Opinion

Buckner v. Astrue

  • 646 F.3d 549
  • 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 14727
  • 2011 WL 2803017
Court
Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
Filed
Jul 19, 2011
Status
Published
Author
Smith
On the bench
Wollman, Loken, Smith
Cited by
613 cases
Authority
More cited than 98.9%

finding the ALJ did not err in its conclusion that Plaintiff’s “‘sporadic’ work history prior to his alleged disability date ‘indicates that he was not strongly motivated to engage in meaningful productive activity even prior to the alleged onset of disability and weighs against his credibility in assigning reasons for not working.’”

How later courts described this case

  • finding the ALJ did not err in its conclusion that Plaintiff’s “‘sporadic’ work history prior to his alleged disability date ‘indicates that he was not strongly motivated to engage in meaningful productive activity even prior to the alleged onset of disability and weighs against his credibility in assigning reasons for not working.’”
  • stating remand was not required when the ALJ failed to expressly address the claimant’s girlfriend’s statement because the evidence that discredited the claimant’s claims also discredited the girlfriend’s statement, and the claimant’s representations also contradicted his girlfriend’s statement
  • holding that a separate finding concerning the claimant’s girlfriend’s testimony was not necessary because the girlfriend’s testimony was inconsistent with the same evidence that the ALJ cited when evaluating the claimant’s allegations
  • holding that, even if the ALJ did not explicitly evaluate a third party statement, remand is not required where the same evidence that the ALJ used to discredit the claimant’s claims also discredits the third party’s statement.

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT

___________

No. 10-1524

___________

Brian Buckner, *

*

Appellant, *

* Appeal from the United States

v. * District Court for the

* Western District of Missouri.

Michael J. Astrue, Commissioner *

of Social Security, *

*

Appellee. *

___________

Submitted: January 13, 2011

Filed: July 19, 2011

___________

Before WOLLMAN, LOKEN, and SMITH, Circuit Judges.

___________

SMITH, Circuit Judge.

Brian Buckner appeals the district court's1 judgment upholding the

Commissioner of Social Security's ("Commissioner") denial of his application for

disability insurance and supplemental security income (SSI) benefits, under Titles II

and XVI of the Social Security Act (SSA). Buckner argues that the administrative law

judge (ALJ) (1) erroneously determined that Buckner's mental

impairments—specifically, his depression and anxiety—were not severe; (2)

1

The Honorable Ortrie D. Smith, United States District Judge for the Western

District of Missouri.

inadequately evaluated the credibility of Buckner and Buckner's girlfriend; and (3)

based his decision on an improperly phrased hypothetical question to the vocational

expert (VE). For the following reasons, we affirm.

I. Background

In Buckner's application for disability and SSI benefits, he alleged a disability

beginning on August 29, 2005, at age 33. In his application, he stated that he could not

work full time due to hypertension, sleep apnea, restless leg syndrome, headaches,

anxiety, emotional problems, and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). Buckner

has a high school diploma but no further education. He previously worked as a

warehouse worker, a milker on a dairy farm, a nursing assistant, and a taxi cab driver.

A. Medical History

Buckner made several visits to different medical providers between April 2005

and October 2007. These visits were not directly related to his application for

disability and SSI benefits, but they were included in the administrative record. The

conditions documented by these providers are summarized below.

1. Hypertension

Buckner began receiving medication for hypertension in April 2005. At that

time, his blood pressure measured 199/121 and 180/101. He reported smoking 1.5

packs of cigarettes per day. On May 27, 2005, Buckner sought medical treatment and

reported that he had not taken his hypertension medicine for two days, and he reported

smoking two packs of cigarettes per day. His blood pressure measured 175/123,

154/108, and 160/105. He was instructed to take his hypertension medication.

With some exceptions, Buckner's hypertension generally improved over the

course of 17 measurements in the next two years. Starting with a high of 180/132 in

September 2005, Buckner's regular blood pressure readings steadily dropped, reaching

-2-

a low of 122/83 in October 2006. After that point, his blood pressure briefly spiked

but ultimately returned to 150/90 in October 2007.

2. Chest Pain

At Buckner's May 2005 examination, a chest x-ray revealed "[q]uestionable

mild cardiomegaly,"2 which the doctor indicated "may be an artifact of the portable

[x-ray] technique and the patient's body habitus."

Buckner reported a history of chest pain at his September 1, 2005 examination.

