Opinion

Daphne Scarbrough v. the Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County

Court
Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston)
Filed
Aug 31, 2010
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 35.3%

holding that standing is implicit in trial court’s subject matter jurisdiction to consider case

How later courts described this case

  • holding that standing is implicit in trial court’s subject matter jurisdiction to consider case
  • “To be entitled to municipal taxpayer standing, a litigant must prove that the government is actually expending money on the activity that the taxpayer challenges; merely demonstrating that tax dollars are spent on something related to the allegedly illegal conduct is not enough.”
  • “The general test for standing in Texas requires that there (a) shall be a real controversy between the parties, which (b) will be actually determined by the judicial declaration sought.”
  • holding that we consider relevant evidence submitted by parties when necessary to resolve jurisdictional issues raised

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Opinion issued August 31, 2010

In The

Court of

Appeals

For The

First District

of Texas

————————————

NO. 01-08-00792-CV

———————————

Daphne Scarbrough , Appellant

V.

The

Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County , Appellee

On Appeal from the 215th District Court

Harris County, Texas

Trial Court Case No. 0731651

O P I N I O N

Appellant,

Daphne Scarbrough, argues that the trial court erred in granting the plea to

the jurisdiction of appellee, the Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris

County (METRO). In seven issues, she

argues that: (1) the trial court erred in finding that she had no standing to

sue because METRO’s “Contract With the Voters” provides standing to

property-tax payers and referendum voters; (2) the trial court erred in finding

that she had no standing because even petition-signers, who have significantly

less at stake, have previously been found to have standing to sue METRO over

its “Main Street” Line; (3) the trial court erred in finding she had no

standing because it improperly focused on how she voted rather than on whether

she voted; (4) the trial court erred in finding she had no standing by

misinterpreting the requisites for taxpayer standing in a way that would make it

impossible for anyone to sue METRO; (5) the trial court erred by refusing to

abate its hearing on METRO’s plea to the jurisdiction until after the fact

finder resolved disputed fact issues; (6) alternatively, if the trial court was

correct in granting METRO’s plea to the jurisdiction, it erred in ruling that

Scarbrough take nothing and should have dismissed her case without prejudice;

and (7) alternatively, the trial court erred by refusing to provide Scarbrough

an opportunity to replead prior to dismissal of her case.

We

modify the judgment and affirm as modified.

Background

In

the late 1990s, METRO began to develop a plan known as METRO Solutions, which

was intended to increase transit options in the METRO service area by adding

new rail and bus lines and by making contributions to street improvements. On August 28, 2003, METRO’s board of

directors approved resolution number 2003-93, providing notice of a special

election

for the purpose of

submitting to the qualified electors of the Metropolitan Transit Authority of

Harris County, Texas . . . a proposition to authorize METRO to issue bonds,

notes and other obligations payable, in whole or in part, from seventy-five

percent (75%) of METRO’s sales and use tax revenues for the acquisition,

construction, repair, equipping, improvement or extension of METRO’s transit

authority system, including the METRO Solutions transit system plan, as

described herein, which includes bus service expansions and construction of

extensions of METRO’s rail system known as “METRORail,” to approve such plan

and construction of the METRORail and commuter line components thereof, and to

dedicate twenty-five percent (25%) of METRO’s sales and use tax revenues

through September 20, 2014, for street improvements and mobility projects, as

authorized by law and with no increases in the current rate of METRO’s sales

and use tax; and making other provisions related to the subject.

Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County,

Resolution 2003-93 (Aug. 28, 2003) (“Resolution 2003-93”).

METRO

attached a copy of its resolution number 2003-77 (“Resolution 2003-77”),

calling the special election, as an exhibit to its notice of special

election. This resolution stated, in

part,

Section 14. METRO Agreements with the Voters. As authorized by Section 451.072 of the METRO

Act and other applicable law, the Board hereby declares that, if a majority of

the voters voting at the Election approve the Proposition, the following

agreements will be binding on METRO and will constitute contracts with the

voters in accordance with their terms and may not be repealed, altered or

rescinded by any succeeding Board without voter approval at a subsequent

election:

(a) The aggregate principal amount of bonds, notes or other obligations of

METRO that are payable, in whole or in part, from

seventy-five percent (75%) of METRO’s sales and use tax revenues and are issued pursuant to the authority granted at

this Election will never exceed $640,000,000 ;

(b) Proceeds of the bonds, notes or other obligations authorized at the

Election will be used to acquire, construct, repair, equip, improve or extend

METRO’s transit authority system, including the METRO Solutions Plan, provided

that the only portions of METRORail for which such proceeds may be used are new

segments included in Phase II of METRORail, as more particularly described in

Exhibit A-4 ;

(c) Approval of the Proposition at the Election constitutes approval of the

METRO Solutions Plan , including the extensions and

segments of METRORail and the construction of the METRORail and Commuter Line

Components thereof for purposes of the city charter of the City of Houston;

