Opinion

Maryland Attorney General Opinion 109OAG032

Court
Maryland Attorney General Reports
Filed
May 8, 2024
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 40.3%

noting that, in general, a statutory violation based on a mistake of law is not considered “willful”

How later courts described this case

  • noting that, in general, a statutory violation based on a mistake of law is not considered “willful”
  • explaining that the practice of law involves application of “legal principles and precedent”
  • involving representation before administrative agencies and customized contract drafting
  • involving selection of immigration forms

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

32 [109 Op. Att’y

ACCOUNTANTS

UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW – BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP

INFORMATION REPORTING – WHETHER ASSISTANCE BY A

CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANT WITH THE BENEFICIAL

OWNERSHIP INFORMATION REPORTING REQUIREMENT OF

THE CORPORATE TRANSPARENCY ACT WOULD

CONSTITUTE THE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW

May 8, 2024

Dr. Jan L. Williams

Chair, State Board of Public Accountancy

Christopher E. Dorsey

Executive Director, State Board of Public Accountancy

In 2021, Congress enacted the Corporate Transparency Act

(the “Transparency Act” or the “Act”) to help law enforcement

investigate money laundering and other illicit activity conducted

through shell companies. The Act will require millions of

corporations and limited liability companies to identify their

“beneficial owners” to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network

(“FinCEN”), a unit in the U.S. Department of the Treasury. Each

“reporting company” covered by the Act must file a Beneficial

Ownership Information Report (“BOIR”) with FinCEN by a

certain deadline. Many legal entities thus will need to determine

whether they are “reporting companies” and, if they are, will need

to complete and submit a BOIR.

On behalf of the State Board of Public Accountancy, you

requested an official opinion of the Attorney General analyzing

whether, and under what circumstances, a certified public

accountant (“CPA”) who prepares a BOIR for a client or assists a

client with BOIR preparation would be engaged in the

unauthorized practice of law. You suggested that businesses,

especially small businesses, may seek help from their regular CPA

in complying with the Act. But, if BOIR preparation or advice is

“the practice of law,” then nonlawyers may not provide that service

without attorney supervision. You thus asked for “guidance with

respect to what CPA activities relating to BOI reporting would and

would not constitute unauthorized practice of law.”1

1

We received comments on this opinion request from the Maryland

Association of Certified Public Accountants (“MACPA”). Letter from

Rebekah Olson, CPA, Executive Director, MACPA, to Office of the

Gen. 32] 33

In Maryland, the authority to define “the practice of law” rests

with the courts, which have developed the definition on a case-by-

case basis. To answer your question, then, we must attempt to

predict how the courts would evaluate different degrees of CPA

involvement in this area. Although we cannot draw bright lines or

address every hypothetical situation, we will offer our best

guidance consistent with precedent.

In our opinion, to take the easier part of your question first, a

CPA clearly may provide clients with general information about

the BOIR requirement that is not particularized to any specific

client’s situation. Similarly, if a client were to determine for itself

that it is a “reporting company” covered by the Act and provide its

CPA with a list of its beneficial owners, the CPA could perform the

ministerial tasks of gathering the necessary contact information for

those beneficial owners, filling out the BOIR form, and filing it

with FinCEN.

In addition, although the question is closer, we think there will

also be many situations where a CPA can help a client determine

whether it is a “reporting company” or assist a client with

identifying its beneficial owners. More specifically, we think

CPAs may provide a client with the instructions and guidance

FinCEN has published for completing the BOIR form; walk the

client through FinCEN’s instructions (which are designed for

nonlawyers); define terms in the instructions that are within

common knowledge for a layperson or CPA; and help the client

answer factual questions from the client’s records or the CPA’s

own knowledge.

But a CPA who goes beyond those types of activities is at

much greater risk of engaging in unauthorized law practice. As

discussed in greater detail below, to the extent a CPA’s BOIR

assistance requires the knowledge, skills, and training of a

lawyer—such as application of the general legal principles of

statutory or contract interpretation, analysis of legal precedent, or

identifying legal issues in a client-provided fact pattern (so-called

“issue spotting”)—that assistance may violate the prohibition on

unauthorized practice of law.2

Attorney General (Mar. 1, 2024) (“MACPA Comments”). We thank

MACPA for its comments, which we have considered in preparing this

opinion.

2

Our analysis is limited to BOIR preparation or assistance by CPAs

who are not also attorneys. We do not opine on any other area of CPA

34 [109 Op. Att’y

I

Background

A. The Unauthorized Practice of Law

Restrictions on who may practice law have a long history in

Maryland. Starting in 1715, a series of acts of the General

Assembly required courts, and then boards of attorneys appointed

by the courts, to examine would-be lawyers for competence and

character. William H. Adkins, II, What Doth the Board Require of

Thee?, 28 Md. L. Rev. 103, 104-05 (1968). But these statutes only

regulated attorneys’ right to appear in court; law practice outside

of court remained unregulated. See Md. Ann. Code, Art. 10,

§§ 1-16 (1888); see also Barlow F. Christensen, The Unauthorized

Practice of Law: Do Good Fences Really Make Good Neighbors—

Or Even Good Sense?, 5 Am. Bar Found. Res. J. 159, 180-81, 186-

87 (1980) (explaining that the same was true for most states until

the early twentieth century).

The General Assembly broadened the unauthorized practice

prohibition in 1898, when it authorized contempt sanctions “for

assuming to be any attorney . . . and acting as such without

authority” regardless of the setting. 1898 Md. Laws, ch. 31. Two

years later, the Legislature made it a misdemeanor for a non-Bar

member to receive payment for “advice or services as an attorney

at law.” 1900 Md. Laws, ch. 699.

To clarify the scope of the prohibition, the General Assembly

in 1908 enacted a definition of law practice: “[A]ny person who

shall give any legal advice, represent any person in the trial of any

case at law or in equity, or prepare any written instrument affecting

the title to real estate, for pay or reward,” would be deemed to be

practicing law. 1908 Md. Laws, ch. 638. Over the following

decades the Legislature would make minor adjustments to this

definition. See, e.g., 1961 Md. Laws, ch. 456 (adding estate

administration advice on Orphans’ Court matters to the definition

of law practice).

activity or on whether other types of licensed professionals, or

nonprofessionals, may provide BOIR assistance to the same extent as

CPAs. Of course, CPAs who are also Maryland Bar members may

practice law in Maryland to the extent allowed by the two professions’

ethical rules.

Gen. 32] 35

In 1969, however, the Supreme Court of Maryland3 held that

the regulation of the practice of law, and more specifically “the

determination of what constitutes the practice of law,” is vested in

the Judicial Branch. Public Serv. Comm’n v. Hahn Transp., Inc.,

253 Md. 571, 583 (1969). The Court has rested this principle both

on the historical understanding that attorneys are “officers of the

court,” and on the recognition that in our adversarial system, the

Judiciary cannot perform its functions without “a vigorous,

honorable and qualified bar” to present and develop cases.

Attorney General v. Waldron, 289 Md. 683, 693-96 (1981). But

the power the Court recognized in Hahn Transportation extends

beyond the courthouse; the Court there held that appearance before

quasi-judicial administrative agencies was also the practice of law

subject to judicial regulation. 253 Md. at 580-81.

The Court in Hahn Transportation did acknowledge the

validity of legislation implementing and supporting judicial

authority over the legal profession. Hahn Transp., 253 Md. at 583;

see also Waldron, 289 Md. at 698. For example, the General

Assembly has continued to enact mechanisms to enforce the

unauthorized-practice prohibition. Although at one time bar

associations could seek injunctive relief against unauthorized

practice, see 1961 Md. Laws, ch. 217, only the Office of the

Attorney General and the Attorney Grievance Commission’s

Office of Bar Counsel now have that authority, Md. Code Ann.,

Bus. Occ. & Prof. (“BO&P”) § 10-406. Unauthorized practice of

law also remains a misdemeanor punishable by fine and/or

imprisonment. BO&P §§ 10-601, 10-606.

