Opinion

Northbay Wellness Group v. Michael Beyries

  • 789 F.3d 956
  • 74 Collier Bankr. Cas. 2d 466
  • 61 Bankr. Ct. Dec. (CRR) 35
  • 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 9397
  • 2015 WL 3529634
Court
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Filed
Jun 5, 2015
Status
Published
Author
Friedland
On the bench
Smith, Nguyen, Friedland
Nature of suit
Bankruptcy
Cited by
52 cases
Authority
More cited than 87.1%

unclean hands “requires balancing the alleged wrongdoing of the plaintiff against that of the defendant, and ‘weighting] the substance of the right asserted by [the] plaintiff against the transgression which, it is contended, serves to foreclose that right.”

How later courts described this case

  • unclean hands “requires balancing the alleged wrongdoing of the plaintiff against that of the defendant, and ‘weighting] the substance of the right asserted by [the] plaintiff against the transgression which, it is contended, serves to foreclose that right.”
  • where the Ninth Circuit 15 reversed the bankruptcy court because it failed to conduct the balancing test and weigh 16 the parties’ respective wrongdoing, which was an error of law that abused discretion
  • bankruptcy court abused its discretion by failing to conduct the balancing test required by doctrine of 27 unclean hands, and instead determining that unclean hands applied solely because the creditor had engaged in marijuana 28 distribution
  • “[A]n action for breach of fiduciary duty is an action in equity[.]”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

FOR PUBLICATION

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

NORTHBAY WELLNESS GROUP, INC., No. 13-17381

a corporation,

Appellant, D.C. No.

3:11-cv-06255-

v. JSW

MICHAEL KENNETH BEYRIES,

Appellee. OPINION

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Northern District of California

Jeffrey S. White, District Judge, Presiding

Argued and Submitted—January 14, 2015

San Francisco California

Filed June 5, 2015

Before: Milan D. Smith, Jr., Jacqueline H. Nguyen,

and Michelle T. Friedland, Circuit Judges.

Opinion by Judge Friedland

2 NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES

SUMMARY *

Bankruptcy

The panel reversed the district court’s affirmance of the

bankruptcy court’s conclusion that a judgment debt was not

nondischargeable under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(4) as a debt for

fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity.

The debt was for the chapter 7 debtor’s breach of

contract and conversion of a legal defense trust fund for

Northbay Wellness Group, operator of a medical marijuana

dispensary. The debtor served on Northbay’s board of

directors and acted as its attorney. The bankruptcy court

held that under the doctrine of unclean hands, Northbay’s

illegal marijuana sales prevented it from obtaining relief

under § 523(a)(4). The panel reversed because the debtor’s

wrongdoing outweighed Northbay’s and because application

of the unclean hands doctrine to absolve an attorney of

responsibility for stealing from his client would be contrary

to the public interest.

*

This summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the court. It has

been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the reader.

NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES 3

COUNSEL

Lisa L. Gygax (argued), Law Offices of Lisa L. Gygax,

Forestville, California, for Appellant.

Jon C. Chandler (argued), David N. Chandler, Sr., and David

N. Chandler, Jr., Law Offices of David N. Chandler, Santa

Rosa, California, for Appellee.

OPINION

FRIEDLAND, Circuit Judge:

Attorney Michael Beyries stole $25,000 from his client,

a medical marijuana dispensary known as Northbay

Wellness Group (“Northbay”). Beyries later filed for

bankruptcy, and Northbay sought a determination that the

$25,000 was a nondischargeable debt. The bankruptcy court

recognized that debts arising from theft are typically

nondischargeable, but it applied the doctrine of unclean

hands to hold that Northbay’s illegal marijuana sales

prevented Northbay from obtaining relief. Because

Beyries’s wrongdoing outweighs Northbay’s, and because

application of the unclean hands doctrine to absolve an

attorney of responsibility for stealing from his client would

be contrary to the public interest, we reverse. 1

1

We address Northbay’s other arguments in a concurrently filed

memorandum disposition.

