Opinion

Love v. Brown

Court
District Court, S.D. Illinois
Filed
Apr 30, 2025
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 35.0%

holding warden is proper defendant for injunctive relief claim as he would be responsible for ensuring that any injunctive relief would be carried out

How later courts described this case

  • holding warden is proper defendant for injunctive relief claim as he would be responsible for ensuring that any injunctive relief would be carried out
  • an action fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted if it does not plead “enough facts to state a claim that is plausible on its face.”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

ABDUL LOVE, #M10108, )

)

Plaintiff, )

)

vs. ) Case No. 25-cv-00380-SMY

)

CHRISTINE BROWN, PERCY MYERS, )

ANGELA LANKFORD, )

LATOYA HUGHES, JEREMY BONNETT, )

CLAYTON STEPHENSON, )

CHRISTY CROW, JEFFREY SADDLER, )

DAVID MITCHELL, JOHN BARWICK, )

LIVELY, )

WEXFORD HEALTH SOURCES, INC., )

SOUTHERN ILLINOIS HEALTH, )

JANE DOE (Nurse, SIH), and )

JOHN DOE (Doctor, Gastroenterology), )

)

Defendants. )

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

YANDLE, District Judge:

Plaintiff Abdul Love, an inmate of the Illinois Department of Corrections (“IDOC”)

currently incarcerated at Pinckneyville Correctional Center, filed the instant lawsuit pursuant to

42 U.S.C. § 1983 for alleged deprivations of his constitutional rights. He claims defendants

delayed and denied treatment for his serious medical conditions and seeks monetary damages and

injunctive relief.

This case is now before the Court for preliminary review of the Complaint under 28 U.S.C.

§ 1915A, which requires the Court to screen prisoner Complaints to filter out nonmeritorious

claims. 28 U.S.C. § 1915A(a). Any portion of the Complaint that is legally frivolous, malicious,

fails to state a claim for relief, or requests money damages from an immune defendant must be

dismissed. 28 U.S.C. § 1915A(b).

The Complaint

Plaintiff makes the following allegations in the Complaint (Doc. 1): While Plaintiff was

in the custody of the Lake County Jail for a post-conviction hearing in January 2023, he discovered

a painful growth on the right side of his face (Doc. 1, p. 7). Medical providers diagnosed him with

an infected salivary gland. An ear/nose/throat (“ENT”) specialist ordered a CT scan due to

Plaintiff’s history of Crohn’s disease and the medication (Entyvio) he took for that condition, as

well as Plaintiff’s family history of cancer (Doc. 1, p. 8). The CT scan revealed a tumor on

Plaintiff’s right parotid gland as well as a nodule on his left thyroid. He had a biopsy on the parotid

gland tumor and was scheduled to have the tumor surgically removed on August 2, 2023 (Doc. 1,

pp. 8-9). However, the surgery was not done because Plaintiff was transferred back to IDOC

custody on July 21, 2023.

Upon Plaintiff’s arrival at Pinckneyville on August 2, 2023, he told medical staff about the

scheduled surgery and his Entyvio infusion that was set for July 26, 2023, neither of which had

been performed. Pinckneyville staff told him that because the Lake County medical providers

were not part of Wexford Health Sources, Inc., a Wexford provider must restart his Crohn’s

medication and determine whether to approve surgery to remove the tumors (Doc. 1, pp. 9-10). A

Pinckneyville physician’s assistant submitted a referral on August 8, 2023 for Plaintiff to see an

off-site gastroenterologist for his Crohn’s and an ENT specialist for the thyroid and parotid tumors.

