dismissing 5 || plaintiff's federal claims and declining supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims including a 6 || claim for conspiracy to deprive constitutional rights
How later courts described this case
- dismissing 5 || plaintiff's federal claims and declining supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims including a 6 || claim for conspiracy to deprive constitutional rights
- taking 15 notice of existing warrant and its filing date, but not “the veracity of the account contained within 16 the [warrant]”
- noting disagreement 13 between other circuits
- “if the federal claims are dismissed before trial, … the state 24 claims should be dismissed as well”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
1
2
3
4 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
5 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
6
7 MICHAEL JOSEPH MATTINGLY, Case No. 24-cv-04595-SVK
8 Plaintiff, ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO
DISMISS AND DECLINING
9 v.
SUPPLEMENTAL JURISDICTION
10 JAQUELINE JUREK, et al., OVER PLAINTIFF’S STATE-LAW
CLAIMS
11 Defendants.
12 Re: Dkt. No. 32
13
Self-represented Plaintiff Michael Joseph Mattingly brings this action against various
14
defendants employed with the California Department of Parks and Recreation (the “Department”)
15
alleging an invalid warrant and unlawful arrest in violation of his rights under the United States
16
and California Constitutions. See Dkt. 1 (the “Complaint”). Plaintiff seeks compensatory
17
damages and declaratory and injunctive relief against officers Jaqueline Jurek, Tyler Knapp and
18
Trevor Morgan (the “Officers”), police captains Gabe McKenna and Joe Walters (the “Captains”)
19
and director of the Department Armondo Quintero (collectively, “Defendants”). Id at 23. After
20
Defendants’ first motion to dismiss, the Court dismissed some claims with leave to amend while
21
denying the motion to dismiss other claims. Dkt. 28 (“Prior Order”). Plaintiff then filed a Motion
22
to Amend/Correct Complaint which the Court construes as the First Amended Complaint (the
23
“FAC”). Dkts. 30, 31. The FAC seeks similar relief as the Complaint for the remaining claims.
24
FAC at 12. In response to the FAC, Defendants filed a new motion to dismiss (the “Motion”).
25
Dkt 32. Plaintiff opposes the Motion. Dkt. 33.
26
All necessary Parties have consented to the jurisdiction of a magistrate judge. Dkt. 28 at 1
27
(discounting Doe defendants); Dkts. 2, 10. The Court has determined that the Motion is suitable
1 for resolution without oral argument. Civ. L.R. 7-1(b). After considering the Parties’ briefs, the
2 relevant law and the history in this action, and for the reasons explained below, the Court
3 DISMISSES all federal claims WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND and DECLINES
4 supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims.
5 I. REQUESTS FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
6 As an initial matter, Defendants submitted two requests that the Court take judicial notice
7 of documents detailing Plaintiff’s criminal proceedings in which a bench warrant was issued.
8 Dkts. 32-1, 34-1. “Generally, a district court may not consider any material beyond the pleadings
9 in ruling on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.” Hal Roach Studios, Inc. v. Richard Feiner & Co., 896 F.2d
10 1542, 1555 n.19 (9th Cir. 1989). Nonetheless, a district court may consider “documents attached
11 to the complaint, documents incorporated by reference in the complaint, or matters of judicial
12 notice” at the pleadings stage. United States v. Ritchie, 342 F.3d 903, 908 (9th Cir. 2003).
13 Federal Rule of Evidence 201 permits courts to take notice of adjudicative facts if they are “not
14 subject to reasonable dispute because [they] … can be accurately and readily determined from
15 sources whose accuracy cannot reasonably be questioned.” Fed. R. Evid. 201(b)(2); Khoja v.
16 Orexigen Therapeutics, Inc., 899 F.3d 988, 999 (9th Cir. 2018). The Court may generally notice
17 the existence and authenticity of an item, but not the underlying truth of its contents. Lee v. City
18 of Los Angeles, 250 F.3d 668, 689–90 (9th Cir. 2001), overruled on other grounds by Galbraith v.
