Opinion

Avalos

Court
District Court, N.D. California
Filed
Apr 15, 2026
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 41.4%

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

JOSE LUIS AVALOS, Case No. 24-cv-05581-RFL (PR)

Plaintiff,

ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT’S

v. MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT

DR. ASHBY, et al.,

Dkt. No. 27

Defendants.

INTRODUCTION

Plaintiff Jose Luis Avalos alleges in this 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action that his doctor, Ashby,

provided constitutionally inadequate medical care for his post-operative elbow, thereby violating

his Eighth Amendment rights. Defendant Ashby moves for summary judgment on grounds that

the undisputed record shows that he provided timely and thorough medical treatment. Avalos

has not filed any response to the summary judgment motion.

Defendant’s unopposed summary judgment motion is GRANTED. Avalos’s deposition

testimony refutes his allegations in the operative complaint. He testified that Defendant met with

him immediately after his surgeries, examined and cleaned his wounds, and gave him advice

about exercises and other post-operative care measures. He also testified that his wounds were

cleaned and examined every day.

Also, Defendant has presented undisputed medical evidence that he provided Avalos with

appropriate and timely treatment consonant with the post-surgical instructions. Specifically, he

was instructed to perform his range of motion exercises, given pain medication, had his wound

dressings changed daily, and staff spoke with the SJGH staff to make sure his splint was

appropriately arranged. When there was a possibility of wound infection, Defendant sent Avalos

to the hospital immediately, and closely treated and monitored his condition when he returned.

This undisputed record shows attention and care rather than showing a genuine dispute of

material fact that Ashby was deliberately indifferent.

BACKGROUND

Avalos, a California state prisoner, had elbow replacement surgery (left elbow

arthroplasty surgery) on April 26, 2023 at San Joaquin General Hospital (SJGH). (First Am.

Compl., Dkt. No. 12 at 3.) Defendant Ashby was his primary care physician at CTF-Soledad.

Avalos alleges that Ashby’s post-operative treatment of his elbow caused his left elbow to

become infected. “Dr. Ashby was responsible to make sure that I got [] dressing changes and the

surgery area was cleaned. This was never done as Dr. Ashby . . . never ordered staff at C.T.F. to

do[,] which caused and allowed it to get severely infected.” (Id. at 3.) He alleges that on May 5,

2023 he was taken to the hospital for emergency immediate medical care and surgery due to

severe swelling and infection because of medical mistakes in surgery. (Id.)

Avalos’s testimony at his deposition flatly contradicts the allegations in the operative

complaint. He testified that Ashby examined him the day after his first surgery, removed the

cast, observed that everything was “fine” and “normal,” and “cleaned all of the area that had

been operated on. He cleaned everything.” (MSJ, Pl.’s Depo., Dkt. No. 27-15 at 19.) He also

testified that “every morning” a CTF nurse would clean his elbow, examine it, and “do other

post-operative procedures” following his first post-operative visit with Ashby. (Id. at 20-21.)

He further testified that Ashby told him to perform his exercises, and Avalos demonstrated those

exercises at the deposition. (Id. at 21.)

He also testified that Ashby saw him immediately after his return to the prison after his

second operation. (Id. at 28.) Ashby cleaned and examined the wound, and advised him to

perform his exercises and to not to get the wound wet. (Id. at 28-29.) At the deposition, Avalos

blamed the infection on the surgeons at the outside hospitals. (Id. at 31-34.) He trusted

Defendant to refer him to a competent surgeon, but Ashby failed to do so, and therefore is at

fault for the infection, an allegation Avalos does not make in his operative complaint. (Id.)

Defendant Ashby presents a version of events different from those stated in the operative

complaint. He alleges that SJGH provided “operative and discharge materials outlined standard

postoperative measures, including gentle range of motion, elevation of the extremity, sling use,

and daily dressing changes, all of which Avalos was provided at CTF following his surgery.”

(MSJ, Dkt. No. 27 at 7.) In fact, on April 27, 2023, the day after surgery, medical staff noted

“appropriate postoperative pain management, and verified Avalos’s splint positioning with his

surgical team.” (Id.) Specifically, medical staff gave him analgesics when Avalos complained

of pain and spoke with the surgical team at SJGH to make sure the splint was properly

positioned. (MSJ, Ashby Decl. ¶ 4.) On May 2, Ashby documented receiving and reviewing

recommendations from Dr. Huish. (MSJ, Dkt. No. 27 at 7.) These included removing the splint

after three to five days, and instructions for Avalos “to perform passive range of motion of his

elbow, to change his dressings daily, that he may shower after 5 days, to keep the area elevated

and use ice several times a day, and to follow-up with Dr. Huish in clinic in 2 to 4 weeks.”