(d) METRO will not undertake the construction of any new segment of Phase II

of METRORail with proceeds of the bonds, notes or other obligations authorized

at the Election without first obtaining approval of the segment for federal

capital assistance under applicable federal law and regulations or the

commitment of a substantial amount of private funds ;

(e) METRO’s Street Improvement

Dedication will be in force and effect through September 30, 2014, in

accordance with the terms of such dedication, as described in Exhibit B;

(f) Between November 1, 2009 and

January 1, 2013, METRO will call an election seeking a local determination by

voters regarding METRO’s continuing support after September 30, 2014 for

improvements of the types described in Section 451.065 of the METRO Act;

(g) Prior to November 1, 2009, METRO will not call any other election seeking

voter approval to authorize METRO to issue bonds, notes or other obligations to

provide any rail facilities other than Commuter Line Component, as more

particularly described in Exhibit A-8 and depicted in Exhibit A-9, which are

hereby made a part of this Resolution ; and

(h) METRO will not implement any

increase in the rate of its currently existing, previously voted one percent

(1%) sales and use tax.

(Emphasis added.)

Exhibit A-4, referenced in Section

14, paragraph (b) of Resolution 2003-77, provided the details of METRORail

Phase II. In pertinent part, it stated:

METRORail Phase II generally consists of the following

light rail segments or lines, including associated vehicles and facilities:

. . . .

Westpark

·

Approximately 6.6 miles

westward from the Wheeler station on Phase I METRORail to the Hillcroft Transit

Center, serving Greenway Plaza, West University, Bellaire and the

Uptown/Galleria area. This segment or line will have

approximately 4 stations.

. . . .

Note: Final

scope, length of rail segments or lines and other details, together with implementation

schedule, will be based upon demand and completion of the project development

process, including community input.

The METRO Solutions Bus Component Park & Ride in the vicinity of

Hobby Airport will be deferred until a later phase of the Southeast segment or

line.

(Emphasis added.)

Finally, Exhibits A-8 and A-9,

referenced in Section 14, paragraph (g) of METRO Resolution 2003-77, described

the Commuter Line Components. Exhibit

A-8 described the commuter line components, stating that they “generally

consist” of “rail segments or lines, including associated vehicles and

facilities,” along US 90A, US 290, and “other commuter rail corridors within

the METRO service area as are found to be feasible.” This exhibit also contained the caveat that the

“[f]inal scope, length of rail segments or lines and other details, together

with implementation schedule, will be based upon demand and completion of the

project development process, including community input.” Exhibit A-9 was a “Transit System Plan” mapping

the various lines discussed in Exhibit A-8.

The

special election occurred on November 4, 2003, and voters approved the METRO

Solutions Plan.

According to the affidavit of

METRO’s executive vice president, METRO’s board of directors decided in 2007 to

pursue light rail as the preferred transit mode for several of the lines

discussed in the METRO Solutions Plan due to several factors, such as changes

in the profitability of particular bus routes and in the availability of

federal funding. This affected the

Westpark segment of light rail lines connecting the Wheeler Station and the

Hillcroft Transit Center authorized in the 2003 referendum. According to Scarbrough’s pleadings, METRO

currently plans to place a portion of that line in the center of the street on

Richmond Avenue, where it will pass by Scarbrough’s property.

On May 23, 2007, Scarbrough filed this

suit against METRO as a voter who opposed the METRO Solutions transit system

plan in the 2003 referendum and as a residential property owner, commercial

businesswoman and taxpayer in the City of Houston and Harris County, asserting

claims for breach of contract, declaratory judgment, and unconstitutional

impairment of contract and alleging that METRO was improperly implementing the

terms of the November 2003 referendum election.

Scarbrough

contends that Resolution 2003-93, with its exhibits, including Resolution

2003-77 authorizing the referendum and its exhibits, constitutes a “clear and

unambiguous contract” between METRO and the voters and taxpayers and that METRO

has failed to comply with the Resolution.

She states that Metro has entered into a contract calling for early

construction activities, whereas Resolution 2003-77 provides that METRO may not

undertake the construction of any new segment of Phase II of METRORail with

proceeds of the obligations authorized at the Election “without first obtaining

approval of the segment for federal capital assistance.” She further states that cost estimates for

the project exceed the $640 million authorized by the Resolution. Finally, she contends that “Section 14 of the

Resolution specifies that the agreements contained in subparagraphs (a)-(h) may

not be ‘repealed, altered or rescinded’ without voter approval at a subsequent

election,” that “Section 14(c) makes clear that approval of the Resolution

includes approval of the entire Metro Solutions Plan,” that METRO is “not

complying with the routes specified in the Resolution,” and that the voters

“did not authorize Metro to use any portion of Richmond Avenue for the portion

of METRORail known as the Westpark route.”

Thus, she contends that the use of funds authorized by Resolution

2003-93 to construct any of the METRORail project on Richmond is illegal.

