Opinion

United States v. Flores

  • 632 F.3d 229
  • 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 1932
  • 2011 WL 309173
Court
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Filed
Jan 31, 2011
Status
Published
Author
Davis
On the bench
Davis, Smith and Dennis, Circuit Judges
Cited by
10,265 cases
Authority
More cited than 99.9%

addressing requirements for an Anders brief

How later courts described this case

  • addressing requirements for an Anders brief

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 1 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT United States Court of Appeals

Fifth Circuit

FILED

January 31, 2011

No. 09-41281 Lyle W. Cayce

Summary Calendar Clerk

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Plaintiff-Appellee

v.

RAMONA FLORES

Defendant-Appellant

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Southern District of Texas

Before DAVIS, SMITH, and DENNIS, Circuit Judges.

W. EUGENE DAVIS, Circuit Judge:

Defendant Ramona Flores appeals after her guilty plea conviction for

being found illegally in the United States after having been previously deported,

in violation of 8 U.S.C. § 1326. Flores’ counsel has filed a motion to withdraw

and a brief that relies on Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738 (1967), stating that

the appeal is without merit. We grant the motion and take this opportunity to

explain what we expect in an Anders brief and why the brief in this case is

sufficient.

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 2 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

I.

Nicaraguan national Ramona Flores pleaded guilty, pursuant to a written

plea agreement, to being found illegally in the U.S. after having been previously

deported, in violation of 8 U.S.C. § 1326. The plea agreement did not contain an

appeal waiver. The factual basis that Flores admitted to be true at

rearraignment stated that she previously was deported from the U.S. on May 10,

2006, and that she was again found inside the U.S. on July 8, 2009. See United

States v. Rojas-Luna, 522 F.3d 502, 504-06 (5th Cir. 2008) (holding that the fact

of removal must be admitted or proven beyond a reasonable doubt).

The PSR calculated Flores’ total offense level at 21. This included a 16-

level increase, pursuant to U.S.S.G. § 2L1.2(b)(1)(A)(ii), because she had

previously been deported following a felony conviction for a crime of violence,

specifically, a December 2000 Florida conviction for aggravated assault with a

deadly weapon. It determined Flores’ criminal history score to be III, subjecting

her to a guidelines range of 46 to 57 months of imprisonment. Flores did not

object to the PSR’s calculations. The district court sentenced her at the low end

of the guidelines range, 46 months, followed by a three-year period of supervised

release. Flores timely appealed.

II.

The Federal Public Defender appointed to represent Flores has filed a

motion for leave to withdraw and an Anders brief. Anders established standards

for a court-appointed attorney who seeks to withdraw from a direct criminal

appeal on the ground that the appeal lacks an issue of arguable merit. After a

“conscientious examination” of the case, the attorney must “request permission

to withdraw” and submit a “brief referring to anything in the record that might

2

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 3 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

arguably support the appeal.” Anders, 386 U.S. at 744. Flores was informed of

counsel’s motion to withdraw but has not filed a response.

At this point our current practice is to examine the brief submitted by

counsel raising anything in the record that might arguably support an appeal,

examine any points raised by the appellant himself, and independently examine

the record, to determine whether counsel has adequately identified all

nonfrivolous issues. We write in this case to signal a change in this court’s

approach to Anders cases.

Our analysis must start with the Supreme Court’s seminal decision in

Anders v. California. In Anders, after the California District Court of Appeal

had appointed counsel to conduct a first appeal to that court from an indigent's

conviction, counsel informed the court by letter that after a study of the record

and consultation with the accused, he had concluded that there was no merit to

the appeal. The court denied the indigent's request for appointment of another

attorney, after which the indigent filed his own brief pro se. The state responded

and the indigent filed a reply brief. The conviction was affirmed. About 6 years

later, the court denied the indigent's application for writ of habeas corpus,

stating that the earlier appeal had been without merit. The Supreme Court of

California later denied without opinion the indigent's petition for habeas corpus.

On certiorari, the Supreme Court of the United States reversed and held

that the constitutional right to counsel requires that on an indigent's first appeal

from his conviction, court-appointed counsel support the appeal to the best of his

ability, requesting permission to withdraw only if he finds the case to be wholly

frivolous, in which event he must file a brief referring to anything in the record

3

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 4 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

that might arguably support the appeal. A “no merit” letter does not satisfy this

requirement. Rather the court stated that

Counsel[’s] . . . role as advocate requires that he support his client's

appeal to the best of his ability. Of course, if counsel finds his case

to be wholly frivolous, after a conscientious examination of it, he

should so advise the court and request permission to withdraw.

That request must, however, be accompanied by a brief referring to

anything in the record that might arguably support the appeal.

Anders, 386 U.S. at 744. Anders’s focus therefore is on defense counsel’s duty

when he finds no arguable issue to present on appeal. More than thirty years

ago, we directed counsel filing Anders briefs that “Anders requires counsel to

isolate possibly important issues and to furnish the court with references to the

record and legal authorities to aid it in its appellate function.” United States v.

Johnson, 527 F.2d 1328, 1329 (5th Cir. 1976).

As we recognized in another Anders case issued this same day, United

States v. Garland, No. 09-50317,

The Fifth Circuit’s website provides a detailed checklist and

outline for Anders briefs for guilty pleas and for bench or jury trials.

See http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov. The guidelines and checklist are

under the “Attorney Information Section.” This checklist is

designed to assist counsel in preparing a brief that will satisfy the

standards of Anders in this circuit.