19 Cnty. of Santa Clara, 307 F.3d 1119 (9th Cir. 2002). The Court may take notice of “proceedings
20 in other courts, both within and without the federal judicial system, if those proceedings have a
21 direct relation to matters at issue.” Bias v. Moynihan, 508 F.3d 1212, 1225 (9th Cir. 2007)
22 (citation omitted). Such judicial notice can include taking “notice of a bench warrant as a matter
23 of public record.” Neylon v. Cnty. of Inyo, No. 16-cv-00712-AWI (JLT), 2016 WL 6834097, at *4
24 (E.D. Cal. Nov. 21, 2016).
25 In the first request for judicial notice, Defendants request the Court take notice of a minute
26 order from Plaintiff’s California state criminal proceeding and a warrant abstract referencing the
27 same case, numbered 21cr03682. Dkt. 32-2 at 4, 6. The record indicates Plaintiff was charged
1 arraignment scheduled for September 13, 2021. Id. The minute order produced on September 13,
2 2021 notes the issuance of a bench warrant in the amount of $500. Id. at 4. The corresponding
3 warrant abstract confirms the date of issuance as September 13, 2021. Id. at 6. Defendants’
4 second request for judicial notice includes the warrant report documenting the same warrant issued
5 for Plaintiff by Judge Vinluan of the Superior Court of Santa Cruz on September 13, 2021 with the
6 warrant number 21cr03682. Dkt. 34-2 at 4-6.
7 Although Plaintiff disputes the date of the bench warrants’ issuance, (FAC at 6), this is not
8 a matter subject to reasonable dispute. While certain contents of a warrant may be subject to
9 reasonable dispute, such as the veracity of facts justifying a warrant, administrative content such
10 as the existence of a warrant, the person for whom the warrant was issued and the date of issuance
11 are materials not subject to reasonable dispute. See, e.g., Bunkley v. Verber, No. 17-cv-05797-
12 WHO, 2018 WL 1242168, at *2 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 9, 2018) (taking notice of existing arrest warrant
13 and person for whom it was issued for because these contents were not subject to reasonable
14 dispute); Victoria v. City of San Diego, 326 F. Supp. 3d 1003, 1012 (S.D. Cal. 2018) (taking
15 notice of existing warrant and its filing date, but not “the veracity of the account contained within
16 the [warrant]”). Here, notwithstanding Plaintiff’s dispute, the minute order, warrant abstract and
17 warrant report constitute a “public record the accuracy of which cannot be reasonably [disputed]”
18 as to the existence of the warrant and the “date on which the warrant was issued ….” Klahn v.
19 Alameda Cnty. Sheriff’s Dep’t, No. 16-cv-00833-JCS, 2017 WL 565050, at *11 (N.D. Cal. Feb.
20 13, 2017).
21 Accordingly, the Court GRANTS Defendants’ requests for judicial notice and takes notice
22 of the minute order, the warrant abstract and warrant report. Dkt. 32-2 at 4, 6; Dkt. 34-2 at 4-6.
23 The Court will, from these documents, take notice of the fact that a bench warrant was issued for
24 Plaintiff on the date of September 13, 2021, by Judge Vinluan of the Superior Court of Santa
25 Cruz. The Court also takes notice of the authenticity of the documents. The Court does not take
26 notice of any other facts related to these documents.
27 ////
1 II. BACKGROUND
2 The Court has previously summarized the facts, as alleged in Plaintiff’s Complaint.
3 Dkt. 28 at 3. Plaintiff brings this action seeking compensatory damages for alleged unlawful
4 arrest and declaratory and injunctive relief for constitutional violations. FAC at 12. Apart from
5 minor amendments, such as additional case law references and removal of certain damages
6 requests, the FAC does not allege new facts. FAC at 9, 12. Taken as true, Plaintiff was
7 “performing protest music” at Twin Lakes Beach in Santa Cruz on July 30, 2022. FAC at 4.