Scarbrough

alleges that she has standing as a voter and taxpayer of property taxes and of

METRO’s use and sales tax because she will suffer significant financial damages

“if METRO is allowed to proceed in violation of the Resolution.” She further contends that, because her

property and business on Richmond run along one of the streets METRO is

proposing to use for the Westpark route, her use and enjoyment of the property

will be harmed by the line and that the construction, operation, and

maintenance of the line will affect her property rights and severely disrupt

her business.

METRO

filed a plea to the jurisdiction, arguing that Scarbrough could not assert

standing as a voter, taxpayer, or property owner and that she lacked standing

to litigate any issue related to bus service or to challenge METRO’s

distribution of “General Mobility Funds.”

METRO also argued that several of Scarbrough’s issues were not ripe,

were moot, or did not constitute justiciable controversies. Scarbrough amended her pleadings to include

additional facts in support of the trial court’s jurisdiction over the case,

and she specifically argued that “[t]he case at bar demonstrates a legal and

factual pattern where the merits are inextricably intertwined with certain

jurisdictional facts,” and thus a fact finder was required to resolve fact

questions regarding the jurisdictional issue.

Scarbrough also filed a separate motion asking the trial court to abate

its hearing on METRO’s plea to the jurisdiction until after a fact finder could

address the “intertwined” facts pertaining to jurisdiction and the underlying

merits.

The

trial court denied Scarbrough’s motion to abate and subsequently held a hearing

on METRO’s plea. On August 21, 2008, the

trial court issued its “Order Granting METRO’s Plea to the Jurisdiction and

Dismissing Case,” which stated,

The Court concludes that it

does not have subject matter jurisdiction over Scarbrough[’s] legal claims — for all

of the reasons set forth in Metro’s legal briefing. Therefore, the Court hereby grants Metro’s

plea to the jurisdiction. The Court

orders that Scarbrough takes nothing because she has no standing to pursue the

claims asserted. This is a final order,

disposing of all issues and all parties.

This appeal followed.

Standing

In her first four issues,

Scarbrough argues that the trial court erred in finding that she did not have

standing to bring her claims.

A. Standing Generally

Standing

is implicit in the concept of subject-matter jurisdiction, and subject-matter

jurisdiction is essential to the authority of a court to decide a case. Tex.

Ass’n of Bus. v. Tex. Air Control Bd. , 852 S.W.2d 440, 443 (Tex.

1993). Thus, standing is never presumed,

cannot be waived, and can be raised for the first time on appeal. Id.

at 443–45. We review standing under the

same standard by which we review subject-matter jurisdiction generally. Id. at

446 . Whether the trial court has

subject-matter jurisdiction is a question of law that we review de novo. Tex. Dep’t of Parks & Wildlife v.

Miranda , 133 S.W.3d

217, 226 (Tex. 2004) .

A plea to the jurisdiction is a

dilatory plea, which is intended to defeat a cause of action regardless of

whether the claims asserted have merit. Bland Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Blue , 34

S.W.3d 547, 554 (Tex. 2000). The pleader

must allege facts that affirmatively demonstrate the trial court’s jurisdiction

to hear the case. Tex. Ass’n of Bus. , 852 S.W.2d at 446 . If a plea to the jurisdiction challenges the

existence of jurisdictional facts, as here, we consider relevant evidence

submitted by the parties when necessary to resolve the jurisdictional issues

raised. See Bland , 34 S.W.3d at 555 .

We take as true all evidence favorable to the nonmovant and indulge

every reasonable inference and resolve any doubts in the nonmovant’s

favor. Miranda , 133 S.W.3d at 228 .

If the relevant evidence is undisputed or fails to raise a fact question

on the jurisdictional issue, the trial court rules on the plea to the

jurisdiction as a matter of law. Id.

Generally, unless standing

is conferred by statute, a plaintiff must demonstrate that he “possesses an

interest in a conflict distinct from that of the general public, such that the

defendant’s actions have caused the plaintiff some particular injury.” Williams

v. Lara , 52 S.W.3d 171, 178 (Tex. 2001); see also Tex. Ass’n of Bus. , 852

S.W.2d at 446 (“The general test for standing in Texas requires that there (a)

shall be a real controversy between the parties, which (b) will be actually

determined by the judicial declaration sought.”) (internal quotation omitted).

B. Voter Standing

In

her first issue, Scarbrough argues that she has standing as a voter and

taxpayer to challenge METRO’s planned use of bond and tax funds because

representations made in exhibits attached to the notice of special election on

the bond referendum created a “contract with the voters.” In her second issue,

Scarbrough argues that she has standing as a voter because even

petition-signers, who have less interest at stake than she does as a voter,

have standing. In her third issue,

Scarbrough argues that how she voted is immaterial and that the fact that she

voted, “without more, is sufficient to trigger standing to complain over

METRO’s inability or outright refusal to comply with contractual terms of the

2003 Referendum.” We first address

Scarbrough’s claim that she has standing as a voter to challenge the proposed

application of bond funds.

