Opinion

Gordon v. Brown

  • 2026 Ohio 1828
Court
Ohio Court of Appeals
Filed
May 19, 2026
Status
Published
On the bench
Beatty Blunt
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 40.6%

The opinion

[Cite as Gordon v. Brown, 2026-Ohio-1828.]

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO

TENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

Michael Lee Gordon, :

Relator, :

v. : No. 25AP-870

Judge Kimberly Brown, : (REGULAR CALENDAR)

Respondent. :

:

DECISION

Rendered on May 19, 2026

On brief: Michael Lee Gordon, pro se.

On brief: Shayla D. Favor, Prosecuting Attorney, Gareth A.

Whaley, and Devin E. Bartlett, for respondent.

IN MANDAMUS

ON REVIEW OF MAGISTRATE’S DECISION

BEATTY BLUNT, J.

{¶ 1} On October 29, 2025 relator, Michael Lee Gordon, then an inmate at the Iowa

State Penitentiary, filed a complaint in the instant mandamus action, and on November 24,

2025 respondent filed a motion to dismiss relator’s complaint. Relator filed a reply to

respondent’s motion to dismiss on December 22, 2025, and respondent filed a motion to

dismiss relator’s second petition for writ of mandamus on December 30, 2025.

{¶ 2} Pursuant to Civ.R. 53 and Loc.R. 13(M) of the Tenth District Court of

Appeals, this matter was referred to a magistrate. On March 5, 2026, the magistrate

recommended that we dismiss relator’s action sua sponte for failure to comply with the

statutory requirements for a mandamus action under R.C. 2731.04 and dismiss the

respondent’s motion to dismiss as moot.

No. 25AP-870 2

{¶ 3} Relator has not filed any objection to the magistrate’s decision. “If no timely

objections are filed, the court may adopt a magistrate’s decision, unless it determines that

there is an error of law or other defect evident on the face of the magistrate’s decision.”

Civ.R. 53(D)(4)(c). Our review of the magistrate’s decision reveals no error of law or other

evident defect. See, e.g., State ex rel. Alleyne v. Indus. Comm., 2004-Ohio-4223, ¶ 32-33

(10th Dist.) (adopting the magistrate’s decision where no objections were filed).

{¶ 4} As we have found no error of law or other defect on the face of the magistrate’s

decision, we adopt it as our own, including the findings of fact and conclusions of law as

they are set forth in the decision. In accordance with the magistrate’s recommendation, the

cause is dismissed for failure to comply with R.C. 2731.04, and respondent’s motion to

dismiss is moot.

Action dismissed;

motion to dismiss moot.

MENTEL and EDELSTEIN, JJ., concur.

No. 25AP-870 3

APPENDIX

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO

TENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

Michael Lee Gordon, :

Relator, :

v. : No. 25AP-870

Judge Kimberly Brown, : (REGULAR CALENDAR)

:

Respondent. :

MAGISTRATE’S DECISION

Rendered on March 5, 2026

Michael Lee Gordon, pro se.

Shayla D. Favor, Prosecuting Attorney, Gareth A. Whaley,

and Devin E. Bartlett, for respondent.

IN MANDAMUS

ON SUA SPONTE DISMISSAL

{¶ 5} Petitioner Michael Lee Gordon requests a writ of mandamus ordering

respondent Judge Kimberly Brown to rule on a pending motion for postconviction relief.

Judge Brown has filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can

be granted. For the reasons set forth below, the magistrate recommends that Gordon’s

mandamus action be dismissed sua sponte for failure to comply with the statutory

requirements for a mandamus action under R.C. 2731.04.

I. Findings of Fact

{¶ 6} 1. Gordon filed his petition for a writ of mandamus on October 29, 2025.

{¶ 7} 2. Judge Brown filed a motion to dismiss pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6) on

November 24, 2025.