4 NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES

I. Background

Northbay Wellness Group operated as a California

medical marijuana dispensary in 2005 and 2006 under the

leadership of Dona Frank. Michael Beyries served on

Northbay’s board of directors and received $5,000 per

month to act as its attorney. In addition to the monthly

payments, Northbay entrusted Beyries with at least $25,000

of its marijuana sales revenue as a legal defense trust fund,

for use in the event that a Northbay employee, board

member, or patient was arrested on marijuana-related

charges. Northbay made the trust fund payments to Beyries

in cash. Although Beyries assured Frank that he was

keeping track of the trust fund deposits, Beyries never

provided Frank with a receipt or other record of the funds.

On June 14, 2006, Beyries resigned from his roles at

Northbay “effective immediately” and absconded with the

$25,000 trust fund.

In February 2008, Northbay and Frank sued Beyries in

California state court, alleging, among other things,

conversion of the legal defense trust fund and breach of

contract. A jury found against Beyries on both counts and

awarded Northbay $25,000 for conversion and $319,430.96

for breach of contract, as well as $5,000 in punitive damages.

Beyries filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in September

2010 and listed Northbay as a creditor holding an unsecured,

nonpriority claim for the total $349,430.96 awarded in the

California judgment. Shortly thereafter, Northbay and Frank

commenced an adversary proceeding against Beyries in the

United States Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of

NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES 5

California, alleging that the state-court award was

nondischargeable under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a). 2

After holding a trial, the bankruptcy court concluded that

Beyries’s misappropriation of the $25,000 legal defense

trust fund ordinarily would be nondischargeable pursuant to

§ 523(a)(4) of the Bankruptcy Code, which provides that a

debt “for fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary

capacity” may not be discharged. 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(4).

Nevertheless, the court held that the doctrine of unclean

hands precluded any judgment for Northbay because

2

Specifically, Northbay and Frank relied upon the following

provisions of 11 U.S.C. § 523:

(a) A discharge under section 727, 1141, 1228(a),

1228(b), or 1328(b) of this title does not discharge an

individual debtor from any debt—

....

(2) for money . . . to the extent obtained by—

(A) false pretenses, a false representation, or

actual fraud . . .

....

(4) for fraud or defalcation while acting in a

fiduciary capacity . . .

....

(6) for willful and malicious injury by the debtor

to another entity or to the property of another

entity[.]

6 NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES

Northbay created the trust fund using the proceeds of illegal

marijuana sales. The court accordingly dismissed the

adversary proceeding.

Northbay appealed to the United States District Court for

the Northern District of California, which affirmed the

bankruptcy court’s ruling, agreeing that the doctrine of

unclean hands foreclosed relief. This timely appeal

followed.

II. Standard of Review

We review a district court’s decision in an appeal from

the bankruptcy court de novo. Mano-Y & M, Ltd. v. Field

(In re The Mortgage Store, Inc.), 773 F.3d 990, 994 (9th Cir.

2014). In doing so, we apply the same standard of review to

the bankruptcy court’s decision as did the district court. Id.

We review findings of fact for clear error and conclusions of

law de novo. Id.

We review application of the unclean hands doctrine for

abuse of discretion. Seller Agency Council, Inc. v. Kennedy

Ctr. for Real Estate Educ., Inc., 621 F.3d 981, 986 (9th Cir.

2010). A trial court—here, the bankruptcy court—“abuses

its discretion if it does not apply the correct law or if it rests

its decision on a clearly erroneous finding of material fact.”

Jeff D. v. Otter, 643 F.3d 278, 283 (9th Cir. 2011) (internal

quotation marks omitted).

III. Unclean Hands

A plaintiff asking a court for equitable relief “must come

with clean hands.” Johnson v. Yellow Cab Transit Co., 321

U.S. 383, 387 (1944). Specifically, the doctrine of unclean

hands requires that a plaintiff “shall have acted fairly and

NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES 7

without fraud or deceit as to the controversy in issue.”

Ellenburg v. Brockway, Inc., 763 F.2d 1091, 1097 (9th Cir.