With respect to Scarbrough’s third argument,

that she has standing as a voter in the 2003 referendum, without more, to

challenge the proposed application of bond funds, we note that the Texas

Supreme Court has pointed out that “[n]o Texas court has ever recognized that a

plaintiff’s status as a voter, without more, confers standing to challenge the

lawfulness of governmental acts. Our

decisions have always required a plaintiff to allege some injury distinct from

that sustained by the public at large.” Brown v. Todd , 53 S.W.3d 297, 302 (Tex.

2001). This limitation is informed by

the two constitutional limitations on subject-matter jurisdiction — the separation of powers doctrine and Texas’s

open courts provision — which both

require “an actual, not merely a hypothetical or generalized grievance.” Id. Additionally, the Texas Supreme Court “has

never recognized standing on the basis of the results — as opposed to the process — of an initiative election.” Id.

In Brown , a plaintiff asserted “that he possess[ed] an injury distinct

from the general public because he voted in [the referendum at issue], his vote

was for the prevailing side, and Mayor Brown’s executive order negated his

vote.” Id. The court held,

[T]his proposed rationale

for standing is too broad because the injury he identifies is not unique to

him. Indeed, it is shared by all living

Houstonians who were among the 198,563 electors who actually voted against the

proposed ordinance. In no way does [the

plaintiff’s] status as a voter give him an interest sufficiently peculiar to

satisfy our standing requirements.

Id. Similarly, Scarbrough’s status as a

voter, without more, does not confer standing because she is challenging the

results of the election, not the process by which it was conducted and she has

not asserted an injury unique to her that is not shared by every other

Houstonian who voted in the November 2003 referendum.

Scarbrough also argues, however,

that she has standing as a voter under City

of Houston v. Todd . 41 S.W.3d 289 ,

302 n.21 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2001, pet. denied). In Todd , Robb Todd, a city counsel member, and Allan Vogel, a voter

who had signed a petition for a referendum on the city ordinance granting METRO

the right to construct a light rail line along Main Street, sued the City of

Houston and METRO when the City refused to hold an election on the referendum. Id. at

292–93. The petition, which Vogel signed

but Todd did not, stated that a vote of the citizens of Houston was required by

the city charter before METRO could construct the Main Street light rail line. Id.

at 293.

This Court ruled against Vogel and

the other plaintiff on the basis of the City’s argument that the city charter

provisions relied upon by the plaintiffs were preempted by provisions of the

Texas Transportation Code and were not applicable to the complained-of

ordinance. Id. at 295, 302. The Court

did not address the issue of standing, except to state, “We note that appellee

Vogel has standing. . . .” Id. at 302 n.21. The opinion cited Blum v. Lanier , which held that a qualified voter who spearheaded

and signed an initiative petition had standing to challenge the form in which the

referendum was put to the citizens. See 997 S.W.2d 259, 262 (Tex. 1999). Scarbrough does not challenge the form in

which Resolution 2003-93 was put to the voters.

Thus, she has not shown that Todd

is relevant to this case. See id. at 295–302. Rather, the applicable rule is that stated in

Brown , in which the supreme court

held that a plaintiff’s status as a voter, without more, does not confer

standing to challenge the lawfulness of governmental acts, that the plaintiff

must allege some injury distinct from that sustained by the public at large,

and that the court “has never recognized standing on the basis of the results — as opposed to the process — of an initiative election.” Brown, 53 S.W.3d at 302 .

Finally, Scarbrough contends that

she has standing as a referendum voter and taxpayer to challenge METRO’s

alleged violations of section 14 of Resolution 2003-77, attached as an exhibit

to Resolution 2003-93, the resolution approved by the voters in the 2003

referendum. She argues that the Texas

Supreme Court has held that the terms of resolutions and orders calling a tax

or bond election to approve financial undertakings of a governmental body

become a contract with the voters.

Scarbrough cites several cases regarding “contracts with the voters” in

her argument asserting that she has standing.

See San Saba County v. McCraw ,

108 S.W.2d 200 , 202–03 (Tex. 1937); Fletcher

v. Howard , 39 S.W.2d 32, 34 (Tex. 1931); Black v. Strength , 246 S.W. 79, 80 (Tex. 1922); Moore v. Coffman , 200 S.W. 374 , 374–75

(Tex. 1918); Taxpayers for Sensible

Priorities v. City of Dallas , 79 S.W.3d 670, 676 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2002,

pet. denied). However, one of these, San Saba County , did not involve a suit

of a citizen voter against a governmental entity; rather, it was a suit by a

county attempting to compel the attorney general to approve the funding of

certain road and bridge bonds. See San Saba County , 108 S.W.2d at

201 . The remaining cases all address

suits by voters who were also property taxpayers to require a governmental

entity to use the bond funds for the purpose for which they were approved. See

Fletcher , 39 S.W.2d at 32–33; Black ,

246 S.W. at 80 ; Moore , 200 S.W. at

374–75; see also Taxpayers for Sensible

Priorities , 79 S.W.3d at 675 –76. Thus, we

conclude that these cases are more properly characterized as taxpayer suits. See

Bland , 34 S.W.3d at 555 (characterizing as taxpayer challenge action by

taxpayers seeking permanent injunction against payments by school district under

lease-purchase agreement for new high school that they claimed violated the

Public Property Finance Act, Tex.

