Opinion

Smith v. Mulvey

Court
District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania
Filed
Mar 18, 2025
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 34.5%

“Police may rely on hearsay and other evidence that would not be admissible in a court to determine probable cause.”

How later courts described this case

  • “Police may rely on hearsay and other evidence that would not be admissible in a court to determine probable cause.”
  • finding that qualified immunity is lost when an officer’s search warrant lacks probable cause
  • holding that hearsay is acceptable support for finding probable cause
  • holding that use of a District-owned computer for non-work purposes for 780 minutes constituted a de minimis benefit to the petitioner because the benefit was worth $640.11

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

ROBERT BOYER,

Plaintiff, CIVIL ACTION NO. 3:19-CV-00242

v.

(MEHALCHICK, J.)

MICHAEL MULVEY,

Defendant.

MEMORANDUM

This civil rights action was initiated by Plaintiffs Tamra Smith (“Smith”)1 and Robert

Boyer (“Boyer”) on February 12, 2019, by the filing of a complaint against Defendants

Wyoming Borough (“the Borough”) and Michael Mulvey (“Mulvey”). (Doc. 1). In the

complaint, Boyer asserts claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for violations of the Fourth

Amendment right to be free from unlawful search and seizures. (Doc. 1). Presently before the

Court are cross-motions for summary judgment. (Doc. 104; Doc. 112). On August 2, 2024,

Boyer filed a motion seeking partial summary judgment on Count Two of the complaint.

(Doc. 104). On November 6, 2024, Mulvey moved for summary judgment on the complaint

in its entirety. (Doc. 112). For the reasons set forth herein, Mulvey’s motion for summary

judgment shall be GRANTED as to Count One and DENIED as to Count Two. (Doc. 112).

Boyer’s motion for partial summary judgment shall be DENIED. (Doc. 104).

1 On August 30, 2019, Smith was terminated from this action and on August 20, 2019

Boyer, as Executor of the Estate of Smith, was substituted in place of her. (Doc. 28).

I. BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

This factual background is taken from the parties’ statements of material facts and

accompanying exhibits, as well as the parties’ responses thereto. (Doc. 104; Doc. 105; Doc.

109; Doc. 112; Doc. 113; Doc. 114; Doc. 115; Doc. 116; Doc. 119; Doc. 120; Doc. 123). This

case stems from Mulvey’s investigation of two former employees of Wyoming Borough,

Boyer and Smith. (Doc. 1).

The first investigation deals with Boyer. (Doc. 105; Doc. 115). From January 2006 to

January 2018, Boyer was the mayor of Wyoming Borough. (Doc. 105, ¶ 2; Doc. 115, ¶ 2). On

or about May 18, 2018, Mulvey completed a search warrant application along with an

affidavit of sworn probable cause to search Boyer’s residence and submitted it to Magisterial

District Judge Joseph J. Carmody. (Doc. 114, ¶ 48; Doc. 120, ¶ 48). In the search warrant

application for Boyer’s residence, Mulvey alleges that Boyer engaged in a conflict of interest

under the Pennsylvania Public Official and Employee Ethics Act (“Ethics Act”) by supporting

a certain grant application while mayor. (Doc. 105, ¶¶ 27-29; Doc. 114, ¶¶ 46-49; Doc. 115,

¶¶ 27-29; Doc. 120, ¶¶ 46-49). The grant application Mulvey references is the West Wyoming

Firehouse Addition Renovation Project (“LSA Grant”). (Doc. 105, ¶ 25; Doc. 115, ¶ 25). The

LSA Grant sought to increase space and update heating and cooling systems in the facility

used by the West Wyoming Hose Company, a volunteer fire and ambulance service. (Doc.

105, ¶ 25; Doc. 115, ¶ 25). Boyer authored a letter supporting the LSA Grant but did not vote

on the application. (Doc. 105, ¶ 26; Doc. 115, ¶ 26). The LSA Grant was approved by the

Wyoming Borough Council. (Doc. 105, ¶ 25; Doc. 115, ¶ 25). Mulvey alleges that Boyer’s

letter of support violated the Ethics Act because Boyer owns a food business that at times used

the West Wyoming Hose Company’s banquet hall, a connection that Boyer did not disclose

2

in his letter. (Doc. 105, ¶¶ 27-30; Doc. 114, ¶ 49; Doc. 115, ¶¶ 27-30; Doc. 120, ¶ 49). Boyer

contends that any space he would have used at the facility would not have been impacted by

the expansions funded by the LSA Grant, and even if spaces that he used would be impacted,

that economic benefit would have been de minimis, and thus not have created a conflict of

interest. (Doc. 105, ¶¶ 27-30; Doc. 114, ¶ 49; Doc. 115, ¶¶ 27-30; Doc. 120, ¶ 49). Mulvey’s

search warrant application for Boyer’s residence was approved, and a search was executed on

May 18, 2018. (Doc. 105, ¶¶ 31-33; Doc. 115, ¶¶ 31-33).

