noting that a separate statement that is not responsive to movant's statement “is neither contemplated nor permitted by the Local Rules”
How later courts described this case
- noting that a separate statement that is not responsive to movant's statement “is neither contemplated nor permitted by the Local Rules”
- “[w]hen a police officer has received a reliable identification by a victim of his or her attacker, the police have probable cause”
- “If Plaintiffs have not proffered evidence sufficient to create a triable issue of fact as to all five prongs, their malicious prosecution claim must fail as a matter of law.”
- trooper entitled to qualified immunity where probable cause existed for arrest
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
JOSIAH CAYENNE,
Plaintiff, CIVIL NO. 3:23-CV-01543
v.
(LATELLA, M.J.)
DETECTIVE JOHN BOHRMAN,
Defendant.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
This matter stems from a 2019 incident, where a Mount Pocono
West High School student reported that a fellow student, the Plaintiff,
Josiah Cayenne, sexually assaulted her on a school activity bus.
Following that report and a preliminary investigation, school officials
referred the matter to local law enforcement. Ultimately, the Mount
Pocono Regional Police Department filed criminal charges against
Cayenne. Cayenne entered into a plea agreement, pleading guilty to
corruption of minors and was sentenced to one year of probation. He
filed an appeal, and the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed his
adjudication of delinquency based upon the language of the
Pennsylvania statute criminalizing the corruption of minors.
Cayenne then initiated this federal lawsuit against five
defendants. Following an amended pleading and multiple motions to
dismiss, the sole remaining defendant is Detective John Bohrman
(“Detective Bohrman”). Detective Bohrman has filed a motion for
summary judgment, which is ripe for disposition. For the reasons set
forth herein, his motion will be granted.
1. BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Plaintiff commenced this action by filing a Complaint on
September 15, 2023 against Defendants Tobyhanna Township, PA,
Coolbaugh Township, Chief of Police Chris Wagner (“Chief Wagner”),
Detective Bohrman, and Dean Nick Morrell (“Dean Morrell”). (Doc. 1).
On March 27, 2024, Defendants Chief Wagner and Detective Bohrman
filed a Motion to Dismiss. (Doc. 14). Plaintiff filed a motion for leave to
file an amended complaint on April 12, 2024. (Doc. 16). Magistrate
Judge Carlson entered an Order on April 15, 2024, granting Plaintiff’s
motion to amend and dismissing Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss as
moot. (Doc. 18). Multiple motions to dismiss were subsequently filed by
Defendants. First, Defendants Detective Bohrman and Police Chief
Wagner filed a Motion to Dismiss on April 17, 2024. (Doc. 20). Dean
2
Morell then filed a Motion to Dismiss on May 10, 2024. (Doc. 22).
Finally, Defendants Tobyhanna Township and Coolbaugh Township
filed a Motion to Dismiss on May 14, 2024. (Doc. 23). Plaintiff again
filed a “Motion for Leave to File Amended Complaint” on May 28, 2024.
(Doc. 31). Magistrate Judge Carlson denied Plaintiff’s second Motion
for Leave to File Amended Complaint without prejudice due to
Plaintiff’s failure to follow Local Rule 15.1. (Doc. 35). On June 3, 2024,
the parties consented to have Magistrate Judge Carlson conduct all
further proceedings.1 (Doc. 34). On June 17, 2024, Plaintiff filed a new
“Motion for Leave to File Amended Complaint” (Doc. 36), which was
again denied without prejudice due to Plaintiff’s failure to comply with
Local Rule 15.1. (Doc. 37).
1 This matter was reassigned to Magistrate Judge Caraballo on January
30, 2025 and subsequently reassigned to the undersigned Magistrate
Judge on June 10, 2025. On June 24, 2025, we issued an Order
notifying the parties that the matter was transferred to the
undersigned on June 10, 2025 and that we intended to continue to
exercise the jurisdiction previously consented to by the parties. (Doc.
61). We provided the parties with an opportunity to object to our
continued exercise of jurisdiction. (Id.). No such objections were filed.
3
On August 5, 2024, Magistrate Judge Carlson entered a
Memorandum and Order granting Defendant Dean Morell’s Motion to
Dismiss. (Docs. 39, 40). On that same date, he also entered a
Memorandum and Order granting Defendants Tobyhanna and
Coolbaugh Townships’ motion to dismiss. (Docs. 41, 42). The following
day, Magistrate Judge Carlson granted in part and denied in part Chief
Wagner and Detective Bohrman’s Motion to Dismiss. (Docs. 43, 44).