8 Officers Jurek, Knapp and Morgan then approached Plaintiff and claimed they had a warrant for
9 his arrest. Id. Plaintiff demanded to see the warrant but the Officers “failed to produce any
10 warrant” and proceeded to arrest plaintiff. Id. at 5. In the original Complaint, Plaintiff alleged the
11 Officers mentioned a “bench warrant”; however, the FAC now alleges simply that the Officers
12 mentioned “a warrant.” Compare Complaint at 6 with FAC at 4. Because a plaintiff generally
13 cannot “amend pleadings to ‘directly contradict an earlier assertion made in the same
14 proceeding,’” the Court will construe Plaintiff’s allegation of “a warrant” in his FAC as a “bench
15 warrant,” consistent with the original Complaint. Morales v. City & Cnty. of San Francisco, 603 F.
16 Supp. 3d 841, 847 (N.D. Cal. 2022) (quoting Airs Aromatics, LLC v. Victoria’s Secret Stores
17 Brand Mgmt., Inc., 744 F.3d 595, 600 (9th Cir. 2014)).
18 Prior to these events, on September 13, 2021, Plaintiff failed to appear for continued
19 arraignment in a California state case, and the Superior Court of Santa Cruz issued a bench
20 warrant for $500. Dkt. 32-2 at 4, 6; Dkt. 34-2 at 4-6.
21 III. LEGAL STANDARD
22 Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), a court must dismiss a complaint if it
23 “fail[s] to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.” To survive a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, a
24 plaintiff must allege “enough facts to state a claim to relief that is plausible on its face.” Bell Atl.
25 Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007). This facial-plausibility standard requires a plaintiff
26 to allege facts resulting in “more than a sheer possibility that a defendant has acted unlawfully.”
27 Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009) (citation omitted).
1 incorporated into the complaint by reference, and matters [subject to] judicial notice.” See, e.g.,
2 UFCW Loc. 1500 Pension Fund v. Mayer, 895 F.3d 695, 698 (9th Cir. 2018) (citation omitted). A
3 court must also presume the truth of a plaintiff’s allegations and draw all reasonable inferences in
4 the plaintiff’s favor. Boquist v. Courtney, 32 F.4th 764, 782 (9th Cir. 2022). However, a court
5 need not accept as true “allegations that are merely conclusory, unwarranted deductions of fact, or
6 unreasonable inferences.” Khoja, Inc., 899 F.3d at 1008 (citation omitted).
7 If a court grants a motion to dismiss, it may exercise discretion to grant or deny leave to
8 amend the complaint, and it “acts within its discretion to deny leave to amend when amendment
9 would be futile, when it would cause undue prejudice to the defendant, or when it is sought in bad
10 faith.” Nat’l Funding, Inc. v. Com. Credit Counseling Servs., Inc., 817 F. App’x 380, 383 (9th
11 Cir. 2020).
12 IV. DISCUSSION
13 Plaintiff’s FAC contains four causes of action:
14 (1) a 42 U.S.C. § 1983 claim of retaliation violating the First Amendment against
15 Defendants Jurek, Knapp and Morgan,
16 (2) a 42 U.S.C. § 1983 claim of unlawful arrest violating the Fourth Amendment
17 against Defendants Jurek, Knapp and Morgan,
18 (3) a 42 U.S.C. § 1985 claim of conspiracy to violate constitutional rights against
19 Defendants Jurek, Knapp and Morgan, and
20 (4) a claim for violations of his rights under Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the
21 California Constitutional against Defendants Quintero, McKenna and Walters.
22 In the Prior Order, the Court denied dismissal of the originally numbered claims five and
23 six, now labelled as claims three and four, because “Defendants [o]ffer[ed] [n]o [r]eason [t]o
24 [d]ismiss” these claims. Dkt. 28 at 8-9. In response to the FAC, Defendants’ now present
25 defenses which they previously did not raise but could have.1 Thus, the Court first considers
26
27
1 Specifically, Defendants’ Motion now invokes the Eleventh Amendment immunity of Defendant
1 whether it may reach these additional arguments.