The second investigation relevant to this matter involves Smith, Boyer’s girlfriend at

all times relevant to this matter. (Doc. 114, ¶¶ 1, 4-8; Doc. 120, ¶¶ 1, 4-8). From October 2010

through November 2018, Smith was the borough manager for Wyoming Borough, as well as

the treasurer of the Wyoming Library until 2016. (Doc. 105, ¶ 3; Doc. 115, ¶ 3; Doc. 114, ¶

9; Doc. 120, ¶ 9). On August 21, 2015, Special Agent Joseph F. Noone of the Federal Bureau

of Investigation (FBI) opened an investigation into Smith for alleged corruption. (Doc. 114,

¶ 1; Doc. 120, ¶ 1). During their romantic relationship, as well as during both Smith and

Boyer’s terms as borough manger and mayor respectively, Smith owned an accounting and

financial services business. (Doc. 114, ¶ 16, Doc. 120, ¶ 16). She had access to financial

information including debit cards, checkbooks, and physical documents related to the library

and Wyoming Fire Department and Hose Company in her capacity as borough employee

and through her personal business. (Doc. 114-4, at 2-4). Smith failed to turn over such records

and documents related to investigations into her alleged corruption. (Doc. 114-4, at 2-4).

Additionally, postage purchased by Smith on the library debit card went missing during her

time with the library. (Doc. 114, at 4; Doc. 114-4, at 4; Doc. 120, at 7-8). On or about January

24th, 2018, Mulvey and the IRS executed a search warrant on Smith’s home. (Doc. 114-2, ¶

3

14).

On February 12, 2019, Smith and Boyer filed the instant complaint, arguing that the

searches of their homes were executed without probable cause, violating their Fourth

Amendment rights to be free from unlawful search and seizures. (Doc. 1). The summary

judgment motions filed are now ripe for disposition.

II. LEGAL STANDARDS

A. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD

Under Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, summary judgment should be

granted only if “there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled

to judgment as a matter of law.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a). A fact is “material” only if it might

affect the outcome of the case. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). A

dispute of material fact is “genuine” if the evidence “is such that a reasonable jury could return

a verdict for the non-moving party.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248. In deciding a summary

judgment motion, all inferences “should be drawn in the light most favorable to the non-

moving party, and where the non-moving party’s evidence contradicts the movant’s, then the

non-movant’s must be taken as true.” Pastore v. Bell Tel. Co. of Pa., 24 F.3d 508, 512 (3d Cir.

1994). However, a party opposing a summary judgment motion must comply with Local Rule

56.1, which specifically directs the oppositional party to submit a “statement of the material

facts, responding to the numbered paragraphs set forth in the statement required [to be filed

by the movant], as to which it is contended that there exists a genuine issue to be tried”; if the

nonmovant fails to do so, “[a]ll material facts set forth in the statement required to be served

by the moving party will be deemed to be admitted.” See M.D. Pa. L.R. 56.1.

A federal court should grant summary judgment “if the pleadings, depositions,

4

answers to interrogatories, and admissions on file, together with the affidavits, if any, show

that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a

judgment as a matter of law.” Farrell v. Planters Lifesavers Co., 206 F.3d 271, 278 (3d Cir. 2000).

In deciding a motion for summary judgment, the court’s function is not to make credibility

determinations, weigh evidence, or draw inferences from the facts. Anderson, 477 U.S. at 249.