An x-ray revealed "minimal old pulmonary granulomatous disease"3 and a "borderline

cardiac size." An electrocardiogram (EKG) revealed sinus bradycardia4 but was

otherwise normal.

On September 12, 2005, Buckner underwent a myocardial perfusion rest and

stress test involving a "two-day treadmill exam." An EKG indicated a normal resting

heart rate. With stress, Buckner had no chest pain. The examination revealed "[n]o

evidence of myocardial scarring or of stress induced myocardial ischemia,"5 "[m]ild

inferior hypokinesis,"6 and a normal "left ventricular ejection fraction" of 55 percent.

2

Cardiomegaly is an "[e]nlargement of the heart." Stedman's Medical Dictionary

313 (28th ed. 2006).

3

This disease is characterized by small or granular "nodular inflammatory

lesions" in the lungs. See id. at 831–32.

4

Bradycardia is a "[s]lowness of the heartbeat." Id. at 249.

5

Myocardial ischemia involves "inadequate circulation of blood to the

myocardium," the middle layer of the heart. Id. at 1001, 1271.

6

Hypokinesis refers to "[d]iminished or slow movement." Id. at 934.

-3-

From September 2005 to October 2006, all of Buckner's cardiovascular

examinations were normal. On October 10, 2007, Buckner went to the emergency

room, complaining of intermittent chest pain. By the time he was examined, he

reported no pain. Two days later, he had a normal cardiovascular examination.

3. Other Physical Conditions

Buckner suffered from a variety of other physical maladies, varying in their

duration and severity. For example, Buckner's medical records with an advanced

practice nurse indicated an ongoing problem with obesity and frequent complaints of

headaches, nasal congestion, coughing, sneezing, restless leg syndrome, and tooth

pain. Nevertheless, all of Buckner's visits to the advanced practice nurse revealed

normal musculoskeletal, motor/sensory, strength, and sensation examinations.

The advanced practice nurse also diagnosed Buckner with GERD on May 27,

2005, for which she prescribed Zantac. In September 2005, Buckner reported that the

Zantac helped "a lot," and in October 2006, he reported that his GERD was "great"

while on Zantac.

On February 20, 2006, Buckner went to the emergency room, complaining of

neck and back pain due to a motor-vehicle accident. An x-ray of his cervical spine

revealed no fractures or subluxation7 but could not exclude "[d]isc protrusion." An x-

ray of his lumbar spine revealed "a questionable fracture" of the L2 vertebra, but the

report stated it was "more likely . . . an artifact of overlapping soft tissues."

4. Depression and Anxiety

At an examination on September 1, 2005, Buckner reported having anger

problems, and the advanced practice nurse diagnosed him with depression. He had

normal psychological examinations on September 6 and 12, 2005. On September 15,

7

A subluxation is "[a]n incomplete . . . dislocation." Id. at 1856.

-4-

2005, he returned to the advanced practice nurse and reported that his medication,

Zoloft, was helping with his depression. The advanced practice nurse indicated that

Buckner's psychological examination was normal.

On September 29, 2005, Buckner told the advanced practice nurse that the

Zoloft was not helping with his depression. Nevertheless, the advanced practice nurse

indicated that Buckner's psychological examination was normal. During visits in

October, November, and December 2005 and March 2006, the advanced practice

nurse documented normal psychological examinations. In April 2006, Buckner again

reported to the advanced practice nurse that Zoloft was not helping, but Buckner's

psychological examination was normal. The advanced practice nurse documented

normal psychological examinations for Buckner in October and November 2006.

B. Administrative History

1. Function Report

On October 27, 2005, in connection with his August 29, 2005 application for

disability and SSI benefits, Buckner completed a function report indicating how his

mental and physical conditions limited his daily activities and abilities. He indicated

that he could care for his son and girlfriend. He also stated that he could take care of

his personal needs and grooming but would "sometimes" need reminders from his

girlfriend for grooming and taking medication.

Buckner reported that he could clean and do "some yard work," although he

noted that he would have to "sit down about every 10 minutes" because of chest pain.

He stated that he went outside almost every day but usually could not drive because

of his medication. He indicated that he could go shopping and manage his own

money. He listed watching television, playing on the computer, and playing sports as

hobbies, although he stated that he could not play sports "very often" because of pain

in his legs (specifically, his restless leg syndrome). He also stated that he went to

church on a regular basis.