More specifically, he granted Chief Wagner’s Motion to Dismiss in full
and granted Detective Bohrman’s Motion to Dismiss with respect to the
intentional inflection of emotional distress claim but denied the motion
in all other respects. (Doc. 44). Further, he ordered Plaintiff to “submit
a more definite statement of his remaining claims against Detective
Bohrman within 30 days.” (Id.). Plaintiff did not comply with that
portion of the Court’s Order.
On October 7, 2024, Detective Bohrman filed an Answer (Doc. 48)
to Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint (Doc. 19). On January 30, 2025,
Detective Bohrman filed a Motion for Summary Judgment and filed a
supporting brief the following day. (Doc. 55, 56). On February 28,
2025, Plaintiff filed an Answer to the Statement of Facts and a brief in
4
opposition to Detective Bohrman’s Motion for Summary Judgment.
(Docs. 57, 58).
2. UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS
The following facts are taken from the Detective Bohrman’s
Statement of Material Facts and Plaintiff’s Answer thereto.2 On May 8,
2 Pursuant to Local Rule 56.1, we accept as true all undisputed material
facts supported by the Record. Where the record evinces a disputed
fact, we will take notice. On this matter, however, we are compelled to
remind both parties of their respective obligations to comply with the
Local Rules. Local Rule 56.1 sets forth the procedure for filing a motion
for summary judgment. In relevant part, it states:
A motion for summary judgment filed pursuant to
Fed.R.Civ.P. 56, shall be accompanied by a separate, short
and concise statement of the material facts, in numbered
paragraphs, as to which the moving party contends there is
no genuine issue to be tried.
M.D. Pa. L.R. 56.1. Detective Bohrman filed a “Motion for Summary
Judgment,” which consists of 22 numbered paragraphs including both
conclusions of law and statements of fact. The factual statements
include citations to the Record. Plaintiff apparently construed this
filing as Detective Bohrman’s statement of material facts, as the
Answer he filed correlates with the paragraphs in the “Motion for
Summary Judgment.” (See Doc. 55). We will also construe the “Motion
for Summary Judgment” as Detective Bohrman’s statement of
undisputed material facts. Additionally, in his brief, Plaintiff included
a section entitled, “Factual Circumstances.” (Doc. 58 at 3). While the
facts in this section included citations, the documents cited to were not
(footnote continued on next page)
5
2019, Plaintiff and his classmate, A.A.3, were riding an activity bus
together from an afterschool club back to the community where they
both lived. (Doc. 55, ¶2; Doc. 57, ¶2). Plaintiff and A.A. sat together in
the same seat. (Doc. 55, ¶3; Doc. 57, ¶3). A.A. sat next to the window
and Plaintiff sat in the aisle seat. (Id.). The bus was full of other
students. (Id.). Plaintiff put his arm around A.A., touched her breast,
and then put his hand inside of her pants and penetrated her vagina
with his fingers multiple times. (Doc. 55, ¶4; Doc. 57, ¶4).
attached as exhibits. And in any event, Local Rule 56.1 does not permit
the non-moving party to file an additional statement of material facts
that does not respond to the moving party’s statement. See Farmer v.
Decker, 353 F. Supp.3d 342, 347 n.1 (M.D. Pa. 2018) (disregarding non-
movant's additional statement of facts for non-compliance with Local
Rule 56.1); Barber v. Subway, 131 F. Supp. 3d 321, 322 n.1 (M.D. Pa.
2015) (noting that a separate statement that is not responsive to
movant's statement “is neither contemplated nor permitted by the Local
Rules”); see also, e.g., Rau v. Allstate Fire & Cas. Ins. Co., 793 F. App'x
84, 87 (3d Cir. 2019) (upholding district court's decision to strike
counter statement of facts under Local Rule 56.1).
3 Given the very sensitive nature of the underlying circumstances giving
rise to Plaintiff’s arrest, the parties have consistently referred to this
party as A.A. in order to protect her identity. We will do the same.
6
The following day, May 9, 2019, A.A. gave a statement school
resource officer Jason Wile (“SRO Wile”), stating:
I was sitting on the inside of the seat and talking
to my friend and he wrapped his arm around me
and started touching my breast then he touched
inside my pants while on the bus and he was
fingering me until he had to get off the bus. He
never asked me to do it I froze that’s why I didn’t
tell him to stop. I normally don’t sit with him. I
believe his name is Josiah.