1985). Because bankruptcy courts are courts of equity,

Young v. United States, 535 U.S. 43, 50 (2002), a plaintiff

deemed to have unclean hands cannot obtain a judgment of

nondischargeability. See Republic of Rwanda v. Uwimana

(In re Uwimana), 274 F.3d 806, 810 (4th Cir. 2001) (“A

plaintiff with unclean hands is not entitled to relief from a

court of equity in the form of an order denying the

dischargeability of debt.” (internal quotation marks

omitted)), abrogated on other grounds by Bullock v.

BankChampaign, N.A., 133 S. Ct. 1754, 1758–59 (2013). 3

The Supreme Court has emphasized, however, that the

doctrine of unclean hands “does not mean that courts must

always permit a defendant wrongdoer to retain the profits of

his wrongdoing merely because the plaintiff himself is

possibly guilty of transgressing the law.” Yellow Cab, 321

U.S. at 387. Rather, determining whether the doctrine of

unclean hands precludes relief requires balancing the alleged

wrongdoing of the plaintiff against that of the defendant, and

“weigh[ing] the substance of the right asserted by [the]

3

Federal law governs whether nondischargeability is barred by

unclean hands. See Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279, 283–84 (1991)

(“The validity of a creditor’s claim is determined by rules of state law.

Since 1970, however, the issue of nondischargeability has been a matter

of federal law governed by the terms of the Bankruptcy Code.” (citation

and footnote omitted)); Shaver v. Shaver, 736 F.2d 1314, 1316 (9th Cir.

1984) (“Because of the federal interests reflected in the Bankruptcy Act,

the courts look to federal law to determine whether an obligation is . . .

nondischargeable.” (internal quotation marks omitted)).

8 NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES

plaintiff against the transgression which, it is contended,

serves to foreclose that right.” Republic Molding Corp. v.

B.W. Photo Utils., 319 F.2d 347, 350 (9th Cir. 1963). In

addition, “the clean hands doctrine should not be strictly

enforced when to do so would frustrate a substantial public

interest.” EEOC v. Recruit U.S.A., Inc., 939 F.2d 746, 753

(9th Cir. 1991). 4

The bankruptcy court failed to conduct the required

balancing, instead concluding solely from the fact that

Northbay had engaged in wrongful activity that the doctrine

of unclean hands applied. In so doing, the bankruptcy court

made an error of law, and thus abused its discretion.

Had the bankruptcy court weighed the parties’ respective

wrongdoing, it necessarily would have concluded that

Beyries’s wrongdoing outweighed Northbay’s, both as to

harm caused to each other and as to harm caused to the

public.

Beyries was on Northbay’s board of directors and

partnered in Northbay’s business, so he was as responsible

as Northbay for its illegal marijuana sales. That illegal

4

In EEOC, we upheld an injunction despite the plaintiff agency’s

wrongdoing because denying the injunction “would disserve the public

interest in eliminating age, sex, and race discrimination in employment

and would punish the innocent victims of discrimination for the errors of

the EEOC.” 939 F.2d at 754. The defendant corporation’s wrongdoing

in engaging in employment discrimination was a greater wrong than the

agency’s alleged violation of Title VII’s confidentiality provisions. Id.

at 752–53.

NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES 9

activity must be attributed to both parties in the weighing of

wrongdoing, so it does not tip the balance in either direction.

The bankruptcy court appears to have believed that

Northbay’s use of cash to create the trust fund, and its failure

to carefully count and document that cash, were additional

forms of wrongdoing by Northbay. But Northbay’s use of

cash is unsurprising given that, until February 2014, the

federal government had not authorized banks to do business

with marijuana sellers in states that had legalized marijuana

sales. 5 Northbay’s use of cash was (at the time) part and

parcel to conducting illegal marijuana sales, which, as

discussed, was wrongdoing attributable to Beyries as well.

