition suggests both views of the matter. J.A. 148–49

(“CA ’046 . . . in view of . . . JP ’910 . . . invalidates claims

3 through 5”); J.A. 155 (“JP ’910 uses single conductors

(4a-4d), but it is known to likewise use twisted pairs with

a cross shaped separator—see for example CA ’046”). The

Board’s Institution Decision does so as well: “[O]ne with

ordinary skill in the art would have understood that the

method of JP ’910 is applicable for use in manufacturing a

telecommunications cable. Accordingly, one with ordinary

skill in the art would have known to apply the teaching in

CA ’046, about a conductor unit’s being made convention-

ally of a twisted pair of conductors, to each conductor unit

4a, 4b, 4c, and 4d, in JP ’910.” Nexans, 2013 WL 8595538,

at *18.

As the Board found, it is “undisputed that CA ’046

discloses ‘a helically twisted cable.’ ” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL

1253012, at *24. There is no dispute that the twisted

pairs in CA ’046 need to fit into the notches of (i.e., be

aligned with) the separator, as shown in the two figures

from CA ’046 reproduced above, for the resulting cable to

be made. And the Board correctly recognized in its dis-

cussion of claims 1 and 2 that JP ’910 clearly teaches the

importance of aligning conductors with a separator (core),

18 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

and suggests doing so with a die to prevent twisting of the

separator, before they are all bunched together for twist-

ing in a stranding device. That evidence points clearly

toward a motivation of a skilled artisan to arrive at the

methods of claims 5 and 6 based on JP ’910 and CA ’046,

as the Board reasoned in its preliminary determination in

the Institution Decision.

None of the Board’s reasons for concluding otherwise

in its Final Written Decision withstands scrutiny through

the lens of governing law. The Board’s first reason was

that JP ’910 shows only conductors that are not individu-

ally insulated, so that “one of ordinary skill, tasked to

produce the conventional twisted cable of CA ’046, would

not have been motivated by the teachings of JP ’910

simply to substitute twisted pairs of insulated conductors

for the bare metal conductors in the method of JP ’910.”

Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *23 (emphasis in origi-

nal). But JP ’910 plainly discloses the need to align the

conducting wires with the core and how to do so, as the

Board recognized in its analysis of claims 1 and 4, id. at

*13–14. The alignment problem and solution do not

depend on whether the wires are insulated. The Board’s

disregard of the insulation-independent alignment teach-

ing of JP ’910 violates the principle that “[a] reference

must be considered for everything it teaches by way of

technology and is not limited to the particular invention it

is describing and attempting to protect.” EWP Corp. v.

Reliance Universal Inc., 755 F.2d 898, 907 (Fed. Cir. 1985)

(emphases in original); see In re Applied Materials, Inc.,

692 F.3d 1289, 1298 (Fed. Cir. 2012).

The Board next reasoned that “Berk-Tek ha[d] not

explained why a person of ordinary skill in the art would

have had sufficient reason to use the S-Z stranding step of

JP ’910 to manufacture the helically-twisted cable of CA

’046,” stating that “the S-Z stranding step of JP ’910 is

inconsistent with production of a helically-twisted cable.”

Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *24. That reasoning

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 19

makes the same mistake we have just noted regarding the

Board’s reliance on the lack of insulation of the individual

conductors in JP ’910: it disregards the evident independ-

ent force of JP ’910’s teaching of the alignment problem

and solution. The Board did not find, and could not

reasonably find, that the significance to claims 5 and 6 of

JP ’910’s alignment teaching is dependent on the particu-

lar method of stranding described in JP ’910, any more

than it is dependent on insulation of individual wires.

The claims of Belden’s patent call simply for “twisting”

the assembly, without restrictions on the particular kind

of twisting. And Belden’s expert, Mr. Clark, did not rely

on the S-Z stranding method of JP ’910 in urging the

validity of claims 5 and 6.