Rather, the court must simply “determine whether there is a genuine issue for trial.” Anderson,

477 U.S. at 249.

The party seeking summary judgment “bears the initial responsibility of informing the

district court of the basis for its motion,” and demonstrating the absence of a genuine dispute

of any material fact. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986). If the movant makes

such a showing, the non-movant must go beyond the pleadings with affidavits or declarations,

answers to interrogatories, or the like to demonstrate specific material facts which give rise to

a genuine issue. Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c); Celotex, 477 U.S. at 324. The non-movant must produce

evidence to show the existence of every element essential to its case, which it bears the burden

of proving at trial, because “a complete failure of proof concerning an essential element of the

nonmoving party's case necessarily renders all other facts immaterial.” Celotex, 477 U.S. at

323. Furthermore, mere conclusory allegations and self-serving testimony, whether made in

the complaint or a sworn statement, cannot be used to obtain or avoid summary judgment

when uncorroborated and contradicted by other evidence of record. See Lujan v. Nat’l Wildlife

Fed’n, 497 U.S. 871, 888 (1990); see also Thomas v. Delaware State Univ., 626 F. App’x 384, 389

n.6 (3d Cir. 2015) (not precedential) (“[U]nsupported deposition testimony, which is

contradicted by the record, is insufficient to defeat summary judgment.”); Nat’l Labor Rel. Bd.

v. FES, 301 F.3d 83, 95 (3d Cir. 2002) (“[The plaintiff’s] testimony . . . amounts to an

5

unsupported, conclusory assertion, which we have held is inadequate to satisfy the movant’s

burden of proof on summary judgment.”).

B. 42 U.S.C. § 1983

Section 1983 is the vehicle by which private citizens may seek redress for violations of

federal constitutional rights committed by state officials. See 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The statute

states, in pertinent part:

Every person who, under color of any statute, ordinance, regulation, custom,

or usage, of any State or Territory or the District of Columbia, subjects, or

causes to be subjected, any citizen of the United States or other person within

the jurisdiction thereof to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or

immunities secured by the Constitution and laws, shall be liable to the party

injured in an action at law, suit in equity, or other proper proceeding for redress.

42 U.S.C. § 1983.

“Section 1983 is not a source of substantive rights,” but is merely a means through

which “to vindicate violations of federal law committed by state actors.” See Pappas v. City of

Lebanon, 331 F. Supp. 2d 311, 315 (M.D. Pa. 2004) (quoting Gonzaga Univ. v. Doe, 536 U.S.

273, 284-85 (2002)). To state a cause of action under Section 1983, a plaintiff must allege that:

(1) the conduct complained of was committed by persons acting under color of state law; and

(2) the conduct violated a right, privilege, or immunity secured by the Constitution or laws of

the United States. See Harvey v. Plains Twp. Police Dep’t, 421 F.3d 185, 189 (3d Cir. 2005)

(quoting West v. Atkins, 487 U.S. 42, 48 (1988)).

III. DISCUSSION

A. FOURTH AMENDMENT CLAIMS

The complaint brings claims for violations of the Fourth Amendment related to

Mulvey’s search of Smith and Boyer’s residences. (Doc. 1). The parties dispute the threshold

6

issue of whether Mulvey’s searches of the residences were properly supported by probable

cause. (Doc. 109; Doc. 119).

The Fourth Amendment states, in pertinent part, that “[t]he right of the people to be

secure in their persons ... against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated,

and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause....” U.S. CONST. Amend. IV. Whether

a search or seizure is unreasonable “depends on all of the circumstances surrounding the

search or seizure and the nature of the search or seizure itself.” Skinner v. Ry. Labor Execs.’

Ass'n, 489 U.S. 602, 616 (1989) (quoting United States v. Montoya de Hernandez, 473 U.S. 531,

537 (1985)). A court's inquiry involves assessing “on the one hand, the degree to which [the

search or seizure] intrudes upon an individual's privacy and, on the other, the degree to which

[the search or seizure] is needed for the promotion of legitimate governmental interests.”

Wyoming v. Houghton, 526 U.S. 295, 300 (1999).

“A search warrant may be issued only if there is probable cause to believe that evidence

of criminal activity will be found on the premises or person searched.” Lesoine v. Cnty. of

Lackawanna, No. CIV.A. 3:98-CV-0764, 2000 WL 572466, at *4 (M.D. Pa. May 5, 2000)

(citing Carroll v. United States, 267 U.S. 132 (1925)). When considering whether a warrant was

properly supported by probable cause, a court must take into consideration “the totality of

circumstances.” See Lesoine, 2000 WL 572466, at *4 (citing Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 235

(1983)); Gomez v. Markley, No. CIV.A. 07-868, 2011 WL 113163, at *4 (W.D. Pa. Jan. 13,

2011) (“Probable cause requires ‘a fair probability that contraband or evidence of a crime will

be found in a particular place,’ and is based on the ‘totality of the circumstances’ available at

the time of the search”) (quoting Gates, 462 U.S. at 238). To find a Fourth Amendment

violation based on an improper search warrant, a plaintiff must prove “(1) that the affiant

7

knowingly, or with a reckless disregard for the truth, made false statements or omissions that

create a falsehood in applying for a warrant; and, (2) that such statements or omissions are

material to the finding of probable cause.” Lesoine, 2000 WL 572466, at *4 n.2.