Counsel obviously has broad discretion in the preparation of

his brief. For example, he can cover the material set forth in the

checklist in narrative form, or cut and paste the outline from the

checklist and answer the questions called for in it. No particular

form of brief is required. The point is that counsel should

demonstrate that he has considered the issues set forth in the

checklist to the extent they apply to her case. This will assist our

review of the brief to determine whether it is adequate.

Barring unusual circumstances in the proceedings, a brief

submitted by an attorney considering the issues set forth in the

4

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 5 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

checklist and addressing the areas of inquiry appropriate to his case

will be facially adequate, meaning that it meets both the

requirement placed on counsel to “support his client’s appeal to the

best of his ability”, Anders, 386 U.S. at 744, and “to act with candor

[to the court] in presenting claims for judicial resolution,” McCoy v.

Court of Appeals, Dist. 1, 486 U.S. 429, 440 (1988).

Id. In addition to fully complying with Anders, counsel must provide a copy of

his brief to the defendant and the brief should include in the Certificate of

Service a statement that this requirement has been complied with. Anders, 386

U.S. at 744.

The brief in this case satisfies these standards. Flores’ brief covers every

applicable item on the Checklist and Outline for Anders briefs for guilty pleas,

applying each item to the facts of Flores’ proceedings and providing references

to the record and citations to appropriate legal authority. The brief also

addresses the propriety of a 16 level enhancement applied to Flores’ sentence

for a prior crime of violence and whether the sentence was reasonable. Flores

did not submit a brief after being informed of her counsel’s motion to withdraw.

The Seventh Circuit has concluded that the appellate court reviewing a

brief filed under Anders need not have its “law clerk or staff attorney . . . scour

the record for issues that the lawyer may have overlooked.” United States v.

Wagner, 103 F.3d 551, 552 (7th Cir. 1996). That practice “gives the indigent

defendant more than he could expect had counsel (whether retained or

appointed) decided to press the appeal, since counsel’s decision on which issues

to raise on appeal would normally be conclusive.” Id. (citing Jones v. Barnes, 463

U.S. 745 (1983); Mason v. Hanks, 97 F.3d 887, 893 (7th Cir. 1996); and Sharp v.

Puckett, 930 F.2d 450 (5th Cir. 1991)).

5

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 6 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

The Seventh Circuit first rejected an approach that attaches conclusive

weight to the defendant’s failure to respond to an Anders motion, because “the

defendant will ordinarily not be learned in the law” and “his failure to respond

may reflect an inability to spot possible flaws in his lawyer’s legal arguments.”

Wagner, 103 F.3d at 552. The court also rejected the “opposite extreme”

requiring the court to comb the record even where the Anders brief appears to

be perfectly adequate, searching for possible nonfrivolous issues that both the

lawyer and the client may have overlooked and, if one is found, appointing a new

lawyer and directing him to the issues identified. The court concluded that the

“Anders procedure implements the Sixth Amendment right of counsel, 386 U.S.

at 742, a right to have counsel of minimum professional competence - not to have

a committee of counsel including judges of the court of appeals.” Id. Instead it

adopted an intermediate position -

The intermediate position, which we now adopt, is for the appellate

court to be guided in reviewing the record by the Anders brief itself,

provided that the brief is adequate on its face. (If it is not, we shall

deny the Anders motion and either direct counsel to file a new brief

or discharge counsel and appoint a new lawyer for the defendant.)

If the brief explains the nature of the case and fully and intelligently

discusses the issues that the type of case might be expected to

involve, we shall not conduct an independent top-to-bottom review

of the record in the district court to determine whether a more

resourceful or ingenious lawyer might have found additional issues

that may not be frivolous. We shall confine our scrutiny of the

record to the portions of it that relate to the issues discussed in the

brief. If in light of this scrutiny it is apparent that the lawyer's

discussion of the issues that he chose to discuss is responsible and

if there is nothing in the district court's decision to suggest that

there are other issues the brief should have discussed, we shall have

enough basis for confidence in the lawyer's competence to forgo

scrutiny of the rest of the record. The resources of the courts of

6

Case: 09-41281 Document: 00511367080 Page: 7 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

No. 09-41281

appeals are limited and the time of staff attorneys and law clerks

that is devoted to searching haystacks for needles is unavailable for

more promising research.

Id. at 553. The Third Circuit follows the Seventh Circuit approach. See United

States v. Youla, 241 F.3d 296 (3d Cir. 2000) and United States v. Ripoll, 123 Fed.

Appx. 479 (3d Cir. 2004)(unpublished).

We agree with the Seventh Circuit’s analysis and adopt its approach to

Anders cases. The holding in this case, along with the holding in our companion

case, United States v. Garland, No. 09-50317, setting forth the minimum

standards for Anders briefs, will fully satisfy defendants’ Sixth Amendment

right of counsel on direct appeal.

Applying this process to the facts of Flores’ guilty plea and sentence, and

based on our review of counsel’s brief and the relevant portions of the record

referenced therein, we accept counsel’s assessment that Flores has no

nonfrivolous issues to raise on appeal.

III.

Accordingly, counsel’s motion to withdraw is granted and the appeal is

dismissed as frivolous. See 5th Cir. R. 42.2.1

1

We have incorporated a number of changes in the opinion suggested by other judges

on the court and, with those changes, all active judges have assented.

7

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.