The Board, returning to its focus on insulation of in-

dividual conductors, further reasoned: “Berk-Tek also has

not explained why a person of ordinary skill in the art

would have had sufficient reason to use the final jacket-

ing/extrusion step of JP ’910, which serves to insulate

electrically the bare-metal conductors of JP ’910, to manu-

facture a cable comprising twisted pairs of individually-

insulated conductors that do not require additional elec-

trical insulation.” Id. The Board found no answer to

Belden’s statement that the final jacketing step, if the

conductors themselves were insulated, would be “ ‘redun-

dant.’ ” Id. But that logic misconstrues the claim lan-

guage and overlooks on-point evidence.

The claim language concerning the final jacketing

step does not require that the jacket be insulating at all.

And it is clear from the Belden patent and at least

CA ’046 that the jacketing step serves a function not

dependent on adding insulation. The evident function is

to hold the assembly together to form a cable, and hold its

components in place, whether or not the component

conductors are insulated. Thus, Belden’s patent itself

declares that “[c]onventional designs of data grade tele-

communications cables for installation in plenum cham-

20 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

bers have a low smoke generating jacket material . . .

surrounding a core of twisted conductor pairs, each con-

ductor individually insulated with a[n] . . . insulation

layer.” ’503 patent, col. 2, lines 24–30 (emphases added);

see id., col. 4, lines 22–25; id., col. 2, lines 59–64 (“[T]he

cable includes . . . an outer jacket maintaining the plurali-

ty of data transmission media in position with respect to

the core.”). CA ’046 also teaches this purpose of jacketing

insulated twisted pairs. CA ’046, col. 3, line 16 to col. 4,

line 4 (“[I]n a cable 20, the jacket 12 surrounds four pairs

14 of insulated conductors 16 which are held in controlled

distances apart, as they extend in stranded condition

along the cable, by a spacer means in the form of a central

core member 20.”) (emphasis added).

Finally, the Board made a passing reference to

“Belden’s argument that modifying the cable of JP ’910 to

include twisted pairs would ‘destroy the circular shape of

JP ’910’s “quad” wire.’ ” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at

*24. But nothing in the ’503 patent describes or claims

the circularity of the cable produced by its method. And

neither JP ’910 nor CA ’046 ascribes any significance to

the shape of the cables they disclose. The Board identi-

fied, and we see, no reason that the teaching of JP ’910

about the alignment problem and solution is inapplicable

to making the cables of CA ’046 even if the resulting

cable’s cross-section is not circular.

In short, the record is one-sided on the proper ques-

tion of whether JP ’910 taught a solution to the problem of

aligning cable components that a skilled artisan would

have been motivated to use in making CA ’046’s cables.

The Board erred in determining that Berk-Tek had not

proven the obviousness of the methods of claims 5 and 6

of the ’503 patent by a preponderance of the evidence.

B

Belden challenges the Board’s denial of the motion to

exclude the Baxter declaration that Berk-Tek submitted

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 21

with its Reply. It argues that the Board violated a regula-

tion governing evidence submitted with a Reply and two

aspects of the Patent Office Trial Practice Guide, thereby

relying on evidence to which Belden lacked a fair oppor-

tunity to respond. We review the Board’s evidentiary

ruling for abuse of discretion, which may be found if the

Board violated governing law. Chen v. Bouchard, 347

F.3d 1299, 1307 (Fed. Cir. 2003). We reject Belden’s

contentions.

1

Belden asserts that Berk-Tek’s filing of the Baxter

declaration violated 37 C.F.R. § 42.23(b), which states

that “[a] reply may only respond to arguments raised in

the corresponding opposition or patent owner response.”

The Board found no violation, concluding that Mr. Bax-

ter’s declaration “fairly responds to Mr. Clark’s declara-

tion” and is “generally . . . in fair reply to Mr. Clark’s

declaration and/or Belden’s response to the revised peti-

tion.” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *26. We see no

error in that ruling.