(Doc. 55, ¶7).4
4 We note that Plaintiff denied in part and admitted in part this fact.
(Doc. 57 at ¶7). However, Plaintiff does not indicate whether he admits
or denies that A.A. provided that statement to the school resource
officer. (Id.) Rather, he admits that “he did touch A.A.’s vagina and
breast.” Plaintiff then provides his version of the events that occurred
on May 8, 2019, maintaining that the encounter was consensual. (Id.).
Local Rule 56.1 provides, in relevant part, that “[a]ll material facts set
forth in the statement required to be served by the moving party will be
deemed to be admitted unless controverted by the statement required to
be served by the opposing party.” M.D. Pa. L.R. 56.1. Here, Plaintiff
did not provide a citation to any evidence in the record controverting
Detective Bohrman’s assertion that A.A. provided the quoted statement
to SRO Wile. (See Doc. 57, ¶7). Accordingly, that fact – but not the
substance of the statement – will be deemed admitted. See Ullrich v.
U.S. Sec. of Veterans Affairs, 457 Fed. App’x 132, 137 (3d Cir. 2012)
(finding the district court properly deemed facts admitted where
opposing party failed to properly dispute them).
7
Also on May 9, 2019, Plaintiff was called to the assistant
principal’s office, where he met with Dean Morrell. (Doc. 55, ¶5; Doc.
57, ¶5). Plaintiff gave a written statement at that time, which was
signed by both Dr. Morrell and Plaintiff, who reviewed the document
together. (Id.). Plaintiff does not dispute that he touched A.A.’s breast
or penetrated her vagina. (Doc. 55, ¶6; Doc. 57, ¶6). He admitted to
doing so in the written statement that he provided to Dr. Morrell and
affirmed the same in his deposition on January 2, 2025. (Id.).
However, Plaintiff maintains that the contact was consensual. (Doc. 55,
¶8; Doc. 57, ¶8). He asserts that A.A. consented to all of his touching
before it occurred. (Id.).
On August 18, 2019, Detective Bohrman executed an affidavit of
probable cause seeking an arrest warrant for Plaintiff, alleging that
Plaintiff had committed delinquent acts of aggravated indecent assault
without consent, indecent assault without consent of other, and open
lewdness. (Doc. 55, ¶9; Doc. 57, ¶). The Affidavit of Probable Cause
includes the statement that A.A. provided to SRO Wile as well as the
statement that Plaintiff made to the Dean Morrell. (Doc. 55, ¶10; Doc.
57, ¶10). On January 1, 2020, the Monroe County District Attorney’s
8
Office filed a petition alleging Plaintiff’s delinquency for the offenses of
aggravated indecent assault without consent, indecent assault without
consent of other, and open lewdness. (Doc. 55, ¶11; Doc. 57, ¶11).
On July 7, 2021, Plaintiff executed a four-page written “admission
colloquy,” admitting to corruption of minors, a first degree
misdemeanor. (Doc. 55, ¶12; Doc. 57, ¶12). After an adjudication
hearing, during which the Court conducted an oral colloquy, the Court
accepted Plaintiff’s admission, finding that it was voluntarily made.
(Doc. 55, ¶13; Doc. 57, ¶13). In exchange for Plaintiff’s admission, the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania agreed to nolle prose the original
charges. (Doc. 55, ¶14; Doc. 57, ¶14). In accordance with the
Pennsylvania Rules of Juvenile Court Procedure, before accepting an
admission, the court must ensure there is a factual basis for the
admission. (Doc. 55, ¶15; Doc. 57, ¶15). Accordingly, the court noted
the following as the factual basis for Plaintiff’s admission: “this juvenile
[Plaintiff] and another juvenile [A.A.] were on a bus and there was
sexual contact, which the victim [A.A.] indicated that it [sic] was
unwanted.” (Id.). The Pennsylvania Superior Court vacated and
reversed Plaintiff’s adjudication of delinquency because a “child,”
9
according to the statutory language, is incapable of committing the
crime of corruption of minors where the statute requires the perpetrator
to be at least 18 years old. (Doc. 55, ¶16; Doc. 57, ¶16; see also Doc. 55-9
at 17). At the time of the alleged assault, Plaintiff was fifteen years old.
(See Doc. 55-9 at 14-15).
3. LEGAL STANDARD
A. Summary Judgment
A court may only grant a motion for summary judgment when
“there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is
entitled to judgment as a matter of law.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a). A fact is
“material” only if it might affect the outcome of the case. Anderson v.
Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). A dispute of material fact
is “genuine” if the evidence “is such that a reasonable jury could return
a verdict for the non-moving party.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248.