-5-

In describing his abilities, Buckner claimed that his conditions affected his

ability to lift, stand, climb stairs, see, remember, concentrate, and get along with

others. He stated that he could walk 100 to 400 feet without resting but would require

20 to 30 minutes rest before resuming. He reported having panic attacks.

2. Dr. Sutton's Psychological Report

On January 18, 2006, Geoffrey Sutton, Ph.D., a licensed pyschologist,

completed a "Psychiatric Review Technique" form. Dr. Sutton confirmed that

Buckner's medical records showed that Buckner was suffering from depression and

anxiety, concluding that "the allegations for mental disorders are partially credible."

He concluded that Buckner's mental impairments did not impair Buckner's activities

of daily living; mildly limited his ability to maintain social functioning; mildly limited

his ability to maintain concentration, persistence, and pace; and did not result in any

episodes of decompensation. Ultimately, Dr. Sutton concluded that Buckner's mental

impairments were not severe.

3. Disability Questionnaire

Buckner completed a questionnaire on December 12, 2007, in which he stated

that an ordinary day involves watching television, walking outside for a little while,

and resting. He stated that he can stand no longer than 30 minutes at a time, walk short

distances, lift light weights, and use his hands and arms. He also indicated that he can

sit if he frequently changes positions. Finally, he reported being able to mow "small

areas" of grass "with breaks" and to cook and wash dishes only if he needs to and

"with breaks."

4. Dr. Hwang's Physical Evaluation

At the request of Buckner's attorney, Yung Hwang, M.D., examined Buckner

on December 28, 2007. Dr. Hwang's report noted Buckner's history of hypertension,

heart problems, restless leg syndrome, and headaches, which Dr. Hwang stated could

be managed effectively with Buckner's prescribed medications. He noted that Buckner

-6-

had mild depression and anxiety not being treated with medication. He explained that

Buckner "is mentally clear" and "has been evaluated for depression and anxiety but

comprehends very well and understands with no difficulty and is capable of tending

to his affairs with no assistance."

Dr. Hwang also noted Buckner's obesity and his lower back pain, and he

reported that Buckner had full range of motion in his upper extremities (shoulders,

elbows, wrists, hands, and fingers) and lower extremities (hips, ankles, and joints). Dr.

Hwang indicated that Buckner had "full grip strength," could "walk 20 minutes before

he becomes short of breath, stand[] 30 minutes without pain, lift 50 pounds

occasionally[,] and sit for long periods."

Dr. Hwang reported the following limitations in a "Medical Source Statement

(Physical)." He stated that Buckner could (1) lift objects weighing no more than 50

pounds; (2) stand or walk for four hours in an eight-hour day, up to 30 minutes at one

time; and (3) sit with normal breaks for four hours in an eight-hour day, up to 30

minutes at one time. Dr. Hwang also reported mild limitations in Buckner's ability to

(1) "push/pull" using his upper and lower extremities, (2) reach, and (3) handle. Dr.

Hwang further stated that Buckner could never climb or be exposed to heights,

temperature extremes, dust, fumes, or vibration. Finally, Dr. Hwang reported that, on

average, Buckner's impairments would force him to be absent from work "[f]our plus

times" each month.

5. First Administrative Hearing

The ALJ held Buckner's first administrative hearing on January 30, 2008. Nine

days before the hearing, Buckner's girlfriend submitted a written statement stating that

Buckner runs out of breath easily, is "always tired," and has no energy. She further

stated that Buckner cannot work and cannot watch the children when she leaves the

house.

-7-

Buckner testified at the hearing. He stated that he cannot work because of his

hypertension. He described having two to three "bad days"each week, where he gets

migraine headaches so intense that he isolates himself in his bedroom without any

light. He claimed that he has panic attacks when he leaves the house and interacts with

other people. He also stated that he has "throbbing" lower back pain if he sits or stands

in one place for too long. He testified that he can play with the children for two to

three hours at a time, "rolling on the floor a little bit maybe and walking with them

just a short distance around the yard." He also said that he helps around the house and

occasionally goes fishing.

6. Dr. Corsolini's Physical Evaluation

At the ALJ's request, Thomas B. Corsolini, M.D., evaluated Buckner on

February 18, 2008. Dr. Corsolini reported that Buckner had full range of motion in his

upper and lower extremities and in "all joints in the cervical spine." Buckner could

"demonstrate a full squat independently" and had "excellent" balance and

coordination. Dr. Corsolini concluded that Buckner's hypertension was "currently

adequately treated," and Dr. Corsolini recommended no physical limitations.