Plaintiff saw Defendant John Doe (gastroenterologist) regarding his Crohn’s treatment and

Defendant Jane Doe (gastroentero/gastrointestinal physician’s assistant) about the tumors, on

August 28, 2023.1 Jane Doe told Plaintiff that the formation of tumors and cancer are known side

effects of Entyvio. John Doe decided Plaintiff should not re-start Entyvio or any other related

1 Plaintiff alleges that John Doe and Jane Doe are employed by Southern Illinois Health (“SIH”) and that SIH is a

subcontractor of Wexford that provides off-site medical care for Pinckneyville prisoners (Doc. 1, pp. 6-7).

medication for Crohn’s until a thyroid biopsy was performed (Doc. 1, p. 11).

Plaintiff wrote to Defendant Acting Warden Crow on September 29, 2023, seeking help to

get medical care because Defendants Myers (Pinckneyville Medical Director) and Brown (Health

Care Unit Administrator) were unresponsive to his requests (Doc. 1, pp. 11, 38-39). His parotid

tumor had doubled in size in the previous two months and his pain had increased (Doc. 1, p. 38).

Crow did not respond. Plaintiff underwent a parotidectomy on December 8, 2023 to remove the

tumor from his salivary gland (Doc. 1, p. 12). No biopsy was performed on his thyroid.

Plaintiff returned to see Defendants John Doe and Jane Doe on March 14, 2024. He told

Jane Doe that for the past seven weeks, he had been having multiple daily bloody bowel

movements and diarrhea, stomach cramps, and rectal burning, indicating his Crohn’s disease was

no longer in remission. He also notified her the thyroid biopsy had not been done and asked her

to have the John Doe Doctor put in an order to expedite that biopsy. They gave Plaintiff an order

to return to see John Doe in three to six months (Doc. 1, pp. 12-13).

On approximately April 1, 2024, Plaintiff was sent to Barnes Jewish Hospital for an

ultrasound on his thyroid. The doctor there opined that the tumor did not appear to be cancerous.

Plaintiff questioned why he had not been given a biopsy. Plaintiff had a second ultrasound at the

Pinckneyville HCU on April 8, 2024, which resulted in the provider recommending a thyroid

biopsy (Doc. 1, pp. 13-14).

Plaintiff spoke with Defendant Brown at the HCU on approximately May 7, 2024. He told

her about his Crohn’s disease flare-up that had been going on since February or March 2024, and

that he could not re-start his Entyvio medication until he had a thyroid biopsy. He showed Brown

the report from his Lake County doctor that included an order for the thyroid biopsy. Brown

responded, “as long as there is a single breath in my body you will never get treatment for Crohn’s

disease or anything else.” (Doc. 1, p. 14).

Plaintiff wrote to Defendant Warden Barwick on June 19, 2024, informing him of Brown’s

statement, the nearly one-year delay in obtaining the thyroid biopsy, his worsening Crohn’s

symptoms, and requesting Barwick to address the matter with Defendants Myers and Brown (Doc.

1, pp. 14-15, 41-42). Barwick never responded. Plaintiff sent similar letters to Defendant Hughes

(IDOC Director) on July 6, 2024, and to Defendant ADA Coordinator Lankford on July 10, 2024,

but neither responded (Doc. 1, pp. 15-16, 44-45, 47).

On or about August 13, 2024, Plaintiff returned to the office of Dr. John Doe and P.A. Jane

Doe (Doc. 1, p. 16). He again told Jane Doe that his severe Crohn’s symptoms were continuing,

he had not received any medication to treat the Crohn’s symptoms for over one year, and the

thyroid biopsy had not been done. He demanded that Jane Doe or John Doe order the thyroid

biopsy. Jane Doe told Plaintiff that he would return to Pinckneyville with an order for the thyroid

biopsy in his treatment plan (Doc. 1, p. 17).