And to the extent that no one documented the exact cash

deposits, it was Beyries’s responsibility to maintain those

records. See Cal. Rules of Prof’l Conduct R. 4-100(B)(3)

(2013) (requiring that members of the California bar

“[m]aintain complete records of all funds, securities, and

other properties of a client coming into the possession of the

member or law firm and render appropriate accounts to the

client regarding them”). Thus, if relevant to the balance of

wrongdoing at all, Beyries’s failure to properly account for

his client’s money weighs against Beyries.

On top of the illegal activity shared with Northbay,

Beyries is also responsible for much more. Beyries stole

5

See Treas. Guidance FIN-2014-G001 (Feb. 14, 2014); Dep’t of

Justice, Memorandum for All United States Attorneys, Guidance

Regarding Marijuana Related Financial Crimes (Feb. 14, 2014),

available at http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/usao-wdwa/

legacy/2014/02/14/DAG%20Memo%20-%20Guidance%20Regarding

%20Marijuana%20Related%20Financial%20Crimes%202%2014%201

4%20%282%29.pdf.

10 NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES

$25,000 from his client. A lawyer’s “[m]isappropriation of

a client’s property is a gross violation of general morality

likely to undermine public confidence in the legal profession

and therefore merits severe punishment.” Greenbaum v.

State Bar, 544 P.2d 921, 928 (Cal. 1976) (in bank) (internal

quotation marks omitted). As the California Supreme Court

has emphasized, theft from a client is “an offense which

involves moral turpitude and clearly warrants disbarment in

the absence of extenuating circumstances.” Persion v. State

Bar, 509 P.2d 524, 527 (Cal. 1973) (in bank) (internal

quotation marks omitted); see also Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code

§ 6106 (“The commission of any act involving moral

turpitude, dishonesty or corruption . . . constitutes a cause for

disbarment or suspension.”). Indeed, the California State

Bar disbarred Beyries because of the very conduct at issue

here. See In re Michael Kenneth Beyries, Case No. 11-O-

15899-PEM, at 3–6 (State Bar Ct. Cal. Sept. 25, 2014),

available at http://members.calbar.ca.gov/courtDocs/11-O-

15899-3.pdf. In the balance of wrongdoing, Beyries thus

fares much worse than Northbay. 6

Allowing Beyries to avoid through bankruptcy his

responsibility for misappropriating his client’s money would

undermine the public interest in holding attorneys to high

6

The Seventh Circuit has likewise concluded that theft may be a

greater wrong than illegal drug sales for purposes of applying the

doctrine of unclean hands. In Kaye v. Rose (In re Rose), 934 F.2d 901

(7th Cir. 1991) (per curiam), the Seventh Circuit held that the unclean

hands doctrine did not prevent the plaintiff from enforcing a judgment

requiring the return of stolen funds, even though the plaintiff may have

acquired the stolen funds through illegal drug sales. Id. at 904 n.4.

NORTHBAY WELLNESS V. BEYRIES 11

ethical standards. 7 Recognizing the critical importance of

enforcing lawyers’ obligations to their clients, we previously

have held that “[w]hen a lawyer has by immoral or illegal

conduct violated his professional obligations to his client, an

action by the client to recover the lawyer’s fee will not be

barred on the lawyer’s plea that the client also engaged in

immoral or illegal conduct.” Estrada v. Speno & Cohen, 244

F.3d 1050, 1061 n.1 (9th Cir. 2001) (internal quotation

marks and citation omitted). We similarly now hold that the

doctrine of unclean hands cannot prevent recovery of funds

stolen from a client by his or her lawyer.

IV. Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, the bankruptcy court abused

its discretion by applying the doctrine of unclean hands to

bar Northbay’s request for a judgment of

nondischargeability.

REVERSED and REMANDED.

7

Because an action for breach of fiduciary duty is an action in equity,

see Stebbins v. Crocker Citizens Nat’l Bank (In re Ahlswede), 516 F.2d

784, 788 (9th Cir. 1975), extending the doctrine of unclean hands to

situations like that at issue here would not only allow lawyers to

discharge debts arising from thefts from clients, but could also block

wronged clients’ suits against their lawyers for breaches of fiduciary

duties.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.