The courts have continued to cite the General Assembly’s

definition of the practice of law, though they have not treated it as

binding. See, e.g., Attorney Grievance Comm’n v. Jackson, 477

Md. 174, 200 n.11 (2022). The definition, now codified at

§ 10-101(h) of the Business Occupations and Professions Article,

states:

(1) “Practice law” means to engage in any of

the following activities:

(i) giving legal advice;

3

Until December 2022, the Supreme Court of Maryland and the

Appellate Court of Maryland were known as the Court of Appeals and

the Court of Special Appeals, respectively. This opinion uses the courts’

current names throughout for consistency.

36 [109 Op. Att’y

(ii) representing another person before a unit

of the State government or of a political

subdivision; or

(iii) performing any other services that the

Supreme Court of Maryland defines as

practicing law.

(2) “Practice law” includes:

(i) advising in the administration of probate of

estates of decedents in an orphans’ court of the

State;

(ii) preparing an instrument that affects title to

real estate;

(iii) preparing or helping in the preparation of

any form or document that is filed in a court

or affects a case that is or may be filed in a

court; or

(iv) giving advice about a case that is or may

be filed in a court.

In general, though, the Maryland courts since 1969 have developed

the definition of “practice of law” in a common-law fashion.

Rather than “craft an all-encompassing definition,” the courts will

“look at the facts of each case and determine whether they ‘fall

within the fair intendment of the term’” “practice of law.” E.g.,

Jackson, 477 Md. at 200-01 (quoting Attorney Grievance Comm’n

v. Hallmon, 343 Md. 390, 397 (1996)).

The prohibition on unauthorized practice of law aims to

protect both the courts and the public from incompetent or

unethical would-be practitioners. See, e.g., In re R.G.S., 312 Md.

626, 638 (1988); see also, e.g., Restatement (Third) of the Law

Governing Lawyers § 4 cmt. b (Am. Law Inst. 2000). Because

lawyers are subject to rules governing their competence and ethics,

courts can rely on lawyers’ assertions. See Susan B. Schwab, Note,

Bringing Down the Bar: Accountants Challenge Meaning of

Unauthorized Practice, 21 Cardozo L. Rev. 1425, 1433 n.39

(2000). “Law practice” by individuals who lack a lawyer’s training

and ethical duties thus harms not only clients but also the

administration of justice more generally. See 56 Opinions of the

Attorney General 5, 8 (1971); 44 Opinions of the Attorney General

443, 444-45 (1959). So even a client’s free and fully informed

consent cannot authorize a nonlawyer to practice law on their

behalf. See Turkey Point Prop. Owners’ Ass’n v. Anderson, 106

Md. App. 710, 717-18 (1995).

Gen. 32] 37

That said, as scholars have recognized, it can sometimes be

difficult to define, consistently and coherently, what activities

(outside of litigation, and activity ancillary to litigation) constitute

“the practice of law.” See, e.g., Deborah L. Rhode, Policing the

Professional Monopoly: A Constitutional and Empirical Analysis

of Unauthorized Practice Prohibitions, 34 Stan. L. Rev. 1, 81-85

(1981); Adam J. Smith, Unauthorized Practice of Law and CPAs:

A Law of the Lawyers, by the Lawyers, for the Lawyers, 23 U. Fla.

J.L. & Pub. Pol’y 373, 381-85 (2012). This question is especially

difficult considering that the practice of many other professions

involves applying, or at least understanding, aspects of law. See,

e.g., Pamela A. McManus, Have Law License; Will Travel, 15 Geo.

J.L. Ethics 527, 541-42 (2002). Certified public accountancy is one

such profession.

B. Certified Public Accountants

Accountants, like lawyers, offer a wide variety of services.

These services most often involve the collection, organization, and

validation of financial information. See, e.g., Comprehensive

Accounting Serv. Co. v. Maryland State Bd. of Pub. Accountancy,

284 Md. 474, 478 (1979); Accountant’s Soc’y of Va. v. Bowman,

860 F.2d 602, 604-05 (4th Cir. 1988). But the work of accountants

“generally go[es] beyond simple auditing and bookkeeping” and

may include, for example, “financial management and planning

advice.” 13 N.Y. Jur. 2d Businesses & Occupations § 181 (Apr.

2024 update).

The definition of certified public accountancy is narrower.4

In Maryland, CPAs are licensed and regulated by the State Board

of Public Accountancy under the Maryland Public Accountancy

Act, Title 2 of the Business Occupations and Professions Article.

Only a CPA who has met the “stringent educational, experience

and other eligibility requirements” for licensure, Comprehensive

Accounting, 284 Md. at 476, may “practice certified public

accountancy,” BO&P § 2-301. The “practice [of] certified public

accountancy” is defined as:

4

The Maryland Public Accountancy Act expressly preserves the right

of non-CPAs to provide “bookkeeping and accounting services” as long

as those services fall outside the definition of certified public

accountancy in BO&P § 2-101(m). See BO&P § 2-102(a)(3). And

certain non-CPAs may prepare tax returns. BO&P §§ 21-102(b),

21-301.

38 [109 Op. Att’y

(1) conducting an audit, review, or

compilation of financial statements;

(2) conducting any examination, review, or

agreed-upon procedures engagement to be

performed in accordance with the Statements

on Standards for Attestation Engagements

issued by [the American Institute of Certified

Public Accountants]; or

(3) providing a written certificate or opinion

offering positive or negative assurance or full

or limited assurance on the correctness of the

information or on the fairness of the

presentation of the information in:

(i) a financial statement;

(ii) a report;

(iii) a schedule; or

(iv) an exhibit.

BO&P § 2-101(m). To summarize at the expense of some nuance,

then, the special domain of CPAs is to provide, for the benefit of

third parties, a degree of written assurance on the fairness or

correctness of financial statements or other information provided

by their clients.5

5

An “audit” produces an opinion on the correctness of the

information, or the fairness of the presentation of the information, in

financial statements. 84 Opinions of the Attorney General 3, 5, 14

(1999); 66 Opinions of the Attorney General 190, 190 (1981). A

“review” produces a “limited assurance” that the accountant is not aware

of any material modifications that must be made to the financial

statements to conform to generally accepted accounting principles. 84

Opinions of the Attorney General at 6, 15; 66 Opinions of the Attorney

General at 193-94. A “compilation” ordinarily involves no assurance at

all, 84 Opinions of the Attorney General at 5, and so the Public

Accountancy Act allows non-CPAs to prepare compilations, but only

with certain disclaimers. BO&P § 2-102(a)(3)(iii)(2). Thus, the

preparation of compilations without disclaimers is limited to CPAs. See

id.; BO&P § 2-101(m)(1). Finally, the American Institute of Certified

Public Accountants (“AICPA”) Statements on Standards for Attestation

Engagements, referenced in BO&P § 2-101(m)(2), govern the

preparation of opinions or conclusions about subject matter other than

financial statements, such as “a schedule of investment returns, the

effectiveness of an entity’s controls over the security of a system, or a

statement of greenhouse gas emissions.” AICPA, U.S. Attestation

Gen. 32] 39

CPAs can also offer services outside of this exclusive

bailiwick, unless prohibited by some other law or their own

professional code of conduct. See COMAR 09.24.01.06C-E

(establishing ethical limits on CPAs’ other services). The

American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (“AICPA”)

promulgates standards for various practice areas other than core

CPA practice, such as management consulting and personal

financial planning. AICPA, Statement on Standards for Consulting

Services No. 1 (1991); AICPA, Statement on Standards in Personal

Financial Planning Services (2015).

Relevant here, a practice has apparently developed of CPAs

helping clients comply with certain federal statutory reporting

requirements. See MACPA Comments at 2. CPAs have long

assisted clients with tax return preparation, see, e.g., Erwin N.

Griswold, A Further Look: Lawyers and Accountants, 41 A.B.A.