Local Gov’t Code § 271.004,

providing for voter approval of contracts for purchase or improvement of real

property by school districts).

Therefore, we address these cases in the next section.

We hold that Scarbrough’s status as

a voter in the November 2003 bond referendum, without more, does not confer

standing on her to sue METRO for its alleged misuse of bond funds whose

issuance was authorized by the referendum. [1]

We overrule Scarbrough’s first,

second, and third issues insofar as they allege her standing as a voter in the

November 2003 referendum.

C. Taxpayer Standing

In

her first and fourth issues, Scarbrough argues that she has standing to sue on

METRO’s alleged “contract with the voters” as a voter and taxpayer. Scarbrough contends that METRO’s expenditure

of public taxpayer funds on its current light rail plans would be illegal

because those plans were not authorized by the 2003 resolution and referendum.

The Texas Supreme Court addressed

taxpayer standing to sue a public entity for the alleged misappropriation of

public funds in Bland . 34 S.W.3d at 549 . The supreme court recognized the rule that,

[i]n general, taxpayers do

not have a right to bring suit to contest government decision-making because,

as we observed more than half a century ago in Osborne v. Keith , “[g]overnments cannot operate if every citizen

who concludes that a public official has abused his discretion is granted the

right to come into court and bring such official’s public acts under judicial

review.”

Id . However, while recognizing that “taxpayers

must show as a rule that they have suffered a particularized injury distinct

from that suffered by the general public in order to have standing to challenge

a government action or assert a public right,” the court also recognized the

“long-established exception to this rule,” under which “a taxpayer has standing

to sue in equity to enjoin the illegal expenditure of public funds, even

without showing a distinct injury.” Id . at 555–56. The court recognized that the exception,

“strictly limited, provides important protection to the public from the illegal

expenditure of public funds without hampering too severely the workings of the

government.” Id . at 556–57 (refusing to apply taxpayer exception where contract

sought to be enjoined had already been performed and suit was, therefore, moot,

and concluding that potential for disruption of government operations was too

great to allow taxpayer with no special injury distinct from general public to

sue to prohibit government for paying for goods and services already received).

Here,

Resolution 2003-93 provided notice of a special election “for the purpose of

submitting to the qualified electors of the Metropolitan Transit Authority of

Harris County, Texas . . . a proposition to authorize METRO to issue bonds,

notes and other obligations payable, in whole or in part, from seventy-five

percent (75%) of METRO’s sales and use tax revenues for the acquisition,

construction, repair, equipping, improvement or extension of METRO’s transit

authority system, including the METRO Solutions transit system plan, as

described herein.” It is undisputed that

METRO’s sole tax support comes from a one percent sales tax, and it is likewise

undisputed that Scarbrough, a voter in the 2003 referendum on Resolution

2003-93, pays both this sales tax and property tax. Scarbrough argues, therefore, that her

payment of this sales tax and her status as a landowning property-tax payer

confer standing on her as a taxpayer to challenge METRO’s current plan for rail

on Richmond as an illegal expenditure of public funds under the exception to

the general taxpayer standing rule.

METRO argues that Scarbrough does

not have taxpayer standing because the Texas Transportation Code restricts

METRO from imposing ad valorem property

taxes, and thus the only tax Scarbrough pays to METRO is the one percent sales

tax, which the Texas Supreme Court has unequivocally held is insufficient to

confer standing. Scarbrough argues that

applying this rule to conclude that she lacks standing to sue METRO would make

it impossible for anyone to sue METRO.

To support her claims that she has

standing as a sales tax and property tax payer to challenge METRO’s alleged

improper diversion of funds from the proceeds of obligations authorized to be

issued by the 2003 Referendum, Scarbrough relies on Williams v. Lara , in which the Texas Supreme Court considered

taxpayer standing to oppose the expenditure of public funds to support the

Chaplain’s Education Unit (CEU) within the Tarrant County Corrections Center

(TCCC). 52 S.W.3d at 175 . One of the plaintiffs paid only sales tax;

the other paid sales and property tax.

The supreme court held that taxpayers may fall under the limited taxpayer

exception to the general rule that a plaintiff must demonstrate that he

possesses an interest in a conflict distinct from that of the general

public. Id. at 179 (citing Bland ,

34 S.W.3d at 556 ). “Taxpayers in Texas

have standing to enjoin the illegal expenditure of public funds, and need not

demonstrate a particularized injury.” Id. This

limited exception to the general rule requires that the plaintiff be a taxpayer

and that public funds be expended on the allegedly illegal activity. Id. The court further held that whether the

plaintiff has taxpayer standing depends upon the type of tax she claims to have

paid. Id.