2 In adjudicating second or subsequent motions to dismiss, courts in this District and Circuit
3 may disallow arguments that could have been raised in a prior motion, but were not, because “the
4 filing of an amended pleading does not revive the opposing party’s right to file a motion to dismiss
5 after that party has answered the prior pleading.” Leung v. Fed. Deposit Ins. Corp., No. 24-cv-
6 00337-NW, 2025 WL 1397205, at *6 (N.D. Cal. May 14, 2025) (citing, e.g., Brooks v. Caswell,
7 No. 14-cv-01232-JVA, 2016 WL 866303, at *2 (D. Or. Mar. 2, 2016) (collecting cases)). Yet, “a
8 defendant who omits a defense under Rule12(b)(6) … does not waive that defense.” In re Apple
9 iPhone Antitrust Litig., 846 F.3d 313, 317 (9th Cir. 2017), aff’d sub nom. Apple Inc. v. Pepper,
10 587 U.S. 273 (2019). Rather, “a defendant who fails to assert a failure-to-state-a-claim defense in
11 a pre-answer Rule 12 motion cannot assert that defense in a later pre-answer motion under Rule
12 12(b)(6), [although] the defense may be asserted in other ways.” Id. at 318 (noting disagreement
13 between other circuits); see Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(g). In interpreting Rule 12(g), the Ninth Circuit
14 has explained that—because the unraised defense could still be raised “in a pleading under Rule 7,
15 in a post-answer motion under Rule 12(c), or at trial,” — “the general policy of the Federal Rules
16 of Civil Procedure, expressed in Rule 1,” permits district courts to nonetheless consider unraised
17 12(b)(6) defenses, in successive motions, in the interests of judicial economy. Id. at 318-19 (e.g.,
18 if a district court “were to evade the merits of Defendants’ … defenses here, Defendants would be
19 required to file answers within 14 days[,] … would presumably assert [the same defenses,] …
20 would then file Rule 12(c) motions, the parties would then repeat the briefing … and the Court
21 would have to address the same questions in several months.” (quoting Allstate Ins. Co. v.
22 Countrywide Fin. Corp., 824 F. Supp. 2d 1164, 1175 (C.D. Cal. 2011)). The judicial economy
23 concern, as explained in In re Apple iPhone Antirust litigation, fits this case. Id.; see also Yockey
24 v. Salesforce, Inc., 745 F. Supp. 3d 945, 950 (N.D. Cal. 2024) (explaining that courts may
25 consider under Rule 12(b)(6) arguments “that otherwise could be brought in a later Rule 12(c)
26 motion,” and distinguishing cases where an answer had already been filed).
27 Accordingly, because Defendants have not filed an answer and could raise these same
1 allow Defendants’ Motion to introduce arguments in response to the FAC which they previously
2 failed to assert.
3 Turning to the merits, the Court first addresses the claims against Defendant Quintero and
4 his invoked Eleventh Amendment immunity defense. The Court then addresses the qualified
5 immunity defense as applied to claims one, two and three against officers Jurek, Knapp and
6 Morgan. Finally, the Court discusses the claim for violations of the California Constitution.
7 A. The Eleventh Amendment Immunizes Defendant Quintero from All Claims
8 Under the Eleventh Amendment to the United States Constitution, “[s]tates are protected
9 … from suits brought by citizens in federal court.” Douglas v. Cal. Dep’t of Youth Auth., 271
10 F.3d 812, 817 (9th Cir. 2001) (citations omitted). “The Eleventh Amendment bars suits against
11 the State or its agencies for all types of relief, absent unequivocal consent by the state.” Romano
12 v. Bible, 169 F.3d 1182, 1185 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Pennhurst v. Halderman, 465 U.S. 89, 100
13 (1984)). This immunity extends to the Department and, to the extent they are sued in their official
14 capacities, the Department’s employees. See, e.g., Pullman v. Schwarzenegger, No. 11-cv-00202-
15 JLS, 2011 WL 6396631, at *8 (S.D. Cal. Dec. 20, 2011); Hahn v. Cal. Dep’t of Parks &
16 Recreation, No. 09-cv-01479-JAM, 2009 WL 3048716, at *3 (E.D. Cal. Sept. 18, 2009). In ruling
17 on Defendants’ initial motion to dismiss, the Court determined the Eleventh Amendment
18 immunized Quintero from suit only as to the claims for which Defendant Quintero invoked the
19 defense.2 In the present Motion, Defendants raise the Eleventh Amendment immunity as to all
20 claims brought against Quintero. Dkt. 32 at 1.