1. Whether Mulvey Had Probable Cause to Search Smith’s Home

Mulvey moves for summary judgment on Count One of the complaint, which asserts

Fourth Amendment claims related to his search of Smith’s home. (Doc. 1). Mulvey contends

that he had probable cause to search Smith’s residence, and as such, Smith’s Fourth

Amendment rights were not violated. (Doc. 113, at 10-11). According to Mulvey, none of the

information in his application for a search warrant of Smith’s residence was misleading, nor

were there any material omissions. (Doc. 113, at 10). Boyer’s opposition to summary

judgment on Count One relies entirely on the assertion that much of the basis for Mulvey’s

probable cause affidavit was statements and information that constituted hearsay. (Doc. 119,

at 20-22). However, Boyer does not seem to contest Mulvey’s assertion that no information

in his search warrant application for Smith’s home was misleading. (Doc. 119, at 20-22).

Hearsay does not implicate the analysis for whether Mulvey had probable cause.

Warner v. McCunney, No. CIV.A. 05-1248, 2005 WL 2811738, at *3 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 27, 2005)

(“The evidence establishing probable cause may be hearsay.”), aff'd, 259 F. App'x 476 (3d Cir.

2008) (citing Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 165 (1978)); Evans v. City of Newark, No.

CV1400120KMMAH, 2023 WL 2535283, at *18 n.9 (D.N.J. Mar. 16, 2023) (“[w]hatever its

merits, the hearsay argument is irrelevant for purposes of evaluating the probable cause

possessed by the police. Police may rely on hearsay evidence to supply the probable cause

necessary to make an arrest.”) (citations omitted); Miller v. Ctr. Cnty., No. 4:15-CV-1754, 2016

WL 4582063, at *7 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 1, 2016) (noting that hearsay may support an affidavit of

8

probable cause and stating “[i]n judging whether particular averments establish probable

cause, we are mindful of the principle that probable cause [. . . ] is a practical, non-technical

conception requiring a consideration of the totality of the circumstances”), aff'd sub nom. Miller

v. Cnty. of Ctr., 702 F. App'x 69 (3d Cir. 2017); Smith v. Angelo, No. CV 14-1066-GMS, 2017

WL 2276985, at *1 n.2 (D. Del. May 25, 2017), aff'd, 765 F. App'x 757 (3d Cir. 2018)

(“Further, the Third Circuit has made clear that ‘probable cause may rest upon hearsay’”)

(quoting Torres v. City of Philadelphia, No. 13–2710, 2016 WL 7396723, at *2 (3d Cir: Dec. 21,

2016); Franks, 438 U.S. at 164–65 (“probable cause may be founded upon hearsay and upon

information received from informants”); United States v. Mathis, 357 F.3d 1200, 1205 (10th

Cir. 2004) (holding that hearsay is acceptable support for finding probable cause) “[H]earsay

from unknown or unnamed individuals has been recognized as acceptable support for a

finding of probable cause.”); Hart v. Parks, 450 F.3d 1059, 1066 (9th Cir. 2006) (“Police may

rely on hearsay and other evidence that would not be admissible in a court to determine

probable cause.”).

Here, Smith was being investigated for corruption and certain suspicious financial

activities. (Doc. 114, at 4; Doc. 114-4, at 2-4; Doc. 120, at 7-8). The undisputed record

contains evidence that Mulvey had information and reason to believe that Smith had access

to financial accounts for both Wyoming Borough and the Wyoming Hose Company; that

documents she possessed had gone missing during her tenure as borough manager and

treasurer of the library; that she ran her accounting business out of her home; and that there

was suspicious use of funds related to certain purchases of postage Smith had made. (Doc.