(MSJ, Feinberg Decl. ¶ 16.)

On May 3, Defendant saw Avalos for a follow-up, and reviewed the recommendations

with him. (MSJ, Ashby Decl., ¶ 5; Feinberg Decl., ¶ 17.) Because Avalos resisted moving his

arm, Defendant, through a translator, told him it was important to perform the exercises for 15

minutes every waking hour or he would lose his range of motion in the elbow. (Id., Feinberg

Decl., ¶ 17.) Defendant also ordered pain medication, ice packs, and daily dressing changes.

(Id.)

On May 5, swelling and color change raised concerns that the surgical wound was

infected. CTF medical staff, in consultation with Defendant, sent Avalos to the Natividad

Medical Center (NMC) where he was treated with antibiotics. (MSJ, Ashby Decl., ¶ 5; Feinberg

Decl., ¶¶ 18-19.) In fact, there was no documented infection at this time. There was mild

redness, but no pus. It appeared to be “normal postop swelling.” (Id.) Defendant stayed in

communication with Avalos’s surgeon throughout this postoperative time. (Id., Ashby Decl. ¶

5.) The surgeon expressed no concern and planned continued follow-ups. (Id., Ashby Decl., ¶ 5;

Feinberg Decl., ¶¶ 21, 28-30.) After Avalos’s return to CTF from NMC, Ashby and other

medical staff evaluated him, treated his pain, scheduled orthopedic follow-ups, and instructed

him to perform his range of motion exercises, which Avalos resisted performing. (Id., Ashby

Decl., ¶¶ 5, 10; Feinberg Decl., ¶¶ 20-26.)

On July 22, Avalos complained of a possible cyst in his elbow and “needle poking” pain,

and was prescribed antibiotics by a different doctor. (Id., Feinberg Decl., ¶ 37.) On July 29,

Avalos had a follow up with a nurse who noted that he had an open, warm, swollen wound. (Id.,

Feinberg Decl., ¶ 38.) The nurse alerted Defendant, who immediately arranged for Avalos to

have outside surgical care at SJGH. (Id., Ashby Decl., ¶ 7; Feinberg Decl., ¶¶ 38-39.) The

SJGH orthopedic surgeons removed the elbow hardware, placed an antibiotic spacer, and

administered intravenous antibiotics to treat an infection. (Id.) After Avalos returned to CTF on

August 8, Defendant gave him oral antibiotics, ordered lab monitoring, and continued follow-up

and wound surveillance. (Id., Ashby Decl., ¶ 8.) On August 13, Avalos signed a refusal of care

after refusing a recommended treatment and triage area evaluation for slight wound dehiscence

that day. (Id., ¶ 10.)

Defendant continued to monitor Avalos’s healing through subsequent visits, including

after a third revision surgery in January 2024. (Id., ¶ 9.) Defendant notes that Avalos had been

diagnosed with diabetes, which “increases the risk of surgical-site infection.” (Id., ¶ 10.)

Avalos’s medical records were examined by Dr. Bennett Feinberg, a licensed physician

and the Chief Medical Consultant for the California Correctional Health Care Services (CCHCS)

Office of Legal Affairs. (MSJ, Feinberg Decl.) Feinberg determined that Avalos received

timely, adequate and appropriate medical attention and care. (Id., ¶ 40.)

STANDARD OF REVIEW

Summary judgment is proper where the pleadings, discovery and affidavits demonstrate

that there is “no genuine dispute as to any material fact and [that] the movant is entitled to

judgment as a matter of law.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a). Material facts are those which may affect

the outcome of the case. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). A dispute

as to a material fact is genuine if there is sufficient evidence for a reasonable jury to return a

verdict for the nonmoving party. Id.