In Williams , the supreme court expressly held that “paying sales tax

does not confer taxpayer standing upon a party.” Id. at

180 . In reaching this conclusion, the

court reasoned:

Taxpayer standing is a

judicially created exception to the general standing rule. We have already limited the applicability of

this exception by narrowly defining the type of action a taxpayer can

maintain. A taxpayer may maintain an

action solely to challenge proposed illegal expenditures; a taxpayer may not

sue to recover funds previously expended, or challenge expenditures that are

merely “unwise or indiscreet.”

Underpinning these limitations is the realization that “[g]overnments

cannot operate if every citizen who concludes that a public official has abused

his discretion is granted the right to come into court and bring such

official’s public acts under judicial review.”

Extending taxpayer standing to those who pay only sales tax would mean

that even a person who makes incidental purchases while temporarily in the

state could maintain an action. This

would eviscerate any limitation on taxpayer suits. It would allow a person with virtually no

personal stake in how the public funds are expended to come into court and

bring the government’s actions under judicial review. This is not what this Court envisioned in

crafting the taxpayer-standing exception.

Id. (internal

citations omitted). Although the court

held that the plaintiff who paid only sales tax lacked standing, it also held

that the plaintiff who paid property taxes did satisfy the taxpayer

requirement, and it stated that “[t]he dispositive issue regarding [his]

standing is whether Tarrant County is actually expending public funds in

operating the [allegedly unconstitutional entity, the CEU].” Id. at

180–81.

Because it was dealing with a case

of first impression, the supreme court in Williams

looked to federal cases dealing with the issue of “what constitutes expending

public funds.” Id. at 181 . The court stated

that it would “look to the jurisprudence of municipal taxpayer standing to

guide [it] in determining whether” the county was expending public funds in

operating the CEU. Id. It cited multiple

federal cases supporting the proposition that “[m]unicipal taxpayers need only

establish that they pay taxes to the relevant entity, and that public funds are

expended on the allegedly unconstitutional activity.” Id. It further stated that to be entitled to

taxpayer standing a plaintiff “must prove that the government is actually

expending money on the activity that the taxpayer challenges” and that “merely

demonstrating that tax dollars are spent on something related to the allegedly

illegal conduct is not enough.” Id.

The court went on to state that the record in Williams established that the county was using tax dollars to

manage the allegedly unconstitutional CEU because county-paid employees

oversaw, managed, and “spent a significant amount of the County’s time

operating” the unit. Id. at 182 –83. Implicit in this reasoning is

the fact that the property tax paid by the plaintiff was paid to the county,

the entity that was supporting the allegedly illegal activity.

Concerning Scarbrough’s standing as

a taxpayer, we note that while the supreme court prohibited extension of

standing to challenge the expenditure of public funds to someone who paid only

sales tax, Scarbrough does not fall into this category. The fact that she also pays property tax

addresses the concern raised in Williams that

“[e]xtending taxpayer standing to those who pay only sales tax would mean that

even a person who makes incidental purchases while temporarily in the state

could maintain an action.” Id. at 180 . However, this distinction is insufficient to

overcome the bright-line rule in Williams

that standing to challenge the expenditure of public funds as illegal cannot be

derived from the payment of sales tax due to policy concerns. Thus, we must look to Scarbrough’s standing

as a property-tax payer.

The relationship between

Scarbrough’s payment of property taxes here and the anticipated allegedly

illegal expenditures by METRO is much more attenuated than the relationship

between the expenditure of tax funds and the allegedly unconstitutional

expenditure of those funds in Williams . In Williams ,

the plaintiff paid property taxes directly to the entity, Tarrant County, which

supported the allegedly illegal CEU activity in the TCCC. See id.

at 181 (“To be entitled to municipal taxpayer standing, a litigant must

prove that the government is actually expending money on the activity that the

taxpayer challenges; merely demonstrating that tax dollars are spent on

something related to the allegedly illegal conduct is not enough.”); see also Bland , 34 S.W.3d at 556

(explaining that exception allowing taxpayer standing to sue to enjoin

expenditure of illegal funds is justified because “[w]hen a taxpayer brings an

action to restrain the illegal expenditure . . . of tax money, he sues for

himself, and it is held that his interest in the subject-matter is sufficient

to support the action”) (quoting Hoffman

v. Davis , 100 S.W.2d 95 , 96 (Tex. 1937)).

By contrast, in approving

Resolution 2003-93, about which Scarbrough complains, the voters authorized the

funding of the METRO transit system plan as described in the resolution by the

issuance of bonds, notes and other obligations payable from METRO’s sales and

use tax revenue, as well as by “federal capital assistance under applicable

federal law and regulations or the commitment of a substantial amount of

private funds.” See Resolution 2003-93 (proving notice of special referendum

election and including as exhibit Resolution 2003-77, ¶¶ (a), (d), calling

special election). The referendum did

not authorize METRO to use any property taxes to fund the implementation of the

authorized transit plan. Thus,

Scarbrough cannot argue that any of her property taxes are being used to fund

the complained-of activity.