In reviewing a motion for summary judgment, the court must view
the facts in the light most favorable to the non-moving party and draw
all reasonable inferences in that party's favor. Jutrowski v. Twp. of
Riverdale, 904 F.3d 280, 288 (3d Cir. 2018) (citing Scheidemantle v.
Slippery Rock Univ. State Sys. of Higher Educ., 470 F.3d 535, 538 (3d
10
Cir. 2006)). The court’s role in deciding a motion for summary
judgment is not to make credibility determinations, weigh evidence, or
draw inferences from facts. Anderson, 477 U.S. at 249. Rather, the
court must “simply determine whether there is a genuine issue for
trial.” Id.
The party seeking summary judgment “bears the initial
responsibility of informing the district court of the basis for its motion,”
and demonstrating the absence of a genuine dispute of any material
fact. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986). If the movant
makes such a showing, the non-movant must go beyond the pleadings
with affidavits or declarations, answers to interrogatories, or the like to
demonstrate specific material facts which give rise to a genuine issue.
Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c); Celotex, 477 U.S. at 324. The non-movant must
produce evidence to show the existence of every element essential to its
case, which it bears the burden of proving at trial, because “a complete
failure of proof concerning an essential element of the nonmoving
party's case necessarily renders all other facts immaterial.” Celotex,
477 U.S. at 323. Additionally, “[i]f a party fails to properly support an
assertion of fact or fails to properly address another party’s assertion of
11
fact as required by Rule 56(c),” the court may “consider the fact
undisputed for purposes of the motion.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(e)(2); see
also Weitzner v. Sanofi Pasteur Inc., 909 F.3d 604, 613-14 (3d Cir.
2018).
B. Section 1983
Plaintiff has alleged violations of his constitutional rights and
filed suit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Section 1983 states, “Every person
who, under color of any statute, ordinance, regulation, custom, or
usage...subjects, or causes to be subjected, any citizen ...or any other
person...to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities
secured by the Constitution and laws, will be liable to the party
injured.” Section 1983 “is not itself a source of substantive rights, but a
method for vindicating federal rights elsewhere conferred by those parts
of the United States Constitution and federal statutes that it
describes.” City of Monterey v. Del Monte Dunes, 526 U.S. 687, 749 n. 9
(1999) (quoting Baker v. McCollan, 443 U.S. 137 144 n.3 (1979)). To
prevail in an action under § 1983, a plaintiff must demonstrate: (1) a
violation of a right secured by the Constitution or laws of the United
States, and (2) that the alleged deprivation was committed by a person
12
acting under color of state law. Nicini v. Morra, 212 F.3d 798, 806 (3d
Cir. 2000); Moore v. Tartler, 986 F.2d 682, 685 (3d Cir. 1993). “Action
under color of state law ‘requires that one liable under § 1983 have
exercised power possessed by virtue of state law and made possible only
because the wrongdoer is clothed with the authority of state
law.’” Harvey v. Plains Twp. Police Dep't, 635 F.3d 606, 609 (3d Cir.
2011) (quoting Abbott v. Latshaw, 164 F.3d 141, 146 (3d Cir.1998)).
4. DISCUSSION
Following Judge Carlson’s August 6, 2024 Memorandum and
Order, two claims remain against Detective Bohrman: false arrest and
malicious prosecution. (Docs. 43, 44). Detective Bohrman has moved
for summary judgment, asserting that summary judgment is
appropriate as to both claims and alternatively, that he is entitled to
qualified immunity. (Doc. 56 at 1-2). Given the “importance of
resolving immunity questions at the earliest possible stage in
litigation,” we will first address qualified immunity. Saucier v. Katz,
533 U.S. 194, 201 (2001), overruled in part on other grounds by Pearson
v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 233 (2009).
13
A. Qualified Immunity Standard
The doctrine of qualified immunity protects government officials
from liability for civil damages “insofar as their conduct does not violate
clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a
reasonable person would have known.” Pearson, 555 U.S. at 231.
“Qualified immunity balances two important interests—the need to
hold public officials accountable when they exercise power irresponsibly
and the need to shield officials from harassment, distraction, and
liability when they perform their duties reasonably.” Id. Qualified
immunity “provides ample protection to all but the plainly incompetent
or those who knowingly violate the law.” Malley v. Briggs, 475 U.S.
335, 341 (1986). “Thus, so long as an official reasonably believes that
his conduct complies with the law, qualified immunity will shield that
official from liability.” Sharp v. Johnson, 669 F.3d 144, 159 (3d Cir.