Upon returning to Pinckneyville, Plaintiff met with Defendant Myers regarding his Crohn’s

treatment plan. Myers said the plan was for Plaintiff to continue his Crohn’s disease medication

and return to see John Doe in six months. Myers noted Plaintiff was not on any Crohn’s

medication. Plaintiff confirmed he had not received any medication for the condition for over a

year and had been experiencing bloody bowel movements, rectal burning, stomach cramps, and

diarrhea for about six months. He asked Myers what his treatment plan would be in light of John

Doe’s failure to do anything for approximately a year (Doc. 1, pp. 17-18). Myers said he would

confer with John Doe on a treatment plan. Plaintiff told Myers he wanted to lodge a formal

complaint with Wexford and Defendant Southern Illinois Health (“SIH”) over the failure of John

Doe and Jane Doe to treat his Crohn’s disease treatment. Myers said he would inform Wexford

and SIH about his concerns and Plaintiff would be contacted by representatives of those entities.

Plaintiff received no such contact. Neither Myers nor John Doe ever made a treatment plan for

Plaintiff (Doc. 1, p. 18).

Plaintiff had another ultrasound of his thyroid in February 2025 after complaining of

painful swallowing and trouble breathing and turning his head (Doc. 1, p. 26). That test showed

that his thyroid tumor had more than doubled in size in the past year.

Defendants Bonnett, Stephenson, Saddler, Lively, Mitchell, and Barwick reviewed

Plaintiff’s detailed grievances over the lack of treatment for his Crohn’s disease and delayed

thyroid biopsy but did nothing to help him obtain treatment (Doc. 1, pp. 22, 25-26). Defendant

Brown prevented Plaintiff from obtaining medical treatment in retaliation for grievances and

complaints he had lodged against her over several years (Doc. 1, pp. 26-30). Plaintiff asserts a

civil conspiracy claim pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) and § 1986 against Brown, Wexford, SIH,

Lively, Barwick, Bonnett, and Hughes (Doc. 1, pp. 30-34).

In addition to monetary damages, Plaintiff seeks preliminary and permanent injunctions

requiring defendants to immediately provide him with a thyroid biopsy and Crohn’s disease

medication, as well as other medical treatment (Doc. 1, pp. 34-35).

Based on the allegations in the Complaint, the Court designates the following claims in

this pro se action:

Count 1: Eighth Amendment deliberate indifference to serious medical needs

claim against Defendants Myers, Jane Doe, John Doe, Brown,

Crow, Lankford, Barwick, Hughes, Bonnett, Stephenson, Saddler,

Lively, and Mitchell for failing to provide treatment for Plaintiff’s

severe and painful Crohn’s disease symptoms beginning on August

2, 2023.

Count 2: Eighth Amendment deliberate indifference to serious medical needs

claim against Defendants Myers, Jane Doe, John Doe, Brown,

Crow, Lankford, Barwick, Hughes, Bonnett, Stephenson, Saddler,

Lively, and Mitchell for failing to provide a biopsy or treatment for

Plaintiff’s thyroid tumor beginning on August 2, 2023.

Count 3: First Amendment retaliation claim against Brown for denying

and/or interfering with Plaintiff’s medical treatment because he filed

grievances and complaints against her.

Count 4: Civil conspiracy claim against Brown, Wexford, Southern Illinois

Health, Lively, Barwick, Bonnett, and Hughes for colluding to

prevent Plaintiff from obtaining medical treatment for his Crohn’s

disease and thyroid tumor.

Any other claim that is mentioned in the Complaint but not addressed in this Order should be

considered dismissed without prejudice as inadequately pled under the Twombly pleading

standard. See Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007) (an action fails to state a

claim upon which relief can be granted if it does not plead “enough facts to state a claim that is

plausible on its face.”).

Discussion

Counts 1 and 2

Prison officials and medical staff violate the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition against cruel

and unusual punishment when they act with deliberate indifference to a prisoner’s serious medical

needs. Rasho v. Elyea, 856 F.3d 469, 475 (7th Cir. 2017). To state such a claim, a prisoner must

plead facts and allegations suggesting that (1) he suffered from an objectively serious medical

condition, and (2) the defendant acted with deliberate indifference to his medical needs. Id. An

objectively serious condition includes a condition that significantly affects an individual’s daily

activities or which involves chronic and substantial pain. Gutierrez v. Peters, 111 F.3d 1364, 1373

(7th Cir. 1997). “[D]eliberate indifference may be found where an official knows about

unconstitutional conduct and facilitates, approves, condones, or turns a blind eye to it.” Perez v.