21 In its Prior Order, the Court explained that in the original Complaint Plaintiff sued
22 Quintero in his official, not individual, capacity and that as a result, Quintero is afforded Eleventh
23 Amendment immunity. Dkt. 28 at 6-7. The Court incorporates its prior Eleventh Amendment
24 discussion here. See Id. To determine whether a claim is against an official in his or her “official”
25
2 The Court’s order dismissed originally-numbered claims three and seven as raised against
26 Defendant Quintero. See Dkt. 28 at 7. The Court noted possible Eleventh Amendment immunity
for Quintero which would require dismissal of originally-numbered claim six, presently labelled
27 claim four. Id. at 9. However, at that time the Court did not extend the Eleventh Amendment
1 or “individual” capacity, “courts must still analyze the specifics of the conduct involved . . . .”
2 Pena v. Gardner, 976 F.2d 469, 474 (9th Cir. 1992) (Nelson, J., specially concurring). Neither
3 Plaintiff’s FAC nor his Opposition provide new facts or pose new argument as to why Eleventh
4 Amendment immunity should not apply. Plaintiff’s claims continue to expressly arise out of
5 Quintero’s official capacity as director of the Department, and Plaintiff does not allege with
6 particularity conduct sufficient to sue Quintero in an individual capacity. See FAC at 8 (alleging
7 that Quintero enforced unconstitutional policies, which entails Quintero’s official capacity as an
8 employee of a state agency).
9 Accordingly, the Court determines that Quintero is afforded Eleventh Amendment
10 immunity from all of Plaintiff’s claims, including the fourth cause of action as alleged in the
11 FAC.3 The Court GRANTS Defendants’ motion to dismiss claims against Defendant Quintero.
12 These claims are dismissed without leave to amend for the reasons explained below. See, infra,
13 § IV.C
14 B. Defendant Officers Are Entitled to Qualified Immunity
15 “Qualified immunity attaches when an official’s conduct does not violate clearly
16 established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.”
17 Kisela v. Hughes, 584 U.S. 100, 104 (2018) (citation omitted). A qualified immunity inquiry
18 requires determining “(1) whether the facts that a plaintiff has alleged … or shown … make out a
19 violation of a ‘constitutional right’ and 2) whether the right at issue was ‘clearly established’ at the
20 time of defendant’s alleged misconduct.” Johnson v. Barr, 79 F.4th 996, 1004 (9th Cir. 2023)
21 (quoting Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223, 232 (2009)). “Defendants are entitled to qualified
22
23
3 As in its Prior Order, the Court observes that defects may infect Defendant Quintero’s invocation
of Eleventh Amendment immunity beyond the purported deficiencies raised by Plaintiff and
24
rejected in this Order. Dkt. 28, n. 5. But, as the Court then explained, “the Eleventh Amendment
is not a true limitation upon the court’s subject matter jurisdiction.” Snoqualmie Indian Tribe v.
25
Wash., 8 F.4th 853, 861 n.4 (9th Cir. 2021) (citation omitted). Rather, “the Eleventh Amendment
grants the State a legal power to assert a sovereign immunity defense should it choose to do so[,
26
and u]nless the State raises the matter, a court can ignore it.” Wis. Dep’t of Corr. v. Schacht, 524
U.S. 381, 389 (1998) (citations omitted). Accordingly, as when it otherwise evaluates a Rule
27
12(b)(6) motion to dismiss, the Court need not address arguments not raised by a n opposing
1 immunity… if they reasonably could have believed that their conduct was lawful in light of clearly
2 established law and the information that they possessed.” Demers v. Austin, 746 F.3d 402, 417
3 (9th Cir. 2014) (cleaned up). In the case of a claim for unlawful arrest, even if an officer makes an
4 arrest without probable cause, the officer “may still be entitled to qualified immunity if he
5 reasonably believed there to have been probable cause.” Rosenbaum v. Washoe Cnty., 663 F.3d
6 1071, 1076 (9th Cir. 2011) (emphasis in original). “An outstanding warrant does provide probable
7 cause for an arrest.” United States v. Daniels, No. 19-CR-00709-BLF-1, 2022 WL 1540035, at *4
8 (N.D. Cal. May 16, 2022) (citing Case v. Kitsap Cnty. Sheriffs Dept., 249 F.3d 921, 927-28 (9th
9 Cir. 2001)).
10 Defendants argue in the Motion that qualified immunity protects officers Jurek, Knapp and
11 Morgan from claims one, two and three as alleged in the FAC. Dkt. 32 at 4, 8. Plaintiff’s FAC
12 alleges that the Officers approached Plaintiff “claiming they had a warrant for his arrest.”