Each of the points that Mr. Baxter made in his decla-

ration responds to a statement made in Mr. Clark’s decla-

ration. Mr. Baxter’s discussion of claims 1 and 4 of

Belden’s patent is representative. After quoting Mr.

Clark’s argument that JP ’910 does not teach a method of

making communication cables, the Baxter declaration

responds with reference to JP ’910 and a supporting

exhibit. J.A. 692. After summarizing Mr. Clark’s argu-

ment about JP ’910’s teaching of a need to control twisting

of the core and the elimination of back twisting, the

Baxter declaration explains what JP ’910 means by “back

stranding” and distinguishes back stranding from the

problem of “back-twisting” addressed by Belden’s patent

and JP ’910. J.A. 692–97. The Baxter declaration then

similarly summarizes and responds to Mr. Clark’s state-

ments regarding S-Z stranding in JP ’910, the utility of

22 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

board 5 in preventing twisting of the core, the deformabil-

ity of the core in JP ’910, and the ability of board 5 to grip

the core. J.A. 697–705. The Baxter declaration’s discus-

sion of claims 2, 3, 5, and 6 follows a similar approach.

J.A. 706–09. The Board did not abuse its discretion in

concluding that, as relevant here, Mr. Baxter’s declara-

tion fairly responds only to arguments made in Mr.

Clark’s declaration and Belden’s response.

2

Belden relies on a passage from the Patent Office

Trial Practice Guide that elaborates on the regulation

that limits replies to responsive arguments, excluding

new issues. The passage states that “[e]xamples of indi-

cations that a new issue has been raised in a reply include

new evidence necessary to make out a prima facie case for

the . . . unpatentability of an original . . . claim.” 77 Fed.

Reg. at 48,767. Belden argues that the Baxter declara-

tion, submitted with Berk-Tek’s Reply, was necessary to

make out the prima facie case of obviousness and for that

reason should have been excluded.

Although the Board has recognized that the Guide

merely “provides guidance,” Innolux Corp. v. Semiconduc-

tor Energy Lab. Co., IPR2013-60, 2013 WL 8595541, at *3

(PTAB May 3, 2013), the Board did not reject Belden’s

contention on the ground that the Guide is not a binding

regulation. Rather, the Board rejected Belden’s premise

“that Mr. Baxter’s testimony was necessary for Berk-Tek

to establish a prima facie case.” Berk-Tek, 2014 WL

1253012, at *26. We see no error in that ruling. 4

4 The same Guide passage includes, among its

“[e]xamples of indications that a new issue has been

raised in a reply,” “new evidence that could have been

presented in a prior filing.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 48,767. That

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 23

Our earlier discussion of the merits of the obviousness

issues shows how the prior art itself, together with the

Petition, sufficed to supply a prima facie case of obvious-

ness—as confirmed by the Institution Decision. For

example, as to claim 1, the Board found that JP ’910 itself

articulates a special need to have the wires aligned with

the grooves on the core after passing through board 5, and

that one with ordinary skill in the art would have known

that board 5 could and preferably should be made to

prevent twisting of the core that would cause misalign-

ment. Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *14–15; Nexans,

2013 WL 8595538, at *14. As to claim 2, the Board found

that both US ’582 and JP ’694 disclose the advantage of

using an additional die to center the core relative to the

transmission media, and that a person of skill in the art

would recognize that the same benefit predictably would

be achieved by using a third die in the method of JP ’910.

Berk-Tek, 2014 WL 1253012, at *18–19; Nexans, 2013 WL

8595538, at *15. Such findings are well supported in the

prior-art documents themselves, as are those which we

have concluded show obviousness of the methods of claims

5 and 6.

To be sure, the Board cited Mr. Baxter’s declaration in

its Final Written Decision—mostly in explaining why it

was rejecting Belden’s arguments, but partly in stating

the affirmative reasons to find the motivation required for

a prima facie case. But such citations do not mean that

the Baxter declaration was “necessary” for the prima facie

case. Evidence admitted in rebuttal to respond to the

patent owner’s criticisms will commonly confirm the

prima facie case. That does not make it necessary to the

prima facie case. And nothing required the Board to write

language—which, read literally, might cover most respon-

sive evidence—is not independently significant here.