7. Second Administrative Hearing

Buckner testified again at a second administrative hearing on July 21, 2008. He

stated that he was no longer living with his girlfriend.

A VE also testified in response to hypothetical questions posed by the ALJ and

Buckner's attorney. The ALJ asked the VE to consider "a hypothetical person of Mr.

Buckner's age, education and work history" with the limitations described in Dr.

Hwang's report, except for the limitations on reaching, handling, and being absent

from work four times per month. The VE testified that a person with those limitations

could perform "sedentary, unskilled work" as a credit card clerk or a final assembler,

jobs which existed in significant numbers in the national economy. Buckner's attorney

asked the VE to consider the same hypothetical person, including all of the limitations

-8-

noted in Dr. Hwang's report. The VE testified that such a person would not be able to

find work.

8. ALJ's Decision

The ALJ issued a written decision denying Buckner's application for SSI and

disability benefits, concluding that Buckner was "not disabled" within the meaning of

the SSA. The ALJ found that Buckner had the following "severe" impairments:

hypertension, morbid obesity, degenerative disc disease of the lumbar spine, and mild

cardiomegaly.

The ALJ found that Buckner's depression was "not severe." In reaching this

conclusion, the ALJ explained that "[b]ecause [Buckner's] medically determinable

mental impairment causes no more than 'mild' limitation in any of the first three

functional areas [activities of daily living; social functioning; and concentration,

persistence, or pace] and 'no' limitation in the fourth area [episodes of decompensation

of extended duration]," the depression was not severe under 20 C.F.R. §§

404.1520a(d)(1) and 416.920a(d)(1).

In assessing Buckner's residual functional capacity (RFC), the ALJ accepted all

of Dr. Hwang's limitations, except for the limitations on handling, reaching, and being

absent from work four times per month. The ALJ stated that Dr. Hwang did not

explain his reasons for reaching these conclusions, and Dr. Hwang's own

report—along with the other medical evidence of record—did not support, or even

contradicted, Dr. Hwang's conclusions.

The ALJ expressly found that Buckner's statements about "the intensity,

persistence and limiting effects of his symptoms are not credible to the extent they are

inconsistent with the [RFC]." The ALJ based this credibility finding on several

factors. First, Buckner's claims were inconsistent with the medical evidence and his

own statements in the function report, the disability questionnaire, and at the

-9-

hearings—all of which indicated that Buckner "engage[d] in a range of daily activities

inconsistent with" his claimed symptoms and limitations. The ALJ also noted that

Buckner's hypertension was "not always controlled by medication," but Buckner

"ha[d] apparently made no effort to improve his blood pressure reading by losing

weight or eliminating tobacco use." Further, he had not reported any of the alleged

symptoms of hypertension to his doctors. Finally, the ALJ noted that Buckner's

sporadic work history prior to his alleged disability date "indicates that he was not

strongly motivated to engage in productive activity," which weighed against his

credibility.

Given these findings, the ALJ found that Buckner was unable to perform any

of his past relevant work. Based on the VE's testimony, however, the ALJ concluded

that Buckner could perform sedentary, unskilled work as a credit card clerk or a final

assembler, jobs which exist in significant numbers in the national economy.

Therefore, the ALJ found that Buckner was not disabled.

Buckner requested review of the ALJ's decision from the SSA's Appeals

Council. On November 25, 2008, the Appeals Council denied Buckner's request,

making the ALJ's decision the final decision of the Commissioner.

Buckner thereafter filed a complaint in the district court, seeking review of the

Commissioner's final decision. The district court affirmed the Commissioner's

decision, concluding that substantial evidence supported the determination that

Buckner was not disabled.

II. Discussion

We review de novo the district court's decision affirming the ALJ's denial of

social security benefits. Hulsey v. Astrue, 622 F.3d 917, 922 (8th Cir. 2010). In doing

so, we will consider whether the ALJ's decision "is supported by substantial evidence

on the record as a whole." Id. "Substantial evidence means less than a preponderance,

-10-

but sufficient evidence that a reasonable person would find adequate to support the

decision." Id. "We will not disturb the denial of benefits so long as the ALJ's decision

falls within the available zone of choice. An ALJ's decision is not outside the zone of

choice simply because we might have reached a different conclusion had we been the

initial finder of fact." Bradley v. Astrue, 528 F.3d 1113, 1115 (8th Cir. 2008) (internal

quotations and citations omitted). "Rather, if, after reviewing the record, we find that

it is possible to draw two inconsistent positions from the evidence and one of those

positions represents the Commissioner's findings, we must affirm the decision of the

Commissioner." Young v. Apfel, 221 F.3d 1065, 1068 (8th Cir. 2000) (internal

quotations, alteration, and citations omitted).