13 FAC at 4. Defendants argue qualified immunity applies because the Officers had a valid bench
14 warrant and, even if the warrant were proven invalid, the Officers “are entitled to qualified
15 immunity” because they “had a reasonably arguable belief that they were arresting with a valid
16 warrant.” Dkt. 32 at 8.
17 Plaintiff first opposes qualified immunity by arguing that “there was no probable cause
18 because no valid warrant existed at the time of arrest….” Dkt. 33 at 7-8. However, this argument
19 relies on Plaintiff’s allegation that there was, in fact, no warrant. See, e.g., FAC at 6. Having
20 taken judicial notice of the fact that there was a bench warrant issued as to Plaintiff as of
21 September 13, 2021, (see Dkt. 32-2 at 4, 6; Dkt. 34-2 at 4-6), the Court cannot agree with
22 Plaintiff. While the bench warrant may or may not have been valid, its existence (which is not
23 subject to reasonable dispute) supports the Officers’ reasonably arguable belief that they were
24 arresting Plaintiff with a valid warrant.
25 Construing Plaintiff’s opposition liberally in light of his self-represented status, he appears
26 to make a second argument that the Officers are not entitled to qualified immunity because “any
27 reasonable officer would know that an arrest without a producible warrant, when one is repeatedly
1 Plaintiff references as requiring such production concern search warrants and arrest warrants,
2 which are subject to validation and production requirements not applicable to bench warrants. For
3 example, Plaintiff cites to United States v. Gantt to support his argument that warrants must be
4 produced, but that case relates to search warrants, not bench warrants. Dkt. 33 at 3-4; 194 F.3d
5 987, 992 (9th Cir. 1999). Plaintiff similarly cites Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 153(c) as requiring the
6 seal of a court be affixed to a warrant, but it relates to “a warrant of arrest,” not a bench warrant.
7 Contra Dkt. 33 at 5. Finally, Plaintiff quotes Penal Code § 850(a), which permits an officer
8 containing a warrant abstract to proceed as if they held the original warrant from the issuing
9 authority. Id. at 6. But this section undermines Plaintiff’s contention because it permits officers to
10 act as if they had a physical warrant, and therefore a reasonable officer could believe in the
11 lawfulness of an arrest even without a producible warrant.
12 Accordingly, because the allegations and record before the Court demonstrate that the
13 Officers had an arguably reasonable belief that they were arresting Plaintiff subject to a valid
14 bench warrant, and they were not unreasonable in failing to produce a physical copy of the bench
15 warrant to Plaintiff, the Court GRANTS Defendants’ motion to dismiss claims one, two, and three
16 against the Officers due to qualified immunity. These claims are dismissed without leave to
17 amend for the reasons below.
18 C. The Court Denies Leave to Amend as Futile
19 Ordinarily, when a district court dismisses a complaint for failure to state a claim, “leave to
20 amend should be granted unless the court determine[s] that the allegation of other facts consistent
21 with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency.” Schreiber Distrib. Co. v.
22 Serv-Well Furniture Co., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986). Although district courts may
23 provide self-represented plaintiffs multiple opportunities to amend, dismissing a “pro se complaint
24 without leave to amend is appropriate where any opportunity to amend the complaint would be
25 futile.” Johnson v. Superior Ct. of California, No. 16-cv-01096-DAD (EPG), 2016 WL 6471123,
26 at *2 (E.D. Cal. Oct. 31, 2016) (citing Lopez v. Smith, 203 F.3d 1122, 1127 (9th Cir. 2000)). In
27 particular, leave to amend can properly be denied for futility when defendants are afforded
1 amendment opportunity was futile because of defendant’s Eleventh Amendment immunity); Scott
2 v. Keller, No. cv08-0781 CAS, 2010 WL 1780204, at *4 (E.D. Cal. Apr. 30, 2010) (finding leave
3 to amend futile because defendants were afforded qualified immunity).