J. 1113, 1115-16 (1955), as Maryland law expressly recognizes, see

BO&P § 21-102(b)(1) (exempting CPAs from State licensing

requirements for tax return preparers). A CPA practice of assisting

with other form-based federal reporting and disclosure

requirements may have evolved by analogy to tax practice. For

example, according to MACPA, CPAs help their clients comply

with federal requirements to disclose foreign bank accounts and

interests in foreign corporations. See MACPA Comments at 2;

FinCEN, BSA Electronic Filing Requirements for Report of

Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (Jan. 2017) (“FBAR

Instructions”); IRS, Instructions for Form 5471: Information

Return of U.S. Persons with Respect to Certain Foreign

Corporations (Jan. 2024 revision). Another new area where some

CPAs are considering offering services is the beneficial ownership

disclosure requirement of the Corporate Transparency Act.

C. The Corporate Transparency Act

Congress enacted the Corporate Transparency Act as part of

the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021. Pub.

L. No. 116-283, tit. LXIV, 134 Stat. 3388, 4604 (2021) (codified

at 31 U.S.C. § 5336). The Act’s purpose was to help law

enforcement pursue bad actors who use shell companies—often

many layers of them—to conceal their illicit activities and their

Standards—AICPA (Clarified) §§ .01, .06 (2023). Originally, non-

CPAs in Maryland could provide all of these services except audits. See

84 Opinions of the Attorney General at 20. But later amendments

expanded the definition of CPA practice to include reviews,

compilations, and attestations. See 2011 Md. Laws, ch. 229; 2015 Md.

Laws, ch. 110.

40 [109 Op. Att’y

movement of funds and assets. See id. § 6402. Congress sought to

pierce the shells by “providing for the collection of beneficial

ownership information for corporations, limited liability

companies, or other similar entities.” Id.6

Compliance with the Act involves two steps. The first step is

for an entity to determine whether it is subject to the Act. The Act’s

requirements apply to any “reporting company.” See 31 U.S.C.

§ 5336(b)(1). Every corporation, LLC, or other entity that is

formed by filing with a state Secretary of State or analogous office,

as well as every foreign corporation, LLC, or other entity that

registers to do business in the United States through such an office,

is presumptively a reporting company. Id. § 5336(a)(11)(A).

The Act then sets out a number of exemptions from “reporting

company” status (and thus from the Act’s reporting requirements).

Id. § 5336(a)(11)(B). Most of the exemptions are for entities

regulated under other provisions of state or federal law, such as

securities issuers, banks, insurance companies, public utilities, and

governmental units. Id. § 5336(a)(11)(B)(i)-(xx). Another

exemption applies to entities that have more than twenty full-time

employees, a physical office, and more than $5 million in gross

sales, all in the United States. Id. § 5336(a)(11)(B)(xxi).

Conversely, an entity is also exempt if it is inactive; to qualify as

inactive an entity must have engaged in no significant recent

financial transactions, must have no assets, and must meet certain

other requirements. Id. § 5336(a)(11)(B)(xxiii). Wholly owned

6

On March 1, 2024, the United States District Court for the Northern

District of Alabama held that the Transparency Act is unconstitutional

because it exceeds the enumerated powers of Congress. National Small

Bus. United v. Yellen, No. 5:22-cv-1448-LCB, 2024 WL 899372, at *21

(N.D. Ala. Mar. 1, 2024). The court permanently enjoined the federal

government from enforcing the Act, but only against the plaintiffs in that

case: the National Small Business Association and one individual. Final

Judgment, National Small Bus. United, 2024 WL 899372 (5:22-cv-1448-

LCB), ECF No. 52; Complaint ¶¶ 11-14, National Small Bus. United,

2024 WL 899372 (5:22-cv-1448-LCB), ECF No. 1. The United States

has appealed the decision. Notice of Appeal, National Small Bus.

United, 2024 WL 899372 (5:22-cv-1448-LCB), ECF No. 54. And

FinCEN has stated that it will continue to enforce the Act against all

entities other than the plaintiffs in the Alabama litigation and the plaintiff

business association’s members. FinCEN, Updated: Notice Regarding

National Small Business United v. Yellen, No. 5:22-cv-01448 (N.D.

Ala.) (Mar. 4, 2024), https://www.fincen.gov/news/news-releases/

updated-notice-regarding-national-small-business-united-v-yellen-no-

522-cv-01448.

Gen. 32] 41

subsidiaries of exempt entities are also exempt. Id. § 5336(a)(11)(B)(xxii);

31 C.F.R. § 1010.380(c)(2)(xxii).

If an entity is a “reporting company” under the Act, the second

compliance step is to identify the company’s beneficial owners.

Only individuals can be beneficial owners. See 31 U.S.C.

§ 5336(a)(3)(A). An individual can be a beneficial owner of a

reporting company in one (or both) of two ways. First, an

individual who “exercises substantial control” over a reporting

company is a beneficial owner of the company. Id. Second, an

individual who owns or controls at least 25% of the ownership

interests in a reporting company is also a beneficial owner. Id.7

FinCEN’s implementing regulations further flesh out the

definition of “beneficial owner.” As to the first type of beneficial

ownership—“substantial control”—an individual has substantial

control over a company if they are a senior officer, if they have

authority to appoint or remove a senior officer or majority of the

board, if they “direct[], determine[], or [have] substantial influence

over” important decisions of the company, or if they have “any

other form of substantial control over the reporting company.” 31

C.F.R. § 1010.380(d)(1)(i). This control may be direct or indirect

(e.g., control exercised through another entity counts). Id.

§ 1010.380(d)(1)(ii).

Turning to the second type of beneficial ownership—25%

ownership—an individual is a beneficial owner if they own 25% or

more of a reporting company regardless of the precise nature of

their ownership interest; stock, other forms of equity, membership

interests in LLCs, and more, all may qualify. Id.

§ 1010.380(d)(2)(i). As with the “substantial control” definition,

there is a catch-all for “[a]ny other instrument, contract,

arrangement, understanding, relationship, or mechanism used to

establish ownership.” Id. § 1010.380(d)(2)(i)(E). The regulations

also provide a mechanism to identify 25% owners for an entity with

more than one type of ownership interest. Id. § 1010.380(d)(2)(iii).

7

Certain individuals who would otherwise qualify as beneficial

owners are excluded from the definition: minors; individuals who hold

an interest as nominee or custodian on behalf of another; individuals who

are employees of a reporting company and have control of, or receive

economic benefits from, the entity only in that capacity; individuals

whose interest in the company arises only from the expectation of

inheritance; and creditors who do not otherwise meet the definition of a

beneficial owner. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(a)(3)(B).

42 [109 Op. Att’y

Once a reporting company has identified its beneficial

owners, it must file the BOIR with FinCEN. The BOIR must

include certain identifying information for each beneficial owner

of a reporting company, including name, date of birth, address, and

a copy of an identification document. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(b)(2); 31

C.F.R. § 1010.380(b)(1)(ii).8 There is no requirement to report the

reason why an individual qualifies as a beneficial owner

(substantial control, 25% ownership, or both). FinCEN, Small

Entity Compliance Guide: Beneficial Ownership Information

Reporting Requirements 16 (Version 1.1, Dec. 2023)

(“Compliance Guide”).

The deadline to file depends on when the entity was created.

Generally speaking, reporting companies created or registered after

January 1, 2024, must report within 90 days after creation or U.S.

registration; entities created or registered after January 1, 2025,

must report within 30 days after creation or registration; and

entities created or registered before 2024 must report by January 1,

2025. 31 C.F.R. § 1010.380(a)(1). Although there is no annual or

periodic reporting requirement, a company must report any

changes to its previously reported BOIR within 30 days of the

change. Id. § 1010.380(a)(2).

FinCEN must maintain this information in a secure database

and release it only to authorized requesters for the purposes

specified in the Act. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(c); see also 31 C.F.R.

§ 1010.955 (implementing regulation for data access provisions).