A. Severity of Mental Impairments

Buckner first contends that the ALJ's finding that his mental

impairments—specifically, his depression and anxiety—were not severe was not

supported by substantial evidence on the record as a whole. In particular, Buckner

asserts that the ALJ ignored evidence of Buckner's treatment for depression, Buckner's

complaints that the treatment was not effective, and Buckner's testimony that he

sometimes isolated himself due to the depression. Moreover, Buckner notes that Dr.

Sutton's psychological evaluation "concluded that [Buckner] would have mild

difficulties maintaining social functioning and concentration, persistence, and pace."

Because these symptoms have "more than a minimal impact" on Buckner's ability to

do basic work activities, Buckner maintains that the ALJ was compelled to find that

his mental impairments were severe.

We disagree and hold that substantial evidence on the record as a whole

supports the ALJ's finding that Buckner's mental impairments were not severe. First,

in determining whether a claimant's mental impairments are "severe," the regulations

require the ALJ to consider "four broad functional areas in which [the ALJ] will rate

the degree of [the claimant's] functional limitation: Activities of daily living; social

-11-

functioning; concentration, persistence, or pace; and episodes of decompensation." 20

C.F.R. §§ 404.1520a(c)(3), 416.920a(c)(3). The regulations further provide:

If we rate the degree of your limitation in the first three functional areas

as "none" or "mild" and "none" in the fourth area, we will generally

conclude that your impairment(s) is not severe, unless the evidence

otherwise indicates that there is more than a minimal limitation in your

ability to do basic work activities.

Id. §§ 404.1520a(d)(1), 416.920a(d)(1). Here, Dr. Sutton, a licensed psychologist,

concluded in his report that Buckner's depression and anxiety did not impair his

activities of daily living; mildly limited his ability to maintain social functioning;

mildly limited his ability to maintain concentration, persistence, and pace; and did not

result in any episodes of decompensation. As a result, the ALJ found that Buckner's

depression and anxiety "causes no more than 'mild' limitation in any of the first 3

functional areas and 'no' limitation in the fourth area." Thus, pursuant to the

regulations, the ALJ had substantial evidence supporting a conclusion that Buckner's

depression and anxiety were "not severe."

Buckner does not challenge either Dr. Sutton's or the ALJ's findings in these

four functional areas. Instead, he argues that, despite these findings, the evidence

showed that his depression and anxiety had "more than a minimal impact" on his

ability to do basic work activities. To the contrary, the evidence in the administrative

record shows that Buckner's depression and anxiety resulted in very few limitations.

Although Buckner did complain to the advanced practice nurse on two occasions in

2005 and 2006 that his medication was not helping with his depression, he had several

normal psychological evaluations throughout this same time period. He also had

several visits to the advanced practice nurse where he did not raise any concerns about

his depression or the ineffectiveness of his medication. Likewise, Dr. Hwang noted

that Buckner could effectively manage his depression and anxiety without medication

or other assistance. While Buckner testified at the first administrative hearing that his

-12-

anxiety sometimes forced him to isolate himself in his bedroom, he also attributed

those incidents to headaches caused by his hypertension. In any case, as discussed

infra, the ALJ properly discounted Buckner's credibility regarding his claims of severe

impairments. In sum, although Buckner was diagnosed with depression and anxiety,

substantial evidence on the record supports the ALJ's finding that his depression and

anxiety was not severe. See Trenary v. Bowen, 898 F.2d 1361, 1364 (8th Cir. 1990)

("Depression . . . is not necessarily disabling.").

B. Credibility Assessments

Next, Buckner argues that the ALJ erred by not properly assessing his

credibility and by not expressly addressing the credibility of his girlfriend's written

statement. First, Buckner asserts that the ALJ improperly evaluated his credibility by

(1) failing to "evaluate the dosage, effectiveness, and side effects of Buckner's

prescription medications"; (2) improperly assessing Buckner's daily activities; and (3)

"failing to consider that another agency found . . . Buckner disabled." Second,

Buckner asserts that the ALJ must specifically discuss and express the credibility of

any third-party statements regarding a claimant's condition. Smith v. Heckler, 735 F.2d

312, 317 (8th Cir. 1984); 20 C.F.R. § 404.1529(c)(3). He maintains that the ALJ's

failure to discuss his girlfriend's statement was "clear legal error" requiring a remand.