No. 25AP-870 4

{¶ 8} 3. Gordon filed an amended petition for writ of mandamus on December 16,

2025.1

{¶ 9} 4. Gordon did not bring either his original or amended petition in the name

of the state on the relation of the person applying for the writ of mandamus.

{¶ 10} 5. As reflected in Gordon’s petitions, Gordon is an inmate incarcerated at

Iowa State Penitentiary in Fort Madison, Iowa.

{¶ 11} 6. In his amended petition, Gordon alleges that he filed a motion in case

No. 01CR-3612 on September 16, 2025.2 Gordon requests a writ of mandamus ordering

Judge Brown to rule on the September 16, 2025 motion. Gordon also requests that Judge

Brown be ordered to personally serve him with a copy of the ruling.

{¶ 12} 7. Judge Brown filed a motion to dismiss Gordon’s amended petition

pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6) on December 30, 2025.

II. Discussion and Conclusions of Law

{¶ 13} Gordon requests a writ of mandamus ordering Judge Brown to rule on a

motion for postconviction relief and personally serve Gordon with a copy of the ruling.

Judge Brown has asked that Gordon’s petition be dismissed pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6).

Before considering the bases asserted in the motion to dismiss, it is necessary to address

whether Gordon has complied with the statutory requirements for bringing a mandamus

action.

{¶ 14} Under R.C. 2731.04, a petitioner seeking a writ of mandamus must, in part,

file the petition “in the name of the state on the relation of the person applying.” Ohio courts

have held that “while the requirements of R.C. 2731.04 are ‘not jurisdictional, . . . a court

may dismiss the complaint for failure to comply with the provisions of R.C. 2731.04.’ ”

Thompson v. Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Comp., 2026-Ohio-720, ¶ 7 (10th Dist.), quoting In

re Collado, 2020-Ohio-5337, ¶ 8 (8th Dist.). See also State ex rel. Harper v. Perlatti, 2025-

Ohio-1313. This court has held that a complainant’s failure to comply with the captioning

requirement of R.C. 2731.04 is grounds for a court to dismiss the mandamus complaint sua

1 Gordon’s December 16, 2025 pleading was labeled as a “Second Petition for a Writ of Mandamus.” Consistent

with Civ.R. 15(A), this pleading is considered as an amended petition.

2 In his original petition, Gordon described the September 16, 2025 motion as a motion for postconviction

relief pursuant to R.C. 2953.21 State v. Gordon, Franklin C.P. No. 01CR-3612. Gordon alleged that the State

of Ohio responded to the petition on September 19, 2025 and Gordon filed a reply on October 8, 2025. These

allegations are absent from the amended petition.

No. 25AP-870 5

sponte. Thompson at ¶ 8. See Wright v. Application for Relief from Disability, 2025-Ohio-

1425, ¶ 6 (10th Dist.) (holding trial court did not err by dismissing mandamus complaint

sua sponte because the petitioner did not file his petition for a writ of mandamus in the

name of the state on his relation as required by R.C. 2731.04).

{¶ 15} Here, Gordon did not bring either his first or amended petition for a writ of

mandamus in the name of the state on the relation of the person applying. Accordingly,

consistent with Thompson and Wright, it is the decision and recommendation of the

magistrate that this Court should sua sponte dismiss Gordon’s cause without prejudice for

failure to comply with R.C. 2731.04. As a result, respondent’s motion to dismiss is rendered

moot.

/S/ MAGISTRATE

JOSEPH E. WENGER IV

NOTICE TO THE PARTIES

Civ.R. 53(D)(3)(a)(iii) provides that a party shall not assign as

error on appeal the court’s adoption of any factual finding or

legal conclusion, whether or not specifically designated as a

finding of fact or conclusion of law under Civ.R.

53(D)(3)(a)(ii), unless the party timely and specifically objects

to that factual finding or legal conclusion as required by Civ.R.

53(D)(3)(b). A party may file written objections to the

magistrate’s decision within fourteen days of the filing of the

decision.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.