2012) (citing Pearson, 555 U.S. at 244).
Qualified immunity shields officials from liability for civil
damages brought pursuant to section 1983 “so long as their conduct
does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of
which a reasonable person would have known.” Bland v. City of
14
Newark, 900 F.3d 77, 83 (3d Cir. 2018) (quoting Mullenix v. Luna, 577
U.S. 7, 11 (2015)). The official seeking qualified immunity has the
burden of establishing their entitlement to the affirmative defense.
Halsey v. Pfeiffer, 750 F.3d 273, 288 (3d Cir. 2014) (citing Reedy v.
Evanson, 615 F.3d 197, 223 (3d Cir. 2010)). To determine whether an
official is entitled to the affirmative defense of qualified immunity for a
section 1983 claim, a court must determine (1) whether the official
violated a constitutional right and, if so, (2) whether the right was
clearly established. Saucier, 533 U.S. 194. The court is not required to
conduct these inquiries sequentially. Pearson, 555 U.S. at 239-41.
However, if the court chooses to address the alleged constitutional
violations, analysis of the merits for purposes of summary judgment
merges with analysis of the deprivation of federal rights for purposes of
qualified immunity. See Gruenke v. Seip, 225 F.3d 290, 299–300 (3d
Cir.2000); Russoli v. Salisbury Twp., 126 F.Supp.2d 821, 838–41 (E.D.
Pa. 2000); see also Grant v. City of Pittsburgh, 98 F.3d 116, 122 (3d Cir.
1996) (“[C]rucial to the resolution of [the] assertion of qualified
immunity is a careful examination of the record . . . to establish . . . a
15
detailed factual description of the actions of each individual defendant
(viewed in a light most favorable to the plaintiff).”).
1. Plaintiff Failed to Establish a Constitutional
Violation with Respect to False Arrest.
Detective Bohrman maintains that he is entitled to qualified
immunity because Plaintiff cannot establish the violation of a federal
right. (Doc. 56 at 14). He maintains that he had “ample probable cause
to justify both the arrest and prosecution of Cayenne, in the form of the
victim’s statement, as well as a statement from Cayenne himself.” (Id.).
As to probable cause, earlier in Detective Bohrman’s supporting
brief, he notes that A.A. gave a statement detailing the sexual assault.
(Id. at 9). Detective Bohrman asserts that this alone could establish
probable cause. (Id.). Additionally, he asserts that his affidavit of
probable cause also included notes on Plaintiff’s interview with Dean
Morrell and Plaintiff’s statement.5 (Id.). Detective Bohrman argues
5 In support of his claim that probable cause exists, Detective Bohrman
also points to a video of the incident. Detective Bohrman did not
include any facts regarding the videotape in his statement of material
facts and so, we will not consider them. (See Doc. 55) (Plaintiff’s Motion
(footnote continued on next page)
16
that “[t]he undisputed material facts of record demonstrate that
probable cause existed to arrest Plaintiff.” (Id. at 7).
Plaintiff maintains that summary judgment is not appropriate as
to his false arrest claim, stating, “[c]learly there is a genuine issue of
material fact, as to whether there was probable cause supporting
Detective Bohrman’s arrest of Plaintiff.” (Doc. 58 at 15). Plaintiff
asserts that he and A.A. were high school classmates who provided
different accounts of a sexual encounter. (Id.). While Plaintiff
acknowledges that A.A. told police that “she did not consent to being
digitally penetrated and groped by Plaintiff, this is belied by the fact
that she never told him to stop, offered no physical resistance and did
not plead for help.” (Id.). Rather, Plaintiff maintains this conduct was
“consistent with Plaintiff’s claim that he sought her permission before
being intimate.” (Id.). Additionally, Plaintiff claims that “[i]n the
for Summary Judgment, which, as noted supra, we will construe as his
statement of material facts); see also Ismail v. Honeywell International,
Inc., No. 1:21-CV-00143, 2024 WL 3033985, *7 n.5 (M.D. Pa. June 17,
2024) (“This assertion is not included in the statement of material facts,
and, accordingly, we will not consider it.”)
17
affidavit of probable cause, Detective Bohrman attested that there was
a videotape which corroborated the claims of A.A. However, that
videotape was never provided to Plaintiff’s counsel, and was not
available for Plaintiff’s adjudicatory hearing.” (Id.).