See Willcockson v. Astrue, 540 F.3d 878, 880 (8th Cir. 2008).

1. Buckner

This court has long required an ALJ to consider the following factors when

evaluating a claimant's credibility:

(1) the claimant's daily activities; (2) the duration, intensity, and

frequency of pain; (3) the precipitating and aggravating factors; (4) the

dosage, effectiveness, and side effects of medication; (5) any functional

restrictions; (6) the claimant's work history; and (7) the absence of

objective medical evidence to support the claimant's complaints.

-13-

Moore v. Astrue, 572 F.3d 520, 524 (8th Cir. 2009) (citing Finch v. Astrue, 547 F.3d

933, 935 (8th Cir.2008); Polaski v. Heckler, 739 F.2d 1320, 1322 (8th Cir.1984)).

ALJs "need not explicitly discuss each Polaski factor." Goff v. Barnhart, 421 F.3d

785, 791 (8th Cir. 2005) (quotation and citation omitted). Although "an ALJ may not

discount a claimant's allegations of disabling pain solely because the objective medical

evidence does not fully support them," the ALJ may find that these allegations are not

credible "if there are inconsistencies in the evidence as a whole." Id. at 792 (internal

quotations and citations omitted). We will defer to the ALJ's credibility finding if the

ALJ "explicitly discredits a claimant's testimony and gives a good reason for doing

so." Wildman v. Astrue, 596 F.3d 959, 968 (8th Cir. 2010) (quotation and citation

omitted).

Here, the ALJ expressly found that Buckner's "statements concerning the

intensity, persistence and limiting effects of his symptoms" were not credible.

Although the ALJ did not explicitly cite Polaski, he clearly considered the following

factors: Buckner's daily activities, the effectiveness of his medication and other

treatments, his work history, and the absence of objective medical evidence to support

his complaints. Regarding Buckner's daily activities, the ALJ noted that in Buckner's

disability questionnaire and his hearing testimony, Buckner stated that

he was able to care for his son and his girlfriend (who was frequently ill),

do house-cleaning, do some yard work, leave his residence nearly every

day, ride in a car, go out alone, go shopping in stores, manage his

finances, use a computer, play sports occasionally, socialize and play

games with friends or family members and attend religious services.

The ALJ found these statements to be inconsistent with Buckner's claims of disabling

pain. Next, regarding Buckner's medication and treatment, the ALJ stated that

Buckner's "hypertension is not always controlled by medication, but [he] has

apparently made no effort to improve his blood pressure reading by losing weight or

eliminating tobacco use." Additionally, the ALJ found that Buckner's "sporadic" work

-14-

history prior to his alleged disability date "indicates that he was not strongly motivated

to engage in meaningful productive activity even prior to the alleged onset of

disability and weighs against his credibility in assigning reasons for not working."

Finally, the ALJ found that Buckner's complaints were not supported by objective

medical evidence. The ALJ noted that (1) Buckner's back problems were diagnosed

as "mild" and did not warrant further testing or treatment; (2) his depression and

headaches "never required regular psychiatric or psychological treatment[,] . . . and

the record contains minimal documentation of complaints of headaches"; and (3) Dr.

Hwang's examination report indicated that Buckner had full range of motion in all

extremities, no sign of arthritis, full grip strength, and the ability to lift up to 50

pounds occasionally. The ALJ did not err by failing to discuss expressly some of the

other factors, including any side effects from Buckner's medication. See Moore, 572

F.3d at 524. Our review of the ALJ's decision, in light of the entire administrative

record, shows that there were inconsistencies between Buckner's allegations of pain

and the evidence as a whole. See Goff, 421 F.3d at 792 (explaining that "[t]he ALJ

may disbelieve subjective complaints if there are inconsistencies in the evidence as

a whole" (quotation and citation omitted)). As a result, the ALJ did not err in

evaluating Buckner's credibility.8

2. Buckner's Girlfriend

The regulations also provide that the ALJ will "carefully consider any other

information you may submit about your symptoms," including statements "other

persons provide about your pain or other symptoms." 20 C.F.R. § 404.1529(c)(3). The

regulation, however, does not define what is meant by "careful consideration." When

8

The ALJ also did not err by failing to address the fact that Buckner may have

received Medicaid benefits at one time because this evidence, standing alone, does not

indicate whether another agency found Buckner disabled. See 20 C.F.R.