Fenoglio, 792 F.3d 768, 781 (7th Cir. 2015).

The allegations in the Complaint are sufficient for Plaintiff to proceed on the deliberate

indifference claims in Counts 1 and 2 against medical professionals Myers, Jane Doe, John Doe,

and Brown.2 While Wardens Crow and Barwick and IDOC Director Hughes are not medical

providers, Plaintiff alleges he contacted each of them directly, explaining his serious medical

conditions and his inability to obtain care from the medical providers. Where a plaintiff informs

prison officials that he is being denied access to health care, those officials may be liable under 42

U.S.C. § 1983 for their inaction. See Perez, 792 F.3d 768, 781 (7th Cir. 2015); Hayes v. Snyder,

546 F.3d 516, 527 (7th Cir. 2008). Counts 1 and 2 may also proceed against Crow, Barwick, and

Hughes.

However, ADA Coordinator Lankford will be dismissed from the case. Plaintiff

communicated with her as well, but he fails to allege any facts indicating that he qualifies as an

individual with a disability requiring accommodation or that Lankford had any responsibility to

obtain medical care for him.

Plaintiff asserts Pinckneyville grievance officers Saddler and Lively, Warden Mitchell, and

ARB officials Stephenson and Bonnett should be liable for failing to take action to obtain medical

care for him after reviewing his grievances. With respect to each of the three grievances Plaintiff

included, these officials relied on information provided by the Health Care Unit Administrator

(“HCUA”) stating that Plaintiff was under the care of outside specialists who would address his

medical issues (Doc. 1, pp. 53-54, 59, 66). On April 8, 2024, Lively noted, per the HCUA, the

specialist at Barnes/Washington University determined a thyroid biopsy was not needed (Doc. 1,

2 At this stage, the Court accepts Plaintiff’s allegation regarding the contractual relationship between SIH and Wexford

as true. A contract with Wexford (which contracts with IDOC to provide medical care to inmates) for SIH and its

employees Jane Doe and John Doe to provide medical services to Plaintiff would allow these parties to be considered

as “state actors” subject to suit under § 1983. See West v. Atkins, 487 U.S. 42, 55-56 (1988).

p. 59). Lively responded on September 25, 2024, that per the HCUA, Plaintiff’s GI specialist had

determined no follow-up was needed for his thyroid and Plaintiff was scheduled for another GI

specialist visit (Doc. 1, p. 66). Mitchell, Stephenson, and Bonnett approved the disposition of one

or more of those grievances.

Grievance officials and those who sign off on grievance reports and appeals are ordinarily

not liable in a civil rights action for failing to remedy the matters raised in the grievance. Rather,

to be liable under § 1983, a defendant must be personally responsible for the violation of a

constitutional right; review of a grievance does not amount to personal involvement. Taylor v.

Ways, 999 F.3d 478, 493 (7th Cir. 2021); Owens v. Evans, 878 F.3d 559, 563 (7th Cir. 2017). If a

prisoner is under the care of prison medical professionals, a non-medical prison official “will

generally be justified in believing that the prisoner is in capable hands.” Arnett v. Webster, 658

F.3d 742, 755 (7th Cir. 2011) . Plaintiff’s documentation does not indicate that these grievance

officials had sufficient awareness of the allegedly inadequate medical care to support a deliberate

indifference claim against them. Accordingly, Saddler, Lively, Mitchell, Stephenson, and Bonnett

will be dismissed from Counts 1 and 2.