113, at 10-11; Doc. 114-4, at 2-4). Mulvey’s reasonable belief that Smith may have had

information or records in her home related to missing financial documents formed a basis of

9

probable cause, even if the suspicion was based on hearsay. See Evans, 2023 WL 2535283, at

*18 n.9; see also Lesoine, 2000 WL 572466, at *4 (finding that a search warrant is supported by

probable cause when an officer has reason to believe evidence of criminal activity may be

located in that searched location).

Having found that the warrant for the search of Smith’s reference was properly

supported by probable cause, the Court finds that Mulvey is entitled to summary judgment

on Count One. See Bhd. of Locomotive Eng'rs v. Rossi, 290 F. App'x 518, 519 (3d Cir. 2008)

(affirming district court’s grant of summary judgment to defendants when there was a warrant

based upon probable cause and stating “[t]he critical element in a reasonable search is not

that the owner of the property is suspected of crime but that there is reasonable cause to believe

that the specific ‘things' to be searched for and seized are located on the property for which

entry is sought.”). Accordingly, Mulvey’s motion for summary judgement on Count One is

GRANTED. (Doc. 112).

2. Whether Mulvey Had Probable Cause to Search Boyer’s Home

Both parties move for summary judgment on Count Two, Boyer’s Fourth Amendment

claim related to Mulvey’s search of his own home. (Doc. 1; Doc. 104; Doc. 112). Boyer

submits that he is entitled to summary judgment because Mulvey’s search warrant application

included material omissions or misstatements, and for that reason, Mulvey’s search lacked

probable cause. (Doc. 119, at 6). Mulvey contends that his search warrant application was

predicated upon probable cause and that the probable cause affidavit included no material

falsehoods. (Doc. 113, at 7-10).

The search warrant for Boyer’s residence was based upon Mulvey’s alleged belief that

he would find evidence of Boyer’s potential violations of the Ethics Act within the searched

10

property. See Lesoine, 2000 WL 572466, at *4. Per the Ethics Act, “[no] public official or public

employee shall engage in conduct that constitutes a conflict of interest.” 65 Pa.C.S.A. § 1103.

Under the statute, a “conflict of interest” consists of:

“Use by a public official or public employee of the authority of his office or

employment or any confidential information received through his holding

public office or employment for the private pecuniary benefit of himself, a

member of his immediate family or a business with which he or a member of

his immediate family is associated. The term does not include an action having

a de minimis economic impact or which affects to the same degree a class

consisting of the general public or a subclass consisting of an industry,

occupation or other group which includes the public official or public

employee, a member of his immediate family or a business with which he or a

member of his immediate family is associated.”

65 Pa.C.S.A. § 1102.

A de minimis economic impact consists of “[a]n economic consequence which has an

insignificant effect.” 65 Pa.C.S.A. § 1102. Though there is not a precise definition of what

constitutes a de minimis benefit to avoid triggering a violation of the Ethics Act, courts have

considered factors such as the monetary value of the benefit. See Thomas Bixler, v. State Ethics

Comm’n, 2004 WL 3414060, at *11 (finding that a violation of the Ethics Act was not triggered

when a public official participated in decisions resulting in maintenance services for Township

Vehicles by a fleet service by which he was employed, because the total profit from the repairs

was $561.77, a de minimis benefit); see also Seropian v. State Ethics Comm'n, 20 A.3d 534 (Pa.

Commw. Ct. 2011) (holding that use of a District-owned computer for non-work purposes for

780 minutes constituted a de minimis benefit to the petitioner because the benefit was worth

$640.11); see also Kraines v. Pennsylvania State Ethics Comm'n, 805 A.2d 677, 682-83 (Pa.

Commw. Ct. 2002) (holding that a public official did not violate the Ethics Act when she

11

signed off on county checks to her spouse for pathologist fees in excess of amounts set forth

between her spouse and the county’s contract in part because the payments received had an

“insignificant adverse economic impact,” since the fees paid were lower than fees charged by

other pathologists in the area); see also Pulice v. State Ethics Comm’n, 713 A.2d 161, 168 (finding

a de minimis economic impact regarding a salary increase of $1,672 when considered with the

greater responsibility and qualifications required by the worker). Additionally, in determining

whether a suspected Ethics Act violation has occurred, courts consider whether the benefit

affected to the same degree a class consisting of an occupation or other group. See Pulice, 713