§ 404.1512(b)(5); Mo. Rev. Stat. § 208.151 (listing the types of individuals eligible

for Missouri Medicaid benefits).

-15-

considering the issue, this court has not always insisted that the ALJ explicitly explain

its reasons for discrediting a third-party's statements about the claimant's condition.

In Robinson v. Sullivan, the ALJ explicitly discredited testimony from the

claimant's wife but failed to discuss the reasons for doing so. 956 F.2d 836, 841 (8th

Cir. 1992). We noted that "it is clear that the ALJ specifically addressed [the wife's]

testimony and found it not credible" and that "[t]his finding is supported by the same

evidence that proved [the claimant's] claims not credible." Id. Ultimately, we affirmed

the ALJ, explaining that "[w]hile it is preferable that the ALJ delineate the specific

credibility determinations for each witness, an arguable deficiency in opinion-writing

technique does not require us to set aside an administrative finding when that

deficiency had no bearing on the outcome." Id. (quotation and citation omitted).

Three years later, in Lorenzen v. Chater, we again considered an argument that

the ALJ erred by "fail[ing] to list specific reasons for discrediting the testimony" of

a third party. 71 F.3d 316, 319 (8th Cir. 1995). Nonetheless, we affirmed the ALJ

because "it is evident that most of [the third party's] testimony concerning [the

claimant's] capabilities was discredited by the same evidence that discredits [the

claimant's] own testimony concerning his limitations." Id.

Finally, in Willcockson, we considered an ALJ's failure to consider statements

submitted by the claimant's mother, daughter, and sister. 540 F.3d at 880. We noted

that we could not "determine from the record whether the ALJ overlooked these

statements, gave them some weight, or completely disregarded them." Id. Moreover,

we "question[ed] whether witness statements corroborating a claimant's subjective

complaints can logically be treated as cumulative by assuming that they would have

been rejected for the same reasons that the claimant statements were rejected." Id. at

881. This failure to address the third-party statements—combined with the ALJ's

failure to explain the weight given to a nonexamining consultant's report and his

-16-

insufficient assessment of the claimant's own statements—compelled us to remand the

case. Id. at 880–81.

In the present case, although the ALJ did not expressly address the girlfriend's

statement in his decision, the ALJ's error does not require remand. Unlike the

statements in Robinson, the ALJ did not explicitly address the claims that Buckner's

girlfriend made about Buckner's conditions. Rather, as in Willcockson, we cannot

determine from the record whether the ALJ considered her statements at all. At the

same time, much like the third-party statements Robinson and Lorenzan, the same

evidence that the ALJ referred to in discrediting Buckner's claims also discredits the

girlfriend's claims. Specifically, Buckner's girlfriend stated that Buckner cannot watch

the children when she leaves the house. As noted above, the ALJ observed that

Buckner, in his disability questionnaire and his hearing testimony, "stated that he was

able to care for his son." Buckner's girlfriend also claimed that Buckner could not

work, would run out of breath easily, and had no energy. Although the ALJ did not

address all of these specific claims, the ALJ did find that Buckner's own statements

and hearing testimony "show that he engages in a range of daily activities inconsistent

with his allegation of disabling hypertension, headaches, back pain, hand cramps,

shortness [of] breath, chest pains, depression and anxiety." Finally, the decision here

did not suffer from the other deficiencies noted in Willcockson; most notably, as

discussed supra, the ALJ here did sufficiently assess Buckner's credibility. Thus, we

hold that the ALJ's "arguable deficiency in opinion-writing technique," Robinson, 956

F.2d at 841 (quotation and citation omitted), had no bearing on the outcome of

Buckner's case and does not require remand.

C. Hypothetical Questions to VE

Finally, Buckner argues that the ALJ's finding that Buckner could find

employment as a credit card clerk or a final assembler was not supported by

substantial evidence because it was based on a VE's response to an improperly phrased

hypothetical question. Buckner contends that the ALJ's hypothetical question to the

-17-

VE must include all credible, relevant impairments in order for the VE's response to

qualify as "substantial evidence." See Hunt v. Massanari, 250 F.3d 622, 626 (8th Cir.

