Opinion

Young v. Mathews Trucking Corp.

  • 383 Pa. 464
  • 119 A.2d 239
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Jan 3, 1956
Status
Published
Author
Arnold
On the bench
Stern, Stearns, Jones, Bell, Musmanno, Arnold
Cited by
21 cases
Authority
More cited than 94.6%

The opinion

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Arnold,

TMs was a petition to strike off a judgment entered by default. It necessarily had to do with the regularity of the record under admitted facts, and could not be based upon any equities of the situation. The court declined to strike off the judgment but opened it, and the plaintiffs appealed.

This appeal is by the plaintiffs and not by the defendant, and there is not before this Court the validity of the ruling of the court below refusing to strike off the judgment:

Bowser v. Citizens Light, Heat & Power Company,

267 Pa. 483, 489 , 110 A. 372 ;

Miller v. Wayne Title & Trust Company,

154 Pa. Superior Ct. 329, 338 , 35 A. 2d 786 .

Without the consent or even the knowledge of the parties, the court below converted the rule to strike into a rule to open, and thereupon made the rule absolute. This was error:

Hamborsky v. Magyar Presbyterian Church (No.1),

78 Pa. Superior Ct. 519 . See also

Nixon v. Nixon,

329 Pa. 256, 263 , 198 A. 154 .

Before the court could open the judgment it was necessary for the petition to set forth (1) due diligence;

*466

(2) the grounds for opening the judgment; and (3) the existence of a meritorious defense, by averring the facts upon which the meritorious defense is based:

Planters Nut and Chocolate Company v. Brown-Murray Co., Inc.,

128 Pa. Superior Ct. 239, 244 , 193 A. 381 . See also

Britton v. Continental Mining and Smelting Corporation,

366 Pa. 82, 84 , 76 A. 2d 625 .

In addition, the appellee in the case at bar entered only a qualified appearance, and to open the judgment he must first submit himself to the jurisdiction of the court.

As was done in

Rome Sales and Service Station v. Finch,

120 Pa. Superior Ct. 402, 404 , 183 A. 54 , we make the following order:

Order reversed, without prejudice to the appellee to present in 20 days a petition to the court below to open said judgment; that court to dispose of the same after taking whatever testimony may be necessary.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.