24 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

its opinion to separate the material offered by Berk-Tek

at different stages of the proceeding.

No rule requires a Petition to be accompanied by any

declaration, let alone one from an expert guiding the

Board as to how it should read prior art. What the Board

can find without an expert depends on the prior art in-

volved in a particular case. Even in court, we have said,

“expert testimony is not required when the references and

the invention are easily understandable.” Wyers v. Master

Lock Co., 616 F.3d 1231, 1242 (Fed. Cir. 2010). And

Board members, because of expertise, may more often find

it easier to understand and soundly explain the teachings

and suggestions of prior art without expert assistance. In

the present case, which is all we address, we conclude

that the Baxter declaration was not necessary for the

prima facie case of obviousness.

3

Belden cites the Patent Trial Guide’s statement that

“[t]he Board will not attempt to sort proper from improper

portions of the reply.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 48,767. It argues

on that basis that the Board had to exclude Berk-Tek’s

entire Reply and supporting material if any portion was

improper. But Belden has identified no part of the Reply

and supporting declaration that is improper and material

to the Board’s ruling. Nothing in the Guide requires

wholesale exclusion in such circumstances. More general-

ly, the Guide cannot fairly be read to do more than put

the public on notice that the Board may, in its discretion,

refuse to consider a Reply if any part is improper. Here,

the Board warned Berk-Tek and gave it an opportunity to

truncate its Reply and supporting submissions to elimi-

nate any improper material. We see no error in that

reasonable course of action.

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 25

4

Belden’s broadest contention is that the Board im-

properly relied on new evidence to which Belden had no

opportunity to respond. But Belden provides no argument

on this score that is independent of its specific allegations

of error. We have rejected those allegations, upholding

the Board’s rulings that the Baxter evidence was legiti-

mately responsive to Belden’s arguments and not needed

for a prima facie case of obviousness. In these circum-

stances, and without any other identification of error,

Belden has not established that it was denied its proce-

dural rights.

A patent owner in Belden’s position is undoubtedly

entitled to notice of and a fair opportunity to meet the

grounds of rejection. “The indispensable ingredients of

due process are notice and an opportunity to be heard by

a disinterested decision-maker.” Abbott Labs. v. Cordis

Corp., 710 F.3d 1318, 1328 (Fed. Cir. 2013). And for a

formal adjudication like the one at issue here, the Admin-

istrative Procedure Act requires the PTO to “timely

inform[]” a patent owner of “the matters of fact and law

asserted” in an inter partes review of its patent, 5 U.S.C.

§ 554(b)(3), to give “all interested parties opportunity for

. . . the submission and consideration of facts [and] argu-

ments . . . [and] hearing and decision on notice,” § 554(c),

and to permit a party “to submit rebuttal evidence, and to

conduct such cross-examination as may be required for a

full and true disclosure of the facts,” § 556(d). See Bow-

man Transp., Inc. v. Arkansas-Best Freight Sys., Inc., 419

U.S. 281, 288 n.4 (1974); Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp.

v. LTV Corp., 496 U.S. 633, 655 (1990). Section 554(b)(3)

has been applied to mean that “an agency may not change

theories in midstream without giving respondents rea-

sonable notice of the change” and “the opportunity to

present argument under the new theory.” Rodale Press,

Inc. v. FTC, 407 F.2d 1252, 1256–57 (D.C. Cir. 1968). In a

related PTO setting, this court has determined whether

26 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

the Board relied on a “new ground of rejection” by asking

“whether applicants have had fair opportunity to react to

the thrust of the rejection.” In re Biedermann, 733 F.3d

329, 337 (Fed. Cir. 2013) (internal quotation marks and

citation omitted).