In a § 1983 claim based upon false arrest, the proper inquiry is
“whether the arresting officers had probable cause to believe the person
arrested had committed the offense.” Dowling v. Philadelphia, 855 F.2d
136, 141 (3d Cir.1995). The Third Circuit has described the procedure
for an officer seeking a warrant on the basis of probable cause as
follows:
First, the officer swears to an affidavit containing
a summary of the events that she believes give
rise to probable cause. In doing so, the officer ‘is
not free to disregard plainly exculpatory evidence,
even if substantial inculpatory evidence (standing
by itself) suggests that probable cause exists.’
Wilson v. Russo, 212 F.3d 781, 790 (3d Cir.
2000) (quoting Kuehl v. Burtis, 173 F.3d 646, 650
(8th Cir. 1999)). Second, the officer presents
the affidavit to a neutral magistrate, who
conducts his own independent review of the
evidence to determine whether it does, in fact,
establish probable cause, and, if so, issues
a warrant.
In this way, our system protects the public from
the harm caused by criminals as well as the harm
18
that would result if no process were required to
obtain a warrant; it allows officers to pursue
leads zealously while also ensuring that an
arrest warrant will issue only if ‘a neutral and
detached magistrate’ agrees with the officer
that probable cause exists. Id. at 787 (‘[A]n
uninterested party is presumably better suited to
review and evaluate the facts than an officer
pursuing a lead.’); see United States v. Leon, 468
U.S. 897, 913-14, 104 S.Ct. 3405, 82 L.Ed.2d 677
(1984) (‘[T]he detached scrutiny of a neutral
magistrate... is a more reliable safeguard [against
Fourth Amendment violations] than the hurried
judgment of a law enforcement officer....’)
(quoting United States v. Chadwick, 433 U.S. 1, 9,
97 S.Ct. 2476, 53 L.Ed.2d 538 (1977)). If,
however, the officer does not provide the neutral
magistrate with an accurate affidavit of probable
cause, the protection afforded by the magistrate's
review is lost; the magistrate will be unable to
assess the circumstances for probable cause
because he will not know what those
circumstances actually are.
Dempsey v. Bucknell University, 834 F.3d 457, 469 (3d Cir. 2016).
Accordingly, to state a claim for false arrest based on a warrant,
the plaintiff must establish that the defendant: (1) “knowingly and
deliberately, or with reckless disregard for the truth, made false
statements or omissions that create a falsehood in applying for a
warrant;” and (2) that “such statements or omissions are material, or
necessary, to the finding of probable cause.” Wilson v. Russo, 212 F.3d
19
781, 786–87 (3d Cir.2000) (quoting Sherwood v. Mulvihill, 113 F.3d 396,
399 (3d Cir.1997)).
Here, Plaintiff does not specifically allege that Detective Bohrman
“knowingly and deliberately, or with reckless disregard for the truth,
made false statements or omissions” in his affidavit of probable cause.
See Wilson, 212 F.3d at 781. However, Plaintiff does allege – with no
citation to the record – that “[i]n his affidavit of probable cause,
Detective Bohrman attested that there was a videotape which
corroborated the claims of AA.” (Doc. 58 at 15). While we could
construe this as an argument that Detective Bohrman made a false
statement in the affidavit of probable cause, Detective Bohrman
included no such attestation. Plaintiff’s contention is demonstrably
false as Detective Bohrman attached a copy of the affidavit of probable
cause as an exhibit to his Motion for Summary Judgment. (See Doc. 55-
20
6 at 2). Nowhere in that document does Detective Bohrman reference a
videotape of the incident. (Id.).6
6 We note that Plaintiff raises arguments about the videotape on three
occasions in his opposition brief with no citation to any record evidence.
(Doc. 58 at 16, 19, 21). Such arguments are insufficient to overcome a
summary judgment motion. See Wright v. Dallas School Dist., No. 2007
WL 9775650, 2007 WL 9775650 (M.D. Pa. July 5, 2007) (“[t]o overcome a
motion for summary judgment, it is the plaintiff’s burden of presenting
specific facts, with specific reference to the record.”) While, as noted
supra, we declined to consider the arguments advanced by either party
regarding the videotape, based upon the record evidence regarding the
videotape that we have reviewed, we are satisfied that consideration of
such arguments would not have changed our analysis. The existence of
probable cause is central to our analysis regarding whether Plaintiff
established a constitutional violation as to both his false arrest and
malicious prosecution claims. Detective Bohrman testified that he never
saw the video. (Doc. 56-8 at 13:21-22). He testified that Dean Morrell
and SRO Wile watched the video and reported that because of the angle
and the location on the bus where A.A. and Plaintiff were seated, they
were only able to see that the two did, in fact, sit together, and that
Plaintiff did put his arm around her. (Id. at 14:5-14). Dean Morrell and
SRO Wile reported that was all they were able to see on the video. (Id.