The

“contract with voters” cases cited by Scarbrough similarly fail to accord her

standing. Each of these cases

acknowledged the standing of property-tax payers obligated to pay through their

taxes for bonds issued for public construction projects pursuant to voter

approval in a bond election. Fletcher , 39 S.W.2d at 34 ; Black , 246 S.W. at 80 ; Moore , 200 S.W. at 374–75; Taxpayers for Sensible Priorities , 79

S.W.3d at 676 . Each of these cases

involved a suit brought by property taxpayers who had voted to issue bonds to

be paid for from general tax revenues, including from their property taxes. See

Fletcher , 39 S.W.2d at 32–33 (treating pre-election orders as contract

between commissioners’ court and “electorate entitled to vote at said election”

and overturning dismissal of voter and property-tax payer suit alleging

diversion of proceeds from sale of bonds issued for use on certain public

road); Black , 246 S.W. at 80 (holding

that county commissioners’ court that had adopted order designating roads to be

improved if bond issue carried could not designate other roads to be improved

with proceeds of bonds after election contrary to “the will of those having to

bear the bond burden”); Moore , 200

S.W. at 374–75 (in action by property owners subject to tax for bond issued

pursuant to county bond election, affirming injunction against diversion of

proceeds of bond sales to construction of bridge at different location than

presented in petition for bond election); see

also Taxpayers for Sensible Priorities , 79 S.W.3d at 675 –76 (holding, following sale of general obligation

bonds approved by city voters to develop waterway project and initiation of

work on project, “It is elementary that the proceeds of bonds voted by the

people must be expended for the purposes for which they were voted.”). Scarbrough does not have standing under the

foregoing cases through her payment of property taxes because in each of those

cases the bonds authorized burdened property tax payers, whereas the bonds and

other obligations authorized to be issued by voter approval of Resolution

2003-93 are payable only from METRO’s sales and use tax revenues.

We decline to extend the very

limited taxpayer exception to the general taxpayer standing rule based on the

attenuated relationship between Scarbrough’s tax payments and the funding of

METRO’s transit plan authorized by Resolution 2003-93.

We overrule Scarbrough’s fourth

issue.

D. Standing as an Affected Property Owner

Scarbrough

also impliedly contends that she does have a “personal stake in whether METRO

complies with the Resolution” because METRO intends to construct a portion of

the METRORail “right in front of her home and business.” Her petition alleges concerns over the

disruption caused by the construction and other alleged dangers and

inconveniences. However, Scarbrough

concedes that “it is true that [she] is not alleging or currently able to prove

that METRO has taken her property” and that “a takings claim is not yet ripe.”

Both

ripeness and standing are components of subject-matter jurisdiction. McAllen

Med. Ctr., Inc. v. Cortez , 66 S.W.3d 227, 232, 234 (Tex. 2001). Standing prohibits suits by those who are not

personally aggrieved. DaimlerChrysler Corp. v. Inman , 252

S.W.3d 299, 304 (Tex. 2008). The

ripeness doctrine prohibits suits involving “uncertain or contingent future

events that may not occur as anticipated, or indeed may not occur at all.” Perry

v. Del Rio , 66 S.W.3d 239, 250 (Tex. 2001).

An issue is ripe for decision when at the time a lawsuit is filed the

facts are sufficiently developed “so that an injury has occurred or is likely

to occur, rather than being contingent or remote.” Waco Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Gibson , 22 S.W.3d 849 , 851–52 (Tex. 2000).

There was no evidence at the time

the trial court ruled that METRO’s proposed construction would occur on any

part of Scarbrough’s property or that she would be denied access to or

restricted in the use of her property, nor do Scarbrough’s pleadings assert

such claims. Rather, she concedes that as

of the time of the trial court’s ruling, any claims she might have related to

her use or enjoyment of her property or to a taking by METRO were not ripe for

adjudication. Thus, Scarbrough

acknowledges and we agree that the likelihood of injury to her depended on

factors too speculative to address at the time of the trial court’s ruling and that

any such claims were, therefore, not ripe for decision. See

Perry , 66 S.W.3d at 250 ; Gibson ,

22 S.W.3d at 851–52 .

We

conclude that Scarbrough’s claims based on her status as a property owner were

not ripe at the time of the trial court’s ruling, and thus this ground did not confer

subject-matter jurisdiction on the trial court.

E. Standing Hearing & Opportunity to

Replead

In

her fifth issue, Scarbrough argues that the trial court erred by refusing to

abate its hearing on standing until after a trial on the merits. However, standing is implicit in the trial

court’s subject-matter jurisdiction to consider a case. Tex.

Ass’n of Bus. , 852 S.W.2d at 443 . Thus,

the trial court correctly considered the jurisdictional challenge raised by

METRO before proceeding to a trial on the merits of Scarbrough’s claims. See id.