4 Here, despite the challenges of attempting to amend around immunity defenses, this Court
5 previously allowed Plaintiff an opportunity to amend his Complaint. Dkt. 28 at 9. The Court
6 directed Plaintiff to consider “all of the arguments raised by Defendants in the [motion] and assert
7 only those facts or argument that can be put forward in good faith.” Id. As discussed above, the
8 FAC neither addresses Defendants’ arguments nor pleads facts sufficient to state a claim. See,
9 supra, §§ IV.A-B. The Court now determines that further leave to amend would be futile: It
10 would not change Defendant Quintero’s Eleventh Amendment immunity nor Defendant Officers’
11 qualified immunity arising from the bench warrant. Accordingly, claims one, two and three of the
12 FAC are dismissed without leave to amend.
13 D. The Court Declines Supplemental Jurisdiction Over the State-Law Claims
14 The Defendants also move to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(1), which directs a district court to
15 dismiss claims over which a court does not have subject matter jurisdiction. Dkt. 32 at 2. After
16 dismissing the federal claims, the only remaining claim is Plaintiff’s fourth claim: a state-law
17 claim alleging violation of his rights under the California Constitution. FAC at 11-12.
18 While the Court may exercise supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims, a plaintiff
19 must first have a plausible claim for relief under federal law. See 28 U.S.C. § 1367. “To the
20 extent plaintiff intends to bring state-law claims, those claims should not proceed due to the
21 absence of a cognizable federal claim.” Kepler v. Gingery, No. 2:24-CV-01426-DAD-CKD (PS),
22 2024 WL 4459144, at *3 (E.D. Cal. Oct. 10, 2024) (citing United Mine Auto Workers of Am. V.
23 Gibbs, 383 U.S. 715, 726 (1966) (“if the federal claims are dismissed before trial, … the state
24 claims should be dismissed as well”)). The Ninth Circuit also emphasizes that “state-law claims
25 ‘should’ be dismissed if all the federal claims have been dismissed short of trial.” Acri v. Varian
26 Assocs., Inc., 114 F.3d 999, 1000 (9th Cir. 1997) (en banc).
27 Here, because the remaining state-law claim does not raise any “extraordinary or unusual
] in the absence of any federal claims,” the Court will decline to exercise supplemental jurisdiction
2 || over the state-law claims against Defendants Quintero, McKenna and Walters. Molaris v. County
3 || of Sierra, 2012 WL 170159, *4 (E.D.Cal. Jan. 19, 2012); see also Ismail v. Cnty. of Orange, 917
4 || F. Supp. 2d 1060, 1064 (C.D. Cal. 2012), aff'd, 676 F. App’x 690 (9th Cir. 2017) (dismissing
5 || plaintiff's federal claims and declining supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims including a
6 || claim for conspiracy to deprive constitutional rights) (citing McInerney v. City & County of San
7 || Francisco, 466 Fed. App’x. 571, 573 (9th Cir. 2012) (on review of district court’s decision to
8 decline supplemental jurisdiction, “[t]here was no abuse of discretion because the district court
9 || had dismissed or granted judgment on all of McInerney’s federal claims.”)).
10 V. CONCLUSION
1] For the reasons set forth above, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants’ Motion to
12 || Dismiss is GRANTED in part as follows:
13 e All Claims against Defendant Quintero are DISMISSED without leave to amend
14 and with prejudice.
15 e Claims one, two and three against defendant Officers are DISMISSED without
a 16 leave to amend and with prejudice.
2 17 e Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c), the Court DECLINES supplemental jurisdiction
Z 18 over all state-law claims against Defendants Quintero, McKenna and Walters and
19 so dismisses these claims without prejudice to Plaintiff's ability to pursue them,
20 as appropriate, in a state court action.
21 Accordingly, having dismissed or declined jurisdiction over all claims, this case is
22 || DISMISSED. The Court directs the Clerk of the Court to close the file.
23
24 SO ORDERED.
25 Dated: June 26, 2025
26 Stason ya
SUSAN VAN KEULEN
27 United States Magistrate Judge
28