at 13:16-17). There is no evidence that either party has pointed to that
suggests the video footage could be characterized as exculpatory. In any
event, Plaintiff has not argued that Detective Bohrman omitted this
information from his affidavit of probable cause. Rather, he erroneously
argued that Detective Bohrman “attested that there was a videotape
which corroborated the claims of AA.” (Doc. 58 at 15). Thus, even if we
were to consider the parties’ arguments regarding the videotape, it would
not change the probable cause analysis.
21
Rather, the parties do not dispute that Detective Bohrman
included both A.A. and Plaintiff’s versions of events in his affidavit of
probable cause. (Doc. 55, ¶¶10; Doc. 57, ¶ 10) (stating that the affidavit
included both A.A.’s statement to the school resource officer and
Plaintiff’s statement to the dean of students). As Detective Bohrman
correctly pointed out, A.A.’s statement alone was sufficient to establish
probable cause.7 The Third Circuit’s rule provides that “statements of a
7 Detective Bohrman asserts that he executed an affidavit of probable
cause, alleging Cayenne committed the following acts: aggravated
indecent assault without consent, 18 Pa.C.S. § 3125(A)(1); indecent
assault without consent of other, 18 Pa.C.S. § 3126(A)(1); and open
lewdness, 18 Pa.C.S. § 5901. (Doc. 55 at ¶9). The affidavit of probable
cause does not specifically reference these (or any) offenses. (See Doc.
55-6). However, Plaintiff does not dispute Detective Bohrman’s
statement. (Doc. 57 at ¶9). 18 Pa.C.S. § 3125(A)(1) provides that “a
person who engages in penetration, however slight, of the genitals . . . of
a complainant with a part of the person’s body . . . commits aggravated
indecent assault if . . . the person does so without the complainant’s
consent.” 18 Pa.C.S. § 3126(A)(A) provides that “a person is guilty of
indecent assault if the person has indecent contact with the
complainant . . . and . . . the person does so without the complainant’s
consent. Finally, 18 Pa.C.S. § 5901 provides that “a person commits a
misdemeanor of the third degree if he does any lewd act which he
knows is likely to be observed by others who would be affronted or
alarmed.”
22
victim witness are typically sufficient to establish probable cause in the
absence of independent exculpatory evidence or substantial evidence of
a witness’s own unreliability that outweigh[s] the probable cause that
otherwise exists.” Dempsey, 834 F.3d at 477-78 (internal quotations
and citations omitted); see also Sharrar v. Felsing, 128 F.3d 810, 818
(3d Cir. 1997) (“[w]hen a police officer has received a reliable
identification by a victim of his or her attacker, the police have probable
cause”), abrogated on other grounds by Curley v. Klem, 499 F.3d 199,
209-11 (3d Cir. 2007).
Neither party has pointed to any “substantial evidence” in the
record of A.A.’s unreliability or to any “independent exculpatory
evidence.” The only evidence inconsistent with A.A.’s statement was
Plaintiff’s statement, asserting that the encounter was consensual. But
Plaintiff’s statement disputing A.A.’s account of the interaction does not
negate the probable cause established by A.A.’s statement. See Forde v.
Home Depot, No. 11-5823, 2011 WL 6372090 (E.D. Pa. Dec. 20, 2011)
(“A policeman . . . is under no obligation to give any credence to a
suspect’s story nor should a plausible explanation in any sense require
the officer to forego arrest pending further investigation if the facts as
23
initially discovered provide probable cause.”) (quoting Criss v. City of
Kent, 876 F.2d 259, 263 (6th Cir. 1988)); Anderson v. Gaga, No. 11-528,
2013 WL 3242445, *3 (W.D. Pa. June 25, 2013) (quoting Pearson v.
Lorancaitis, No. 3:09-cv-1641, 2012 WL 162355 (D. Conn. Jan. 19, 2012)
(“a finding of probable cause is not foreclosed where a police officer is
presented with different stories from an alleged victim and an
arrestee.”)).