The party moving for summary judgment bears the initial burden of identifying those

portions of the pleadings, discovery, and affidavits that demonstrate the absence of a genuine

issue of material fact. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986). Where the moving

party will have the burden of proof on an issue at trial, it must affirmatively demonstrate that no

reasonable trier of fact could find other than for the moving party. On an issue for which the

opposing party by contrast will have the burden of proof at trial, as is the case here, the moving

party need only point out “that there is an absence of evidence to support the nonmoving party’s

case.” Id. at 325.

Once the moving party meets its initial burden, the nonmoving party must go beyond the

pleadings and, by its own affidavits or discovery, set forth specific facts showing that there is a

genuine issue for trial. Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c). The Court is concerned only with disputes over

material facts and “[f]actual disputes that are irrelevant or unnecessary will not be counted.”

Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248. It is not the task of the court to scour the record in search of a

genuine issue of triable fact. Keenan v. Allan, 91 F.3d 1275, 1279 (9th Cir. 1996). The

nonmoving party has the burden of identifying, with reasonable particularity, the evidence that

precludes summary judgment. Id. If the nonmoving party fails to make this showing, “the

moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law.” Celotex, 477 U.S. at 323 (internal

quotation marks omitted).

DISCUSSION

Deliberate indifference to a prisoner’s serious medical needs violates the Eighth

Amendment's proscription against cruel and unusual punishment. Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S.

97, 104 (1976). A prison official is deliberately indifferent if he knows that a prisoner faces a

substantial risk of serious harm and disregards that risk by failing to take reasonable steps to

abate it. Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S. 825, 837 (1994) (equating the standard with that of

criminal recklessness). The prison official must not only “be aware of facts from which the

inference could be drawn that a substantial risk of serious harm exists,” but “must also draw the

inference.” Id. Consequently, in order for deliberate indifference to be established, there must

exist both a purposeful act or failure to act on the part of the defendant and resulting harm.

McGuckin v. Smith, 974 F.2d 1050, 1060 (9th Cir. 1992) (overruled on other grounds, WMX

Technologies, Inc. v. Miller, 104 F.3d 1133, 1136 (9th Cir. 1997) (en banc)).

The Supreme Court has further clarified this standard by holding that “it is obduracy and

wantonness, not inadvertence or error in good faith, that characterize the conduct prohibited by

the Eighth Amendment.” Whitley v. Albers, 475 U.S. 312, 319 (1986). A mere accident or

evaluative mistake is not to be characterized as wanton infliction of unnecessary pain. Estelle,

429 U.S. at 105. Instead, a plaintiff must show that his doctors or nurses embarked on a course

of “medically unacceptable” treatment in “conscious disregard of an excessive risk to [his]

health.” Toguchi v. Chung, 391 F.3d 1051, 1058-60 (9th Cir. 2004). A claim of mere negligence

related to medical problems, or a difference of opinion between a prisoner patient and a medical

doctor, is not enough to make out a violation of the Eighth Amendment. Id.; Franklin v. Oregon,

662 F.2d 1337, 1344 (9th Cir. 1981).

Summary judgment will be granted in Defendant’s favor. As an initial matter, Avalos’s

testimony refutes the allegations in the operative complaint. He testified that Defendant met

with him immediately after his surgeries, examined and cleaned his wounds, and gave him

advice about exercises and other post-operative care measures. He also testified that his wounds

were cleaned and examined every day.

Avalos now blames the infection on the outside surgeons, and holds Defendant

responsible for failing to refer him to a competent surgeon. These allegations did not appear in

the operative complaint, and therefore Avalos cannot now create a genuine dispute from such

allegations.

Also, the undisputed medical evidence presented by Defendant shows that Ashby

provided Avalos with appropriate and timely treatment consonant with the post-surgical

instructions. Specifically, he was instructed to perform his range of motion exercises, given pain

medication, and had his wound dressings changed daily, and staff spoke with the SJGH staff to

make sure his splint was appropriately arranged. Ashby received medical reports from prison

staff confirming that these measures were taken. He also met with Ashby for a follow up,

reviewed his care and the post-surgical recommendations, ordered pain medication for him, and

emphasized the importance of performing his exercises. When there was concern in May that

the wound may be infected, CTF staff and Defendant had Avalos sent to the hospital for

treatment, and Defendant kept in touch with Avalos’s surgeon. When in July there was again a

concern about infection, Defendant arranged for Avalos’s immediate transfer to a hospital. After

his return, Defendant ordered antibiotics, lab monitoring, continued follow up and would

surveillance. This record shows attention and care, not deliberate indifference.