A.2d at 166 (finding that a public official did not violate the Ethics Act by maintaining a joint

bank account with her son-in-law who received a salary increase even if she did receive a

private pecuniary benefit, because the “amount of the salary increase affected to the same

degree every member of the class of school administrators [. . .] the increase was not in the

form of a bonus or other individual increase”); see also Bixler, 2004 WL 3414060, at *9 (finding

no violation because there was a de minimis economic impact and because Bixler was a

member of a subclass of truck mechanics). Finally, Pennsylvania courts have emphasized that

to violate § 1103(a), a public official must “use” the public office to obtain financial

gain. McGuire v. State Ethics Commission, 657 A.2d 1346, 1351 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 1995). While

the Ethics Act does not define the term “use,” “[t]his Court has held that ‘use’ of public office

requires action by a public official that in some way facilitates his receipt of compensation to

which he is not entitled.” Kraines, 805 A.2d at 681 (citing McGuire, 657 A.2d at 1351).

Here, there are material facts in dispute regarding the degree of omissions and the

materiality of the misleading statements in the search warrant application. Mulvey indicated

in his affidavit of probable cause that the kitchen was being expanded. (Doc. 105-3, at 24, 28;

12

Doc. 115, ¶ 30). A reasonable juror may assume that this means that the renovations were

aimed, if not primarily, at least to a substantial degree, towards kitchen improvements. If as

much is true, it follows that Boyer, as mayor, supported the LSA Grant that would primarily

benefit Boyer personally. This would give Mulvey reason to believe evidence of an Ethics Act

violation may be found in Boyer’s home. However, Boyer has presented evidence that

Mulvey’s description of the LSA Grant was misleading and contained material admissions in

reckless disregard of the truth. (Doc. 105-3, at 24, 28; Doc. 119, at 8-10). The record contains

evidence that the only construction planned under the LSA Grant that affected the kitchen

would have been that of a new door connecting the kitchen to a newly constructed area

adjacent to the kitchen. (Doc. 105-3, at 24, 28). In fact, the kitchen is only mentioned twice

in the 94-page LSA Grant. (Doc. 105-3). Thus, a reasonable juror could find that such an

omission was in reckless disregard for the truth. The Court also finds that a reasonable juror

could conclude that such omissions materially impacted Magistrate Judge Carmody’s

approval of the search warrant. See, e.g., Dempsey v. Bucknell University, 834 F.3d 457, 468-70

(3d Cir. 2016). As such, there is a question of material fact regarding whether the warrant was

constitutional. See Steinhauer v. E. Pennsboro Area Sch. Dist., No. 1:21-CV-02030, 2024 WL

3905037, at *4 (M.D. Pa. Aug. 22, 2024) (“[f]or a warrant to be constitutionally suspect,

‘misstatements and omissions must have been material, or necessary, to the finding of

probable cause.’” (quoting Pinkney v. Meadville, Pennsylvania, 95 F.4th 743, 748-49 (3d Cir.

2024) (quotations omitted)) (citing Sherwood v. Mulvihill, 113 F.3d 396, 399 (3d Cir. 1997)).

13

Accordingly, both motions for summary judgment on Count Two are DENIED. (Doc. 104;

Doc. 114).2

B. QUALIFIED IMMUNITY

Mulvey also moves for summary judgment on the grounds that he is entitled to

qualified immunity for each of the claims in the complaint. (Doc. 113, at 11-14). Under the

doctrine of qualified immunity, law enforcement officers, like other public officials,

performing discretionary duties within the scope of their employment, are “shielded from

liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory

constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Harlow v. Fitzgerald,

457 U.S. 800, 818 (1982). The two-pronged test for whether qualified immunity applies

requires this court to determine (1) “whether the facts that a plaintiff has alleged or shown

make out a violation of a constitutional right” and (2) “whether the right at issue was clearly

established at the time of a defendant's alleged misconduct.” Montanez v. Thompson, 603 F.3d

243, 250 (3d Cir.2010) (quoting Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223 (2009)).

Given the discussion above, when viewed in the light most favorable to Boyer, a

reasonable juror could conclude that a reasonable juror could find Fourth Amendment

constitutional violations. The Court, therefore, must proceed to the second step of the analysis

to determine whether the constitutional rights at issue were clearly established at the time of

2 The Court further emphasizes that there are facts in dispute regarding whether

Boyer’s benefit from the kitchen door or facility expansion outside of the kitchen constitute

an Ethics Act violation. At this stage, reasonable jurors could differ in their conclusions about

whether the benefit of the new expansions, to the kitchen or other areas, would have a de

minimis economic impact on Boyer or whether the benefit affected a class consisting of the

same occupation (i.e. caterers) to the same degree. See Bixler, 2004 WL 3414060, at *9.