Count 3

Prison officials may not retaliate against inmates for filing grievances, lawsuits, or

otherwise complaining about their conditions of confinement. See, e.g., Gomez v. Randle, 680

F.3d 859, 866 (7th Cir. 2012); Walker v. Thompson, 288 F.3d 1005 (7th Cir. 2002). “A complaint

states a claim for retaliation when it sets forth ‘a chronology of events from which retaliation may

plausibly be inferred.’” Zimmerman v. Tribble, 226 F.3d 568, 573 (7th Cir. 2000) (citation

omitted). In this case, Plaintiff alleges that he filed several grievances and complaints against

Brown before telling her in May 2024 that he needed a thyroid biopsy in order to re-start his

Crohn’s disease medication. Brown allegedly responded that she would not allow him to get

medical treatment. Plaintiff was unable to get the care he sought, up to and including the date he

filed this action, March 21, 2025. Given this chronology of events, Count 3 may proceed against

Brown.

Count 4

Plaintiff invokes 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) and 42 U.S.C. § 1986 as the foundations for his civil

conspiracy claim (Doc. 1, p. 31). Civil conspiracy claims are cognizable under § 1983. See Lewis

v. Washington, 300 F.3d 829, 831 (7th Cir. 2002); Walker v. Thompson, 288 F.3d 1005, 1007-08

(7th Cir. 2002). Here, Plaintiff alleges that his September 11, 2024 grievance put Wexford, SIH,

Barwick, Hughes, Lively, and Bonnett on notice that Brown vowed in May 2024 to prevent him

from getting any medical treatment. He also alleges that thereafter, these defendants took no steps

to prevent Brown from making good on her promise. Plaintiff further claims that his October 12,

2024 grievance regarding untreated foot and back pain confirmed that Brown succeeded in

preventing him from getting medical care, and the other defendants failed to stop Brown from

violating his rights (Doc. 1, pp. 33, 70-72, 74).

Plaintiff’s assertion that Wexford and SIH were put “on notice” of his complaints and of

Brown’s alleged misconduct through his prison grievances is implausible because his factual

allegations fail to suggest that Wexford or SIH received copies of these grievances or of the prison

officials’ responses. The bare allegation that these entities conspired to deprive Plaintiff of his

right to medical care, absent any indication that Wexford or SIH knew about these grievances, fails

to state a viable claim. Wexford and SIH will therefore be dismissed from Count 4.

Barwick, Hughes, Lively, and Bonnett, who are IDOC employees, are the only remaining

defendants in Plaintiff’s conspiracy claim. Under the intracorporate conspiracy doctrine, a

conspiracy cannot exist solely between members of the same entity. This rule applies to claims

brought under § 1985 and § 1986. See Wright v. Illinois Dept. of Children & Family Services, 40

F.3d 1492, 1508 (7th Cir. 1994); Greene v. Teslik, No. 21-2154, 2023 WL 2320767, at *4 (7th Cir.

Mar. 2, 2023). Therefore, Count 4 will be dismissed in its entirety for failure to state a claim upon

which relief may be granted.

Injunctive Relief

Because the Complaint includes a request for injunctive relief, John Barwick, the current

Warden of Pinckneyville Correctional Center, will remain as a defendant in his official capacity

with regard to this request. See Gonzales v. Feinerman, 663 F.3d 311, 315 (7th Cir. 2011) (holding

warden is proper defendant for injunctive relief claim as he would be responsible for ensuring that

any injunctive relief would be carried out).

Official Capacity Claims

Plaintiff raises claims against each defendant in his or her individual and official capacities.

As noted above, the injunctive relief claim is properly brought against the Pinckneyville Warden

Barwick in his official capacity. However, Plaintiff’s claims for monetary damages may only be

pursued against state officials in their individual capacities. Brown v. Budz, 904 F.3d 904, 918

(7th Cir. 2005); Shockley v. Jones, 823 F.2d 1068, 1070 (7th Cir. 1987). Accordingly, the official

capacity claims against the remaining individual defendants are dismissed without prejudice.