With limited exceptions, access is only available to law

enforcement agencies for investigatory, security, or intelligence

purposes. See 31 U.S.C. § 5336(c)(2)(B). FinCEN estimates that

some 32.6 million reporting companies will need to file BOIRs in

2024 alone. Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting

Requirements, 87 Fed. Reg. 59,498, 59,549 (Sept. 30, 2022)

(“BOIR Final Rule”).

The Act comes with criminal and civil penalties. Any person

who willfully provides, or attempts to provide, false or fraudulent

beneficial ownership information to FinCEN, or willfully fails to

report complete or updated beneficial ownership information, may

be liable for a civil penalty of up to $500 per day the violation

continues, a fine of up to $10,000, and/or imprisonment for up to

8

Reporting companies formed after January 1, 2024, must identify

both their beneficial owners and their “applicants,” meaning the

individual who actually files the documents to create the entity and the

individual who directs or controls the filing. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(b)(2)(A);

31 C.F.R. § 1010.380(b)(2)(iv), (e).

Gen. 32] 43

two years. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(h)(1), (3). All senior officers of a

reporting company are liable if the company fails to file a BOIR.

See 31 C.F.R. § 1010.380(g)(4).

To help entities comply with the Act, FinCEN has issued

guidance to accompany the BOIR form. See generally Compliance

Guide, supra. In particular, FinCEN’s Small Entity Compliance

Guide offers step-by-step instructions to help an entity determine

whether it is a “reporting company” and, if so, to identify its

beneficial owners and complete the BOIR. These instructions are

intended to “provid[e] comprehensive guidance and

communicat[e] information about the reporting requirements in

plain language.” Id. at v. To that end, the instructions distill the

various questions an entity faces under the Act into flowcharts and

yes-or-no questions with illustrative examples. See, e.g., id. at 2,

5-14, 20, 22. FinCEN also publishes answers to frequently asked

questions and other informal guidance on its website. FinCEN,

Beneficial Ownership Information: Small Business Resources,

https://www.fincen.gov/boi/small-business-resources (last visited

May 2, 2024).

Some CPA organizations believe that “[d]ue to the nature of

the CPA-client relationship, a client’s first inclination may be to

turn to their CPA for advice on [the Transparency Act] rather than

their attorney,” but note that this creates various risks—including

unauthorized practice of law risk—and recommend that CPAs

explicitly exclude BOIR services from the scope of their

engagements. AICPA Member Ins. Programs, Risk Alert:

Navigating Corporate Transparency Act/Beneficial Ownership

Reporting (2024), https://www.cpai.com/Education-Resources/my-

firm/Tax-Services/What-accounting-firms-need-to-know-about-CTA. At

least one large accounting firm has announced that it “will not

advise on or assist with the preparation of BOI reporting” due to

unauthorized law practice risk. Baker Tilly, The New Beneficial

Ownership Reporting (Sept. 20, 2023),

https://www.bakertilly.com/insights/the-new-beneficial-

ownership-reporting.

But other accounting industry commentators see the BOIR

requirement as “an opportunity for accounting professionals to

expand the scope of advisory services offered.” E.g., Thomson

Reuters Tax & Accounting, Are You Ready? The Corporate

Transparency Act Becomes Effective Jan. 1, 2024 (Oct. 19, 2023),

https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/blog/are-you-ready-the-corporate-

transparency-act-becomes-effective-jan-1-2024/. The possibility

44 [109 Op. Att’y

that some CPAs might seek to offer BOIR preparation services

prompted the Board of Public Accountancy to request this opinion.

II

Analysis

A. The Definition of “Practice of Law”

“Except as otherwise provided by law, a person may not

practice, attempt to practice, or offer to practice law in the State

unless admitted to the Bar.” BO&P § 10-601(a). An individual

who is neither a lawyer, nor acting under a lawyer’s supervision,

and who performs activities that constitute “the practice of law,” is

thus engaged in the unauthorized practice of law.9 See, e.g., Lukas

v. Bar Ass’n of Montgomery County, Md., 35 Md. App. 442, 443

(1977).

The Maryland Constitution vests the authority to define “the

practice of law” in the Judiciary. Hahn Transp., 253 Md. at 583.

However, our Office has often issued official opinions on practice-

of-law questions for the guidance of our clients and the public in

areas where the Supreme Court has not yet spoken. See, e.g., 90

Opinions of the Attorney General 101 (2005); 80 Opinions of the

Attorney General 138 (1995); 79 Opinions of the Attorney General

174 (1994). Our role, then, is to “predict, as best we can,” how the

courts would resolve your question, using case law as “our most

important guide.” 107 Opinions of the Attorney General 153, 153-

54 (2022).

Your question sought guidance on what forms of “assistance

to clients in connection with BOI reporting” and “what CPA

activities relating to BOI reporting would and would not constitute

unauthorized practice of law.” A number of activities could fall

under those headings:

(1) Informing clients generally that the

BOIR requirement exists and must be

complied with;

9

Some activities that would otherwise qualify as “practice of law”

might not be unauthorized practice of law if performed under the

supervision of an attorney. For example, a supervised law clerk may

draft court filings and perform other tasks that a nonlawyer could not

perform on their own. See, e.g., Hallmon, 343 Md. at 400. Here,

however, we have assumed that CPAs would undertake their BOIR-

related activities independently, without attorney supervision.

Gen. 32] 45

(2) Answering general client questions

about the BOIR requirement without

particularizing an answer to the client’s

individual circumstances;

(3) Directing the client to guidance

published by FinCEN;

(4) Helping a client determine whether it is

a “reporting company” that must file a BOIR;

(5) Helping a client that is a “reporting

company” identify its beneficial owners (and,

for new entities, its “applicants”);

(6) Once beneficial owners have been

identified, gathering the required personal

information on each beneficial owner;

(7) Filling out the BOIR and filing it with

FinCEN.

The courts have “not endeavor[ed] to formulate a precise definition

of the practice of law.” Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 443. Instead, they

will “consider each state of facts and determine whether it falls

within the fair intendment” of the term. E.g., Attorney Grievance

Comm’n v. Shaw, 354 Md. 636, 649 (1999) (quoting In re Mark

W., 303 Md. 1, 8 (1985)).

But case law nonetheless offers some general guidelines. “To

determine whether an individual has engaged in the practice of law,

the focus of the inquiry should ‘be on whether the activity in

question required legal knowledge and skill in order to apply legal

principles and precedent.’” E.g., Hallmon, 343 Md. at 397 (quoting

In re Discipio, 163 Ill.2d 515, 523 (1994)). After all, the practice

of law “connot[es] much more than merely working with legally-

related matters.” Attorney Grievance Comm’n v. Sperling, 459 Md.

194, 267 (2018) (quoting Mark W., 303 Md. at 19). A central

question in determining whether an activity is the practice of law,

then, is whether that activity requires a lawyer’s skills, training, and

professional judgment. See, e.g., id.; see also, e.g., Kennedy v. Bar

Ass’n of Montgomery County, 316 Md. 646, 662 (1989) (“Utilizing

legal education, training, and experience an attorney applies the

special analysis of the profession to a client’s problem.”); Hahn

Transp., 253 Md. at 585; Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 448-49; 90

Opinions of the Attorney General at 104.

In other words, to determine whether an activity is the practice

of law, it is necessary to assess how far that activity implicates the

46 [109 Op. Att’y

fundamental, basic knowledge and skills of a lawyer, which are

taught in law school, tested on the bar exam, and honed through

experience in practice.10 These fundamentals have been defined,

to some extent, by the Supreme Court of Maryland in the Rules of

Professional Conduct. They include the knowledge of substantive

legal principles appropriate to a matter, see Md. Rule 19-301.1 cmt.

1; the skills of legal research, analyzing precedent, evaluating

evidence, legal drafting, and “determining what kind of legal

problems a situation may involve” (“issue spotting”), see id. cmt.