14

the alleged violation. This requires the Court to ask the question of whether “it would be clear

to a reasonable officer that his conduct was unlawful in the situation confronted.” Montanez,

603 F.3d at 250.

If the right violated was “clearly established,” then the official is not entitled to

immunity. “To be clearly established, a right must be sufficiently clear that every reasonable

official would have understood that what he is doing violates that right.” Reichle v. Howards,

566 U.S. 658, 664 (2012); Saucier v. Katz, 533 U.S. 194, 202 (2001). “This is an objective

inquiry, to be decided by the court as a matter of law.” Doe v. Groody, 361 F.3d 232, 238 (3d

Cir. 2004). “[E]xisting precedent must have placed the statutory or constitutional question

beyond debate” for a right to be clearly established. Reichle, 566 U.S. at 664. The Supreme

Court does “not require a case directly on point, but existing precedent must have placed the

statutory or constitutional question beyond debate.” Taylor v. Barkes, 575 U.S. 822, 825 (2015).

Essentially, “in light of pre-existing law the unlawfulness must be apparent.” Hope v. Pelzer,

536 U.S. 730, 739 (2002). This may be the case “despite notable factual distinctions between

the precedents relied on and the cases then before the Court, so long as the prior decisions

gave reasonable warning that the conduct violated constitutional rights.” Hope, 536 U.S. at

740 (citation omitted).

Here, the right to be free from unlawful searches except on probable cause was clearly

established at the time of Mulvey’s search of Boyer’s residence. Messerschmidt v. Millender, 565

U.S. 535, 547 (2012) (finding that qualified immunity is lost when an officer’s search warrant

lacks probable cause) (citing United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897, 923 (1984)). Further, as

discussed supra, there are material facts in dispute regarding whether Mulvey’s search of

Boyer’s residence was properly supported by probable cause. Boyer’s rights to be free from

15

searches of their properties predicated on warrants that lack probable cause was “grounded in

well-settled law and thus, on the record of this case, a reasonable juror could find that ‘it

would be clear to a reasonable officer that [Mulvey’s] conduct was unlawful in the situation

[he] confronted.’” Andrews v. Scuilli, 853 F.3d 690, 705 (3d Cir. 2017) (quoting Saucier, 533

U.S. at 202).

Accordingly, Mulvey’s motion for summary judgment on the issue of qualified

immunity is DENIED.3 (Doc. 113); see Contreras v. Conrad, No. 3:17-CV-02360, 2020 WL

2193429, at *9 (M.D. Pa. May 6, 2020) (denying summary judgment on qualified immunity

argument because genuine issues of material fact existed as to whether defendants violated

plaintiff’s Fourth Amendment rights); Moore v. Monaghan, No. CV 19-4400, 2021 WL 39631,

at *9 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 5, 2021) (denying entry of summary judgment on qualified immunity

because genuine issues of material fact existed whether defendants violated plaintiff’s Fourth

Amendment rights); Figueroa v. Moyer, No. 3:21-CV-601, 2023 WL 4195846, at *14 (M.D. Pa.

Jan. 31, 2023), report and recommendation adopted, No. CV 3:21-601, 2023 WL 4188024 (M.D.

Pa. June 26, 2023) (“The factual dispute regarding the issue of probable cause also defeats the

defendants' argument that they are entitled to qualified immunity.”).

3 Although the Court denies Mulvey’s motion for summary judgment on Boyer’s

Count I Fourth Amendment claims, Mulvey may again raise qualified immunity as a defense

after the fact finder has resolved the disputed issues. See Geist v. Ammary, 40 F. Supp. 3d 467,

483 (E.D. Pa. 2014). (“Qualified Immunity, however, may be raised again as a defense after

the disputed issues of fact are resolved.”).

16

IV. CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, Mulvey’s motion for summary judgment is GRANTED as

to Count One and DENIED as to Count Two. (Doc. 112). Count One is DISMISSED. (Doc.

1). Boyer’s motion for partial summary judgment as to Count Two is DENIED. (Doc. 104).

An appropriate Order follows.

Dated: March 18, 2025 s/ Karoline Mehalchick

KAROLINE MEHALCHICK

United States District Judge

17

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.