2001). In Buckner's case, the ALJ "found that Buckner had mild deficiencies in

maintaining activities of daily living social functioning, and concentration,

persistence, or pace." Despite this fact, the ALJ failed to include these deficiencies in

the hypothetical question to the VE. Moreover, Buckner argues the ALJ failed to

include "the impact of drowsiness as a side effect of Buckner's medications." Thus,

he argues that the VE's testimony cannot provide substantial evidence for the ALJ's

determination that Buckner was not disabled.

The Commissioner responds that the ALJ's hypothetical question to the VE

properly included all of Buckner's "credible limitations." First, the Commissioner

contends that because Buckner's mental impairments were "not severe," the ALJ was

entitled to exclude "any limitation flowing from depression" in the hypothetical

question to the VE. Likewise, the Commissioner asserts that the record did not support

Buckner's claims of drowsiness as a side effect of his medication and that the ALJ

properly excluded it as a possible impairment in the hypothetical question. Because

the ALJ's hypothetical question to the VE properly incorporated all credible

limitations, the Commissioner concludes that the VE's testimony provided substantial

evidence supporting the ALJ's determination that Buckner was not disabled.

"A vocational expert's testimony constitutes substantial evidence when it is

based on a hypothetical that accounts for all of the claimant's proven impairments."

Hulsey, 622 F.3d at 922. But "[w]hen a hypothetical question does not encompass all

relevant impairments, the vocational expert's testimony does not constitute substantial

evidence. Thus, the ALJ's hypothetical question must include those impairments that

the ALJ finds are substantially supported by the record as a whole." Pickney v. Chater,

96 F.3d 294, 296 (8th Cir. 1996) (internal citation omitted). At the same time, we have

recognized that "[t]he hypothetical need not frame the claimant's impairments in the

specific diagnostic terms used in medical reports, but instead should capture the

-18-

concrete consequences of those impairments." Hulsey, 622 F.3d at 922 (quotation and

citation omitted).

For example, we have held that "an ALJ may omit alleged impairments from

a hypothetical question posed to a vocational expert when '[t]here is no medical

evidence that these conditions impose any restrictions on [the claimant's] functional

capabilities'" or "when the record does not support the claimant's contention that his

impairments 'significantly restricted his ability to perform gainful employment.'"

Owen v. Astrue, 551 F.3d 792, 801–02 (8th Cir. 2008) (quoting Haynes v. Shalala, 26

F.3d 812, 815 (8th Cir. 1994); Eurom v. Chater, 56 F.3d 68 (8th Cir. 1995) (per

curiam) (unpublished table opinion)). On at least one occasion, we have held that the

ALJ did not err by excluding the claimant's mental limitations from the hypothetical

questions to the VE, when substantial evidence supported the ALJ's determination that

the claimant's mental limitations were "nonsevere." Jackson v. Apfel, 162 F.3d 533,

538 (8th Cir. 1998).

Here, the ALJ did not explicitly mention Buckner's depression and anxiety in

the hypothetical to the VE. On this record the ALJ did not err. The ALJ did not

entirely discount the credibility of Buckner's claims of depression and anxiety.

However, the ALJ, as explained above, reasonably concluded with substantial

evidence that these impairments were "not severe." This is consistent with our

precedent. See Jackson, 162 F.3d at 538. The ALJ's hypothetical asked the VE to

consider the restrictions noted in Dr. Hwang's report, excluding only Dr. Hwang's

restrictions on reaching, handling, and being absent from work.9 Dr. Hwang's report

did note that Buckner had been diagnosed with depression. Because Dr. Hwang's

Medical Source Statement incorporated all of Buckner's impairments—including

Buckner's depression and anxiety—into Dr. Hwang's recommended limitations, we

9

The ALJ excluded them from the hypothetical because he found that they were

not credible, and Buckner has not challenged the exclusion of these restrictions from

the ALJ's hypothetical to the VE.

-19-

can safely conclude that the ALJ's hypothetical "capture[d] all of the concrete

consequences of those [credible] impairments." Hulsey, 622 F.3d at 922 (emphasis

added). As such, the VE's answer to that hypothetical constitutes substantial evidence

supporting the ALJ's determination that Buckner was not disabled.

III. Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, we hold that substantial evidence on the record as

a whole supports the ALJ's decision. We therefore affirm the judgment of the district

court.

______________________________

-20-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.