2; and the judgment to determine the best legal means of pursuing

a client’s objectives, including making tactical decisions on the

client’s behalf where appropriate, see Md. Rule 19-301.2 cmt. 1.

The more these skills and legal knowledge are required, the more

likely an activity is the “practice of law.”

The courts and our opinions have also identified activities that

usually do require, or traditionally have been understood to require,

a lawyer’s training and skills. The bulk of Maryland precedent on

unauthorized practice involves advocacy for others before courts

and government agencies or activities ancillary to such advocacy,

including advice on advocacy proceedings, preparation of

pleadings and documents related to those proceedings, and

negotiations with adverse parties. Although the courts have

avoided stating categorical rules, such activities will typically

constitute the practice of law. See, e.g., Attorney Grievance

Comm’n v. Smith, 443 Md. 351, 368-69 (2015); 80 Opinions of the

Attorney General at 143; 65 Opinions of the Attorney General 28,

30-31 (1980); see also BO&P § 10-101(h)(1)(ii), (h)(2)(iii).

Another area that has been held to require legal training and

skill is the preparation of customized legal instruments that create

or alter legal rights, such as wills, deeds, or contracts. See, e.g.,

Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 444, 448-49 (involving a contract); Attorney

Grievance Comm’n v. Brooke, 374 Md. 155, 176-77 (2003)

(involving a will); 90 Opinions of the Attorney General at 105

(involving real estate documents); see also BO&P

§ 10-101(h)(2)(ii). These activities, too, are likely to be considered

law practice, although as always the courts will consider each case

on its own facts.

10

Maryland law defines the scope of some other professions in a

similar way. For example, the Maryland Architects Act provides that an

activity does not constitute the practice of architecture unless it “requires

education, training, and experience in architecture.” BO&P

§ 3-101(l)(1).

Gen. 32] 47

The Supreme Court of Maryland has also said, generally, that

“advising clients by applying legal principles to the client’s

problem is practicing law.” Kennedy, 316 Md. at 663; see also id.

at 666 (“[T]he very acts of interview, analysis and explanation of

legal rights constitute practicing law in Maryland.”). Similarly, the

Appellate Court has stated that “[w]here trial work is not involved

but the preparation of legal documents, their interpretation, the

giving of legal advice, or the application of legal principles to

problems of any complexity, is involved, these activities are still

the practice of law.” Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 448 (quoting F.

Trowbridge vom Baur, Administrative Agencies and Unauthorized

Practice of Law, 48 A.B.A. J. 715, 716 (1962)). And the General

Assembly’s definition of practice of law includes “giving legal

advice.” BO&P § 10-101(h)(1)(i). Thus, one might argue that any

application of law to fact, for a client, is “legal advice,” and thus is

the practice of law. See, e.g., Disciplinary Counsel v. Deters, 165

Ohio St.3d 537, 541 (2021).

However, these statements by the Maryland courts should be

understood in context. They were made in cases that either

involved one of the traditional law-practice activities identified

above, see Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 445-46 (involving representation

before administrative agencies and customized contract drafting),

or involved individuals who actually held themselves out as

Maryland attorneys, see Kennedy, 316 Md. at 665-66; see also

Somuah v. Flachs, 352 Md. 241, 262 (1998) (distinguishing

Kennedy on that basis). Of course, the practice of law is not limited

to these situations, and advising clients by applying law to fact will

often qualify as law practice. But because the courts will consider

each practice-of-law case on its own facts, we do not understand

the courts’ general statements to mean that application of law to

fact will always be “legal advice” within the meaning of the

unauthorized practice prohibition. We think that the ultimate

question remains whether the particular activity at issue requires a

lawyer’s knowledge and skills, and thus comes within the “fair

intendment” of the term “practice of law.” E.g., Shaw, 354 Md. at

649.

Under that test, an activity is not “the practice of law” just

because it requires some knowledge of a particular area of law. For

example, an activity is not the practice of law when it requires no

more than the “elementary knowledge of the law” that “the

ordinary or average [layperson] may be deemed to possess.” See

Lukas, 35 Md. App at 448 (quoting R.E. Heinselman, Annotation,

What Amounts to Practice of Law, 111 A.L.R. 19, 24-25 (1937));

80 Opinions of the Attorney General at 141.

48 [109 Op. Att’y

Even activities that may require more than an ordinary

layperson’s substantive knowledge of the law, as well as

application of that knowledge to facts, may not qualify as practice

of law if they do not call for a lawyer’s training, skills, and

judgment. For example, although calculating the capital gains and

losses of a stock portfolio for tax purposes involves the application

of tax law principles to particular facts, it is not necessarily the

practice of law. See Shaw, 354 Md. at 641, 652. This could be

because, as Massachusetts’ highest court put it, an activity that is

“commonly performed by competent nonlawyer professionals”

might not be law practice. Real Estate Bar Ass’n for Mass. v.

National Real Estate Info. Servs., 459 Mass. 512, 521 (2011); cf.

Mark W., 303 Md. at 19 (holding that, for purposes of admission-

without-examination rule, work as a hearing examiner for a State

agency “in a very limited field of law” was not practice of law).

An established practice of nonlawyer involvement in an activity

may be evidence that a lawyer’s training and skills are not needed

for that activity.11

Our Office has also opined that many activities of an estate’s

personal representative do not rise to the level of “practice of law,”

such that a nonlawyer may perform them and—especially relevant

here—the staff of the office of a Register of Wills may assist with

them. See 61 Opinions of the Attorney General 738, 738-39, 740

n.1 (1976); 56 Opinions of the Attorney General 250, 251 (1971);

Md. Op. Att’y Gen. No. 76-102, at 2-3 (June 30, 1976)

(unpublished). Even though the administration of an estate

involves the application of procedural and substantive law to a

particular matter, much of the process is sufficiently

11

We understand that CPAs regularly prepare tax returns and give tax

advice to their clients, which involves the interpretation and application

of complex legal rules. See, e.g., McManus, supra, at 541-42. This

practice, by itself, does not establish that CPAs may also assist in BOIR

preparation without restrictions. You did not ask, and so we do not opine

here, about how the unauthorized practice of law prohibition interacts

with CPAs’ tax practice. But at least some aspects of CPA tax practice

are expressly authorized both by Maryland law, see BO&P

§ 21-102(b)(1), and (at least as to federal taxes) by IRS regulations, see

31 C.F.R. §§ 10.2(a)(4), 10.3(b). Also, CPAs’ tax practice activities

have a decades-long history, see, e.g., Griswold, supra, at 1115-16, and

are more closely related to CPAs’ traditional core function of verifying

and communicating financial data, see supra Part I.B; cf. 52 Opinions of

the Attorney General 244, 246 (1967) (opining that custom and practice

may be relevant to the definition of “practice of law”). None of these

arguments carry over to BOIR preparation. Thus, we do not think CPAs’

tradition of tax practice is directly relevant, one way or the other, to the

“practice of law” analysis for BOIR preparation.

Gen. 32] 49

“administrative” that “any advice given by the Register with

respect to those functions would not constitute the unauthorized

practice of law.” Md. Op. Att’y Gen. No. 76-102, at 2. This is

further indication that not every activity requiring some knowledge

of law or involving application of law to particular circumstances

is the practice of law.

We also think the courts would recognize the practical

problems with an inflexible rule that any application of law to fact

for another is law practice. Members of many recognized

professions apply law to fact in the course of their work. For

example, architects must assess (for themselves and their clients)

whether the plans for a building comply with applicable building

codes. See Annette Davis Perrochet, Architects and Engineers

§ 3:3 (June 2023 update). Electricians do the same with electrical

codes. See BO&P § 6-101(j) (defining a “master electrician” as

someone who has the ability to provide electrical services “in a

manner that complies with applicable . . . codes[] or law”).