Because there is no genuine dispute as to whether Detective
Bohrman “knowingly and deliberately, or with reckless disregard for
the truth, made false statements or omissions that create[d] a falsehood
in applying for a warrant,” probable cause existed and Plaintiff cannot
establish a constitutional violation. Accordingly, Detective Bohrman is
entitled to qualified immunity as to Plaintiff’s false arrest claim. See
Ward v. Noonan, 147 F.Supp.3d 262, 287 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 25, 2015)
(trooper entitled to qualified immunity where probable cause existed for
arrest); Giacalone v. Northeastern Pennsylvania Insurance Fraud Task
Force, No. 3:11-CV-01647, 2013 WL 12145004 (M.D. Pa. Aug. 6, 2013)
(defendant entitled to qualified immunity because plaintiff failed to
make out violation of constitutional right where probable cause existed).
24
The failure to establish a constitutional violation also requires a
finding that Detective Bohrman is entitled to summary judgment with
respect to Plaintiff’s claim of false arrest.
2. Plaintiff Failed to Establish a Constitutional
Violation with Respect to Malicious Prosecution.
Again, Detective Bohrman argues that he is entitled to qualified
immunity because he had “ample probable cause” to justify the
prosecution of Cayenne, and so, Plaintiff cannot establish a
constitutional violation. (Doc. 56 at 14). Earlier in his supporting brief,
Detective Bohrman argues in more detail that the existence of probable
cause vitiates Plaintiff’s malicious prosecution claim. (Id. at 12-13).
Additionally, Detective Bohrman again makes arguments about the
videotape.8 (Id. at 12). Detective Bohrman also argues that Plaintiff
failed to allege the role that Detective Bohrman may have played in the
prosecution, and in any event, “Assistant District Attorney Matthew
Bernall made the decision to file charges against [Plaintiff.]” (Doc. 56).
8 For the reasons set forth supra in note 5, we will not consider these
arguments.
25
Finally, Detective Bohrman argues that the criminal proceeding did not
end in Plaintiff’s favor. (Doc. 56 at 13). Detective Bohrman argues that
Plaintiff “entered a voluntary admission to the crime of corruption of
minors.” (Id.). While the Superior Court ultimately reversed and
vacated that adjudication of delinquency, Detective Bohrman argues
that neither the Superior Court nor Plaintiff disputed the factual basis
of the admission. (Id.).
In response, Plaintiff argues, “Detective Bohrman initiated the
criminal proceedings against him by swearing out a false affidavit of
probable cause for his arrest then subsequently arresting Plaintiff.”
(Doc. 58 at 18). He further maintains, “[t]he prosecution against
Plaintiff culminated in the Plaintiff’s misdemeanor conviction being
vacated by the Superior Court of Pennsylvania after it was clear that
Plaintiff was arrested without probable cause as evidenced by the
proceeding section.” (Id.).
It is well-settled that “[t]o prove malicious prosecution [under §
1983]. . . a plaintiff must show that: (1) the defendants initiated a
criminal proceeding; (2) the criminal proceeding ended in plaintiff's
favor; (3) the proceeding was initiated without probable cause; (4) the
26
defendants acted maliciously or for a purpose other than bringing the
plaintiff to justice; and (5) the plaintiff suffered deprivation of liberty
consistent with the concept of seizure as a consequence of a legal
proceeding.” Estate of Smith v. Marasco, 318 F.3d 497, 521 (3d Cir.
2003). To prevail on a claim of malicious prosecution, a plaintiff must
satisfy each element. McCormack v. Livergood, 353 F.Supp.3d 357, 365
(M.D. Pa. 2018); Ward v. Noonan, 147 F.Supp.3d 262, 281 (M.D. Pa.
2015) (“If Plaintiffs have not proffered evidence sufficient to create a
triable issue of fact as to all five prongs, their malicious prosecution
claim must fail as a matter of law.”)
As set forth supra, there is no genuine dispute of material fact
regarding whether probable cause existed for Plaintiff’s arrest.
Accordingly, Plaintiff cannot establish a constitutional violation with
respect to malicious prosecution. See McCormack, 353 F.Supp.3d at 365
(plaintiff must satisfy each element to establish malicious prosecution).
Detective Bohrman is therefore entitled to qualified immunity with
respect to this claim.
Further, because Plaintiff cannot establish a constitutional
violation with respect to his malicious prosecution claim, it necessarily
27
follows that Detective Bohrman is entitled to summary judgment as to
this claim as well.
5. CONCLUSION
For all of the reasons set forth herein, we will grant Detective
Bohrman’s Motion for summary judgment.
An appropriate Order is filed simultaneously with this
Memorandum.
Dated: September 30, 2025 s/ Leo A. Latella
LEO A. LATELLA
United States Magistrate Judge
28