But the rules and practices of the Board generally

protect against loss of patent rights without the required

notice and opportunity to respond. If there are deficien-

cies in Board rules and practices, none has been estab-

lished as relevant to this case. Nor has Belden identified

a deficiency in the application of Board rules and practic-

es to this case.

The statute provides for inter partes review proceed-

ings to begin with a petition from the challenger. 35

U.S.C. §§ 311, 312(a). The patent owner has the right to

file a preliminary response to argue against the institu-

tion of review. § 313. If a review is instituted, based on a

finding of a reasonable likelihood that the claims do not

meet statutory requirements, the patent owner has the

right to file a post-institution response to defend the

claims. § 316(a)(8). The petitioner also has a right to file

at least one set of written comments. § 316(a)(13). And

both parties have a right to an oral hearing. § 316(a)(10).

The PTO Director has implemented those provisions

through regulations under § 316(a). The regulations

provide for the two patent-owner filings, one before and

one after institution. 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.107(a), 42.120(a).

And they allow the petitioner to reply to the patent own-

er’s post-institution response, but declare that the “reply

may only respond to arguments raised in the correspond-

ing opposition or patent owner response.” § 42.23(b).

Under § 42.51(b)(1)(ii), moreover, a party may cross-

examine an affiant who has submitted testimony pre-

pared for the review. Under § 42.51(b)(2)(i), a party also

may move for additional discovery. In addition, a party

may move to exclude evidence, whether as improper

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 27

under the response-only regulation, under the Trial

Practice Guide’s advice, or on other grounds. § 42.64(c).

The Guide itself provides that, “[i]n the event that cross-

examination occurs after a party has filed its last sub-

stantive paper on an issue, . . . [t]he Board may authorize

the filing of observations” on that cross-examination,

though the observations are to be brief and non-

argumentative. 77 Fed. Reg. at 48,767–68. And for most

regulations governing inter partes review—i.e., those

promulgated under parts 1, 41, and 42 of title 37 of the

Code of Federal Regulations—“[t]he Board may waive or

suspend a requirement . . . and may place conditions on

the waiver or suspension.” 37 C.F.R. § 42.5(b).

Finally, although no rule provides patent owners the

right to file surreplies to a petitioner’s Reply, the Board

has allowed such surreplies in inter partes reviews. See,

e.g., Sensio, Inc. v. Select Brands, Inc., IPR2013-580, 2015

WL 1009189, at *1, *4–7 (PTAB Feb. 9, 2015); Zodiac Pool

Sys., Inc. v. Aqua Prods., Inc., IPR2013-159, 2014 WL

4244016, at *1, *22 (PTAB Aug. 22, 2014); ABB, Inc. v.

ROY-G-BIV Corp., IPR2013-63, 2014 WL 2112556, at *4

(PTAB May 16, 2014). In doing so, the Board has followed

a tradition that pre-dates the America Invents Act. In

proceedings on applications and in interferences, the

Board (or its predecessor) has long granted permission to

file surreplies despite the absence of any regulation

providing for such filings. 5

5 For interferences, see, e.g., Tseng v. Doroodian,

Interference No. 104,482, 2002 WL 390537 at *28 (BPAI

2002); Flanders v. Moorman, Interference No. 103,891,

2001 WL 35825814, at *2–4 (BPAI Sept. 26, 2001). For

applications, see, e.g., Ex parte Jang, Appeal No. 2011-

7826, 2012 WL 3186809, at *4 (BPAI July 31, 2012); Ex

parte Wyss, Appeal No. 2011-5375, 2012 WL 3142233, at

28 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

Thus, if the petitioner submits a new expert declara-

tion with its Reply, the patent owner can respond in

multiple ways. It can cross-examine the expert and move

to file observations on the cross-examination. It can move

to exclude the declaration. It can dispute the substance of

the declaration at oral hearing before the Board. It can

move for permission to submit a surreply responding to

the declaration’s contents. And it can request that the

Board waive or suspend a regulation that the patent

owner believes impairs its opportunity to respond to the

declaration. The options are not mutually exclusive.