Professional land surveyors prepare plats and similar documents

affecting property rights. See BO&P 15-101(k). Licensed athlete

agents negotiate contracts on their clients’ behalf, and presumably

also explain contract terms to their clients. See Md. Code Ann.,

Bus. Reg. § 4-401(b), (c). And registered tax preparers give tax

advice and prepare tax returns. See BO&P § 21-101(f). Holding

that the application of legal principles to a client’s situation is

always practicing law would impair or destroy these licensed

professionals’ ability to function. See Real Estate Bar, 459 Mass.

at 518 (noting this issue); cf. Kennedy, 316 Md. at 662 (rejecting a

definition of law practice that “would be impossible to apply and

enforce in the real world”).

Finally, in deciding whether a given activity violates the

prohibition on unauthorized practice, the court may also consider

the purpose of the unauthorized practice prohibition, which is to

protect the public and the legal system from unqualified and/or

unethical practitioners. See R.G.S., 312 Md. at 638. In some

situations, there will be “little consumer benefit” to requiring an

attorney to perform a particular task, and “little threat that the

absence of an attorney will result in the consumer harm that the

prohibition against unauthorized practice is designed to prevent.”

90 Opinions of the Attorney General at 106.

50 [109 Op. Att’y

With those principles in mind, we will consider whether any

of the categories of BOIR-related activity listed above qualifies as

the practice of law.12

B. BOIR Assistance and the Practice of Law

1. Providing General Information About the BOIR

Requirement

We first consider whether it would be practice of law to

inform clients generally that the BOIR requirement exists and must

be complied with; to answer general questions about the BOIR

requirement, without particularizing an answer to the client’s

individual circumstances; and/or to direct the client to FinCEN’s

published guidance.

In our opinion, none of these activities would constitute the

practice of law. Our Office has consistently opined that providing

general information about the law, without expressing a view about

the client’s particular circumstances, is not law practice. For

example, in 79 Opinions of the Attorney General 174, we

concluded that a nonlawyer social worker could inform a birth

parent of the existence of certain statutory rights, including the

right to revoke consent to an adoption, id. at 175-77. Similarly, we

have opined that it is not unauthorized practice of law for a “lay

advocate” to give domestic violence survivors “unadorned . . .

information about what rights and remedies exist.” 80 Opinions of

the Attorney General at 142; see also, e.g., Letter from Robert N.

McDonald, Chief Counsel for Opinions & Advice, to Robert J.

Rhudy, Esq., Maryland Legal Servs. Corp., at 9 (Oct. 3, 2001)

(“Rhudy Letter”) (“[A] legal services hotline that simply dispenses

general information about an area of the law, as opposed to

12

If FinCEN were to promulgate a regulation expressly authorizing

CPAs to perform certain activities related to BOIR preparation, our

analysis could change. Such a federal regulation might preempt the

State’s unauthorized practice of law rule as applied to BOIR preparation.

See Sperry v. Florida ex rel. Florida Bar, 373 U.S. 379, 385 (1963)

(holding that regulations authorizing nonlawyers to practice before the

U.S. Patent Office preempted state unauthorized practice of law rules).

But while FinCEN has recognized that some reporting companies may

turn to CPAs for BOIR preparation, see, e.g., BOIR Final Rule at 59,571,

so far we see no evidence of an intent to preempt State unauthorized

practice of law rules, see Wells v. Chevy Chase Bank, F.S.B., 377 Md.

197, 211 (2003) (noting that analysis of preemptive effect of federal

regulation turns on federal agency’s intent).

Gen. 32] 51

particularized legal advice, would not be involved in the practice

of law.”).

This view rests on “common practice and common sense,”

because “[c]ommerce and government would grind to a halt if

every piece of information about a statutory right or obligation

could be communicated only by a lawyer.” 79 Opinions of the

Attorney General at 176. But our view that providing general

information about the law is not law practice also aligns with the

principle that an activity is not the practice of law if it does not

require a lawyer’s skill and judgment. Merely pointing out the

existence of certain legal rights and remedies requires some

knowledge of the law but does not necessarily require a lawyer’s

specialized abilities.

It thus would not be the practice of law for a CPA to offer

clients general information about the BOIR requirement or to

answer general questions about it. See Rhudy Letter at 9. Along

similar lines, we think a CPA could direct a client to BOIR

guidance promulgated by FinCEN, such as the FinCEN

Compliance Guide and FAQs on the FinCEN website, without

straying beyond the boundary of giving “general information”

about the law. CPAs can thus provide this kind of basic

information about the BOIR requirement to their clients.

2. “Mechanically” Filling Out and Filing the BOIR Form

If a client were to determine for itself that it is a reporting

company and provide its CPA with a list of beneficial owners, it

would not be “practice of law” for the CPA to gather the necessary

information about each beneficial owner (address, birthdate, etc.),

enter it on the BOIR form, and file the form with FinCEN. The

“mere mechanical filling out of forms” does not require a lawyer’s

skills and so is not the practice of law. Lukas, 35 Md. App at 448.

Following Lukas, we have concluded that it would not be practice

of law for a loan officer to insert factual information, such as the

name of the borrower and address of the property, in a standardized

mortgage form. 90 Opinions of the Attorney General at 105.

Similarly, the BOIR form is a standardized, government-provided

form, and merely entering factual information on the form and

filing it with FinCEN would not be law practice.

52 [109 Op. Att’y

3. Determining Whether the Client Is a “Reporting

Company” or Identifying a Client’s Beneficial Owners

A client might ask their CPA for help in determining whether

it is a “reporting company” that is required to file a BOIR, or with

identifying its “beneficial owners” as defined in the Act. These

determinations are closer to the line of “practice of law” than the

other activities we have discussed so far. They require applying

the law—the Transparency Act and implementing regulations—to

a particular client’s circumstances. But this is only the beginning

of the analysis. See supra Part II.A. The ultimate question is

whether helping a client determine its “reporting company” status

or identify beneficial owners comes within the “fair intendment” of

the term “practice of law,” and whether it calls for a lawyer’s

professional training, skills, and judgment. See, e.g., Hallmon, 343

Md. at 397.

An important consideration in this analysis is that FinCEN has

published detailed instructions for BOIR reporting. See generally

Compliance Guide, supra. The instructions provide a series of yes-

or-no questions (some in flowchart form) and arithmetic questions.

Answering the questions posed by these instructions will, in theory,

provide all the information one needs to comply with the BOIR

requirement, including the determination of whether an entity is a

“reporting company” and who its beneficial owners are.

Compliance Guide at 2-31.13 Once an entity has gone through the

instructions, assuming it is a reporting company, only the

ministerial task of listing beneficial owners on the BOIR form and

filing it will remain.

FinCEN designed the BOIR instructions for lay users. See id.

at v. In fact, FinCEN expects that “many, if not most” entities,

aided by the instructions, should be able to comply with the BOIR

requirement without professional assistance from either an attorney

or a CPA. FinCEN, Beneficial Ownership Information:

Frequently Asked Questions § B.7 (Apr. 18, 2024),

https://www.fincen.gov/boi-faqs.

13

Two other aspects of BOIR compliance covered by the instructions

are the determination whether a person who would otherwise qualify as

a “beneficial owner” is exempt from that status, Compliance Guide at

29-31; see supra note 7, and the identification of “applicants”—the

individuals responsible for filing the paperwork to create a new entity,

Compliance Guide at 32-36; see supra note 8. Although we do not

separately discuss these issues, the framework we set forth below applies

to them as well.

Gen. 32] 53

The existence and accessibility of these government-provided

instructions is a relevant consideration in the practice-of-law

analysis. “Filling out standard government forms for others is not

necessarily the practice of law.” Real Estate Bar, 459 Mass. at 525.

This is because such forms are often designed to be filled out by

laypersons, without the need for any independent legal knowledge.

See Lowell Bar Ass’n v. Loeb, 315 Mass. 176, 185 (1943) (noting

that in many cases, an income tax form “can readily be filled out

by any intelligent taxpayer . . . who has the patience to study the

instructions”); Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. v. Kentucky Bar

Ass’n, 113 S.W.3d 105, 122 (Ky. 2003) (recognizing that, at real

estate closings, a lawyer is not needed for questions that can be

answered “by reading the face of the document or by offering a

blackletter description”).