Scarbrough argues, however, that “[t]he

case at bar demonstrates a legal and factual pattern where the merits are

inextricably intertwined with certain jurisdictional facts.” Specifically, she argues that a jury trial

was necessary to determine standing because the question of standing was

intertwined with the merits of whether the resolution in question authorized

METRO to construct a light rail line along Richmond Avenue. She argues, “This is precisely the type of

situation that the Texas Supreme Court had in mind when it decided the Miranda case: ‘[i]f the evidence creates

a fact question regarding the jurisdictional issue, then the trial court cannot

grant the plea to the jurisdiction, and the fact issue will be resolved by the

fact finder.’” See Miranda , 133 S.W.3d at 227–28.

We disagree.

The alleged contract with the voters

upon which Scarbrough bases her claims consists of Resolution 2003-93, i.e.,

the bond proposition itself, together with its exhibits, which the 2003

referendum approved, not extraneous documents.

See Taxpayers for Sensible

Priorities , 79 S.W.3d at 676 (holding that extraneous documents were not

part of contract with voters created by voter approval of bond proposition). Thus, the ripe issues raised in Scarbrough’s petition

are questions of law regarding the construction of the terms of the Resolution,

not questions of fact regarding the details of the Resolution’s implementation. The facts material to a determination of

Scarbrough’s standing as to her ripe claims are complete, are jurisdictional,

and are largely uncontested. No

additional discovery is necessary to determine Scarbrough’s standing to assert

her ripe claims, hence to decide the plea to the jurisdiction. See Bland , 34 S.W.3d at 555 (holding that we consider relevant evidence submitted

by parties when necessary to resolve jurisdictional issues raised); Miranda , 133 S.W.3d at 227–28 (holding

that i f relevant evidence is undisputed

or fails to raise fact question on jurisdictional issue trial court rules on

plea to jurisdiction as matter of law).

We

overrule Scarbrough’s fifth issue.

In her seventh issue, Scarbrough

argues that even if the trial court correctly determined that she lacked

standing to bring her claim, it erred in refusing to allow her to replead.

If a plaintiff fails to plead

sufficient facts affirmatively demonstrating the trial court’s jurisdiction,

but the pleadings do not affirmatively demonstrate incurable defects in

jurisdiction, he should be afforded the opportunity to amend. County

of Cameron v. Brown , 80 S.W.3d 549, 555 (Tex. 2002).

Here, the challenge to jurisdiction

was not made based on Scarbrough’s pleadings, but on the jurisdictional facts

presented in the trial court. Because

the jurisdictional facts upon which we rely were largely uncontested and

because Scarbrough has otherwise failed to indicate that there is any genuine

fact issue to be resolved, and thus her lack of standing cannot be changed by

merely repleading her case, we need not remand.

See Miranda , 133 S.W.3d at

226–28 (“If the pleadings affirmatively negate the existence of jurisdiction,

then a plea to the jurisdiction may be granted without allowing the plaintiff

an opportunity to amend . . . . [I]f the

relevant evidence is undisputed or fails to raise a fact question on the

jurisdictional issue, the trial court rules on the plea to the jurisdiction as

a matter of law.”).

We

overrule Scarbrough’s seventh issue.

Terms of Judgment

In her sixth issue, Scarbrough

argues that, even if the trial court correctly determined that she lacked

standing to bring her claims, it erred in issuing a take-nothing judgment

against her, rather than dismissing her claims without prejudice. Scarbrough is correct that the trial court’s

lack of jurisdiction prevented it from entering a judgment on the merits. See Tex.

Ass’n of Bus. , 852 S.W.2d at 443 (holding that standing is implicit in

trial court’s subject matter jurisdiction to consider case). However, the trial court’s order here does

not enter a judgment on the merits. Its

order was titled “Order Granting METRO’s Plea to the Jurisdiction and

Dismissing Case.” However, it stated,

“The Court orders that Scarbrough takes nothing because she has no standing to

pursue the claims asserted.” Thus, we

modify the trial court’s order to make it clear that Scarbrough’s claims are

dismissed for lack of jurisdiction and that the trial court’s judgment was not

an adjudication on the merits of any claim she may have over which she is able

to establish subject-matter jurisdiction. [2]

We

sustain Scarbrough’s sixth issue.

Conclusion

We

modify the trial court’s judgment dismissing Scarbrough’s claims to clearly

reflect that her case was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction and affirm it as

modified.

Evelyn

V. Keyes

Justice

Panel

consists of Justices Keyes, Sharp, and Massengale.

[1] We do

not find it necessary to address the impact, if any, of Scarbrough’s vote for

the losing side in the November 2003 referendum.

[2] METRO

argues that Scarbrough failed to preserve this complaint for appellate

review. However, because her complaint

is related to the jurisdiction of the trial court to enter the order, it can be

raised for the first time on appeal. See Tex.

Ass’n of Bus. v. Tex. Air Ctr’l Bd. , 852 S.W.2d 440 , 443–44 (Tex. 1993).

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.