Avalos has filed no opposition, and therefore has not presented any competent medical

evidence to dispute the evidence in his medical records or the evidence presented by Defendant.

That his wound may have become infected is not sufficient, especially in light of the undisputed

showing that Defendant immediately addressed and treated his condition. Avalos’s conclusory

allegations that Defendant’s failure to provide adequate care cannot create a genuine dispute of

material fact in the face of the undisputed medical evidence presented. He has not presented any

competent medical evidence to show that Defendant embarked on a course of “medically

unacceptable” treatment in “conscious disregard of an excessive risk to [his] health,” Toguchi,

391 F.3d at 1058-60, or otherwise failed to take reasonable steps to treat him, Farmer, 511 U.S.

at 837.

Avalos did not file an opposition to the motion for summary judgment. A district court

may not grant a motion for summary judgment solely because the opposing party has failed to

file an opposition. See Cristobal v. Siegel, 26 F.3d 1488, 1494-95 & n.4 (9th Cir. 1994)

(unopposed motion may be granted only after court determines that there are no material issues

of fact). This is so even if the failure to oppose violates a local rule. See Martinez v. Stanford,

323 F.3d 1178, 1182-83 (9th Cir. 2003). But a court may grant an unopposed motion for

summary judgment if the movant’s papers are themselves sufficient to support the motion and do

not on their face reveal a genuine issue of material fact. See United States v. Real Property at

Incline Village, 47 F.3d 1511, 1520 (9th Cir. 1995) (local rule cannot mandate automatic entry of

judgment for moving party without consideration of whether motion and supporting papers

satisfy Fed. R. Civ. P. 56), rev’d on other grounds sub nom. Degen v. United States, 517 U.S.

820 (1996); Henry v. Gill Industries, Inc., 983 F.2d 943, 950 (9th Cir. 1993) (same).

The evidence presented by Defendant supports his motion for summary judgment and

Avalos has presented no competent medical evidence (and therefore has not shown a genuine

dispute of material fact) that he received constitutionally inadequate medical care. The

Defendant’s papers are sufficient to support the motion and do not on their face reveal a genuine

issue of material fact.

Defendant contends that he is entitled to qualified immunity. (MSJ, Dkt. No. 27 at 13.)

The defense of qualified immunity protects government officials “from liability for civil

damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional

rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800,

818 (1982). To determine whether an official is entitled to qualified immunity, the court must

decide whether the facts alleged show that the official’s conduct violated a constitutional right;

and, if so, whether it would be clear to a reasonable officer that his conduct was unlawful in the

situation he confronted. See Saucier v. Katz, 533 U.S. 194, 201-02 (2001); see also Pearson v.

Callahan, 555 U.S. 223 (2009) (overruling Saucier’s requirement that qualified immunity

analysis proceed in a particular sequence). “[I]f no constitutional right would have been violated

were the allegations established, there is no necessity for further inquiries concerning qualified

immunity.” Saucier, 533 U.S. at 201.

Regarding the first prong, the threshold question must be: Taken in the light most

favorable to the party asserting the injury, do the facts alleged show the officer’s conduct

violated a constitutional right? Saucier, 533 U.S. at 201; see Martin v. City of Oceanside, 360

F.3d 1078, 1082 (9th Cir. 2004) (in performing the initial inquiry, court is obligated to accept

plaintiff's facts as alleged, but not necessarily his application of law to the facts; the issue is not

whether a claim is stated for a violation of plaintiff's constitutional rights, but rather whether the

defendants actually violated a constitutional right) (emphasis in original). “If no constitutional

right would have been violated were the allegations established, there is no necessity for further

inquiries concerning qualified immunity.” Saucier, 533 U.S. at 201.

Defendant is entitled to qualified immunity. Avalos’s deposition testimony wholly

refutes the allegations in the operative complaint. He admits that Defendant and prison staff

cleaned his wound and provided appropriate post-operative care. Because the allegations do not

show a violation of a constitutional right, there is no necessity for further inquiries concerning

qualified immunity.

CONCLUSION

Defendant’s motion for summary judgment is GRANTED. (Dkt. No. 27.) The Clerk

shall terminate Dkt. No. 27.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

Dated: April 14, 2026

United States District Judge

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.