Opinion

the Daneshjou Company, Inc. v. W. Lee Brown & Sons, Inc.

Court
Texas Court of Appeals, 3rd District (Austin)
Filed
Aug 24, 2006
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 36.2%

The opinion

TEXAS COURT OF APPEALS, THIRD DISTRICT, AT AUSTIN

NO. 03-04-00730-CV

NO. 03-04-00734-CV

NO. 03-04-00735-CV NO. 03-04-00737-CV

NO. 03-04-00738-CV

NO. 03-04-00739-CV

NO. 03-04-00740-CV

The Daneshjou Company, Inc., Appellant

v.

Joe Goergen

&

CNA Construction, Inc.

&

Modern Design and Construction, Inc.

&

Loredo Truss Company, Inc.

&

Loma Excavation, Inc.

&

G. P. Equipment Company

&

W. Lee Brown & Sons, Inc., Appellees

FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF TRAVIS COUNTY, 126TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

NOS. GN403647, GN403032, GN402512, GN402481, GN403033, GN402513 & GN402685,

HONORABLE PAUL DAVIS, JUDGE PRESIDING

O R D E R

Appellee W. Lee Brown & Sons, Inc. filed a motion to dismiss cause 03-04-00740-CV based on a late notice of appeal. (Cause number 03-04-00740-CV was consolidated with the

other causes listed in the heading for the purposes of briefing and argument. See The Daneshjou Co.,

Inc. v. Goergen, No. 03-04-00730-CV (Tex. App.--Austin Mar. 17, 2006) (order)). Brown notes

that the final judgment was signed on August 6, 2004. (1) Assuming this date of judgment, a motion

for new trial was due by September 7, 2004, but none was filed until September 16. Without the

extended appellate timetable conferred by a motion for new trial, appellant's notice of appeal would

have been due September 7, 2004, but was not filed until November 4, 2004, (2) which would have

been untimely. See Tex. R. App. P. 26.1(a). However, appellant Daneshjou actually filed an earlier

motion for new trial.

On June 10, 2004, the trial court by letter indicated that it would grant a partial

summary judgment on all of Daneshjou's claims against W. Lee Brown & Sons except Daneshjou's

claim for contribution and noted a fact issue existed concerning Brown's quality of work. On July

15, 2004, the trial court signed an interlocutory order. On July 13, Daneshjou had already filed a

motion to clarify and reconsider the "judgment." (3) On July 29, Daneshjou filed a supplemental

motion to reconsider. Daneshjou wanted the court to clarify which basis for contribution remained

pending as it had claimed three possible grounds for contribution: section 17.555 of the business

and commerce code; chapter 33 of the civil practice and remedies code; and chapter 32 of the civil

practice and remedies code. (4) Daneshjou's motion also asked the court to reconsider its ruling, if it

had intended to grant summary judgment against Daneshjou on any of his grounds for contribution.

For each ground, Daneshjou argued why the court was incorrect in denying the claim. In its

supplemental motion to reconsider, Daneshjou asserted it had express contractual indemnity claims

against Brown that should be considered. On August 3, the court overruled Daneshjou's motion.

Then, on August 6, 2004, the court dismissed Daneshjou's claims for contribution and severed

Brown's cause, creating a final judgment against Daneshjou. Daneshjou asserts that the July motion

to reconsider had the effect of a motion for new trial with regard to the August judgment.

A motion for new trial "shall be filed prior to or within thirty days after the judgment

or other order complained of is signed." Tex. R. Civ. P. 329b(a). The rules of appellate procedure

permit the appellate court to "treat actions taken before an appealable order is signed as relating to

an appeal of that order and give them effect as if they had been taken after the order was signed."

Tex. R. App. P. 27.2. Premature filing rules are construed liberally in favor of the right to appeal.