Completion of a government form in compliance with

instructions designed for laypersons thus does not necessarily

require a lawyer’s skills. This is especially true for a reporting or

disclosure form. With this kind of form, neither discretionary

judgment as to means or ends nor unguided issue-spotting is

involved; the only objective is correct compliance with one specific

mandate. See Hargis v. JLB Corp., 357 S.W.3d 574, 585 (Mo.

2011) (holding that preparation of loan applications and financial

disclosures was not practice of law because “[t]he forms state what

information is required to be filled in or provided” and “accuracy,

rather than discretion—legal or otherwise—is what is required”).

And if the form’s instructions are designed to be understood by

laypersons, then neither independent knowledge of substantive law

nor legal interpretation skills are required to correctly complete the

form.

Consistent with that view, we have recognized that walking a

layperson through the instructions for a legal form is not

necessarily the practice of law. For example, our 1995 opinion

concluded that a lay advocate could help a domestic violence

survivor “fill out a form pleading herself by defining terms in the

instructions . . . or by pointing out where on the form particular

information is to be set out.” 80 Opinions of the Attorney General

at 143. We have also concluded that filling in factual information

in a standardized mortgage form is not the practice of law. 90

Opinions of the Attorney General at 106-07.

In other contexts, however, assisting with a form might well

be the practice of law. For example, where a form will be filed in

an adversarial proceeding, creates or alters legal rights (like a

contract or deed), or requires discretionary choices among

54 [109 Op. Att’y

alternatives (such that advice is needed on the possible legal effects

of each choice), assistance with the form that goes beyond merely

transcribing factual information is more likely to be considered the

practice of law. See, e.g., 80 Opinions of the Attorney General at

144; In re Peterson, No. 19-24045, 2022 WL 1800949, at *46-48

(Bankr. D. Md. June 1, 2022) (holding that a nonprofit engaged in

unauthorized practice of law by offering software to guide

bankruptcy petitioners’ choice of exemptions for property).

Similarly, helping a client identify which forms are needed to

achieve their objectives in the first place may, in some cases,

qualify as law practice. See Attorney Grievance Comm’n v.

Brisbon, 422 Md. 625, 638-39 (2011) (involving selection of

immigration forms). But none of those circumstances exist here.

When considering unauthorized practice questions, it is also

important to keep in mind the purpose of the unauthorized practice

prohibition, which seeks to prevent incompetent and/or unethical

“representation” by nonlawyers. See, e.g., R.G.S., 312 Md. at 638;

90 Opinions of the Attorney General at 106. In the context of

advocacy before tribunals or preparation of legal instruments, for

example, an error by an incompetent practitioner can cause

irreparable harm, such as a missed statute of limitations, a

judgment against the client that a competent lawyer could have

avoided, a client bound to unfavorable contract terms, or a will that

doesn’t effectuate the client’s wishes. See, e.g., Md. Rule 19-301.3

cmt. 3. But with a government form that merely implements a

statutory disclosure requirement, the probability of a mistake

irreparably harming the client’s interests, through the permanent

loss of a valuable legal right or the taking on of an unwanted legal

duty, is smaller.

A BOIR does come with legal consequences for

misstatements or material omissions—potentially severe

consequences—but the same is true for almost every document

filed with the government. Moreover, an error on a BOIR will

cause no legal harm unless the error is willful. See 31 U.S.C.

§ 5336(h)(1). And an error or omission stemming solely from a

good-faith misinterpretation of the instructions is unlikely to meet

that threshold. Under the Transparency Act, a “willful” violation

must be both voluntary and intentional. 31 U.S.C. § 5336(h)(6);

see also Jerman v. Carlisle, McNellie, Rini, Kramer & Ulrich LPA,

559 U.S. 573, 584-85 (2010) (noting that, in general, a statutory

violation based on a mistake of law is not considered “willful”). So

assuming the CPA acts in good faith, the risk that any errors they

make in BOIR preparation will harm the client is relatively low, at

least compared to errors in traditional law-practice activities.

Gen. 32] 55

Furthermore, CPAs, like lawyers, are subject to high ethical

standards. The CPA code of professional conduct, adopted by the

Board of Public Accountancy, covers subjects such as

independence, truthfulness, competence, and confidentiality.

COMAR 09.24.01.06; cf. Sperry v. Florida ex rel. Florida Bar, 373

U.S. 379, 402 (1963) (noting that state’s interest in protecting the

public from unqualified practitioners was lessened in the case of

patent agents who must meet Patent Office standards). A CPA

violating this code of conduct may face reprimand, monetary

penalties, license suspension, or license revocation. BO&P

§ 2-315.

Where, as here, the risk of errors causing irreparable harm to

the client is small, and the service is provided by a practitioner

subject to ethical constraints, there is “little threat that the absence

of an attorney will result in the consumer harm that the prohibition

against unauthorized practice is designed to prevent.” 90 Opinions

of the Attorney General at 106. These considerations standing

alone would not necessarily be enough to take an activity outside

the bounds of law practice. A low-risk activity may nonetheless

qualify as practice of law. But the low risk of client harm is a

relevant factor in determining whether a trained and qualified

lawyer’s skills are necessary for a given task.

With these principles as our starting point, we will make our

best effort to offer guidance about which activities in BOIR

assistance (beyond providing general information and mechanical

form-filling) would be unauthorized practice of law. However,

because the array of questions and fact situations that might

potentially exist in the BOIR context is so large, and because of the

courts’ case-by-case approach in this area, we are unable to provide

a bright-line set of rules that will address every potential

circumstance in advance. Identifying unauthorized practice of law

in this context is less a question of kind and more a question of

degree: the degree to which the situation calls for a lawyer’s

knowledge, training, skills, and judgment. With that said, the

following general principles may assist in evaluating particular

situations.

i. Walking the Client Through the Instructions

First, we think a CPA may walk a client through the

instructions as laid out in FinCEN’s Compliance Guide by

directing the client’s attention to each question in turn and

recording the client’s answers. This includes following the yes-or-

no branches on one of the instructions’ flowcharts, e.g.,

56 [109 Op. Att’y

Compliance Guide at 2, and performing simple calculations to

determine ownership shares, id. at 23, as appropriate. If the client

is able to answer all of these questions, then determination of

“reporting company” status and identification of beneficial owners

based on their answers will be a merely “mechanical” function. See

Lukas, 35 Md. App at 448. Given that the instructions are designed

for laypeople, merely walking a client through the instructions in

this way does not seem to require a lawyer’s skills. See 80

Opinions of the Attorney General at 143.

Some of the individual questions within the instructions might

call for some form of legal analysis, such as whether a particular

individual has authority to appoint or remove a majority of the

entity’s board of directors. See infra Part II.B.3.iii. But we suspect

that, in many cases, the client will nonetheless be able to answer a

lot of these questions based on their own knowledge. For example,

an existing entity is likely to already know whether it is a federally

regulated bank, and an entity’s management is likely to know who,

if anyone, controls the seats on its board of directors. A CPA who

merely asks the client these questions and notes the answers would

clearly not be practicing law. However, to ensure that the client

does not explicitly or implicitly rely on the CPA for legal advice

during this process, we recommend that the CPA warn the client

that the CPA cannot provide legal advice and that the client should

consult an attorney if uncertain about any legal question. See 90

Opinions of the Attorney General at 102 (favorably noting loan

officers’ similar practice when completing mortgage forms).

ii. Defining Terms

Nor do we think a CPA is necessarily limited to reciting the

instructions’ questions and recording the client’s answers. For

example, based on the logic of our 1995 opinion involving

domestic violence survivors’ advocates, we think it would not be

the practice of law for a CPA to define at least some terms in order

to clarify the questions for a client. See 80 Opinions of the Attorney

General at 143. At a minimum, this would include terms like

“corporation” or “stock” that would be familiar to a layperson with

only “the most elementary knowledge of law.” Id. at 141 (quoting

Lukas, 35 Md. App. at 448). And although the question is closer,

we think a CPA could also define terms, like “equity” or “trust,”

that would be familiar to CPAs through their own training and

expertise, even if not to the general public, Compliance Guide at

21-22. Terms that are within the expertise of a reasonably

competent CPA do not necessarily require legal knowledge or

training to define. Moreover, there is no consumer-protection

Gen. 32] 57

reason to prohibit a CPA from defining terms that are commonly

known by CPAs. See 90 Opinions of the Attorney General at 106.

iii. Answering Questions from the Form for the

Client

More difficult issues could arise if a client were to ask their

CPA to go beyond walking them through the instructions and

defining terms. For example, a client might seek advice from their

CPA on how to answer a question from the instructions when the

client is uncertain how the instructions apply to the client’s

situation; might ask a CPA to answer one or more of those

questions for the client; or might want to delegate the BOIR

preparation process in its entirety to the CPA.