In the foregoing respects, the Board’s rules and prac-

tices establish standards bearing similarities to those

often applied in district-court litigation. See Victor Gold,

28 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Evid. § 6164 (2d ed. 2015). The

tribunal has broad discretion to regulate the presentation

of evidence under Fed. R. Evid. 611(a). Rebuttal evidence

is supposed to be limited to that which is responsive to

the adversary’s evidence: “the traditional principle [is]

that evidence offered to rebut must accomplish the func-

tion of rebuttal; ‘to explain, repel, counteract, or disprove

*1 n.1, *3 (BPAI July 31, 2012); Ex parte Zajchowski,

Appeal No. 2010-6962, 2012 WL 2992507, at *2 (BPAI

July 13, 2012); Ex parte Selvin, Appeal No. 2009-13065,

2010 WL 2070576, at *2 n.8, *3 (BPAI May 21, 2010); Ex

parte Domb, Appeal No. 2008-3664, 2010 WL 2030469, at

*8–10, *12 (BPAI May 20, 2010); Ex parte Frippiat, Ap-

peal No. 2009-10881, 2010 WL 1725736, at *2, *5 (BPAI

Apr. 26, 2010); Ex parte Kringelum, Appeal No. 2008-

3378, 2008 WL 3272056, at *7 (BPAI Aug. 7, 2008); Ex

parte Schultz, Appeal No. 2008-3731, 2008 WL 2856377,

at *6, *9–10 (BPAI July 24, 2008); Ex parte Wells, Appeal

No. 2005-2607, 2005 WL 4779434, at *1 n.2 (BPAI Sept.

23, 2005); Ex parte Yoshida, Appeal No. 1997-61, 1999

WL 33134885, at *1 (BPAI Oct. 18, 1999).

BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC 29

the evidence of the adverse party.’ ” Gold, supra (quoting

United States v. Luschen, 614 F.2d 1164, 1170 (8th Cir.

1980)). Where new enough matter is allowed on rebuttal,

surrebuttal may be allowed, but a proffer of specifics may

be required to justify the additional round of evidentiary

submissions. Gold, supra; Hall v. General Motors Corp.,

647 F.2d 175, 181 (D.C. Cir. 1980); United States v. Sad-

ler, 488 F.2d 434, 435 (5th Cir. 1974). Those standards

are widely employed to provide the required procedural

fairness through careful case-specific application.

Here, the Board held Berk-Tek to the response-only

standard for evidence submitted with a Reply and even

held itself to ensuring that the prima facie case did not

depend on that evidence. It provided for Belden’s cross-

examination of Mr. Baxter and for submission of non-

argumentative observations on that cross-examination. It

accepted Belden’s detailed motion to exclude (and its

reply after Berk-Tek’s response). It provided Belden with

a meaningful opportunity to respond to the propriety of

Mr. Baxter’s evidence submitted with Berk-Tek’s Reply,

in that it granted every request Belden made for consid-

eration of the issue. Belden did not seek to file a surreply,

to file additional observations on its cross-examination, to

make arguments in those observations, or to have the

Board waive any other regulations that it believed pre-

vented it from adequately responding to Mr. Baxter’s

declaration. With no Board denial of concrete, focused

requests before us, we are not prepared to find that

Belden was denied a meaningful opportunity to respond

to the grounds of rejection, and we find no basis for dis-

turbing the Board’s denial of Belden’s motion to exclude.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the Board’s

determinations that claims 1–4 of the ’503 patent would

have been obvious, reverse the Board’s determination that

30 BELDEN INC. v. BERK-TEK LLC

claims 5 and 6 would not have been obvious, and affirm

the Board’s denial of Belden’s motion to exclude.

No costs.

AFFIRMED IN PART AND REVERSED IN PART

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.