Unknown/John/Jane Doe Defendants

Plaintiff is responsible for securing information aimed at identifying the Unknown John

Doe and Jane Doe Defendants, in accordance with the John/Jane Doe Identification Order that will

be entered separately. Once the names of the unknown defendants are obtained, Plaintiff must file

a motion to substitute the newly identified defendants in place of the generic designations in the

case caption and throughout the Complaint. Pinckneyville Warden Barwick, in his official

capacity, will be responsible for responding to Plaintiff’s requests for information regarding the

identity of the Unknown Defendants.

Disposition

The Complaint states colorable claims in Counts 1 and 2 against Brown, Myers, Hughes,

Crow, Barwick, Jane Doe, and John Doe; and in Count 3 against Brown. Count 4 and Defendants

Lankford, Bonnett, Stephenson, Saddler, Mitchell, Lively, Wexford Health Sources, Inc., and

Southern Illinois Health are DISMISSED without prejudice.

The Clerk shall prepare for Christine Brown, Percy Myers, Latoya Hughes, Christy Crow,

and Warden John Barwick (in his official and individual capacity): (1) Form 5 (Notice of a Lawsuit

and Request to Waive Service of a Summons), and (2) Form 6 (Waiver of Service of Summons).

The Clerk is DIRECTED to mail these forms, a copy of the Complaint, and this Memorandum

and Order to each Defendant’s place of employment as identified by Plaintiff. If a Defendant fails

to sign and return the Waiver of Service of Summons (Form 6) to the Clerk within 30 days from

the date the forms were sent, the Clerk shall take appropriate steps to effect formal service on the

Defendant, and the Court will require the Defendant to pay the full costs of formal service, to the

extent authorized by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

If a Defendant cannot be found at the work address provided by Plaintiff, the employer

shall furnish the Clerk with the Defendant’s current work address, or, if not known, the

Defendant’s last-known address. This information shall be used only for sending the forms as

directed above or for formally effecting service. Any documentation of the address shall be

retained only by the Clerk and shall not be maintained in the court file or disclosed by the Clerk.

Defendants are ORDERED to timely file an appropriate responsive pleading to the

Complaint and shall not waive filing a reply pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(g). Pursuant to

Administrative Order No. 244 and Local Rule 8.2, Defendants need only respond to the issues

stated in this Merit Review Order.

Plaintiff is ADVISED that if judgment is rendered against him and the judgment includes

the payment of costs under 28 U.S.C. §1915, he will be required to pay the full amount of the

costs.

Plaintiff is further ADVISED that he is under a continuing obligation to keep the Clerk of

Court and the opposing parties informed of any change in his address; the Court will not

independently investigate his whereabouts. This shall be done in writing and not later than 14 days

after a transfer or other change in address occurs. Failure to comply with this order will cause a

delay in the transmission of court documents and may result in dismissal of this action for want of

prosecution. See FED. R. CIV. P. 41(b).

Finally, based on the allegations in the Complaint, the Clerk of Court is DIRECTED to

ENTER the standard qualified protective order pursuant to the Health Insurance Portability and

Accountability Act.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

DATED: April 30, 2025

s/ Staci M. Yandle_____

STACI M. YANDLE

United States District Judge

Notice to Plaintiff

The Court will take the necessary steps to notify the Defendants of your lawsuit and serve

them with a copy of your Complaint. After service has been achieved, Defendants will enter an

appearance and file an Answer to your Complaint. It will likely take at least 60 days from the date

of this Order to receive the Defendants’ Answer, but it is entirely possible that it will take 90 days

or more. When Defendants have filed their Answers, the Court will enter a Scheduling Order

containing important information on deadlines, discovery, and procedures. Plaintiff is advised to

wait until counsel has appeared for Defendants before filing any motions, to give the Defendants

notice and an opportunity to respond to those motions. Motions filed before Defendants’ counsel

has filed an appearance will generally be denied as premature. Plaintiff need not submit any

evidence to the Court at this time, unless specifically directed to do so.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.