As always, whether a CPA can help the client answer a

question in the instructions, or actually answer some or all of those

questions on the client’s behalf, depends on whether answering the

question(s) would require legal knowledge and skill. “Legal

knowledge and skill” includes awareness of substantive rules of

law; legal research skills; facility with general legal principles, like

the rules of statutory interpretation or the principles of analyzing,

weighing, and analogizing from precedent; and the ability to “issue

spot,” that is, to identify legal problems or legal options in a given

fact situation. See supra Part II.A; Md. Rule 19-301.1; Hallmon,

343 Md. at 397 (explaining that the practice of law involves

application of “legal principles and precedent”). There are no

bright lines here, but a spectrum: The more this knowledge and

these skills are involved in answering a question, the more likely it

is that answering the question would be practicing law.

Under this “legal knowledge and skill” test, a CPA who goes

beyond walking clients through the instructions, and instead

answers one or more of the questions themselves, will not

automatically be practicing law. See 90 Opinions of the Attorney

General at 102, 106 (concluding that a bank employee filling out a

standardized mortgage form with factual information, such as the

address of a property, involves little or no legal knowledge or skill).

For instance, we doubt any court would hold that it takes legal

knowledge or skill to identify the CEO of a company. See

Compliance Guide at 20.

Nor does the “legal knowledge and skill” test necessarily

preclude factual research and analysis. A CPA likely may still

answer questions that require gathering facts from the client’s

records or the CPA’s preexisting knowledge. To take one likely

58 [109 Op. Att’y

scenario, it would at least ordinarily not seem to require substantive

knowledge of law, or any of the legal skills identified above, to

compile a list of holders of one of the types of ownership interest

identified in the instructions, such as common stock. See id. at 22-

23. And while it may require legal knowledge and skill to

determine in the first instance whether an entity is required to

register under a particular statutory regime, see, e.g., id. at 5, it

might not require such knowledge to determine whether an entity

is in fact already registered under a particular regime—for

example, whether it has registered a security with the SEC.

In other cases, however, answering the client’s questions

might well require legal knowledge and skill and would be

tantamount to giving legal advice about how to apply the law to the

client’s particular facts. In that event, answering the client’s

questions would constitute the practice of law. Although (as

discussed above) the application of law to specific facts is not

always the practice of law, see supra Part II.A., it can certainly rise

to the level of “legal advice,” Kennedy, 316 Md. at 663, 666, that

needs to be performed by a lawyer when, under the circumstances,

a lawyer’s knowledge and skills are required, see, e.g., Shaw, 354

Md. at 649.

For example, questions such as whether an individual controls

a majority of board seats, Compliance Guide at 20, or whether a

type of interest in the company that is not mentioned in the

instructions qualifies as an ownership interest, see id. at 22, might

in some cases require legal skills to answer, depending on the

extent to which analysis and interpretation of legal documents is

required. As another example, the question of whether an entity is

exempt from reporting on the ground that it “exercises

governmental authority,” id. at 5, seems to be, at least in Maryland,

a primarily legal question involving analysis of the entity’s legal

powers and functions in light of State law precedent on similar

questions, see, e.g., Napata v. University of Md. Med. Sys. Corp.,

417 Md. 724, 729, 737 (2011). Again, we do not suggest that the

client cannot answer these questions themselves. We suggest only

that it would be difficult for a CPA to answer such a question for a

client, or to guide a client in answering, without practicing law.

A client also might ask a CPA to answer general questions

that go beyond individual items on the form or in the instructions.

For example, a client might ask whether there are any beneficial

owners who have not yet been identified. This kind of question

might be challenging for a CPA to answer without engaging in the

unauthorized practice of law. It would presumably require the CPA

Gen. 32] 59

to consider in the abstract whether some possible but as-yet-

unidentified individual(s) might be covered either by one of the

specific “beneficial owner” categories or by the “catch-all”

questions in the instructions—whether there are “any other

individuals who have substantial control over your company,”

Compliance Guide at 20, or “any other instrument, contract,

arrangement, understanding, relationship, or mechanism to

establish ownership,” id. at 22. This is the sort of unguided issue

spotting in a legal context that lawyers normally perform.14

Finally, we doubt that a client will be able to delegate the

BOIR preparation process to the CPA in its entirety, that is, to ask

that the CPA complete every aspect of the BOIR without client

assistance based entirely on the CPA’s pre-existing knowledge and

factual records requested from the client. There are at least some

questions in the BOIR instructions, including the catch-all

questions, that would be difficult for a CPA to answer without the

application of legal knowledge and skill. As we have explained,

the CPA can walk the client through such questions and the client

can answer them, but the CPA who answers them alone risks

practicing law.

Again, we cannot answer every potential question in advance.

A CPA who wishes to provide BOIR assistance will need to use

their best judgment, in light of the principles and examples above,

to decide whether answering a particular question in the BOIR

context requires consultation with a lawyer.15

14

The presence of these “catch-all” questions does not prevent the

CPA from walking the client through the instructions, or from defining

specific words in the catch-all questions for the client, as we have

discussed. However, we doubt that a CPA will be able to answer these

questions for the client. Instead, the client will need to answer them

based on their own knowledge of the company and individuals connected

with the company.

15

The Act requires an entity to file an updated BOIR whenever the

company’s previously reported information changes. See 31 U.S.C.

§ 5336(b)(1)(D); 31 C.F.R. § 1010.380(a)(2). MACPA asked about the

possibility that a CPA might be asked to assist “in developing internal

procedures to monitor ongoing compliance, making sure that any

changes in beneficial ownership are promptly reflected in the reports.”

MACPA Comments at 2. Without knowing what such a compliance

program would look like, it is difficult to opine in the abstract on whether

designing such a program would involve practicing law. However, as

we have just noted, it would be difficult for a CPA to provide

comprehensive assurance that an entity’s BOIR is complete and requires

no updates without engaging in the practice of law.

60 [109 Op. Att’y

III

Conclusion

In our opinion, the Maryland courts would most likely hold

that a CPA may, without violating the prohibition on unauthorized

practice of law, provide clients general information about the

Transparency Act and the BOIR requirement without tailoring the

information to any client’s individual situation, or fill out and file

a BOIR form using a list of beneficial owners submitted by the

client. Though the question is closer, a CPA likely also may help

a client to determine whether it is a “reporting company,” or to

identify its “beneficial owners” within the meaning of the

Transparency Act, by walking the client through FinCEN’s

instructions, by defining terms that are familiar to nonlawyers

and/or CPAs, or by answering questions for the client where the

question and answer do not call for legal knowledge or skills.

However, a CPA generally should not answer a BOIR-related

question for a client where there is uncertainty as to the answer and

resolving that uncertainty would require legal knowledge, skill, and

judgment.

Anthony G. Brown

Attorney General of Maryland

Thomas S. Chapman

Deputy Chief, Opinions and

Advice

Patrick B. Hughes

Chief Counsel, Opinions and Advice

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.