South Tex. GMAC Real Estate v. Cohyco, Inc. , 124 S.W.3d 321, 325 (Tex. App.--Corpus Christi

2003, no pet.); Miller v. Hernandez , 708 S.W.2d 25, 27 (Tex. App.--Dallas 1986, no writ). For

example, a motion for new trial extended the appellate timetable even though directed at an

interlocutory judgment that did not became final until the court dismissed the remaining claims five

months later. Nuchia v. Woodruff , 956 S.W.2d 612, 614-15 (Tex. App.--Houston [14th Dist.] 1997,

pet. denied).

A motion for new trial that complains of error brought forward in a subsequent

judgment generally operates to extend the appellate timetable on the judgment it assails. Wilkins v.

Methodist Health Care System , 160 S.W.2d 559, 562 (Tex. 2005). A motion for new trial that has

been overruled extends the appellate timetable when the complaints raised in the motion have not

been cured and remain applicable to a subsequent judgment. See Wilkins , 160 S.W.3d at 562 (citing

Harris County Hospital District v. Estrada , 831 S.W.2d 876, 880 (Tex. App.--Houston [1st Dist.]

1992, no writ)). (5)

Daneshjou's July motion for reconsideration was directed at the trial court's denial

of its claims for contribution. The court overruled Daneshjou's motion and dismissed its claims for

contribution. Therefore, Daneshjou's motion continued to assail the final judgment by arguing that

it was entitled to contribution from Brown, the claim that the trial court denied. Accordingly, the

July motion for contribution served as an effective premature motion for new trial. Daneshjou was

allowed to use the extended appellate timetable so the November 4 notice of appeal was timely. See

Tex. R. App. P. 26.1(a).

Brown also complains that Daneshjou's notice of appeal filed on November 4, 2004,

named only LOC Consultants, Inc. as the appellee. The clerk's record in cause 03-740-CV contains

a notice of appeal that names LOC Consultants, Inc. as the appellee. However, the rule specifying

the contents of the notice of appeal does not call for a list of appellees. See Tex. R. App. P. 25.1(a).

Further, the rules call for the appellant to file the notice of appeal in the trial court, with a copy to

the appellate court. Id. R. 25.1(e). This court filed a copy of the notice of appeal naming Brown as

the appellee. This notice contained a certificate of service showing service on Brown's counsel. Id .

A mistake made by the district clerk's office in the compilation of the record when appellee Brown

was served with the notice of appeal is not a basis to dismiss the appeal. We overrule Brown's

motion to dismiss the appeal.

It is ordered August 24, 2006.

W. Kenneth Law, Chief Justice

Before Chief Justice Law, Justices Patterson and Pemberton

1. Daneshjou complains that the judgment was initially signed on August 13, 2004, not

August 6. The clerk's record shows a judgment that has August 6 crossed out and August 13 written

in. A handwritten notation on the judgment in the clerk's record shows "corrected minutes." We

need not decide whether we treat August 6 or August 13 as the correct judgment date because we

determine that Daneshjou perfected the appeal as to either date.

2. The notice of appeal was received November 8, 2004. Daneshjou provided an affidavit

demonstrating that the notice of appeal, which has been filed, was properly mailed November 4,

2004. See Tex. R. App. P. 9.2(b) ("mailbox rule").

3. A motion for reconsideration of an order is the equivalent of a motion for new trial for

appeal purposes. See Finley v. J.C. Pace Ltd. , 4 S.W.3d 319, 320 (Tex. App.--Houston [1st Dist.]

1999, no pet.) (effect of motion depends on nature of instrument; substance, not form, controls).

4. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code Ann. § 17.555 (West 2002); Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code Ann.

§§ 32.001-32.003 (West 1997); Id . §§ 33.001-33.017 (West 1997 & Supp. 2005).

5. The opinion then held that a motion for new trial that had been granted cannot assail a

subsequent judgment for purposes of determining the deadline for filing a notice of appeal. Wilkins

v. Methodist Health Care System , 160 S.W.3d 559, 564 (Tex. 2005).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.